Non-human primates used in studies of periodontal disease pathogenesis: a review of the literature

Pre-clinical models for oral and periodontal reconstructive therapies

The development of new medical formulations (NMF) for reconstructive therapies has considerably improved the available treatment options for individuals requiring periodontal repair or oral implant rehabilitation. Progress in tissue engineering and regenerative medicine modalities strongly depends on validated pre-clinical research. Pre-clinical testing has contributed to the recent approval of NMF such as GEM 21S and INFUSE bone grafts for periodontal and oral regenerative therapies. However, the selection of a suitable pre-clinical model for evaluation of the safety and efficacy of a NMF remains a challenge. This review is designed to serve as a primer to choose the appropriate pre-clinical models for the evaluation of NMF in situations requiring periodontal or oral reconstruction. Here, we summarize commonly used pre-clinical models and provide examples of screening and functional studies of NMF that can be translated into clinical use.

Periodontitis in pregnancy: clinical and serum antibody observations from a baboon model of ligature-induced disease

BACKGROUND

Chronic oral infections that elicit host responses leading to periodontal disease are linked with various sequelae of systemic diseases. This report provides seminal information on the clinical and adaptive immunologic characteristics of a baboon model of ligature-induced periodontitis during pregnancy.

METHODS

Female Papio anubis were evaluated for periodontal health at baseline. Ligatures were tied around selected teeth to initiate oral inflammation and periodontitis. Then the animals were bred. At midpregnancy ( approximately 90 days), a clinical evaluation was performed, and additional ligatures were tied on teeth in the contralateral quadrants to maintain progressing periodontitis throughout pregnancy. A final clinical evaluation was done for all experimental teeth after delivery, and ligatures were removed. Serum was collected at all sampling intervals for the determination of antibody levels to a group of 20 oral bacteria. Unligated animals served as controls.

RESULTS

At baseline, 16% of animals exhibited minimal plaque and gingival inflammation without periodontal disease. The remaining baboons demonstrated varying levels of inflammation/bleeding, and approximately 20% of the population had periodontal pocketing (>3 mm). Ligated animals expressed increased levels of inflammation and increased probing depths and clinical attachment loss (AL) and could be stratified into multiple subsets postligation based upon changes in clinical parameters at midpregnancy and at delivery. Baboons were categorized into disease susceptibility groups (periodontal disease susceptibility 1 through 4) that described the extent/severity of induced disease during pregnancy. Control animals showed minimal periodontal changes during gestation. Significant differences in serum antibody to multiple oral bacteria were found in animals presenting with periodontitis at baseline and during the 6 months of ligature-induced disease. A significant correlation to antibody to P. gingivalis, which was sustained throughout ligation and pregnancy, was observed with disease presentation.

CONCLUSIONS

The clinical presentation at baseline, reflecting the natural history of oral disease in these animals, suggests individual variation that is reflected in the characteristics of the adaptive immune responses to oral bacteria. The variability in the response to ligation with resulting periodontal disease provides a model to document prospectively the relationship between oral and systemic health outcomes.

Effects of caloric restriction on inflammatory periodontal disease

OBJECTIVE

Dietary caloric restriction (CR) has been found to reduce systemic markers of inflammation and may attenuate the effects of chronic inflammatory conditions. The purpose of this study was to examine the effects of long-term CR on naturally occurring chronic inflammatory periodontal disease in a nonhuman primate model.

METHODS

The effects of long-term CR on extent and severity of naturally occurring chronic periodontal disease, local inflammatory and immune responses, and periodontal microbiology, were evaluated in a cohort of 81 (35 female and 46 male; 13-40 y of age) rhesus monkeys (Macaca mulatta) with no previous exposure to routine oral hygiene. CR monkeys had been subjected to 30% CR for 13-17 y relative to control-fed (CON) animals starting at 3-5 y of age.

RESULTS

Same sex CR and CON monkeys exhibited similar levels of plaque, calculus, and bleeding on probing. Among CON animals, males showed significantly greater periodontal breakdown, as reflected by higher mean clinical attachment level and periodontal probing depth scores, than females. CR males exhibited significantly less periodontal pocketing, lower IgG antibody response, and lower IL-8 and ss-glucuronidase levels compared to CON males, whereas CR females showed a lower IgG antibody response but comparable clinical parameters and inflammatory marker levels relative to CON females. Long-term CR had no demonstrable effect on the periodontal microbiota.

CONCLUSION

Males demonstrated greater risk for naturally occurring periodontal disease than females. Long-term CR may differentially reduce the production of local inflammatory mediators and risk for inflammatory periodontal disease among males but not females.

Differential gender effects of a reduced-calorie diet on systemic inflammatory and immune parameters in nonhuman primates

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

Dietary manipulation, including caloric restriction, has been shown to impact host response capabilities significantly, particularly in association with aging. This investigation compared systemic inflammatory and immune-response molecules in rhesus monkeys (Macaca mulatta).

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Monkeys on continuous long-term calorie-restricted diets and a matched group of animals on a control ad libitum diet, were examined for systemic response profiles including the effects of both gender and aging.

RESULTS

The results demonstrated that haptoglobin and alpha1-antiglycoprotein levels were elevated in the serum of male monkeys. Serum IgG responses to Campylobacter rectus, Actinobacillus actinomycetemcomitans and Porphyromonas gingivalis were significantly elevated in female monkeys. While only the antibody to Fusobacterium nucleatum was significantly affected by the calorie-restricted diet in female monkeys, antibody levels to Prevotella intermedia, C. rectus and Treponema denticola demonstrated a similar trend.

CONCLUSION

In this investigation, only certain serum antibody levels were influenced by the age of male animals, which was seemingly related to increasing clinical disease in this gender. More generally, analytes were modulated by gender and/or diet in this oral model system of mucosal microbial challenge.

Macaque models of human infectious disease

Macaques have served as models for more than 70 human infectious diseases of diverse etiologies, including a multitude of agents—bacteria, viruses, fungi, parasites, prions. The remarkable diversity of human infectious diseases that have been modeled in the macaque includes global, childhood, and tropical diseases as well as newly emergent, sexually transmitted, oncogenic, degenerative neurologic, potential bioterrorism, and miscellaneous other diseases. Historically, macaques played a major role in establishing the etiology of yellow fever, polio, and prion diseases. With rare exceptions (Chagas disease, bartonellosis), all of the infectious diseases in this review are of Old World origin. Perhaps most surprising is the large number of tropical (16), newly emergent (7), and bioterrorism diseases (9) that have been modeled in macaques. Many of these human diseases (e.g., AIDS, hepatitis E, bartonellosis) are a consequence of zoonotic infection. However, infectious agents of certain diseases, including measles and tuberculosis, can sometimes go both ways, and thus several human pathogens are threats to nonhuman primates including macaques. Through experimental studies in macaques, researchers have gained insight into pathogenic mechanisms and novel treatment and vaccine approaches for many human infectious diseases, most notably acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS), which is caused by infection with human immunodeficiency virus (HIV). Other infectious agents for which macaques have been a uniquely valuable resource for biomedical research, and particularly vaccinology, include influenza virus, paramyxoviruses, flaviviruses, arenaviruses, hepatitis E virus, papillomavirus, smallpox virus, Mycobacteria, Bacillus anthracis, Helicobacter pylori, Yersinia pestis, and Plasmodium species. This review summarizes the extensive past and present research on macaque models of human infectious disease.

Effects of age and oral disease on systemic inflammatory and immune parameters in nonhuman primates

This report evaluated systemic inflammatory and immune biomarkers in a cohort of Macaca mulatta (rhesus monkeys) maintained as a large family social unit, including an age range from <1 year to >24 years. We hypothesized that the systemic host responses would be affected by the age, gender, and clinical oral presentation of the population, each contributing to inflammatory and immune responses that would reflect chronic oral infections. The results demonstrated that the prevalence and severity of periodontitis, including missing teeth, increased significantly with age. Generally, minimal differences in clinical parameters were noted between the genders. Systemic inflammatory mediators, including acute-phase reactants, prostaglandin E(2) (PGE(2)), cytokines/chemokines, and selected matrix metalloproteinases (MMP), demonstrated significant differences among the various age groups of animals. Levels of many of these were increased with age, although PGE(2), RANTES, bactericidal permeability-inducing factor (BPI), MMP-1, and MMP-9 levels were significantly increased in the young group ( approximately 1 to 3 years old) relative to those for the older animals. We observed that in the adult and aged animals, levels of the systemic inflammatory mediators related to gingival inflammation and periodontal tissue destruction were significantly elevated. Serum antibody levels in response to a battery of periodontal pathogens were generally lower in the young animals, <50% of those in the adults, and were significantly related to aging in the cohort. The levels of antibodies, particularly those to Porphorymonas gingivalis, Fusobacterium nucleatum, and Tannerella forsythia, were most significantly elevated in animals with periodontal disease, irrespective of the age of the animal. These results provide a broad description of oral health and host responses in a large cohort of nonhuman primates from very young animals to the aged of this species. The findings afford a base of data with which to examine the ontogeny of host responses at mucosal sites, such as the gingival tissues.

Periodontitis in humans and non-human primates: oral-systemic linkage inducing acute phase proteins

BACKGROUND

The acute phase response (APR) represents a systemic counterpart to the localized inflammatory response. This report describes patient-oriented and non-human primate model studies to determine the effect of periodontal disease on systemic acute phase proteins (APP).

METHODS

Patient-oriented studies included comparison of the levels of APP, using enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA), with the presence and severity of periodontitis in localized chronic periodontitis (LCP), generalized aggressive periodontitis (GAP), and Sjogren's syndrome (SS) patients. The non-human primate experiments evaluated the serum level of APPs under natural conditions, following mechanical hygiene, experimental gingivitis, and during ligature-induced periodontitis.

RESULTS

Analysis of the LCP population showed what appeared to be a threshold of periodontal disease severity required for elevating the C-reactive protein (CRP) and haptoglobin (HG). The results demonstrated a significant elevation in CRP in the GAP versus the control groups, as well as lower levels of all mediators in healthy non-smokers (HNS) versus smokers (HS), suggesting that these systemic inflammatory markers were altered in response to challenge by noxious materials from smoking. Significantly different levels of CRP, HG, and alpha1-antiproteinase were noted in the SS patients suggesting that the autoimmune aspects of Sjögren's syndrome may impact upon oral health and systemic responses. Parallel evidence was also obtained from the primate studies. Providing mechanical oral hygiene, which significantly lowered clinical inflammation and bleeding of the gingiva, decreased the serum APP levels. Both CRP and fibrinogen were significantly elevated during progressing periodontitis, which also appeared to have an impact on serum lipids and lipoproteins.

CONCLUSIONS

These findings supported results relating chronic oral infections and the inflammation of periodontitis as contributors to and/or triggers for systemic inflammatory responses. Finally, similarities in the clinical and microbiological parameters of gingival inflammation and periodontitis between humans and non-human primates was extended to identification of changes in serum APP in the non-human primates that appeared to be in direct response to the induction of progressing periodontitis. These systemic changes provide additional evidence for the biological plausibility of periodontal infections contributing to various systemic diseases.

Developing animal models for polymicrobial diseases

Although polymicrobial diseases are not a new concept for microbiologists, they are experiencing a resurgence of interest owing to the development of suitable animal models and new molecular techniques that allow these diseases to be studied effectively. This broad review provides an excellent introduction to this fascinating topic.

Examples are included of each type of polymicrobial disease and the animal models that are used to study these diseases are discussed. In many instances, schematics for the animal model are presented.

Viral co-infections including bovine viral diarrhoeal viruses, porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome, mixed hepatitis virus infections and HIV co-infection with hepatitis virus are discussed, together with attempts to model these diseases in animals.

Viral and bacterial co-infections are reviewed with a special focus on otitis media and the rodent models that have been used to probe this important childhood illness.

Of the polybacterial diseases, periodontitis is one of the best understood and a clinically relevant rodent model is now available. This model, and the role of biofilm formation in periodontitis are examined.

Fungal infections of humans are often referred to as 'opportunistic' but in fact these infections are often fungal co-infections with viruses such as HIV and fungal mixed co-infections. The roles of these infections in disease and the rodent models used to study them are discussed.

Parasite co-infections are thought to have a role in the severity of malaria and the severity of Lyme arthritis. These diseases and attempts to model them are evaluated.

Finally, co-infections that are associated with virus-induced immunosuppression are discussed, together with their animal models.

Polymicrobial diseases involve two or more microorganisms that act synergistically, or in succession, to mediate complex disease processes. Although polymicrobial diseases in animals and humans can be caused by similar organisms, these diseases are often also caused by organisms from different kingdoms, genera, species, strains, substrains and even by phenotypic variants of a single species. Animal models are often required to understand the mechanisms of pathogenesis, and to develop therapies and prevention regimes. However, reproducing polymicrobial diseases of humans in animal hosts presents significant challenges.

Estrogen Suppression Induces Papillary Gingival Overgrowth in Pregnant Baboons

BACKGROUND

Alterations in sex steroids during pregnancy are associated with the development and exacerbation of reactive lesions involving the gingiva. Currently, few experimental animal models similar to humans are available to examine regulatory pathways involving sex steroids and the periodontium.

METHODS

In the present study, we used the baboon as a novel experimental model for the study of the regulatory actions of estrogen on the periodontium during pregnancy. Pregnant baboons (N = 5) were administered the potent, highly specific aromatase inhibitor CGS 20267 (2 mg/day subcutaneously) daily on days 60 through 165 of gestation (term = 184). Untreated females (N = 10) and females (5) concomitantly administered aromatase inhibitor and estradiol benzoate (2.0 mg/day each subcutaneously) served as controls. Gingival biopsies were taken between days 145 and 165 of gestation.

RESULTS

Administration of CGS 20267 in all females suppressed maternal serum concentrations of estradiol by 95% and induced the development of an exuberant papillomatous enlargement of the gingiva by gestational day 110, with the most prominent development involving the labial aspects of the anterior sextants. None of the untreated pregnant controls or females concomitantly administered aromatase inhibitor and estradiol benzoate developed gingival overgrowth. Thus, estradiol alone prevented the onset of gingival overgrowth induced by estrogen suppression. In all baboons, discontinuation of the aromatase inhibitor at time of cesarean section resulted in spontaneous regression and resolution of the papillomatous hyperplasia within 4 to 6 weeks. Clinically, the gingival papillary overgrowth was erythematous and edematous, with a propensity toward spontaneous subgingival hemorrhage. Histologically, the biopsy specimens demonstrated hyperplasia of the epithelium typified by mild hyperkeratosis, acanthosis, and elongation and isolated anastamoses of rete ridges. Subjacent to the intact epithelium was a loose connective tissue stroma with isolated areas of inflammatory cell infiltrate. Special stains verified the presence of isolated bacterial biofilms; however, no evidence of fungal filaments was present. Histological features suggestive of viral infection were notably absent in the epithelium. No evidence of viral particles or capsids was identified using transmission electron microscopy. Reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction analysis, using a panel of degenerate primers, was negative for papilloma family viruses.

CONCLUSIONS

These results are consistent with a significant role for estrogen during primate pregnancy in the regulation of cellular proliferation and differentiation within the gingiva. The baboon represents an important experimental model for studying the regulatory actions of estrogen on the periodontium during pregnancy.

Defect-determined regenerative options for treating periodontal intrabony defects in baboons

BACKGROUND

In an effort to regenerate periodontal intrabony defects, the healing potential of the defect should determine what therapeutic modalities and materials are employed. The purpose of this study was to compare regenerative outcomes in baboon intrabony defects that were contained versus non-contained, using various regenerative therapies.

METHODS

Nine adult baboons (Papio anubis) in good health were treated. Eighty-six interproximal, intrabony defects were surgically created: 43 contained by 3 walls of bone; 43 non-contained with a missing buccal wall. Chronicity and plaque accumulation were encouraged with wire ligature placement for 8 weeks. After ligature removal, scaling, and a 2- to 4-week healing period, the defects were treated with the following therapies: collagen membrane (GTR), human demineralized freeze-dried bone (DFDB) grafting (BG), combined therapy (GTR + BG) and a DFDB-glycoprotein sponge matrix (MAT). Clinical healing responses were evaluated in 58 sites by changes in soft tissue (recession, probing, clinical attachment) and hard tissue (resorption, defect fill) parameters 6 months post-treatment. Histologic evaluation (defect regeneration, connective tissue attachment, epithelial migration) was done on 26 sites.

RESULTS

For contained defects, no real significant clinical (ANOVA) or histologic differences existed among treatments. However, for non-contained defects, combined therapy (GTR + BG) demonstrated clinically significant (P < or = 0.05, ANOVA) and histologically superior healing results over the other therapies tested.

CONCLUSION

These results confirm a defect morphology directed rationale for periodontal intrabony therapy.

Actinobacillus actinomycetemcomitans genetic heterogeneity: amplification of JP2-like ltx promoter pattern correlated with specific arbitrarily primed polymerase chain reaction (AP-PCR) genotypes from human but not marmoset Brazilian isolates

Specific clonal types of Actinobacillus actinomycetemcomitans, a major human periodontal pathogen, may be responsible for clinical manifestations and the production of leukotoxin virulence factors. Leukotoxicity is associated with genetic polymorphism at the promoter region of the leukotoxin (lItx) gene. Here, we describe the use of arbitrarily primed polymerase chain reaction (AP-PCR) and ltx promoter PCR to molecularly characterise 35 A. actinomycetemcomitans Brazilian isolates: 21 of human origin and 14 from captive marmosets (Callitrix spp., primates commonly used as animal models for periodontal research). The discriminative capacity of each of 12 arbitrary primers was found to be variable, yielding between 3 and 24 PCR amplitypes. Combination of the results for all primers led to characterisation of 14 genotypes that grouped into four major clusters based on genetic similarity. Clusters 2, 3, and 4 were discriminative to host origin. A correlation with periodontal disease was suggested for strains belonging to clusters 3 and 4. The JP2-like PCR amplification pattern, associated with highly leukotoxic strains, was exclusive to human isolates and present in 29% of human isolates where it occurred in close relationship with AP genotypes L and J (cluster 3).

Bacteriocin production by Actinobacillus actinomycetemcomitans isolated from the oral cavity of humans with periodontal disease, periodontally healthy subjects and marmosets

The ability of Actinobacillus actinomycetemcomitans to produce bacteriocin has rarely been reported. Antagonistic substance production may confer an important ecological advantage for the producer microorganisms, especially in a competitive ecosystem such as the oral cavity. In the present study, 75 A. actinomycetemcomitans strains isolated from the oral cavity of human patients with periodontal disease, periodontally healthy subjects and marmosets, as well as two reference strains (A. actinomycetemcomitans ATCC 29523 and FDC Y4) were evaluated for auto-, iso-, and heteroantagonistic activity. Fifty-one (68.00%) strains exhibited antagonistic activity; heteroantagonism was observed more often than isoantagonism. Isolated strains antagonized 17 different species of gram-positive and gram-negative bacteria from the oral and nonoral microbiota. Sensitivity to heat and to proteolytic enzymes constituted strong evidence that the antagonistic substance has a proteic nature. Taken together, our data enabled us to confirm that the antagonistic substance detected was a bacteriocin. The wide spectrum of activity indicates the possibility that more than one antagonistic substance is produced and that these substances play an important role in the ecological balance of the oral ecosystem.

Periodontal disease as a specific, albeit chronic, infection: diagnosis and treatment

Periodontal disease is perhaps the most common chronic infection in adults. Evidence has been accumulating for the past 30 years which indicates that almost all forms of periodontal disease are chronic but specific bacterial infections due to the overgrowth in the dental plaque of a finite number of mostly anaerobic species such as Porphyromonas gingivalis, Bacteroides forsythus, and Treponema denticola. The success of traditional debridement procedures and/or antimicrobial agents in improving periodontal health can be associated with the reduction in levels of these anaerobes in the dental plaque. These findings suggest that patients and clinicians have a choice in the treatment of this overgrowth, either a debridement and surgery approach or a debridement and antimicrobial treatment approach. However, the antimicrobial approach, while supported by a wealth of scientific evidence, goes contrary to centuries of dental teaching that states that periodontal disease results from a "dirty mouth." If periodontal disease is demonstrated to be a risk factor for cardiovascular disease and stroke, it will be a modifiable risk factor since periodontal disease can be prevented and treated. Since the antimicrobial approach may be as effective as a surgical approach in the restoration and maintenance of a periodontally healthy dentition, this would give a cardiac or stroke patient and his or her physician a choice in the implementation of treatment seeking to improve the patient's periodontal condition so as to reduce and/or delay future cardiovascular events.

Nonhuman primates: a critical role in current disease research

This review article emphasizes the critical role of nonhuman primates (NHPs) in biomedical research. It focuses on the most recent contributions that NHPs have made to the understanding, treatment, and prevention of important infectious diseases (e.g., acquired immunodeficiency syndrome, hepatitis, malaria) and chronic degenerative disorders of the central nervous system (e.g., Parkinson's and Alzheimer's diseases). The close phylogenetic relation of NHPs to humans not only opens avenues for testing the safety and efficacy of new drugs and vaccines but also offers promise for evaluating the potential of new gene-based treatments for human infectious and genetic diseases.

Soluble antagonists to interleukin-1 (IL-1) and tumor necrosis factor (TNF) inhibits loss of tissue attachment in experimental periodontitis

BACKGROUND, AIMS

Periodontal disease is a significant cause of tooth loss among adults and is characterized by the alteration and permanent destruction of the deeper periodontal tissues. Although the presence of pathologic microbes is required to trigger this process, the amplification and progression of the diseased state is believed to rely heavily on the production of host mediators in response to bacteria or their metabolic products. The inflammatory response is effective in preventing large-scale colonization of the gingival tissues by bacteria that lie in close proximity to the tooth surface or within the gingival sulcus. It has been postulated that the host-response in some individuals may lead to an over-reaction to invading oral pathogens resulting in the destruction of periodontal tissues.

METHODS

Several host-derived mediators are believed to contribute to this response. Two agents considered to be essential in periodontal destruction are interleukin-1 (IL-1) and tumor necrosis factor (TNF). We investigated the role of IL-1 and TNF in the loss of connective tissue attachment in a Macaca fascicularis primate model of experimental periodontitis. Silk ligatures impregnated with the periodontal pathogen, Porphyromonas gingivalis were wrapped around the posterior teeth and the activity of IL-1 and TNF were inhibited by soluble receptors to these proinflammatory cytokines via local injection into interdental papillae.

RESULTS

Histomorphometric analysis indicates that IL-1 and TNF antagonists significantly reduced the loss of connective tissue attachment by approximately 51% and the loss of alveolar bone height by almost 91%, both of which were statistically significant.

CONCLUSION

This investigation demonstrates that the loss of connective tissue attachment and progression of periodontal disease can be retarded by antagonists to specific host mediators such as IL-1 and TNF and may provide a potential treatment modality to combat the disease process.

Porphyromonas gingivalis induction of mediator and cytokine secretion by human gingival fibroblasts

We hypothesized that bacterial viability and strain characteristics of Porphyromonas gingivalis could affect the induction of pro-inflammatory mediator secretion by human gingival fibroblast cultures. Both killed and viable P. gingivalis elicited production of prostaglandin E2, interleukin-1 beta (IL-1 beta), IL-6 and IL-8, although killed P. gingivalis induced generally higher levels, particularly IL-6 and IL-8, compared with the viable bacteria. P. gingivalis strains, which exhibited wild-type levels of trypsin-like protease activity, stimulated human gingival fibroblasts to secrete increased levels of prostaglandin E2 and IL-1 beta, although minimal levels of IL-6 and IL-8 were noted in supernatants from the gingival fibroblast cells. P. gingivalis strains BEI and NG4B19, which have either decreased or undetectable levels of trypsin-like protease, respectively, induced significantly greater IL-6 and IL-8 levels in gingival fibroblast cultures compared with the other strains. The ability of antibody to P. gingivalis to alter human gingival fibroblast production of pro-inflammatory mediators was tested using nonhuman primate antisera. Both immune and nonimmune sera altered the P. gingivalis-generated pattern of mediators from the gingival fibroblasts. We conclude that: (i) viable and killed P. gingivalis were capable of inducing various pro-inflammatory cytokines from human gingival fibroblasts; (ii) strain differences in cytokine induction were noted, and the expression of a trypsin-like protease activity was related to decreased extracellular levels of IL-6 and IL-8; and (iii) the presence of serum, particularly with specific antibody to P. gingivalis, significantly altered human gingival fibroblast cytokine production compared with P. gingivalis alone.

Gingival crevicular fluid inflammatory mediators and bacteriology of gingivitis in nonhuman primates related to susceptibility to periodontitis

The hypothesis to be tested was that the microbiota and resulting local host inflammatory response characteristics in oral conditions of high levels of chronic gingival inflammation increases susceptibility to progressing periodontitis. This study used cynomolgus monkeys, Macaca fascicularis (nonhuman primates), with high and low levels of long-standing gingival inflammation to define the profiles of gingival crevicular fluid mediators, cytokines and immunoglobulins; describe the subgingival microbiota; and evaluate their susceptibility to ligature-induced periodontitis. Sixteen nonhuman primates were stratified into two groups (HI, LO) based upon Bleeding Index as a measure of the natural level of inflammation (HI = 1.26 +/- 0.45; LO = 0.22 +/- 0.16). The host mediator levels, subgingival microbiota, and clinical characteristics of the LO and HI groups were compared after 30 days of oral hygiene, during a 30 day experimental gingivitis (7, 14, and 30 days), and during periodontitis (30, 60, and 90 days). The results demonstrated that nonhuman primates with high levels of long-standing gingival inflammation when compared to those nonhuman primates with low inflammation show: 1) different inflammatory mediator profiles in gingival crevicular fluid (particularly for immunoglobulin A (IgA) and IgG levels), 2) a different quantitative and qualitative subgingival microbiota; and 3) a similar progression of periodontitis. Thus, while variations in host inflammatory responses to local factors exist in the nonhuman primates, an extensive subgingival challenge (such as ligation) may negate these individual differences.

Systemic manifestations of periodontitis in the non-human primate

This report describes our findings regarding the potential contribution of periodontitis to atherosclerotic processes using a nonhuman primate model. The goal of the investigations was to target general mechanisms which could describe the association of these disease processes, including: (i) systemic translocation of bacteria/products during periodontitis; (ii) alterations in systemic inflammatory biomarkers during periodontitis; and (iii) the relationship of periodontitis to serum lipids/lipoproteins. Increases in serum endotoxin (e.g. LPS) during ligature-induced periodontitis were observed in these animals. We determined serum levels of various acute phase reactants and chemokines (e.g. CRP, alpha 1-antitrypsin, haptoglobin, fibrinogen, IL-8). A number of these host factors were significantly increased during gingivitis and/or periodontitis. Finally, we observed specific changes in serum lipid levels (cholesterol, triglycerides, HDL, LDL) and lipoproteins (apoA-I) during periodontitis, which were exacerbated by exposure of the animals to a diet with elevated fat content. Thus, we have described systemic manifestations of periodontitis that include detection of bacterial products, inflammatory biomarkers, and dyslipoproteinemia consistent with an increased atherogenic risk.

Paradoxical role of PGE2 and cAMP in Actinobacillus actinomycetemcomitants strain Y4-induced lymphocyte proliferation

An immune mechanism has been suggested in the pathogenesis of periodontal disease. Actinobacillus actinomycetemcomitants (Aa) has been implicated as one of the etiological agents that induces the major immune response together with a dense infiltrate of inflammatory cells. But the exact role of these immune cells in periodontal disease has not yet been clarified. In this study the T lymphocyte (TL) proliferative response was evaluated after having being exposed to free cell supernatant (SN) from Aa. Aa SN increased TL proliferation. This mitogenic effect of Aa SN was attenuated by pretreating TL with indomethacin (INDO) or acetylsalicylic acid (ASA) but not by polymyxin B. The inhibitory effect of INDO on cell proliferation was reversed by the addition of prostaglandin E2 (PGE2) to the culture assay. Moreover, when immune cells were exposed to Aa SN they were able to generate PGE2 at the same time as intracellular levels of cAMP decreased. Both, PGE2 release and decrease accumulation of cAMP in TL were blunted by treated lymphocytes with INDO. In this paper we demonstrate that cell free SN from Aa induces a mitogenic effect on murine lymphocytes. The mechanism involves the host's immunecompetent cells and the release of PGE2 and appears not to be induced by capsular-like polysaccharide antigen. Results show a paradoxical mitogenic effect of Aa SN accompanied by increased generation of PGE2 and decreased production of cAMP by lymphocytes.

Periodontitis in the house musk shrew (Suncus murinus): a potential animal model for human periodontal disease

BACKGROUND

Our understanding of periodontal diseases has been facilitated greatly by the use of animal models. However, no animal model has been identified that truly reflects the disease seen in humans. Suncus murinus, a rat-sized laboratory house musk shrew, has received attention as a valuable animal model due to ease of handling. In the studies described here, periodontal conditions in Suncus murinus were evaluated to determine the usefulness of the shrew as an experimental model for understanding various aspects of periodontal diseases.

METHODS

Periodontal tissues of 34 Suncus murinus (18 to 430 days old) were examined macroscopically, morphometrically, histologically, and ultrastructurally.

RESULTS

Dentition pattern is I3/1, C1/1, P2/1, M3/3. Spontaneous gingival swelling with accumulation of plaque was observed in more than two-thirds of animals older than 200 days. Morphometric analysis of alveolar bone demonstrated a pattern of bone loss that correlated closely with animal age. Histologically, periodontal lesions varying from gingivitis to periodontitis, similar to those observed in humans, were noted. Marked infiltration of lymphocytes and plasma cells in the connective tissue was noted, usually not seen in periodontal lesions of rodents. Although osteoclastic alveolar bone resorption was noted, active bone resorption was not a frequent feature in specimens obtained from chronic inflammatory lesions. Ultrastructurally, degradation of collagen fibers in the inflamed area and ingestion of collagen fibrils by fibroblasts in the deeper connective tissue were often seen.

CONCLUSIONS

These results indicate the potential utility of Suncus murinus as a model to study periodontal disease; e.g., chronic nature of the inflammatory periodontal lesions, similar to those in humans, as well as other advantages including size and ease of handling and housing of these animals.

Interleukin-1 and tumor necrosis factor antagonists inhibit the progression of inflammatory cell infiltration toward alveolar bone in experimental periodontitis

Periodontal disease is a significant cause of tooth loss in humans and is one of the most prevalent diseases associated with bone loss. Following bacterial colonization, the gingiva becomes inflamed and, in some cases, progresses to destruction of alveolar bone. To investigate the temporal movement of inflammatory cells toward alveolar bone and the role of interleukin-1 (IL-1) and tumor necrosis factor (TNF) in this process, studies were carried out in a Macaca fascicularis primate model of experimental periodontitis. IL-1 and TNF activity was inhibited by local application of soluble receptors to IL-1 and TNF by injection into interdental papillae. The results indicate that following induction of experimental periodontitis, the front of inflammatory cells progresses toward alveolar bone and is associated with osteoclast formation. These processes are inhibited by blockers to IL-1 and TNF. These studies suggest that the conversion from gingivitis to periodontitis is directly associated with the movement of an inflammatory infiltrate toward alveolar bone, and that this activity is at least partially dependent upon IL-1 and/ or TNF.

Immunization with Porphyromonas gingivalis cysteine protease: effects on experimental gingivitis and ligature-induced periodontitis in Macaca fascicularis

Targeting bacterial virulence factors such as proteases for immunization may hold the key to limiting or preventing loss of attachment and alveolar bone in periodontal disease. This study examined the clinical, microbiological, and immununological responses following active immunization with a purified Porphyromonas gingivalis cysteine protease (porphypain-2) in the nonhuman primate (Nhp) Macaca fascicularis. One group of Nhp was immunized with porphypain-2 antigen while control Nhp received placebo injections. All Nhp were subjected to experimental gingivitis followed by ligature-induced periodontitis in a split-mouth design. An enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay demonstrated that immunization elicited a significantly elevated and specific IgG antibody response to both whole cell P. gingivalis (36-fold) and to porphypain-2 (194-fold). Checkerboard hybridization DNA analysis of subgingival plaque from ligated sextants demonstrated that 25% more Gram-negative anaerobic species became significantly elevated from baseline and at earlier timepoints in the control group than in the immununized group. Immunization with this protease did not suppress the emergence of P. gingivalis. Clinical indices showed few changes related to immunization. Alveolar bone density changes demonstrated a highly significant loss in ligated sextants compared to non-ligated sextants within the control group (P < 0.001), and a smaller but significant difference within the immunized group (P = 0.043). Comparison of ligated sextants only demonstrated more bone loss in the control group versus the immunized group (-13.07+/-9.51 versus -9.41+/-6.18; computer-assisted densitometric image analysis units +/- SD); the difference approached, but did not reach, significance. The results suggest that porphypain-2 may contribute to the pathogenic potential of the subgingival plaque microbiota in the Nhp model of ligature-induced periodontitis, and that active immunization with porphypain-2 appeared capable of altering this pathogenic response.

IL-1 and TNF Antagonists Inhibit the Inflammatory Response and Bone Loss in Experimental Periodontitis

Periodontal disease is the most frequent cause of tooth loss in humans and is the most prevalent disease associated with bone loss, including osteoporosis. Periodontal destruction is initiated by bacteria that colonize the tooth surface, leading to inflammation and bone resorption. To assess the roles of IL-1 and TNF in this process, studies were conducted in a Macaca fascicularis primate model of experimental periodontitis. Function-blocking soluble receptors to IL-1 and TNF were applied by local injection to sites with induced periodontal destruction and compared with similar sites injected with vehicle alone. The results indicate that injection of soluble receptors to IL-1 and TNF inhibited by approximately 80% the recruitment of inflammatory cells in close proximity to bone. The formation of osteoclasts was reduced by 67% at the experimental sites compared with that at the control sites, and the amount of bone loss was reduced by 60%. All results were statistically significant (p &lt; 0.01). These findings indicate that a significant component of the pathologic process of periodontitis is due to IL-1/TNF activity, since inhibiting IL-1/TNF reduces both inflammatory cell recruitment and bone loss. The data also suggest that inflammation associated with gingivitis is actively protective, since blocking further up-regulation of the host response with IL-1/TNF inhibitors does not cause periodontal damage. Furthermore, these results coupled with recent evidence that IL-1 and TNF participate in endocrine-associated osteoporosis suggest that multiple pathologies involving excessive loss of bone may operate through a common mechanism involving IL-1 and/or TNF.

Experimental peri-implantitis in consecutively placed, loaded root-form and plate-form implants in adult Macaca mulatta monkeys

This study is part of an on-going project describing the character of round- and plate-form implants placed in a primate model. In this paper 20 loaded plate-form and 23 root-form implants were connected to prostheses and experimental peri-implantitis was induced by ceasing scaling procedures and placing braided silk ligature around the implants. Twenty-four prostheses utilizing natural teeth were studied for comparison. Clinical measurements were carried out monthly for 6 months and radiographic measurements at 3 and 6 months post-ligature placement and cessation of scaling. Both root-form implants and plate-form implants showed a significant loss of crestal bone height at 3 and 6 months after ligature placement (P < .001 after 6 months). The difference in bone loss between plate- and root-form implants, however, was not significant.

Evidence for serum immunoglobulin G (IgG) antibody responses in Macaca fascicularis identified by monoclonal antibodies to human IgG subclasses

This investigation determined the capacity of murine monoclonal antibodies directed to human immunoglobulin G (IgG) subclasses to identify molecules with conserved epitopes in the serum of the nonhuman primate, Macaca fascicularis. We subsequently utilized this cross-reactivity to document the characteristics of IgG subclass antibody responses in M. fascicularis to parenteral immunization with intact oral microorganisms, antigens from oral microorganisms, and finally a defined protein toxin, tetanus toxoid. The IgG response in nonhuman primates immunized with tetanus toxoid showed a 40-fold and 110-fold increase after primary and secondary immunizations, respectively. The major IgG subclass responses were IgG1 and IgG3, with little, though significant, responses in the IgG4 and IgG2 subclasses. Seventy-five to 94% of the natural IgG antibody in nonhuman primate sera to Porphyromonas gingivalis, Prevotella intermedia and Campylobacter rectus was IgG1. IgG2 and IgG3 predominated to Bacteroides fragilis, IgG4 to Actinomyces viscosus and an equal distribution among the subclasses was noted in response to Fusobacterium nucleatum. Parenteral immunization of nonhuman primates with intact P. gingivalis elicited primarily IgG3 and IgG4, while the post-immunization IgG response to P. intermedia was largely IgG1. Nonhuman primates were also parenterally immunized with cell envelope antigens of P. gingivalis, P. intermedia, or a combination of cell envelope antigen from C. rectus and F. nucleatum and cell wall antigens of A. viscosus. The greatest IgG antibody response seen post-immunization was reactive with anti-human IgG1 for all of these antigens except to C. rectus which bound nonhuman primate antibody reactive with anti-human IgG2. It appears that the bacteria and their products exhibit unique differences in their induction of serum IgG subclass antibody responses. The characteristics of their immunogenicity as detected by the nonhuman primate may contribute to the ability of the immune responses to effectively interact with these pathogens.

Characteristics of systemic antibody responses of nonhuman primates to cell envelope and cell wall antigens from periodontal pathogens

The immune response of the primate, Macaca fascicularis, to cell envelope (CEA) or cell wall (CWA) antigens of several periodontal pathogens was examined to develop a strategy to interfere with ligature-induced periodontitis. Animals were parenterally immunized with CEA of either Porphyromonas gingivalis, Prevotella intermedia or a combination of CEA/CWA of Campylobacter rectus, Fusobacterium nucleatum and Actinomyces viscosus. Serum samples were taken every 2-4 weeks over a 4-month period, which included a 13-week interval with molar teeth ligated. All of the nonhuman primates in the study exhibited baseline levels of IgG, IgM and IgA antibody to formalinized whole cells of the bacteria. These levels increased significantly following immunization and were elevated above baseline throughout the remainder of the experiment. The largest change in antibody responses was seen in IgA antibody levels of P. gingivalis and C. rectus (42-fold above baseline), IgM antibody to P. intermedia, (41-fold increase) and IgG antibody to F. nucleatum and A. viscosus (32 and 63-fold increases). Moreover, the nonhuman primates exhibited differences in isotype response levels to whole microorganisms compared with the cell envelope antigens. These findings demonstrate the capacity of these nonhuman primates to produce an active immune response to microorganisms chronically colonizing the subgingival microbiota. Additionally, it appears that the bacteria may exhibit some unique differences in their immunogenicity as detected by the nonhuman primate and may contribute to the ability of the immune responses to effectively interact with these pathogens.

Host modulation of tissue destruction caused by periodontopathogens: effects on a mixed microbial infection composed of Porphyromonas gingivalis and Fusobacterium nucleatum

These studies determined the ability of selected periodontopathogens to synergistically initiate soft tissue destruction in a murine abscess model. The development of immunity following recovery from infection or by active immunization was also examined. Mice were infected with P. gingivalis W50, F. nucleatum T18, or a combination of the two microorganisms. F. nucleatum caused only a localized lesion in contrast to P. gingivalis which caused a spreading suppurative inflammatory lesion of the skin and subcutaneous tissues, which, depending upon the dose, could result in death. Infection of mice with a combination of P. gingivalis and F. nucleatum elicited a significantly greater lesion size (P<0.001) and lethality compared with P. gingivalis alone. Mice infected with a subclinical dose (no visible lesion) of P. gingivalis failed to develop protective immunity to a secondary P. gingivalis challenge. Mice that had recovered from P. gingivalis lesions demonstrated partial protection against subsequent P. gingivalis challenge; however, the immunity was less protective against the mixed F. nucleatum + P. gingivalis infection. Active immunization with P. gingivalis protected against both the P. gingivalis and F. nucleatum + P. gingivalis challenges and this protection was correlated with the levels of specific serum immunoglobulin G (IgG) antibody. The results indicated that the murine model is ideally suited to examine bacterially-mediated mixed infections that result in soft tissue destruction. This destruction can be minimized, but not abrogated, with development of immunity. Challenge with sufficient numbers of the pathogens can overwhelm the acquired immunity.

Experimental peri-implant tissue breakdown around hydroxyapatite-coated implants

This study monitored experimental peri-implant tissue breakdown around hydroxyapatite (HA)-coated titanium dental implants. Thirty-two HA-coated cylindrical implants, in groups of two, were bilaterally inserted in the posterior maxilla and mandible in 4 Macaca mulatta monkeys. Two months after healing-abutment connection, a 2-month plaque control program was initiated. Clinical and radiographic recordings and peri-implant submucosal microbial samples were then obtained (baseline). Cotton ligatures were next placed around the healing-abutments and plaque control measures were abandoned. Clinical and radiographic recordings were repeated at 5 and 10 months post-baseline. Microbial samples were repeated at 10 months post-baseline, and ligatures were removed. Clinical, radiographic, and microbial examinations were again repeated at 11 months post-baseline. Mean modified plaque index (mPI; P < 0.01), gingival index (G]; P < 0.01), and bleeding on probing (BOP; P < 0.05) scores increased over the plaque accumulation period. The mPI, and GI scores decreased after ligature removal (P < 0.001). Mean probing depth (PD) and clinical attachment level (AL) increased between baseline and the 5- and 10-month examinations (delta PD 3.0 mm; delta AL 2.7 mm; P < 0.05). PD values were reduced following ligature removal (P < 0.05). AL values and BP scores remained unchanged. A significant negative correlation was found between induced defect depth and width of keratinized mucosa at baseline (P = 0.03). At baseline, the submucosal microbiota was dominated by coccoid cells. Following ligature placement, the microbiota included a large proportion of Gram-negative anaerobic rods, predominantly Porphyromonas gingivalis, Bacteroides forsythus, and Fusobacterium species as well as beta-hemolytic streptococci. Ligature removal had a limited effect on the composition of the submucosal microbiota. This non-human primate study indicates that ligature-enhanced plaque accumulation is a precursor of progressive peri-implant tissue breakdown around HA-coated implants. The associated microbiota resembles that of peri-implantitis and destructive periodontal disease in humans. This preclinical model may be useful to study modalities aimed at arresting peri-implant tissue breakdown and at regeneration of bone in peri-implantitis defects.

Analysis of consecutively placed loaded root-form and plate-form implants in adult Macaca mulatta monkeys

The present paper describes 36 consecutively treated non-human primates (Macaca mulatta) as part of a balanced block design study to examine osseointegration in root- and plate-form implants prepared by atraumatic preparation of bone. Clinical measurements around selected teeth and digital radiology were utilized to monitor periodontal disease and bone loss around root- and plate-form implants which were loaded with a fixed prosthesis. Results indicate that once monthly regimen of scaling and root planing can prevent attachment loss in natural teeth, serving as abutments of loaded bridges. Root-form implants exhibited a significant loss of crestal bone height during the first year (P < 0.03) while plate-form implants showed less loss in bone height. There was an increase in bone mass over time for root-form or plate-form implants. Both root-form and plate-form implants provided radiographic evidence of osseointegration in loaded bridges.

Histological and microbiological aspects of ligature-induced periodontitis in beagle dogs

This study was designed to investigate, using 6 beagle dogs, the levels of selected putative pathogens in healthy sites, in gingivitis sites, and in sites with histologically confirmed attachment loss. Levels of attachment loss increased with increasing periods of ligation and reached a maximum of 0.15 mm at 57 days. Both histological attachment level and histological pocket depth were found to vary significantly with health/disease status (p < 0.0001). Higher numbers of total colony-forming units were seen for ligated sites than for healthy and gingivitis sites. Levels of Porphyromonas gingivalis and Prevotella intermedia also changed significantly with health/disease status (p < 0.001). These organisms showed their greatest increases at the time of the most intense attachment loss. Higher levels of Fusobacterium nucleatum were seen in the gingivitis sites than in healthy or ligated sites. Low levels of Campylobacter rectus and Capnocytophaga spp. were detected throughout. The morphometric microbiological analysis revealed unexpectedly high %s of motile rods, while spirochetes were found in very low %s. The total number of bacterial cells detected using phase contrast microscopy was not found to vary significantly. None of the morphotypes were demonstrated as showing significant changes with health/disease status.

Characteristics of systemic antibody responses of nonhuman primates following active immunization with Porphyromonas gingivalis, Prevotella intermedia and Bacteroides fragilis

Periodontal disease is an infectious disease manifested by the progressive change of a healthy resident commensal microbiota to a pathogenic one characterized by a specific microbiota. Thus, the prospect for the use of selected bacteria or their antigens as a vaccine to interfere with the microbial changes and resulting progression of periodontal tissue destruction has been proposed. As a first step in examining the use of bacterial antigens as immunogens in periodontitis, this study characterized the humoral immune response in Macaca fascicularis after systemic immunization with intact Porphyromonas gingivalis, Prevotella intermedia and Bacteroides fragilis. Parental immunization of the nonhuman primate with the intact bacteria resulted in the production of specific and significantly elevated levels of antibodies to P. gingivalis and P. intermedia, with the predominant isotype being immunoglobulin G (IgG). In contrast, the principal response to the nonoral, intestinal bacterium, B. fragilis, was of the IgM isotype. Immunization increased IgG, IgM, and IgA antibody by 14-227 fold to P. gingivalis and 8-108 fold to P. intermedia. The level of serum IgA antibody increased (77-227 fold). The kinetics of the antibody response post-immunization and post-ligation differed with respect to each of the bacteria tested. IgG antibody to P. gingivalis increased through week 16 of the experiment and remained elevated above baseline through week 32. The IgG antibody level to P. intermedia peaked at 4 weeks following the third immunization and decreased post-ligation to near baseline levels by week 16. Characterization of the immune response after active immunization in the nonhuman primate has demonstrated a substantial and specific increase in antibody response which was sustained for several weeks. The insights obtained from these studies should help optimize the potential for immunologic interference with progressing periodontitis.

Production of inflammatory mediators and cytokines by human gingival fibroblasts following bacterial challenge

Bacteria can indirectly affect the course of periodontal diseases by activating host cells to produce and release inflammatory mediators and cytokines. These mediators and cytokines manifest potent proinflammatory and catabolic activity and may play key roles in local amplification of the immune response as well as in periodontal tissue breakdown. This study tested the effect of Actinobacillus actinomycetemcomitans (Aa) and Campylobacter rectus (Cr) challenge on PGE2, IL-1 beta, IL-6 and IL-8 production by human gingival fibroblasts (HGF). Contact-inhibited HGF were prepared and formalin-killed bacterial cells (Aa JP2, ATCC 29523 & 33384 and Cr ATCC 33238) at 10(6)-10(9) were added to the HGF. Culture supernatants were collected at varying time intervals and analyzed for cytokine and mediator content. All concentrations of Aa JP2 and Cr ATCC 33238 suppressed IL-1 beta production up to approximately 50% during the initial 3-12-h period. No bacterial concentration tested was able to increase IL-1 beta production above the maximum basal levels. Both bacterial species stimulated production of IL-6 and IL-8. Aa JP2 did not affect PGE2 levels significantly, whereas Cr ATCC 33238 was stimulatory only at the highest concentration tested (10(9)). There were no significant differences among the three Aa strains with respect to IL-1 beta production. However, Aa ATCC 29523 and ATCC 33384 were less capable of stimulating IL-6 secretion and more efficient in stimulating IL-8 production than Aa JP2. In general, Cr was the most potent enhancer of cytokine and mediator production by HGF. In conclusion, Aa and Cr are capable of amplifying the local immune response and promoting periodontal tissue inflammation by stimulating HGF to secrete mainly IL-6 and IL-8.

Cell envelope and cell wall immunization of Macaca fascicularis: effect on the progression of ligature-induced periodontitis

The nonhuman primate, Macaca fascicularis, was used to study the role of immunization with selected members of the periodontopathic microbiota in the longitudinal progression of ligature-induced periodontitis. Animals were immunized with cell envelope antigens prepared from Porphyromonas gingivalis and Prevotella intermedia, and a mixture prepared from Fusobacterium nucleatum, Campylobacter rectus, and Actinomyces viscosus. Serum immunoglobulin G (IgG), IgM and IgA isotype antibodies increased significantly in all immunization groups and were specific for each of the immunogens. P. gingivalis and P. intermedia immunization resulted in a stabilization of the proportions of these species throughout most of the experiment. The high P. gingivalis antibody titer resulted in low P. gingivalis numbers being recovered. P. gingivalis immunization, while lowering recoverable viable P. gingivalis, resulted in significantly increased levels of Prevotella loescheii, Prevotella buccae, Bacteroides macacae and Prevotella melaninogenica compared with preligation and preimmunization levels. Actinobacillus actinomycetemcomitans, Capnocytophaga spp. and Eikenella spp. remained at preligation levels postimmunization. Campylobacter spp. increased significantly during the course of the experiment in all groups, whereas the levels of Fusobacterium spp. decreased. Plaque indices and bleeding on probing showed significant increases in all groups following ligation, with the placebo group showing the greatest increase. Pocket depth measurements revealed that , whereas the placebo animals showed an approximate 5% increase, the P. gingivalis- and P. intermedia-immunized groups showed nearly a 20% increase in pocket depth. Attachment level measurements showed significantly greater attachment loss in the P. gingivalis- and P. intermedia-immunized groups, and the F. nucleatum + C. rectus + A. viscosus immunization appeared to prevent significant changes in pocket depth/attachment level loss. Radiographic measurement of bone loss by computer-assisted densitometric image analysis revealed that the placebo group lost bone throughout the experiment. P. gingivalis- and P. intermedia-immunized groups showed an exacerbated loss of bone density and the group immunized with F. nucleatum + C. rectus + A. viscosus exhibited significantly lower amounts of bone loss when analyzed by computer-assisted densitometric image analysis, compared with the other immunized groups. Although immunization with P. gingivalis and P. intermedia cell envelope antigens had an effect on their emergence in the complex microbiota of the developing periodontal pocket, this immunization also resulted in greater bone loss than immunization with F. nucleatum + C. rectus + A. viscosus, suggesting that, whereas selective members of the putative periodontopathic microbiota may play a direct role in periodontal tissue destruction, the complexity of the subgingival microbiota dictates that considerable scrutiny is required to select useful immunogens that can elicit functional protection from periodontal tissue destruction induced by oral microorganisms that already colonize or infect the host.

Functional properties of nonhuman primate antibody to Porphyromonas gingivalis

The nonhuman primate (NHP) serves as a useful model for examining the host-parasite interactions in Porphyromonas gingivalis-associated periodontal disease. This study determined the influence of NHP sera on (i) the direct killing of P. gingivalis, (ii) P. gingivalis-induced superoxide anion (O2-) release from human polymorphonuclear leukocytes (PMNs), and (iii) the ability of PMNs to bind and phagocytize P. gingivalis. Three types of NHP sera were utilized: (i) normal or baseline sera; (ii) sera obtained after ligature-induced periodontitis; and (iii) sera obtained following active immunization with formalinized P. gingivalis. All assays were performed with or without the addition of human complement. Significantly more (P < 0.01) direct killing of P. gingivalis occurred with immunized sera and complement than with any of the other treatments. The sera from ligature-induced periodontitis NHPs had significantly less (P < 0.03) killing capacity than the baseline sera, which contained natural antibody produced to P. gingivalis colonization. Sera from immunized NHPs were used to opsonize P. gingivalis and caused significantly greater (P < 0.01) levels of O2- release from PMNs. Finally, the sera from immunized NHPs significantly enhanced (P < 0.009) the uptake of P. gingivalis by PMNs, although binding of the bacteria to PMNs was similar among all three serum types. Active immunization of NHPs with P. gingivalis elicited a functional antibody that enhanced direct killing, positively influenced the activation of PMNs, and enhanced the ability of PMNs to phagocytize P. gingivalis. Moreover, antibody produced as a sequela of progressing periodontitis appeared to lack these functions. A wide variability in functional capacity of the sera from individual NHPs, which may contribute to an individual's susceptibility to P. gingivalis-induced disease, was noted. This variability suggested that results from functional tests of serum antibody may aid in predicting host susceptibility to disease and response to therapy.

Comparative virulence of periodontopathogens in a mouse abscess model

OBJECTIVE(S)

This report compares the virulence of selected strains of P. gingivalis, A. actinomycetemcomitans, C. rectus, F. nucleatum and T. denticola in a murine model as a measure of pathogenic potential of these oral microorganisms. The characteristics of the tissue destruction associated with these monoinfections were then related to a potential model for bacterial synergism in progressing periodontitis.

DESIGN AND METHODS

All bacterial strains were grown to mid-logarithmic to early stationary growth phase, harvested and used at various doses to challenge BALB/c normal and BALB/c dexamethasone (DEX) treated mice to mimic a neutrophil dysfunction. The characteristics of tissue destruction, and overt tissue destructive capacity of these species were examined as a function of challenge dose and time.

OUTCOME MEASURES

The mice were examined for an interval of approximately 15 days post-challenge and the presence/absence of lesions, localized or generalized nature of the lesion (including size in mm2), and lethality of the infection were assessed.

RESULTS

Comparison of the virulence of the various P. gingivalis strains related to lethality and lesion size associated with destruction of the connective tissue, indicated a virulence capacity of P. gingivalis strains 53977>W50 = T22>3079>33277>381. C. rectus elicited localized necrotic lesions which were limited to the epithelial layers of the skin. The size of the lesions also indicated a graded difference in virulence, such that C. rectus strains 234>576>>33238. A. actinomycetemcomitans caused the formation of classic localized abscesses with a PMN infiltrate and inflammatory exudates. Although each of the A. actinomycetemcomitans strains exhibited a similar virulence pattern in this murine model, A. actinomycetemcomitans serotype b representative strains were potentially more pathogenic with a virulence capacity of 3113D-N = 3975A>JP2 > or = Y4>29523>33384. Both C. rectus and A. actinomycetemcomitans strains showed clear evidence that recent clinical isolates were more virulent than laboratory strains. Challenge with F. nucleatum resulted in tissue destructive responses which were different from those observed with the other strains used in this study. A rapid onset of dose-dependent lesion development, related to the formation of either closed abscesses or open lesions, was observed with F. nucleatum. Tissue involvement was also greater at lower F. nucleatum doses when compared to the other bacteria. F. nucleatum challenge of DEX-treated mice resulted in a shift to open lesions. T. denticola appeared to be more tissue invasive than the other species examined in this study. Challenge of mice with T. denticola resulted in involvement of multiple tissues, including epithelial and connective tissues, as well as appearing to invade muscle layers and deeper tissues. In addition to invading deeper tissues, the resulting lesions took considerably longer to resolve. In the DEX-treated mice (neutrophil depleted), P. gingivalis, C. rectus, and A. actinomycetemcomitans were significantly more virulent. In contrast, while DEX treatment altered the characteristics of lesions caused by F. nucleatum, the extent of lesions produced by F. nucleatum and T. denticola was not substantially enhanced.

CONCLUSIONS

The results obtained from this study suggest that different microorganisms have the ability to provide individual pathologies which may act in an additive/synergistic fashion contributing to the tissue destruction noted in periodontitis.

Comparison of canine and non-human primate animal models for periodontal regenerative therapy: results following a single administration of PDGF/IGF-I

Two commonly used animal models for evaluating putative periodontal regenerative therapies are the beagle dog model with natural periodontal disease and the non-human primate with ligature-induced attachment loss. The host response, microbiology, and skeletal rates of remodeling of these two models are summarized. In addition, the results of experiments comparing the healing response to periodontal surgery with and without concurrent use of the combination of platelet-derived growth factor (PDGF) and insulin-like growth factor-I (IGF-I) in these models are presented. At 1 month, PDGF/IGF-I administration resulted in a 64.1% and 51.4% increase in new attachment formation in the non-human primate and canine, respectively, while controls (surgery plus placebo) demonstrated 34.1% and 8.6% increases in new attachment formation in the non-human primate and canine models, respectively. Further, application of PDGF/IGF-I stimulated 21.6% and 65% osseous defect fill in the non-human primate and canine, respectively, while controls demonstrated 8.5% and 14.5% osseous defect fill in the non-human primate and canine, respectively. The osseous response in the canine appears greater than that of the non-human primate, and the new attachment formation was more substantial in the non-human primate than the canine. However, in general these data demonstrate a high degree of consistency in the effects of PDGF/IGF-I in promoting periodontal regeneration. Positive results in these two models--the dog with natural periodontal disease and the non-human primate with ligature-induced attachment loss--justify human clinical trial testing of a putative regenerative therapy.

Evaluation of consecutively placed unloaded root-form and plate-form implants in adult Macaca mulatta monkeys

The present paper describes 18 consecutively-treated non-human primates (Macaca mulatta) as part of a balanced block design study of 36 animals to examine osseointegration in root- and plate-form implants prepared by atraumatic preparation of bone. Clinical measurements around selected teeth and digital radiology were utilized to monitor periodontal disease and bone deposition around the unloaded implants. Once a month scaling procedures were utilized as a means of preventing further advance of periodontal disease. Results indicate that once-monthly regimen of scaling and root planing can prevent attachment loss of natural teeth and will not interfere with the healing of either type of implant; once-monthly scalings produce significant reduction in redness (P < .05) and reduced probing depths (P = .01). A second finding is that both root and blade implants show radiographic evidence of osseointegration in this primate model. The quantitative analysis demonstrates bone gain is not stabilized until 6 months after healing. The data may indicate that occlusal loading of mandibular implants at 3 months may be premature.

Diagnostic tools and biologic markers: animal models in the study of osteoporosis and oral bone loss

Recent data have suggested that there may be a relationship between osteoporosis and oral bone loss. Both diseases are major public health problems of enormous magnitude, but their relationship is poorly understood. This is due to their complex pathogenesis and the fact that coexisting periodontal disease, loss of the dentition, site-specific variability in anatomy and bone density, as well as aging and many other factors complicate the development and progression of bone loss relative to each. The focus of this article is to review the characteristics of animals that are suited for studies of the relationship of osteoporosis and oral bone loss to better understand their relationship.

Ligature-induced marginal inflammation around osseointegrated implants and ankylosed teeth: stereologic and histologic observations in cynomolgus monkeys (Macaca fascicularis)

The aim of the investigation was to provide quantitative and qualitative histologic data on marginal inflammation around osseointegrated implants. The significance of the lack of a periodontal ligament in the initial breakdown phase of supporting tissues in implants was examined by comparing stereologic and histologic manifestations of ligature-induced marginal inflammation around osseointegrated implants with those around ankylosed and normal control teeth in 8 cynomolgus monkeys (Macaca fascicularis). Clinical and radiographic findings have been reported elsewhere. The marginal connective tissue around ligated implants was infiltrated by a significantly increased total number of lymphocytes, plasma cells, and neutrophils compared to non-ligated implants and teeth. The total number of lymphocytes around ligated implants was significantly higher than around ligated ankylosed and normal control teeth. There were, however, no significant differences in the total number of plasma cells and neutrophils within the ligated group. Osteoclasts were exclusively observed around ligated implants and ankylosed teeth. Although variations in microbiota and susceptibility of different jaw positions to periodontal break-down may influence the results of the present study, the results seem to substantiate the theory that marginal inflammation around implants and ankylosed teeth may have more serious implications than does marginal inflammation around teeth with a periodontal ligament. Since presence of osteoclasts was not related to the absence of cervical cementum with inserting gingival fibers around ligated ankylosed teeth, the increased susceptibility of bone loss of implants is probably not caused by the absence of these tissue components. In contrast, the histologic observations seem to support that the increased susceptibility for bone loss around implants may be related to the absence of a periodontal ligament.