Nonhomologous RNA recombination in a cell-free system: evidence for a transesterification mechanism guided by secondary structure

Paradoxes of the replication of picornaviral genomes

A wealth of experimental data on the mechanism of the picornavirus genome replication has accumulated. Not infrequently, however, conclusions derived from these data appear to contradict each other. On the one hand, initiation of a complementary RNA strand can be demonstrated to occur in a solution containing only the poliovirus RNA polymerase, VPg, uridine triphosphate, poly(A) template and appropriate ions. On the other hand, convincing experiments suggest that efficient initiation of a viral complementary RNA strand requires complex cis-acting signals on the viral RNA template, additional viral and possibly cellular proteins as well as a membrane-containing environment. On the one hand, there is evidence that the viral RNA, in order to be replicated, should first be translated, but on the other hand, the viral RNA polymerase appears to be unable to overcome the ribosome barrier. Possible solutions for these and several other similar paradoxes are discussed, along with less contradictory results on the properties of the picornaviral replicative proteins. Recent results suggesting that recombination and other rearrangements of the viral RNA genomes may be accomplished not only by the replicative template switching but also by nonreplicative mechanisms are also briefly reviewed.

'Primer alignment-and-extension': a novel mechanism of viral RNA recombination responsible for the rescue of inactivated poliovirus cDNA clones

In the course of experiments designed to assess the potential role of alternative open reading frames (ORF) present in the 5'-terminal untranslated region (5'-UTR) of poliovirus type 1 (Mahoney strain) genomic RNA, we came across a double mutation that completely abrogated the infectivity of full-length cDNA clones. The infectivity was rescued in trans by cotransfecting COS-1 cells with short RNA transcripts of the wild-type 5'-UTR of poliovirus type 2 Lansing, provided a free 3'-OH was available. Direct sequencing of the viral RNA revealed that the infectious viruses recovered were recombinants Lansing/Mahoney, with variable points of 'crossing-over'. A novel mechanism of RNA-RNA recombination, which we propose to call 'primer alignment-and-extension', is described that would explain the high rate of recombination of RNA viruses observed in natural conditions.

Spontaneous rearrangements in RNA sequences

The ability of RNAs to spontaneously rearrange their sequences under physiological conditions is demonstrated using the molecular colony technique, which allows single RNA molecules to be detected provided that they are amplifiable by the replicase of bacteriophage Qbeta. The rearrangements are Mg2+-dependent, sequence-non-specific, and occur both in trans and in cis at a rate of 10(-9) h(-1) per site. The results suggest that the mechanism of spontaneous RNA rearrangements differs from the transesterification reactions earlier observed in the presence of Qbeta replicase, and have a number of biologically important implications.

Genetics, Pathogenesis and Evolution of Picornaviruses

The discovery of viruses heralded an exciting new era for research in the medical and biological sciences. It has been realized that the cellular receptor guiding a virus to a target cell cannot be the sole determinant of a virus's pathogenic potential. Comparative analyses of the structures of genomes and their products have placed the picornaviruses into a large “picorna-like” virus family, in which they occupy a prominent place. Most human picornavirus infections are self-limiting, yet the enormously high rate of picornavirus infections in the human population can lead to a significant incidence of disease complications that may be permanently debilitating or even fatal. Picornaviruses employ one of the simplest imaginable genetic systems: they consist of single-stranded RNA that encodes only a single multidomain polypeptide, the polyprotein. The RNA is packaged into a small, rigid, naked, and icosahedral virion whose proteins are unmodified except for a myristate at the N-termini of VP4. The RNA itself does not contain modified bases. The key to ultimately understanding picornaviruses may be to rationalize the huge amount of information about these viruses from the perspective of evolution. It is possible that the replicative apparatus of picornaviruses originated in the precellular world and was subsequently refined in the course of thousands of generations in a slowly evolving environment. Picornaviruses cultivated the art of adaptation, which has allowed them to “jump” into new niches offered in the biological world.

In vitro characterization of late steps of RNA recombination in turnip crinkle virus. I. Role of motif1-hairpin structure

Molecular mechanisms of RNA recombination were studied in turnip crinkle carmovirus (TCV), which has a uniquely high recombination frequency and nonrandom crossover site distribution among the recombining TCV-associated satellite RNAs. An in vitro system has been developed that includes a partially purified TCV replicase preparation (RdRp) and chimeric RNAs that resemble the putative in vivo recombination intermediates (Nagy, P. D., Zhang, C., and Simon, A. E. EMBO J. 17, 2392-2403, 1998). This system generates 3'-terminal extension products, which are analogous to the recombination end products. Efficient generation of 3'-terminal extension products depends on the presence of a hairpin structure (termed the motif1-hairpin) that possibly binds to the RdRp. Replacement of the motif1-hairpin with two separate randomized sequences resulted in a basal level of 3'-terminal extension. By using three separate constructs, each carrying similar mutations in the motif1-hairpin, we demonstrate that the role of the motif1-hairpin in 3'-terminal extension is complex and its function is influenced by flanking sequences. In addition to the mutagenesis approach, competition experiments between wild-type and mutated motif1-hairpin constructs suggest that the TCV RdRp likely recognizes the secondary and/or tertiary structure of the motif1-hairpin, while individual nucleotides play a less important role. Overall, the data shed new light into the mechanism of 3'-terminal extension by a viral RdRp that is analogous to the late steps of RNA recombination in TCV.

Genome instability in BVDV: an examination of the sequence and structural influences on RNA recombination

The cytopathogenic biotype of the pestivirus, bovine viral diarrhea virus, is frequently a product of nonhomologous recombination in the region of the genome encoding the viral NS2-NS3 proteins. The possibility that sequences or structures in this region contributed to a hotspot for RNA recombination was examined. A PCR-based strategy was used to examine viral genomic RNA isolated from tissue samples of cattle persistently infected with the noncytopathogenic biotype of the virus. Analysis of two different regions of the viral genome revealed that recombination was not restricted to particular sequences. Alignment of the genomic sequences undergoing recombination and examination of the predicted secondary structures of the participating RNAs revealed that the dissociation of partial, newly synthesized negative strand RNAs from the positive strand template occurred at many different sites on the molecule. Similarly, it appeared that the reassociation of the RNA polymerase complex with a second positive strand template was frequently influenced by short regions of homology between the nascent RNA strand and open secondary structures in the template molecule.

Non-homologous recombination mediated by Thermus aquaticus DNA polymerase I. Evidence supporting a copy choice mechanism

RT-PCR amplification of P450 2C6 from rat liver, using primers in opposite orientations of exon 6, resulted in PCR products containing segments of exons joined at non-consensus splice sites. Moreover, many of the PCR products identified were composed of not only a single region containing exonic segments joined at non-consensus splice sites but, instead, of several repeats of the non-canonically joined region. To investigate whether these PCR products represent pre-existing molecules or are generated during the amplification process, the liver cDNA template was replaced by a plasmid containing the P450 2C6 cDNA. Surprisingly, PCR products containing repeats of non-canonically joined exonic segments were again revealed. In some cases the position of this non-canonical joining was a sequence of one or two identical nucleotides; however, there were also a number of products lacking any nucleotide identity at the position of joining. DNA nicking and/or DNA damage is thought to favour recombination during PCR, probably by misalignment of incomplete DNA strands; however, the presence of multiple repeats of the recombined region in the PCR products identified suggests a certain repetitiveness of the underlying mechanism. It is therefore proposed that these products result from a template switching event that occurs several times during a single polymerization step, following a rolling circle model of DNA synthesis.

Dissecting RNA recombination in vitro: role of RNA sequences and the viral replicase

Molecular mechanisms of RNA recombination were studied in turnip crinkle carmovirus (TCV), which has a uniquely high recombination frequency and non-random crossover site distribution among the recombining TCV-associated satellite RNAs. To test the previously proposed replicase-driven template-switching mechanism for recombination, a partially purified TCV replicase preparation (RdRp) was programed with RNAs resembling the putative in vivo recombination intermediates. Analysis of the in vitro RdRp products revealed efficient generation of 3'-terminal extension products. Initiation of 3'-terminal extension occurred at or close to the base of a hairpin that was a recombination hotspot in vivo. Efficient generation of the 3'-terminal extension products depended on two factors: (i) a hairpin structure in the acceptor RNA region and (ii) a short base-paired region formed between the acceptor RNA and the nascent RNA synthesized from the donor RNA template. The hairpin structure bound to the RdRp, and thus is probably involved in its recruitment. The probable role of the base-paired region is to hold the 3' terminus near the RdRp bound to the hairpin structure to facilitate 3'-terminal extension. These regions were also required for in vivo RNA recombination between TCV-associated sat-RNA C and sat-RNA D, giving crucial and direct support for a replicase-driven template-switching mechanism of RNA recombination.

Rescue of the RNA phage genome from RNase III cleavage

The secondary structure of the RNA from the single-stranded RNA bacteriophages, like MS2 and Qb, has evolved to serve a variety of functions such as controlling gene expression, exposing binding sites for the replicase and capsid proteins, allowing strand separation and so forth. On the other hand, all of these foldings have to perform in bacterial cells in which various RNA splitting enzymes are present. We therefore examined whether phage RNA structure is under selective pressure by host RNases. Here we show this to be true for RNase III. A fully double-stranded hairpin of 17 bp, which is an RNase III target, was inserted into a non-coding region of the MS2 RNA genome. In an RNase III-host these phages survived but in wild-type bacteria they did not. Here the stem underwent Darwinian evolution to a structure that was no longer a substrate for RNase III. This was achieved in three different ways: (i) the perfect stem was maintained but shortened by removing all or most of the insert; (ii) the stem acquired suppressor mutations that replaced Watson-Crick base pairs by mismatches; (iii) the stem acquired small deletions or insertions that created bulges. These insertions consist of short stretches of non-templated A or U residues. Their origin is ascribed to polyadenylation at the site of the RNase III cut (in the + or - strand) either by Escherichia coli poly(A) polymerase or by idling MS2 replicase.