Porphyrin-sensitized solar cells: effect of carboxyl anchor group orientation on the cell performance

Can nitro groups really anchor onto TiO2? Case study of dye-to-TiO2adsorption using azo dyes with NO2substituents

Molecular rationalization of the photovoltaic performance of dye-sensitized solar cells that employ azo dyes bearing a NO₂anchoring group.

Porphyrins Containing a Triphenylamine Donor and up to Eight Alkoxy Chains for Dye-Sensitized Solar Cells: A High Efficiency of 10.9%

Porphyrins are promising DSSC sensitizers due to their structural similarity to chlorophylls as well as their tunable strong absorption. Herein, a novel D-π-A porphyrin dye XW14 containing a strongly electron-donating triphenylamine moiety as the electron donor was designed and synthesized. To avoid undesirably decreased Voc caused by dye aggregation effect, two methoxy or hexyloxy chains were introduced to the para positions of the triphenylamine moiety to afford XW15 and XW16, respectively. To further extend the absorption to a longer wavelength, a benzothiadiazole unit was introduced as an auxiliary acceptor to furnish XW17. Compared with XW14, the introduction of additional methoxy or hexyloxy groups in XW15 and XW16 red-shift the onset wavelengths from 760 to 780 and 790 nm, respectively. More impressively, XW17 has a more extended π-conjugation framework, and thus, it exhibits a much broader IPCE spectrum with an extremely red-shifted onset wavelength of 830 nm, resulting in the highest Jsc (18.79 mA cm(-2)). On the other hand, the hexyloxy chains are favorable for suppressing the dye aggregation effect, and thus XW16 shows the highest Voc of 734 mV. As a result, XW16 and XW17 demonstrate photovoltaic efficiencies of 9.1 and 9.5%, respectively, higher than those of XW14 (8.6%) and XW15 (8.7%), and obviously higher than that of 7.94% for our previously reported dye, XW4. On the basis of optimized porphyrin dye XW17, we used a nonporphyrin dye with a high Voc and strong absorption around 500 nm (WS-5) as the cosensitizer to improve the Voc from 700 to 748 mV, with synergistical Jsc enhancement from 18.79 to 20.30 mA cm(-2). Thus, the efficiency was dramatically enhanced to 10.9%, which is among the highest efficiencies obtained for the DSSCs based on traditional iodine electrolyte. In addition, the DSSCs based on XW17 + WS-5 exhibit good photostability, which is beneficial for practical applications.

Are the orientation and bond strength of the RCO2(-)···M link key factors for ultrafast electron transfers?

The photo-induced electron transfers in the "straight up" ionic assemblies [Pd3(2+)]···MCP and [Pd3(2+)]···DCP···[Pd3(2+)] ([Pd3(2+)]* → MCP or DCP) are ultrafast (<85 fs) indicating that it is not necessary to have a strong coordination bond or a bent geometry to obtain fast electron injection in porphyrin-containing DSSCs.

Synthesis, photophysical characterization, and photoelectrochemical evaluation of a palladium porphyrin sensitizer for TiO2-based dye-sensitized solar cells

An unsymmetrical (A3B) palladium porphyrin bearing a cyanoacrylic acid at one meso position has been synthesized for evaluation as a photosensitizer in dye-sensitized solar cells based on titanium dioxide ( TiO 2) as a comparison to other metalloporphyrins and as a proxy for other potential triplet-state photosensitizer compounds. The synthesis of this palladium porphyrin has provided new insight into the mechanism and product distribution of decarboxylative hydrolysis of malonic acid when attached at the porphyrin meso position. A crystal structure determination for a meso-formyl palladium porphyrin has been determined, showing saddle-distortion of the porphyrin core. The photophysical behavior of the palladium porphyrin sensitizer and its performance in photoelectrochemical cells are described and interpreted in the context of bimolecular excited state quenching pathways including oxygen sensitization, triplet–triplet annihilation and electron transfer events. Palladium porphyrins are proposed as a sensitizer class with potential for high efficiency dye-sensitized solar cells, but with the caveat that some overpotential for electron injection is necessary to compete against the multiple decay pathways that are specially available to triplet state photosensitizers.

Effects of Immersion Solvent on Photovoltaic and Photophysical Properties of Porphyrin-Sensitized Solar Cells

Memory effects in self-assembled monolayers (SAMs) of zinc porphyrin carboxylic acid on TiO2 electrodes have been demonstrated for the first time by evaluating the photovoltaic and electron transfer properties of porphyrin-sensitized solar cells prepared by using different immersion solvents sequentially. The structure of the SAM of the porphyrin on the TiO2 was maintained even after treating the porphyrin monolayer with different neat immersion solvents (memory effect), whereas it was altered by treatment with solutions containing different porphyrins (inverse memory effect). Infrared spectroscopy shows that the porphyrins in the SAM on the TiO2 could be exchanged with the same or analogous porphyrin, leading to a change in the structure of the porphyrin SAM. The memory and inverse memory effects are well correlated with a change in porphyrin geometry, mainly the tilt angle of the porphyrin along the long molecular axis from the surface normal on the TiO2, as well as with kinetics of electron transfer between the porphyrin and TiO2. Such a new structure-function relationship for DSSCs will be very useful for the rational design and optimization of photoelectrochemical and photovoltaic properties of molecular assemblies on semiconductor surfaces.

Electronic state dependence of heterogeneous electron transfer: injection from the S1 and S2 state of phlorin into TiO2

Ultrafast time-resolved measurements were performed on a novel pentafluorophenyl substituted 5,5-dimethyl phlorin derivative in solution and when attached to TiO2 colloidal films. The complex excited state dynamics of this porphyrinoid after S1 and S2 excitation was compared at different wavelengths and can be assigned to several subsequent relaxation mechanisms. The difference between excited state dynamics in the free molecule and when attached to an electron accepting electrode was measured. For both cases the dynamics was compared after excitation to the S1 and the S2 state. For the free molecule in solution an intermediate relaxation step was identified and assigned to a buckling motion of the tetrapyrrole ring. On the electrode, heterogeneous electron transfer (HET) times from both states were very similar and around 50 fs. Surprisingly, the large difference in the density of acceptor states that are resonant with the respective donor level of the molecule does not significantly influence HET dynamics. This result indicates that HET proceeds into intermediate transition states that are different from steady state surface states obtained from experiments or computations. The density of states (DOS) of these transient acceptor states appears not to be directly related to the corresponding surface or bulk DOS.

Anchoring groups for dye-sensitized solar cells

The dyes in dye-sensitized solar cells (DSSCs) require one or more chemical substituents that can act as an anchor, enabling their adsorption onto a metal oxide substrate. This adsorption provides a means for electron injection, which is the process that initiates the electrical circuit in a DSSC. Understanding the structure of various DSSC anchors and the search for new anchors are critical factors for the development of improved DSSCs. Traditionally, carboxylic acid and cyanoacrylic acid groups are employed as dye anchors in DSSCs. In recent years, novel anchor groups have emerged, which make a larger pool of materials available for DSSC dyes, and their associated physical and chemical characteristics offer interesting effects at the interface between dye and metal oxide. This review focuses especially on the structural aspects of these novel dye anchors for TiO2-based DSSCs, including pyridine, phosphonic acid, tetracyanate, perylene dicarboxylic acid anhydride, 2-hydroxylbenzonitrile, 8-hydroxylquinoline, pyridine-N-oxide, hydroxylpyridium, catechol, hydroxamate, sulfonic acid, acetylacetanate, boronic acid, nitro, tetrazole, rhodanine, and salicylic acid substituents. We anticipate that further exploration and understanding of these new types of anchoring groups for TiO2 substrates will not only contribute to the development of advanced DSSCs, but also of quantum dot-sensitized solar cells, water splitting systems, and other self-assembled monolayer-based technologies.

Effects of number and position of meta and para carboxyphenyl groups of zinc porphyrins in dye-sensitized solar cells: structure-performance relationship

Porphyrin sensitizers containing meta- and para-carboxyphenyl groups in their meso positions have been synthesized and investigated for their performance in dye-sensitized solar cells (DSSCs). The superior performance of para-derivative compared to meta-derivative porphyrins was revealed by optical spectroscopy, electrochemical property measurements, density functional theory (DFT) calculations, attenuated total reflectance-Fourier transform infrared (ATR-FTIR) spectroscopy, incident photon-to-current conversion efficiency (IPCE), electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS), and stability performance. Absorption spectra of para-carboxyphenyl-substituted porphyrins on TiO2 show a broader Soret band compared to meta-carboxyphenyl-substituted porphyrins. ATR-FTIR spectra of the studied porphyrins on TiO2 were applied to investigate the number and mode of carboxyl groups attached to TiO2. The VOC, JSC, and IPCE values of para-series porphyrins were distinctly superior to those of meta-series porphyrins. The Nyquist plots of the studied porphyrins show that charge injection in para-series porphyrins is superior to that in meta-series porphyrins. The orthogonally positioned para derivatives have more efficient charge injection and charge transfer over charge recombination, whereas the efficiencies of flat-oriented meta derivatives are retarded by rapid charge recombination. Photovoltaic measurements of the studied meta- and para-carboxyphenyl-functionalized porphyrins show that the number and position of carboxyphenyl groups play a crucial role in the performance of the DSSC. Our results indicate that para-carboxyphenyl derivatives outperform meta-carboxyphenyl derivatives to give better device performance. This study will serve as a guideline for the design and development of organic, porphyrin, and ruthenium dyes in DSSCs.

Photophysical study of a self-assembled donor-acceptor two-layer film on TiO2

The self-assembled monolayer (SAM) technique was employed to fabricate a two-layer donor-acceptor film on the surface of TiO2. The approach is based on using donor and acceptor compounds with anchoring groups of different lengths. The acceptor, a fullerene derivative, has a carboxyl anchor attached to the fullerene moiety via a short linker that places the fullerene close to the surface. The donor, a porphyrin derivative, is equipped with a long linker that can penetrate between the fullerenes and keep porphyrin on top of the fullerene layer. The two-layer fullerene-porphyrin structures were deposited on a mesoporous film of TiO2 nanoparticles by immersing the TiO2 film sequentially into fullerene and porphyrin solutions. Transient absorption spectroscopy studies of the samples revealed that after the selective photoexcitation of porphyrin a fast (<5 ps) intermolecular electron transfer (ET) takes place from porphyrin to the fullerene layer, which confirms the formation of the interlayer donor-acceptor interface. Furthermore, in the second step of ET the fullerene anions donate electrons to the TiO2 nanoparticles. The latter reaction is relatively slow with an average time constant of 230 ps. It involves roughly half of the primary generated charges, and the second half relaxes by the interlayer charge recombination. The resulting state with a porphyrin cation and electron in TiO2 has an extremely long lifetime and recombines with an average time constant of 23 ms.

Push–pull porphyrins with different anchoring group orientations for fully printable monolithic dye-sensitized solar cells with mesoscopic carbon counter electrodes

Compared with WH-C4 and WH-C1, WH-C6- and WH-C7-sensitized devices show a significantly reduced V_oc, J_sc and power conversion efficiency (η).

The number density effect of N-substituted dyes on the TiO2 surface in dye sensitized solar cells: a theoretical study

The bulky of the donor moiety reduces the number density of the adsorbed Dye3 on the surface dramatically, corresponding to poorer energy conversion efficiency of 3.91% in Dye3 compared to the significantly better performance of 5.45% in Dye2.

Improvement of dye-sensitized solar cells performance through introducing different heterocyclic groups to triarylamine dyes

The overall power conversion efficiency (PCE) of DSSCs based on TTR1–3 with chenodeoxycholic acid (CDCA) coadsorbant are 5.20%, 5.71% and 6.30%, respectively, and the value of TTR3 is close to that of N719 (6.62%).

A “click-chemistry” approach for the synthesis of porphyrin dyads as sensitizers for dye-sensitized solar cells

Two novel porphyrin dyads consisting of two zinc-metallated porphyrin units, linked by 1,2,3-triazole containing bridges, have been synthesized via “click” reactions, and used as sensitizers in DSSCs.

Porphyrins as excellent dyes for dye-sensitized solar cells: recent developments and insights

Porphyrin sensitizers have exhibited power conversion efficiencies that are comparable to or even higher than those of well-established highly efficient DSSCs based on ruthenium complexes.

Triple bond-modified anthracene sensitizers for dye-sensitized solar cells: a computational study

We performed a theoretical investigation on a series of organic dyes incorporating an anthracene moiety between a carbazole donor group and a cyanoacrylic acid acceptor, in which a triple bond (TB)-modified moiety acts as a π-conjugated linker.

The relationship between the boron dipyrromethene (BODIPY) structure and the effectiveness of homogeneous and heterogeneous solar hydrogen-generating systems as well as DSSCs

BODIPY photosensitizers were used to investigate the relationship between structure and effectiveness of visible-light-driven hydrogen production as well as DSSCs.

Synthesis, characterization and electrochemical properties of meso-thiocarboxylate-substituted porphyrin derivatives

Considering the versatility of 5,10,15,20-tetrakis(pentafluorophenyl)porphyrin (TPPF20) to react with nucleophiles we highlight here the synthesis and characterization of several mono- and tetra-thiocarboxylate derivatives. The selective displacement of the para-fluorine groups in TPPF20 by thiocarboxylic acids demonstrates that TPPF20 is an ideal platform for the rapid formation of thiocarboxylate porphyrins. The optical and electrochemical features of the thiocarboxylate derivatives were also examined thinking on their potential use in photovoltaic devices. From their electrochemical characterization the following parameters were taken into account: (i) electronegative induced effect of the thiocarboxylate dyes owing the presence of the fluorine and sulfur atoms on the molecular structure of the porphyrin; and (ii) the free rotation and flexibility features that such S atom gives to the porphyrin relatively to the semiconductor.

Effect of a long alkyl group on cyclopentadithiophene as a conjugated bridge for D-A-π-A organic sensitizers: IPCE, electron diffusion length, and charge recombination

The option of using conjugated π-linkers is critical for rational molecular design toward an energy-level strategy for organic sensitizers. To further optimize photovoltaic performance, methyl- and octyl-substituted 4H-cyclopenta[2,1-b:3,4-b']dithiophene (CPDT) are introduced into D-A-π-A featured sensitizers. Along with CPDT, instead of thiophene as conjugated bridge, WS-39 and WS-43 exhibit an extended spectral response due to the excellent conjugation and coplanarity of CPDT. Specifically, we focused on the critical effect of length of the alkyl group linked to the bridging carbon atoms of CPDT on the photovoltaic performances. Octyl-substituted WS-39 shows a broader IPCE onset with an enhanced photovoltage relative to the analogue WS-5. In contrast, WS-43, with methyl substituted on the CPDT moiety, presents a relatively low quantum conversion efficiency within the whole spectral response region, along with low photocurrent density. WS-43 displays a distinctly low IPCE platform, predominately arising from the short electron diffusion length with significant electron loss during the electron transport. The relative movement of the conduction band edge (E(CB)) and charge transfer resistance as well as lifetime of injected electrons are studied in detail. Under standard AM 1.5 conditions, WS-39-based solar cells show a promising photovoltaic efficiency of 9.07% (J(SC) = 16.61 mA cm(-2), V(OC) = 770 mV, FF = 0.71). The octyl chains attached on CPDT can provide dual protection and exhibit a high propensity to prevent binding of the iodide-triiodide redox couple, producing an efficient shielding effect to retard the charge recombination and resulting in improvement of V(OC). Our research paves the way to explore more efficient sensitizers through ingenious molecular engineering.

Synthesis and properties of a meso- tris–ferrocene appended zinc(ii) porphyrin and a critical evaluation of its dye sensitised solar cell (DSSC) performance

A zinc(ii) porphyrin derivative, F3P, was prepared containing a single ferrocene group appended at three of the meso positions.

Theoretical study on the light harvesting efficiency of zinc porphyrin sensitizers for DSSCs

DFT and TDDFT calculations have been carried out to investigate the effect of donor and acceptor groups on the electronic properties of zinc-porphyrin sensitizers. The calculated results show that increasing the electron releasing strength of a meso-donor group opposite to a meso substituted acceptor group increases the light harvesting efficiency and short circuit current density.

2-Diphenylaminothiophene as the donor of porphyrin sensitizers for dye-sensitized solar cells

Four porphyrin dyes containing 2-diphenylaminothiophene were synthesized, and the 4-ethynylbenzoic acid based dye YQ1 exhibited the highest efficiency of 6.01%.

The importance of various anchoring groups attached on porphyrins as potential dyes for DSSC applications

The influence of different anchoring groups in the efficiency of porphyrin dye sensitized solar cells.

Salicylic acid as a tridentate anchoring group for azo-bridged zinc porphyrin in dye-sensitized solar cells

Two series dyes of azo-bridged zinc porphyrins have been devised, synthesized, and performed in dye-sensitized solar cells, in which salicylic acids and azo groups were introduced as a new anchoring group and π-conjugated bridge via a simple synthetic procedure. The representation of the new dyes has been investigated by optical, photovoltaic, and electrochemical means. The photoelectric conversion efficiency of their DSSC devices has been improved compared with other DSSC devices sensitized by symmetrical porphyrin dyes. The results revealed that tridentate binding modes between salicylic acid and TiO2 nanoparticles could enhance the efficiency of electron injection. The binding modes between salicylic acid and TiO2 nanoparticles may play a crucial role in the photovoltaic performance of DSSCs.