Methane Activation by Gas Phase Atomic Clusters

Consecutive methane activation mediated by single metal boride cluster anions NbB4. Phys Chem Chem Phys 2021;23:12592-12599. [PMID: 34047332 DOI: 10.1039/d1cp01418h]

Cleavage of all C-H bonds in two methane molecules by gas-phase cluster ions at room temperature is a challenging task. Herein, mass spectrometry and quantum chemical calculations have been used to identify one single metal boride cluster anions NbB4- that can activate eight C-H bonds in two methane molecules and release one H2 molecule each time under thermal collision conditions. In these consecutive reactions, the loaded Nb atoms and the support B4 units play different roles but act synergistically to activate CH4, which is responsible for the interesting reactivity of NbB4-. Moreover, there are some mechanistic differences in these two reactions, including the mechanisms for the first C-H bond activation steps, dihydrogen desorption sites, and major electron donors. This study shows that non-noble metal boride species are reactive enough to facilitate thermal C-H bond cleavages, and boron-based materials may be one kind of potential support material facilitating surface hydrogen transport.

Simultaneous Functionalization of Methane and Carbon Dioxide Mediated by Single Platinum Atomic Anions

Mass spectrometric analysis of the anionic products of interaction among Pt^-, methane, and carbon dioxide shows that the methane activation complex, H₃C-Pt-H^-, reacts with CO₂ to form [H₃C-Pt-H(CO₂)]^-. Two hydrogenation and one C-C bond coupling products are identified as isomers of [H₃C-Pt-H(CO₂)]^- by a synergy between anion photoelectron spectroscopy and quantum chemical calculations. Mechanistic study reveals that both CH₄ and CO₂ are activated by the anionic Pt atom and that the successive depletion of the negative charge on Pt drives the CO₂ insertion into the Pt-H and Pt-C bonds of H₃C-Pt-H^-. This study represents the first example of the simultaneous functionalization of CH₄ and CO₂ mediated by single atomic anions.

Oxidation of isoprene by titanium oxide cluster cations in the gas phase

The heterogeneous oxidation of isoprene (C5H8) by metal-oxide particles, such as the typical mineral aerosols TiO2, plays an important role in the isoprene atmospheric chemistry. However, the underlying mechanism of C5H8 oxidation remains elusive owing to the complexities of aerosol surfaces and reaction channels. Herein, we report the gas-phase reactions of TixOy+ (x = 1-7, y = 1-14) cations with isoprene by using mass spectrometry and density functional theory (DFT) calculations. Five types of reaction channels were observed: association, hydrogen atom transfer (HAT), C-C bond cleavage, combined oxygen atom transfer (OAT) and HAT and combined OAT and C-C bond cleavage. It is noteworthy that formaldehyde is known as the major oxidation product of isoprene/hydroxyl radicals in the atmosphere. In addition, CO has not been observed in the reactions of isoprene with gas-phase ions. Therefore, the reaction mechanisms of CH2O and CO generation observed in Ti2O5+/C5H8 and Ti4O8+/C5H8 systems were further investigated by DFT calculations, and the calculated results are in agreement with the experimental observations. In these two reactions, both Ti and O atoms can be the adsorption sites for C5H8. The reaction channels and mechanistic information gained in these gas-phase model reactions may offer fundamental insights relevant to the corresponding oxidation processes over titanium oxide aerosols in the atmosphere.

Dinitrogen Activation and Functionalization by Heteronuclear Metal Cluster Anions FeV2C2- at Room Temperature

It is of great importance to study the mechanisms to activate dinitrogen (N₂), the very inert molecule, under mild conditions. Gas-phase metal clusters are being actively generated to react with N₂ to identify new reaction types and mechanisms. Herein, an unprecedented, mechanistically unique metal atom (Fe or V) ejection in the thermal reaction of FeV₂C₂^- with N₂ has been identified using mass spectrometry, photoelectron imaging spectroscopy, and quantum chemistry calculations. Strong evidence suggests that the complete cleavage of the N≡N triple bond and subsequent functionalization of two N atoms via C-N coupling were achieved in this reaction. The complementary cooperation between V atoms with strong electron-donating ability and an Fe atom with large electron-withdrawing ability as well as the geometric flexibility of the Fe-V-V ring drives the whole reaction. The important role of C ligands in N≡N cleavage was also revealed. This study emphasizes the importance of heteronuclear metal systems for N₂ fixation.

Adsorption and reactions of NO molecules on anionic gold clusters in the size range below 1 nm: effects of clusters' global electronic properties

We systemically studied adsorption and reactions of NO on Au_n^- (n≤ 80) using a mini flow-tube reactor running at 150 K. For Au_n^- (n≤ 11), their reactions with NO mainly formed cluster complexes containing various numbers of NO units; for Au_n^- (n≥ 12), most active sizes eventually formed specific complexes Au_n(NO)₃^-. The relative rates of the reactions with the first NO were measured. Correlations between these relative rates and the adiabatic detachment energies (ADEs) of Au_n^- revealed the dominant effect of the clusters' spins and a more complicated electron transfer mechanism than that of reactions with O₂. Au₂₀^- as well as previously reported Au_4,6,8^- is an exceptional size, which eventually formed the disproportionate product Au₂₀NO₂^-, and all these four sizes have very low ADEs. The effects of the clusters' global electronic properties on adsorption and reactions of NO on anionic gold are helpful to understand catalytic mechanisms of gold-based catalysts in NO removal reactions.

Reactivity of Iron Hydride Anions Fe2Hn- (n = 0-3) with Carbon Dioxide

The hydrogenation of CO₂ into value-added complexes is of great importance for both environmental and economic issues. Metal hydrides are good models for the active sites to explore the nature of CO₂ hydrogenation; however, the fundamental insights into C-H bond formation are still far from clear because of the complexity of real-life catalysts. Herein, gas-phase reactions of the Fe₂H_n^- (n = 0-3) anions with CO₂ were investigated using mass spectrometry and quantum chemical calculations. The experimental results showed that the reduction of CO₂ into CO dominates all of these reactions, whereas Fe₂H^- and Fe₂H₂^- can induce the hydrogenation of CO₂ effectively to give rise to products Fe(HCO₂)^- and HFe(HCO₂)^-, respectively. The mechanistic aspects and the reactivity of Fe₂H_n^- with an increased number of H atoms in CO₂ hydrogenation were rationalized by theoretical calculations.

Methane Borylation Catalyzed by Ru, Rh, and Ir Complexes in Comparison with Cyclohexane Borylation: Theoretical Understanding and Prediction

Methane borylation catalyzed by Cp*M(Bpin)_n (M = Ru or Rh; HBpin = pinacolborane; n = 2 or 3) and (TMPhen)Ir(Bpin)₃ (TMPhen = 3,4,7,8-tetramethyl-1,10-phenanthroline) was investigated by DFT in comparison with cyclohexane borylation. Because Ru-catalyzed borylation has not been theoretically investigated yet, its reaction mechanism was first elucidated; Cp*Ru(Bpin)₃ 1-Ru is an active species, and Cp*Ru(Bpin)₃(H)(CH₃) 4-Ru is a key intermediate. In 4-Ru, the Ru is understood to have an ambiguous oxidation state between +IV and +VI because it has a H··Bpin bonding interaction with a bond order of about 0.5. Methane borylation occurs through oxidative addition of methane C-H bond followed by reductive elimination of borylmethane in all of these catalysts. The catalytic activity for methane borylation increases following the order Cp*Ru(Bpin)₃ < (TMPhen)Ir(Bpin)₃ < Cp*Rh(Bpin)₂. Cyclohexane borylation occurs in the same mechanism except for the presence of isomerization of a key intermediate. Chemoselectivity of methane over cyclohexane increases following the order Ir < Ru < Rh. In all of these catalysts, the rate-determining step (RDS) of cyclohexane borylation needs a larger ΔG°^‡ than the RDS of methane borylation because the more bulky cyclohexyl group induces larger steric repulsion with the ligand than methyl. One reason for the worse chemoselectivity of the Ir catalyst is its less congested transition state of the reductive elimination of borylcyclohexane. Herein, use of a strongly electron-donating ligand consisting of pyridine and N-heterocyclic carbene with bulky substituents is computationally proposed as a good ligand for the Ir catalyst; actually, the Ir complex of this ligand is calculated to be more active and more chemoselective than Cp*Rh(Bpin)₂ for methane borylation.

Revisiting the Intriguing Electronic Features of the BeOBeC Carbyne and Some Isomers: A Quantum-Chemical Assessment

Extensive high-level quantum-chemical calculations reveal that the rod-shaped molecule BeOBeC, which was recently generated in matrix experiments, exists in two nearly isoenergetic states, the 5 Σ quintet (5 6) and the 3 Σ triplet (3 6). Their IR features are hardly distinguishable at finite temperature. The major difference concerns the mode of spin coupling between the terminal beryllium and carbon atoms. Further, the ground-state potential-energy surface of the [2Be,C,O] system at 4 K is presented and differences between the photochemical and thermal behaviors are highlighted. Finally, a previously not considered, so far unknown C2v -symmetric rhombus-like four-membered ring 3 [Be(O)(C)Be] (3 5) is predicted to represent the global minimum on the potential-energy surface.

Photoassisted Selective Steam and Dry Reforming of Methane to Syngas Catalyzed by Rhodium-Vanadium Bimetallic Oxide Cluster Anions at Room Temperature

Photoassisted steam reforming and dry (CO₂ ) reforming of methane (SRM and DRM) at room temperature with high syngas selectivity have been achieved in the gas-phase catalysis for the first time. The catalysts used are bimetallic rhodium-vanadium oxide cluster anions of Rh₂ VO_1-3 ^- . Both the oxidation of methane and reduction of H₂ O/CO₂ can take place efficiently in the dark while the pivotal step to govern syngas selectivity is photo-excitation of the reaction intermediates Rh₂ VO_2,3 CH₂ ^- to specific electronically excited states that can selectively produce CO and H₂ . Electronic excitation over Rh₂ VO_2,3 CH₂ ^- to control the syngas selectivity is further confirmed from the comparison with the thermal excitation of Rh₂ VO_2,3 CH₂ ^- , which leads to diversity of products. The atomic-level mechanism obtained from the well-controlled cluster reactions provides insight into the process of selective syngas production from the photocatalytic SRM and DRM reactions over supported metal oxide catalysts.

Direct functionalization of C-H bonds by electrophilic anions

Alkanes and [B₁₂X₁₂]^2- (X = Cl, Br) are both stable compounds which are difficult to functionalize. Here we demonstrate the formation of a boron-carbon bond between these substances in a two-step process. Fragmentation of [B₁₂X₁₂]^2- in the gas phase generates highly reactive [B₁₂X₁₁]^- ions which spontaneously react with alkanes. The reaction mechanism was investigated using tandem mass spectrometry and gas-phase vibrational spectroscopy combined with electronic structure calculations. [B₁₂X₁₁]^- reacts by an electrophilic substitution of a proton in an alkane resulting in a B-C bond formation. The product is a dianionic [B₁₂X₁₁C_nH_2n+1]^2- species, to which H⁺ is electrostatically bound. High-flux ion soft landing was performed to codeposit [B₁₂X₁₁]^- and complex organic molecules (phthalates) in thin layers on surfaces. Molecular structure analysis of the product films revealed that C-H functionalization by [B₁₂X₁₁]^- occurred in the presence of other more reactive functional groups. This observation demonstrates the utility of highly reactive fragment ions for selective bond formation processes and may pave the way for the use of gas-phase ion chemistry for the generation of complex molecular structures in the condensed phase.

Exploring the Reaction Mechanism of H2S Decomposition with MS3 (M = Mo, W) Clusters

H₂S is abundantly available in nature, and it is a common byproduct in industries. Molybdenum sulfides have been proved to be active in the catalytic decomposition of hydrogen sulfide (H₂S) to produce hydrogen. In this study, density functional theory (DFT) calculations are carried out to explore the reaction mechanisms of H₂S with MS₃ (M = Mo, W) clusters. The reaction mechanism of H₂S with MoS₃ is roughly the same as that of the reaction with WS₃, and the free-energy profile of the reaction with MoS₃ is slightly higher than that of the reaction with WS₃. The overall driving forces (-ΔG) are positive, and the overall reaction barriers (ΔG _b) are rather small, indicating that such H₂ productions are product-favored. MS₃ (M = Mo, W) clusters have clawlike structures, which have electrophilic metal sites to receive the approaching H₂S molecule. After several hydrogen-atom transfer (HAT) processes, the final MS₄·H₂ (IM-4) complexes are formed, which could desorb H₂ at a relatively low temperature. The singlet product MS₄ clusters contain the singlet S₂ moiety, similar to the adsorbed singlet S₂ on the surface of sulfide catalysts. The theoretical results are compared with the experiments of heterogeneous catalytic decomposition of H₂S by MoS₂ catalysts. Our work may provide some insights into the optimal design of the relevant catalysts.

On the Crucial Role of Isolated Electronic States in the Thermal Reaction of ReC+ with Dihydrogen

Presented here is that isolated, long‐lived electronic states of ReC⁺ serve as the root cause for distinctly different reactivities of this diatomic ion in the thermal activation of dihydrogen. Detailed high‐level quantum chemical calculations support the experimental findings obtained in the highly diluted gas phase using FT‐ICR mass spectrometry. The origin for the existence of these long‐lived excited electronic states and the resulting implications for the varying mechanisms of dihydrogen splitting are addressed.

Nanostructured Carbon Nitrides for CO2 Capture and Conversion

Carbon nitride (CN), a 2D material composed of only carbon (C) and nitrogen (N), which are linked by strong covalent bonds, has been used as a metal-devoid and visible-light-active photocatalyst owing to its magnificent optoelectronic and physicochemical properties including suitable bandgap, adjustable energy-band positions, tailor-made surface functionalities, low cost, metal-free nature, and high thermal, chemical, and mechanical stabilities. CN-based materials possess a lot of advantages over conventional metal-based inorganic photocatalysts including ease of synthesis and processing, versatile functionalization or doping, flexibility for surface engineering, low cost, sustainability, and recyclability without any leaching of toxic metals from photocorrosion. Carbon nitrides and their hybrid materials have emerged as attractive candidates for CO₂ capture and its reduction into clean and green low-carbon fuels and valuable chemical feedstock by using sustainable and intermittent renewable energy sources of sunlight and electricity through the heterogeneous photo(electro)catalysis. Here, the latest research results in this field are summarized, including implementation of novel functionalized nanostructured CNs and their hybrid heterostructures in meeting the stringent requirements to raise the efficiency of the CO₂ reduction process by using state-of-the-art photocatalysis, electrocatalysis, photoelectrocatalysis, and feedstock reactions. The research in this field is primarily focused on advancement in the synthesis of nanostructured and functionalized CN-based hybrid heterostructured materials. More importantly, the recent past has seen a surge in studies focusing significantly on exploring the mechanism of their application perspectives, which include the behavior of the materials for the absorption of light, charge separation, and pathways for the transport of CO₂ during the reduction process.

Spin-orbit coupling and vibronic transitions of Ce(C3H4) and Ce(C3H6) formed by the Ce reaction with propene: Mass-analyzed threshold ionization and relativistic quantum computation

A Ce atom reaction with propene is carried out in a pulsed laser vaporization molecule beam source. Several Ce-hydrocarbon species formed by the C-H and C-C bond activation of propene are observed by time-of-flight mass spectrometry, and Ce(C₃H_n) (n = 4 and 6) are characterized by mass-analyzed threshold ionization (MATI) spectroscopy and density functional theory, multiconfiguration, and relativistic quantum chemical calculations. The MATI spectrum of each species consists of two vibronic band systems, each with several vibronic bands. Ce(C₃H₆) is identified as an inserted species with Ce inserting into an allylic C-H bond of propene and Ce(C₃H₄) as a metallocycle through 1,2-vinylic dehydrogenation. Both species have a C_s structure with the Ce 4f¹6s¹ ground valence electron configuration in the neutral molecule and the Ce 4f¹ configuration in the singly charged ion. The two vibronic band systems observed for each species are attributed to the ionization of two pairs of the lowest spin-orbit coupled states with each pair being nearly degenerate.

Methane activation by heteronuclear diatomic AuRh+ cation: comparison with homonuclear Au2+ and Rh2. Phys Chem Chem Phys 2020;22:6231-6238. [PMID: 32129335 DOI: 10.1039/c9cp05699h]

The ability to activate methane differs appreciably for different transition metals, and it is attractive to find the most suitable metal for the direct conversion of methane to value-added chemicals. Herein, we performed a comparative study on the reactions of CH₄ with Au₂⁺, AuRh⁺ and Rh₂⁺ cations by mass-spectrometry based experiments and DFT-based theoretical analysis. Different reactivity has been found for these cations: Au₂⁺ has the lowest reactivity, and it can activate methane but only produce H-Au₂-CH₃⁺ without H₂ release; Rh₂⁺ has the highest reactivity, and it can produce both carbene-type Rh₂-CH₂⁺ and carbyne-type H-Rh₂-CH⁺ with H₂ release; AuRh⁺ also has high reactivity to produce only AuRh-CH₂⁺ with H₂, avoiding the excessive dehydrogenation of CH₄. Our theoretical results demonstrate that Rh is responsible for the high reactivity, while Au leads to selectivity, which may be caused by the unique intrinsic bonding properties of the metals.

Pyrolysis of mixtures of methane and ethane: activation of methane with the aid of radicals generated from ethane

Inert CH₄ molecules can be activated and incorporated into pyrolysis products with the aid of radicals generated by pyrolysis of C₂H₆.

Semiconductor nanocrystals for small molecule activation via artificial photosynthesis

The protocol of artificial photosynthesis using semiconductor nanocrystals shines light on green, facile and low-cost small molecule activation to produce solar fuels and value-added chemicals.

Geometric and Electronic Structures of VB40/+ Clusters and Reactivity of the Cationic Cluster with Methane from Quantum Chemical Calculations

Quantum chemical methods have been employed to study the geometric and electronic structures of VB₄^0/+ clusters and the mechanism of the reaction of the cationic clusters with methane. It was found that the ground states of the neutral and cationic clusters were ⁴A' and ³A' of a planar isomer in C_s symmetry in which vanadium atom side-on binds to the rhombic B₄ moiety. The ionization energy of the neutral cluster was calculated to be 7.13 eV at the CCSD(T) level. The reaction pathways on the triplet and quintet potential energy profiles of the dehydrogenation and elimination of V⁺ in the reaction of VB₄⁺ cluster with methane were established based on the BPW91 functional calculations. Both of the dehydrogenation and elimination of V⁺ in the reaction of VB₄⁺ cluster with methane were initiated by the B₄ moiety of the VB₄⁺ cluster, and these two reaction channels were thermodynamically and kinetically favorable. The dehydrogenation and elimination of V⁺ in the reaction of VB₄⁺ cluster with methane were exothermic processes.

Direct Conversion of Methane with Carbon Dioxide Mediated by RhVO3 - Cluster Anions

Direct conversion of methane with carbon dioxide to value-added chemicals is attractive but extremely challenging because of the thermodynamic stability and kinetic inertness of both molecules. Herein, the first dinuclear cluster species, RhVO₃ ^- , has been designed to mediate the co-conversion of CH₄ and CO₂ to oxygenated products, CH₃ OH and CH₂ O, in the temperature range of 393-600 K. The resulting cluster ions RhVO₃ CO^- after CH₃ OH formation can further desorb the [CO] unit to regenerate the RhVO₃ ^- cluster, leading to the successful establishment of a catalytic cycle for methanol production from CH₄ and CO₂ (CH₄ +CO₂ →CH₃ OH+CO). The exceptional activity of Rh-V dinuclear oxide cluster (RhVO₃ ^- ) identified herein provides a new mechanism for co-conversion of two very stable molecules CH₄ and CO₂ .

A Reaction-Induced Localization of Spin Density Enables Thermal C-H Bond Activation of Methane by Pristine FeC4. Chemistry 2019;25:12940-12945. [PMID: 31268193 PMCID: PMC6852486 DOI: 10.1002/chem.201902572]

The reactivity of the cationic metal-carbon cluster FeC₄ ⁺ towards methane has been studied experimentally using Fourier-transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry and computationally by high-level quantum chemical calculations. At room temperature, FeC₄ H⁺ is formed as the main ionic product, and the experimental findings are substantiated by labeling experiments. According to extensive quantum chemical calculations, the C-H bond activation step proceeds through a radical-based hydrogen-atom transfer (HAT) mechanism. This finding is quite unexpected because the initial spin density at the terminal carbon atom of FeC₄ ⁺ , which serves as the hydrogen acceptor site, is low. However, in the course of forming an encounter complex, an electron from the doubly occupied sp-orbital of the terminal carbon atom of FeC₄ ⁺ migrates to the singly occupied π*-orbital; the latter is delocalized over the entire carbon chain. Thus, a highly localized spin density is generated in situ at the terminal carbon atom. Consequently, homolytic C-H bond activation occurs without the obligation to pay a considerable energy penalty that is usually required for HAT involving closed-shell acceptor sites. The mechanistic insights provided by this combined experimental/computational study extend the understanding of methane activation by transition-metal carbides and add a new facet to the dizzying mechanistic landscape of hydrogen-atom transfer.

Efficient Liberation of Ammonia from Thermal Reaction of ScNH+ Cations and Water

Ammonia synthesis by using water as a hydrogen source is a challenging task. Laser-ablation-generated ScNH⁺ cations have been mass-selected using a quadrupole mass filter and reacted with H₂O in a linear ion trap reactor under thermal collision conditions. Through mass spectrometry in conjunction with density functional theory calculations, we found that ammonia is released as the product in the reaction of ScNH⁺ with H₂O, and this reaction is with high efficiency and selectivity, and the rate constant for the reaction is (1.14 ± 0.23) × 10^-10 cm³ molecule^-1 s^-1, corresponding to the reaction efficiency of 15%. Metal imido complexes (*MNH) are one of the important intermediates in the currently reported NH₃ synthetic reactions. The gas-phase ScNH⁺ cation can be a simplified model of *MNH over catalysts of NH₃ synthesis, and the facile proton transfer mechanism obtained in this model system may offer fundamental mechanistic insights into how to design catalysts for ammonia production by using water as the hydrogen source under ambient conditions.

Selective Activation of the C-H Bond in Methane by Single Platinum Atomic Anions

Mass spectrometric analysis of the anionic products of interaction between platinum atomic anions, Pt^- , and methane, CH₄ and CD₄ , in a collision cell shows the preferred generation of [PtCH₄ ]^- and [PtCD₄ ]^- complexes and a low tendency toward dehydrogenation. [PtCH₄ ]^- is shown to be H-Pt-CH₃ ^- by a synergy between anion photoelectron spectroscopy and quantum chemical calculations, implying the rupture of a single C-H bond. The calculated reaction pathway accounts for the observed selective activation of methane by Pt^- . This study presents the first example of methane activation by a single atomic anion.

Selective Generation of Free Hydrogen Atoms in the Reaction of Methane with Diatomic Gold Boride Cations

The thermal reaction of diatomic gold boride cation AuB+ with methane has been studied by using state-of-the-art mass spectrometry in conjunction with density functional theory calculations. The AuB+ ion can activate a methane molecule to produce exclusively the free hydrogen atom, an important intermediate in hydrocarbon transformation. This result is different from the reactivity of AuC+ and CuB+ counterparts with methane in previous studies. The AuC+ cation mainly transforms methane into ethylene. The CuB+ reaction system principally generates the free hydrogen atoms, but it also gives rise a portion of ethylene-like product H2B−CH2. The B atom of AuB+ is the active site to activate methane. The strong relativistic effect on gold plays an important role for the product selectivity. The mechanistic insights obtained from this study provide guidance for rational design of active sites with high product selectivity toward methane activation.

Identification of Active Sites and Structural Characterization of Reactive Ionic Intermediates by Cryogenic Ion Trap Vibrational Spectroscopy

Cryogenic ion trap vibrational spectroscopy paired with quantum chemistry currently represents the most generally applicable approach for the structural investigation of gaseous cluster ions that are not amenable to direct absorption spectroscopy. Here, we give an overview of the most popular variants of infrared action spectroscopy and describe the advantages of using cryogenic ion traps in combination with messenger tagging and vibrational predissociation spectroscopy. We then highlight a few recent studies that apply this technique to identify highly reactive ionic intermediates and to characterize their reactive sites. We conclude by commenting on future challenges and potential developments in the field.

Isomerizations of a Pt4 cluster revealed by spatiotemporal microscopic analysis

We now report the first direct observation of the fluxional nature in which the four-atomic platinum cluster (Pt4) randomly walks through several isomers. Time-lapse analysis by a Cs-corrected transmission electron microscope allowed us to acquire the atomic coordinates at a sub-angstrom space resolution and 0.2 s time resolution for each cluster isomer. The analysis revealed that the isomerization follows a simple first-order kinetic model.

Intrinsic Reactivity of Diatomic 3d Transition-Metal Carbides in the Thermal Activation of Methane: Striking Electronic Structure Effects

Mechanistic aspects of the C-H bond activation of methane by metal-carbide cations MC⁺ of the 3d transition-metals Sc-Zn were elucidated by NEVPT2//CASSCF quantum-chemical calculations and verified experimentally for M = Ti, V, Fe, and Cu by using Fourier transform ion-cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry. While MC⁺ species with M = Sc, Ti, V, Cr, Cu, and Zn activate CH₄ at ambient temperature, this is prevented with carbide cations of M = Mn, Fe, and Co by high apparent barriers; NiC⁺ has a small apparent barrier. Hydrogen-atom transfers from methane to metal-carbide cations were found to proceed via a proton-coupled electron transfer mechanism for M = Sc-Co; wherein the doubly occupied π_xz/yz-orbitals between metal and carbon at the carbon site serve as electron donors and the corresponding metal-centered vacant π*_xz/yz-orbitals as electron acceptors. Classical hydrogen-atom transfer transpires only in the case of NiC⁺, while ZnC⁺ follows a mechanistic scenario, in which a formally hydridic hydrogen is transferred. CuC⁺ reacts by a synchronous activation of two C-H bonds. While spin density is often so crucial for the reactions of numerous MO⁺/CH₄ couples, it is much less important for the C-H bond activation by carbide cations of the 3d transition-metals, in which one notes large changes in bond dissociation energies, spin states, number of d-electrons, and charge distributions. All these factors jointly affect both the reactivity of the metal carbides and their mechanisms of C-H bond activation.