Comparison of mesial versus neocortical onset temporal lobe seizures: neurodiagnostic findings and surgical outcome

Visual and quantitative ictal EEG predictors of outcome after temporal lobectomy

PURPOSE

We investigated whether visual and quantitative ictal EEG analysis could predict surgical outcome after anteromesial temporal lobectomy (AMTL) in which mesial structures, basal, and temporal tip cortex were resected.

METHODS

We retrospectively reviewed 282 presurgical scalp-recorded ictal EEGs (21- to 27-channel) from 75 patients who underwent AMTL. We examined the pattern of seizure onset (frequency, distribution, and evolution) and estimated the principal underlying cerebral generators by using a multiple fixed dipole model that decomposes temporal lobe activity into four sublobar sources (Focus 1.1). We correlated findings with a 2-year postoperative outcome.

RESULTS

Sixteen patients had seizures with a well-lateralized, regular 5 to 9-Hz rhythm at onset, that most often had a temporal or subtemporal distribution. All patients became seizure free after surgery. In 51 patients, seizure onset was remarkable for lateralized slow rhythms (<5 Hz), which sometimes appeared as periodic discharges, were often irregular and stable only for short periods (<5 s), and had a widespread lateral temporal distribution. Among these a favorable surgical outcome was encountered in patients with seizures having prominent anterior-tip sources ( 16 of 17 seizure free), whereas those with dominant lateral or oblique sources had a less favorable outcome (three of 14 and 13 of 18, respectively). Irregular, nonlateralized slowing characterized seizure onsets in eight patients. Three patients became seizure free after surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

Both visual and quantitative sublobar source analysis of scalp ictal EEG can predict surgical outcome in most cases after AMTL and complement non-invasive presurgical evaluation.

Clinical and EEG analysis of mesial and lateral temporal lobe seizures

The analysis of the temporal lobe seizures through video-EEG systems shows that they often consist of a sequence of clinical and EEG features which may suggest the localization and the lateralization of the epileptogenic lobe. We analyzed clinical and EEG features of 50 temporal lobe seizures which were separated in group 1 with 25 patients (related to mesial temporal sclerosis) and group 2 with 25 patients (other neocortical temporal lesions). Among the auras, the epigastric type was the most frequent and predominated in group 1. There were differences between the two groups, considering dystonic and tonic posturing and versive head and eye movements. Dystonic posturing was always contralateral to the ictal onset and was considered the most useful lateralizing clinical feature. Ictal speech, spitting and blinking automatisms, prolonged disorientation for place and a greatest percentage of postictal language preservation occurred in right temporal seizures. Postictal aphasia and global disorientation predominated in left temporal seizures. EEG was important for lateralizing the epileptogenic lobe, specially considering rhythmic ictal activity and postictal findings.

Time-frequency analysis using the matching pursuit algorithm applied to seizures originating from the mesial temporal lobe

OBJECTIVES

The ability to analyze patterns of recorded seizure activity is important in the localization and classification of seizures. Ictal evolution is typically a dynamic process with signals composed of multiple frequencies; this can limit or complicate methods of analysis. The recently-developed matching pursuit algorithm permits continuous time-frequency analyses, making it particularly appealing for application to these signals. The studies here represent the initial applications of this method to intracranial ictal recordings.

METHODS

Mesial temporal onset partial seizures were recorded from 9 patients. The data were analyzed by the matching pursuit algorithm were continuous digitized single channel recordings from the depth electrode contact nearest the region of seizure onset. Tine frequency energy distributions were plotted for each seizure and correlated with the intracranial EEG recordings.

RESULTS

Periods of seizure initiation, transitional rhythmic bursting activity, organized rhythmic bursting activity and intermittent bursting activity were identified. During periods of organized rhythmic bursting activity, all mesial temporal onset seizures analyzed had a maximum predominant frequency of 5.3-8.4 Hz with a monotonic decline in frequency over a period of less than 60 s. The matching pursuit method allowed for time-frequency decomposition of entire seizures.

CONCLUSIONS

The matching pursuit method is a valuable tool for time-frequency analyses of dynamic seizure activity. It is well suited for application to the non-stationary activity that typically characterizes seizure evolution. Time-frequency patterns of seizures originating from different brain regions can be compared using the matching pursuit method.

Intracartotid amobarbital procedure memory performance and age at first risk for seizures distinguish between lateral neocortical and mesial temporal lobe epilepsy

PURPOSE

To determine whether intracarotid amobarbital procedure (IAP) memory-performance asymmetries and early risk factors for epilepsy distinguish between lateral neocortical temporal lobe epilepsy (LNTLE) and mesiobasal temporal lobe epilepsy (MBTLE).

METHODS

We studied 10 patients with LNTLE and 22 with MBTLE. All LNTLE patients showed (a) presence of temporal neocortical lesion or lateral seizure onset by intracranial recording, and (b) absence of mesial temporal sclerosis (MTS) by histopathologic analysis. All patients with MBTLE showed (a) video-scalp EEG seizures consistent with mesial TLE, and (b) presence of unilateral MTS by histopathologic analysis. All patients had good surgical outcomes (Engel I or II). Unilateral IAP memory performance was defined as percentage of memory items presented during hemispheric anesthesia that was recognized after recovery. IAP asymmetry scores were the differences in memory performance after right and left injections.

RESULTS

Mean memory-asymmetry scores were significantly lower in the LNTLE than in the MBTLE group. An IAP memory asymmetry of < 25% correctly classified seven of 10 patients with LNTLE, and an asymmetry of > or = 25% correctly classified 18 of 22 patients with MBTLE. Age at first risk for epilepsy was significantly younger in those with MBTLE than in those with nonlesional LNTLE. Results suggest that both IAP memory performance and age at first risk can help distinguish between MBTLE and LNTLE.

Clinical features of neocortical temporal lobe epilepsy

Few studies have examined the clinical features of neocortical temporal lobe epilepsy (NTLE) in carefully selected patients. We reviewed records from 21 patients with NTLE, defined by intracranial electroencephalogram (EEG), who have been seizure free for 1 year or more following temporal lobectomy. The mean age of onset at the time of first seizure was 14 years (range, 1-41 years). Febrile seizures were reported in only 2 patients (9.5%). In contrast to prior mesial temporal lobe epilepsy (MTLE) studies, seizure-free intervals between the initial cerebral insult or first seizure and habitual seizures were uncommon. Possible or known risk factors for epilepsy were reported in 13 of 21 patients (62%). Fifteen (71%) patients reported auras, with experiential phenomena being the most common type. Magnetic resonance imaging was normal or nonspecific in 15 patients, revealed mild hippocampal atrophy in 2, tumors in 2, and heterotopic gray matter and hippocampal atrophy in 1, and cortical dysgenesis in 1. Neuropsychological testing showed deficits consistent with the seizure focus in 13 patients (62%), and Wada test showed ipsilateral memory deficits in 10 (48%). The most common behavioral manifestation was a motionless stare at ictal onset (48%). In contrast to prior studies of MTLE, only 1 NTLE patient had frequent independent, contralateral temporal lobe epileptiform spikes on scalp EEG.