The number of positively charged amino acids in the basic domain of Tat is critical for trans-activation and complex formation with TAR RNA

Design and synthesis of RNA miniduplexes via a synthetic linker approach. 2. Generation of covalently closed, double-stranded cyclic HIV-1 TAR RNA analogs with high Tat-binding affinity

We recently developed an approach which allows rapid generation of short, double-stranded oligonucleotides whereby one end of the duplex was joined and stabilized by a synthetic linker of specific design (miniduplexes)(6). Model miniduplexes based on the HIV-1 TAR RNA hairpin were shown to be thermodynamically stable and good substrates for binding by the HIV-1 Tat protein which normally bind to natural TAR (6). In this study, we have extended our studies to the design, synthesis and analysis of the binding properties of covalently closed, double-stranded, cyclic RNA miniduplexes. A strategy using automated chemical synthesis and T4 RNA ligase-catalyzed cyclization was employed to generate cyclic oligoribonucleotides. When both ends of a shortened, wild-type TAR RNA stem (9 bp) were covalently linked through either nucleotidic loops (4-6 nt) or synthetic linkers (derivatized from hexaethylene glycol), the resulting cyclic TAR RNA analogs were good substrates for binding by both Tat-derived peptide or full-length Tat protein. Interestingly, the cyclic TAR analogs failed to show any binding if the synthetic linker was reduced in length (e.g. derivatized from triethylene glycol), although such linkers are acceptable in the hairpin-shaped miniduplexes series (6). This implies that RNA conformational changes are required for Tat binding and that these changes are restricted in certain cyclic variants. Our findings suggest that covalently-closed nucleic acid miniduplexes may be useful both to study nucleic acid-protein interactions as well as to provide a basis for therapeutic intervention as transcription decoys.

Relatedness of an RNA-binding motif in human immunodeficiency virus type 1 TAR RNA-binding protein TRBP to human P1/dsI kinase and Drosophila staufen

TRBP is a human cellular protein that binds the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 TAR RNA. Here, we show that the intact presence of amino acids 247 to 267 in TRBP correlates with its ability to bind RNA. This region contains a lysine- and arginine-rich motif, KKLAKRNAAAKMLLRVHTVPLDAR. A 24-amino-acid synthetic peptide (TR1) of this sequence bound TAR RNA with affinities similar to that of the entire TRBP, thus suggesting that this short motif contains a sufficient RNA-binding activity. Using RNA probe-shift analysis, we determined that TR1 does not bind all double-stranded RNAs but prefers TAR and other double-stranded RNAs with G+C-rich characteristics. Immunoprecipitation of TRBP from human immunodeficiency virus type 1-infected T lymphocytes recovered TAR RNA. This is consistent with a TRBP-TAR ribonucleoprotein during viral infection. Computer alignment revealed that TR1 is highly homologous to the RNA-binding domain of human P1/dsI protein kinase and two regions within Drosophila Staufen. We suggest that these proteins are related by virtue of sharing a common RNA-binding moiety.

Relatedness of an RNA-binding motif in human immunodeficiency virus type 1 TAR RNA-binding protein TRBP to human P1/dsI kinase and Drosophila staufen

TRBP is a human cellular protein that binds the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 TAR RNA. Here, we show that the intact presence of amino acids 247 to 267 in TRBP correlates with its ability to bind RNA. This region contains a lysine- and arginine-rich motif, KKLAKRNAAAKMLLRVHTVPLDAR. A 24-amino-acid synthetic peptide (TR1) of this sequence bound TAR RNA with affinities similar to that of the entire TRBP, thus suggesting that this short motif contains a sufficient RNA-binding activity. Using RNA probe-shift analysis, we determined that TR1 does not bind all double-stranded RNAs but prefers TAR and other double-stranded RNAs with G+C-rich characteristics. Immunoprecipitation of TRBP from human immunodeficiency virus type 1-infected T lymphocytes recovered TAR RNA. This is consistent with a TRBP-TAR ribonucleoprotein during viral infection. Computer alignment revealed that TR1 is highly homologous to the RNA-binding domain of human P1/dsI protein kinase and two regions within Drosophila Staufen. We suggest that these proteins are related by virtue of sharing a common RNA-binding moiety.

Electrostatic interactions modulate the RNA-binding and transactivation specificities of the human immunodeficiency virus and simian immunodeficiency virus Tat proteins

The transcriptional activating (Tat) proteins from human immunodeficiency virus and simian immunodeficiency virus are sequence-specific RNA-binding proteins. In human immunodeficiency virus Tat, a single arginine residue, flanked on each side by three to four basic amino acids, mediates specific binding to a bulge region in trans-acting responsive element (TAR) RNA. We have systematically mutated the flanking charged residues and found that, in addition to the position of the sequence-specific arginine, the particular arrangement of nonspecific electrostatic interactions is an important determinant of RNA-binding specificity and transactivation activity. These additional electrostatic contacts may help stabilize the structure of TAR RNA when bound to arginine. One critical electrostatic interaction, located two residues N-terminal to the arginine, is absent in the simian immunodeficiency virus Tat protein and accounts for the difference in promoter specificities of the human and simian immunodeficiency viral proteins.

TAR RNA binding properties and relative transactivation activities of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 and 2 Tat proteins

Using gel shift assays, we found that the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) Tat protein (Tat-1) bound both HIV-1 and HIV-2 TAR RNAs with similar high affinities. In contrast, the HIV-2 Tat protein (Tat-2) bound only TAR-2 RNA with high affinity. We conclude that the weak in vivo activity of Tat-2 on the HIV-1 long terminal repeat that has been observed previously is likely the result of low affinity for TAR-1 RNA. Additionally, TAR-2 RNA was found to contain multiple specific binding sites for Tat proteins. GAL4-Tat fusion proteins were analyzed to compare the relative transactivation activities of Tat-1 and Tat-2 in the absence of requirements for binding to TAR RNAs. The GAL4-Tat-2 protein was found to transactivate synthetic promoters containing GAL4 binding sites at levels severalfold higher than did the GAL4-Tat-1 protein.

Rotational symmetry in ribonucleotide strand requirements for binding of HIV-1 Tat protein to TAR RNA

Transactivation of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) gene expression requires binding of the viral Tat protein to a RNA hairpin-loop structure (TAR) which contains a two or three-nucleotide bulge. Tat binds in the vicinity of the bulge and the two adjacent duplex stems, recognising both specific sequence and structural features of TAR. Binding is mediated by an arginine-rich domain, placing Tat in the family of arginine-rich RNA binding proteins that includes other transactivators, virus capsid proteins and ribosome binding proteins. In order to determine what features of TAR allow Tat to bind efficiently to RNA but not DNA forms, we examined Tat binding to a series of RNA-DNA hybrids. We found that only one specific strand in each duplex stem region needs to be RNA, implying that interaction between Tat and a given stem may be solely or predominantly with one of the two strands. However, the essential strand is not the same one for each stem, suggesting a switch in the bound strand on opposing sides of the bulge.

Random mutagenesis of the human immunodeficiency virus type-1 trans-activator of transcription (HIV-1 Tat)

A new method is described for the direct construction of randomly mutagenized genes by applying the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) to an oligonucleotide synthesized using doped nucleotide reservoirs. We have demonstrated the utility of this method by generating a library of mutant HIV-1 tat genes. Several arbitrarily selected, inactive tat clones were sequenced to evaluate the extent of the mutagenesis. Moreover, fourteen recombinants encoding varying levels of transcriptional trans-activator activity were isolated by transient transfection of sub-library pools into a HeLa cell line bearing an HIV-LTR-chloramphenicol acetyltransferase (CAT) reporter gene. Sequence data revealed a spectrum of alterations including nucleotide substitutions, insertions, and deletions, suggesting that mutations arose from both the doped DNA synthesis and the subsequent PCR 'rescue' of full-length product. Sequence comparison between inactive and active Tat clones revealed a selection pressure against amino-acid substitutions within the N-terminal domains of Tat, indicating the importance of this region to trans-activation competence. In addition, single and double missense mutations within the basic-rich, TAR RNA-binding domain were seen to be tolerated within active Tat clones.

Conformation of the TAR RNA-arginine complex by NMR spectroscopy

The messenger RNAs of human immunodeficiency virus-1 (HIV-1) have an RNA hairpin structure, TAR, at their 5' ends that contains a six-nucleotide loop and a three-nucleotide bulge. The conformations of TAR RNA and of TAR with an arginine analog specifically bound at the binding site for the viral protein, Tat, were characterized by nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy. Upon arginine binding, the bulge changes conformation, and essential nucleotides for binding, U23 and A27.U38, form a base-triple interaction that stabilizes arginine hydrogen bonding to G26 and phosphates. Specificity in the arginine-TAR interaction appears to be derived largely from the structure of the RNA.

Conserved nucleotides in the TAR RNA stem of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 are critical for Tat binding and trans activation: model for TAR RNA tertiary structure

Interaction between the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) trans-activator Tat and its cis-acting responsive RNA element TAR is necessary for activation of HIV-1 gene expression. We investigated the hypothesis that the essential uridine residue at position 23 in the bulge of TAR RNA is involved in intramolecular hydrogen bonding to stabilize an unique RNA structure required for recognition by Tat. Nucleotide substitutions in the two base pairs of the TAR stem directly above the essential trinucleotide bulge that maintain base pairing but change sequence prevent complex formation with Tat in vitro. Corresponding mutations tested in a trans-activation assay strongly affect the biological activity of TAR in vivo, suggesting an important role for these nucleotides in the Tat-TAR interaction. On the basis of these data, a model is proposed which implicates uridine 23 in a stable tertiary interaction with the GC pair directly above the bulge. This interaction would cause widening of the major groove of the RNA, thereby exposing its hydrogen-bonding surfaces for possible interaction with Tat. The model also predicts a gap between uridine 23 and the first base pair in the stem above, which would require one or more unpaired nucleotides to close, but does not predict any other role for such nucleotides. In accordance with this prediction, synthetic propyl phosphate linkers of equivalent length to 1 or 2 nucleotides, were found to be fully acceptable substitutes in the bulge above uridine 23, demonstrating that neither the bases nor the ribose moieties at these positions are implicated in the recognition of TAR RNA by Tat.

Functional comparison of the basic domains of the Tat proteins of human immunodeficiency virus types 1 and 2 in trans activation

The trans-activator Tat proteins coded by human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) and HIV-2 appear to be similar in structure and function. However, the Tat protein of HIV-2 (Tat2) activates the HIV-1 long terminal repeat (LTR) less efficiently than Tat1 (M. Emerman, M. Guyader, L. Montagnier, D. Baltimore, and M. A. Muesing, EMBO J. 6:3755-3760, 1987). To determine the functional domain of Tat2 which contributes to this incomplete reciprocity, we have carried out domain substitution between Tat1 and Tat2 by exchanging the basic domains involved in Tat interaction with its target trans-activation-response (TAR) RNA structure. Our results indicate that Tat1 proteins containing substitutions of either 8 or 14 amino acids of the basic domain of Tat2 exhibited reduced trans activation of the HIV-1 LTR by about 1/20 or one-fourth the level induced by wt Tat1. In contrast, Tat2 containing a substitution of the 9-amino-acid basic domain of Tat1 trans activated HIV-1 LTR like native Tat1. A substitution of the highly conserved core domain of Tat2 with that of Tat1 did not have any significant effect on trans activation of the HIV-1 LTR. These results indicate that the basic domain of Tat2 contributes to its inefficient trans activation of the HIV-1 LTR. Mutation of an acidic residue (Glu) located between the core domain and the Arg-rich basic domain of Tat2 at position 77 to a Gly residue increased the activity of Tat2 substantially. These results further suggest that the presence of an acidic residue (Glu) adjacent to Arg-rich sequences may at least partially contribute to the reduced activity of the Tat2 basic domain.

Critical chemical features in trans-acting-responsive RNA are required for interaction with human immunodeficiency virus type 1 Tat protein

The human immunodeficiency virus type 1 Tat protein binds to an RNA stem-loop structure called TAR which is present at the 5' end of all human immunodeficiency virus type 1 transcripts. This binding is centered on a bulge within the stem of TAR and is an essential step in the trans-activation process which results in a dramatic increase in viral gene expression. By analysis of a series of TAR derivatives produced by transcription or direct chemical synthesis, we determined the structural and chemical requirements for Tat binding. Tat binds well to structures which have a bulge of two to at least five unpaired bases bounded on both sides by a double-stranded RNA stem. This apparent flexibility in bulge size is in contrast to an absolute requirement for an unpaired uridine (U) in the 5'-most position of the bulge (+23). Substitution of the U with either natural bases or chemical analogs demonstrated that the imido group at the N-3 position and, possibly, the carbonyl group at the C-4 position of U are critical for Tat binding. Cytosine (C), which differs from U at only these positions, is not an acceptable substitute. Furthermore, methylation at N-3 abolishes binding. While methylation of U at the C-5 position has little effect on binding, fluorination reduces it, possibly because of its effects on relative tautomer stability at the N-3 and C-4 positions. Thus, we have identified key moieties in the U residue that are of importance for the binding of Tat to TAR RNA. We hypothesize that the invariant U is involved in hydrogen bond interactions with either another part of TAR or the TAR-binding domain in Tat.