Reliability of colposcopy and directed punch biopsy

Histological differences between colposcopic-directed biopsy and loop excision of the transformation zone (LETZ): a cause for concern

Colposcopic examination and biopsy were performed on 100 patients with abnormal cervical cytology. All were suitable for ablative therapy but were treated by loop excision of the transformation zone (LETZ) as outpatients. Histological comparison between the colposcopic biopsies and LETZ samples showed poor agreement with only 43% of cases illustrating identical degrees of dysplasia. The dysplasia was underestimated by colposcopic biopsy in 16% of cases and overestimated in 41% of cases, when compared to the LETZ specimen. Microinvasive carcinoma was diagnosed in 3 cases on the LETZ histology, having been missed by the preceding colposcopy and colposcopic biopsy. The disparity between histological findings is of great concern and would not have been detected if the patients were treated by ablative therapy. It is the authors' view that LETZ should replace ablative therapy in the treatment of localized cervical dysplasia and that it may avoid the need for pretreatment colposcopic biopsy. LETZ limits the possibility of inadequate treatment and also provides a method of audit for the colposcopist.

Computerization of a colposcopy clinic

The first phase of a paperless computer record has been developed at Hammersmith Hospital. The system was designed around the work practices of the clinic staff. In this phase the data are collected on forms which replace the normal case notes. This information is entered onto an IBM compatible computer by the secretary using a quick, user-friendly program written in a dBASE dialect and compiled with Quicksilver. The program produces letters to patients and their doctors and a printed record of the clinic findings for the case sheet to replace the handwritten form. When funding for hardware becomes available the data will be entered directly into the system by the medical staff in the clinic. Clinic appointment lists are maintained and patients "lost to follow-up' can be identified. Ad hoc enquiries can be made using dBASE III Plus or any similar program. This approach has integrated the computerized recording of data in a colposcopy clinic with the normal work of the staff involved so that no extra effort is required from medical or secretarial staff. The immediate accessibility of patient data and the ability to audit the work of the clinic have been particularly useful.