Pressure-time product, flow, and oxygen cost of resistive breathing in humans

Reliability of a commercially available threshold loading device in healthy subjects and in patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease

BACKGROUND

Threshold loading with the Nickerson and Keens' device is frequently applied in the training and assessment of inspiratory muscles. However, this equipment is not easily applied in clinical practice and training. A study was therefore designed to investigate the accuracy and reliability of the Threshold, a commercially available threshold loading device.

METHODS

The resolution (accuracy) of the system was determined by measuring variation of pressure and flow during one minute in an experimental setup. The reproducibility and flow independence were then determined during threshold loading at six different inspiratory loads between 25% and 50% maximal inspiratory pressure (PImax) in 10 patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) and eight healthy subjects.

RESULTS

In the first experiment the mean variation of the sustained pressure for all loads was 1.7%. The mean coefficients of variation for pressure and flow measurements were 0.2% and 3%, respectively. In the second experiment the healthy subjects showed mean coefficients of variation for pressure and flow of 0.8% and 20.5%, respectively, and the patients showed mean coefficients of variation of 0.6% and 14.5%, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

During the in vitro experiment as well as during the experiments in patients with COPD and in healthy subjects only small variations in pressure were observed despite large variations in flow. The Threshold is a reliable and reproducible device for loading inspiratory muscles in patients with COPD as well as in healthy subjects.

Infant lung function testing in the intensive care unit

As a result of the previous shortage of tools to assess objectively the overall physiological status of the respiratory system in infants and young children, it has been difficult to measure the degree of physiological disorder or the response to therapy in respiratory diseases such as BPD, the pediatric version of ARDS, bronchiolitis, pneumonia, asthma and croup in this patient population. The newborn- four-year old child is particularly difficult to study because of their lack of cooperation and size. The recent progress in computer technology made pulmonary function testing available for this age range and opened up new possibilities for monitoring changes in disease processes affecting the respiratory system. This may improve medical management of infants and children with lung and heart diseases in particular. In 1989, Shannon [49] proposed in this Journal that the minimum physiological information needed for the intelligent use of mechanical ventilation (particularly if lower airway and/or pulmonary parenchymal disease was apparent) required the measurement of at least 4 variables: i) arterial partial pressure of carbon dioxide; ii) arterial oxygen saturation; iii) the mechanical time constant of the lung and iv) FRC. In many circumstances, arterial CO2 is approximated by alveolar (end-tidal) CO2 and the arterial oxygen saturation is obtained from pulse oximetry accurately if perfusion is adequate. The mechanical time constant and FRC are easily measured by the techniques described above and together provide important information concerning appropriate ventilator settings for a given disease. The described techniques bring new insights and awareness, but also new responsibilities in the management of infants and children with respiratory compromise. Not all of these techniques need to be applied to all infants in the ICU. Not all the assumptions upon which some of the techniques we have described are based will prove true. Any such methods which do not withstand solid scientific testing must be quickly discarded and replaced with better and (hopefully) easier methods.

Using tracheal pressure to trigger the ventilator and control airway pressure during continuous positive airway pressure decreases work of breathing

STUDY OBJECTIVE

We evaluated the difference in work of breathing (WOB) during spontaneous ventilation with continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP) among three methods of triggering the ventilator: conventional pressure triggering, tracheal pressure triggering, and flow-by triggering.

METHODS

In an in vitro model of the respiratory system consisting of a bellows (lungs) in a plastic canister (chest wall), spontaneous ventilation was simulated with a piston-driven pump (respiratory muscles). Data were recorded during CPAP of 5 cm H2O (model 7200ae ventilator, Puritan-Bennett, Overland Park, Kan) at peak sinusoidal inspiratory flow rate demands of 60 and 80 L/min and airway resistances of 5 and 20 cm H2O/L/s, with the demand flow system triggered by conventional pressure, tracheal pressure, or flow. Under each condition, tidal volume, pressure-time product (PTP), WOB, and changes in intrapleural pressure (Ppl) and airway pressure were recorded in real time by means of a computerized portable respiratory monitor (model CP-100, Bicore, Irvine, Calif). The Ppl was measured from within the canister, tidal volume by positioning a flow sensor between the Y-piece of the breathing circuit and the endotracheal tube (ETT), and airway pressure from a catheter attached to the flow sensor. The WOB was calculated by the monitor in real time.

RESULTS

Changes in Ppl were greatest with conventional pressure triggering, less with flow-by triggering, and least with tracheal pressure triggering. The WOB was significantly lower (approximately 50%) with tracheal pressure triggering than with the other two methods. With tracheal pressure triggering only, an effect similar to that of pressure support ventilation (PSV) occurred, which accounted in part for the significant decrease in WOB. The PTP/breath ratio correlated strongly and was a good predictor of WOB (r2 = 0.95).

CONCLUSIONS

Compared with conventional pressure and flow-by methods, triggering with tracheal pressure decreased WOB significantly. This method of triggering may improve patient-ventilator interaction.

Measurement of inspiratory muscle performance with incremental threshold loading: a comparison of two techniques

BACKGROUND

Incremental threshold loading (ITL) is a test of inspiratory muscle performance which is usually performed by breathing through a weighted inspiratory plunger, the load on the inspiratory muscles being increased by externally adding weights to the intake valve. This is not a true threshold device and may be inaccurate. This method was compared with a true threshold device consisting of a solenoid valve which only opens to supply air at a predetermined negative mouth pressure.

METHODS

Six naive, normal subjects (three men and three women) aged 22-24 years underwent three tests using each system. The inspiratory loads were increased every minute by equivalent amounts, -10 cm H2O with the solenoid valve and by 50 g with the weighted plunger, until the subjects could not inspire or sustain inspiration for a full minute. Six experienced subjects (four men and two women) aged 23-41 years were subsequently randomised to perform ITL with the solenoid valve, twice with the breathing pattern fixed and twice free.

RESULTS

The solenoid valve generated a more accurate mouth pressure response and was less variable at higher loads than the weighted plunger. The work performed (expressed as the pressure-time product) was less with the solenoid valve but was more reproducible. ITL with the solenoid valve was not influenced by controlling the breathing pattern of the subjects.

CONCLUSIONS

The solenoid valve has several features that make it superior to the weighted plunger as a device for ITL. It generates a more accurate mouth pressure response which is less variable at higher loads. Increases in load are smoother and quicker to introduce. ITL with the solenoid valve is not influenced by varying breathing patterns and does not require any external regulation.

Exercise-induced diaphragmatic fatigue in healthy humans

1. Twelve healthy subjects (33 +/- 3 years) with a variety of fitness levels (maximal oxygen uptake (VO2, max) = 61 +/- 4 ml kg-1 min-1, range 40-80), exercised at 95 and 85% VO2, max to exhaustion (mean time = 14 +/- 3 and 31 +/- 8 min, expired ventilation (VE) over final minute of exercise = 149 +/- 9 and 126 +/- 10 l min-1). 2. Bilateral transcutaneous supramaximal phrenic nerve stimulation (BPNS) was performed before and immediately after exercise at four lung volumes, and 400 ms tetanic stimulations were performed at 10 and 20 Hz. The coefficients of variation of repeated measurements for the twitch transdiaphragm pressures (Pdi) were +/- 7-10% and for compound muscle action potentials (M wave) +/- 10-15%. 3. Following exercise at 95% of VO2, max, group mean Pdi twitch values were reduced at all lung volumes (range -8 +/- 3 to -32 +/- 5%) and tetanically stimulated Pdi values were reduced at both 10 and 20 Hz (-21 +/- 3 and -13 +/- 2%, respectively) (P = 0.001-0.047). Following exercise at 85% VO2, max, stimulated Pdi values were reduced at all lung volumes and stimulating frequencies, but only significantly so with the twitch at functional residual capacity (-15 +/- 5%). Stimulated Pdi values recovered partially by 30 min post-exercise and almost completely by an average time of 70 min. 4. The fall in stimulated Pdi values post-exercise was significantly correlated with the percentage increase in diaphragmatic work (integral of Pdi min-1) from rest to end-exercise and the relative intensity of the exercise. 5. The integral of Pdi min-1 and the integral of Po min-1 (Po, esophageal pressure) rose together from rest through the fifth to tenth minute of exercise, after which integral of Pdi min-1 plateaued even though integral of Po min-1, VE and inspiratory flow rate all continued to rise substantially until exercise terminated. Thus, the relative contribution of the diaphragm to total respiratory motor output was progressively reduced with exercise duration. 6. We conclude that significant diaphragmatic fatigue is caused by the ventilatory requirements imposed by heavy endurance exercise in healthy persons with a variety of fitness levels. The magnitude of the fatigue and the likelihood of its occurrence increases as the relative intensity of the exercise exceeds 85% of VO2, max.

Volume-assured pressure support ventilation (VAPSV). A new approach for reducing muscle workload during acute respiratory failure

This study reports the preliminary clinical evaluation of a new mode of ventilation--volume-assured pressure support ventilation (VAPSV)--which incorporates inspiratory pressure support (PSV) with conventional volume-assisted cycles (VAV). This combination optimizes the inspiratory flow during assisted/controlled cycles, reducing the patient's respiratory burden commonly observed during VAV. Different from conventional PSV, VAPSV assures precise control of tidal volume (VT) in unstable patients. Eight patients with acute respiratory failure (ARF) were submitted to assisted ventilation under VAV and VAPSV. Patient's ventilatory workload (evaluated through the pressure-time product, mechanical work per liter of ventilation, and work per minute) and patient's ventilatory drive (occlusion pressure--P0.1) were significantly reduced during VAPSV. This "relief" was more evident among the most distressed patients (p < 0.001), allowing a reduction of more than 60 percent in muscle load, without the need of increasing peak tracheal pressure. Mean inspiratory flow (VT/TI), VT, and effective dynamic compliance were significantly increased during VAPSV, whereas the effective inspiratory impedance decreased. These mechanical advantages of VAPSV allowed a reduction of intrinsic PEEP, whenever it was present. Blood gas values were similar in both periods. We concluded that VAPSV is a promising form of ventilatory support. At the same time that it was able to safely assure a minimum preset VT, VAPSV reduced patient workload and improved synchrony between the patient and the ventilator during ARF.

Mechanical load on the inspiratory muscles during exercise hyperpnea in patients with type 1 (insulin-dependent) diabetes mellitus

The aim of this study was to evaluate the difference between Type 1 (insulin-dependent) diabetic patients and healthy control subjects regarding inspiratory muscle load during exercise hypernea. For this purpose an incremental progressive exercise test on a cycle ergometer was performed by 36 Type 1 diabetic patients and 40 healthy subjects. In order to determine the mechanical load on the inspiratory muscles breath by breath, we selected the following two parameters, which represent the pressure generated by the inspiratory muscles as well as the duration and velocity of their contraction: (1) the oesophageal tension time index, which is the product of the duty cycle (ratio of inspiratory time to total breath cycle duration) and the mean oesophageal pressure expressed as a percentage of the maximal oesophageal pressure and (2) the mean oesophageal pressure change per time unit during the inspiratory phase of each breathing manoeuver, which is expressed as a fraction of the subject's maximal oesophageal pressure. Comparison of the two groups revealed that at similar levels of ventilation the mechanical load on the inspiratory muscles was significantly higher in the Type 1 diabetic patients than in the control subjects. When the loading was stopped the maximal ventilation was lower in the patients. Nevertheless, they reported a degree of respiratory effort sensation comparable to the control group, which seems to have been caused by an increase of the mechanical load on the ventilatory muscles.

Respiratory muscle fatigue and breathing pattern

The major determinants of VO2 resp and, thus, diaphragmatic endurance are the tension-time index, work rate and lung volume. Changes in breathing pattern that adversely affect any of these factors can impair diaphragmatic endurance. A TTdi above 0.15-0.18 indicates a potentially fatiguing pattern of contraction. However, fatigue may occur at a TTdi below 0.15 if the work rate is sufficiently high or the Pdimax is not measured at the prevailing lung volume. Inspiratory muscle fatigue usually elicits an increase in minute ventilation and respiratory rate and to a lesser degree a reduction in tidal volume. However, fatigue may not always be accompanied by changes in breathing pattern. Furthermore, fatigue may sometimes result in a reduction rather than an increase in motor outflow to the respiratory muscles. Finally, abdominal paradox initially considered to be characteristic clinical sign of inspiratory muscle fatigue appears to be due to increases in respiratory load rather than to muscle fatigue.

Diaphragm VO2, diaphragm EMG, pressure-time product and calculated ventilation in newborn lambs during hypercapnic hyperpnoea

We examined the relationship between diaphragmatic EMG (EMGdi) and pressure-time index (Pt'), and diaphragmatic oxygen consumption (VO2di) in 6 newborn lambs quietly breathing air and during 3 levels of hypercapnic hyperpnoea (PaCO2 was equal to 48, 53, or 60 Torr). We also determined minute ventilation (VI), whole body oxygen consumption (VO2), diaphragmatic oxygen consumption (VO2di), and respiratory muscle oxygen consumption (VO2resp). VO2 did not change significantly throughout the experiment. While breathing air VO2di was 0.46 +/- 0.03 ml.min-1, VO2resp was 1.40 +/- 0.22 ml.min-1, and VI was 1.98 +/- 0.11 L.min-1. These values increased significantly during hyperpnoea and reached 3.88 +/- 0.45 ml.min-1, 7.22 +/- 1.12 ml.min-1, and 6.99 +/- 1.03 L.min-1, respectively. EMGdi, and Pt' also increased significantly during hyperpnoea. A strong linear relationship was found between the normalized values of EMGdi and Pt' (r = 0.90), between VO2di and EMGdi (r = 0.88), and between VO2di and Pt' (r = 0.88). The relationship between both EMGdi and VI and PaCO2 was logarithmic. We found that (i) both EMGdi and Pt' correlate well with VO2di, and (ii) VI, VO2di, and EMGdi increased significantly when PaCO2 was greater than 48 Torr.

Efficiency of work of inspiratory muscles in standing and in exercising dogs

The objective of this study was to elucidate the resistive, elastic, and total inspiratory muscle work and mainly the efficiency of the inspiratory muscle work in still standing and in exercising dogs. In 180 experiments with nine mongrel dogs, respiratory and circulatory functions were recorded at rest and during a 1.5-mph walk on a treadmill belt which was inclined by 9 degrees. Each dog had been trained and surgically prepared before the series of experiments started. An electronic pressure transducer together with a fluid-filled catheter was attached to the ribs at the midthoracic level. Airflow was monitored with a pneumotachygraph attached to a face mask. Aortic flow was monitored with an electromagnetic flow transducer. Catheters in the atria, the ventricles, and the pulmonary and systemic vessels were used to determine hemodynamic parameters and blood gas levels. All recorded and all derived functions were evaluated by a dedicated computer. At rest, resistive inspiratory work (0.98 kg cm) was smaller than elastic work (1.36 kg cm). Elastic work did not change with exercise but resistive work increased to 1.46 kg.cm. The increase of total work from 2.33 kg.cm at rest to 2.79 kg.cm during exercise did not reach significance. Inspiratory power increased with exercise. Estimated diaphragmatic oxygen consumption increased from 2.23 ml/min at rest to 3.64 ml/min during exercise. It was 1.6 percent of the total oxygen consumption at rest and 1.7 percent of the total oxygen consumption during exercise. The estimated efficiency of the work of inspiratory muscles was 15.8 percent at rest and 25.8 percent during exercise. These values did not vary substantially between different animals.

Resistive breathing training in patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease

In order to investigate the effect of resistive breathing training on ventilatory muscular endurance, we examined the maximal sustained ventilatory capacity in ten patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) before and after a six-week program of resistive breathing training. In addition, we investigated the effect of altered breathing strategy on resistive breathing performance. The patients performed two 15-minute sessions of resistive breathing daily for six weeks using an inspiratory resistive device (Pflex). Before and after the training, we found no significant change in spirometric data, pulmonary volumes, maximal inspiratory pressure, and maximal expiratory pressure. Of the ten patients, seven failed to show an improvement in their performance of resistive breathing. Furthermore, the maximal sustained ventilatory capacity was unchanged after the resistive breathing training. After the completion of the training program, seven of the patients participated in an additional experiment in which they were instructed to take long slow inspirations while breathing through the resistive device. With this change in breathing pattern, five of the seven were able to improve their performance of resistive breathing. Analysis of the breathing strategy showed that a reduction in the peak mouth pressure, breathing frequency, and external resistive work with a longer inspiratory time was beneficial. We conclude that neither resistive breathing performance nor ventilatory muscular endurance, as measured by sustained hyperpnea, is improved by resistive breathing training performed according to the current instructions with the resistive device, and alterations in breathing strategy have a profound effect on the performance of resistive breathing. The lack of details of breathing strategy in previous studies of resistive breathing makes it difficult to determine if previously demonstrated improvements were due to a real enhancement of ventilatory muscular performance or merely secondary to a different strategy.

Relief of sleep-related oropharyngeal airway obstruction by continuous insufflation of the pharynx

Sleep-related upper airway obstruction was treated by continuous insufflation of the pharynx (CIP) in 20 children. All had symptoms but only 1 qualified for a diagnosis of the obstructive sleep apnoea syndrome. Passage of warm humidified air through a thin nasopharyngeal tube at 2-10 litres/min (mean 3.5) relieved obstruction immediately in all patients. Relief was always clinically apparent and accompanied by reduced pleural pressure excursions during breathing. An index of the work of breathing (the product of breathing frequency and pleural pressure change per breath) fell by nearly 60% while patients were on CIP. Transcutaneous oxygen tension was monitored in 5 patients and was improved by CIP in each instance. Side-effects of CIP were minor and preventable with up to 72 days of continuous use. CIP is thus a simple and safe method that rapidly relieves severe oropharyngeal airway obstruction in children during sleep. Whether CIP is useful in domiciliary care or for adults has still to be established.