Custom DNA-binding proteins come of age: polydactyl zinc-finger proteins

In vivo selection of engineered homing endonucleases using double-strand break induced homologous recombination

Homing endonucleases, endonucleases capable of recognizing long DNA sequences, have been shown to be a tool of choice for precise and efficient genome engineering. Consequently, the possibility to engineer novel endonucleases with tailored specificities is under strong investigation. In this report, we present a simple and efficient method to select meganucleases from libraries of variants, based on their cleavage properties. The method has the advantage of directly selecting for the ability to induce double-strand break induced homologous recombination in a eukaryotic environment. Model selections demonstrated high levels of enrichments. Moreover, this method compared favorably with phage display for enrichment of active mutants from a mutant library. This approach makes possible the exploration of large sequence spaces and thereby represents a valuable tool for genome engineering.

Engineering of large numbers of highly specific homing endonucleases that induce recombination on novel DNA targets

The last decade has seen the emergence of a universal method for precise and efficient genome engineering. This method relies on the use of sequence-specific endonucleases such as homing endonucleases. The structures of several of these proteins are known, allowing for site-directed mutagenesis of residues essential for DNA binding. Here, we show that a semi-rational approach can be used to derive hundreds of novel proteins from I-CreI, a homing endonuclease from the LAGLIDADG family. These novel endonucleases display a wide range of cleavage patterns in yeast and mammalian cells that in most cases are highly specific and distinct from I-CreI. Second, rules for protein/DNA interaction can be inferred from statistical analysis. Third, novel endonucleases can be combined to create heterodimeric protein species, thereby greatly enhancing the number of potential targets. These results describe a straightforward approach for engineering novel endonucleases with tailored specificities, while preserving the activity and specificity of natural homing endonucleases, and thereby deliver new tools for genome engineering.

Site-directed genome modification: nucleic acid and protein modules for targeted integration and gene correction

A variety of technological advances in recent years have made permanent genetic manipulation of an organism a technical possibility. As the details of natural biological processes for genome modification are elucidated, the enzymes catalyzing these events (transposases, recombinases, integrases and DNA repair enzymes) are being harnessed or modified for the purpose of intentional gene modification. Targeted integration and gene repair can be mediated by the DNA-targeting specificity inherent to a particular enzyme, or rely on user-designed specificities. Integration sites can be defined by using DNA base-pairing or protein-DNA interaction as a means of targeting. This review will describe recent progress in the development of 'user-targetable' systems, particularly highlighting the application of custom DNA-binding proteins or nucleic acid homology to confer specificity.

Gene targeting using zinc finger nucleases

The ability to achieve site-specific manipulation of the mammalian genome has widespread implications for basic and applied research. Gene targeting is a process in which a DNA molecule introduced into a cell replaces the corresponding chromosomal segment by homologous recombination, and thus presents a precise way to manipulate the genome. In the past, the application of gene targeting to mammalian cells has been limited by its low efficiency. Zinc finger nucleases (ZFNs) show promise in improving the efficiency of gene targeting by introducing DNA double-strand breaks in target genes, which then stimulate the cell's endogenous homologous recombination machinery. Recent results have shown that ZFNs can be used to create targeting frequencies of up to 20% in a human disease-causing gene. Future work will be needed to translate these in vitro findings to in vivo applications and to determine whether zinc finger nucleases create undesired genomic instability.

Effects of linking 15-zinc finger domains on DNA binding specificity and multiple DNA binding modes

To assess the possibility of multi-connection of zinc finger domains for understanding of DNA binding mechanisms and gene regulation, the longest artificial zinc finger protein, Sp1ZF15, has been constructed. This zinc finger consists of 5 units of Sp1 zinc finger peptide connected by canonical short linker sequences (TGEKP). Recognition of the 50 base pairs of DNA and potential binding to shorter targets by Sp1ZF15 were determined. Sequence alterations of the GCG triplet to ATA at a target site clearly showed that Sp1ZF15 changes its DNA binding mode depending on the target sequences. Of special interest is the fact that Sp1ZF15 controls the number of finger domains active in DNA binding corresponding to the length and sequence of the target DNA. These results suggest that artificial transcription factors based upon these multi-zinc finger proteins have great potential for the regulation of a vast number of cellular processes.

Gene therapy: twenty-first century medicine

Broadly defined, the concept of gene therapy involves the transfer of genetic material into a cell, tissue, or whole organ, with the goal of curing a disease or at least improving the clinical status of a patient. A key factor in the success of gene therapy is the development of delivery systems that are capable of efficient gene transfer in a variety of tissues, without causing any associated pathogenic effects. Vectors based upon many different viral systems, including retroviruses, lentiviruses, adenoviruses, and adeno-associated viruses, currently offer the best choice for efficient gene delivery. Their performance and pathogenicity has been evaluated in animal models, and encouraging results form the basis for clinical trials to treat genetic disorders and acquired diseases. Despite some initial success in these trials, vector development remains a seminal concern for improved gene therapy technologies.

Isolation of novel single-chain Cro proteins targeted for binding to the bcl-2 transcription initiation site by repertoire selection and subunit combinatorics

New designed DNA-binding proteins may be recruited to act as transcriptional regulators and could provide new therapeutic agents in the treatment of genetic disorders such as cancer. We have isolated tailored DNA-binding proteins selected for affinity to a region spanning the transcription initiation site of the human bcl-2 gene. The proteins were derived from a single-chain derivative of the lambda Cro protein (scCro), randomly mutated in its recognition helices to construct libraries of protein variants of distinct DNA-binding properties. By phage display-afforded affinity selections combined with recombination of shuffled subunits, protein variants were isolated, which displayed high affinity for the target bcl-2 sequence, as determined by electrophoretic mobility shift and biosensor assays. The proteins analyzed were moderately sequence-specific but provide a starting point for further maturation of desired function.

Laboratory-directed protein evolution

Systematic approaches to directed evolution of proteins have been documented since the 1970s. The ability to recruit new protein functions arises from the considerable substrate ambiguity of many proteins. The substrate ambiguity of a protein can be interpreted as the evolutionary potential that allows a protein to acquire new specificities through mutation or to regain function via mutations that differ from the original protein sequence. All organisms have evolutionarily exploited this substrate ambiguity. When exploited in a laboratory under controlled mutagenesis and selection, it enables a protein to "evolve" in desired directions. One of the most effective strategies in directed protein evolution is to gradually accumulate mutations, either sequentially or by recombination, while applying selective pressure. This is typically achieved by the generation of libraries of mutants followed by efficient screening of these libraries for targeted functions and subsequent repetition of the process using improved mutants from the previous screening. Here we review some of the successful strategies in creating protein diversity and the more recent progress in directed protein evolution in a wide range of scientific disciplines and its impacts in chemical, pharmaceutical, and agricultural sciences.

Sequence-Selective and Hydrolytic Cleavage of DNA by Zinc Finger Mutants

We have reported the successful conversion of the structural zinc site in zinc finger peptides to a functional zinc site. A series of resulting zinc finger mutants exhibit the hydrolytic ability of the activated ester depending on the coordination geometry and acidity of the zinc ions. In this study, we explored the hydrolytic ability of DNA by the H4 mutant since the mutant showed the highest hydrolytic ability of the activated ester among the series of mutant peptides. The zinc-bound form of the H4 mutant peptide exhibited the hydrolytic ability of activated phosphoesters and even converted the supercoiled plasmid to the nicked circular form. An increasing ionic strength leads to a loss in the nuclease ability of the zinc finger mutants due to the nonspecific interaction between the zinc finger peptide and DNA. In sharp contrast, the three-tandem H4-type zinc finger protein performed the specific DNA hydrolysis at the GC box even at a high ionic strength. Thus, the present study demonstrated that converting the native zinc site to the hydrolytic zinc site in the zinc finger protein is a novel approach for creating artificial nucleases with sequence selectivity.

Designing transcription factor architectures for drug discovery

Recent advances in the design, selection, and engineering of DNA binding proteins have led to the emerging field of designer transcription factors (TFs). Modular DNA-binding protein domains can be assembled to recognize a given sequence of a DNA in a regulatory region of a targeted gene. TFs can be readily prepared by linking the DNA-binding protein to a variety of effector domains that mediate transcriptional activation or repression. Furthermore, the interaction between the TF and the genomic DNA can be regulated by several approaches, including chemical regulation by a variety of small molecules. Genome-wide single target specificity has been demonstrated using arrays of sequence-specific zinc finger (ZF) domains, polydactyl proteins. Any laboratory today can easily construct polydactyl ZF proteins by linkage of predefined ZF units that recognize specific triplets of DNA. The potential of this technology to alter the transcription of specific genes, to discover new genes, and to induce phenotypes in cells and organisms is now being applied in the areas of molecular therapeutics, pharmacology, biotechnology, and functional genomics.

Attenuation of HIV-1 Replication in Primary Human Cells with a Designed Zinc Finger Transcription Factor

Small molecule inhibitors of human immunodeficiency virus, type 1 (HIV-1) have been extremely successful but are associated with a myriad of undesirable effects and require lifelong daily dosing. In this study we explore an alternative approach, that of inducing intracellular immunity using designed, zinc finger-based transcription factors. Three transcriptional repression proteins were engineered to bind sites in the HIV-1 promoter that were expected to be both accessible in chromatin structure and highly conserved in sequence structure among the various HIV-1 subgroups. Transient transfection assays identified one factor, KRAB-HLTR3, as being able to achieve 100-fold repression of an HIV-1 promoter. Specificity of repression was demonstrated by the lack of repression of other promoters. This factor was further shown to repress the replication of several HIV-1 viral strains 10- to 100-fold in T-cell lines and primary human peripheral blood mononuclear cells. Repression was observed for at least 18 days with no significant cytotoxicity. Stable T-cell lines expressing the factor also do not show obvious signs of cytotoxicity. These characteristics present KRAB-HLTR3 as an attractive candidate for development in an intracellular immunization strategy for anti-HIV-1 therapy.

Fusion proteins consisting of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 integrase and the designed polydactyl zinc finger protein E2C direct integration of viral DNA into specific sites

In order to establish a productive infection, a retrovirus must integrate the cDNA of its RNA genome into the host cell chromosome. While this critical process makes retroviruses an attractive vector for gene delivery, the nonspecific nature of integration presents inherent hazards and variations in gene expression. One approach to alleviating the problem involves fusing retroviral integrase to a sequence-specific DNA-binding protein that targets a defined chromosomal site. We prepared proteins consisting of wild-type or truncated human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) integrase fused to the synthetic polydactyl zinc finger protein E2C. The purified fusion proteins bound specifically to the 18-bp E2C recognition sequence as analyzed by DNase I footprinting. The fusion proteins were catalytically active and biased integration of retroviral DNA near the E2C-binding site in vitro. The distribution was asymmetric, and the major integration hot spots were localized within a 20-bp region upstream of the C-rich strand of the E2C recognition sequence. Integration bias was not observed with target plasmids bearing a mutated E2C-binding site or when HIV-1 integrase and E2C were added to the reaction as separate proteins. The results demonstrate that the integrase-E2C fusion proteins offer an efficient approach and a versatile framework for directing the integration of retroviral DNA into a predetermined DNA site.

Therapeutic modulation of endogenous gene function by agents with designed DNA-sequence specificities

Designer molecules that can specifically target pre-determined DNA sequences provide a means to modulate endogenous gene function. Different classes of sequence-specific DNA-binding agents have been developed, including triplex-forming molecules, synthetic polyamides and designer zinc finger proteins. These different types of designer molecules with their different principles of engineered sequence specificity are reviewed in this paper. Furthermore, we explore and discuss the potential of these molecules as therapeutic modulators of endogenous gene function, focusing on modulation by stable gene modification and by regulation of gene transcription.

Toward a functional annotation of the human genome using artificial transcription factors

We have developed a novel, high-throughput approach to collecting randomly perturbed gene-expression profiles from the human genome.A human 293 cell library that stably expresses randomly chosen zinc-finger transcription factors was constructed, and the expression profile of each cell line was obtained using cDNA microarray technology.Gene expression profiles from a total of 132 cell lines were collected and analyzed by (1) a simple clustering method based on expression-profile similarity, and (2) the shortest-path analysis method. These analyses identified a number of gene groups, and further investigation revealed that the genes that were grouped together had close biological relationships. The artificial transcription factor-based random genome perturbation method thus provides a novel functional genomic tool for annotation and classification of genes in the human genome and those of many other organisms.

Highly specific zinc finger proteins obtained by directed domain shuffling and cell-based selection

Engineered Cys2His2 zinc finger proteins (ZFPs) can mediate regulation of endogenous gene expression in mammalian cells. Ideally, all zinc fingers in an engineered multifinger protein should be optimized concurrently because cooperative and context-dependent contacts can affect DNA recognition. However, the simultaneous selection of key contacts in even three fingers from fully randomized libraries would require the consideration of >10(24) possible combinations. To address this challenge, we have developed a novel strategy that utilizes directed domain shuffling and rapid cell-based selections. Unlike previously described methods, our strategy is amenable to scale-up and does not sacrifice combinatorial diversity. Using this approach, we have successfully isolated multifinger proteins with improved in vitro and in vivo function. Our results demonstrate that both DNA binding affinity and specificity are important for cellular function and also provide a general approach for optimizing multidomain proteins.

Zinc fingers and a green thumb: manipulating gene expression in plants

Artificial transcription factors can be rapidly constructed from predefined zinc-finger modules to regulate virtually any gene. Stable, heritable up- and downregulation of endogenous genes has been demonstrated in transgenic plants. These advances promise new approaches for creating functional knockouts and conditional overexpression, and for other gene discovery and manipulation applications in plants.

Evaluation of a modular strategy for the construction of novel polydactyl zinc finger DNA-binding proteins

In previous studies, we have developed a technology for the rapid construction of novel DNA-binding proteins with the potential to recognize any unique site in a given genome. This technology relies on the modular assembly of modified zinc finger DNA-binding domains, each of which recognizes a three bp subsite of DNA. A complete set of 64 domains would provide comprehensive recognition of any desired DNA sequence, and new proteins could be assembled by any laboratory in a matter of hours. However, a critical parameter for this approach is the extent to which each domain functions as an independent, modular unit, without influence or dependence on its neighboring domains. We therefore examined the detailed binding behavior of several modularly assembled polydactyl zinc finger proteins. We first demonstrated that 80 modularly assembled 3-finger proteins can recognize their DNA target with very high specificity using a multitarget ELISA-based specificity assay. A more detailed analysis of DNA binding specificity for eight 3-finger proteins and two 6-finger proteins was performed using a target site selection assay. Results showed that the specificity of these proteins was as good or better than that of zinc finger proteins constructed using methods that allow for interdependency. In some cases, near perfect specificity was achieved. Complications due to target site overlap were found to be restricted to only one particular amino acid interaction (involving an aspartate in position 2 of the alpha-helix) that occurs in a minority of cases. As this is the first report of target site selection for designed, well characterized 6-finger proteins, unique insights are discussed concerning the relationship of protein length and specificity. These results have important implications for the design of proteins that can recognize extended DNA sequences, as well as provide insights into the general rules of recognition for naturally occurring zinc finger proteins.

Selective dimerization of a C2H2 zinc finger subfamily

The C2H2 zinc finger is the most prevalent protein motif in the mammalian proteome. Two C2H2 fingers in Ikaros are dedicated to homotypic interactions between family members. We show here that these fingers comprise a bona fide dimerization domain. Dimerization is highly selective, however, as homologous domains from the TRPS-1 and Drosophila Hunchback proteins support homodimerization, but not heterodimerization with Ikaros. Ikaros-Hunchback selectivity is determined by 11 residues concentrated within the alpha-helical regions typically involved in base recognition. Preferential homodimerization of one chimeric protein predicts a parallel dimer interface and establishes the feasibility of creating novel dimer specificities. These results demonstrate that the C2H2 motif provides a versatile platform for both sequence-specific protein-nucleic acid interactions and highly specific dimerization.

Regulation of gene expression in Arabidopsis thaliana by artificial zinc finger chimeras

The artificial regulation of endogenous gene expression in plants is limited to only a few approaches. Here, we describe the use of artificial zinc finger chimeras to regulate the expression of a known reporter construct. The artificial zinc finger chimera TFIIIAZif is a fusion protein consisting of the four zinc fingers of TFIIIA linked through a spacer region to the three zinc fingers of Zif268. This artificial zinc finger chimera is able to bind specifically to a target DNA sequence (ZBS, zinc finger binding site) of 27 base pairs (bp). TFIIIAZif was fused to a transactivation domain from the herpes simplex virus VP16 or its tetramer VP64 to give ZF-VP16 or ZF-VP64, respectively. In transient expression assays, these two transcription activators were able to activate a target reporter gene (luc and GFP) expressed from a minimal -46 35S promoter linked to four copies of ZBS. The activation was confirmed in transgenic plants using an inducible XVE system [Zuo et al. (2000) Plant J. 24: 265] to express ZF-VP16 or ZF-VP64. Furthermore, to test the specificity of ZF-VP64 we have compared reporter gene expression from a wild type (1xZBS) and a mutant (1xZBSmu) binding site in transgenic plants. The 1xZBS was used to express green fluorescent protein (GFP) whereas the 1xZBSmu was used to express red fluorescent protein (RFP). Upon induction of ZF-VP64 we found a much higher expression of GFP (about 33-fold) as compared to RFP expression. These results suggest that artificial zinc finger chimeras can be used to target specific DNA sequences and to regulate gene expression in plants.

Regulation of transgene expression in plants with polydactyl zinc finger transcription factors

Designer zinc finger transcription factors (TFs(ZF)) have been developed to control the expression of transgenes and endogenous genes in mammalian cells. Application of TFs(ZF) technology in plants would enable a wide range of both basic and applied studies. In this paper, we report the use of TFs(ZF) to target a defined 18-bp DNA sequence to control gene expression in plant cells and in transgenic plants. A beta-glucuronidase reporter gene was activated by using the designed six-zinc finger protein 2C7 expressed as a fusion with the herpes simplex virus VP16 transcription factor activation domain. Reporter gene expression was activated 5- to 30-fold by using TFs(ZF) in BY-2 protoplasts, whereas expression was increased as much as 450 times in transgenic tobacco plants. Use of a phloem-specific promoter to drive expression of the TFs(ZF) resulted in activation of the reporter gene in vascular tissues. Transgenic tobacco plants that produce 2C7 transcription factors were phenotypically normal through two generations, suggesting that the factors exerted no adverse effects. This study demonstrates the utility of zinc finger technology in plants, setting the stage for its application in basic and applied agricultural biotechnology.

Designed transcription factors as structural, functional and therapeutic probes of chromatin in vivo. Fourth in review series on chromatin dynamics

Despite its central importance in gene regulation, chromatin in mammalian cells remains relatively poorly understood-a predicament due to the paucity of robust genetic tools in mammals, the complexity of the chromatin remodeling machinery, and the dynamic properties of chromatin in vivo. Here we review recent developments in understanding endogenous mammalian gene regulation via the use of designed transcription factors (TFs). These include mutated forms of naturally occurring TFs that exhibit dominant-negative activity, and designed proteins with novel, predetermined DNA-binding specificities. Systematic targeting of designed TFs to particular promoters is helping to illuminate the complex rules that chromatin imposes on TF access and action in vivo. We evaluate the potential applications of these proteins as probes of mammalian chromatin-based regulatory pathways and their potential for the therapy of human disease, highlighting leukemia in particular.

The use of zinc finger peptides to study the role of specific factor binding sites in the chromatin environment

The once ambitious goal of creating custom DNA-binding factors has been achieved. Advances in construction methodology now enable any laboratory to create site-specific binding proteins to nearly any sequence. Using predefined zinc finger modules, new proteins can be constructed in days with minimal cost and using only standard polymerase chain reaction techniques. The existing spectrum of modules can be rearranged to produce more than one billion different proteins that bind with high affinity and specificity. Artificial transcription factors based on modified zinc finger domains have recently been shown by several groups to be capable of activating or repressing transcription of a handful of endogenous genes in the chromatin environment of plant and animal cells. These proteins can also be used in a number of ways to compete with endogenous factors for specific binding sites in vivo. Zinc finger peptides are therefore useful tools in the study of gene regulation and signal transduction. A detailed description of the construction method is presented, along with a full discussion of potential caveats and future expectations.