In vivo dissection of the Helicobacter pylori Fur regulatory circuit by genome-wide location analysis

CbpA acts as a modulator of HspR repressor DNA binding activity in Helicobacter pylori

The ability of pathogens to cope with disparate environmental stresses is a crucial feature for bacterial survival and for the establishment of a successful infection and colonization of the host; in this respect, chaperones and heat shock proteins (HSPs) play a fundamental role in host-pathogen interactions. In Helicobacter pylori, the expression of the major HSPs is tightly regulated through dedicated transcriptional repressors (named HspR and HrcA), as well as via a GroESL-dependent posttranscriptional feedback control acting positively on the DNA binding affinity of the HrcA regulator itself. In the present work we show that the CbpA chaperone also participates in the posttranscriptional feedback control of the H. pylori heat shock regulatory network. Our experiments suggest that CbpA specifically modulates HspR in vitro binding to DNA without affecting HrcA regulator activity. In particular, CbpA directly interacts with HspR, preventing the repressor from binding to its target operators. This interaction takes place only when HspR is not bound to DNA since CbpA is unable to affect HspR once the repressor is bound to its operator site. Accordingly, in vivo overexpression of CbpA compromises the response kinetics of the regulatory circuit, inducing a failure to restore HspR-dependent transcriptional repression after heat shock. The data presented in this work support a model in which CbpA acts as an important modulator of HspR regulation by fine-tuning the shutoff response of the regulatory circuit that governs HSP expression in H. pylori.

The Helicobacter pylori Ferric Uptake Regulator (Fur) is essential for growth under sodium chloride stress

Epidemiological data and animal models indicate that Helicobacter pylori and dietary NaCl have a synergistic ill effect on gastric maladies. Here we show that the Ferric Uptake Regulator (Fur), which is a crucial regulatory factor required for H. pylori colonization, is essential for growth in the presence of high NaCl concentrations. Moreover, we demonstrate that the transcriptional response induced by sodium chloride stress exhibits similarities to that seen under iron depletion.

Metalloregulatory proteins: metal selectivity and allosteric switching

Prokaryotic organisms have evolved the capacity to quickly adapt to a changing and challenging microenvironment in which the availability of both biologically required and non-essential transition metal ions can vary dramatically. In all bacteria, a panel of metalloregulatory proteins controls the expression of genes encoding membrane transporters and metal trafficking proteins that collectively manage metal homeostasis and resistance. These "metal sensors" are specialized allosteric proteins, in which the direct binding of a specific or small number of "cognate" metal ion(s) drives a conformational change in the regulator that allosterically activates or inhibits operator DNA binding, or alternatively, distorts the promoter structure thereby converting a poor promoter to a strong one. In this review, we discuss our current understanding of the features that control metal specificity of the allosteric response in these systems, and the role that structure, thermodynamics and conformational dynamics play in mediating allosteric activation or inhibition of DNA binding.

Change is good: variations in common biological mechanisms in the epsilonproteobacterial genera Campylobacter and Helicobacter

Microbial evolution and subsequent species diversification enable bacterial organisms to perform common biological processes by a variety of means. The epsilonproteobacteria are a diverse class of prokaryotes that thrive in diverse habitats. Many of these environmental niches are labeled as extreme, whereas other niches include various sites within human, animal, and insect hosts. Some epsilonproteobacteria, such as Campylobacter jejuni and Helicobacter pylori, are common pathogens of humans that inhabit specific regions of the gastrointestinal tract. As such, the biological processes of pathogenic Campylobacter and Helicobacter spp. are often modeled after those of common enteric pathogens such as Salmonella spp. and Escherichia coli. While many exquisite biological mechanisms involving biochemical processes, genetic regulatory pathways, and pathogenesis of disease have been elucidated from studies of Salmonella spp. and E. coli, these paradigms often do not apply to the same processes in the epsilonproteobacteria. Instead, these bacteria often display extensive variation in common biological mechanisms relative to those of other prototypical bacteria. In this review, five biological processes of commonly studied model bacterial species are compared to those of the epsilonproteobacteria C. jejuni and H. pylori. Distinct differences in the processes of flagellar biosynthesis, DNA uptake and recombination, iron homeostasis, interaction with epithelial cells, and protein glycosylation are highlighted. Collectively, these studies support a broader view of the vast repertoire of biological mechanisms employed by bacteria and suggest that future studies of the epsilonproteobacteria will continue to provide novel and interesting information regarding prokaryotic cellular biology.

The structure of the Helicobacter pylori ferric uptake regulator Fur reveals three functional metal binding sites

Fur, the ferric uptake regulator, is a transcription factor that controls iron metabolism in bacteria. Binding of ferrous iron to Fur triggers a conformational change that activates the protein for binding to specific DNA sequences named Fur boxes. In Helicobacter pylori, HpFur is involved in acid response and is important for gastric colonization in model animals. Here we present the crystal structure of a functionally active HpFur mutant (HpFur2M; C78S-C150S) bound to zinc. Although its fold is similar to that of other Fur and Fur-like proteins, the crystal structure of HpFur reveals a unique structured N-terminal extension and an unusual C-terminal helix. The structure also shows three metal binding sites: S1 the structural ZnS₄ site previously characterized biochemically in HpFur and the two zinc sites identified in other Fur proteins. Site-directed mutagenesis and spectroscopy analyses of purified wild-type HpFur and various mutants show that the two metal binding sites common to other Fur proteins can be also metallated by cobalt. DNA protection and circular dichroism experiments demonstrate that, while these two sites influence the affinity of HpFur for DNA, only one is absolutely required for DNA binding and could be responsible for the conformational changes of Fur upon metal binding while the other is a secondary site.

Mutagenesis of conserved amino acids of Helicobacter pylori fur reveals residues important for function

The ferric uptake regulator (Fur) of the medically important pathogen Helicobacter pylori is unique in that it has been shown to function as a repressor both in the presence of an Fe2+ cofactor and in its apo (non-Fe2+-bound) form. However, virtually nothing is known concerning the amino acid residues that are important for Fur functioning. Therefore, mutations in six conserved amino acid residues of H. pylori Fur were constructed and analyzed for their impact on both iron-bound and apo repression. In addition, accumulation of the mutant proteins, protein secondary structure, DNA binding ability, iron binding capacity, and the ability to form higher-order structures were also examined for each mutant protein. While none of the mutated residues completely abrogated the function of Fur, we were able to identify residues that were critical for both iron-bound and apo-Fur repression. One mutation, V64A, did not alter regulation of any target genes. However, each of the five remaining mutations showed an effect on either iron-bound or apo regulation. Of these, H96A, E110A, and E117A mutations altered iron-bound Fur regulation and were all shown to influence iron binding to different extents. Additionally, the H96A mutation was shown to alter Fur oligomerization, and the E110A mutation was shown to impact oligomerization and DNA binding. Conversely, the H134A mutant exhibited changes in apo-Fur regulation that were the result of alterations in DNA binding. Although the E90A mutant exhibited alterations in apo-Fur regulation, this mutation did not affect any of the assessed protein functions. This study is the first for H. pylori to analyze the roles of specific amino acid residues of Fur in function and continues to highlight the complexity of Fur regulation in this organism.

Built shallow to maintain homeostasis and persistent infection: insight into the transcriptional regulatory network of the gastric human pathogen Helicobacter pylori

Transcriptional regulatory networks (TRNs) transduce environmental signals into coordinated output expression of the genome. Accordingly, they are central for the adaptation of bacteria to their living environments and in host-pathogen interactions. Few attempts have been made to describe a TRN for a human pathogen, because even in model organisms, such as Escherichia coli, the analysis is hindered by the large number of transcription factors involved. In light of the paucity of regulators, the gastric human pathogen Helicobacter pylori represents a very appealing system for understanding how bacterial TRNs are wired up to support infection in the host. Herein, we review and analyze the available molecular and "-omic" data in a coherent ensemble, including protein-DNA and protein-protein interactions relevant for transcriptional control of pathogenic responses. The analysis covers approximately 80% of the annotated H. pylori regulators, and provides to our knowledge the first in-depth description of a TRN for an important pathogen. The emerging picture indicates a shallow TRN, made of four main modules (origons) that process the physiological responses needed to colonize the gastric niche. Specific network motifs confer distinct transcriptional response dynamics to the TRN, while long regulatory cascades are absent. Rather than having a plethora of specialized regulators, the TRN of H. pylori appears to transduce separate environmental inputs by using different combinations of a small set of regulators.

Regulatory circuits in Helicobacter pylori : network motifs and regulators involved in metal-dependent responses

The ability of Helicobacter pylori, one of the most successful human bacterial pathogens, to colonize the acidic gastric niche persistently, depends on the proper homeostasis of intracellular metal ions, needed as cofactors of essential metallo-proteins involved in acid acclimation, respiration and detoxification. This fundamental task is controlled at the transcriptional level mainly by the regulators Fur and NikR, involved in iron homeostasis and nickel response, respectively. Herein, we review the molecular mechanisms that underlie the activity of these key pleiotropic regulators. In addition, we will focus on their involvement in the transcriptional regulatory network of the bacterium, pinpointing a surprising complexity of network motifs that interconnects them and their gene targets. These motifs appear to confer versatile dynamics of metal-dependent responses by extensive horizontal connections between the regulators and feedback control of metal-cofactor availability.

Induction of the ferritin gene (ftnA) of Escherichia coli by Fe(2+)-Fur is mediated by reversal of H-NS silencing and is RyhB independent

FtnA is the major iron-storage protein of Escherichia coli accounting for < or = 50% of total cellular iron. The FtnA gene (ftnA) is induced by iron in an Fe(2+)-Fur-dependent fashion. This effect is reportedly mediated by RyhB, the Fe(2+)-Fur-repressed, small, regulatory RNA. However, results presented here show that ftnA iron induction is independent of RyhB and instead involves direct interaction of Fe(2+)-Fur with an 'extended' Fur binding site (containing five tandem Fur boxes) located upstream (-83) of the ftnA promoter. In addition, H-NS acts as a direct repressor of ftnA transcription by binding at multiple sites (I-VI) within, and upstream of, the ftnA promoter. Fur directly competes with H-NS binding at upstream sites (II-IV) and consequently displaces H-NS from the ftnA promoter (sites V-VI) which in turn leads to derepression of ftnA transcription. It is proposed that H-NS binding within the ftnA promoter is facilitated by H-NS occupation of the upstream sites through H-NS oligomerization-induced DNA looping. Consequently, Fur displacement of H-NS from the upstream sites prevents cooperative H-NS binding at the downstream sites within the promoter, thus allowing access to RNA polymerase. This direct activation of ftnA transcription by Fe(2+)-Fur through H-NS antisilencing represents a new mechanism for iron-induced gene expression.

Direct methods for studying transcription regulatory proteins and RNA polymerase in bacteria

Transcription factors and sigma factors play a major role in bacterial gene regulation by guiding the distribution of RNA polymerase between the promoters of different transcription units in response to changes in the environment. For 40 years Escherichia coli K-12 has been the paradigm for investigating this regulation and most studies have focused on small numbers of promoters studied by a combination of genetics and biochemistry. Since the first complete sequence for a bacterial genome was reported, the emphasis has switched to studying transcription on a global scale, with transcriptomics and bioinformatics becoming the methods of choice. Here we discuss two complementary direct experimental methods for studying transcription factors and sigma factors and we outline their potential use in rapidly establishing the regulatory networks in newly sequenced bacteria.

Dissecting regulatory networks in host-pathogen interaction using chIP-on-chip technology

Understanding host-microbe interactions has been greatly enhanced by our broadening knowledge of the regulatory mechanisms at the heart of pathogenesis. The "transcriptomics" approach of measuring global gene expression has identified genes involved in bacterial pathogenesis. More recently, chromatin immunoprecipitation (ChIP) and hybridization to microarrays (chIP-on-chip) has emerged as a complementary tool that permits protein-DNA interactions to be studied in vivo. Thus, chIP-on-chip can be used to map the binding sites of transcription factors, thereby teasing apart gene regulatory networks. In this Review, we discuss the ChIP-on-chip technique and focus on its application to the study of host-pathogen interactions.

Growth phase and metal-dependent transcriptional regulation of the fecA genes in Helicobacter pylori

Balancing metal uptake is essential for maintaining a proper intracellular metal concentration. Here, we report the transcriptional control exerted by the two metal-responsive regulators of Helicobacter pylori, Fur (iron-dependent ferric uptake regulator) and NikR (nickel-responsive regulator), on the three copies of the fecA genes present in this species. By monitoring the patterns of transcription throughout growth and in response to nickel, iron, and a metal chelator, we found that the expression of the three fecA genes is temporally regulated, responds to metals in different ways, and is selectively controlled by either one of the two regulators. fecA1 is expressed at a constant level throughout growth, and its expression is iron sensitive; the expression of fecA2 is mainly off, with minor expression coming up in late exponential phase. In contrast, the expression of fecA3 is maximal in early exponential phase, gradually decreases with time, and is repressed by nickel. The direct roles of Fur and NikR were studied both in vitro, by mapping the binding sites of each regulator on the promoter regions via DNase I footprinting analysis, and in vivo, by using primer extension analyses of the fecA transcripts in fur and nikR deletion strains. Overall, the results show that the expression of each fecA gene is finely tuned in response to metal availability, as well as during the bacterial growth phase, suggesting specific and dedicated functions for the three distinct FecA homologues.

Snapshot of iron response in Shewanella oneidensis by gene network reconstruction

Background

Iron homeostasis of Shewanella oneidensis, a γ-proteobacterium possessing high iron content, is regulated by a global transcription factor Fur. However, knowledge is incomplete about other biological pathways that respond to changes in iron concentration, as well as details of the responses. In this work, we integrate physiological, transcriptomics and genetic approaches to delineate the iron response of S. oneidensis.

Results

We show that the iron response in S. oneidensis is a rapid process. Temporal gene expression profiles were examined for iron depletion and repletion, and a gene co-expression network was reconstructed. Modules of iron acquisition systems, anaerobic energy metabolism and protein degradation were the most noteworthy in the gene network. Bioinformatics analyses suggested that genes in each of the modules might be regulated by DNA-binding proteins Fur, CRP and RpoH, respectively. Closer inspection of these modules revealed a transcriptional regulator (SO2426) involved in iron acquisition and ten transcriptional factors involved in anaerobic energy metabolism. Selected genes in the network were analyzed by genetic studies. Disruption of genes encoding a putative alcaligin biosynthesis protein (SO3032) and a gene previously implicated in protein degradation (SO2017) led to severe growth deficiency under iron depletion conditions. Disruption of a novel transcriptional factor (SO1415) caused deficiency in both anaerobic iron reduction and growth with thiosulfate or TMAO as an electronic acceptor, suggesting that SO1415 is required for specific branches of anaerobic energy metabolism pathways.

Conclusion

Using a reconstructed gene network, we identified major biological pathways that were differentially expressed during iron depletion and repletion. Genetic studies not only demonstrated the importance of iron acquisition and protein degradation for iron depletion, but also characterized a novel transcriptional factor (SO1415) with a role in anaerobic energy metabolism.

Dynamics of RpaB-promoter interaction during high light stress, revealed by chromatin immunoprecipitation (ChIP) analysis in Synechococcus elongatus PCC 7942

In cyanobacteria, a series of genes are induced by, and cause tolerance to, high light stress conditions. Some of these genes share a short, repeated sequence motif known as a high light regulatory 1 (HLR1) element in their promoter regions. Previously, RpaB, a two-component response regulator, was shown to interact with the HLR1 element of several high light-responsive promoters in vitro. However, how RpaB regulates target promoters in vivo remained elusive. In this study, we analyzed the role of RpaB in transcriptional regulation of high light-responsive genes by chromatin immunoprecipitation (ChIP) analysis, which has been recently developed and utilized to study in vivo interactions between DNA-binding proteins and the relevant target DNA. One of the advantages of this method is the ability to detect dynamic interaction patterns in response to various growth and/or environmental conditions instantaneously at the time of the analysis. Here we examined the binding patterns of RpaB under various light conditions using ChIP assays. We found that strong interactions of RpaB with target promoters were weakened in a high light-dependent manner, and that the lower binding level of RpaB continued as long as the high light conditions were maintained. Thus, in regulation of high light-inducible genes, we suggest that RpaB functions as a repressor under normal light conditions, and that high light conditions result in release of the repression.

Methods for studying global patterns of DNA binding by bacterial transcription factors and RNA polymerase

A major goal in the study of gene regulation is to untangle the transcription-regulatory networks of Escherichia coli and other 'simple' organisms. To do this we must catalogue the binding sites of all transcription factors. ChIP (chromatin immunoprecipitation), combined with DNA microarray analysis, is a powerful tool that permits global patterns of DNA binding to be measured. Here, we discuss the benefits of this approach and the application of this technique to bacterial systems.

Alteration of growth-phase-dependent protein regulation by a fur mutation in Helicobacter pylori

The ferric-uptake regulator (Fur) protein is an Fe(2+)-dependent transcriptional repressor. To clarify the global regulation of Helicobacter pylori proteins by Fur according to the growth phase, we compared the proteome profiles of H. pylori 26695 and its isogenic fur mutant, harvested during in vitro culture. Clustering analysis of the proteome profiles of the two strains revealed that the growth-phase-dependent protein regulation in the wild-type strain was largely altered in the fur mutant. Reverse transcriptase-PCR analysis of several H. pylori genes showed that a major switch in transcription occurred 12 h earlier than in the wild type, indicating that the fur mutation induced an earlier transcriptional switch from log to stationary phase. Several H. pylori proteins also showed changes in their patterns of protein post-translational modification (PTM). In particular, the HydB protein, which was detected as four spots on 2-dimensional electrophoresis gels, underwent two types of PTM, which were under different kinds of regulation. These data demonstrate that a fur mutation affects the growth-phase-dependent regulation of proteins and mRNAs, suggesting a role for Fur in controlling the global regulation of cellular processes in response to changing growth environments.

Genomic analysis of protein-DNA interactions in bacteria: insights into transcription and chromosome organization

Chromatin immunoprecipitation (ChIP) is a powerful method to measure protein-DNA interactions in vivo, and it can be applied on a genomic scale with microarray technology (ChIP-chip). ChIP-chip has been used extensively to map DNA-protein interactions across eukaryotic chromosomes. Here we review recent applications of ChIP-chip to the study of bacteria, which provide important and unexpected insights into transcription and chromosome organization.

Efficient degradation and expression prioritization with small RNAs

We build a simple model for feedback systems involving small RNA (sRNA) molecules based on the iron metabolism system in the bacterium E. coli, and compare it with the corresponding system in H. pylori which uses purely transcriptional regulation. This reveals several unique features of sRNA-based regulation that could be exploited by cells. Firstly, we show that sRNA regulation can maintain a smaller turnover of target mRNAs than transcriptional regulation, without sacrificing the speed of response to external shocks. Secondly, we propose that a single sRNA can prioritize the usage of different target mRNAs. This suggests that sRNA regulation would be more common in more complex systems which need to co-regulate many mRNAs efficiently.

A comparative analysis of perturbations caused by a gene knock-out, a dominant negative allele, and a set of peptide aptamers

The study of protein function mostly relies on perturbing regulatory networks by acting upon protein expression levels or using transdominant negative agents. Here we used the Escherichia coli global transcription regulator Fur (ferric uptake regulator) as a case study to compare the perturbations exerted by a gene knock-out, the expression of a dominant negative allele of a gene, and the expression of peptide aptamers that bind a gene product. These three perturbations caused phenotypes that differed quantitatively and qualitatively from one another. The Fur peptide aptamers inhibited the activity of their target to various extents and reduced the virulence of a pathogenic E. coli strain in Drosophila. A genome-wide transcriptome analysis revealed that the "penetrance" of a peptide aptamer was comparable to that of a dominant negative allele but lower than the penetrance of the gene knock-out. Our work shows that comparative analysis of phenotypic and transcriptome responses to different types of perturbation can help decipher complex regulatory networks that control various biological processes.

Transcriptional regulation of stress response and motility functions in Helicobacter pylori is mediated by HspR and HrcA

The hrcA and hspR genes of Helicobacter pylori encode two transcriptional repressor proteins that negatively regulate expression of the groES-groEL and hrcA-grpE-dnaK operons. While HspR was previously shown to bind far upstream of the promoters transcribing these operons, the binding sites of HrcA were not identified. Here, we demonstrate by footprinting analysis that HrcA binds to operator elements similar to the so-called CIRCE sequences overlapping both promoters. Binding of HspR and HrcA to their respective operators occurs in an independent manner, but the DNA binding activity of HrcA is increased in the presence of GroESL, suggesting that the GroE chaperonin system corepresses transcription together with HrcA. Comparative transcriptome analysis of the wild-type strain and hspR and hrcA singly and doubly deficient strains revealed that a set of 14 genes is negatively regulated by the action of one or both regulators, while a set of 29 genes is positively regulated. While both positive and negative regulation of transcription by HspR and/or HrcA could be confirmed by RNA primer extension analyses for two representative genes, binding of either regulator to the promoters could not be detected, indicating that transcriptional regulation at these promoters involves indirect mechanisms. Strikingly, 14 of the 29 genes which were found to be positively regulated by HspR or HrcA code for proteins involved in flagellar biosynthesis. Accordingly, loss of motility functions was observed for HspR and HrcA single or double mutants. The possible regulatory intersections of the heat shock response and flagellar assembly are discussed.

Ten years after the first Helicobacter pylori genome: comparative and functional genomics provide new insights in the variability and adaptability of a persistent pathogen

In this review, we summarize how genomic approaches contributed to the understanding of the biology of the recently discovered pathogen Helicobacter pylori. Comparative genomics provided new insights into H. pylori's spectacular genetic diversity and generated exiting hypotheses on its evolutionary history. Transcriptomic studies provided original information on the mechanisms of H. pylori gastric adaptation that are central to its virulence.

Analysis of a ferric uptake regulator (Fur) mutant of Desulfovibrio vulgaris Hildenborough

Previous experiments examining the transcriptional profile of the anaerobe Desulfovibrio vulgaris demonstrated up-regulation of the Fur regulon in response to various environmental stressors. To test the involvement of Fur in the growth response and transcriptional regulation of D. vulgaris, a targeted mutagenesis procedure was used for deleting the fur gene. Growth of the resulting Deltafur mutant (JW707) was not affected by iron availability, but the mutant did exhibit increased sensitivity to nitrite and osmotic stresses compared to the wild type. Transcriptional profiling of JW707 indicated that iron-bound Fur acts as a traditional repressor for ferrous iron uptake genes (feoAB) and other genes containing a predicted Fur binding site within their promoter. Despite the apparent lack of siderophore biosynthesis genes within the D. vulgaris genome, a large 12-gene operon encoding orthologs to TonB and TolQR also appeared to be repressed by iron-bound Fur. While other genes predicted to be involved in iron homeostasis were unaffected by the presence or absence of Fur, alternative expression patterns that could be interpreted as repression or activation by iron-free Fur were observed. Both the physiological and transcriptional data implicate a global regulatory role for Fur in the sulfate-reducing bacterium D. vulgaris.

Pathogenomics of helicobacter

The pathogenic bacterium Helicobacter pylori infects half of the human population and is one of the genetically most diverse bacterial species known. H. pylori was one of the first bacterial species whose genome was sequenced in 1997, and the first species for which two complete sequences from independent isolates were available for within-species comparisons. For almost 10 years, genomic and post-genomic analysis has contributed enormously to our understanding of the pathogenesis of H. pylori infection. This review summarizes the available information, emphasizing work performed in the framework of the PathoGenoMik funding initiative (2001-2006) of the German Ministry of Education and Research.

Genomic approaches to understanding bacterial virulence

The genomic sequences of bacterial pathogens and of the host species they infect have greatly increased the understanding of host-pathogen interactions. Sequences of bacterial genomes have led to the identification of virulence factors through the use of bioinformatics, targeted mutant library construction, screening approaches combining transposon mutagenesis and microarray technology, and through the expression of libraries of bacterial proteins within model organisms such as yeast. Host genomic information has also yielded insights into bacterial virulence through transcriptional profiling of host responses to infection and identification of host proteins required for bacterial pathogenicity using knockdown of host gene product expression during infection. Research using genomic approaches to bacterial pathogenesis is a rapidly growing field and will expand further as additional bacterial genome sequences become available and techniques for conducting high-throughput analysis are refined.