The mecillinam resistome reveals a role for peptidoglycan endopeptidases in stimulating cell wall synthesis in Escherichia coli

Microbial Experimental Evolution - a proving ground for evolutionary theory and a tool for discovery

Microbial experimental evolution uses controlled laboratory populations to study the mechanisms of evolution. The molecular analysis of evolved populations enables empirical tests that can confirm the predictions of evolutionary theory, but can also lead to surprising discoveries. As with other fields in the life sciences, microbial experimental evolution has become a tool, deployed as part of the suite of techniques available to the molecular biologist. Here, I provide a review of the general findings of microbial experimental evolution, especially those relevant to molecular microbiologists that are new to the field. I also relate these results to design considerations for an evolution experiment and suggest future directions for those working at the intersection of experimental evolution and molecular biology.

Simultaneously inhibiting undecaprenyl phosphate production and peptidoglycan synthases promotes rapid lysis in Escherichia coli

Peptidoglycan (PG) is a highly cross-linked polysaccharide that encases bacteria, resists the effects of turgor and confers cell shape. PG precursors are translocated across the cytoplasmic membrane by the lipid carrier undecaprenyl phosphate (Und-P) where they are incorporated into the PG superstructure. Previously, we found that one of our Escherichia coli laboratory strains (CS109) harbors a missense mutation in uppS, which encodes an enzymatically defective Und-P(P) synthase. Here, we show that CS109 cells lacking the bifunctional aPBP PBP1B (penicillin binding protein 1B) lyse during exponential growth at elevated temperature. PBP1B lysis was reversed by: (i) reintroducing wild-type uppS, (ii) increasing the availability of PG precursors or (iii) overproducing PBP1A, a related bifunctional PG synthase. In addition, inhibiting the catalytic activity of PBP2 or PBP3, two monofunctional bPBPs, caused CS109 cells to lyse. Limiting the precursors required for Und-P synthesis in MG1655, which harbors a wild-type allele of uppS, also promoted lysis in mutants lacking PBP1B or bPBP activity. Thus, simultaneous inhibition of Und-P production and PG synthases provokes a synergistic response that leads to cell lysis. These findings suggest a biological connection that could be exploited in combination therapies.

Bacillus subtilis cell diameter is determined by the opposing actions of two distinct cell wall synthetic systems

Rod-shaped bacteria grow by adding material into their cell wall via the action of two spatially distinct enzymatic systems: the Rod complex moves around the cell circumference, whereas class A penicillin-binding proteins (aPBPs) do not. To understand how the combined action of these two systems defines bacterial dimensions, we examined how each affects the growth and width of Bacillus subtilis as well as the mechanical anisotropy and orientation of material within their sacculi. Rod width is not determined by MreB, rather it depends on the balance between the systems: the Rod complex reduces diameter, whereas aPBPs increase it. Increased Rod-complex activity correlates with an increased density of directional MreB filaments and a greater fraction of directional PBP2a enzymes. This increased circumferential synthesis increases the relative quantity of oriented material within the sacculi, making them more resistant to stretching across their width, thereby reinforcing rod shape. Together, these experiments explain how the combined action of the two main cell wall synthetic systems builds and maintains rods of different widths. Escherichia coli Rod mutants also show the same correlation between width and directional MreB filament density, suggesting this model may be generalizable to bacteria that elongate via the Rod complex.

Plasticity of Escherichia coli cell wall metabolism promotes fitness and antibiotic resistance across environmental conditions

Although the peptidoglycan cell wall is an essential structural and morphological feature of most bacterial cells, the extracytoplasmic enzymes involved in its synthesis are frequently dispensable under standard culture conditions. By modulating a single growth parameter-extracellular pH-we discovered a subset of these so-called 'redundant' enzymes in Escherichia coli are required for maximal fitness across pH environments. Among these pH specialists are the class A penicillin binding proteins PBP1a and PBP1b; defects in these enzymes attenuate growth in alkaline and acidic conditions, respectively. Genetic, biochemical, and cytological studies demonstrate that synthase activity is required for cell wall integrity across a wide pH range and influences pH-dependent changes in resistance to cell wall active antibiotics. Altogether, our findings reveal previously thought to be redundant enzymes are instead specialized for distinct environmental niches. This specialization may ensure robust growth and cell wall integrity in a wide range of conditions.

Editorial note

This article has been through an editorial process in which the authors decide how to respond to the issues raised during peer review. The Reviewing Editor's assessment is that all the issues have been addressed (see decision letter).

In Vitro Activity of Tebipenem (SPR859) against Penicillin-Binding Proteins of Gram-Negative and Gram-Positive Bacteria

Tebipenem (SPR859) is the microbiologically active form of SPR994 (tebipenem-pivoxil), an orally available carbapenem with activity against extended-spectrum β-lactamase (ESBL)-producing Enterobacteriaceae Measurement of the relative binding of SPR859 to the bacterial cell targets revealed that it is a potent inhibitor of multiple penicillin-binding proteins (PBPs) but primarily a Gram-negative PBP 2 inhibitor, similar to other compounds in this class. These data support further clinical development of SPR994.

Endopeptidase Regulation as a Novel Function of the Zur-Dependent Zinc Starvation Response

Bacteria encode a variety of adaptations that enable them to survive during zinc starvation, a condition which is encountered both in natural environments and inside the human host. In Vibrio cholerae, the causative agent of the diarrheal disease cholera, we have identified a novel member of this zinc starvation response, a cell wall hydrolase that retains function and is conditionally essential for cell growth in low-zinc environments. Other Gram-negative bacteria contain homologs that appear to be under similar regulatory control. These findings are significant because they represent, to our knowledge, the first evidence that zinc homeostasis influences cell wall turnover. Anti-infective therapies commonly target the bacterial cell wall; therefore, an improved understanding of how the cell wall adapts to host-induced zinc starvation could lead to new antibiotic development. Such therapeutic interventions are required to combat the rising threat of drug-resistant infections.

The cell wall is a strong, yet flexible, meshwork of peptidoglycan (PG) that gives a bacterium structural integrity. To accommodate a growing cell, the wall is remodeled by both PG synthesis and degradation. Vibrio cholerae encodes a group of three nearly identical zinc-dependent endopeptidases (EPs) that are predicted to hydrolyze PG to facilitate cell growth. Two of these (ShyA and ShyC) are conditionally essential housekeeping EPs, while the third (ShyB) is not expressed under standard laboratory conditions. To investigate the role of ShyB, we conducted a transposon screen to identify mutations that activate shyB transcription. We found that shyB is induced as part of the Zur-mediated zinc starvation response, a mode of regulation not previously reported for cell wall lytic enzymes. In vivo, ShyB alone was sufficient to sustain cell growth in low-zinc environments. In vitro, ShyB retained its d,d-endopeptidase activity against purified sacculi in the presence of the metal chelator EDTA at concentrations that inhibit ShyA and ShyC. This insensitivity to metal chelation is likely what enables ShyB to substitute for other EPs during zinc starvation. Our survey of transcriptomic data from diverse bacteria identified other candidate Zur-regulated EPs, suggesting that this adaptation to zinc starvation is employed by other Gram-negative bacteria.

Peptidoglycan

The peptidoglycan sacculus is a net-like polymer that surrounds the cytoplasmic membrane in most bacteria. It is essential to maintain the bacterial cell shape and protect from turgor. The peptidoglycan has a basic composition, common to all bacteria, with species-specific variations that can modify its biophysical properties or the pathogenicity of the bacteria. The synthesis of peptidoglycan starts in the cytoplasm and the precursor lipid II is flipped across the cytoplasmic membrane. The new peptidoglycan strands are synthesised and incorporated into the pre-existing sacculus by the coordinated activities of peptidoglycan synthases and hydrolases. In the model organism Escherichia coli there are two complexes required for the elongation and division. Each of them is regulated by different proteins from both the cytoplasmic and periplasmic sides that ensure the well-coordinated synthesis of new peptidoglycan.

Pathway-Directed Screen for Inhibitors of the Bacterial Cell Elongation Machinery

New antibiotics are needed to combat the growing problem of resistant bacterial infections. An attractive avenue toward the discovery of such next-generation therapies is to identify novel inhibitors of clinically validated targets, like cell wall biogenesis. We have therefore developed a pathway-directed whole-cell screen for small molecules that block the activity of the Rod system of Escherichia coli This conserved multiprotein complex is required for cell elongation and the morphogenesis of rod-shaped bacteria. It is composed of cell wall synthases and membrane proteins of unknown function that are organized by filaments of the actin-like MreB protein. Our screen takes advantage of the conditional essentiality of the Rod system and the ability of the beta-lactam mecillinam (also known as amdinocillin) to cause a toxic malfunctioning of the machinery. Rod system inhibitors can therefore be identified as molecules that promote growth in the presence of mecillinam under conditions permissive for the growth of Rod^- cells. A screen of ∼690,000 compounds identified 1,300 compounds that were active against E. coli Pathway-directed screening of a majority of this subset of compounds for Rod inhibitors successfully identified eight analogs of the MreB antagonist A22. Further characterization of the A22 analogs identified showed that their antibiotic activity under conditions where the Rod system is essential was strongly correlated with their ability to suppress mecillinam toxicity. This result combined with those from additional biological studies reinforce the notion that A22-like molecules are relatively specific for MreB and suggest that the lipoprotein transport factor LolA is unlikely to be a physiologically relevant target as previously proposed.

A Proteolytic Complex Targets Multiple Cell Wall Hydrolases in Pseudomonas aeruginosa

Carboxy-terminal processing proteases (CTPs) occur in all three domains of life. In bacteria, some of them have been associated with virulence. However, the precise roles of bacterial CTPs are poorly understood, and few direct proteolytic substrates have been identified. One bacterial CTP is the CtpA protease of Pseudomonas aeruginosa, which is required for type III secretion system (T3SS) function and for virulence in a mouse model of acute pneumonia. Here, we have investigated the function of CtpA in P. aeruginosa and identified some of the proteins it cleaves. We discovered that CtpA forms a complex with a previously uncharacterized protein, which we have named LbcA (lipoprotein binding partner of CtpA). LbcA is required for CtpA activity in vivo and promotes its activity in vitro. We have also identified four proteolytic substrates of CtpA, all of which are uncharacterized proteins predicted to cleave the peptide cross-links within peptidoglycan. Consistent with this, a ctpA null mutant was found to have fewer peptidoglycan cross-links than the wild type and grew slowly in salt-free medium. Intriguingly, the accumulation of just one of the CtpA substrates was required for some ΔctpA mutant phenotypes, including the defective T3SS. We propose that LbcA-CtpA is a proteolytic complex in the P. aeruginosa cell envelope, which controls the activity of several peptidoglycan cross-link hydrolases by degrading them. Furthermore, based on these and other findings, we suggest that many bacterial CTPs might be similarly controlled by partner proteins as part of a widespread mechanism to control peptidoglycan hydrolase activity.

Bacterial carboxy-terminal processing proteases (CTPs) are widely conserved and have been associated with the virulence of several species. However, their roles are poorly understood, and few direct substrates have been identified in any species. Pseudomonas aeruginosa is an important human pathogen in which one CTP, known as CtpA, is required for type III secretion system function and for virulence. This work provides an important advance by showing that CtpA works with a previously uncharacterized binding partner to degrade four substrates. These substrates are all predicted to hydrolyze peptidoglycan cross-links, suggesting that the CtpA complex is an important control mechanism for peptidoglycan hydrolysis. This is likely to emerge as a widespread mechanism used by diverse bacteria to control some of their peptidoglycan hydrolases. This is significant, given the links between CTPs and virulence in several pathogens and the importance of peptidoglycan remodeling to almost all bacterial cells.

Distinct domains of Escherichia coli IgaA connect envelope stress sensing and down-regulation of the Rcs phosphorelay across subcellular compartments

In enterobacteria, the Rcs system (Regulator of capsule synthesis) monitors envelope integrity and induces a stress response when damages occur in the outer membrane or in the peptidoglycan layer. Built around a two-component system, Rcs controls gene expression via a cascade of phosphoryl transfer reactions. Being particularly complex, Rcs also involves the outer membrane lipoprotein RcsF and the inner membrane essential protein IgaA (Intracellular growth attenuator). RcsF and IgaA, which are located upstream of the phosphorelay, are required for normal Rcs functioning. Here, we establish the stress-dependent formation of a complex between RcsF and the periplasmic domain of IgaA as the molecular signal triggering Rcs. Moreover, molecular dissection of IgaA reveals that its negative regulatory role on Rcs is mostly carried by its first N-terminal cytoplasmic domain. Altogether, our results support a model in which IgaA regulates Rcs activation by playing a direct role in the transfer of signals from the cell envelope to the cytoplasm. This remarkable feature further distinguishes Rcs from other envelope stress response systems.

A thorough understanding of the mechanisms that allow bacteria to thrive in various environments is crucial to the development of new antibiotics, an urgent endeavor to combat antimicrobial resistance. A landmark feature of Gram-negative bacteria is the presence of a multi-layered envelope. Because this structure is essential, its integrity is constantly monitored to detect and respond to potential breaches in a fast and adequate manner. Here, we describe how IgaA, an essential protein present in the cytoplasmic membrane of enterobacteria, participates in the transfer of stress signals from the envelope to the cytoplasm. We provide evidence that IgaA works in concert with RcsF, a lipoprotein that is posted as a sentinel in the outermost envelope layer, to detect envelope stress: under stress conditions, RcsF forms a complex with the C-terminal, periplasmic domain of IgaA. As a result, cells turn on the Rcs response. We also discovered that the N-terminal, cytoplasmic domain of IgaA plays an important role in inhibiting Rcs in the absence of stress. Together, these findings reveal that distinct IgaA domains coordinate stress sensing and Rcs activation across the cytoplasmic membrane. They enhance our understanding of Rcs regulation and open new avenues for the development of new antibacterials.

A global regulatory system links virulence and antibiotic resistance to envelope homeostasis in Acinetobacter baumannii

The nosocomial pathogen Acinetobacter baumannii is a significant threat due to its ability to cause infections refractory to a broad range of antibiotic treatments. We show here that a highly conserved sensory-transduction system, BfmRS, mediates the coordinate development of both enhanced virulence and resistance in this microorganism. Hyperactive alleles of BfmRS conferred increased protection from serum complement killing and allowed lethal systemic disease in mice. BfmRS also augmented resistance and tolerance against an expansive set of antibiotics, including dramatic protection from β-lactam toxicity. Through transcriptome profiling, we showed that BfmRS governs these phenotypes through global transcriptional regulation of a post-exponential-phase-like program of gene expression, a key feature of which is modulation of envelope biogenesis and defense pathways. BfmRS activity defended against cell-wall lesions through both β-lactamase-dependent and -independent mechanisms, with the latter being connected to control of lytic transglycosylase production and proper coordination of morphogenesis and division. In addition, hypersensitivity of bfmRS knockouts could be suppressed by unlinked mutations restoring a short, rod cell morphology, indicating that regulation of drug resistance, pathogenicity, and envelope morphogenesis are intimately linked by this central regulatory system in A. baumannii. This work demonstrates that BfmRS controls a global regulatory network coupling cellular physiology to the ability to cause invasive, drug-resistant infections.

Infections with the hospital-acquired bacterium Acinetobacter baumannii are highly difficult to treat. The pathogen has evolved multiple lines of defense against antimicrobial stress, including a barrier-forming cell envelope as well as control systems that respond to antimicrobial stresses by enhancing antibiotic resistance and virulence. Here, we uncovered the role of a key stress-response system, BfmRS, in controlling the transition of A. baumannii to a state of heightened resistance and virulence. We show that BfmRS enhances pathogenicity in mammalian hosts, and augments the ability to grow in the presence of diverse antibiotics and tolerate transient, high-level antibiotic exposures. Connected to these effects is the ability of BfmRS to globally reprogram gene expression and control multiple pathways that build, protect, and shape the cell envelope. Moreover, we determined that resistance-enhancing mutations bypassing the need for BfmRS also modulate envelope- and morphology-associated pathways, further linking control of physiology with resistance in A. baumannii. This work uncovers a global control circuit that shifts cellular physiology in ways that promote hospital-associated disease, and points to inhibition of this circuit as a potential strategy for disarming the pathogen.

Conserved mechanism of cell-wall synthase regulation revealed by the identification of a new PBP activator in Pseudomonas aeruginosa

Penicillin-binding proteins (PBPs) are synthases required to build the essential peptidoglycan (PG) cell wall surrounding most bacterial cells. The mechanisms regulating the activity of these enzymes to control PG synthesis remain surprisingly poorly defined given their status as key antibiotic targets. Several years ago, the outer-membrane lipoprotein ^EcLpoB was identified as a critical activator of Escherichia coli PBP1b (^EcPBP1b), one of the major PG synthases of this organism. Activation of ^EcPBP1b is mediated through the association of ^EcLpoB with a regulatory domain on ^EcPBP1b called UB2H. Notably, Pseudomonas aeruginosa also encodes PBP1b (^PaPBP1b), which possesses a UB2H domain, but this bacterium lacks an identifiable LpoB homolog. We therefore searched for potential ^PaPBP1b activators and identified a lipoprotein unrelated to LpoB that is required for the in vivo activity of ^PaPBP1b. We named this protein LpoP and found that it interacts directly with ^PaPBP1b in vitro and is conserved in many Gram-negative species. Importantly, we also demonstrated that ^PaLpoP-^PaPBP1b as well as an equivalent protein pair from Acinetobacter baylyi can fully substitute for ^EcLpoB-^EcPBP1b in E. coli for PG synthesis. Furthermore, we show that amino acid changes in ^PaPBP1b that bypass the ^PaLpoP requirement map to similar locations in the protein as changes promoting ^EcLpoB bypass in ^EcPBP1b. Overall, our results indicate that, although different Gram-negative bacteria activate their PBP1b synthases with distinct lipoproteins, they stimulate the activity of these important drug targets using a conserved mechanism.

Recent advances in understanding how rod-like bacteria stably maintain their cell shapes

Cell shape and cell volume are important for many bacterial functions. In recent years, we have seen a range of experimental and theoretical work that led to a better understanding of the determinants of cell shape and size. The roles of different molecular machineries for cell-wall expansion have been detailed and partially redefined, mechanical forces have been shown to influence cell shape, and new connections between metabolism and cell shape have been proposed. Yet the fundamental determinants of the different cellular dimensions remain to be identified. Here, we highlight some of the recent developments and focus on the determinants of rod-like cell shape and size in the well-studied model organisms Escherichia coli and Bacillus subtilis.

Don't let sleeping dogmas lie: new views of peptidoglycan synthesis and its regulation

Bacterial cell wall synthesis is the target for some of our most powerful antibiotics and has thus been the subject of intense research focus for more than 50 years. Surprisingly, we still lack a fundamental understanding of how bacteria build, maintain and expand their cell wall. Due to technical limitations, directly testing hypotheses about the coordination and biochemistry of cell wall synthesis enzymes or architecture has been challenging, and interpretation of data has therefore often relied on circumstantial evidence and implicit assumptions. A number of recent papers have exploited new technologies, like single molecule tracking and real-time, high resolution temporal mapping of cell wall synthesis processes, to address fundamental questions of bacterial cell wall biogenesis. The results have challenged established dogmas and it is therefore timely to integrate new data and old observations into a new model of cell wall biogenesis in rod-shaped bacteria.