Pyromellitamide Aggregates and Their Response to Anion Stimuli

Determining association constants from titration experiments in supramolecular chemistry

The most common approach for quantifying interactions in supramolecular chemistry is a titration of the guest to solution of the host, noting the changes in some physical property through NMR, UV-Vis, fluorescence or other techniques. Despite the apparent simplicity of this approach, there are several issues that need to be carefully addressed to ensure that the final results are reliable. This includes the use of non-linear rather than linear regression methods, careful choice of stoichiometric binding model, the choice of method (e.g., NMR vs. UV-Vis) and concentration of host, the application of advanced data analysis methods such as global analysis and finally the estimation of uncertainties and confidence intervals for the results obtained. This tutorial review will give a systematic overview of all these issues-highlighting some of the key messages herein with simulated data analysis examples.

Oxalyl retro-peptide gelators. Synthesis, gelation properties and stereochemical effects

In this work we report on gelation properties, self-assembly motifs, chirality effects and morphological characteristics of gels formed by chiral retro-dipeptidic gelators in the form of terminal diacids (1a-5a) and their dimethyl ester (1b-5b) and dicarboxamide (1c-5c) derivatives. Terminal free acid retro-dipeptides (S,S)-bis(LeuLeu) 1a, (S,S)-bis(PhgPhg) 3a and (S,S)-bis(PhePhe) 5a showed moderate to excellent gelation of highly polar water/DMSO and water/DMF solvent mixtures. Retro-peptides incorporating different amino acids (S,S)-(LeuPhg) 2a and (S,S)-(PhgLeu) 4a showed no or very weak gelation. Different gelation effectiveness was found for racemic and single enantiomer gelators. The heterochiral (S,R)-1c diastereoisomer is capable of immobilizing up to 10 and 4 times larger volumes of dichloromethane/DMSO and toluene/DMSO solvent mixtures compared to homochiral (S,S)-1c. Based on the results of (1)H NMR, FTIR, CD investigations, molecular modeling and XRPD studies of diasteroisomeric diesters (S,S)-1b/(S,R)-1b and diacids (S,S)-1b/(S,R)-1a, a basic packing model in their gel aggregates is proposed. The intermolecular hydrogen bonding between extended gelator molecules utilizing both, the oxalamide and peptidic units and layered organization were identified as the most likely motifs appearing in the gel aggregates. Molecular modeling studies of (S,S)-1a/(S,R)-1a and (S,S)-1b/(S,R)-1b diasteroisomeric pairs revealed a decisive stereochemical influence yielding distinctly different low energy conformations: those of (S,R)-diastereoisomers with lipophilic i-Bu groups and polar carboxylic acid or ester groups located on the opposite sides of the oxalamide plane resembling bola amphiphilic structures and those of (S,S)-diasteroisomers possessing the same groups located at both sides of the oxalamide plane. Such conformational characteristics were found to strongly influence both, gelator effectiveness and morphological characteristics of gel aggregates.

Novel anion-tuning supramolecular gels with dual-channel response: reversible sol-gel transition and color changes

Two novel low-molecular-weight organogelators (LMOGs) 1 and 2 composed of an anthraquinone unit, a hydrazide group, and long alkyl chains were synthesized. They could form stable gels in wide tested solvents. Chloroalkanes and aromatic solvents tend to result in transparent gels, while alcohol and other solvents yield opaque gels. The FT-IR, PXRD, and (1)H NMR spectral studies revealed that hydrogen bonding and pi-pi interactions were the main driving forces for formation of the gels. Although the hydrazide unit and the anthraquinone group were connected by the sigma-bond, the chloroform gel of 1 could be changed into a red solution upon the addition of anion (F(-), AcO(-), and H(2)PO(4)(-)) due to the disruption of the intermolecular hydrogen-bondings. Moreover, the red color clearly faded at once and the solution regelated upon the addition of methanol. The results indicated that 1 and 2 as smart anion-responsive gel might provide the basis for the development of nonfluid systems for sensing anion with the naked eye.

Positionally isomeric organic gelators: structure-gelation study, racemic versus enantiomeric gelators, and solvation effects

Low molecular weight gelator molecules consisting of aliphatic acid, amino acid (phenylglycine), and omega-aminoaliphatic acid units have been designed. By varying the number of methylene units in the aliphatic and omega-aminoaliphatic acid chains, as defined by descriptors m and n, respectively, a series of positionally isomeric gelators having different positions of the peptidic hydrogen-bonding unit within the gelator molecule has been obtained. The gelation properties of the positional isomers have been determined in relation to a defined set of twenty solvents of different structure and polarity and analyzed in terms of gelator versatility (G(ver)) and effectiveness (G(eff)). The results of gelation tests have shown that simple synthetic optimizations of a "lead gelator molecule" by variation of m and n, end-group polarity (carboxylic acid versus sodium carboxylate), and stereochemistry (racemate versus optically pure form) allowed the identification of gelators with tremendously improved versatility (G(ver)) and effectiveness (G(eff)). Dramatic differences in G(eff) values of up to 70 times could be observed between pure racemate/enantiomer pairs of some gelators, which were manifested even in the gelation of very similar solvents such as isomeric xylenes. The combined results of spectroscopic ((1)H NMR, FTIR), electron microscopy (TEM), and X-ray diffraction studies suggest similar organization of the positionally isomeric gelators at the molecular level, comprising parallel beta-sheet hydrogen-bonded primary assemblies that form inversed bilayers at a higher organizational level. Differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) studies of selected enantiomer/racemate gelator pairs and their o- and p-xylene gels revealed the simultaneous presence of different polymorphs in the racemate gels. The increased gelation effectiveness of the racemate compared to that of the single enantiomer is most likely a consequence of its spontaneous resolution into enantiomeric bilayers and their subsequent organization into polymorphic aggregates of different energy. The latter determine the gel fiber thickness and solvent immobilization capacity of the formed gel network.

Pyromellitamide gelators: exponential rate of aggregation, hierarchical assembly, and their viscoelastic response to anions

The gelation and aggregation properties of a newly synthesized structurally simplified tetrahexyl pyromellitamide 2 have been studied and compared to the previously reported tetra(ethylhexanoate) pyromellitide 1, indicating that the ester groups in the latter significantly impede its aggregation. Morphology studies (AFM and TEM) on the aggregates formed by tetrahexyl pyromellitamide 2 in cyclohexane revealed highly uniform aggregates with different dimensions at different starting concentrations, suggesting that this molecule aggregates in a hierarchical fashion from a one-dimensional supramolecular polymer through hollow tubes or compressed helices to a network structure and then to a gel. This hypothesis is further supported by viscosity measurements that indicate a crossover point where individual supramolecular fibers get entangled at concentrations above ca. 3 mM in cyclohexane. Addition of 1 equiv of tetraalkylammonium salts of chloride or bromide, however, caused the viscosities of these pyromellitamide solutions to drop by a factor of 2-3 orders of magnitude, demonstrating the sensitivity of these aggregates to the presence of small anions. The sensitivity to anions does depend on the solubility of the salts used as small anion salts with little solubility in cyclohexane did not show this effect. Time-dependent viscosity studies showed that the aggregation of pyromellitamide 2 follows an exponential rate law, possibly related to the columnar rearrangements that are associated with the observed 6 angstroms contraction in d spacing in the XRD pattern of these gels. These results, particularly on the importance of kinetics of aggregation of self-assembled pyromellitamide gels, will be useful for future development of related materials for a number of applications, including tissue engineering and drug delivery.

Synthesis, optical, and mesomorphic properties of self-assembled organogels featuring phenylethynyl framework with elaborated long-chain pyridine-2,6-dicarboxamides

A series of new organogelators with pi-conjugated phenylethynyl framework featuring long-chain carboxamides have been synthesized. These organgelators have shown great ability to gel a variety of organic solvents to form stable organogels with the minimum gelation concentration as low as 0.1 wt %. Gelation is completely thermoreversible, and it occurs due to the aggregation of the organogelators resulting in the formation of a fibrous network via a combination of intermolecular hydrogen bonding, pi-pi stacking, and van der Waals interactions that is observed for the xerogels by TEM. The influence of sol-to-gel transition has been explored in detail by variable-temperature 1H NMR, UV-vis absorption, and fluorescence spectroscopy. Aggregation-induced enhanced emission has been observed in these organogelator molecules with an order of higher fluorescence quantum yields from solution to gels. In addition, some molecules also exhibit unique liquid crystalline properties over a large temperature range as revealed by DSC and POM studies.

Self-assembly of two-component gels: stoichiometric control and component selection

Two-component systems capable of self-assembling into soft gel-phase materials are of considerable interest due to their tunability and versatility. This paper investigates two-component gels based on a combination of a L-lysine-based dendron and a rigid diamine spacer (1,4-diaminobenzene or 1,4-diaminocyclohexane). The networked gelator was investigated using thermal measurements, circular dichroism, NMR spectroscopy and small angle neutron scattering (SANS) giving insight into the macroscopic properties, nanostructure and molecular-scale organisation. Surprisingly, all of these techniques confirmed that irrespective of the molar ratio of the components employed, the "solid-like" gel network always consisted of a 1:1 mixture of dendron/diamine. Additionally, the gel network was able to tolerate a significant excess of diamine in the "liquid-like" phase before being disrupted. In the light of this observation, we investigated the ability of the gel network structure to evolve from mixtures of different aromatic diamines present in excess. We found that these two-component gels assembled in a component-selective manner, with the dendron preferentially recognising 1,4-diaminobenzene (>70 %), when similar competitor diamines (1,2- and 1,3-diaminobenzene) are present. Furthermore, NMR relaxation measurements demonstrated that the gel based on 1,4-diaminobenzene was better able to form a selective ternary complex with pyrene than the gel based on 1,4-diaminocyclohexane, indicative of controlled and selective pi-pi interactions within a three-component assembly. As such, the results in this paper demonstrate how component selection processes in two-component gel systems can control hierarchical self-assembly.

The Effect of Unsaturation on the Formation of Self-Assembled Gels from Fatty Acid L-Serine Amides and their Cytotoxicity Towards Caco-2 Cancer Cells

A series of saturated and unsaturated fatty acid l-serines 3 were synthesized and their ability to form self-assembled gels was investigated. The saturated (lauroyl 3a and steraoyl 3b) and monounsaturated (oleoyl 3c) fatty acid l-serines form gels in both water and organic solvent, whereas the diunsaturated linoleyl-l-serine 3d does not form gels in these solvents, indicating that unsaturation adversely affects the gelation process. Cytotoxicity studies on these compounds with Caco-2 cancer cells in vitro show that these gels are only moderately cytotoxic at concentrations up to 0.5 mM, making them a promising candidate for applications such as drug delivery.

High catalytic activities of artificial peroxidases based on supramolecular hydrogels that contain heme models

Composed of a supramolecular hydrogel and a heme model compound, a new type of artificial peroxidase shows high catalytic activity in organic media. The activity of this new type of artificial enzyme is significantly higher than that of the heme model compounds alone. Changes in the distal substituents above the coordinated-metal centers of the model compounds directly modulate catalytic activity. This supramolecular-hydrogel-based artificial enzyme is most active in toluene, reaching about 90% of the nascent activity of horseradish peroxidase. Moreover, this study confirms that the incorporation of the heme models into the nanofibers of gelators accounts for most of the enhancement of catalytic activity.

Challenges and breakthroughs in recent research on self-assembly

The controlled fabrication of nanometer-scale objects is without doubt one of the central issues in current science and technology. However, existing fabrication techniques suffer from several disadvantages including size-restrictions and a general paucity of applicable materials. Because of this, the development of alternative approaches based on supramolecular self-assembly processes is anticipated as a breakthrough methodology. This review article aims to comprehensively summarize the salient aspects of self-assembly through the introduction of the recent challenges and breakthroughs in three categories: (i) types of self-assembly in bulk media; (ii) types of components for self-assembly in bulk media; and (iii) self-assembly at interfaces.