Interindividual variability and correlation among morphological parameters of knee joint cartilage plates: analysis with three-dimensional MR imaging

Imaging of the disease process

Until recently, imaging evaluation of osteoarthritis (OA) has relied primarily on conventional radiography. Using radiography in clinical practice or clinical research, however, has been fraught with difficulty. Techniques for reproducibly acquiring serial radiographs of joints have improved considerably over the past several years. However, the greatest promise for advancing knowledge about OA and its treatment lies in magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and its unique ability to examine the joint as a whole organ. In contrast to conventional radiography, MRI can directly visualize the articular cartilage, synovium, menisci, and other intra-articular structures important to the functional integrity of joints. There have been considerable advances in MRI of articular cartilage in particular over the past several years. However, much of this has come from small cross-sectional studies, and published longitudinal studies remain quite scant. The following discussion reviews the current status of imaging in OA and points to where changes might be anticipated in the future.

Quantitative cartilage imaging of the human hind foot: precision and inter-subject variability

Alterations of ankle cartilage are observed in degenerative and inflammatory joint disease, but cartilage cannot be directly visualized by radiography. The purpose of this study was therefore to analyze the feasibility and precision of quantitative cartilage imaging in the human hind foot (talocrural, talotarsal, and intertarsal joints), and to report the inter-subject variability for cartilage volume, thickness and surface areas. The feet of 16 healthy volunteers were imaged using a 3D gradient-echo magnetic resonance imaging sequence with water-excitation. After interpolation to a resolution of 1 x 0.125 x 0.125 mm3 the cartilage plates were segmented, and the cartilage volume, thickness, and surface areas determined. The precision (four repeated measurements) was examined in eight volunteers, the RMS average CV% being 2.1% to 10.9% in single joint surfaces, and < or = 3% for the cumulative values of all joints. The mean cartilage thickness ranged from 0.57+/-0.08 (navicular surface) to 0.89+/-0.19 mm (trochlear surface for tibia). In conclusion this study shows that it is feasible to quantify thin cartilage layers in the hind foot under in vivo imaging conditions, and that the precision errors are substantially smaller than the inter-subject variability in healthy subjects.

Functional adaptation of human joints to mechanical stimuli

OBJECTIVE

This study tests the hypothesis that functional adaptation occurs in human joints, and that substantial differences in joint 'loading history' explain the phenotypic variability observed in human cartilage morphology.

METHOD

We examined 18 triathletes (nine men and nine women) who had been physically active throughout life (training for >10 h per week for the last 3 years), and 18 volunteers that had never been physically active on a regular basis. The right knee joints were imaged with a previously validated fat-suppressed gradient-echo MR sequence. Cartilage volume, thickness, joint surface areas, and normalized cartilage signal intensity were determined with post-processing software, specifically designed for these applications.

RESULTS

The knee joint cartilage thickness, and signal intensity were not significantly different between athletes and inactive volunteers, but male athletes displayed significantly larger knee joint surfaces (P< 0.01; +8.8%). Female athletes displayed a significantly larger medial tibia (P< 0.05; +18.9%), the difference in the total knee surface area reaching borderline significance (P=0.08; +7.0%).

CONCLUSIONS

The results suggest that joint size can be modulated during growth, but that (opposite to muscle and bone) the thickness of the cartilage does not adapt to mechanical stimulation. This finding may reveal a general principle in the development and functional adaptation of diarthrodial joints, elucidating an important mechanism for reducing mechanical stress in biphasic cartilage layers.