Long-term transgene expression in the central nervous system using DNA nanoparticles

AAV and compacted DNA nanoparticles for the treatment of retinal disorders: challenges and future prospects

Gene therapy based on delivery of viral and nonviral vectors has shown great promise for the treatment of human ocular diseases; however, limitations have consistently prevented its widespread clinical application. Viral vectors have generally been better in terms of efficiency but have safety concerns. Nonviral vectors, on the other hand, offer safety but have often been disappointing in terms of efficiency of nuclear delivery and gene expression. Extensive animal studies have reported significant progress using both systems, but thus far only a few studies have shown promise in human clinical trials. This article reviews both viral and nonviral work with focus on two candidates for clinical ocular application--AAV and nanoparticles. Of particular interest are various requirements for successful clinical application of these technologies including vector trafficking, delivery, specific gene expression, and treatment safety, and tolerance.

Non-viral episomal modification of cells using S/MAR elements

INTRODUCTION

The early potential of gene therapy is slowly becoming realized following the recent treatment of patients with severe combined immunodeficiency and ocular diseases. However at present the field of gene therapy is tempered by the toxicity issues, mainly that of the integrated retroviral vector used in most trials which led to oncogenesis in several of the treated patients. The development of safer, alternative vectors is therefore vital for further progress in this field, in particular vectors which remain episomal and are therefore less genotoxic. One such unique class of vectors are those based on scaffold matrix attachment regions (S/MARs) elements, which are maintained extra-chromosomally and replicate in vitro and in vivo.

AREAS COVERED

The overview here describes the most relevant studies utilizing the S/MAR element to episomally modify mammalian cells and tissues with a particular focus on liver tissue, as well as the brain, the muscle, the eye, cancer cells, embryonic cells and neonatal mice. For this purpose, recently published data in these areas (mainly articles published between 2000 and 2010) are reviewed.

EXPERT OPINION

The utilisation of vectors harbouring an S/MAR element is an efficient, safe and cost-effective way to episomally modify mammalian cells.

DNA nanoparticles: detection of long-term transgene activity in brain using bioluminescence imaging

In this study, we used bioluminescence imaging (BLI) to track long-term transgene activity following the transfection of brain cells using a nonviral gene therapy technique. Formulations of deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) combined with 30-mer lysine polymers (substituted with 10 kDa polyethylene glycol) form nanoparticles that transfect brain cells in vivo and produce transgene activity. Here we show that a single intracerebral injection of these DNA nanoparticles (DNPs) into the rat cortex, striatum, or substantia nigra results in long-term and persistent luciferase transgene activity over an 8- to 11-week period as evaluated by in vivo BLI analysis, and single injections of DNPs into the mouse striatum showed stable luciferase transgene activity for 1 year. Compacted DNPs produced in vivo signals 7- to 34-fold higher than DNA alone. In contrast, ex vivo BLI analysis, which is subject to less signal quenching from surrounding tissues, demonstrated a DNP to DNA alone ratio of 76- to 280-fold. Moreover, the ex vivo BLI analysis confirmed that signals originated from the targeted brain structures. In summary, BLI permits serial analysis of luciferase transgene activity at multiple brain locations following gene transfer with DNPs. Ex vivo analysis may permit more accurate determination of relative activities of gene transfer vectors.

Bioluminescent imaging of reporter gene expression in the lungs of wildtype and model mice following the administration of PEG-stabilized DNA nanoparticles

DNA nanoparticles (DNPs) formed by compacting DNA with polyethyleneglycolylated poly-L-lysine are a nonviral vector shown to be safe and efficacious in animals and humans. To extend our capabilities of assessing the efficacy and duration of expression achieved by DNPs, we tested the utility of bioluminescent imaging (BLI) of transgene expression in wildtype and cystic fibrosis (CF) mouse models. We tested the effect of route of administration, mouse coat color, anesthesia, dose, and promoter sequence on the level and duration of expression. Furthermore, we investigated the correlation between imaging and direct analysis of luciferase expression in lung homogenates. We found that intratracheal instillation, and the use of deep and prolonged anesthesia with avertin produced significantly higher expression compared with intranasal administration, and the use of lighter anesthesia with isoflurane. Although similar expression was observed for both dark and light coat animals, imaging signal intensity was attenuated in mice with dark fur. Furthermore, good correlation between imaging and direct homogenate analysis was observed for single dose (r = 0.96), and dose response studies in wildtype (r = 0.82) and CF mice (r = 0.87). Finally, we used imaging to track gene expression over a 56-day time course. We found that the human ubiquitin B promoter gives stable transgene expression up to 49 days following nanoparticle administration, while expression with the cytomegalovirus promoter diminished after 2 days and returned to background levels by day 14. Taken together, our results demonstrate that BLI is an effective and useful modality for measuring gene expression conferred by DNPs in the lung.

Reducible DNA nanoparticles enhance in vitro gene transfer via an extracellular mechanism

We developed polylysine based DNA nanoparticles (DNA NPs) that contain disulfide linkage in the carrier and demonstrated that this reducible DNA NP enhances in vitro gene transfer via an extracellular mechanism. Polylysine was conjugated through an N-terminal cysteine to a polyethylene glycol chain (PEG) by either a disulfide bond (SS) or a thioether bond (CS), and the resulting PEG-peptide conjugates were used to compact plasmid DNA into reducible SS-DNA NPs or non-reducible CS-DNA NPs with identical physical properties. SS-DNA NPs mediated more than 10-fold higher in vitro gene transfer. Others have suggested that disulfide bonds in synthetic gene carriers undergo cleavage in the reducing environment inside the cell, allowing increased intracellular DNA release. In this study, however, both higher cellular uptake of SS-DNA NPs and inhibition of SS-DNA NP mediated in vitro gene transfer by blocking extracellular free thiols suggested an extracellular mechanism. DePEGylation of SS-DNA NPs by extracellular thiols caused aggregation which might lead to higher cellular uptake and higher transgene expression. A series of SS-DNA NPs prepared with stabilized disulfide bonds survived the extracellular environment without aggregation but lost the superior gene transfer ability, indicating that, in our system, intracellular mechanisms are not involved. These results provided further insight into the mechanisms of in vitro gene transfer enhancement by introducing reducible linkages, contributing to the rational design of more efficient non-viral gene delivery systems.

Nanoparticles for retinal gene therapy

Ocular gene therapy is becoming a well-established field. Viral gene therapies for the treatment of Leber's congentinal amaurosis (LCA) are in clinical trials, and many other gene therapy approaches are being rapidly developed for application to diverse ophthalmic pathologies. Of late, development of non-viral gene therapies has been an area of intense focus and one technology, polymer-compacted DNA nanoparticles, is especially promising. However, development of pharmaceutically and clinically viable therapeutics depends not only on having an effective and safe vector but also on a practical treatment strategy. Inherited retinal pathologies are caused by mutations in over 220 genes, some of which contain over 200 individual disease-causing mutations, which are individually very rare. This review will focus on both the progress and future of nanoparticles and also on what will be required to make them relevant ocular pharmaceutics.

Targeted nonviral delivery vehicles to neural progenitor cells in the mouse subventricular zone

Targeted gene therapy can potentially minimize undesirable off-target toxicity due to specific delivery. Neuron-specific gene delivery in the central nervous system is challenging because neurons are non-dividing and also outnumbered by glial cells. One approach is to transfect dividing neural stem and progenitor cells (NSCs and NPCs, respectively). In this work, we demonstrate cell-specific gene delivery to NPCs in the brains of adult mice using a peptide-modified polymeric vector. Tet1, a 12-amino acid peptide which has been shown to bind specifically to neuronal cells, was utilized as a neuronal targeting ligand. The cationic polymer polyethylenimine (PEI) was covalently modified with polyethylene glycol (PEG) for in vivo salt stability and Tet1 for neuron targeting to yield a Tet1-PEG-PEI conjugate. When plasmid DNA encoding the reporter gene luciferase was complexed with Tet1-PEG-PEI and delivered in vivo via an injection into the lateral ventricle, Tet1-PEG-PEI complexes mediated increased luciferase expression levels in brain tissue when compared to unmodified PEI-PEG complexes. In addition, cells transfected by Tet1-PEG-PEI complexes were found to be exclusively adult NPCs whereas untargeted PEG-PEI complexes were found to transfect a heterogenous population of cells. Thus, we have demonstrated targeted, nonviral delivery of nucleic acids to adult NPCs using the Tet1 targeting ligand. These materials could potentially be used to deliver therapeutic genes for the treatment of neurodegenerative diseases.

Ocular delivery of compacted DNA-nanoparticles does not elicit toxicity in the mouse retina

Subretinal delivery of polyethylene glycol-substituted lysine peptide (CK30PEG)-compacted DNA nanoparticles results in efficient gene expression in retinal cells. This work evaluates the ocular safety of compacted DNA nanoparticles. CK30PEG-compacted nanoparticles containing an EGFP expression plasmid were subretinally injected in adult mice (1 µl at 0.3, 1.0 and 3.0 µg/µl). Retinas were examined for signs of inflammation at 1, 2, 4 and 7 days post-injection. Neither infiltration of polymorphonuclear neutrophils or lymphocytes was detected in retinas. In addition, elevation of macrophage marker F4/80 or myeloid marker myeloperoxidase was not detected in the injected eyes. The chemokine KC mRNA increased 3–4 fold in eyes injected with either nanoparticles or saline at 1 day post-injection, but returned to control levels at 2 days post-injection. No elevation of KC protein was observed in these mice. The monocyte chemotactic protein-1, increased 3–4 fold at 1 day post-injection for both nanoparticle and saline injected eyes, but also returned to control levels at 2 days. No elevations of tumor necrosis factor alpha mRNA or protein were detected. These investigations show no signs of local inflammatory responses associated with subretinal injection of compacted DNA nanoparticles, indicating that the retina may be a suitable target for clinical nanoparticle-based interventions.

Compacted DNA nanoparticle gene transfer of GDNF to the rat striatum enhances the survival of grafted fetal dopamine neurons

Previously it was established that infusion of glial cell line-derived neurotrophic factor (GDNF) protein into grafts of embryonic dopamine cells has a neurotrophic effect on the grafted cells. In this study we used a nonviral technique to transfer the gene encoding for GDNF to striatal cells. Plasmid DNA encoding for GDNF was compacted into DNA nanoparticles (DNPs) by 10 kDa polyethylene glycol (PEG)-substituted lysine 30-mers (CK(30)PEG10k) and then injected into the denervated striatum of rats with unilateral 6-hydroxydopamine lesions. Sham controls were injected with saline. One week later, experimental animals received either a ventral mesencephalic (VM) tissue chunk graft or a cell suspension VM graft implanted into the denervated striatum. Grafts were allowed to integrate for 4-6 weeks and during this period we monitored spontaneous and drug-induced motor activity. Using stereological cell counting we observed a 16-fold increase in the number of surviving TH(+) cells within tissue chunk grafts placed into the striatum pretreated with pGDNF DNPs (14,923 +/- 4,326) when compared to grafts placed into striatum pretreated with saline (955 +/- 343). Similarly, we observed a sevenfold increase in the number of TH(+) cells within cell suspension grafts placed into the striatum treated with pGDNF DNPs when compared to cell suspension grafts placed into the saline dosed striatum. Behaviorally, we observed significant improvement in rotational scores and in spontaneous forepaw usage of the affected forelimb in grafted animals receiving prior treatment with compacted pGDNF DNPs when compared to grafted animals receiving saline control pretreatment. Data analysis for protein, morphological, and behavioral measures suggests that compacted pGDNF DNPs injected into the striatum can result in transfected cells overexpressing GDNF protein at levels that provide neurotrophic support for grafted embryonic dopamine neurons.