Prostaglandins for peptic ulcer: a promise unfulfilled

Twenty-four-hour intragastric acidity and clinical trial of bedtime enprostil 70 micrograms compared with ranitidine 300 mg in duodenal ulcer

The effects of bedtime 70 micrograms and twice daily 35 micrograms doses of enprostil on 24-hour intragastric acidity were investigated in nine duodenal ulcer patients in remission. Median nocturnal acidity decreased significantly by 30% with 35 micrograms twice daily, and by 48% with 70 micrograms at bedtime. In a clinical trial using bedtime dosing, 102 duodenal ulcer patients randomly received either ranitidine 300 mg or enprostil 70 micrograms. More ulcers healed after 4 and 8 weeks treatment with ranitidine than with enprostil (76% ranitidine vs 52% enprostil, at 4 weeks p = 0.0065 and 94% vs 68%, respectively at 8 weeks, P = 0.0007). However, 6 months after cessation of treatment there was no material difference in overall outcome. Despite combining mucosal protection with acid inhibition enprostil treatment conferred no advantage over simple acid inhibition.

It is wise to prescribe NSAIDs with modern gastroprotective agents?

The administration of non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) leads to mucosal lesions in the upper gastrointestinal tract. Furthermore, NSAIDs increase the risk of ulcer bleeding and perforation, but the overall risk of fatal complications is relatively small (about 21 per one million prescriptions). Therefore, in asymptomatic patients, it is not justified to prescribe NSAIDs together with gastroprotective agents. The following recommendations can be given with respect to the management of peptic lesions in patients taking NSAIDs: (i) Fibre endoscopy should be performed even when there are relatively mild symptoms since mucosal lesions in rheumatic patients under NSAIDs produce minor or no symptoms. (ii) "Modern" NSAIDs might produce less gastric lesions than aspirin. (iii) Rheumatic patients with peptic disorders should be treated with an H2-antagonist. (iv) After complications such as ulcer bleeding or after rapid recurrence of peptic lesions, maintenance treatment with an H2-antagonist is advisable.