Evaluation of Gas-Phase Rearrangement and Competing Fragmentation Reactions on Protein Phosphorylation Site Assignment Using Collision Induced Dissociation-MS/MS and MS3

Enhanced characterization of singly protonated phosphopeptide ions by femtosecond laser-induced ionization/dissociation tandem mass spectrometry (fs-LID-MS/MS)

To develop an improved understanding of the regulatory role that post-translational modifications (PTMs) involving phosphorylation play in the maintenance of normal cellular function, tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) strategies coupled with ion activation techniques such as collision-induced dissociation (CID) and electron-transfer dissociation (ETD) are typically employed to identify the presence and site-specific locations of the phosphate moieties within a given phosphoprotein of interest. However, the ability of these techniques to obtain sufficient structural information for unambiguous phosphopeptide identification and characterization is highly dependent on the ion activation method employed and the properties of the precursor ion that is subjected to dissociation. Herein, we describe the application of a recently developed alternative ion activation technique for phosphopeptide analysis, termed femtosecond laser-induced ionization/dissociation (fs-LID). In contrast to CID and ETD, fs-LID is shown to be particularly suited to the analysis of singly protonated phosphopeptide ions, yielding a wide range of product ions including a, b, c, x, y, and z sequence ions, as well as ions that are potentially diagnostic of the positions of phosphorylation (e.g., 'a(n)+1-98'). Importantly, the lack of phosphate moiety losses or phosphate group 'scrambling' provides unambiguous information for sequence identification and phosphorylation site characterization. Therefore, fs-LID-MS/MS can serve as a complementary technique to established methodologies for phosphoproteomic analysis.

Gas-phase rearrangements do not affect site localization reliability in phosphoproteomics data sets

Intramolecular transfer of phosphate during collision-induced dissociation (CID) in ion-trap mass spectrometers has recently been described. Because phosphorylation events are assigned to discrete serine, threonine, and tyrosine residues based on the presence of site-determining ions in MS/MS spectra, phosphate transfer may invalidate or confound site localization in published large-scale phosphorylation data sets. Here, we present evidence for the occurrence of this phenomenon using synthetic phosphopeptide libraries, specifically for doubly charged species. We found, however, that the extent of the transfer reaction was insufficient to cause localization of phosphorylation sites to incorrect residues. We further compared CID to electron-transfer dissociation (ETD) for site localization using synthetic libraries and a large-scale yeast phosphoproteome experiment. The agreement in site localization was >99.5 and 93%, respectively, suggesting that ETD-based site localization is no more reliable than CID. We conclude that intramolecular phosphate transfer does not affect the reliability of current or past phosphorylation data sets.

Subcellular phosphoproteomics

Protein phosphorylation represents one of the most extensively studied post-translational modifications, primarily due to the emergence of sensitive methods enabling the detection of this modification both in vitro and in vivo. The availability of enrichment methods combined with sensitive mass spectrometry instrumentation has played a crucial role in uncovering the dynamic changes and the large expanding repertoire of this reversible modification. The structural changes imparted by the phosphorylation of specific residues afford exquisite mechanisms for the regulation of protein functions by modulating new binding sites on scaffold proteins or by abrogating protein-protein interactions. However, the dynamic interplay of protein phosphorylation is not occurring randomly within the cell but is rather finely orchestrated by specific kinases and phosphatases that are unevenly distributed across subcellular compartments. This spatial separation not only regulates protein phosphorylation but can also control the activity of other enzymes and the transfer of other post-translational modifications. While numerous large-scale phosphoproteomics studies highlighted the extent and diversity of phosphoproteins present in total cell lysates, the further understanding of their regulation and biological activities require a spatio-temporal resolution only achievable through subcellular fractionation. This review presents a first account of the emerging field of subcellular phosphoproteomics where cell fractionation approaches are combined with sensitive mass spectrometry methods to facilitate the identification of low abundance proteins and to unravel the intricate regulation of protein phosphorylation.

Targeted proteomics by selected reaction monitoring mass spectrometry: applications to systems biology and biomarker discovery

Mass Spectrometry-based proteomics is now considered a relatively established strategy for protein analysis, ranging from global expression profiling to the identification of protein complexes and specific post-translational modifications. Recently, Selected Reaction Monitoring Mass Spectrometry (SRM-MS) has become increasingly popular in proteome research for the targeted quantification of proteins and post-translational modifications. Using triple quadrupole instrumentation (QqQ), specific analyte molecules are targeted in a data-directed mode. Used routinely for the quantitative analysis of small molecular compounds for at least three decades, the technology is now experiencing broadened application in the proteomics community. In the current review, we will provide a detailed summary of current developments in targeted proteomics, including some of the recent applications to biological research and biomarker discovery.

Separation of peptide isomers with variant modified sites by high-resolution differential ion mobility spectrometry

Many proteins and proteolytic peptides incorporate the same post-translational modification (PTM) at different sites, creating multiple localization variants with different functions or activities that may coexist in cells. Current analytical methods based on liquid chromatography (LC) followed by tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) are challenged by such isomers that often coelute in LC and/or produce nonunique fragment ions. The application of ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) was explored, but success has been limited by insufficient resolution. We show that high-resolution differential ion mobility spectrometry (FAIMS) employing helium-rich gases can readily separate phosphopeptides with variant modification sites. Use of He/N(2) mixtures containing up to 74% He has allowed separating to >95% three monophosphorylated peptides of identical sequence. Similar separation was achieved at 50% He, using an elevated electric field. Bisphosphorylated isomers that differ in only one modification site were separated to the same extent. We anticipate FAIMS capabilities for such separations to extend to other PTMs.

EZYprep LC-coupled MALDI-TOF/TOF MS: an improved matrix spray application for phosphopeptide characterisation

The quality of MALDI-TOF mass spectrometric analysis is highly dependent on the matrix and its deposition strategy. Although different matrix-deposition methods have specific advantages, one major problem in the field of proteomics, particularly with respect to quantitation, is reproducibility between users or laboratories. Compounding this is the varying crystal homogeneity of matrices depending on the deposition strategy used. Here, we describe a novel optimised matrix-deposition strategy for LC-MALDI-TOF/TOF MS using an automated instrument that produces a nebulised matrix "mist" under controlled atmospheric conditions. Comparisons of this with previously reported strategies showed the method to be advantageous for the atypical matrix, 2,5-DHB, and improved phosphopeptide ionisation when compared with deposition strategies for CHCA. This optimised DHB matrix-deposition strategy with LC-MALDI-TOF/TOF MS, termed EZYprep LC, was subsequently optimised for phosphoproteome analysis and compared to LC-ESI-IT-MS and a previously reported approach for phosphotyrosine identification and characterisation. These methods were used to map phosphorylation on epidermal growth factor-stimulated epidermal growth factor receptor to gauge the sensitivity of the proposed method. EZYprep DHB LC-MALDI-TOF/TOF MS was able to identify more phosphopeptides and characterise more phosphorylation sites than the other two proteomic strategies, thus proving to be a sensitive approach for phosphoproteome analysis.

Label-free liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry analysis with automated phosphopeptide enrichment reveals dynamic human milk protein phosphorylation during lactation

Protein phosphorylation is a critical posttranslational modification that affects cell-cell signaling and protein function. However, quantifying the relative site-specific changes of phosphorylation occupancies remains a major issue. An online enrichment of phosphopeptides using titanium dioxide incorporated in a microchip liquid chromatography device was used to analyze trypsin-digested human milk proteins with mass spectrometry. The method was validated with standards and used to determine the dynamic behavior of protein phosphorylation in human milk from the first month of lactation. α-Casein, β-casein, osteopontin, and chordin-like protein 2 phosphoproteins were shown to vary during this lactation time in an independent manner. In addition, changes in specific regions of these phosphoproteins were found to vary independently. Novel phosphorylation sites were discovered for chordin-like protein 2, α-lactalbumin, β-1,4-galactosyl transferase, and poly-Ig (immunoglobulin) receptor. Coefficients of variation for the quantitation were comparable to those in other contemporary approaches using isotopically labeled peptides, with a median value of 11% for all phosphopeptide occupancies quantified.

Assay development for the determination of phosphorylation stoichiometry using multiple reaction monitoring methods with and without phosphatase treatment: application to breast cancer signaling pathways

We have developed a phosphatase-based phosphopeptide quantitation (PPQ) method for determining phosphorylation stoichiometry in complex biological samples. This PPQ method is based on enzymatic dephosphorylation, combined with specific and accurate peptide identification and quantification by multiple reaction monitoring (MRM) with stable-isotope-labeled standard peptides. In contrast with classical MRM methods for the quantitation of phosphorylation stoichiometry, the PPQ-MRM method needs only one nonphosphorylated SIS (stable isotope-coded standard) and two analyses (one for the untreated sample and one for the phosphatase-treated sample), from which the expression and modification levels can accurately be determined. From these analyses, the percent phosphorylation can be determined. In this manuscript, we compare the PPQ-MRM method with an MRM method without phosphatase and demonstrate the application of these methods to the detection and quantitation of phosphorylation of the classic phosphorylated breast cancer biomarkers (ERalpha and HER2), and for phosphorylated RAF and ERK1, which also contain phosphorylation sites of biological importance. Using synthetic peptides spiked into a complex protein digest, we were able to use our PPQ-MRM method to accurately determine the total phosphorylation stoichiometry on specific peptides as well as the absolute amount of the peptide and phosphopeptide present. Analyses of samples containing ERalpha protein revealed that the PPQ-MRM method is capable of determining phosphorylation stoichiometry in proteins from cell lines, and is in good agreement with determinations obtained using the direct MRM approach in terms of phosphorylation and total protein amount.

Negative electron transfer dissociation of deprotonated phosphopeptide anions: choice of radical cation reagent and competition between electron and proton transfer

Despite significant developments in mass spectrometry technology in recent years, no routine proteomics sequencing tool is currently available for peptide anions. The use of a molecular open-shell cation is presented here as a possible reaction partner to induce electron transfer dissociation with deprotonated peptide anions. In this negative electron transfer dissociation (NETD) scheme, an electron is abstracted from the peptide anion and transferred to the radical cation. This is demonstrated for the example of the fluoranthene cation, C(16)H(10)(+*), which is reacted with deprotonated phosphorylated peptides in a 3-D ion trap mass spectrometer. Selective backbone cleavage at the C(alpha)-C bond is observed to yield a and x fragments, similarly to electron detachment dissociation (EDD) of peptide anions. Crucially, the phosphorylation site is left intact in the dissociation process, allowing an identification and localization of the post-translational modification (PTM) site. In contrast, NETD using Xe(+*) as the reagent cation results in sequential neutral losses (CO(2) and H(3)PO(4)) from a/x fragments, which complicate the interpretation of the mass spectra. This difference in dissociation behavior can be understood in the framework of the reduced recombination energy of the electron transfer process for fluoranthene, which is estimated at 2.5-4.5 eV, compared to 6.7-8.7 eV for xenon. Similarly to ETD, proton transfer is found to compete with electron transfer processes in NETD. Isotope fitting of the charge-reduced species shows that in the case of fluoranthene-mediated NETD, proton transfer only accounts for <20%, whereas this process highly abundant for Xe(+*) (43 and 82%). Since proton abstraction from Xe(+*) is not possible, this suggests that Xe(+*) ionizes other transient species in the ion trap, which then engage in proton transfer reactions with the peptide anions.

Identification of phosphorylation sites within the signaling adaptor APPL1 by mass spectrometry

APPL1 is a membrane-associated adaptor protein implicated in various cellular processes, including apoptosis, proliferation, and survival. Although there is increasing interest in the biological roles as well as the protein and membrane interactions of APPL1, a comprehensive phosphorylation profile has not been generated. In this study, we use mass spectrometry (MS) to identify 13 phosphorylated residues within APPL1. By using multiple proteases (trypsin, chymotrypsin, and Glu C) and replicate experiments of linear ion trap (LTQ) MS and LTQ-Orbitrap-MS, a combined sequence coverage of 99.6% is achieved. Four of the identified sites are located in important functional domains, suggesting a potential role in regulating APPL1. One of these sites is within the BAR domain, two cluster near the edge of the PH domain, and one is located within the PTB domain. These phosphorylation sites may control APPL1 function by regulating the ability of APPL1 domains to interact with other proteins and membranes.

A review of current applications of mass spectrometry for neuroproteomics in epilepsy

The brain is unquestionably the most fascinating organ, and the hippocampus is crucial in memory storage and retrieval and plays an important role in stress response. In temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE), the seizure origin typically involves the hippocampal formation. Despite tremendous progress, current knowledge falls short of being able to explain its function. An emerging approach toward an improved understanding of the complex molecular mechanisms that underlie functions of the brain and hippocampus is neuroproteomics. Mass spectrometry has been widely used to analyze biological samples, and has evolved into an indispensable tool for proteomics research. In this review, we present a general overview of the application of mass spectrometry in proteomics, summarize neuroproteomics and systems biology-based discovery of protein biomarkers for epilepsy, discuss the methodology needed to explore the epileptic hippocampus proteome, and also focus on applications of ingenuity pathway analysis (IPA) in disease research. This neuroproteomics survey presents a framework for large-scale protein research in epilepsy that can be applied for immediate epileptic biomarker discovery and the far-reaching systems biology understanding of the protein regulatory networks. Ultimately, knowledge attained through neuroproteomics could lead to clinical diagnostics and therapeutics to lessen the burden of epilepsy on society.

Comparative assessment of site assignments in CID and electron transfer dissociation spectra of phosphopeptides discloses limited relocation of phosphate groups

In large scale mass spectrometry-based phosphoproteomics, a current bottleneck is the unambiguous assignment of the phosphorylation site within the peptide. An additional problem is that it has been reported that under conditions wherein peptide ions are collisionally activated the phosphate group may migrate to a nearby phosphate group acceptor, thus causing ambiguity in site assignment. Here, we generated and analyzed a statistically significant number of phosphopeptides. Starting with a human cell lysate, we obtained via strong cation exchange fractionation nearly pure phosphopeptide pools from trypsin and Lys-N digestions. These pools were subjected to nano-LC-MS using an Orbitrap mass spectrometer that is equipped with both CID and electron transfer dissociation with supplemental activation (ETcaD) functionality. We configured a method to obtain sequentially both ETcaD and CID spectra for each peptide ion. We exploited the resistant nature of ETcaD toward rearrangement of phosphate groups to evaluate whether there is potentially phosphate group relocation occurring during CID. We evaluated a number of peptide and spectral annotation properties and found that for ∼75% of the sequenced phosphopeptides the assigned phosphosite was unmistakably identical for both the ETcaD and CID spectra. For the remaining 25% of the sequenced phosphopeptides, we also did not observe evident signs of relocation, but these peptides exhibited signs of ambiguity in site localization, predominantly induced by factors such as poor fragmentation, sequences causing inefficient fragmentation, and generally poor spectrum quality. Our data let us derive the conclusion that both for trypsin- and Lys-N-generated peptides there is little relocation of phosphate groups occurring during CID.

Phosphoproteomics for the masses

Protein phosphorylation serves as a primary mechanism of signal transduction in the cells of biological organisms. Technical advancements over the last several years in mass spectrometry now allow for the large-scale identification and quantitation of in vivo phosphorylation at unprecedented levels. These developments have occurred in the areas of sample preparation, instrumentation, quantitative methodology, and informatics so that today, 10 000-20 000 phosphorylation sites can be identified and quantified within a few weeks. With the rapid development and widespread availability of such data, its translation into biological insight and knowledge is a current obstacle. Here we present an overview of how this technology came to be and is currently applied, as well as future challenges for the field.

Fulfilling the Krebs and Beavo criteria for studying protein phosphorylation in the era of mass spectrometry-driven kinome research

The reversible phosphorylation of proteins controls virtually all aspects of cell function. However, in order to establish that the phosphorylation of a protein by a particular protein kinase is of physiological relevance, a series of criteria (proposed by Krebs & Beavo, 1979 ) should be satisfied. Surprisingly, amongst the thousands of protein kinase targets that have been reported in the literature, there are not so many for which there is good evidence for phosphorylation having functional consequences in vivo. Here we review the approaches that can be used to establish physiologically important protein phosphorylation according to the Krebs and Beavo criteria, taking as an example heart 6-phosphofruco-2-kinase phosphorylation-induced activation by insulin. We also point out the pitfalls of the various techniques that can be used to implicate the involvement of a particular protein kinase in a biological response. Lastly, we discuss the use of mass spectrometry techniques to search for new protein kinase targets, bearing in mind that each new target found would have to be validated by the criteria before being considered as a bona fide protein kinase substrate.

Time-resolved observation of product ions generated by 157 nm photodissociation of singly protonated phosphopeptides

Vacuum UV photodissociation tandem mass spectra of singly charged arginine-terminated phosphopeptides were recorded at times ranging from 300 ns to ms after photoexcitation, to investigate when the phosphate group falls off from the precursor and product ions and whether loss of phosphate can be eliminated in tandem mass spectra. For peptide ions containing phosphoserine and phosphothreonine, little loss of 98 Da from the product ions was observed up to 1 micros after photoexcitation. However, neutral losses from the precursor ions were considerable just 300 ns after photoactivation. Loss of 98 Da from product ions first appears about 1 micros after laser irradiation and becomes more common 13 micros after photoexcitation. Consistent with previous reports, phosphotyrosine was more stable than either phosphoserine or phosphothreonine.

Evaluation of several MS/MS search algorithms for analysis of spectra derived from electron transfer dissociation experiments

Electron transfer dissociation (ETD) is increasingly becoming popular for high-throughput experiments especially in the identification of the labile post-translational modifications. Most search algorithms that are currently in use for querying MS/MS data against protein databases have been optimized on the basis of matching fragment ions derived from collision induced dissociation of peptides, which are dominated by b and y ions. However, electron transfer dissociation of peptides generates completely different types of fragments: c and z ions. The goal of our study was to test the ability of different search algorithms to handle data from this fragmentation method. We compared four MS/MS search algorithms (OMSSA, Mascot, Spectrum Mill, and X!Tandem) using approximately 170,000 spectra generated from a standard protein mix, as well as from complex proteomic samples which included a large number of phosphopeptides. Our analysis revealed (1) greater differences between algorithms than has been previously reported for CID data, (2) a significant charge state bias resulting in >60-fold difference in the numbers of matched doubly charged peptides, and (3) identification of 70% more peptides by the best performing algorithm than the algorithm identifying the least number of peptides. Our results indicate that the search engines for analyzing ETD derived MS/MS spectra are still in their early days and that multiple search engines could be used to reduce individual biases of algorithms.

Gas-phase intramolecular phosphate shift in phosphotyrosine-containing peptide monoanions

Phosphotyrosine-containing peptide monoanions [M-H](-) exhibit extensive neutral loss of phosphoric acid (98 Da) upon quadrupole time-of-flight and ion-trap collision-induced dissociation (CID). In contrast, a neutral loss of metaphosphoric acid HPO(3) (80 Da) is negligible from the deprotonated phosphotyrosine peptides. The efficient H(3)PO(4) release is unexpected, given the structure of phosphotyrosine. Our study reveals that the abundant [M-H-98](-) product ions of pTyr-peptides are not a result of consecutive losses of HPO(3) and H(2)O but, rather, are induced by an intramolecular interaction of the phosphotyrosine phosphate with deprotonated peptide functions such as hydroxyl, carboxyl, and to a small extent, amide. As a result, an internal phosphotyrosine phosphate shift occurs, and the obtained phosphorylated functionalities undergo elimination of H(3)PO(4) to give rise to the [M-H-98](-) fragments. The mechanism proposed for the phosphoric acid neutral loss is based on extensive CID studies of Ala-substituted model phosphorylated peptides and oxygen-18 labeling. The proposed mechanistic pathway explains the fact that the pTyr phosphate transfer and the subsequent H(3)PO(4) neutral loss are not observed for multiply charged anions of pTyr-peptides. Monoanions of pSer-containing peptides undergo the intramolecular phosphate shift as well, although its efficiency is much lower compared to the aromatic phosphorylation sites. These observations facilitate correct identification of pSer-, pThr-, and pTyr-peptides in CID studies. This work demonstrates that the established phosphate-specific neutral loss fragmentation rules of protonated pTyr-peptides cannot be applied to the CID spectra of their [M-H](-) ions.

Phosphoproteomics--finally fulfilling the promise?

Networks of protein-protein and protein-metabolite interactions are commonly found in biological systems where signals must be passed from one location or component within a cell to another, such as from a receptor on the plasma membrane to a transcription factor in the nucleus. Regulation of such networks, or signal transduction pathways, is often achieved by transient, reversible modification of the components involved. Several types of post-translational modifications of proteins are employed in signal transduction including ubiquitylation of lysines and palmitoylation of cysteines, but by far the best appreciated and apparently the most important involves phosphorylation of serine, threonine and tyrosine residues. Whilst protein phosphorylation has long been recognized as functionally important, low stoichiometry has ultimately impeded global analyses (phosphoproteomics). Recent developments in the application of metal oxide chromatography and advanced mass spectrometric techniques have enabled phosphoproteomics to move beyond mere proof-of-principle experiments, to the stage where it can successfully address complex biological questions. Here we cover the development of phosphopeptide/protein analysis by mass spectrometry and the various techniques used to enrich phosphopeptides/proteins. We also speculate on the future of phosphoproteomic research, now that the goal of generating global phosphoproteomic datasets has been realized.

Phosphopeptide fragmentation and analysis by mass spectrometry

Reversible phosphorylation is a key event in many biological processes and is therefore a much studied phenomenon. The mass spectrometric (MS) analysis of phosphorylation is challenged by the substoichiometric levels of phosphorylation and the lability of the phosphate group in collision-induced dissociation (CID). Here, we review the fragmentation behaviour of phosphorylated peptides in MS and discuss several MS approaches that have been developed to improve and facilitate the analysis of phosphorylated peptides. CID of phosphopeptides typically results in spectra dominated by a neutral loss of the phosphate group. Several proposed mechanisms for this neutral loss and several factors affecting the extent at which this occurs are discussed. Approaches are described to interpret such neutral loss-dominated spectra to identify the phosphopeptide and localize the phosphorylation site. Methods using additional activation, such as MS(3) and multistage activation (MSA), have been designed to generate more sequence-informative fragments from the ion produced by the neutral loss. The characteristics and benefits of these methods are reviewed together with approaches using phosphopeptide derivatization or specific MS scan modes. Additionally, electron-driven dissociation methods by electron capture dissociation (ECD) or electron transfer dissociation (ETD) and their application in phosphopeptide analysis are evaluated. Finally, these techniques are put into perspective for their use in large-scale phosphoproteomics studies.

Large scale localization of protein phosphorylation by use of electron capture dissociation mass spectrometry

We used on-line electron capture dissociation (ECD) for the large scale identification and localization of sites of phosphorylation. Each FT-ICR ECD event was paired with a linear ion trap collision-induced dissociation (CID) event, allowing a direct comparison of the relative merits of ECD and CID for phosphopeptide identification and site localization. Linear ion trap CID was shown to be most efficient for phosphopeptide identification, whereas FT-ICR ECD was superior for localization of sites of phosphorylation. The combination of confident CID and ECD identification and confident CID and ECD localization is particularly valuable in cases where a phosphopeptide is identified just once within a phosphoproteomics experiment.

Femtosecond laser-induced ionization/dissociation of protonated peptides

Although tandem mass spectrometry has revolutionized the identification and structural characterization of peptides and proteins, future advances in comprehensive proteome analysis will depend on the development of improved methods for ion activation that yield greater sequence information, and with selective control over the fragmentation chemistry. This report presents initial findings that demonstrate the utility of a novel ion activation method using ultrashort (approximately 30 fs) laser pulses as a means to overcome the limitations of current technologies, while opening the door to solving significant challenges in protein and peptide analysis.