Is There or Isn't There? The Case for (and Against) Residual Structure in Chemically Denatured Proteins

Quantitative determination of site-specific conformational distributions in an unfolded protein by solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance

Solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) techniques are used to investigate the structure of the 35-residue villin headpiece subdomain (HP35) in folded, partially denatured, and fully denatured states. Experiments are carried out in frozen glycerol/water solutions, with chemical denaturation by guanidine hydrochloride (GdnHCl). Without GdnHCl, two-dimensional solid-state (13)C NMR spectra of samples prepared with uniform (13)C labeling of selected residues show relatively sharp cross-peaks at chemical shifts that are consistent with the known three-helix bundle structure of folded HP35. At high GdnHCl concentrations, most cross-peaks broaden and shift, qualitatively indicating disruption of the folded structure and development of static conformational disorder in the frozen denatured state. Conformational distributions at one residue in each helical segment are probed quantitatively with three solid-state NMR techniques that provide independent constraints on backbone varphi and psi torsion angles in samples with sequential pairs of carbonyl (13)C labels. Without GdnHCl, the combined data are well fit by alpha-helical conformations. At [GdnHCl]=4.5 M, corresponding to the approximate denaturation midpoint, the combined data are well fit by a combination of alpha-helical and partially extended conformations at each site, but with a site-dependent population ratio. At [GdnHCl]=7.0 M, corresponding to the fully denatured state, the combined data are well fit by a combination of partially extended and polyproline II conformations, again with a site-dependent population ratio. Two entirely different models for conformational distributions lead to nearly the same best-fit distributions, demonstrating the robustness of these conclusions. This work represents the first quantitative investigation of site-specific conformational distributions in partially folded and unfolded states of a protein by solid-state NMR.

Folding mechanism of the C-terminal domain of nucleophosmin: residual structure in the denatured state and its pathophysiological significance

Nucleophosmin (NPM1) is a ubiquitously expressed protein and is one of the most abundant proteins found in the nucleolus. Naturally occurring mutations in the C-terminal domain of nucleophosmin (Cter-NPM1) are found in approximately 30% of patients with acute myeloid leukemia (AML). These mutations cause changes at the C terminus of NPM1 that lead to denaturation of the protein, a critical factor in determining aberrant translocation of NPM1 to the cytosol. Hence, this protein system represents an ideal candidate to investigate the relations between folding and unfolding and disease. Here we report the characterization of the folding and unfolding kinetics of Cter-NPM1. Data reveal that this small helical domain folds via a compact denatured state, displaying a malleable residual structure. Moreover, analysis of folding rate constants measured under different experimental conditions suggests that the existence of a preorganized structure in the denatured state accelerates folding, implying a native-like residual structure. Because a major feature of Cter-NPM1 mutants responsible for AML is a reduction in stability of the protein and thus prevalence of a denatured state even under physiological conditions, our findings may pave the way to further studies with the aim of designing chemicals capable of interacting with the "pathological" mutants to stabilize the native conformation.

Characterization of the unfolded state of repeat proteins

The unfolded state ensemble of proteins has been described as a structurally featureless state. While this approach is supported by the fact that many unfolded proteins follow the scaling law behavior of a random coil, there is evidence that the unfolded states of various proteins are stabilized by native or non-native interactions. Recently, the existence of extensive non-native structure was reported for a repeat protein, which resulted in a scaling law exponent that is significantly smaller than that of a random polymer [Cortajarena et al., J. Mol. Biol. 382(1), 203-212 (2008)]. It was concluded that the high compactness of this protein stems from a significant fraction of interacting PP(II) helical segments in the unfolded state. In this study, we aim at providing possible molecular understanding of this anomalous compactness of the unfolded state and to investigate its origin. Using a hierarchy of computational models, we ask whether in general the unfolded state of a repeat protein is likely to be intrinsically more compact than the unfolded state of globular proteins, or whether this phenomenon depends mostly on the occurrence of a specific sequence that promotes PP(II) conformations. Our results suggest that the formation of the PP(II) conformation is indeed essential, yet the recurring sequence of repeat proteins promotes the interactions between these PP(II) segments and the formation of non-native interactions in the unfolded state.

Probing the lower size limit for protein-like fold stability: ten-residue microproteins with specific, rigid structures in water

Mutational optimization of two long-range interactions first observed in Ac-WINGKWT-NH2, (a) bifurcated H-bonding involving the threonine amide H(N) and side chain OH and the N-terminal acetyl carbonyl and (b) an H-bond between the entgegen-H(N) of the C-terminal amide and the indole ring of Trp6 that stabilizes a face-to-edge indole/indole interaction between Trp1 and Trp6, has afforded < or = 10 residue systems that yield a remarkably stable fold in water. Optimization was achieved by designing a hydrophobic cluster that sequesters these H-bonds from solvent exposure. The structures and extent of amide H/D exchange protection for CH3CH2CO-WI pGXWTGPS (p = D-Pro, X = Leu or Ile) were determined. These two systems are greater than 94% folded at 298 K (97.5% at 280 K) with melting temperatures > 75 degrees C. The fold appears to display minimal fluxionality; a well-converged NMR structure rationalizes all of the large structuring shifts observed, and we suggest that these designed constructs can be viewed as microproteins.

Effects of excluded volume upon protein stability in covalently cross-linked proteins with variable linker lengths

To explore the effects of molecular crowding and excluded volume upon protein stability, we used a series of cross-linking reagents with nine different single-cysteine mutants of staphylococcal nuclease to make covalently linked dimers. These cross-linkers ranged in length from 10.5 to 21.3 A, compelling separations which would normally be found only in the most concentrated protein solutions. The stabilities of the dimeric proteins and monomeric controls were determined by guanidine hydrochloride and thermal denaturation. Dimers with short linkers tend to exhibit pronounced three-state denaturation behavior, as opposed to the two-state behavior of the monomeric controls. Increasing linker length leads to less pronounced three-state behavior. The three-state behavior is interpreted in a three-state model where cross-linked native protein dimer, N-N, interconverts in a two-state transition with a dimer where one protein subunit is denatured, N-D. The remaining native protein in turn can denature in another two-state transition to a state, D-D, in which both tethered proteins are denatured. Three-state behavior is best explained by excluded volume effects in the denatured state. For many dimers, linkers longer than 17 A removed most three-state character. This sets a limit on the flexibility and size of the denatured state. Notably, in contradiction to theoretical predictions, these cross-linked dimers were not stabilized. The failure of these predictions is possibly due to neglect of the alteration in hydrophobic exposure that accompanies any significant reduction in the conformational space of the denatured state.

Toward resolution of ambiguity for the unfolded state

The unfolded states in proteins and nucleic acids remain weakly understood despite their importance in folding processes; misfolding diseases (Parkinson's and Alzheimer's); natively unfolded proteins (as many as 30% of eukaryotic proteins, according to Fink); and the study of ribozymes. Research has been hindered by the inability to quantify the residual (native) structure present in an unfolded protein or nucleic acid. Here, a scaling model is proposed to quantify the molar degree of folding and the unfolded state. The model takes a global view of protein structure and can be applied to a number of analytic methods and to simulations. Three examples are given of application to small-angle scattering from pressure-induced unfolding of SNase, from acid-unfolded cytochrome c, and from folding of Azoarcus ribozyme. These examples quantitatively show three characteristic unfolded states for proteins, the statistical nature of a protein folding pathway, and the relationship between extent of folding and chain size during folding for charge-driven folding in RNA.

Small-angle X-ray scattering of reduced ribonuclease A: effects of solution conditions and comparisons with a computational model of unfolded proteins

The disulfide-reduced form of bovine ribonuclease A, with the Cys thiols irreversibly blocked, was characterized by small-angle x-ray scattering. To help resolve the conflicting results and interpretations from previous studies of this model unfolded protein, we measured scattering profiles using a range of solution conditions and compared them with the profiles predicted by a computational model for a random-coil polypeptide. Analysis of the simulated and experimental profiles reveals that scattering intensities at intermediate angles, corresponding to interatomic distances in the range of 5-20 A, are particularly sensitive to changes in solvation and can be used to assess the internal scaling behavior of the polypeptide chain, expressed as a mass fractal dimension, D(m). This region of the scattering curve is also much less sensitive to experimental artifacts than is the very small angle regime (the Guinier region) that has been more typically used to characterize unfolded proteins. The experimental small-angle x-ray scattering profiles closely matched those predicted by the computational model assuming relatively small solvation energies. The scaling behavior of the polypeptide approaches that of a well-solvated polymer under conditions where it has a large net charge and at high urea concentrations. At lower urea concentrations and neutral pH, the behavior of the chain approaches that expected for theta-conditions, where the effects of slightly unfavorable interactions with solvent balance those of excluded volume, leading to scaling behavior comparable to that of an idealized random walk chain. Though detectable, the shift toward more compact conformations at lower urea concentrations does not correspond to a transition to a globule state and is associated with little or no reduction in conformational entropy. This type of collapse, therefore, is unlikely to greatly reduce the conformational search for the native state.

Combining experiment and simulation in protein folding: closing the gap for small model systems

All-atom molecular dynamics (MD) simulations on increasingly powerful computers have been combined with experiments to characterize protein folding in detail over wider time ranges. The folding of small ultrafast folding proteins is being simulated on micros timescales, leading to improved structural predictions and folding rates. To what extent is 'closing the gap' between simulation and experiment for such systems providing insights into general mechanisms of protein folding?

Stability of a protein tethered to a surface

Surface-tethered proteins are increasingly being used in a variety of experimental situations, and they are the basis for many new technologies. Nevertheless, a thorough understanding of how a surface can impact the native state stability of an attached protein is lacking. In this work, the authors use molecular dynamics simulations of a model beta-barrel protein to investigate how surface tethering influences native state stability. They find that stability, as measured by the folding temperature Tf, can be either increased, decreased, or remain unchanged as a result of tethering. Observed shifts are highly dependent on the location of residue used as the tether point, and stability is influenced by a number of factors, both energetic and entropic. These factors include native state vibrations, loss of bulk unfolded conformations, changes to the unfolded state ensemble, and the emergence of an entropic term not present for the bulk protein. They discuss each of these contributions in detail and comment on their relative importance and connection to experiment.

Pockets of short-range transient order and restricted topological heterogeneity in the guanidine-denatured state ensemble of GED of dynamin

The nature and variety in the denatured state of a protein, a non-native state under a given set of conditions, has been a subject of intense debate. Here, using multidimensional NMR, we have characterized the 6 M Gdn-HCl-denatured state of GED, the assembly domain of dynamin. Even under such strongly denaturing conditions, we detected the presence of conformations in slow exchange on the NMR chemical shift time scale. Although the GED oligomer as well as the SDS-denatured monomeric GED were seen to be predominantly helical [Chugh et al. (2006) FEBS J. 273, 388-397], the 6 M Gdn-HCl-denatured GED has largely beta-structural preferences. However, against such a background, we could detect the presence of a population with a short helical stretch (Arg42-Ile47) in the ensemble. The 1H-1H NOEs suggested presence of pockets of transient short-range order along the chain. Put together these segments may lead to a rather small number of interconverting topologically distinguishable ensembles. Spectral density analysis of 15N relaxation rates and {1H}-15N NOE, measured at 600 and 800 MHz, and comparison of J(0) with hydrophobic patches calculated using AABUF approach, indicated presence of four domains of slow motions. These coincided to a large extent with those showing significant Rex. Additionally, a proline residue in the connection between two of these domains seems to cause a fast hinge motion. These observations help enhance our understanding of protein denatured states, and of folding concepts, in general.

Dynamic similarity of the unfolded states of proteins L and G

The formation of specific intramolecular contacts has been studied under a range of denaturing conditions in single domains of the immunoglobulin-binding proteins L and G. Although they share no significant sequence similarity and have dissimilar folding pathways, the two domains have a similar native fold. Our measurements show that the rates of forming corresponding contacts in the unfolded states of both proteins are remarkably similar and even exhibit similar dependence on denaturant concentration. The unfolded proteins were modeled using Szabo, Schulten, and Schulten (SSS) theory as wormlike chains with excluded volume; when combined with our experimental data, the SSS analysis suggests that the unfolded state becomes uniformly more compact and less diffusive (i.e., rearranges more slowly) with decreasing denaturant concentrations.

Structural characterization of the intrinsically unfolded protein beta-synuclein, a natural negative regulator of alpha-synuclein aggregation

The synuclein family of intrinsically unfolded proteins is composed of three highly homologous members, alpha-synuclein (alphaS), beta-synuclein (betaS) and gamma-synuclein (gammaS), which are linked to neurodegenerative disorders and cancer. alphaS has been studied intensively after its identification as the major protein component of amyloid-like deposits in Parkinson's disease and dementia with Lewy bodies. betaS, on the other hand, was found to act as a potent inhibitor of alphaS amyloid formation, and it is proposed as a natural regulator of its neurotoxicity. It is then of particular interest to elucidate the structural and dynamic features of the soluble state of betaS as a first step to understand the molecular basis of its anti-amyloidogenic effect on alphaS. We present here the characterization of natively unstructured betaS by high resolution heteronuclear NMR techniques. A combination of pulse-field gradient, three-dimensional heteronuclear correlation, residual dipolar couplings, paramagnetic relaxation enhancement and backbone relaxation experiments were employed to characterize the ensemble of conformations populated by the protein. The results indicate that betaS adopts extended conformations in its native state, characterized by the lack of the long-range contacts as previously reported for alphaS. Despite the lack of defined secondary structure, we found evidence for transient polyproline II conformations clustered at the C-terminal region. The structuring of the backbone at the C terminus is locally encoded, stabilized by the presence of eight proline residues embedded in a polypeptide stretch rich in hydrophilic and negatively charged amino acids. The structural and functional implications of these findings are analyzed via a thorough comparison with its neurotoxic homolog alphaS.

Folding versus aggregation: polypeptide conformations on competing pathways

Protein aggregation has now become recognised as an important and generic aspect of protein energy landscapes. Since the discovery that numerous human diseases are caused by protein aggregation, the biophysical characterisation of misfolded states and their aggregation mechanisms has received increased attention. Utilising experimental techniques and computational approaches established for the analysis of protein folding reactions has ensured rapid advances in the study of pathways leading to amyloid fibrils and amyloid-related aggregates. Here we describe recent experimental and theoretical advances in the elucidation of the conformational properties of dynamic, heterogeneous and/or insoluble protein ensembles populated on complex, multidimensional protein energy landscapes. We discuss current understanding of aggregation mechanisms in this context and describe how the synergy between biochemical, biophysical and cell-biological experiments are beginning to provide detailed insights into the partitioning of non-native species between protein folding and aggregation pathways.

Small-Angle X-Ray Scattering from RNA, Proteins, and Protein Complexes

Small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) is increasingly used to characterize the structure and interactions of biological macromolecules and their complexes in solution. Although still a low-resolution technique, the advent of high-flux synchrotron sources and the development of algorithms for the reconstruction of 3-D electron density maps from 1-D scattering profiles have made possible the generation of useful low-resolution molecular models from SAXS data. Furthermore, SAXS is well suited for the study of unfolded or partially folded conformational ensembles as a function of time or solution conditions. Here, we review recently developed algorithms for 3-D structure modeling and applications to protein complexes. Furthermore, we discuss the emerging use of SAXS as a tool to study membrane protein-detergent complexes. SAXS is proving useful to study the folding of functional RNA molecules, and finally we discuss uses of SAXS to study ensembles of denatured proteins.

Atomic-level characterization of disordered protein ensembles

The roles of unfolded states of proteins in normal folding and in diseases involving aggregation, as well as the prevalence and regulatory functions of intrinsically disordered proteins, have become increasingly recognized. The structural representation of these disordered states as ensembles of interconverting conformers can therefore provide critical insights. Experimental methods can be used to probe ensemble-averaged structural properties of disordered states and computational approaches generate representative ensembles of conformers using experimental restraints. In particular, NMR and small-angle X-ray scattering provide quantitative data that can readily be incorporated into calculations. These techniques have gleaned structural information about denatured, unfolded and intrinsically disordered proteins. The use of experimental data in different computational approaches, including ensemble molecular dynamics simulations and algorithms that assign populations to pregenerated conformers, has highlighted the presence of both local and long-range structure, and the occurrence of native-like and non-native interactions in unfolded and denatured states. Analysis of the resulting ensembles has suggested important implications of this fluctuating structure for folding, aggregation and binding.

Mapping protein collapse with single-molecule fluorescence and kinetic synchrotron radiation circular dichroism spectroscopy

We have used the combination of single-molecule Förster resonance energy transfer and kinetic synchrotron radiation circular dichroism experiments to probe the conformational ensemble of the collapsed unfolded state of the small cold shock protein CspTm under near-native conditions. This regime is physiologically most relevant but difficult to access experimentally, because the equilibrium signal in ensemble experiments is dominated by folded molecules. Here, we avoid this problem in two ways. One is the use of single-molecule Förster resonance energy transfer, which allows the separation of folded and unfolded subpopulations at equilibrium and provides information on long-range intramolecular distance distributions. From experiments with donor and acceptor chromophores placed at different positions within the chain, we find that the distance distributions in unfolded CspTm agree surprisingly well with a Gaussian chain not only at high concentrations of denaturant, where the polypeptide chain is expanded, but also at low denaturant concentrations, where the chain is collapsed. The second, complementary approach is synchrotron radiation circular dichroism spectroscopy of collapsed unfolded molecules transiently populated with a microfluidic device that enables rapid mixing. The results indicate a beta-structure content of the collapsed unfolded state of approximately 20% compared with the folded protein. This suggests that collapse can induce secondary structure in an unfolded state without interfering with long-range distance distributions characteristic of a random coil, which were previously found only for highly expanded unfolded proteins.

Toward an accurate theoretical framework for describing ensembles for proteins under strongly denaturing conditions

Our focus is on an appropriate theoretical framework for describing highly denatured proteins. In high concentrations of denaturants, proteins behave like polymers in a good solvent and ensembles for denatured proteins can be modeled by ignoring all interactions except excluded volume (EV) effects. To assay conformational preferences of highly denatured proteins, we quantify a variety of properties for EV-limit ensembles of 23 two-state proteins. We find that modeled denatured proteins can be best described as follows. Average shapes are consistent with prolate ellipsoids. Ensembles are characterized by large correlated fluctuations. Sequence-specific conformational preferences are restricted to local length scales that span five to nine residues. Beyond local length scales, chain properties follow well-defined power laws that are expected for generic polymers in the EV limit. The average available volume is filled inefficiently, and cavities of all sizes are found within the interiors of denatured proteins. All properties characterized from simulated ensembles match predictions from rigorous field theories. We use our results to resolve between conflicting proposals for structure in ensembles for highly denatured states.

Urea-induced unfolding of the immunity protein Im9 monitored by spFRET

We have studied the urea-induced unfolding of the E colicin immunity protein Im9 using diffusion single-pair fluorescence resonance energy transfer. Detailed examination of the proximity ratio of the native and denatured molecules over a wide range of urea concentrations suggests that the conformational properties of both species are denaturant-dependent. Whereas native molecules become gradually more expanded as urea concentration increases, denatured molecules show a dramatic dependence of the relationship between proximity ratio and denaturant concentration, consistent with substantial compaction of the denatured ensemble at low denaturant concentrations. Analysis of the widths of the proximity ratio distributions for each state suggests that whereas the native state ensemble is relatively narrow and homogeneous, the denatured state may possess heterogeneity in mildly denaturing conditions.

Site-specific Dimensions Across a Highly Denatured Protein; A Single Molecule Study

Do highly denatured proteins adopt random coil configurations? Here, we address this question by measuring residue-to-residue separations across the denatured FynSH3 domain. Using single-molecule Forster resonance energy transfer techniques, we have collected transfer efficiency probability distributions for dye-labeled, denatured protein. Applying maximum likelihood analysis to the interpretation of these distributions, we have determined the through-space distance between five residue pairs in the protein's guanidine hydrochloride-unfolded and trifluoroethanol-unfolded states. We find that, while the dimensions of the guanidine hydrochloride -unfolded molecule generally coincide with the dimensions predicted for a random coil ensemble, potentially statistically significant deviations from random coil behavior are also evident. These small, site-specific deviations may provide a means of reconciling earlier, scattering-based evidence for the random coil nature of the unfolded state with more site-specific spectroscopic evidence suggesting residual structure. We have also studied the unfolded ensemble populated in 50% trifluoroethanol, a denaturant that induces a highly helical unfolded state. We find that the size and shape of the unfolded ensemble under these conditions is effectively indistinguishable from that populated in guanidinium hydrochloride solutions, suggesting that the gross structure of the denatured state is, perhaps surprisingly, independent of the chemistry of the cosolvent.