Future challenges with DNA-encoded chemical libraries in the drug discovery domain

Merging C(sp3)-H activation with DNA-encoding

DNA-encoded library (DEL) technology has the potential to dramatically expedite hit identification in drug discovery owing to its ability to perform protein affinity selection with millions or billions of molecules in a few experiments. To expand the molecular diversity of DEL, it is critical to develop different types of DNA-encoded transformations that produce billions of molecules with distinct molecular scaffolds. Sequential functionalization of multiple C–H bonds provides a unique avenue for creating diversity and complexity from simple starting materials. However, the use of water as solvent, the presence of DNA, and the extremely low concentration of DNA-encoded coupling partners (0.001 M) have hampered the development of DNA-encoded C(sp³)–H activation reactions. Herein, we report the realization of palladium-catalyzed C(sp³)–H arylation of aliphatic carboxylic acids, amides and ketones with DNA-encoded aryl iodides in water. Notably, the present method enables the use of alternative sets of monofunctional building blocks, providing a linchpin to facilitate further setup for DELs. Furthermore, the C–H arylation chemistry enabled the on-DNA synthesis of structurally-diverse scaffolds containing enriched C(sp³) character, chiral centers, cyclopropane, cyclobutane, and heterocycles.

DNA-compatible C(sp³)–H activation reactions of aliphatic carboxylic acids, amides, and ketones were developed for efficient access to DEL synthesis.

High-Throughput Screening: today's biochemical and cell-based approaches

High-throughput screening (HTS) provides starting chemical matter in the adventure of developing a new drug. In this review, we survey several HTS methods used today for hit identification, organized in two main flavors: biochemical and cell-based assays. Biochemical assays discussed include fluorescence polarization and anisotropy, FRET, TR-FRET, and fluorescence lifetime analysis. Binding-based methods are also surveyed, including NMR, SPR, mass spectrometry, and DSF. On the other hand, cell-based assays discussed include viability, reporter gene, second messenger, and high-throughput microscopy assays. We devote some emphasis to high-content screening, which is becoming very popular. An advisable stage after hit discovery using phenotypic screens is target deconvolution, and we provide an overview of current chemical proteomics, in silico, and chemical genetics tools. Emphasis is made on recent CRISPR/dCas-based screens. Lastly, we illustrate some of the considerations that inform the choice of HTS methods and point to some areas with potential interest for future research.

Ultra-large chemical libraries for the discovery of high-affinity peptide binders

High-diversity genetically-encoded combinatorial libraries (108-1013 members) are a rich source of peptide-based binding molecules, identified by affinity selection. Synthetic libraries can access broader chemical space, but typically examine only ~ 106 compounds by screening. Here we show that in-solution affinity selection can be interfaced with nano-liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry peptide sequencing to identify binders from fully randomized synthetic libraries of 108 members-a 100-fold gain in diversity over standard practice. To validate this approach, we show that binders to a monoclonal antibody are identified in proportion to library diversity, as diversity is increased from 106-108. These results are then applied to the discovery of p53-like binders to MDM2, and to a family of 3-19 nM-affinity, α/β-peptide-based binders to 14-3-3. An X-ray structure of one of these binders in complex with 14-3-3σ is determined, illustrating the role of β-amino acids in facilitating a key binding contact.

Selection of Small Molecules that Bind to and Activate the Insulin Receptor from a DNA-Encoded Library of Natural Products

Although insulin is a life-saving medicine, administration by daily injection remains problematic. Our goal was to exploit the power of DNA-encoded libraries to identify molecules with insulin-like activity but with the potential to be developed as oral drugs. Our strategy involved using a 10⁴-member DNA-encoded library containing 160 Traditional Chinese Medicines (nDEL) to identify molecules that bind to and activate the insulin receptor. Importantly, we used the natural ligand, insulin, to liberate bound molecules. Using this selection method on our relatively small, but highly diverse, nDEL yielded a molecule capable of both binding to and activating the insulin receptor. Chemical analysis showed this molecule to be a polycyclic analog of the guanidine metformin, a known drug used to treat diabetes. By using our protocol with other, even larger, DELs we can expect to identify additional organic molecules capable of binding to and activating the insulin receptor.

•

Annotation of natural products via complementary bifunctional linkers

•

Function-guided DEL selection using the natural ligand for competitive elution

•

Identification of Rutaecarpine as a binder and activator of insulin receptor

A DNA-encoded library for the identification of natural product binders that modulate poly (ADP-ribose) polymerase 1, a validated anti-cancer target

Natural products have been an invaluable source of drug discovery, but their targets remain largely unknown. Natural products enriched DNA-encoded chemical libraries (nDELs) empower the researchers to rapidly and economically screen numerous natural products against various protein targets, and therefore promote the elucidation of the molecular mechanisms. In this work, we used poly (ADP-ribose) polymerase 1 (PARP1), as an example to explore the usage of nDEL for the functional natural products selection. We used late-stage modification approach to label three positive binders with unique DNA barcodes, whose dissociation constants range from sub-micromolar to micromolar. The selection criterion was set up according to the enrichment of these controls. Five natural products selected by this criterion directly bind to PARP1 in SPR, among which luteolin exhibits the highest inhibitory activity against PARP1. Moreover, luteolin selectively induces accumulation of DNA double-strand breaks and G2/M phase arrest in BRCA-deficient cells. All the findings from these investigations on luteolin support that PARP1 inhibition is one of the mechanisms for its anti-cancer activity.

Critical Evaluation of Photo-cross-linking Parameters for the Implementation of Efficient DNA-Encoded Chemical Library Selections

The growing importance of DNA-encoded chemical libraries (DECLs) as tools for the discovery of protein binders has sparked an interest for the development of efficient screening methodologies, capable of discriminating between high- and medium-affinity ligands. Here, we present a systematic investigation of selection methodologies, featuring a library displayed on single-stranded DNA, which could be hybridized to a complementary oligonucleotide carrying a diazirine photoreactive group. Model experiments, performed using ligands of different affinity to carbonic anhydrase IX, revealed a recovery of preferential binders up to 10%, which was mainly limited by the highly reactive nature of carbene intermediates generated during the photo-cross-linking process. Ligands featuring acetazolamide or p-phenylsulfonamide exhibited a higher recovery compared to their counterparts based on 3-sulfamoyl benzoic acid, which had a lower affinity toward the target. A systematic evaluation of experimental parameters revealed conditions that were ideally suited for library screening, which were used for the screening of a combinatorial DECL library, featuring 669 240 combinations of two sets of building blocks. Compared to conventional affinity capture procedures on protein immobilized on solid supports, photo-cross-linking provided a better discrimination of low-affinity CAIX ligands over the background signal and therefore can be used as a tandem methodology with the affinity capture procedures.

RASS-Enabled S/P-C and S-N Bond Formation for DEL Synthesis

DNA encoded libraries (DEL) have shown promise as a valuable technology for democratizing the hit discovery process. Although DEL provides relatively inexpensive access to libraries of unprecedented size, their production has been hampered by the idiosyncratic needs of the encoding DNA tag relegating DEL compatible chemistry to dilute aqueous environments. Recently reversible adsorption to solid support (RASS) has been demonstrated as a promising method to expand DEL reactivity using standard organic synthesis protocols. Here we demonstrate a suite of on-DNA chemistries to incorporate medicinally relevant and C-S, C-P and N-S linkages into DELs, which are underrepresented in the canonical methods.

The Impact of Variable Selection Coverage on Detection of Ligands from a DNA-Encoded Library Screen

DNA-encoded library (DEL) technology has become a prominent screening platform in drug discovery owing to the capacity to screen billions or trillions of compounds in a single experiment. Although numerous successes with DEL technology have been reported, we are unaware of a rigorous examination of the many different variables that can influence a screen’s success. Herein, we explore the impact of variable sample sequencing depth on the detection of tool compounds with known affinities toward a given target while simultaneously probing the effect of initial compound input. Our sequencing data confirm reports that high-affinity compounds can be discovered directly from a DEL screen, but we demonstrate that a mismatch between selection output and sequencing quantity can obscure useful ligands. Our results highlight the importance of selection coverage in grasping the entire picture of a DEL screen where the signal of a weak or underrepresented ligand may be suppressed by the inherent noise of a selection. These potential missed ligands may be critical to the success or failure of a drug discovery program.

Multifunctional Building Blocks Compatible with Photoredox-Mediated Alkylation for DNA-Encoded Library Synthesis

DNA-encoded library (DEL) technology has emerged as a novel interrogation modality for ligand discovery in the pharmaceutical industry. Given the increasing demand for a higher proportion of C(sp3)-hybridized centers in DEL platforms, a photoredox-mediated cross-coupling and defluorinative alkylation process is introduced using commercially available alkyl bromides and structurally diverse α-silylamines. Notably, no protecting group strategies for amines are necessary for the incorporation of a variety of amino-acid-based organosilanes, providing crucial branching points for further derivatization.

High Fidelity Suzuki-Miyaura Coupling for the Synthesis of DNA Encoded Libraries Enabled by Micelle Forming Surfactants

DNA encoded chemical libraries provide a highly efficient means of screening vast numbers of small molecules against an immobilized protein target. Their potential is currently restricted by the constraints of carrying out library synthesis in the presence of attached DNA tags, for which a limited number of reactions and substrates can be used. Even established reactions, such as Suzuki-Miyaura couplings, do not give efficient coupling reactions across a wide range of substrates and can lead to significant DNA degradation. We developed an efficient protocol for carrying out Suzuki-Miyaura couplings on DNA tagged substrates that proceeds with unprecedented efficiency to the desired biaryl products (>98% on average with no detectable DNA degradation) across a wide range of drug-like substrates using a micellar promoted process with commercial TPGS-750-M surfactant. We have demonstrated the applicability of this method in DEL synthesis by preparing a prototypical two-dimensional 36-member library employing the Suzuki-Miyaura coupling methodology as the final library synthesis step. This work shows, for the first time, that standard micellar surfactants can promote reactions for encoded library synthesis, leading to libraries of exceptional fidelity, and demonstrates the potential to expand the range of accessible DNA compatible chemistry.