Oligomerization of the Human Prion Protein Proceeds via a Molten Globule Intermediate

Prion proteins with pathogenic and protective mutations show similar structure and dynamics

Conformational change in the prion protein (PrP) is thought to be responsible for a group of rare but fatal neurodegenerative diseases of humans and other animals, including Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease and bovine spongiform encephalopathy. However, little is known about the mechanism by which normal cellular PrPs initiate and propagate the conformational change. Here, we studied backbone dynamics of the inherited pathogenic mutants (P101L and H186R), protective mutants (Q167R and Q218K), and wild-type mouse PrP(89-230) at pH 5.5 and 3.5. Mutations result in minor chemical shift changes around the mutation sites except that H186R induces large chemical shift changes at distal regions. At lower pH values, the C-terminal half of the second helix is significantly disordered for the wild-type and all mutant proteins, while other parts of the protein are essentially unaffected. This destabilization is accompanied by protonation of the partially exposed histidine H186 in the second helix of the wild-type protein. This region in the mutant protein H186R is disordered even at pH 5.5. The wild-type and mutant proteins have similar microsecond conformational exchange near the two beta-strands and have similar nanosecond internal motions in several regions including the C-terminal half of the second helix, but only wild type and P101L have extensive nanosecond internal motions throughout the helices. These motions mostly disappear at lower pH. Our findings raise the possibility that the pathogenic or dominant negative mutations exert their effects on some non-native intermediate form such as PrP* after conversion of cellular PrP (PrP(C)) into the pathogenic isoform PrP(Sc) has been initiated; additionally, formation of PrP(Sc) might begin within the C-terminal folded region rather than in the disordered N-terminal region.

Conformational properties of beta-PrP

Prion propagation involves a conformational transition of the cellular form of prion protein (PrPC) to a disease-specific isomer (PrPSc), shifting from a predominantly alpha-helical conformation to one dominated by beta-sheet structure. This conformational transition is of critical importance in understanding the molecular basis for prion disease. Here, we elucidate the conformational properties of a disulfide-reduced fragment of human PrP spanning residues 91-231 under acidic conditions, using a combination of heteronuclear NMR, analytical ultracentrifugation, and circular dichroism. We find that this form of the protein, which similarly to PrPSc, is a potent inhibitor of the 26 S proteasome, assembles into soluble oligomers that have significant beta-sheet content. The monomeric precursor to these oligomers exhibits many of the characteristics of a molten globule intermediate with some helical character in regions that form helices I and III in the PrPC conformation, whereas helix II exhibits little evidence for adopting a helical conformation, suggesting that this region is a likely source of interaction within the initial phases of the transformation to a beta-rich conformation. This precursor state is almost as compact as the folded PrPC structure and, as it assembles, only residues 126-227 are immobilized within the oligomeric structure, leaving the remainder in a mobile, random-coil state.

Dynamics of a truncated prion protein, PrP(113-231), from (15)N NMR relaxation: order parameters calculated and slow conformational fluctuations localized to a distinct region

Prion diseases are associated with the misfolding of the prion protein (PrP(C)) from a largely alpha-helical isoform to a beta-sheet rich oligomer (PrP(Sc)). Flexibility of the polypeptide could contribute to the ability of PrP(C) to undergo the conformational rearrangement during PrP(C)-PrP(Sc) interactions, which then leads to the misfolded isoform. We have therefore examined the molecular motions of mouse PrP(C), residues 113-231, in solution, using (15)N NMR relaxation measurements. A truncated fragment has been used to eliminate the effect of the 90-residue unstructured tail of PrP(C) so the dynamics of the structured domain can be studied in isolation. (15)N longitudinal (T(1)) and transverse relaxation (T(2)) times as well as the proton-nitrogen nuclear Overhauser effects have been used to calculate the spectral density at three frequencies, 0, omega(N,) and 0.87omega(H). Spectral densities at each residue indicate various time-scale motions of the main-chain. Even within the structured domain of PrP(C), a diverse range of motions are observed. We find that removal of the tail increases T(2) relaxation times significantly indicating that the tail is responsible for shortening of T(2) times in full-length PrP(C). The truncated fragment of PrP has facilitated the determination of meaningful order parameters (S(2)) from the relaxation data and shows for the first time that all three helices in PrP(C) have similar rigidity. Slow conformational fluctuations of mouse PrP(C) are localized to a distinct region that involves residues 171 and 172. Interestingly, residues 170-175 have been identified as a segment within PrP that will form a steric zipper, believed to be the fundamental amyloid unit. The flexibility within these residues could facilitate the PrP(C)-PrP(Sc) recognition process during fibril elongation.

Internal friction and nonequilibrium unfolding of polymeric globules

The stretching response of a single collapsed homopolymer is studied using Brownian dynamic simulations. The irreversibly dissipated work is found to be dominated by internal friction effects below the collapse temperature, and the internal viscosity grows exponentially with the effective cohesive strength between monomers. These results explain friction effects of globular DNA and are relevant for dissipation at intermediate stages of protein folding.

Molecular dynamics simulation of the acidic compact state of apomyoglobin from yellowfin tuna

A molecular model of the acidic compact state of apomyoglobin (A-state) from yellowfin tuna was obtained using molecular dynamics simulations (MD) by calculating multiple trajectories. To cause partial unfolding within a reasonable amount of CPU time, both an acidic environment (pH 3 and 0.15M NaCl) and a temperature jump to 500 K were needed. Twenty-five acidic structures of apomyoglobin were generated by MD, 10 of them can be clustered by RMSD in an average structure having a common hydrophobic core as was reported for acidic sperm whale apomyoglobin, with shortened helices A,G,E, and H (the helix A appears to be translated along the sequence). Prolonging the MD runs at 500 K did not cause further substantial unfolding, suggesting that the ensemble of generated structures is indicative of a region of the conformational space accessible to the apoprotein at acidic pH corresponding to a local energy minimum. The comparison of experimentally determined values of specific spectroscopic properties of the apomyoglobin in acidic salt conditions with the expected ones on the basis of the MD generated structures shows a reasonable agreement considering the characteristic uncertainties of both experimental and simulation techniques. We used frequency domain fluorometry, acrylamide fluorescence quenching, and fluorescence correlation spectroscopy together with far UV circular dichroism to estimate the helical content, the Stern-Volmer quenching constant and the radius of gyration of the protein. Tuna apomyoglobin is a single tryptophan protein and thus, interpretation of its intrinsic fluorescence is simpler than for other proteins. The high sensitivity of the applied fluorescence techniques enabled experiments to be performed under very dilute conditions, that is, at concentrations of subnanomolar for the FCS measurements and 6 muM for the other fluorescence measurements. As high concentrations of proteins can strongly affect the association equilibrium among partially unfolded states, fluorescence techniques can provide complementary information with respect to other techniques requiring higher sample concentrations, such as NMR. The analysis of exposed hydrophobic regions in each of the MD-generated acidic structures reveals potential candidates involved in the aggregation processes of apomyoglobin in the acidic compact state. Our investigation represents an effective model system for studying amyloid fibril formation found in important diseases that are believed to proceed via aggregation of protein in the molten globule state.

pH effects on the conformational preferences of amyloid beta-peptide (1-40) in HFIP aqueous solution by NMR spectroscopy

The structure and aggregation state of amyloid beta-peptide (Abeta) in membrane-like environments are important determinants of pathological events in Alzheimer's disease. In fact, the neurotoxic nature of amyloid-forming peptides and proteins is associated with specific conformational transitions proximal to the membrane. Under certain conditions, the Abeta peptide undergoes a conformational change that brings the peptide in solution to a "competent state" for aggregation. Conversion can be obtained at medium pH (5.0-6.0), and in vivo this appears to take place in the endocytic pathway. The combined use of (1)H NMR spectroscopy and molecular dynamics-simulated annealing calculations in aqueous hexafluoroisopropanol simulating the membrane environment, at different pH conditions, enabled us to get some insights into the aggregation process of Abeta, confirming our previous hypotheses of a relationship between conformational flexibility and aggregation propensity. The conformational space of the peptide was explored by means of an innovative use of principal component analysis as applied to residue-by-residue root-mean-square deviations values from a reference structure. This procedure allowed us to identify the aggregation-prone regions of the peptide.

Prions and the proteasome

Prion diseases are fatal neurodegenerative disorders that include Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease in humans and bovine spongiform encephalopathy in animals. They are unique in terms of their biology because they are caused by the conformational re-arrangement of a normal host-encoded prion protein, PrPC, to an abnormal infectious isoform, PrPSc. Currently the precise mechanism behind prion-mediated neurodegeneration remains unclear. It is hypothesised than an unknown toxic gain of function of PrPSc, or an intermediate oligomeric form, underlies neuronal death. Increasing evidence suggests a role for the ubiquitin proteasome system (UPS) in prion disease. Both wild-type PrPC and disease-associated PrP isoforms accumulate in cells after proteasome inhibition leading to increased cell death, and abnormal beta-sheet-rich PrP isoforms have been shown to inhibit the catalytic activity of the proteasome. Here we review potential interactions between prions and the proteasome outlining how the UPS may be implicated in prion-mediated neurodegeneration.

Inter-oligomer interactions of the human prion protein are modulated by the polymorphism at codon 129

The common polymorphism at codon 129 in the human prion protein (PrP) has been shown in many studies to influence not only the pathology of prion disease but also the misfolding propensity of PrP. Here we used NMR, CD and atomic force microscopy in solution to investigate differences in beta-oligomer (beta(O)) formation and inter-oligomer interaction depending on the polymorphism at codon 129. NMR investigations assigned the observable amide resonances to the beta(O) N-terminal segments, showing that it is the core region of PrP (residues 127-228) that is involved in beta(O) formation. Atomic force microscopy revealed distinctive 1.8 x 15 x 15-nm disk-like structures that form stacks through inter-oligomer interactions. The propensity to form stacks and the number of oligomers involved depended on the polymorphism at codon 129, with a significantly lower degree of stacking for beta(O) with valine at position 129. This result provides evidence for conformational differences between the beta(O) allelic forms, showing that the core region of the protein including position 129 is actively involved in inter-oligomer interactions, consistent with NMR observations.

Conformational pH dependence of intermediate states during oligomerization of the human prion protein

Intermediate states are key to understanding the molecular mechanisms governing protein misfolding. The human prion protein (PrP) can follow various misfolding pathways, and forms a soluble beta-sheet-rich oligomer under acidic, mildly denaturing, high salt conditions. Here we describe a fast conformational switch from the native alpha-monomer to monomeric intermediate states under oligomer-forming conditions, followed by a slower oligomerization process. We observe a pH dependence of the secondary structure of these intermediate forms, with almost native-like alpha-helical secondary structure at pH 4.1 and predominantly beta-sheet characteristics at pH 3.6. NMR spectroscopy differentiates these intermediate states from the native protein and indicates dynamic rearrangements of secondary structure elements characteristic of a molten globule. The alpha-helical intermediate formed at pH 4.1 can convert to the beta-sheet conformation at pH 3.6 but not vice versa, and neither state can be reconverted to an alpha-monomer. The presence of methionine rather than valine at codon 129 accelerates the rate of oligomer formation from the intermediate state.

Curcumin binds to the alpha-helical intermediate and to the amyloid form of prion protein - a new mechanism for the inhibition of PrP(Sc) accumulation

Conversion of the native, predominantly alpha-helical conformation of prion protein (PrP) into the beta-stranded conformation is characteristic for the transmissible spongiform encephalopathies such as Creutzfeld-Jakob disease. Curcumin, an extended planar molecule and a dietary polyphenol, inhibits in vitro conversion of PrP and formation of protease resistant PrP in neuroblastoma cell lines. Curcumin recognizes the converted beta-form of the PrP both as oligomers and fibrils but not the native form. Curcumin binds to the prion fibrils in the left-handed chiral arrangement as determined by circular dichroism. We show that curcumin labels the plaques of the brain sections of variant Creutzfeld-Jakob disease cases and stains the same structures as antibodies against the PrP. In contrast to thioflavin T, curcumin also binds to the alpha-helical intermediate of PrP present at acidic pH at stoichiometry of 1 : 1. Congo red competes with curcumin for binding to the alpha-intermediate as well as to the beta-form of PrP but is toxic and binds also to the native form of PrP. We therefore show that the partially unfolded structural intermediate of the PrP can be targeted by non-toxic compound of natural origin.

Prion protein alpha-to-beta transition monitored by time-resolved Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy

The conformational change of the recombinant, murine prion protein (PrP) from an alpha-helical to a beta-sheet enriched state was monitored by time-resolved Fourier transform infrared (FT-IR) spectroscopy. The alpha-to-beta transition is induced by reduction of the single disulfide bond in PrP. This transition is believed to generate the scrapie form PrP(Sc), the supposed infectious agent of transmissible spongiform encephalopathies. We followed the kinetics of this conformational change using a novel method for amide I band analysis of the infrared (IR) spectra. The amide I analysis provides the secondary structure. The amide I decomposition was calibrated with the three dimensional structure of cellular PrP solved by nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR). The novel secondary structure analysis provides a root mean squared deviation (RMSD) of only 3% as compared to the NMR structure. Reduction of alpha-helical PrP caused the transient accumulation of a partially unfolded intermediate, followed by formation of a state with higher beta-sheet than alpha-helical structure contents. The novel approach allows us to now determine the secondary structure of the beta-sheet conformation. This was not determined by either NMR or X-ray. The experiments were performed in a double-sealed security cuvette developed for IR analysis of potentially infectious PrP samples outside the biosafety laboratory.

In vitro and in vivo neurotoxicity of prion protein oligomers

The mechanisms underlying prion-linked neurodegeneration remain to be elucidated, despite several recent advances in this field. Herein, we show that soluble, low molecular weight oligomers of the full-length prion protein (PrP), which possess characteristics of PrP to PrPsc conversion intermediates such as partial protease resistance, are neurotoxic in vitro on primary cultures of neurons and in vivo after subcortical stereotaxic injection. Monomeric PrP was not toxic. Insoluble, fibrillar forms of PrP exhibited no toxicity in vitro and were less toxic than their oligomeric counterparts in vivo. The toxicity was independent of PrP expression in the neurons both in vitro and in vivo for the PrP oligomers and in vivo for the PrP fibrils. Rescue experiments with antibodies showed that the exposure of the hydrophobic stretch of PrP at the oligomeric surface was necessary for toxicity. This study identifies toxic PrP species in vivo. It shows that PrP-induced neurodegeneration shares common mechanisms with other brain amyloidoses like Alzheimer disease and opens new avenues for neuroprotective intervention strategies of prion diseases targeting PrP oligomers.

Structural and hydration properties of the partially unfolded states of the prion protein

Misfolding and aggregation of the prion protein (PrP) is responsible for the development of transmissible spongiform encephalopathies (TSE). To gain insights into possible aggregation-prone intermediate states, we construct the free energy surface of the C-terminal globular domain of the PrP from enhanced sampling of replica exchange molecular dynamics. This cellular domain is characterized by three helices H1-H3 and a small beta-sheet. In agreement with experimental studies, the partially unfolded states display a stable core built from the central portions of helices H2 and H3 and a high mobility of helix H1 from the core. Among all identified conformational basins, a marginally populated state appears to be a very good candidate for aggregation. This intermediate is stabilized by four TSE-sensitive key interactions, displays a longer helix H1 with both a dry and solvated surface, and is featured by a significant detachment of helix H1 from the PrP-core.