Transition States of Epoxidations: Diradical Character, Spiro Geometries, Transition State Flexibility, and the Origins of Stereoselectivity

Transition-state geometry measurements from (13)c isotope effects. The experimental transition state for the epoxidation of alkenes with oxaziridines

We here suggest and evaluate a methodology for the measurement of specific interatomic distances from a combination of theoretical calculations and experimentally measured (13)C kinetic isotope effects. This process takes advantage of a broad diversity of transition structures available for the epoxidation of 2-methyl-2-butene with oxaziridines. From the isotope effects calculated for these transition structures, a theory-independent relationship between the C-O bond distances of the newly forming bonds and the isotope effects is established. Within the precision of the measurement, this relationship in combination with the experimental isotope effects provides a highly accurate picture of the C-O bonds forming at the transition state. The diversity of transition structures also allows an evaluation of the Schramm process for defining transition-state geometries on the basis of calculations at nonstationary points, and the methodology is found to be reasonably accurate.

Chiral ketone and iminium catalysts for olefin epoxidation

Organo-catalyzed asymmetric epoxidation has received much attention in the past 30 years and significant progress has been made for various types of olefins. This review will cover the advancement made in the field of chiral ketone and chiral iminium salt-catalyzed epoxidations.

Asymmetric epoxidation of 1,1-disubstituted terminal olefins by chiral dioxirane via a planar-like transition state

Various 1,1-disubstituted terminal olefins have been investigated for asymmetric epoxidation using chiral ketone catalysts. Up to 88% ee has been achieved with a lactam ketone, and a planar transition state is likely to be a major reaction pathway.

Theoretical investigations of substituent effects in dimethyldioxirane epoxidation reactions

A detailed theoretical study of dimethyldioxirane-mediated epoxidations with a variety of differently substituted alkenes 3-21 is presented. Transition structures and activation barriers were determined in the gas phase and in acetone as solvent with the B3LYP/6-311+G(d) level of theory. Substituent effects were elucidated by frontier orbital analyses of the reacting species as well as by natural bond orbital (NBO) analysis of the transition structures. Epoxidations with alkenes carrying electron-donating groups such as OMe or NHAc commonly tend to have low activation energies and early transitions states, whereas using alkenes with electron-withdrawing moieties such as CN, SO2Me, CO2Me, CF3, CHO, and Cl higher activation barriers and late transition states are observed. In all cases a net charge transfer (CT) from the alkene to the dioxirane was observed substantiating the electrophilic character of dimethyldioxirane.

Generation of mono- and bis-dioxiranes from 2,3-butanedione

Biacetyl reacts with oxone to give bis-dioxirane [3,3'-dimethyl-3,3'-bidioxirane, 3B] and mono-dioxirane [1-(3-methyl-dioxiran-3-yl)ethanone, 3A)]. Bis-dioxirane 3B is formed when two oxygens are incorporated into biacetyl, while mono-dioxirane 3A incorporated only one. A greater stability is observed in 3B compared to 3A, which is attributed to an alpha-dioxiranyl (anomeric) effect in the former. In contrast, 3A suffers from a destabilizing pi-electron withdrawing effect from the adjacent carbonyl group.

Peroxy acid epoxidation of acyclic allylic alcohols. Competition between s-trans and s-cis peroxy acid conformers

[Reaction: see text]. RB3LYP calculations, reported here, indicate that peroxy acid s-cis conformer is more stable than its s-trans counterpart, in agreement with experimental data. Difference in stability is the highest in the gas phase, but it falls considerably on going from the gas phase to moderately polar solvent. In the case of peroxy formic acid, the enthalpy (free energy) difference is about 3.4 (2.5) kcal/mol, respectively, in the gas phase but decreases to 1.2 (0.6) kcal/mol in dichloromethane solution. Introduction of an alkyl or aryl substituent on the peroxy acid, that is, on passing to peroxy acetic, peroxy benzoic (PBA), and m-chloroperoxy benzoic acid (MCPBA), adds a further significant (1.0-1.5 kcal/mol) favor to the s-cis isomer. RB3LYP/6-31+G(2d,p) calculations on the epoxidation of 2-propenol with peroxy formic and peroxy benzoic acids, respectively, suggest that the less stable peroxy acid s-trans conformer can compete with the more stable s-cis form in epoxidation reaction of these substrates. Transition structures arising from s-trans peroxy acids ("trans" TSs) retain both the well-established, for "cis" TS, perpendicular orientation of the O-H peroxy acid bond relative to the C=C bond and the one-step oxirane ring formation. These TSs collapse to the final epoxide via a 1,2-H shift at variance with the 1,4-H transfer of the classical Bartlett's "cis" mechanism. The "trans" reaction pathways have a higher barrier in the gas phase than the "cis" reaction channels, but in moderately polar solvents they become competitive. In fact, the "trans" TSs are always significantly more stabilized than their "cis" counterparts by solvation effects. Calculations also suggest that going from peroxy formic to peroxy benzoic acid should slightly disfavor the "trans" route relative to the "cis" one, reflecting, in an attenuated way, the decrease in the peroxy acid s-trans/s-cis conformer ratio. The predicted behavior for MCPBA parallels that of PBA acid.

The Role of Asynchronous Bond Formation in the Diastereoselective Epoxidation of Cyclic Enol Ethers: A Density Functional Theory Study

Density functional theory (DFT) (Becke3LYP functional and the D95 basis set) was used to study the influence of substitution on the dimethyldioxirane epoxidation reaction of six- and seven-membered cyclic enol ethers. In agreement with our previously reported experimental results, the calculations predict that substitution on the cyclic enol ether influences the level of diastereoselectivity. Apparent only from the calculations is that the degree of synchronicity in the transition state is important in the diastereoselectivity.

Torsional steering controls the stereoselectivity of epoxidation in the guanacastepene a synthesis

[reaction: see text] The stereoselectivity of the key epoxidation step in the synthesis of guanacastepene A is shown to be controlled by torsional steering. In this particular epoxidation reaction, the transition structure energetic difference is enhanced by the great asynchronicity of the forming C-O bonds that intensifies the torsional interactions.

The design of organic catalysis for epoxidation by hydrogen peroxide

The potential of various organic species to catalyze epoxidation of ethene by hydrogen peroxide is explored with B3LYP/6-31G* DFT calculations.

New paradigms for the peroxy acid epoxidation of CC double bonds: the role of the peroxy acid s-trans conformer and of the 1,2-H transfer in the epoxidation of cyclic allylic alcohols

RB3LYP calculations, on reaction of performic acid with cyclic allylic alcohols, demonstrate that the less stable s-trans conformer of peroxy acids can be involved in epoxidations of C=C bonds. Transition structures (TSs) arising from s-trans performic acid retain some of the well-established characteristics of the TSs of the s-cis isomer such as the perpendicular orientation of the O-H peroxy acid bond relative to the C=C bond and a one-step oxirane ring formation. These TSs are very asynchronous but collapse directly (without formation of any intermediate) to the final epoxide-peroxy acid complex via a 1,2-H shift. Thus, our findings challenge the traditional mechanism of peroxy acid epoxidation of C=C bonds by demonstrating that the involvement of the s-trans isomer opens an alternative one-step reaction channel characterized by a 1,2-H transfer. This novel reaction pathway can even overcome, in the case of the reaction of cyclic allylic alcohols in moderately polar solvents (e.g., in dichloromethane), the classical Bartlett's mechanism that is based on the s-cis peroxy acid form and that features a 1,4-H shift. However, the latter mechanism remains strongly favored for the epoxidation of normal alkenes.

Highly enantioselective epoxidation of styrenes: implication of an electronic effect on the competition between spiro and planar transition states

Asymmetric epoxidation of various styrenes using carbocyclic oxazolidinone-containing ketone 3 has been investigated. High enantioselectivity (89-93% enantiomeric excess) has been attained for this challenging class of alkenes. Mechanistic studies show that substituents on the ketone catalyst can have electronic influences on secondary orbital interactions, which affects the competition between spiro and planar transition states and, ultimately, enantioselectivity. The results described herein not only reveal the potential of chiral dioxirane catalyzed asymmetric epoxidation as a viable entry into this important class of olefins but also further enhance the understanding of the mechanistic aspects of chiral ketone-catalyzed asymmetric epoxidation.

From Evolution to Green Chemistry: Rationalization of Biomimetic Oxygen-Transfer Cascades

Thermodynamic electron-transfer potentials from biology textbooks elucidate the sequence of electron-transfer events in the respiratory chain in mitochondria. In this study, thermodynamic and kinetic oxygen-transfer potentials have been defined and predicted for oxidants and substrates using density functional theory, aiming to rationalize multiple oxygen-transfer events in chemical catalysis, particularly in current developments of the Sharpless dihydroxylation. Key transition states for competing mechanisms in a recent dihydroxylation method containing the olefin, osmium tetraoxide, methyltrioxorhenium(VII), a chiral tertiary amine, and the green terminal oxidant hydrogen peroxide have been investigated rigorously. The calculations show the amine to function as an oxygen-transfer mediator between rhenium peroxides and osma-2,5-dioxolanes, in addition to its role as a carrier of chiral information. Unique mechanistic and stereoelectronic patterns in this oxygen-transfer cascade explain the unexpected failure of reactivity predictions using simpler models such as Marcus theory.

VCD configuration of enantiopure/-enriched tetrasubstituted α-fluoro cyclohexanones and their use for epoxidation oftrans-olefins

The configurations of three enantiopure tetrasubstituted alpha-fluoro cyclohexanones (-)-5Ia, (-)-5IIa and (-)-6a were determined by VCD and proved to be (-)-(2S,5R)-5Ia, (-)-(2R,5R)-5IIa, and (-)-(2R,5R)-6a. The VCD study also identified the conformers populated in CDCl3 solution, including higher-energy gas-phase conformers with equatorial fluorine for 5Ia and 5IIa that are stabilized in CDCl3 solution. Used as catalysts for epoxidation of trans olefins (beta-methylstyrene, stilbene, methyl p-methoxy cinnamate) by oxone, it was found that (-)-5Ia is the most efficient for all trans olefins (providing, respectively, 62%, 90% and 66% ee) but that all three ketones provide high ee% with stilbene (78-90% ee). Moreover, the configurations predicted from the stereo outcome of the epoxidation reaction are identical to those determined by VCD.

Epoxidation of Chiral Camphor N-Enoylpyrazolidinones with Methyl(trifluoromethyl)dioxirane and Urea Hydrogen Peroxide/Acid Anhydride: Reversal of Stereoselectivity

Both diastereomeric isomers of epoxides with high optical purity are obtained when camphor N-methacryloylpyrazolidinone (1a) and N-tigloylpyrazolidinone (1b) are treated with a urea hydrogen peroxide/TFAA and methyl(trifluoromethyl)dioxirane, respectively.

Chemistry. Enhanced: a view of unusual peroxides

Chemical processes involving oxygen can lead to unstable peroxide molecules such as three-membered ring dioxiranes. In his Perspective, Greer describes the stability of a variety of heteroatom-containing dioxiranes and the tools used to characterize unstable peroxides species. He highlights the report by Ho et al., who have used low-temperature nuclear magnetic resonance to obtain direct evidence for dioxirane intermediates. The method may also be applicable to biological systems in which peroxides have been implicated.

Strategies for the design of organic aziridination reagents and catalysts: transition structures for alkene aziridinations by NH transfer

B3LYP/6-31G* transition structures for aziridination of various alkenes by substituted oxaziridines and diaziridinum salts were located. Oxaziridines substituted with electron-withdrawing groups have activation energies for nitrogen transfer similar to those calculated for epoxidation by various known organic oxidants. These transition states are relatively insensitive to alkene substituents, but highly electron deficient alkenes were calculated to have low activation energies. N-Trimethylsilyl-derived oxaziridines are predicted to be good targets for alkene aziridination reagents. Activation energies calculated for aziridination by diaziridinium salts are generally lower in energy. Aziridinations of electron-rich and highly electron deficient alkenes by diaziridinium salts are predicted to be rapid. N-Methyl, N-trifluoroacetyl, and N-trimethylsilyl derivatives showed reasonable activation energies for nitrogen transfer.

An S(N)2-like transition state for alkene episulfidation by dinitrogen sulfide

Episulfidation of alkenes by dinitrogen sulfide, generated from thermolysis of 5-aryloxy-1,2,3,4-thiatriazoles, was found to be an S(N)2-like reaction involving simultaneous sulfur addition and dinitrogen extrusion. The preference for the one-step S(N)2 mechanism instead of the two-step (2+3) dipolar cycloaddition and denitrogenation is attributed to the higher geometry distortion penalty in the (2+3) transition state than that in the S(N)2-like transition state.

Enantioselective epoxidation of alkenes catalyzed by 2-fluoro-N-carbethoxytropinone and related tropinone derivatives

Several alpha-substituted N-carbethoxytropinones have been evaluated as catalysts for asymmetric epoxidation of alkenes with Oxone, via a dioxirane intermediate. alpha-Fluoro-N-carbethoxytropinone (2) has been studied in detail and is an efficient catalyst which does not suffer from Baeyer-Villiger decomposition and can be used in relatively low loadings. This ketone was prepared in enantiomerically pure form using chiral base desymmetrization of N-carbethoxytropinone. Asymmetric epoxidation catalyzed by 2 affords epoxides with up to 83% ee. Among other derivatives tested, the alpha-acetoxy derivative 7 affords the highest enantioselectivities.

Planar transition structures in the epoxidation of alkenes. A DFT study on the reaction of peroxyformic acid with norbornene derivatives

We studied, with the RB3LYP/6-311+G(d,p) method, the mechanism of peroxyformic acid epoxidation of norbornene, norbornadiene, tetramethylethene, and anti- and syn-sesquinorbornenes. The transition structures (TSs) for the reaction of tetramethylethene and norbornene show a perfect spiro geometry (the peroxy acid plane is perpendicular to the C=C bond axis) with synchronous bond formation. Also three out of the four TSs of the norbornadiene reaction are spiro-like, but the highly asynchronous syn,endo-TS has a planar-like geometry. anti- and syn-sesquinorbornenes are substrates that, because of steric constraints, cannot easily accommodate spiro-like TSs. In fact, we managed to locate only a planar-like TS and a planar TS (the peroxy acid plane contains the C=C bond axis), respectively, for these substrates. These planar TSs are "nonconcerted" since they are strongly unsymmetrical and only one of the C-O bonds of the oxirane ring is significantly formed. IRC analysis, while confirming that formation of one C-O bond fully precedes that of the other, also suggests that all this can take place without formation of intermediates, that is, within a "nonconcerted one-step process". Our theoretical data correctly reproduce the experimental facial syn selectivity of norbornene and norbornadiene epoxidations and compare well with the experimental activation free energies of the peroxy acid epoxidation of all the olefins reported here. This accord validates the method used as adequate to deal with the reactivity of these systems.

Epoxidations by peracid anions in water: ambiphilic oxenoid reactivity and stereoselectivity

[reaction: see text] Transition structures have been located for oxygen transfer from performate anion to ethylene, propene, vinylamine, vinyl chloride, vinyl cyanide, and 2-propen-1-ol at the B3LYP/6-31+G(d,p) level in a CPCM continuum model for water. Oxygen transfer is concerted, except for acrylonitrile, which is stepwise. Peracid anions react as ambiphilic oxygen donors. Predictions are made about the diastereoselectivity of epoxidations of acylic, chiral, and allylic alcohols in an alkaline solution, and one is verified experimentally.

Synthetic applications of nonmetal catalysts for homogeneous oxidations

Nonmetal oxidation catalysts have gained much attention in recent years. The reason for this surge in activity is 2-fold: On one hand, a number of such catalysts has become readily accessible; on the other hand, such catalysts are quite resistant toward self-oxidation and compatible under aerobic and aqueous reaction conditions. In this review, we have focused on five nonmetal catalytic systems which have attained prominence in the oxidation field in view of their efficacy and their potential for future development; stoichiometric cases have been mentioned to provide overview and scope. Such nonmetal oxidation catalysts include the alpha-halo carbonyl compounds 1, ketones 2, imines 3, iminium salts 4, and nitroxyl radicals 5. In combination with a suitable oxygen source (H2O2, KHSO5, NaOCl), these catalysts serve as precursors to the corresponding oxidants, namely, the perhydrates I, dioxiranes II, oxaziridines III, oxaziridinium ions IV, and finally oxoammonium ions V. A few of the salient features about these nonmetal, catalytic systems shall be reiterated in this summary. The first class entails the alpha-halo ketones, which catalyze the oxidation of a variety of organic substrates [figure: see text] by hydrogen peroxide as the oxygen source. The perhydrates I, formed in situ by the addition of hydrogen peroxide to the alpha-halo ketones, are quite strong electrophilic oxidants and expectedly transfer an oxygen atom to diverse nucleophilic acceptors. Thus, alpha-halo ketones have been successfully employed for catalytic epoxidation, heteroatom (S, N) oxidation, and arene oxidation. Although high diastereoselectivities have been achieved by these nonmetal catalysts, no enantioselective epoxidation and sulfoxidation have so far been reported. Consequently, it is anticipated that catalytic oxidations by perhydrates hold promise for further development, especially, and should ways be found to transfer the oxygen atom enantioselectively. The second class, namely, the dioxiranes, has been extensively used during the last two decades as a convenient oxidant in organic synthesis. These powerful and versatile oxidizing agents are readily available from the appropriate ketones by their treatment [figure: see text] with potassium monoperoxysulfate. The oxidations may be performed either under stoichiometric or catalytic conditions; the latter mode of operation is featured in this review. In this case, a variety of structurally diverse ketones have been shown to catalyze the dioxirane-mediated epoxidation of alkenes by monoperoxysulfate as the oxygen source. By employing chiral ketones, highly enantioselective (up to 99% ee) epoxidations have been developed, of which the sugar-based ketones are so far the most effective. Reports on catalytic oxidations by dioxiranes other than epoxidations are scarce; nevertheless, fructose-derived ketones have been successfully employed as catalysts for the enantioselective CH oxidation in vic diols to afford the corresponding optically active alpha-hydroxy ketones. To date, no catalytic asymmetric sulfoxidations by dioxiranes appear to have been documented in the literature, an area of catalytic dioxirane chemistry that merits attention. A third class is the imines; their reaction with hydrogen peroxide or monoperoxysulfate affords oxaziridines. These relatively weak electrophilic oxidants only manage to oxidize electron-rich substrates such as enolates, silyl enol ethers, sulfides, selenides, and amines; however, the epoxidation of alkenes has been achieved with activated oxaziridines produced from perfluorinated imines. Most of the oxidations by in-situ-generated oxaziridines have been performed stoichiometrically, with the exception of sulfoxidations. When chiral imines are used as catalysts, optically active sulfoxides are obtained in good ee values, a catalytic asymmetric oxidation by oxaziridines that merits further exploration. The fourth class is made up by the iminium ions, which with monoperoxysulfate lead to the corresponding oxaziridinium ions, structurally similar to the above oxaziridine oxidants except they possess a much more strongly electrophilic oxygen atom due to the positively charged ammonium functionality. Thus, oxaziridinium ions effectively execute besides sulfoxidation and amine oxidation the epoxidation of alkenes under catalytic conditions. As expected, chiral iminium salts catalyze asymmetric epoxidations; however, only moderate enantioselectivities have been obtained so far. Although asymmetric sulfoxidation has been achieved by using stoichiometric amounts of isolated optically active oxaziridinium salts, iminium-ion-catalyzed asymmetric sulf-oxidations have not been reported to date, which offers attractive opportunities for further work. The fifth and final class of nonmetal catalysts concerns the stable nitroxyl-radical derivatives such as TEMPO, which react with the common oxidizing agents (sodium hypochlorite, monoperoxysulfate, peracids) to generate oxoammonium ions. The latter are strong oxidants that chemoselectively and efficiently perform the CH oxidation in alcohols to produce carbonyl compounds rather than engage in the transfer of their oxygen atom to the substrate. Consequently, oxoammonium ions behave quite distinctly compared to the previous four classes of oxidants in that their catalytic activity entails formally a dehydrogenation, one of the few effective nonmetal-based catalytic transformations of alcohols to carbonyl products. Since less than 1 mol% of nitroxyl radical is required to catalyze the alcohol oxidation by the inexpensive sodium hypochlorite as primary oxidant under mild reaction conditions, this catalytic process holds much promise for future practical applications.

Olefin epoxidation by molybdenum and rhenium peroxo and hydroperoxo compounds: a density functional study of energetics and mechanisms

A density functional study on olefin epoxidation by rhenium and molybdenum peroxo complexes has been carried out. Various intermediates and transition structures of the systems CH3ReO3/H2O2, H3NMoO3/H2O2, and H3NOMoO3/H2O2 were characterized, including ligated and unligated mono- and bisperoxo intermediates as well as hydroperoxo derivatives. For the rhenium system the bisperoxo complex CH3ReO(O2)2*H2O was found to be most stable and the one with the lowest transition state for epoxidation of ethylene (activation barrier of 16.2 kcal/mol), in line with experimental findings. However, participation of monoperoxo and hydroperoxo complexes in olefin epoxidation cannot be excluded. For both molybdenum systems, hydroperoxo species with an additional ammonia model ligand in axial position were calculated to be most stable. Inspection of calculated activation barriers of ethylene epoxidation reveals that, in both molybdenum systems, hydroperoxo mechanisms are competitive if not superior to peroxo mechanisms. The reaction barriers of the various oxygen transfer processes can be rationalized by structural, orbital, and charge characteristics, exploiting a model that interprets the electrophilic nature of the reactive oxygen center.

Kinetic resolution of acyclic secondary allylic silyl ethers catalyzed by chiral ketones

Kinetic resolution of acyclic secondary allylic silyl ethers by chiral dioxiranes generated in situ from chiral ketones (R)-1 and (R)-2 and Oxone was investigated. An efficient and catalytic method has been developed for kinetic resolution of those substrates with a CCl(3), tert-butyl, or CF(3) group at the alpha-position. In particular, high selectivities (S up to 100) were observed for kinetic resolutions of racemic alpha-trichloromethyl allylic silyl ethers 7 and 9-15 catalyzed by ketones (R)-2. Both the recovered substrates and the resulting epoxides were obtained in high enantiomeric excess. On the basis of steric and electrostatic interactions between the chiral dioxiranes and the racemic substrates, a model was proposed to rationalize the enantioselectivities and diastereoselectivities in the chiral ketone-catalyzed kinetic resolution process.