Functional role of heme ligation in cytochrome c. Effects of replacement of methionine 80 with natural and non-natural residues by semisynthesis

Increasing the conformational stability by replacement of heme axial ligand in c-type cytochrome

To investigate the role of the heme axial ligand in the conformational stability of c-type cytochrome, we constructed M58C and M58H mutants of the red alga Porphyra yezoensis cytochrome c(6) in which the sixth heme iron ligand (Met58) was replaced with Cys and His residues, respectively. The Gibbs free energy change for unfolding of the M58H mutant in water (DeltaG degrees (unf)=1.48 kcal/mol) was lower than that of the wild-type (2.43 kcal/mol), possibly due to the steric effects of the mutation on the apoprotein structure. On the other hand, the M58C mutant exhibited a DeltaG degrees (unf) of 5.45 kcal/mol, a significant increase by 3.02 kcal/mol compared with that of wild-type. This increase was possibly responsible for the sixth heme axial bond of M58C mutant being more stable than that of wild-type according to the heme-bound denaturation curve. Based on these observations, we propose that the sixth heme axial ligand is an important key to determine the conformational stability of c-type cytochromes, and the sixth Cys heme ligand will give stabilizing effects.

Site-directed mutagenesis of the heme axial ligands in the hemoflavoenzyme cellobiose dehydrogenase

Cellobiose dehydrogenase (CDH) from Phanerochaete chrysosporium is an extracellular 90-kDa hemoflavoenzyme, organized into an N-terminal heme domain and a C-terminal flavin domain. The amino acid residues Met65 and His114 or His163 were suggested to be heme iron ligands. Mutations of these residues were made and mutant proteins were characterized. H114A mutant cultures produce a stable hemoflavoenzyme with spectral and kinetic characteristics similar to those of wild-type CDH. The M65A and H163A transformants secrete a 90-kDa hemoflavoenzyme, which oxidizes cellobiose in the presence of 2,6-dichlorophenol-indophenol (DCPIP), but is unable to reduce cytochrome c. The heme domains of the M65A and H163A CDH variants are, however, unstable and susceptible to degradation, both yielding a 70-kDa cellobiose-oxidizing flavoenzyme. The spectral and kinetic characteristics of these truncated variants suggest that they contain only their respective flavin domains. The yield of the 90-kDa proteins was low and the proteins could not be purified to homogeneity; however, absorption spectra indicate that the 90-kDa proteins do contain the heme domain. Like the truncated flavoenzymes, the 90-kDa variants reduce DCPIP but are unable to transfer electrons to cytochrome c, in contrast to wild-type CDH. These findings suggest that H163 and M65 are the axial heme ligands and that both ligands are required for the reactivity and structural integrity of the heme domain.

Total synthesis of cytochrome b562 by native chemical ligation using a removable auxiliary

We have completed the total chemical synthesis of cytochrome b562 and an axial ligand analogue, [SeMet(7)]cyt b562, by thioester-mediated chemical ligation of unprotected peptide segments. A novel auxiliary-mediated native chemical ligation that enables peptide ligation to be applied to protein sequences lacking cysteine was used. A cleavable thiol-containing auxiliary group, 1-phenyl-2-mercaptoethyl, was added to the alpha-amino group of one peptide segment to facilitate amide bond-forming ligation. The amine-linked 1-phenyl-2-mercaptoethyl auxiliary was stable to anhydrous hydrogen fluoride used to cleave and deprotect peptides after solid-phase peptide synthesis. Following native chemical ligation with a thioester-containing segment, the auxiliary group was cleanly removed from the newly formed amide bond by treatment with anhydrous hydrogen fluoride, yielding a full-length unmodified polypeptide product. The resulting polypeptide was reconstituted with heme and folded to form the functional protein molecule. Synthetic wild-type cyt b562 exhibited spectroscopic and electrochemical properties identical to the recombinant protein, whereas the engineered [SeMet(7)]cyt b562 analogue protein was spectroscopically and functionally distinct, with a reduction potential shifted by approximately 45 mV. The use of the 1-phenyl-2-mercaptoethyl removable auxiliary reported here will greatly expand the applicability of total protein synthesis by native chemical ligation of unprotected peptide segments.

ATP induces a conformational change in lipid-bound cytochrome c

Resonance energy transfer studies using a pyrene-labeled phospholipid derivative 1-palmitoyl-2-[10-(pyren-1-yl)decanoyl]-sn-glycero-3-phosphoglycerol (donor) and the heme (acceptor) of cytochrome c (cyt c) have indicated that ATP causes changes in the conformation of the lipid-bound protein (Rytömaa, M., Mustonen, P., and Kinnunen, P. K. J. (1992) J. Biol. Chem. 267, 22243-22248). Accordingly, after binding cyt c via its so called C-site to neat phosphatidylglycerol liposomes (mole fraction of PG = 1.0) has commenced, further quenching of donor fluorescence is caused by ATP, saturating at 2 mm nucleotide. ATP-induced conformational changes in liposome-associated cyt c could be directly demonstrated by CD in the Soret band region (380-460 nm). The latter data were further supported by time-resolved spectroscopy using the fluorescent cyt c analog with a Zn(2+)-substituted heme moiety. A high affinity ATP-binding site has been demonstrated in cyt c (Craig, D. B., and Wallace, C. J. A. (1993) Protein Sci. 2, 966-976) that is compromised by replacing the invariant Arg(91) to norleucine. Although no major effects on conformation and function of cyt c were concluded due to the modification, a significantly reduced effect by ATP on the lipid-bound [Nle(91)]cyt c was evident, implying that this modulation is mediated via the Arg(91)-containing binding site.

Site-specific independent double labeling of proteins with reporter atoms

Many types of physical, spectroscopic, and biological studies of proteins and other macromolecules are facilitated by the incorporation of reporter groups. In many cases these are single atom substitutes, for example isotopes (13C for C), or light (F for H) and heavy (Se for S) atom homologs. In some circumstances the incorporation of two different labels in the same molecule would be greatly desirable. Commonly used protein engineering methods for incorporating them can rarely cope with differential double labeling, and have other limitations such as universal, non-specific, or random incorporation. Although de novo peptide synthesis has the power to achieve highly specific labeling, the difficulties inherent in creating long sequences lead us to propose protein semisynthesis as the most practical approach. By ligating combinations of natural and labeled synthetic fragments to reform holoproteins, we can overcome any of the limitations discussed. Using cytochrome c as a model protein we show that two reporter atoms, selenium and bromine, can be simultaneously and site-specifically incorporated without significant consequences to structure and (or) function. This capability opens up the prospect of advances in a number of areas in structural biology.

Key words: semisynthesis, peptide synthesis, reporter groups, cytochrome c, structural biology.

Heme environmental structure of CooA is modulated by the target DNA binding. Evidence from resonance Raman spectroscopy and CO rebinding kinetics

In order to investigate the gene activation mechanism triggered by the CO binding to CooA, a heme-containing transcriptional activator, the heme environmental structure and the dynamics of the CO rebinding and dissociation have been examined in the absence and presence of its target DNA. In the absence of DNA, the Fe-CO and C=O stretching Raman lines of the CO-bound CooA were observed at 487 and 1969 cm-1, respectively, suggesting that a neutral histidine is an axial ligand trans to CO. The frequency of nu(Fe-CO) implies an open conformation of the distal heme pocket, indicating that the ligand replaced by CO is located away from the bound CO. When the target DNA was added to CO-bound CooA, an appearance of a new nu(Fe-CO) line at 519 cm-1 and narrowing of the main line at 486 cm-1 were observed. Although the rate of the CO dissociation was insensitive to the additions of DNA, the CO rebinding was decelerated in the presence of the target DNA, but not in the presence of nonsense DNA. These observations demonstrate the structural alterations in the heme distal site in response to binding of the target DNA and support the activation mechanism proposed for CooA, which is triggered by the movement of the heme distal ligand to modify the conformation of the DNA binding domain.

Synergy in protein engineering. Mutagenic manipulation of protein structure to simplify semisynthesis

Semisynthesis is a chemical technique of protein engineering that provides a valuable complement to directed mutagenesis. It is the method of choice when the structural modification requires, for example, a noncoded amino acid. The process involves specific and limited protein fragmentation, structural manipulation of the target sequence, and subsequent religation of fragments to give the mutant holoprotein. We suggested and demonstrated that mutagenesis and semisynthesis could be used synergistically to achieve protein engineering goals otherwise unobtainable, if mutagenesis was used to shuffle methionine residues in the yeast cytochrome c sequence (Wallace, C. J. A., Guillemette, J. G., Hibiya, Y., and Smith, M. (1991) J. Biol. Chem. 266, 21355-21357). These residues can not only be sites of specific cleavage by CNBr but also of spontaneous peptide bond synthesis between fragments in noncovalent complexes, which greatly facilitates the semisynthetic process. We have now used an informed "methionine scan" of the protein sequence to discover other useful sites and to characterize the factors that promote this extraordinary and convenient autocatalytic religation. Of eight sites canvassed, in a wide range of settings, five efficiently provoked peptide bond synthesis. The principal factor determining efficiency seems to be the hydropathy of the religation site. The mutants created have also provided some new insights on structure-function relationships in the cytochrome.

Structural studies of imidazole-cytochrome c: resonance assignments and structural comparison with cytochrome c

Two-dimensional nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy (2D NMR) was used to obtain extensive proton resonance assignments of Im-cyt c complex which is a possible analog of a late folding intermediate of cytochrome c. Assignments were made nearly completely for the main-chain and the side-chain protons (all except Gly29). As starting points for the assignment of the Im-cyt c, a limited set of protons was initially assigned by use of 2D NMR magnetization transfer methods to correlated resonances in the Im-cyt c with assigned resonances in the native cyt c. The subsequent search focused on recognition of main-chain NOE connectivity patterns, with use of previously assigned residues to place NOE-connected segments within the amino acid sequence. The observed patterns of main-chain NOEs provided some structural information and suggested potentially significant differences between Im-cyt c and the native cyt c. Differences in NOEs involving side-chain protons were reported and analyzed. There was evidence for conformational changes induced by the breakage of Fe-S bond. It was concluded that the Im-cyt c had undergone a rearrangement of several regions forming the heme pocket of the protein. The structural understanding of these effects of the mutation may be essential to elucidate the changes in function and kinetic mechanism of cyt c folding.

2D-NMR studies of the effects of axial substitution on two helices in horse cytochrome c

The sequential amino acids from Gly-1 to Cys-14 in the N-terminal segment and from Lys-88 to Glu-104 in the C-terminal segment of cytochrome c-imidazole complex (Im-cyt c) have been studied by two-dimensional nuclear magnetic resonance techniques. Resonance assignments for the main-chain and side-chain protons are reported. Qualitative interpretation of nuclear Overhauser enhancement data allows the secondary structure of the two segments to be described, which indicate the patterns of NOEs found are consistent with an alpha-helix between Val-3 and Cys-14 in the N-terminus, and between Lys-88 and Asn-103 in the C-terminus. Two alpha-helices are found to be maintained. Comparison of the long-range NOEs of Im-cyt c relative to the crystal structure of native cytochrome c reveals apparent conformational changes of some side-chains especially those close to heme pocket within the N- and C-terminal helices resulting from the binding of imidazole to iron by displacing native Met-80 side-chain. The explanation for ligand-induced changes within the N- and C-helices is therefore suggested.

Comparison of low oxidoreduction potential cytochrome c553 from Desulfovibrio vulgaris with the class I cytochrome c family

The cytochrome c553 from Desulfovibrio vulgaris (DvH c553) is of importance in the understanding of the relationship of structure and function of cytochrome c due to its lack of sequence homology with other cytochromes, and its abnormally low oxido-reduction potential. In evolutionary terms, this protein also represents an important reference point for the understanding of both bacterial and mitochondrial cytochromes c. Using the recently determined nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) structure of the reduced protein we compare the structural, dynamic, and functional characteristics of DvH c553 with members of both the mitochondrial and bacterial cytochromes c to characterize the protein in the context of the cytochrome c family, and to understand better the control of oxide-reduction potential in electron transfer proteins. Despite the low sequence homology, striking structural similarities between this protein and representatives of both eukaryotic [cytochrome c from tuna (tuna c)] and prokaryotic [Pseudomonas aeruginosa c551 (Psa c551)] cytochromes c have been recognized. The previously observed helical core is also found in the DvH c553. The structural framework and hydrogen bonding network of the DvH c553 is most similar to that of the tuna c, with the exception of an insertion loop of 24 residues closing the heme pocket and protecting the propionates, which is absent in the DvH c553. In contrast, the Psa c551 protects the propionates from the solvent principally by extending the methionine ligand arm. The electrostatic distribution at the recognized encounter surface around the heme in the mitochondrial cytochrome is reproduced in the DvH c553, and corresponding hydrogen bonding networks, particularly in the vicinity of the heme cleft, exist in both molecules. Thus, although the cytochrome DvH c553 exhibits higher primary sequence homology to other bacterial cytochromes c, the structural and physical homology is significantly greater with respect to the mitochondrial cytochrome c. The major structural and functional difference is the absence of solvent protection for the heme, differentiating this cytochrome from both reference cytochromes, which have evolved different mechanisms to cover the propionates. This suggests that the abnormal redox potential of the DvH c553 is linked to the raised accessibility of the heme and supports the theory that redox potential in cytochromes is controlled by heme propionate solvent accessibility.

Control of the redox potential in c-type cytochromes: importance of the entropic contribution

The enthalpic and entropic components of the redox free energy variation of cytochrome c553 from Desulfovibrio vulgaris Hildenborough and its mutant Y64V, flavocytochrome b2 from Saccharomyces cerevisiae, and the different hemes of cytochromes c3 from Desulfovibrio vulgaris Miyazaki and Desulfovibrio desulfuricans Norway have been determined in 0.1 M Tris-HCl pH 7.0 (7.6 for cytochromes c3) at 25 degrees C by using nonisothermal potentiometric titrations. The set of available experimental data demonstrates that the entropic component plays an important role in the control of the redox potential in c-type and b-type cytochromes. The variation of the entropic component within the class of cytochromes characterized by a positive value of E degrees ' is proposed to be mainly determined by the variation of the exposure of the heme propionates to the solvent. In the case of tetraheme cytochromes c3, the thermodynamic characteristics vary largely among the hemes belonging to the same molecule, which reflects the environmental peculiarities of each heme and also the heme-heme redox interactions. This study substantiates the existence of compensatory effects between large and opposite contributions to E degree ' predicted by all the current theoretical models which are based on electrostatic free energy calculations.

Peptide ligation and semisynthesis

Semisynthesis is used to create defined analogues of proteins by the chemical manipulation of peptide fragments largely derived from the natural protein and the subsequent reassembly of those fragments into a near-native conformation. In common with the total synthesis of proteins, it requires efficient and non-destructive methods for peptide religation. Recently, a wide range of chemoselective ligation schemes have been elaborated that now permit the assembly of minimally protected peptides from either synthetic or natural sources.

Selenomethionine labelling of phosphomannose isomerase changes its kinetic properties

Phosphomannose isomerase (PMI) is an essential enzyme in the early steps of the protein glycosylation pathway in both prokaryotes and eukaryotes. Lack of the enzyme is lethal for fungal organisms and it is thus a potential fungicidal target. To facilitate the solution of the three-dimensional structure of the enzyme from the pathogen Candida albicans, we have produced the recombinant selenomethionine-labelled enzyme (SeMet-PMI). DL41, a methionine auxotroph Escherichia coli strain, was transformed with a PMI expression plasmid and grown on an enriched selenomethionine-containing medium to high-cell densities. The SeMet-PMI protein has been purified and found by amino acid analysis to have its methionine residues replaced by selenomethionine residues. Electrospray mass spectroscopy showed a major species of 49,063 +/- 10 Da for SeMet-PMI compared to 48,735 +/- 6 Da for the normal recombinant enzyme, accounting for the incorporation of seven selenomethionine residues. SeMet-PMI crystallised isomorphously with the normal PMI protein and the crystals diffract to 0.23 nm. Kinetic characterisation of SeMet-PMI showed that its Km for the substrate mannose-6-phosphate was fourfold higher than that of its methionine-containing counterpart. The inhibition constant for zinc ions was also increased by a similar factor. However, the Vmax was unaltered. These results suggested that one or more methionine residues must be in close proximity to the substrate-binding pocket in the active site, rendering substrate access more difficult compared to the normal enzyme. This hypothesis was confirmed by the finding of four methionine residues lying along one wall of the active site.

Synthesis of proteins by native chemical ligation

A simple technique has been devised that allows the direct synthesis of native backbone proteins of moderate size. Chemoselective reaction of two unprotected peptide segments gives an initial thioester-linked species. Spontaneous rearrangement of this transient intermediate yields a full-length product with a native peptide bond at the ligation site. The utility of native chemical ligation was demonstrated by the one-step preparation of a cytokine containing multiple disulfides. The polypeptide ligation product was folded and oxidized to form the native disulfide-containing protein molecule. Native chemical ligation is an important step toward the general application of chemistry to proteins.

Synthetic proteins. Designer proteins

Attempts to synthesize de novo proteins with particular properties should improve our understanding of the long-range cooperative interactions that are so crucial to the structure and function of proteins.

Characterization of mutant Met100Lys of cytochrome c-550 from Thiobacillus versutus with lysine-histidine heme ligation

The heme iron in cytochrome c-550 from Thiobacillus versutus has a methionine and a histidine as axial ligands. In order to study the characteristics of a possible lysine-histidine ligation in a heme protein, the methionine has been replaced by a lysine. This residue acts as a ligand between pH 3 and 12. The midpoint potential of the mutant has shifted -329 mV compared to wild type, but apart from this shift the pH dependence of the midpoint potential is unchanged, suggesting that the large drop is caused by specific ligand effects and not by protein refolding. While the EPR spectrum of wild-type cytochrome c-550 shows one species with gz = 3.35, in the spectrum of the mutant two species occur with gz values of 3.53 and 3.30. The intensity ratio of both species depends on the presence of organic cosolvents. In the low frequency region (-4 to -1 ppm) of the 1H NMR spectrum of mutant ferrocytochrome c-550, four one-proton peaks replace the resonances of the ligand methionine side chain protons. Using two-dimensional NMR spectroscopy (COSY and NOESY), these protons and five others have been assigned to the lysine ligand. The spectroscopic results obtained for this mutant show similarities with those observed for the alkaline form of cytochrome c, supporting the Lys-His ligation proposed for this protein. The data are consistent with the evidence for amine ligation in cytochrome f: the EPR spectrum of M100K cytc-550 is similar to that of cytochrome f. However, the NMR spectra show significant differences.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Mutations of iso-1-cytochrome c at positions 13 and 90. Separate effects on physical and functional properties

Residues at positions 13 (lysine or arginine) and 90 (glutamate or aspartate) of eukaryotic cytochromes c have been conserved during evolution; Cys102, however, is found only in yeast cytochrome c. The positively charged residue at position 13 and the negatively charged residue at position 90 are close together in those cytochromes c for which three-dimensional structures are available. We have replaced the amino acids at these two positions by cysteine in Saccharomyces cerevisiae iso-1-cytochrome c; in an earlier study, Cys102 was replaced by threonine without negatively influencing the physical or enzymic properties of the protein. The mutated proteins [R13C, C102T]cytochrome c (iso-1-cytochrome c containing Arg13-->Cys and Cys102-->Thr mutations), [D90C, C102T]cytochrome c (iso-1-cytochrome c containing Asp90-->Cys and Cys102-->Thr mutations) and [R13C, D90C, C102T]cytochrome c (iso-1-cytochrome c containing Arg13-->Cys, Asp90-->Cys, and Cys102-->Thr mutations) are functional in vivo. Free sulfhydryl titration shows that the doubly mutated forms each contain one sulfhydryl group while the triple mutant contains two sulfhydryl groups. The stability of mutant [R13C, C102T]cytochrome c resembles that of [C102T] cytochrome c, whereas the stability of [D90C, C102T]cytochrome c resembles the stability of [R13C, D90C, C102T]cytochrome c. The activity of cytochrome-c oxidase using cytochrome c was monitored polarographically. Compared to the wild-type or [C102T]cytochrome c, which shows two kinetic phases with cytochrome-c oxidase, [D90C, C102T]cytochrome c has much the same profile; [R13C, C102T]cytochrome c and [R13C, D90C, C102T]cytochrome c exhibit one kinetic phase with decreased activity. Electron-transfer activity of the mutant cytochromes c is inhibited by Hg2+. The inhibition is highest for the triple mutant, less for [R13C, C102T]cytochrome c, even less for [D90C, C102T]cytochrome c and insignificant for the wild type. It would appear as though the stability of the triple mutant follows the changes that result from the Asp90-->Cys mutation while the activity changes follow those of the Arg13-->Cys mutation.

Resonance Raman spectroscopy of c-type cytochromes

This paper provides an overview of the usefulness of the resonance Raman (RR) spectroscopy in the determination of the structural and electronic properties of heme(s) included in c-type cytochromes. It reviews the mode assignments presently available for heme c and includes recent RR data on the most important subclasses of c-type cytochromes. It also describes the effects of cytochrome c-oxidase and cytochrome c-reductase associations on the heme vibrational modes of the bound cytochrome c.

The chemical synthesis of proteins

Total chemical synthesis is developing as an important approach to the construction of native proteins and their analogs for the study of the structural basis of biochemical activity. In the past year, a radical departure from conventional synthetic approaches has led to a renaissance in this field. The inherent simplicity of these new modes of protein construction will allow large synthetic proteins (> 200 amino acids in length) to be routinely assembled; this will vastly expand the repertoire of protein molecules accessible to research.

ATP binding to cytochrome c diminishes electron flow in the mitochondrial respiratory pathway

Eukaryotic cytochrome c possesses an ATP-binding site of substantial specificity and high affinity that is conserved between highly divergent species and which includes the invariant residue arginine91. Such evolutionary conservatism strongly suggests a physiological role for ATP binding that demands further investigation. We report the preparation of adducts of the protein and the affinity labels 8-azido adenosine 5'-triphosphate, adenosine 5'-triphosphate-2',3'-dialdehyde, and 5'-p-fluorosulfonylbenzoyladenosine. The two former reagents were seen to react at the arginine91-containing site, yet the reaction of the latter, although specific, occurred elsewhere, suggesting caution is necessary in its use. None of the adducts displayed significant modification of global structure, stability, or physicochemical properties, leading us to believe that the 8-N3-ATP and oATP adducts are good stabilized models of the noncovalent interaction; yet modification led to significant, and sometimes pronounced, effects on biological activity. We therefore propose that the role of ATP binding to this site, which we have shown to occur when the phosphorylation potential of the system is high under the equivalent of physiological conditions, is to cause a decrease in electron flow through the mitochondrial electron transport chain. Differences in the degree of inhibition produced by differences in adduct chemistry suggest that this putative regulatory role is mediated primarily by electrostatic effects.

The curious case of protein splicing: mechanistic insights suggested by protein semisynthesis

The gradual accumulation of examples of protein splicing, in which a nested intervening sequence is spliced out of the interior of a polyprotein precursor, suggests that this curious phenomenon might prove to have universal phylogenetic distribution and biological significance. The known examples are reviewed, with the aim of establishing underlying patterns, and a generalized mechanism of autocatalytic protein splicing is proposed. The testable consequences of such a proposal and the possible evolutionary origins of the phenomenon are discussed.