Quantitative evaluation of siRNA delivery in vivo

Image-based analysis of lipid nanoparticle-mediated siRNA delivery, intracellular trafficking and endosomal escape

Delivery of short interfering RNAs (siRNAs) remains a key challenge in the development of RNA interference (RNAi) therapeutics. A better understanding of the mechanisms of siRNA cellular uptake, intracellular transport and endosomal release could critically contribute to the improvement of delivery methods. Here we monitored the uptake of lipid nanoparticles (LNPs) loaded with traceable siRNAs in different cell types in vitro and in mouse liver by quantitative fluorescence imaging and electron microscopy. We found that LNPs enter cells by both constitutive and inducible pathways in a cell type-specific manner using clathrin-mediated endocytosis as well as macropinocytosis. By directly detecting colloidal-gold particles conjugated to siRNAs, we estimated that escape of siRNAs from endosomes into the cytosol occurs at low efficiency (1-2%) and only during a limited window of time when the LNPs reside in a specific compartment sharing early and late endosomal characteristics. Our results provide insights into LNP-mediated siRNA delivery that can guide development of the next generation of delivery systems for RNAi therapeutics.

Technologies for investigating the physiological barriers to efficient lipid nanoparticle-siRNA delivery

Small interfering RNA (siRNA) therapeutics have advanced from bench to clinical trials in recent years, along with new tools developed to enable detection of siRNA delivered at the organ, cell, and subcellular levels. Preclinical models of siRNA delivery have benefitted from methodologies such as stem-loop quantitative polymerase chain reaction, histological in situ immunofluorescent staining, endosomal escape assay, and RNA-induced silencing complex loading assay. These technologies have accelerated the detection and optimization of siRNA platforms to overcome the challenges associated with delivering therapeutic oligonucleotides to the cytosol of specific target cells. This review focuses on the methodologies and their application in the biodistribution of siRNA delivered by lipid nanoparticles.

The rough endoplasmatic reticulum is a central nucleation site of siRNA-mediated RNA silencing

Despite progress in mechanistic understanding of the RNA interference (RNAi) pathways, the subcellular sites of RNA silencing remain under debate. Here we show that loading of lipid-transfected siRNAs and endogenous microRNAs (miRNA) into RISC (RNA-induced silencing complexes), encounter of the target mRNA, and Ago2-mediated mRNA slicing in mammalian cells are nucleated at the rough endoplasmic reticulum (rER). Although the major RNAi pathway proteins are found in most subcellular compartments, the miRNA- and siRNA-loaded Ago2 populations co-sediment almost exclusively with the rER membranes, together with the RISC loading complex (RLC) factors Dicer, TAR RNA binding protein (TRBP) and protein activator of the interferon-induced protein kinase (PACT). Fractionation and membrane co-immune precipitations further confirm that siRNA-loaded Ago2 physically associates with the cytosolic side of the rER membrane. Additionally, RLC-associated double-stranded siRNA, diagnostic of RISC loading, and RISC-mediated mRNA cleavage products exclusively co-sediment with rER. Finally, we identify TRBP and PACT as key factors anchoring RISC to ER membranes in an RNA-independent manner. Together, our findings demonstrate that the outer rER membrane is a central nucleation site of siRNA-mediated RNA silencing.

Pharmacological Characterization of a Novel ENaCα siRNA (GSK2225745) With Potential for the Treatment of Cystic Fibrosis

Lung pathology in cystic fibrosis is linked to dehydration of the airways epithelial surface which in part results from inappropriately raised sodium reabsorption through the epithelial sodium channel (ENaC). To identify a small-interfering RNA (siRNA) which selectively inhibits ENaC expression, chemically modified 21-mer siRNAs targeting human ENaCα were designed and screened. GSK2225745, was identified as a potent inhibitor of ENaCα mRNA (EC₅₀ (half maximal effective concentration) = 0.4 nmol/l, maximum knockdown = 85%) and protein levels in A549 cells. Engagement of the RNA interference (RNAi) pathway was confirmed using 5′ RACE. Further profiling was carried out in therapeutically relevant human primary cells. In bronchial epithelial cells, GSK2225745 elicited potent suppression of ENaCα mRNA (EC₅₀ = 1.6 nmol/l, maximum knockdown = 82%). In human nasal epithelial cells, GSK2225745 also produced potent and long-lasting (≥72 hours) suppression of ENaCα mRNA levels which was associated with significant inhibition of ENaC function (69% inhibition of amiloride-sensitive current in cells treated with GSK2225745 at 10 nmol/l). GSK2225745 showed no evidence for potential to stimulate toll-like receptor (TLR)3, 7 or 8. In vivo, topical delivery of GSK2225745 in a lipid nanoparticle formulation to the airways of mice resulted in significant inhibition of the expression of ENaCα in the lungs. In conclusion, GSK2225745 is a potent inhibitor of ENaCα expression and warrants further evaluation as a potential novel inhaled therapeutic for cystic fibrosis.

From RNA interference technology to effective therapy: how far have we come and how far to go?

Over a decade has passed since the first description of RNAi in animals--the fundamental endogenous process by which small dsRNAs mediate sequence-specific gene silencing. This discovery has radically transformed our understanding of gene regulation and function and spawned a whole new biotechnology industry focused on developing RNAi-based therapeutic approaches to a variety of human diseases that have otherwise proved challenging to conventional therapies. While RNAi technologies hold great promise as a powerful medical tool, successful delivery of RNAi agents and effective measurement of their uptake are major challenges in translating RNAi therapies to the clinic. Exciting developments in the field have also been tempered by safety concerns surrounding the immunogenic potential of this gene silencing technology and the potential side effects associated with exploiting a crucial biological pathway for therapeutic benefit. This article examines the progress of RNAi therapeutics including advances in delivery and safety, and recent findings from several Phase I-III clinical trials. The emergence of a novel application of RNAi in enhancing the delivery of low-molecular weight drugs to neuronal tissues will also be presented to provide an outlook on the future of RNAi technologies.

Right- and left-loop short shRNAs have distinct and unusual mechanisms of gene silencing

Small hairpin RNAs (shRNAs) having duplex lengths of 25–29 bp are normally processed by Dicer into short interfering RNAs (siRNAs) before incorporation into the RNA-induced silencing complex (RISC). However, shRNAs of ≤19 bp [short shRNAs (sshRNAs)] are too short for Dicer to excise their loops, raising questions about their mechanism of action. sshRNAs are designated as L-type or R-type according to whether the loop is positioned 3′ or 5′ to the guide sequence, respectively. Using nucleotide modifications that inhibit RNA cleavage, we show that R- but not L-sshRNAs require loop cleavage for optimum activity. Passenger-arm slicing was found to be important for optimal functioning of L-sshRNAs but much less important for R-sshRNAs that have a cleavable loop. R-sshRNAs could be immunoprecipitated by antibodies to Argonaute-1 (Ago1); complexes with Ago1 contained both intact and loop-cleaved sshRNAs. In contrast, L-sshRNAs were immunoprecipitated with either Ago1 or Ago2 and were predominantly sliced in the passenger arm of the hairpin. However, ‘pre-sliced’ L-sshRNAs were inactive. We conclude that active L-sshRNAs depend on slicing of the passenger arm to facilitate opening of the duplex, whereas R-sshRNAs primarily act via loop cleavage to generate a 5′-phosphate at the 5′-end of the guide strand.

Nucleic acid delivery: the missing pieces of the puzzle?

The delivery of genes or RNA interference (RNAi) agents can increase or decrease the expression of virtually any protein in a cell, and this process opens the path for cures to most diseases that afflict humans. However, the high molecular weight, anionic nature, and instability of nucleic acids in the presence of enzymes pose major obstacles to their delivery and frustrates their use as human therapies. This Account describes current ideas about the mechanisms in nonviral nucleic acid delivery and how lipidic and polymeric carriers can overcome some of the critical barriers to delivery. Over the last 20 years, researchers have developed a multitude of polymeric and lipidic vectors, but only a small fraction of these have progressed into clinical trials. None of these vectors has received FDA approval, which indicates that the current vectors do not yet have suitable properties for effective in vivo nucleic acid delivery. Nucleic acid delivery is a multistep process and inefficiencies at any stage result in a dramatic decrease in gene delivery or gene silencing. However, the majority of studies investigating synthetic vectors focus solely on optimization of endosomal escape. A small number of studies address how to improve uptake via targeted delivery, and an even smaller fraction examine the intracellular fate of the delivery systems and nucleic acid cargo. The internalization of genes into the cell nucleus remains an inefficient and mysterious process. In the case of DNA delivery, strategies are needed to increase and accelerate the migration of DNA through the cytoplasm and transport it through the nuclear membrane. siRNA delivery involves fewer barriers. siRNA is more readily released from the carrier and more resistant to enzymatic degradation, and its target is in the cytoplasm; hence, siRNA delivery systems are becoming a clinical reality. With regard to siRNA therapy, the exact cytoplasmic location of RNA-induced silencing complex (RISC) formation and activity is unknown, which makes specific targeting of the RISC for more efficient delivery difficult. Furthermore, we would like to identify the factors that favor the binding of siRNA to Ago-2. If we could understand how the half-life of siRNA and Ago-2/siRNA complex in the cytoplasm can be modulated without interfering with RISC functions that are essential for normal cell activity, we could increase siRNA delivery efficiency. In this Account, we review the current synthetic vectors and propose alternative strategies in a few cases. We also suggest how certain cellular mechanisms might be exploited to improve gene transfection and silencing. Finally, we discuss whether some carriers that deliver the siRNA to cells could also repackage the siRNA into exosomes. The exosomes would then transport the siRNA into a subsequent population of cells that manifest the siRNA effect. This piggy-back mechanism may be responsible for reported deep tissue siRNA effects using certain carriers.

Delivery and biodistribution of siRNA for cancer therapy: challenges and future prospects

RNAi-based approaches provide a promising therapeutic modality for the treatment of cancer. The inaccessibility of tumors in different cancer types necessitates the development of safe, specific and efficient systemic delivery systems to meet therapeutic need. The translation of siRNA-based cancer therapeutics to the clinic is hindered by several challenges associated with the cargo (siRNA) and the delivery system, including susceptibility to nucleases; insufficient circulation half-life due to phagocytosis by the reticuloendothelial system, transient and poor biodistribution in the tumor tissue; cellular uptake; inability to escape endosomes and release into the cytosolic compartment for an RNAi-mediated effect; microRNA-like unintended off-target effects; undesirable immune stimulation; and carrier-related toxicity. This review provides an overview of the pharmacokinetic and biodistribution challenges witnessed in the delivery of siRNA when administered systemically. It also describes the current delivery approaches using liposome-, polymer- and peptide-based delivery systems shown to elicit significant gene silencing and tumor growth regression in proof-of-concept studies. As part of future perspectives, delivery agents that showed significant efficacy in preclinical rodent models and clinical trials are also reviewed.

mRNA knockdown by single strand RNA is improved by chemical modifications

While RNAi has traditionally relied on RNA duplexes, early evaluation of siRNAs demonstrated activity of the guide strand in the absence of the passenger strand. However, these single strands lacked the activity of duplex RNAs. Here, we report the systematic use of chemical modifications to optimize single-strand RNA (ssRNA)-mediated mRNA knockdown. We identify that 2′F ribose modifications coupled with 5′-end phosphorylation vastly improves ssRNA activity both in vitro and in vivo. The impact of specific chemical modifications on ssRNA activity implies an Ago-mediated mechanism but the hallmark mRNA cleavage sites were not observed which suggests ssRNA may operate through a mechanism beyond conventional Ago2 slicer activity. While currently less potent than duplex siRNAs, with additional chemical optimization and alternative routes of delivery, chemically modified ssRNAs could represent a powerful RNAi platform.

RNA-induced silencing complex-bound small interfering RNA is a determinant of RNA interference-mediated gene silencing in mice

Deeper knowledge of pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamic (PK/PD) concepts for RNA therapeutics is important to streamline the drug development process and for rigorous selection of best performing drug candidates. Here we characterized the PK/PD relationship for small interfering RNAs (siRNAs) targeting luciferase by examining siRNA concentration in plasma and liver, the temporal RNA-induced silencing complex binding profiles, mRNA reduction, and protein inhibition measured by noninvasive bioluminescent imaging. A dose-dependent and time-related decrease in bioluminescence was detected over 25 days after a single treatment of a lipid nanoparticle-formulated siRNA targeting luciferase messenger RNA. A direct relationship was observed between the degree of in vivo mRNA and protein reduction and the Argonaute2 (Ago2)-bound siRNA fraction but not with the total amount of siRNA found in the liver, suggesting that the Ago2-siRNA complex is the key determinant of target inhibition. These observations were confirmed for an additional siRNA that targets endogenously expressed Sjögren syndrome antigen B (Ssb) mRNA, indicating that our observations are not limited to a transgenic mouse system. Our data provide detailed information of the temporal regulation of siRNA liver delivery, Ago2 loading, mRNA reduction, and protein inhibition that are essential for the rapid and cost-effective clinical development of siRNAs therapeutics.