Magnetic resonance angiography for the diagnosis of renal artery stenosis: a meta-analysis

Magnetic resonance imaging of the peripheral vasculature

BACKGROUND

Atherosclerotic disease of the peripheral vasculature is a prevalent condition for which catheter-based techniques have been considered to be the gold standard for diagnosis. However, because of their invasive nature, these techniques inherently have the potential for complications. Non-invasive diagnostic techniques have historically been limited by low accuracy and high operator dependence. Magnetic resonance angiography (MRA) is a new approach that has diagnostic accuracy comparable with invasive angiography.

METHODS

The literature on MRA for evaluation of carotid, mesenteric, renal, and lower-extremity arterial disease was extensively reviewed. Helpful diagnostic algorithms on the basis of the literature are also provided.

RESULTS

MRA is both sensitive and specific when compared with invasive angiography for the evaluation of peripheral arterial disease and avoids the potential for complications resulting from arterial puncture and use of iodinated contrast.

CONCLUSION

Current MRA techniques are diagnostically robust and have proven to be a highly accurate, safe, and convenient means of diagnosing atherosclerotic disease of the peripheral vascular system.

Magnetic resonance angiography

MRA and MRI have become increasingly important diagnostic modalities in vascular surgery. The ability to obtain cross-sectional and angiographic images by these noninvasive and non-nephrotoxic modalities represents one of the most significant advances in vascular surgery over the past decade. We review the current status of MRI and MRA in vascular surgical practice.

Accessory Renal Arteries Are Not Related to Hypertension Risk:A Review of MR Angiography Data

OBJECTIVE

It has been hypothesized that accessory renal arteries are related to the risk of hypertension. Our goal was to determine the prevalence of accessory renal arteries in hypertensive patients using MR angiography and to assess the relationship between accessory renal arteries and hypertension risk.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

From 1996 to 2002, 185 hypertensive patients underwent MR angiography of the renal arteries at our institution for assessment of renal artery stenosis. MR angiograms were obtained using a 1.5-T magnet, IV gadolinium, and 3D gradient-echo sequences. Interpretations of the MR angiograms were retrospectively reviewed.

RESULTS

Of 185 hypertensive patients, 45 (24%) showed accessory renal arteries. Of these 45 patients, nine (20%) showed renal artery stenosis and 36 (80%) showed no significant stenosis. Of the 140 patients with a single renal artery, 42 (30%) showed renal artery stenosis and 98 (70%) showed no stenosis. The odds ratio of renal artery stenosis in the accessory renal artery group versus the single renal artery group was 0.58 (95% confidence interval, 0.26-1.3%), which is not statistically significant at a power of 0.85 (chi(2) = 1.705; p = 1.0).

CONCLUSION

We found no statistically significant difference in the prevalence of renal artery stenosis between patients with accessory renal arteries and those without accessory renal arteries. Assuming that the presence of two separate causes of hypertension in the same patient would be unlikely, this finding implies that accessory renal arteries are a vascular anomaly and not a direct cause of hypertension. The findings are potentially relevant in refuting the theory of accessory renal arteries as an anatomically treatable cause of hypertension.

Current issues in the diagnosis and management of patients with renal artery stenosis: a cardiologic perspective

Renal artery stenosis most often is caused by atherosclerosis. Although patients with renal artery stenosis can be managed conservatively, renal revascularization may be indicated, particularly in patients with refractory hypertension on a multidrug regimen and patients with declining renal function. Duplex ultrasonography of the renal arteries and magnetic resonance angiography are currently the most efficient noninvasive methods for the evaluation of renal artery stenosis. Selective digital subtraction renal arteriography remains the gold standard for the definitive diagnosis. In selected patients undergoing coronary studies and angiography immediately after the coronary procedure can be efficient. Atherosclerotic renal artery lesions, which commonly affect the renal artery ostium, can be treated safely and effectively with balloon-expandable stents. Successful angioplasty commonly results in improved control of hypertension, but an overall benefit on renal function and/or patient survival has not been shown. Generally the risk/benefit ratio of renal artery stenting seems favorable, but further randomized studies are needed for evidence-based decision making. All patients with atherosclerotic renal artery stenosis should receive rigorous secondary prevention measures including platelet inhibitors, statins, and beta-blockers.

MR techniques for renal imaging

This article describes the principles, attributes, and pitfalls of the many MR imaging approaches available for assessment of renal-related disorders. Tables 1 and 2 summarize the specific approach and rationale.

Renal MR angiography: current debates and developments in imaging of renal artery stenosis

Because of its safety and robustness with reproducible image quality, three-dimensional gadolinium-enhanced magnetic resonance angiography (3D-Gd-MRA) has been widely established as a diagnostic tool for screening and grading of renal artery stenosis. Accuracy and superiority over other noninvasive imaging procedures was again demonstrated in two recent meta-analyses. However, ambiguous results on the accuracy of this technique have been reported recently, again questioning the sole role of this modality for diagnostic assessment of the renal arteries. The main deficiencies of the technique are limited spatial resolution, high interobserver variability, limited anatomic coverage, as well as inability to assess the stenosis site after stent placement. In addition, a high level of competition has been introduced by techniques such as 16 detector multislice computed tomography, which generates superb image quality, with broad anatomic coverage and high spatial resolution, with minimal technical complexity. Lastly, aggressive search for renal artery stenosis by angiographic techniques in patients with hypertension is of debate, since only a limited percentage of these patients benefit from interventions. In this article, a comprehensive approach to high-resolution 3D-Gd-MRA, using parallel imaging in combination with cardiac-gated, phase-contrast flow measurements, is reviewed. This review is based on various studies and articles that address many of the problems of 3D-Gd-MRA. By making use of maximum spatial resolution and additional functional data, MRI permits accurate detection and grading of renal artery stenosis in most cases, with acceptable interobserver variability.

Managing renal arterial disease and hypertension

Treating patients with renovascular disease is complex, particularly as imaging and medical techniques become more effective. Atherosclerotic renal artery disease is present in 7% of the general population above age 65 and in 20 to 45% of patients with coronary disease or aortoiliac disease. Most patients are treated medically, but when progressive hypertension, renal insufficiency, or circulatory congestion develops, revascularization should be considered. Endovascular procedures with arterial stents are now widely employed. These procedures sometimes offer major benefits in blood pressure control and stabilization of renal function. Stent procedures continue to entail hazards, including atheroemboli, arterial dissections, and thrombosis, in addition to restenosis rates of 14 to 20%. Small, randomized trials to date demonstrate no survival benefit to either endovascular or surgical revascularization as compared with medical management. Recognizing renal artery disease and directing revascularization procedures to those with the most benefit remains a premier challenge for the clinician.

New diagnostic techniques for imaging the renal arteries

There has been an increasing focus on renovascular disease, particularly in renal failure, and on the role of renal angioplasty and stenting. Significant improvements have occurred in non-invasive imaging techniques. This review concentrates on the recent developments in imaging that specifically targets the renal artery and renal artery stenosis. It also discusses how these techniques may facilitate better selection of cases that will respond to intervention.

Pathophysiology of renovascular hypertension

Studies of the renin-angiotension system and the effects of pharmacologic blockade have enhanced our understanding of renovascular hypertension. A critical degree of arterial stenosis produces kidney ischemia sufficient to activate this hormonal system, whose actions include vasoconstriction and sodium retention. Accurate clinical evaluation may depend upon recognizing the differences in pathophysiology between "one-kidney" and "two-kidney" forms and the dynamic nature of this condition.