Mean-field dynamics with stochastic decoherence (MF-SD): A new algorithm for nonadiabatic mixed quantum/classical molecular-dynamics simulations with nuclear-induced decoherence

Nonadiabatic Quantum Molecular Dynamics in Dense Manifolds of Electronic States

Most nonadiabatic molecular dynamics methods require the determination of a basis of adiabatic or diabatic electronic states at every time step, but in dense manifolds of electronic states, such approaches become intractable. A notable exception is Ehrenfest molecular dynamics, which can be implemented without explicit determination of such a basis but suffers from unphysical behavior when propagation on a mean-field potential energy surface (PES) does not accurately reflect the true dynamics on multiple electronic states. Here we introduce the multiple cloning for dense manifolds of states (MCDMS) method, a systematically improvable approximation to the multiple cloning method. MCDMS avoids both the mean-field PES problem and the need to compute the full electronic spectrum. This is achieved by reformulating multiple cloning to use a subspace of approximate eigenstates constructed from the time-dependent Ehrenfest electronic wave function. By application to model systems, we show that this approach allows a substantial reduction in the size of the required electronic basis without significant loss in accuracy.

Improved Ehrenfest Approach to Model Correlated Electron-Nuclear Dynamics

Mixed quantum-classical mechanical descriptions are critical to modeling coupled electron-nuclear dynamics, i.e., nonadiabatic molecular dynamics, relevant to photochemical and photophysical processes. We introduce an efficient description of such dynamics in terms of an effective Hamiltonian that not only properly captures electron-nuclear correlation effects but also helps develop an efficient computational method. In particular, we introduce a coupled Gaussian wavepacket parametrization of the nuclear wave function, which generalizes the Ehrenfest approach to account for electron-nuclei correlations. We test this new approach, Ehrenfest-Plus, on a suite of model problems that probe electron-nuclear correlation in nonadiabatic transitions. The high accuracy of our approach, combined with mixed quantum-classical efficiency, opens a path for improved simulation of nonadiabatic molecular dynamics in realistic molecular systems.

Subspace Surface Hopping with Size-Independent Dynamics

We present a subspace surface hopping strategy to deal with complex surface crossings in nonadiabatic dynamics. By focusing on only important adiabatic states, we make subspace crossing correction (SCC) in the framework of the standard fewest switches surface hopping (FSSH) and the global flux surface hopping (GFSH). The resulting SCC-FSSH and SCC-GFSH approaches show much better performance than the counterparts using all adiabatic states for surface hopping. As demonstrated in a series of Holstein models with up to over 1000 molecular sites, both SCC-FSSH and SCC-GFSH show excellent size independence with a large time step size of 1 fs. Especially, SCC-GFSH does not refer to nonadiabatic couplings at all and gives a more proper description of superexchange, and thus, it is promising for realistic applications with complex potential energy surfaces.

Crossing Classified and Corrected Fewest Switches Surface Hopping

In the traditional fewest switches surface hopping (FSSH), trivial crossings between uncoupled or weakly coupled states have highly peaked nonadiabatic couplings and thus are difficult to deal with in the preferred, adiabatic representation. Here, we classify surface crossings into four general types and propose a parameter-free crossing corrected FSSH (CC-FSSH) algorithm, which could treat multiple trivial crossings within a time interval. As examples, Holstein Hamiltonians with different parameters are adopted to mimic electron dynamics in tens to hundreds of molecules, which suffer from severe trivial crossing problems. Using existed surface hopping approaches as references, we show that CC-FSSH exhibits significantly fast time interval convergence and weak system size dependence. In all cases, a reliable description is achieved with a large time interval of 1 fs. With a simple formalism and the ability to describe complex surface crossings, CC-FSSH could potentially simulate general nonadiabatic dynamics in nanoscale materials with a high efficiency.

An efficient solution to the decoherence enhanced trivial crossing problem in surface hopping

We provide an in-depth investigation of the time interval convergence when both trivial crossing and decoherence corrections are applied to Tully's fewest switches surface hopping (FSSH) algorithm. Using one force-based and one energy-based decoherence strategies as examples, we show decoherence corrections intrinsically enhance the trivial crossing problem. We propose a restricted decoherence (RD) strategy and incorporate it into the self-consistent (SC) fewest switches surface hopping algorithm [L. Wang and O. V. Prezhdo, J. Phys. Chem. Lett. 5, 713 (2014)]. The resulting SC-FSSH-RD approach is applied to general Hamiltonians with different electronic couplings and electron-phonon couplings to mimic charge transport in tens to hundreds of molecules. In all cases, SC-FSSH-RD allows us to use a large time interval of 0.1 fs for convergence and the simulation time is reduced by over one order of magnitude. Both the band and hopping mechanisms of charge transport have been captured perfectly. SC-FSSH-RD makes surface hops in the adiabatic representation and can be implemented in both diabatic and locally diabatic representations for wave function propagation. SC-FSSH-RD can potentially describe general nonadiabatic dynamics of electrons and excitons in organics and other materials.

Crossover from Hopping to Band-Like Charge Transport in an Organic Semiconductor Model: Atomistic Nonadiabatic Molecular Dynamics Simulation

The mechanism of charge transport (CT) in a 1D atomistic model of an organic semiconductor is investigated using surface hopping nonadiabatic molecular dynamics. The simulations benefit from a newly implemented state tracking algorithm that accounts for trivial surface crossings and from a projection algorithm that removes decoherence correction-induced artificial long-range charge transfer. The CT mechanism changes from slow hopping of a fully localized charge to fast diffusion of a polaron delocalized over several molecules as electronic coupling between the molecules exceeds the critical threshold V ≥ λ/2 (λ is the reorganization energy). With increasing temperature, the polaron becomes more localized and the mobility exhibits a "band-like" power law decay due to increased site energy and electronic coupling fluctuations (local and nonlocal electron-phonon coupling). Thus, reducing both types of electron-phonon coupling while retaining high mean electronic couplings should be part of the strategy toward discovery of new organics with high room-temperature mobilities.

Surface Hopping Dynamics beyond Nonadiabatic Couplings for Quantum Coherence

Description of correct electron-nuclear couplings is crucial in modeling of nonadiabatic dynamics. Within traditional semiclassical or mixed quantum-classical dynamics, the coupling between quantum electronic states and classical nuclear trajectories is governed by nonadiabatic coupling vectors coupled to classical nuclear momenta. This enables us to develop a very powerful nonadiabatic dynamics algorithm, namely, surface hopping dynamics, which can describe the splitting of nuclear wave packets and detailed balance. Despite its efficiency and practicality, it suffers from the lack of quantum decoherence due to incorrect accounts for the electron-nuclear coupling. Here we present a new surface hopping algorithm based on the exact electron-nuclear correlation from the exact factorization of molecular wave functions. This algorithm demands comparable computational costs to existing surface hopping methods. Numerical simulations with two-state models and a multidimensional multistate realistic molecule show that the electron-nuclear coupling beyond the nonadiabatic coupling terms can describe the quantum coherence properly.

Ab Initio Nonadiabatic Dynamics with Coupled Trajectories: A Rigorous Approach to Quantum (De)Coherence

We report the first nonadiabatic molecular dynamics study based on the exact factorization of the electron-nuclear wave function. Our approach (a coupled-trajectory mixed quantum-classical, CT-MQC, scheme) is based on the quantum-classical limit derived from systematic and controlled approximations to the full quantum-mechanical problem formulated in the exact-factorization framework. Its strength is the ability to correctly capture quantum (de)coherence effects in a trajectory-based approach to excited-state dynamics. We show this by benchmarking CT-MQC dynamics against a revised version of the popular fewest-switches surface-hopping scheme that is able to fix its well-documented overcoherence issue. The CT-MQC approach is successfully applied to investigation of the photochemistry (ring-opening) of oxirane in the gas phase, analyzing in detail the role of decoherence. This work represents a significant step forward in the establishment of the exact factorization as a powerful tool to study excited-state dynamics, not only for interpretation purposes but mainly for nonadiabatic ab initio molecular dynamics simulations.

Non-Hermitian surface hopping

We present a generalized non-Hermitian equation of motion (nH-EOM) to go beyond standard trajectory surface hopping dynamics. The derivation is based on the Born-Huang expansion of the total wave function and the polar representation of the nuclear factor. The nH-EOM contains two additional terms, a skew symmetry term iΓ with dissipation operator Γ to account for decoherence, and a kinetic-energy renormalization term to account for phase shifts, without destroying the invariance to the choice of representation. Numerically, the nH-EOM can still be solved efficiently using a semiclassical approximation in the framework of Tully's fewest-switches surface hopping (FSSH) algorithm. Applications to model Hamiltonians demonstrate improved performance over the standard FSSH approach, through comparison to exact quantum results.

An Efficient, Augmented Surface Hopping Algorithm That Includes Decoherence for Use in Large-Scale Simulations

We propose and implement a highly efficient augmented surface hopping algorithm that (i) can be used for large simulations (with many nuclei and many electronic states) and (ii) includes the effects of decoherence without parametrization. Our protocol is based on three key modifications of the surface hopping methodology: (a) a novel separation of classical and quantum degrees of freedom that treats avoided and trivial crossings efficiently, (b) a multidimensional approximation of the time derivative matrix that avoids explicit construction of the derivative coupling at most time steps, and (c) an efficient approximation for the augmented fewest-switches surface hopping decoherence rate. We will show that this protocol can be several orders of magnitude more efficient than the traditional protocol for large multidimensional problems. Furthermore, the marginal cost for including decoherence effects is now negligible.

Drift of charge carriers in crystalline organic semiconductors

We investigate the direct-current response of crystalline organic semiconductors in the presence of finite external electric fields by the quantum-classical Ehrenfest dynamics complemented with instantaneous decoherence corrections (IDC). The IDC is carried out in the real-space representation with the energy-dependent reweighing factors to account for both intermolecular decoherence and energy relaxation by which conduction occurs. In this way, both the diffusion and drift motion of charge carriers are described in a unified framework. Based on an off-diagonal electron-phonon coupling model for pentacene, we find that the drift velocity initially increases with the electric field and then decreases at higher fields due to the Wannier-Stark localization, and a negative electric-field dependence of mobility is observed. The Einstein relation, which is a manifestation of the fluctuation-dissipation theorem, is found to be restored in electric fields up to ∼10(5) V/cm for a wide temperature region studied. Furthermore, we show that the incorporated decoherence and energy relaxation could explain the large discrepancy between the mobilities calculated by the Ehrenfest dynamics and the full quantum methods, which proves the effectiveness of our approach to take back these missing processes.

Recent Progress in Surface Hopping: 2011-2015

Developed 25 years ago, Tully's fewest switches surface hopping (FSSH) has proven to be the most popular approach for simulating quantum-classical dynamics in a broad variety of systems, ranging from the gas phase, to the liquid and solid phases, to biological and nanoscale materials. FSSH is widely adopted as the fundamental platform to introduce modifications as needed. Significant progress has been made recently to enhance the accuracy and efficiency of the surface hopping technique. Various limitations of the standard FSSH-associated with quantum nuclear effects, interference and decoherence, trivial or "unavoided" crossings, superexchange, and representation dependence-have been lifted. These advances are needed to allow one to treat many important phenomena in chemistry, physics, materials, and related disciplines. Examples include charge transport in extended systems such as organic solids, singlet fission in molecular aggregates, Auger-type exciton multiplication, recombination and relaxation in quantum dots and other nanoscale materials, Auger-assisted charge transfer, nonradiative luminescence quenching, and electron-hole recombination. This Perspective summarizes recent advances in the surface hopping formulation of nonadiabatic dynamics and provides an outlook on the future of surface hopping.

Coupled wave-packets for non-adiabatic molecular dynamics: a generalization of Gaussian wave-packet dynamics to multiple potential energy surfaces

Coupled wave-packets for non-adiabatic dynamics is a new method for simulation of molecular dynamics on coupled potential energy surfaces, which efficiency and correctly accounts for decoherence and interferences effects.

Accurate simulation of the non-adiabatic dynamics of molecules in excited electronic states is key to understanding molecular photo-physical processes. Here we present a novel method, based on a semi-classical approximation, that is as efficient as the commonly used mean field Ehrenfest or ad hoc surface hopping methods and properly accounts for interference and decoherence effects. This novel method is an extension of Heller's thawed Gaussian wave-packet dynamics that includes coupling between potential energy surfaces. By studying several standard test problems we demonstrate that the accuracy of the method can be systematically improved while maintaining high efficiency. The method is suitable for investigating the role of quantum coherence in the non-adiabatic dynamics of many-atom molecules.

Quantum-Classical Nonadiabatic Dynamics: Coupled- vs Independent-Trajectory Methods

Trajectory-based mixed quantum-classical approaches to coupled electron-nuclear dynamics suffer from well-studied problems such as the lack of (or incorrect account for) decoherence in the trajectory surface hopping method and the inability of reproducing the spatial splitting of a nuclear wave packet in Ehrenfest-like dynamics. In the context of electronic nonadiabatic processes, these problems can result in wrong predictions for quantum populations and in unphysical outcomes for the nuclear dynamics. In this paper, we propose a solution to these issues by approximating the coupled electronic and nuclear equations within the framework of the exact factorization of the electron-nuclear wave function. We present a simple quantum-classical scheme based on coupled classical trajectories and test it against the full quantum mechanical solution from wave packet dynamics for some model situations which represent particularly challenging problems for the above-mentioned traditional methods.

Scaling relationships for nonadiabatic energy relaxation times in warm dense matter: toward understanding the equation of state

The dependence of nonadiabatic ion-electron energy transfer rates in warm dense aluminum on the mass density and temperature with decoherence changing this relationship qualitatively.

Dopants Control Electron-Hole Recombination at Perovskite-TiO₂ Interfaces: Ab Initio Time-Domain Study

TiO2 sensitized with organohalide perovskites gives rise to solar-to-electricity conversion efficiencies reaching close to 20%. Nonradiative electron-hole recombination across the perovskite/TiO2 interface constitutes a major pathway of energy losses, limiting quantum yield of the photoinduced charge. In order to establish the fundamental mechanisms of the energy losses and to propose practical means for controlling the interfacial electron-hole recombination, we applied ab initio nonadiabatic (NA) molecular dynamics to pristine and doped CH3NH3PbI3(100)/TiO2 anatase(001) interfaces. We show that doping by substitution of iodide with chlorine or bromine reduces charge recombination, while replacing lead with tin enhances the recombination. Generally, lighter and faster atoms increase the NA coupling. Since the dopants are lighter than the atoms they replace, one expects a priori that all three dopants should accelerate the recombination. We rationalize the unexpected behavior of chlorine and bromine by three effects. First, the Pb-Cl and Pb-Br bonds are shorter than the Pb-I bond. As a result, Cl and Br atoms are farther away from the TiO2 surface, decreasing the donor-acceptor coupling. In contrast, some iodines form chemical bonds with Ti atoms, increasing the coupling. Second, chlorine and bromine reduce the NA electron-vibrational coupling, because they contribute little to the electron and hole wave functions. Tin increases the coupling, since it is lighter than lead and contributes to the hole wave function. Third, higher frequency modes introduced by chlorine and bromine shorten quantum coherence, thereby decreasing the transition rate. The recombination occurs due to coupling of the electronic subsystem to low-frequency perovskite and TiO2 modes. The simulation shows excellent agreement with the available experimental data and advances our understanding of electronic and vibrational dynamics in perovskite solar cells. The study provides design principles for optimizing solar cell performance and increasing photon-to-electron conversion efficiency through creative choice of dopants.