Interferon-alpha does not improve outcome at one year in patients with diffuse cutaneous scleroderma: results of a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial

Systemic sclerosis: hypothesis-driven treatment strategies

We review data from controlled trials and randomised controlled trials to examine the hypothesis for the pathogenesis of systemic sclerosis. Strategies used to treat the vascular complications in systemic sclerosis have so far shown the biggest successes, especially in the management of renal crisis and pulmonary arterial hypertension. Because these drugs have improved function and quality of life and have increased survival rates, they can truly be classified as disease-modifying compounds. Immunosuppressive therapy with cyclophosphamide in particular has also shown evidence of efficacy, and randomised controlled trials of autologous stem-cell transplantation are underway. So far, strategies to reduce or control fibrosis directly (bosentan, interferon gamma, and relaxin) have been disappointing but new strategies against fibrosis based on advanced understanding of the molecular biology of systemic sclerosis hold promise. Treatments against several cardinal features of the disorder simultaneously have not yet been examined but are being considered for future trials.

Recombinant human anti–transforming growth factor β1 antibody therapy in systemic sclerosis: A multicenter, randomized, placebo-controlled phase I/II trial of CAT-192

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate CAT-192, a recombinant human antibody that neutralizes transforming growth factor beta1 (TGFbeta1), in the treatment of early-stage diffuse cutaneous systemic sclerosis (dcSSc).

METHODS

Patients with SSc duration of <18 months were randomly assigned to the placebo group or to 1 of 3 CAT-192 treatment groups: 10 mg/kg, 5 mg/kg, 0.5 mg/kg. Infusions were given on day 0 and weeks 6, 12, and 18. The primary objective of this study was to evaluate the safety, tolerability, and pharmacokinetics of CAT-192. Secondary outcomes included the modified Rodnan skin thickness score (MRSS), the Scleroderma Health Assessment Questionnaire, assessment of organ-based disease, serum levels of soluble interleukin-2 receptor, collagen propeptides (N propeptide of type I [PINP] and type III collagen), and tissue levels of messenger RNA for procollagens I and III and for TGFbeta1 and TGFbeta2.

RESULTS

Forty-five patients were enrolled. There was significant morbidity and mortality, including 1 death in the group receiving 0.5 mg/kg of CAT-192 and 3 deaths in the group receiving 5 mg/kg of CAT-192. There were more adverse events and more serious adverse events in patients receiving CAT-192 than in those receiving placebo, although these events were not more frequent in the high-dose treatment group. The MRSS improved in all groups during the study, but there was no evidence of a treatment effect for CAT-192. Improvement in the MRSS correlated with the disease duration (r = -0.54, P = 0.0008). Changes in the PINP level from baseline correlated with changes in the MRSS (r = 0.37, P = 0.027).

CONCLUSION

We report the first evaluation of a systemically administered and repeatedly dosed anti-TGFbeta1 drug. In this pilot study, CAT-192, in doses up to 10 mg/kg, showed no evidence of efficacy. The utility of clinical and biochemical outcome measures and the feasibility of multicenter trials of early dcSSc were confirmed.

Tumor necrosis factor-alpha in psoriasis and psoriatic arthritis: a clinical, genetic, and histopathologic perspective

The successful introduction of anti-tumor necrosis factor (TNF) therapies in psoriasis and psoriatic arthritis has sharpened considerable interest in this chronic and frequently disabling disease. Unlike the situation in rheumatoid arthritis, where anti-TNF therapies were introduced after years of painstaking research which confirmed a key proinflammatory role for TNF, the evidence for TNF having a key role in psoriatic arthritis has lagged behind. In this paper, the emerging immunohistochemical, genetic, and clinical literature relating to TNF's role in skin and joint manifestations of this disease is reviewed and areas for future research are suggested.

Life-threatening dermatoses due to connective tissue disorders

Connective tissue disorders such as scleroderma, dermatomyositis and lupus erythematosus are autoimmune, multi-system disorders whose clinical manifestations can be restricted to the skin or may involve many organs. The degree and rate of organ system involvement defer, as does the prognosis and rapidity of disease progression. In this article, scleroderma, dermatomyositis and lupus erythematosus will be reviewed in respect to their life-threatening potential.

High-dose immunosuppressive therapy and autologous progenitor cell transplantation for systemic sclerosis

High-dose immunosuppressive therapy aimed at immunoablation, given together with autologous stem cell transplantation, has resulted in prolonged (>3 years) improvements of skin thickening and functional ability, together with a stabilization of pulmonary function in two-thirds of treated patients with severe systemic sclerosis. Transplant-related mortality occurred in 17% of the first cohort of 41 patients reported to the European Group for Blood and Marrow Transplantation, which included cases from the United States, but this figure has dropped to 8.7% in a recent retrospective analysis of 57 transplants performed in Europe. Similar outcomes were reported in multicentre studies from the United States of 19 patients, and from France of 12 patients, with improvements in skin scores and functional assessments, together with a stabilization of internal organ dysfunction. Based on the results of these phase I/II studies, multicentre prospective randomized trials are being planned or are in progress in Europe and the United States employing uniform patient entry criteria and outcome parameters. The aim of these studies is to compare the clinical benefits and safety of transplant regimens versus conventional chemotherapy in patients with severe systemic sclerosis who are at risk of life-threatening organ failure and premature mortality. Eligibility criteria include a diagnosis of diffuse systemic sclerosis of recent onset and major organ (heart, kidney, lungs) involvement according to predefined criteria. The prospective randomized trials address two issues related to the treatment of severe systemic sclerosis: is intensive immunosuppressive therapy superior to conventional therapy, and can self-tolerance be re-established?

Altered neurological function in mice immunized with early endosome antigen 1

BACKGROUND

Autoantibodies directed against the 160 kDa endosome protein early endosome antigen 1 (EEA1) are seen in patients with neurological diseases. To determine if antibodies to EEA1 have a neuropathological effect, mice from three major histocompatibility haplotype backgrounds (H2q, H2b and H2d) were immunized with EEA1 (amino acids 82-1411) that was previously shown to contain the target EEA1 epitopes. The mice were then subjected to five neuro-behavioural tests: grid walking, forelimb strength, open field, reaching and rotarod.

RESULTS

The immunized SWR/J mice with sustained anti-EEA1 antibodies had significantly reduced forelimb strength than the control non-immune mice of the same strain, and BALB/CJ immune mice demonstrated significantly more forelimb errors on the grid walk test than the control group.

CONCLUSIONS

Antibodies to recombinant EEA1 in mice may mediate neurological deficits that are consistent with clinical features of some humans that spontaneously develop anti-EEA1 autoantibodies.

The assessment of the patient with systemic sclerosis

Systemic sclerosis presents a great deal of variability among different patients in the extent of skin and internal organ involvement, the pace of the disease and consequently, the prognosis. In addition, the single patient, during his/her disease course, can present with distinct manifestations. Each patient must, therefore, be carefully investigated. The assessment should be adapted to the setting, i.e. clinical practice, clinical investigation, therapeutic trials. The clinician cannot confine the diagnostic process to labelling the disease. He must define the subset, the extent of internal organ involvement, and the type of lesions underlying the clinical manifestations, i.e. fibrotic lesions, reflecting irreversible damage should be separated from active lesions (such as alveolitis) which can be reversed by drug treatment. The clinical investigator must assure that his/her patients are comparable to other series. ACR criteria have been shown to not assure such comparability. To this purpose, a core set of variables to be assessed in any clinical investigation study has been proposed. Finally, the clinical researcher should enrol patients with active disease and must rely for his/her conclusions on feasible and sensitive to change measures. An OMERACT committee has recently reviewed the literature selecting those ready for use in clinical trials.

Scleroderma en coup de sabre with central nervous system and ophthalmologic involvement: treatment of ocular symptoms with interferon gamma

Scleroderma en coup de sabre, a variant of localized scleroderma, is a disorder of unknown origin characterized by fibrosis of connective tissue. Rare complications of scleroderma en coup de sabre are orbital and intracerebral involvement. We describe a patient with scleroderma en coup de sabre in whom intracerebral and orbital lesions developed after 2 decades of disease duration. Clinically, she had epilepsy, impaired vision, and retro-ocular pain of the affected eye. A 12-month course of interferon-gamma stopped progression of visual symptoms caused by orbital fibrous tissue. To our knowledge, this is the first patient with scleroderma en coup de sabre complicated by orbital involvement who was successfully treated with interferon-gamma.

Update on disease-modifying antirheumatic drugs in the treatment of systemic sclerosis

Treatment of systemic sclerosis has been somewhat haphazard and treatment has often been "borrowed" from the experience gained from treating other connective tissue diseases. There was a period of time that was focused mainly on organ-specific manifestations of systemic sclerosis and some advance in preventing vital organ damage (such as renal crisis) was achieved. The vast improvement in mortality from the use of ACE inhibitors raises one's hopes for other effective therapeutic interventions. At this juncture, the evidence is strong that the ACE inhibitors that are used in scleroderma renal crisis are disease-modifying, even without proving it by a randomized controlled trial. The evidence is strong that the use of epoprostenol for primary pulmonary hypertension is life-saving; however, whether epoprostenol is life-saving in the pulmonary hypertension in scleroderma remains to be proven. There are suggestions that bosentan (for the pulmonary hypertension of scleroderma), cyclophosphamide (for SSc alveolitis), stem cell transplant, interferon-gamma (for interstitial pulmonary fibrosis), and methotrexate (for the skin thickening of diffuse scleroderma) may improve organ function or functional activities, but whether they are truly disease-modifying remains to be proven. As we increase our understanding of the pathophysiology of systemic sclerosis and we learn how better to design trials for systemic sclerosis, we may be more successful in developing optimal disease-modifying therapy. Although the treatment of systemic sclerosis remains difficult, there are an increasing number of potentially effective regimens that are undergoing clinical investigations. A rational approach to therapy seems possible, based on a hypothesis of the pathogenesis of systemic sclerosis. Thus, there is accumulating evidence that supports the use of prostacyclin derivatives to treat systemic sclerosis, some evidence that antifibrotic regimens may be effective, and moderate evidence that immunosuppression also may be effective in certain stages of this disease.

Interstitial lung disease in scleroderma

Pulmonary fibrosis occurs most patients who have scleroderma. It progresses to severe restrictive lung disease in about 15% of patients and remains a major cause of death in this disease. Risks for developing pulmonary fibrosis include diffuse cutaneous scleroderma and anti-Scl-70 antibodies, and risks for developing progressive pulmonary fibrosis and death include low pulmonary function test results at presentation and lung inflammation. Early evaluation of the extent and severity of pulmonary fibrosis and the presence of lung inflammation is key, so that therapy can be given to patients who are at higher risk of progressive pulmonary fibrosis before they develop severe functional impairment occurs. Evaluation often includes pulmonary function tests, HRCT of the lungs, Doppler echocardiogram, and bronchoalveolar lavage. For patients who are unwilling or unable to participate in therapeutic trials that target pulmonary fibrosis in scleroderma, therapy with oral or intravenous cyclophosphamide is often given.

[Interferon-alpha and auto-immunity]

PURPOSE

To assess the role of endogenous interferon alpha (IFN) in auto-immune experimental models and human diseases, and to evaluate its iatrogenic potential as a therapeutic agent.

MAIN POINTS

IFN is a cytokine involved in cellular immunity, that promotes both differentiation of dendritic cells and the TH1 pathway. Auto-immune side-effects of recombinant IFN depend on IFN dosage and the pathology concerned. The spectrum extends from occurrence of auto-antibodies in an asymptomatic patient to overt disease such as systemic lupus. Antigenic targets of auto-antibodies are diverse: blood cells coagulation factors, immunoglobulin, hormones, intrinsic factor, intracellular components. Thyroiditis is the most frequently reported auto-immune disease occurring during IFN treatment, including hypothyroidism, hyperthyroidism or a bi-phasic pattern. Currently, true incidence of thyroiditis remains debated. It appears very low (under 1%) in hepatologic series using low-dose IFN. The fact that auto-immunity may be related to the treated disease--before use of IFN--must also be addressed: e.g. antinuclear factors and anti-DNA antibodies in chronic myeloid leukemia or anti-actin and anti-LKM antibodies in chronic C hepatitis.

FUTURE PROSPECTS

Recombinant alpha interferon appears more as a trigger than a de novo inducer of auto-immune disorders. Its use as an immunomodulator agent should be treated with caution.

Statistical presentation and analysis of ordered categorical outcome data in rheumatology journals

OBJECTIVE

To assess the appropriateness of presentation of summary measures and analysis of ordered categorical (ordinal) data in three rheumatology journals in 1999, and to consider differences between basic and clinical science articles.

METHODS

Six hundred forty-four full-length articles from the 1999 editions of 3 rheumatology journals were evaluated for inclusion of an ordinal outcome. Articles were classified as basic or clinical science, and the appropriateness of presentation and analysis of the ordinal outcome were assessed. Chi-square tests were used to evaluate difference in percentages.

RESULTS

Ordinal outcomes were identified in 175 (27.2%) of 644 articles. Only 69 (39.4%) had appropriate data presentation, and 111 (63.4%) had appropriate data analysis. Appropriate presentation was seen less commonly in the basic science rather than the clinical science articles, but differences in the occurrence of appropriate analysis were not seen.

CONCLUSION

Ordinal data are common in rheumatology articles, but presentation usually does not conform to recommended guidelines.

Treatment of systemic sclerosis

Systemic sclerosis is an extremely variable disease in its manifestations and consequently, treatment needs to be individualized depending on the specific problems that each patient has. Limited scleroderma patients have a prolonged duration of Raynaud's phenomenon and puffy fingers before they develop any skin thickening, digital ulcers or gastrointestinal symptoms. They are likely to present with all the classic manifestations of scleroderma. Diffuse scleroderma patients have a much more acute systemic onset with marked whole hand swelling and may initially have only subtle skin thickening. A good understanding of the differences between the natural history of limited and diffuse scleroderma will enable the physician to treat present problems and anticipate future ones more effectively. One should determine which major subset and organ systems are involved before deciding on the appropriate therapy. Advances in organ-specific therapy, particularly calcium channel antagonists in Raynaud's phenomenon, proton pump inhibitors in esophageal reflux, intravenous iloprost and endothelin receptor antagonists in pulmonary hypertension, and ACE inhibitors in renal crisis, have decreased morbidity and mortality in patients with scleroderma. Studies of aggressive therapies to prevent or improve pulmonary fibrosis are in progress. Further clinical experience in wound healing, gastrointestinal malabsorption and physical therapy for loss of motion has helped patients to have a more comfortable life. In recent years, a significant number of controlled clinical trials have been performed and there has been improved understanding of the best way to perform studies and of which patients are most likely to respond to therapy. Penicillamine, methotrexate, photopheresis, relaxin, interferons, and cyclosporine have all been studied in controlled trials with variable outcomes. Although an overall remittive therapy has not yet been determined, new, potentially useful agents are being investigated.

Design and quality considerations for randomized controlled trials in systemic sclerosis

OBJECTIVE

To appraise systematically randomized controlled trials (RCTs) on systemic sclerosis (SSc) in order to determine whether the parameter of study design and its quality may influence the reporting of efficacy for tested interventions.

METHODS

Seventy RCTs were analyzed (1965-2000) in terms of design, patient characteristics, outcomes, and reported results.

RESULTS

Median sample size was 28 patients. Fifty-nine trials were double blind, but only 16 mentioned the randomization mode and only 7 described allocation concealment. There was sufficient information on withdrawals in 37 trials. Larger trials with longer followup scored higher on quality characteristics, but had higher withdrawal rates. Only 8 trials had a followup of more than 1 year. Significant efficacy was less likely to be reported in double-blind studies (P = 0.029) and in studies with larger rates of withdrawal (P = 0.032). Specification of the following parameters improved over time: power calculations (P = 0.0003), outcomes (P = 0.001), and sample size per arm (P = 0.011).

CONCLUSIONS

Several aspects of the quality of design and conduct of SSc RCTs can be improved. Adequately powered trials with longer followup and clear outcomes are needed.

Recognition and management of scleroderma in children

Juvenile scleroderma is a rare disease of childhood. The 2 main forms are localised and systemic scleroderma, although the pathogenesis of both forms is still unclear. The main clinical characteristic is the presence of skin sclerosis. Localised scleroderma can be divided into 3 different subtypes: morphoea, linear scleroderma and 'coup de sabre' lesions. The incidence is 0.2 to 0.4 per 100,000. 25 to 40% of patients are rheumatoid factor positive and 23 to 67% antinuclear antibody positive. An increased number of eosinophils occur in 31% of patients. Systemic sclerosis is an even rarer disease; approximately 10% of patients evolve the disease before the age of 18 years. The clinical presentation and disease course differ from the adult disease. This is reflected in the much better outcome. With regard to therapeutic options, there is still no gold standard for either form of the disease.

Treating systemic sclerosis in 2001

Systemic sclerosis (SS) is characterized by sclerosis of the dermis and internal organs and by vascular abnormalities. Although the pathophysiology of the disease has been partly elucidated, the efficacy of long-term treatments remains limited, with no significant increase in survival in prospective studies. Conventional drug treatments are disappointing in clinical practice, and in a recent prospective randomized study standard-dose D-penicillamine was not more effective than mini-dose D-penicillamine. New long-term treatments are emerging for diffuse SS, including cyclophosphamide for patients with progressive interstitial lung disease or stem cell transplantation for those with early organ involvement. The most effective treatments remain symptomatic, such as angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitors for acute renal crisis, calcium channel antagonists for Raynaud's phenomenon, and proton pump inhibitors for the complications of gastroesophageal reflux. This review article focuses on long-term treatments that are most likely to be effective and suggests symptomatic treatment strategies tailored to specific organ involvements.

Juvenile systemic scleroderma

Systemic scleroderma in children is very rare and is considered similar to adult-onset disease. In adults, new etiopathogenetic and therapeutic approaches have emerged in recent years. For instance, it has been shown that microchimerism could play a role in disease pathogenesis and that immunoablation followed by stem cell rescue could be of potential therapeutic benefit. There is also evidence that these new approaches can be of value for childhood-onset disease.

Phase I/II trial of autologous stem cell transplantation in systemic sclerosis: procedure related mortality and impact on skin disease

BACKGROUND

Systemic sclerosis (SSc, scleroderma) in either its diffuse or limited skin forms has a high mortality when vital organs are affected. No treatment has been shown to influence the outcome or significantly affect the skin score, though many forms of immunosuppression have been tried. Recent developments in haemopoietic stem cell transplantation (HSCT) have allowed the application of profound immunosuppression followed by HSCT, or rescue, to autoimmune diseases such as SSc.

METHODS

Results for 41 patients included in continuing multicentre open phase I/II studies using HSCT in the treatment of poor prognosis SSc are reported. Thirty seven patients had a predominantly diffuse skin form of the disease and four the limited form, with some clinical overlap. Median age was 41 years with a 5:1 female to male ratio. The skin score was >50% of maximum in 20/33 (61%) patients, with some lung disease attributable to SSc in 28/37 (76%), the forced vital capacity being <70% of the predicted value in 18/36 (50%). Pulmonary hypertension was described in 7/37 (19%) patients and renal disease in 5/37 (14%). The Scl-70 antibody was positive in 18/32 (56%) and the anticentromere antibody in 10% of evaluable patients. Peripheral blood stem cell mobilisation was performed with cyclophosphamide or granulocyte colony stimulating factor, alone or in combination. Thirty eight patients had ex vivo CD34 stem cell selection, with additional T cell depletion in seven. Seven conditioning regimens were used, but six of these used haemoimmunoablative doses of cyclophosphamide +/- anti-thymocyte globulin +/- total body irradiation. The median duration of follow up was 12 months (3-55).

RESULTS

An improvement in skin score of >25% after transplantation occurred in 20/29 (69%) evaluable patients, and deterioration in 2/29 (7%). Lung function did not change significantly after transplantation. One of five renal cases deteriorated but with no new occurrences of renal disease after HSCT, and the pulmonary hypertension did not progress in the evaluable cases. Disease progression was seen in 7/37 (19%) patients after HSCT with a median period of 67 (range 49-255) days. Eleven (27%) patients had died at census and seven (17%) deaths were considered to be related to the procedure (direct organ toxicity in four, haemorrhage in two, and infection/neutropenic fever in one). The cumulative probability of survival at one year was 73% (95% CI 58 to 88) by Kaplan-Meier analysis.

CONCLUSION

Despite a higher procedure related mortality rate from HSCT in SSc compared with patients with breast cancer and non-Hodgkin's lymphoma, the marked impact on skin score, a surrogate marker of mortality, the trend towards stabilisation of lung involvement, and lack of other treatment alternatives justify further carefully designed studies. If future trials incorporate inclusion and exclusion criteria based on this preliminary experience, the predicted procedure related mortality should be around 10%.

The interferons

The interferons are a group of naturally occurring biologic response modifiers that exhibit antiviral, antiproliferative, differentiating, and immune-enhancing properties. This interesting group of compounds has been found to be effective for the treatment of condylomata acuminata, skin cancers, high-risk melanoma, hepatitis C, mycosis fungoides, and keloid scars. The advantages of these agents must be weighed against their toxicities, the number of treatments, and cost.

Diffuse and limited cutaneous systemic scleroderma

Juvenile systemic scleroderma (jSSc) is a rare disease. Based on the first large data collection on this patient group, the disease course was demonstrated to differ from that in adults. The concept of persistence of maternal cells in patients with SSc remains pathogenetically fascinating, as does the resemblance with graft-versus-host-disease. In view of new therapeutic options, controlled trials have not established a gold standard for treatment, but autologous bone marrow transplantation may be considered a rescue therapy for selected patients. Palliative therapies have also improved markedly in recent years. The first controlled trials for patients with jSSc are being proposed.

Scleroderma and related disorders: therapeutic aspects

Improvements in management of systemic sclerosis have occurred through a growing understanding of pathogenic events accompanied by advances in diagnosis and assessment, as well as developments in organ-based therapeutics. Unfortunately, disease-modifying therapies of proven efficacy remain elusive and several agents in current use have been shown in well-controlled clinical trials to be of questionable benefit. More positively, there have been advances in the treatment of major visceral complications such as renal crisis, pulmonary fibrosis, pulmonary hypertension, gastrointestinal involvement and in the management of scleroderma-associated Raynaud's phenomenon. Current approaches are reviewed, evidence supporting or refuting the use of putative disease-modifying agents is discussed, and new strategies are described that are currently being considered for this fascinating but complex multisystem connective tissue disease.

Novel therapeutic strategies in scleroderma

Optimal management for scleroderma (systemic sclerosis) is likely to require treatment of the underlying disease process, which remains incompletely understood, and also of the organ-based complications of this heterogeneous condition. Clinical trials evaluating several potential agents have been completed recently, including D-penicillamine and interferon alpha. Unfortunately none of these studies has suggested significant efficacy. This article focuses on new treatment approaches using existing therapeutic agents, such as prostacyclin, and considers the potential usefulness of new agents (eg, relaxin, halofuginone) or strategies such as intensive immunosuppression with peripheral stem cell rescue. Ultimately, a better understanding of disease pathogenesis may facilitate the development of targeted therapy against key events or mediators, but for the present better evaluation of existing agents and a focus on optimizing protocols for organ-based complications, such as pulmonary vascular disease or hypertensive renal crisis, are important goals.