Adjuvant radiotherapy for atypical meningiomas

Pathologic Predictors of Local Recurrence in Atypical Meningiomas Following Gross Total Resection

PURPOSE

To assess the local recurrence rate of gross totally resected atypical meningiomas and evaluate for pathologic predictors of recurrence.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

All patients meeting the 2016 World Health Organization grade 2 meningioma criteria who received gross total resection were included in this retrospective analysis. A neuropathologist re-reviewed all surgical specimens for the following pathologic factors: brain invasion, macronuclei, necrosis, sheeting architecture, hypercellularity, high nuclear to cytoplasmic ratio, Ki67 proliferative index, mitotic number, and choroid or clear cell histology. Local recurrence and salvage therapy were recorded.

RESULTS

Ninety-seven patients met the inclusion criteria and had a median radiographic follow-up of 53 months (range, 3-153). Necrosis was present in 41 specimens (42%), and brain invasion occurred in 30 (31%). Seventy-six patients (78%) had 3 of 5 World Health Organization grade 2 qualifying atypical features. Median mitotic number and Ki67 index were 3 (0-12) and 15 (2%-55%), respectively. Only Ki67 proliferative index and mitotic number predict for local recurrence. The Kaplan-Meier estimate of local recurrence was 30.3% at 3 years.

CONCLUSIONS

In this cohort of gross totally resected atypical meningioma followed with observation, local recurrence occurred in 30.3% at 3 years. Ki67 index and mitotic number predict for local failure and could help stratify patients who would benefit from adjuvant therapy.

Predictors of early progression of surgically treated atypical meningiomas

Background

Clinical behaviour of atypical meningiomas is not uniform. While, as a group, they exhibit a high recurrence rate, some pursue a more benign course, whereas others progress early. We aim to investigate the imaging and pathological factors that predict risk of early tumour progression and to determine whether early progression is related to outcome.

Methods

Adult patients with WHO grade II meningioma treated in three regional referral centres between 2007 and 2014 were included. MRI and pathology characteristics were assessed. Gross total resection (GTR) was defined as Simpson 1–3. Recurrence was classified into early and late (≤ 24 vs. > 24 months).

Results

Among the 220 cases, 37 (16.8%) patients progressed within 24 months of operation. Independent predictors of early progression were subtotal resection (STR) (p = 0.005), parafalcine/parasagittal location (p = 0.015), peritumoural oedema (p = 0.027) and mitotic index (MI) > 7 (p = 0.007). Adjuvant radiotherapy was negatively associated with early recurrence (p = 0.046). Thirty-two per cent of patients with residual tumour and 26% after GTR received adjuvant radiotherapy. There was a significantly lower proportion of favourable outcomes at last follow-up (mRS 0–1) in patients with early recurrence (p = 0.001).

Conclusions

Atypical meningiomas are a heterogeneous group of tumours with 16.8% patients having recurrence within 24 months of surgery. Residual tumour, parafalcine/parasagittal location, peritumoural oedema and a MI > 7 were all independently associated with early recurrence. As administration of adjuvant radiotherapy was not protocolised in this cohort, any conclusions about benefits of irradiation of WHO grade II meningiomas should be viewed with caution. Patients with early recurrence had worse neurological outcome. While histological and imaging characteristics provide some prognostic value, further molecular characterisation of atypical meningiomas is warranted to aid clinical decision making.

Histopathological features predictive of local control of atypical meningioma after surgery and adjuvant radiotherapy

OBEJECTIVE

The goal of this study was to investigate the impact of adjuvant radiotherapy (RT) on local recurrence and overall survival in patients undergoing primary resection of atypical meningioma, and to identify predictive factors to inform patient selection for adjuvant RT.

METHODS

One hundred eighty-two patients who underwent primary resection of atypical meningioma at a single institution between 1993 and 2014 were retrospectively identified. Patient, meningioma, and treatment data were extracted from the medical record and compared using the Kaplan-Meier method, log-rank tests, multivariate analysis (MVA) Cox proportional hazards models with relative risk (RR), and recursive partitioning analysis.

RESULTS

The median patient age and imaging follow-up were 57 years (interquartile range [IQR] 45–67 years) and 4.4 years (IQR 1.8–7.5 years), respectively. Gross-total resection (GTR) was achieved in 114 cases (63%), and 42 patients (23%) received adjuvant RT. On MVA, prognostic factors for death from any cause included GTR (RR 0.4, 95% CI 0.1–0.9, p = 0.02) and MIB1 labeling index (LI) ≤ 7% (RR 0.4, 95% CI 0.1–0.9, p = 0.04). Prognostic factors on MVA for local progression included GTR (RR 0.2, 95% CI 0.1–0.5, p = 0.002), adjuvant RT (RR 0.2, 95% CI 0.1–0.4, p < 0.001), MIB1 LI ≤ 7% (RR 0.2, 95% CI 0.1–0.5, p < 0.001), and a remote history of prior cranial RT (RR 5.7, 95% CI 1.3–18.8, p = 0.03). After GTR, adjuvant RT (0 of 10 meningiomas recurred, p = 0.01) and MIB1 LI ≤ 7% (RR 0.1, 95% CI 0.003–0.3, p < 0.001) were predictive for local progression on MVA. After GTR, 2.2% of meningiomas with MIB1 LI ≤ 7% recurred (1 of 45), compared with 38% with MIB1 LI > 7% (13 of 34; p < 0.001). Recursive partitioning analysis confirmed the existence of a cohort of patients at high risk of local progression after GTR without adjuvant RT, with MIB1 LI > 7%, and evidence of brain or bone invasion. After subtotal resection, adjuvant RT (RR 0.2, 95% CI 0.04–0.7, p = 0.009) and ≤ 5 mitoses per 10 hpf (RR 0.1, 95% CI 0.03–0.4, p = 0.002) were predictive on MVA for local progression.

CONCLUSIONS

Adjuvant RT improves local control of atypical meningioma irrespective of extent of resection. Although independent validation is required, the authors’ results suggest that MIB1 LI, the number of mitoses per 10 hpf, and brain or bone invasion may be useful guides to the selection of patients who are most likely to benefit from adjuvant RT after resection of atypical meningioma.

Impact of radiotherapy in atypical meningioma recurrence: literature review

Evaluate whether radiotherapy (RT) after the neurosurgical treatment of atypical meningiomas (AM) has an impact on the reduction rate of recurrence. A Medline search through October 2017 using "atypical meningioma" returned 1277 papers for initial review. Inclusion criteria were as follows. We analyzed the database and included articles in which the anatomic pathological classification of atypical meningiomas was in accordance with WHO 2007 or WHO 2016 criteria, patients > 18 years of age, and there was postoperative external beam radiation to the tumor bed. Exclusion criteria were WHO grade I or III meningioma, patients who underwent whole-brain radiation, RT used as salvage therapy for recurrence, palliative dose of RT (< 45 Gy), recurrent AMs, and multiple AMs. Papers reporting outcomes in which atypical and anaplastic meningiomas were analyzed together were rejected, as were papers with small samples that may compromise evaluation. After filtering our initial selection, only 17 papers were selected. After reviewing the seventeen articles including a total of 1761 patients (972 female and 799 male; 1.21 female/1.0 male), the difference in proportion of tumor recurrence between patients with and without radiotherapy after neurosurgical procedure was 1.0448, 95% CI [0.8318 to 1.3125], p value = 0.7062. On the basis of this review, there is no evidence to suggest that RT decreases the rate of recurrence in patients with atypical meningiomas.

Salvage therapy outcomes for atypical meningioma

Atypical menginomas demonstrate increased clinical aggressiveness characterized by recurrence and diminished survival. The optimal management of atypical meningioma in the recurrent setting is especially not well defined. To characterize outcomes following salvage treatment of recurrent atypical meningioma and to identify risk factors for further recurrence. Retrospective chart review was performed on 65 patients who underwent salvage treatment of atypical meningioma at a single institution. Data were analyzed using the Kaplan-Meier method and Cox proportional hazards modeling. Sixty-five patients with recurrent atypical meningioma and median imaging follow-up of 4.0 years (range 1.9-6.6 years) underwent 62 surgeries and 114 radiation treatments (RT) for salvage therapy. Salvage modality was surgery (21%), surgery/RT (25%), or RT alone (54%), associated with 2 year local freedom from recurrence (LFFR) of 36, 59, and 73%, respectively (P = 0.01). Twenty percent of patients experienced CTCAE grade ≥ 3 toxicity with salvage therapy. Thirty-nine percent of patients experienced ≥ 3 recurrences. The median disease-free survival intervals after first and second salvage treatments were 2.9 and 1.3 years, respectively. On univariate Cox analysis, prior subtotal resection, prior RT, tumor diameter > 2.5 cm, and multifocal local recurrence were associated with recurrence after salvage therapy. On multivariate logistic regression, only multifocal local recurrence was associated with further recurrence. Recurrent atypical meningioma is clinically and pathologically more aggressive than primary atypical meningioma, and the likelihood of durable local control with salvage therapy is lower. Future efforts should identify patients at risk of recurrence, and aggressive upfront treatment should be employed.

Endoscopic Endonasal Craniofacial Surgery for Recurrent Skull Base Meningiomas Involving the Pterygopalatine Fossa, the Infratemporal Fossa, the Orbit, and the Paranasal Sinus

OBJECTIVE

Skull base meningiomas carry a nonnegligible risk of recurrence. In particular, those arising from the sphenoid wings or middle cranial fossa penetrate into extracranial regions, uncommonly showing massive expansion into the craniofacial regions on recurrence. The role of endoscopic endonasal surgery for those intractable lesions remains unclear.

METHODS

We performed endoscopic endonasal craniofacial surgery for 8 recurrent meningiomas invading into the pterygopalatine fossa, infratemporal fossa, nasopharynx, paranasal sinus, or orbit, comprising 2 meningothelial and 1 fibrous meningiomas (World Health Organization [WHO] grade I), 3 atypical and 1 clear cell meningiomas (grade II), and 1 anaplastic meningioma (grade III). All were large (15-80 cm³; median, 45 cm³) and highly vascularized.

RESULTS

All 8 tumors were sufficiently resected. Gross total resection of the craniofacial part of the lesions was achieved in 5 patients (62.5%). In 3 patients with WHO grade I meningiomas and 1 with grade II, tumors were successfully controlled as of the last follow-up. In 4 patients with WHO grade II or III meningiomas, craniofacial lesions were controlled, whereas original intracranial lesions were poorly controlled and became critical.

CONCLUSIONS

We consider the endoscopic endonasal approach as an acceptable, less-invasive alternative for recurrent craniofacial meningioma. Although all these cases were relatively large and highly vascularized, preoperative endovascular embolization of the feeding arteries contributes to significantly reducing vascularity of the tumors, and local control of the craniofacial lesions was successfully achieved in all cases. Endoscopic endonasal craniofacial surgery enabled sufficient mass reduction without disfiguring facial incisions.

World Health Organization Grade II Meningiomas: The Role of Adjuvant/Salvage Gamma Knife Surgery After Initial Surgery and Prognostic Factor Assessment

OBJECTIVE

This study was performed to evaluate the efficiency of Gamma Knife surgery (GKS) on reducing recurrence of World Health Organization (WHO) grade II meningiomas after surgery and to define the risk factors associated with tumor recurrence/progression and patient's death.

METHODS

This retrospective study included 75 patients who were diagnosed with WHO grade II meningiomas after initial surgery. The Kaplan-Meier method with a log-rank test was used to calculate the survival curves. Univariate and multivariate Cox proportional hazards model were used to identify the risk factors associated with tumor recurrence/progression and patient's death.

RESULTS

The median follow-up period was 70 months. The overall survival (OS) was 97.2% at 2 years and 89.8% at 5 years. The progression-free survival (PFS) at 1, 3, and 5 years was 89.3%, 72.6%, and 59.3%, respectively. Comparing the effects on PFS and OS between different groups, there were no statistically significant differences between the surgery-alone group and the surgery with adjuvant/salvage GKS group (P = 0.512; P = 0.949). In multivariate Cox proportional hazards model analysis, extent of resection (P = 0.001) and tumor location (P = 0.015) were associated with tumor recurrence; only histologic subtypes (P = 0.005) were associated with patient's death.

CONCLUSIONS

There was no significant PFS or OS benefit for patients with WHO grade II meningiomas treated with adjuvant/salvage GKS postoperatively. Convexity meningiomas with gross total resection tended to benefit PFS. We suggest trying to achieve maximum safe gross total resection for patients with WHO grade II meningiomas, then following up closely.

Long-Term Clinical Outcomes of Pencil Beam Scanning Proton Therapy for Benign and Non-benign Intracranial Meningiomas

PURPOSE

To assess and report long-term clinical outcomes regarding local control, overall survival, and toxicity-free survival after pencil beam scanning proton therapy for intracranial meningiomas at a single institution.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Ninety-six patients (male/female, 29/67; median age 52.8 years) with intracranial meningiomas (World Health Organization [WHO] grade 1, n=61 [63.5%]; WHO grade 2, n=33 [34.4%]; WHO grade 3, n=2 [2.1%]) were treated with pencil beam scanning proton therapy (n=53 [55.2%] at diagnosis, n=17 [17.7%] at recurrence, and n=26 [27.1%] for tumor progression). Median gross tumor volume before PBSPT was 21.4 cm³ (range, 0.0-546.5 cm³), with a median planning target volume of 123.4 cm³ (range, 4.6-1142.0 cm³). Median duration of follow-up was 56.9 months (range, 12.1-207.2 months). Late toxicity was graded according to the Common Terminology Criteria for Adverse Events, version 4.0.

RESULTS

Thirteen failures (14%) (male/female, 6/7) were observed, of which the majority (n=9, 69%) were of non-benign histology. The 5-year actuarial local control and overall survival were 86.4% and 88.2%, respectively. Five-year grade ≥3 toxicity-free survival was 89.1%. On univariate analysis, local control was worse for patients with higher WHO grade (P≤.001), those treated after at least 1 recurrence (P=.006), those with non-skull base tumor location (P=.014), and males (P=.032). Significant prognosticators for 5-year overall survival were local control (P≤.001), age (P=.002), and timing of proton therapy (initial vs recurrence) (P=.002).

CONCLUSIONS

Pencil beam scanning proton therapy is an effective and safe treatment for patients with intracranial meningiomas, resulting in high local control rates with limited toxicity. Up-front radiation likely results in improved outcomes and should be considered, especially for patients with non-benign tumors and/or for those with incomplete resections.

High-precision radiotherapy for meningiomas : Long-term results and patient-reported outcome (PRO)

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate long-term outcome after high-precision radiotherapy (RT) of meningioma patients in terms of survival and side effects.

METHODS

We analyzed 275 meningioma cases: 147 low-grade and 43 high-grade meningiomas (WHO II: n = 40, III: n = 3). In all, 85 patients had no pathologically confirmed histology but were determined as low-grade based on multimodal imaging. Surgery was performed in 183 cases. RT was delivered as either radiosurgery (RS, n = 16), fractionated stereotactic radiotherapy (FSRT, n = 241), or intensity-modulated radiation therapy (IMRT, n = 18). Of 218 patients contacted for patient-reported-outcome (PRO), 207 responded (95%).

RESULTS

Median follow-up was 7.2 years. For low-grade meningioma the survival rate (OS) was 97% at 3 years, 85% at 10 years, and 64% at 15 years, for atypical meningioma 91% at 3 years, 62% at 10 years, and 50% at 15 years. Local control rate (PFS) for low-grade meningioma was 91% at 3 years, 87% at 5 years, and 86% at 10 years, for atypical cases 67% at 3 years and 55% at 5 years. Of all, 3.0% of patients reported worsened or new symptoms grade ≥3 during RT and the first 6 months thereafter; 17.5% reported a deterioration after more than 2 years. We found the prognostic factors tumor volume and age significantly influencing OS and PFS.

CONCLUSION

Complemented by PRO, we found long-term low toxicity rates in addition to excellent local control. Thus, due to the beneficial risk-benefit profile of benign and high-risk meningiomas, RT should be performed as adjuvant treatment and should not be postponed until tumor progression.