Characteristics of autoantibodies to human interferon in a patient with varicella-zoster disease

An updated review on phenocopies of primary immunodeficiency diseases

Primary immunodeficiency diseases (PIDs) refer to a heterogenous group of disorders characterized clinically by increased susceptibility to infections, autoimmunity and increased risk of malignancies.

These group of disorders present with clinical manifestations similar to PIDs with known genetic defects but have either no genetic defect or have a somatic mutation and thus have been labelled as “Phenocopies of PIDs”. These diseases have been further subdivided into those associated with somatic mutations and those associated with presence of auto-antibodies against various cytokines.

In this review, we provide an update on clinical manifestations, diagnosis and management of these diseases.

Broad-spectrum antibodies against self-antigens and cytokines in RAG deficiency

Patients with mutations of the recombination-activating genes (RAG) present with diverse clinical phenotypes, including severe combined immune deficiency (SCID), autoimmunity, and inflammation. However, the incidence and extent of immune dysregulation in RAG-dependent immunodeficiency have not been studied in detail. Here, we have demonstrated that patients with hypomorphic RAG mutations, especially those with delayed-onset combined immune deficiency and granulomatous/autoimmune manifestations (CID-G/AI), produce a broad spectrum of autoantibodies. Neutralizing anti-IFN-α or anti-IFN-ω antibodies were present at detectable levels in patients with CID-G/AI who had a history of severe viral infections. As this autoantibody profile is not observed in a wide range of other primary immunodeficiencies, we hypothesized that recurrent or chronic viral infections may precipitate or aggravate immune dysregulation in RAG-deficient hosts. We repeatedly challenged Rag1S723C/S723C mice, which serve as a model of leaky SCID, with agonists of the virus-recognizing receptors TLR3/MDA5, TLR7/-8, and TLR9 and found that this treatment elicits autoantibody production. Altogether, our data demonstrate that immune dysregulation is an integral aspect of RAG-associated immunodeficiency and indicate that environmental triggers may modulate the phenotypic expression of autoimmune manifestations.

Practice parameter for the diagnosis and management of primary immunodeficiency

The American Academy of Allergy, Asthma & Immunology (AAAAI) and the American College of Allergy, Asthma & Immunology (ACAAI) have jointly accepted responsibility for establishing the "Practice parameter for the diagnosis and management of primary immunodeficiency." This is a complete and comprehensive document at the current time. The medical environment is a changing environment, and not all recommendations will be appropriate for all patients. Because this document incorporated the efforts of many participants, no single individual, including those who served on the Joint Task Force, is authorized to provide an official AAAAI or ACAAI interpretation of these practice parameters. Any request for information about or an interpretation of these practice parameters by the AAAAI or ACAAI should be directed to the Executive Offices of the AAAAI, the ACAAI, and the Joint Council of Allergy, Asthma & Immunology. These parameters are not designed for use by pharmaceutical companies in drug promotion.

Detection of anti-cytokine antibodies and their clinical relevance

Cytokines regulate many aspects of cell growth and differentiation and play pivotal roles in the orchestration of immune defence against invading pathogens. Though 'self' proteins, they are potentially immunogenic and can give rise to anti-cytokine autoantibodies (aCA). The main foci of the article are a critical summary of the various methodologies applied for detecting and measuring aCA and a broad review of studies of the occurrence, characterization and clinical relevance of aCA in normal healthy individuals, patients with autoimmune diseases or microbial infections and aCA in patients whose disease is treated with recombinant cytokine products. The need for technical and methodological improvement of assays, including validation and standardization, together with approaches to harmonize calculation and reporting of results is also discussed.

Anticytokine autoantibodies in infectious diseases: pathogenesis and mechanisms

Autoantibodies to cytokines occur in many different conditions and situations and can cause a wide range of disease, including pulmonary alveolar proteinosis, disseminated non-tuberculous mycobacterial disease, pure red-cell aplasia, and chronic mucocutaneous candidiasis. Anticytokine autoantibodies may also develop against exogenously administered cytokines, sometimes diminishing their effects or inhibiting the activity of the endogenous cytokine. Unlike primary congenital immunodeficiencies, autoantibodies may develop over time, wax and wane, and may change in titre or avidity. Naturally occurring autoantibodies to interferons α, β, and γ, interleukins 1α, 2, 6, and 10, tumour necrosis factor, and granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor have been reported in healthy individuals and have been identified in rheumatological diseases, graft-versus-host disease, and cancer. Therapeutic antibodies, growth factors, other biological agents, and cytokines used to treat acute, chronic, malignant, and immune diseases may elicit or overcome autoantibodies, hence influencing the primary intended therapy. The increasing number of biologically active anticytokine autoantibodies being reported suggests that currently "idiopathic" diseases may someday be explained by neutralising or agonising autoantibodies. Their protean roles in causing, treating, preventing, and responding to disease, as well as simply maintaining normal homoeostasis, offer fascinating insights into the biology of immunity, inflammation, and infection.

Beware of Antibodies to Dietary Proteins in “Antigen-specific” Immunoassays! Falsely Positive Anticytokine Antibody Tests Due to Reactivity with Bovine Serum Albumin in Rheumatoid Arthritis (The Swedish TIRA Project)

Objective.

To evaluate (1) to what extent sera from healthy subjects and patients with rheumatoid arthritis (RA) contain antibodies to bovine serum albumin (BSA); and (2) if anti-BSA antibodies interfere with results of enzyme-linked immunoassays (ELISA) containing BSA.

Methods.

The ELISA used was a previously developed in-house assay of autoantibodies to tumor necrosis factor (TNF). Anti-TNF and anti-BSA antibodies were analyzed by ELISA in 189 patients with early RA and 186 healthy blood donors. TNF preparations containing either BSA or human serum albumin (HSA) as carrier proteins were used as antigens in the anti-TNF assay. The presence and levels of antibodies were analyzed in relation to disease course and to the presence/absence of rheumatoid factor (RF).

Results.

In patients with RA, anti-TNF/BSA levels strongly correlated with anti-BSA levels (r = 0.81, p < 0.001), whereas anti-TNF/HSA did not (r = −0.09). Neither the presence nor the levels of anti-BSA in RA patients were associated with disease progression, and antibody levels were not significantly altered compared to controls (p = 0.11). IgG reactivity with TNF/HSA was neglible. In paired sera, preincubation with BSA abolished the anti-TNF/BSA reactivity. There were no indications of RF interference with anti-BSA or anti-TNF reactivity.

Conclusion.

Antibodies to BSA are common in patients with RA as well as in healthy individuals. Their presence does not seem to be associated with RA disease activity or disease course, but may severely interfere with ELISA containing BSA. The use of BSA as a “blocking agent” or carrier protein in immunoassays should therefore be avoided.

Neutralizing interferon alpha as a therapeutic approach to autoimmune diseases

Therapeutic antibodies directed against tumor necrosis factor alpha (TNF-alpha) for the treatment of rheumatoid arthritis, and against the human EGF receptor-2 (HER2) receptor for the treatment of breast cancer have provided significant clinical benefit for the patients. The success of these antibodies has also provided strong support for the possibility that increased activity of cytokines or growth factors is causally implicated in a variety of human diseases. Interferon alpha (IFN-alpha) is induced by viruses (linked by epidemiological studies to autoimmune diseases), has significant direct effects on both epithelial cells and the immune system, and then can be further induced by the autoantibodies and apoptotic cells generated by the actions of IFN-alpha. The direct and deleterious impact on target tissues, the ability to induce an autoimmune response, and the potential for a self-sustaining cycle of induction and damage suggests that IFN-alpha could be a pivotal factor in the development of autoimmune diseases. This review will evaluate the rationale for, possible approaches to, and safety concerns associated with, targeting interferon alpha (IFN-alpha) as a therapeutic strategy for the treatment of autoimmune diseases. While the approach may be applicable to several autoimmune diseases, there will be an emphasis on systemic lupus erythematosus and insulin dependent diabetes mellitus.

Neutralizing antibodies to granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor, interleukin-1alpha and interferon-alpha but not other cytokines in human immunoglobulin preparations

Human immunoglobulin preparations are used therapeutically for various disorders. Such therapy is generally safe but adverse effects occasionally occur in recipients. It has been suggested that antibodies to cytokines present in clinical immunoglobulin products may contribute to undesirable effects in recipients. Therefore, we investigated intravenous and intramuscular immunoglobulin products for the presence of cytokine-specific neutralizing antibodies. Using validated bioassays, we detected neutralizing activity against human granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor (GM-CSF), interferon-alpha2a (IFN-alpha2a) and interleukin-1alpha (IL-1alpha) in immunoglobulin products. We found no neutralization of granulocyte colony-stimulating factor, macrophage colony-stimulating factor, stem cell factor, IL-1beta, IL-2, IL-3, IL-4, IL-6, IL-9, IL-10, IL-12, tumour necrosis factor-alpha, oncostatin M (OSM) and IFN-gamma. Most batches which neutralized IFN-alpha2a activity also neutralized other IFN-alpha subtypes, IFN-omega and IFN-beta. Most products (94%) neutralized the biological activity of GM-CSF. No correlation between batches and their ability to neutralize bioactivities of GM-CSF, IFN-alpha2a and IL-1alpha was found. This neutralizing activity could be traced to plasma pools used for manufacture of immunoglobulins. The neutralization was mediated by specific cytokine antibodies contained within immunoglobulin products as it was present in specific immunoglobulin G (IgG) fractions eluted from cytokine affinity chromatography columns. Specific binding of such IgG fractions to cytokines in immunoblots and in enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays (ELISAs) was observed. This contrasts with the broad non-specific recognition of cytokine proteins observed using unfractionated immunoglobulins in ELISAs. This is the first comprehensive study showing the presence of neutralizing antibodies against GM-CSF, IL-1alpha, or IFN-alpha2a in immunoglobulin products.

Levels of gamma interferon and interleukin-4 are inversely related to the levels of their corresponding autoantibodies in patients with lower respiratory tract infection

To study the involvement of cytokines and their corresponding autoantibodies (Aabs) in inflammatory mechanisms in patients with lower respiratory tract infections, blood samples were taken from patients at the time of admission to the hospital and before treatment. Cell-released capturing enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay was used to measure the levels of gamma interferon (IFN-gamma) and interleukin-4 (IL-4) produced spontaneously by peripheral mononuclear cells (PMNC). ELISA was used to measure Aabs to these cytokines in sera. The levels of both cytokines were inversely related to the levels of their corresponding Aabs. While a high level of IFN-gamma was observed together with a low level of anti-IFN-gamma Aab, decreased IL-4 levels were observed with increased levels of Aabs to IL-4. Immunoglobulins were purified, digested to obtain Fab fragments, and tested for specificity and cross-reactivity. The Aabs and their Fab fragments were tested in cytokine biological assays and showed neutralizing effects. Our data demonstrated increased levels of the proinflammatory cytokine IFN-gamma and decreased release of the anti-inflammatory cytokine IL-4 during early presentation of lower respiratory tract infection. The levels of these cytokines were inversely related to the levels of their corresponding Aabs that exhibited regulatory effects on the cytokine biological function in vitro.

Induction of cytokines and anti-cytokine autoantibodies in cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) during experimental bacterial meningitis

We have recently described the induction of anti-cytokine autoantibodies (Aabs) in the serum as a novel mechanism for cytokine regulation during bacterial infections. Here we use the infant rat-model of Haemophilus influenzae type b (Hib) meningitis to examine the induction of five potentially important cytokines and their autoantibody responses in the CSF. Protein levels of the cytokines interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma), tumour necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-alpha), transforming growth factor-beta (TGF-beta), IL-4 and IL-10 were detected at day 3 post-inoculation (p.i.) with maximum induction at day 8. Thereafter, these levels of cytokines had become undetectable. Increased Aab titres to these cytokines, except IL-4, were registered with peak levels between days 7 and 9. Upon re-inoculation with Hib at day 30, regeneration of Aabs was recorded 7 days later (i.e. at day 37). To control the specificity of these Aabs, preincubation of the CSF with a cytokine inhibited the binding effects of that particular cytokine, but not those of any other cytokine. Aabs dose-dependently inhibited IFN-gamma-induced MHC expression by peritoneal macrophages and TNF-alpha-mediated L929 cytotoxicity. Our data demonstrate for the first time the existence of the anti-cytokine antibodies in the CSF of the meningitis Hib model. Furthermore, the data present a role for the Aabs in cytokine regulation, which is consistent with the previously demonstrated effects of the Aabs in the serum.

Recovery from Guillain-Barré syndrome is associated with increased levels of neutralizing autoantibodies to interferon-gamma

Guillain-Barré syndrome (GBS) is an immune-mediated demyelinating disease of peripheral nerves that is often preceded by an infection and is usually self-restricted. The Th1 cytokine interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma) is thought to be disease-promoting in organ-specific autoimmune diseases. We report the spontaneous induction of IFN-gamma and a mechanism involving the generation of neutralizing autoantibodies (Aabs) to IFN-gamma that may regulate the disease. Numbers of cells spontaneously secreting IFN-gamma in peripheral blood were augmented in GBS, in particular at the peak of clinical disease, and decreased during recovery. This decrease was associated with elevated serum concentrations of IgG Aabs to IFN-gamma. These Aabs specifically bound to IFN-gamma and neutralized its effects in a biological assay. Aabs to IFN-gamma are proposed to be another important regulatory mechanism in IFN-gamma-driven GBS.

Cytokine autoantibodies in multiple sclerosis, aseptic meningitis and stroke

BACKGROUND

We have recently described the induction of anti-cytokine autoantibodies during bacterial infections and autoimmune diseases as a mechanism for cytokine regulation.

METHODS

Herein, we study the occurrence of autoantibodies to pro- and anti-inflammatory cytokines in cerebrospinal fluid and plasma from patients with multiple sclerosis, aseptic meningitis and stroke.

RESULTS

Increased levels of autoantibodies to interferon gamma, tumour necrosis factor alpha, interleukin 4 and interleukin 10 were detected in both compartments of multiple sclerosis and aseptic meningitis patients. Interestingly, in cerebrospinal fluid from stroke patients, only autoantibodies to interleukin 4 and interleukin 10, but not interferon alpha or tumour necrosis factor alpha were detected. No significant autoantibody levels were registered in plasma from stroke patients against all four cytokines compared with healthy control subjects. The latter revealed very low autoantibody levels in plasma and no detectable autoantibodies in cerebrospinal fluid.

CONCLUSIONS

Our data show for the first time the occurrence of cytokine autoantibodies in these diseases, but their biological significance is unclear.

Neutralising and binding anti-interferon-beta-I b (IFN-beta-I b) antibodies during IFN-beta-I b treatment of multiple sclerosis

Interferon-beta-I b (IFN-beta-I b) is an immunomodulatory therapy of multiple sclerosis (MS), reducing the numbers and severity of exacerbations and the total lesion load measured by magnetic resonance imaging of the brain. The benefits of IFN-beta-I b could be hampered by the development of neutralising antibodies against the compound. Our results confirmed earlier studies, showing that 42% of MS patients treated with IFN-beta-I b for more than 3 months had developed neutralising antibodies. The occurrence of binding anti-IFN-beta-I b antibodies, presently not believed to impede the clinical efficacy of IFN-beta-I b, were demonstrated by an immunoassay in some patients after 1 month of treatment and in 78% after 3 months. The development of binding antibodies seemed to be an early phenomenon, preceding the appearance of neutralising antibodies. Antibodies crossreacting with IFN-beta-I a and natural IFN-beta were also found in a majority of IFN-beta-I b treated patients with high titres of binding antibodies. Employing a solid-phase enzyme-linked immunospot (ELISPOT) assay, 68% of MS patients treated with IFN-beta-I b for 1-23 months had elevated numbers of anti-IFN-beta-I b-antibody secreting cells in blood, compared to 18% of untreated MS patients and 20% among patients with other neurological diseases. Thus, our findings confirm that IFN-beta-I b is immunogenic in MS patients. High levels of anti-IFN-beta-I b antibody secreting cells were, however, also found in two untreated control patients with inflammatory diseases, suggesting that anti-IFN-beta-I b antibodies might also occur spontaneously.

Anti-cytokine autoantibodies: epiphenomenon or critical modulators of cytokine action

Low amounts of high-affinity autoantibodies to various cytokines have been detected in sera from healthy donors. Their levels, although highly variable, are increased in the circulation of patients subjected to cytokine therapy or suffering from a variety of immunoinflammatory diseases. It has been suggested that these autoantibodies play a regulatory role in the intensity and duration of an immune response. The antibodies may prevent the binding of a cytokine to its specific cell surface receptor thereby neutralizing its biological activity in vivo. They may also act as carrier proteins preventing the rapid elimination of a cytokine from the circulation and thus increase its bioactivity. Additionally or alternatively, autoantibodies may modulate cytokine-induced intracellular signal transduction pathways or trigger complement-mediated cytotoxicity towards cells carrying membrane-bound cytokines. The autoantibodies may exert their regulatory role in compliance with the other factors that control cytokine activity, including soluble cytokine receptors, cell surface decoy receptors, and receptor antagonists. Although not favored by many investigators, a less sophisticated role for naturally occurring anti-cytokine autoantibodies should be considered as well. Recent evidence has shown that autoantibodies are generated at a high frequency as part of a response to foreign antigens. These antibodies are produced by B cells arising from the process of somatic mutation. Thus anti-cytokine autoantibodies may be the result of a "leaky" B cell response triggered by immunoinflammatory processes. High-titered autoantibodies induced by cytokine therapy are of clinical concern since their occurrence is often associated with the loss of response to treatment. Moreover, they may also neutralize endogenously produced cytokines with possible pathological consequences. In this paper we have reviewed the available information on the biological and clinical significance of both naturally occurring and therapeutically induced anti-cytokine autoantibodies in animals and man with the emphasis on antibodies directed to interferons.

Cytokines and autoantibodies to cytokines

Cytokines are essential components of our defense and repair systems but also potentially harmful mediators of infectious and immunoinflammatory reactions. Clinically important cytokines function systemically as pleiotropic hormones with overlapping effects on many cell types. All engage in a complex network of agonists and antagonists. Some immunoglobulin G (IgG) antibodies have been found to be potent and specific regulators of cytokines. These antibodies bind interleukin (IL-1)alpha, IL-6, IL-10, leukemia inhibitory factor (LIF), and interferon (IFN)-alpha/beta with exceptional force. They neutralize their corresponding cytokines ex vivo and perhaps in vivo, although they may also function as cytokine carriers. The biological role of autoantibodies to cytokines is not yet understood, but they may provide a level of regulation not appreciated at present. Inappropriate production/function of such antibodies could be pathogenetically involved in immunoinflammatory and other diseases. Cytokine antibodies may also contribute to the anti-inflammatory effects of human IgG therapy.

High avidity IFN-neutralizing antibodies in pharmaceutically prepared human IgG

This paper demonstrates and characterizes naturally occurring antibodies to interferon (IFN) in human IgG preparations. In vitro neutralization of the antiviral effect of IFN alpha and IFN beta, but not IFN gamma, was observed in 12 of 15 normal IgG preparations. The neutralizing capacity was higher against rIFN alpha 2A and rIFN alpha 2C than against lymphoblastoid IFN alpha and IFN beta. Frühsommer meningoencephalitis hyperimmune IgG and hepatitis-B hyperimmune IgG showed potent neutralization, whereas anti-rhesus D-, anti-rabies-, and anti-tetanus IgG showed weak neutralization. Saturable binding of 125I-rIFN alpha 2A was demonstrated only in those IgG preparations found to neutralize the antiviral effect of IFN. Significant correlation between IFN binding and neutralization capacity was observed. The antibodies bound with Fab to rIFN alpha 2A with an avidity of approximately 30 pM; the majority was of the IgG1 subclass. Maximum binding capacity was 490 pg rIFN alpha 2A/mg IgG. Cross-binding of rIFN alpha 2C, lyIFN alpha N1 and IFN beta occurred with 10 and 100-200 times lower activities than that of rIFN alpha 2A. There was no cross-binding with rIFN gamma or rIL-6. IgG preparations containing anti-IFN antibodies blocked the binding of 125I-rIFN alpha 2A to A549 cells. In conclusion, pharmaceutically prepared human IgG preparations contain variable but significant levels of high-avidity IFN alpha and IFN beta neutralizing antibodies.

Naturally occurring anti-interferon-alpha 2a antibodies in patients with acute viral hepatitis

The occurrence of antibodies against recombinant human interferon-alpha 2a (IFN-alpha 2a) in patients with acute viral hepatitis (AVH) was examined by ELISA. Naturally occurring IgG anti-IFN-alpha 2a were found in 50% of patients with type A, 50% of those with type B and in 8.3% of those with non-A, non-B AVH. The corresponding frequencies of IgM antibodies were 80%, 30% and 33.3%, respectively. IgM anti-IFN-alpha 2a were found more frequently in patients with AVH type A than in normal control subjects (P less than 0.01). Anti-IFN-alpha 2a were detectable at the highest frequency 3 weeks after acute onset and then became negative. An absorption experiment revealed that IgM anti-IFN-alpha 2a did not cross-react with recombinant human IFN-alpha 2b. Immunoblotting analysis confirmed the binding of antibodies to IFN-alpha 2a. Sera positive for IgG and/or IgM anti-IFN-alpha 2a were unable to neutralize IFN-alpha 2a. The appearance of anti-IFN-alpha 2a was not correlated with disease severity. There was no evidence to suggest that anti-IFN-alpha 2a impaired the elimination of hepatitis virus. This is the first study to demonstrate the occurrence of anti-IFN-alpha 2a in patients with AVH. Detection of anti-IFN-alpha 2a may be useful for clarifying any underlying immune events in various diseases.

Spontaneous interferon-alpha antibodies in a patient with pure red cell aplasia and recurrent cutaneous carcinomas

High-titered spontaneous interferon (IFN) antibodies were detected in a patient with pure red cell aplasia (PRCA), a benign mediastinal tumor, and recurrent cutaneous carcinomas. The circulating IFN antibodies reacted broadly with various human IFN-alpha subtypes (20-140 x 10(3) neutralizing units/ml serum) but not with IFN-beta or IFN-gamma, and they neutralized the antiviral activity of the patient's endogenous IFN-alpha. The IFN-alpha-binding activity was restricted to the IgG1 subclass in a nonmonoclonal manner. Whereas the PRCA repeatedly responded to immunosuppression with high-dose cyclosporin A (CSA) and CSA plus plasmapheresis, IFN antibody production continued during treatment with cyclophosphamide and CSA. Serological analysis revealed past infection with parvovirus B19 and persistent B19 IgM titers. Antibody-mediated impairment of the IFN-alpha system might have favored the development of both PRCA and the various cutaneous carcinomas in this patient.