The efficacy of enzyme replacement therapy in patients with chronic neuronopathic Gaucher's disease

Gaucher and Fabry diseases: from understanding pathophysiology to rational therapies

Over the past 40 years there has been remarkable development in our understanding of the pathophysiology of lysosomal storage disorders. This review describes the research carried out on the sphingolipid storage disorders from the first demonstration of the underlying metabolic abnormality in Gaucher disease to the development of enzyme replacement therapy for Gaucher and Fabry diseases. Initial developments in gene therapy are also described.

CONCLUSION

The introduction of enzyme replacement therapy has provided a lifeline for patients with Gaucher or Fabry disease. It is anticipated that future developments, including gene therapy, will provide additional therapeutic options.

Phenotypic continuum in neuronopathic Gaucher disease: an intermediate phenotype between type 2 and type 3

Neuronopathic Gaucher disease, classically divided into two types, can have a continuum of phenotypes, often defying categorization. Nine children had an intermediate phenotype characterized by a delayed age of onset but rapidly progressive neurological disease, including refractory seizures and oculomotor abnormalities. There was genotypic heterogeneity among these patients.

[Gaucher's disease in children: first clinical signs, natural course and benefits of enzyme replacement therapy]

OBJECTIVES

Gaucher's disease is a rare genetic disease. Paediatric patients present with highly severe disease and, until now, literature does not provide many descriptions in children only. A specific enzyme replacement therapy has been available for the last decade. Quality of life has been improved by the treatment.

POPULATION AND METHODS

We studied 17 Gaucher patients (14 type 1 and 3 type 3) diagnosed before the age of 15 and treated afterwards. The first clinical signs and the course of the disease are described before and during treatment. To appreciate the impact of the treatment on quality of life, we established a clinical score with the functional symptoms of the patients.

RESULTS

The mean age was 6.4 years at diagnosis and 18.3 years at the beginning of the treatment. With specific treatment, all clinical and biological symptoms dramatically improved but some specific organic damages were irreversible.

CONCLUSION

The comparison of our patients with other reported paediatric cases confirm that Gaucher's disease in children is severe and has to be precociously diagnosed and treated. Clinical scores appeared to be helpful to choose the moment for treating and to follow-up the patients under treatment.

A model of neuronopathic Gaucher disease

Gaucher disease (GD) is a lysosomal disorder involving the accumulation of glucocerebroside in the liver, spleen, bones and brain. Some patients exhibit only systemic disease (type I), but others have additional neurological signs which may lead to rapid neurodegeneration in infancy (type II) or take a more intermediate course (type III). Types II and III are collectively known as neuronopathic Gaucher disease (NGD). Systemic disease can now be treated by enzyme replacement therapy (ERT), but its efficacy in NGD is limited. Two infants who presented with bulbar palsy and failure to thrive were enzymatically diagnosed at 8 months with NGD. They were started on high-dose ERT (120 IU/kg every 2 weeks). Both underwent serial oculomotor assessment and an audiological battery, including visual reinforcement audiometry, otoacoustic emissions, and the auditory brain stem response (ABR). Biochemical markers showed an incomplete systemic response to ERT, but neurological deterioration was relentless, leading to death at 16 and 25 months. Oculomotor testing revealed a complete absence of saccadic eye movements and progressive bilateral sixth nerve palsy in one. Audiological assessment revealed progressive deterioration of ABRs, but with normal peripheral hearing and otoacoustic emissions. Both infants showed neurological deterioration in spite of high-dose ERT. The audiological findings suggested a loss of inner hair cell pathway function with preserved outer hair function, similar to what is seen in auditory neuropathy. The unusual pattern of audiological and oculomotor abnormalities is consistent with an excitotoxic mechanism predisposing nerve cells to glucocerebroside toxicity. Such excitotoxic damage may be amenable to direct therapeutic intervention.

Gaucher disease: pediatric concerns

Gaucher disease, the most prevalent lysosomal storage disorder, is inherited as an autosomal recessive condition. The gold standard for diagnosis is decreased acid beta-glucosidase activity in the lymphocytes or fibroblasts; molecular analysis of mutations allows for some prognostication of disease severity. Prenatal diagnosis and carrier testing for at-risk families are currently available. There is tremendous phenotypic heterogeneity in the non-neuronopathic form (type I), ranging from clinically asymptomatic to massive hepatomegaly, hypersplenism, growth retardation in children and extensive involvement of bone and lungs. Presence on one allele of the most common mutation, N370S, which is the most prevalent among Ashkenazi Jews for whom there is a predilection for Gaucher disease, is protective of neurological involvement. Some mutations, such as 84GG and IVS2+1, are associated with more severe disease manifestations when appearing as compound heterozygotes with N370S, but when occurring in the homozygous state are not compatible with life. Other mutations, such as L444P, are associated with severe non-neurological disease when occurring as compound heterozygotes with N370S, but when occurring in the homozygous state may be predictive of neurological disease of either acute (type II) or subacute (type III) forms. In the past decade, enzyme replacement therapy has become available which has resulted in a reduction in liver and spleen volume and consequently improved anemia and thrombocytopenia in most patients. It has also engendered catch-up growth in many children, induced improvement in lung involvement secondary to Gaucher disease, and to some extent ameliorated episodes of bone pain. By virtue of treatment, many children who may have been severely affected no longer need to undergo splenectomy to treat hypersplenism, and therefore they are not at risk of bone involvement consequent to the loss of the preferred reservoir for lipid-laden 'Gaucher cells'. However, enzyme treatment is ineffective in reversing neurological signs, requires a lifelong commitment to intravenous infusions, thereby reducing quality of life, and is relatively expensive for many national health schemes. Hence, alternative forms of treatment, such as substrate balance, are being explored. Symptomatic management, including orthopedic surgery, pain relief for bone pain and even splenectomy, still has importance for patients with Gaucher disease. In addition, there is the potential for bone marrow transplantation and, in the future, gene therapy to be curative, particularly for patients with the neuronopathic forms.

Enzyme replacement and enhancement therapies: lessons from lysosomal disorders

The past decade has witnessed remarkable advances in our ability to treat inherited metabolic disorders, especially the lysosomal storage diseases, a group of more than 40 disorders, each of which is caused by the deficiency of a lysosomal enzyme or protein. During the past few years, both enzyme replacement and enhancement therapies have been developed to treat these disorders. This review discusses the successes and shortcomings of these therapeutic strategies, and the contributions that they have made to treating lysosomal storage diseases.

Gene therapy for the central nervous system in the lysosomal storage disorders

Although great promise has been made in the field of gene therapy, a number of difficulties must be solved before successful human studies can be completed. These issues involve safety, immunological reactions to the vectors and their transgene products, persistent transgene expression, and ability to repeat administrations of the vector safely. A major hurdle that must be overcome is the ubiquitous delivery of the transgene throughout the nervous system. Significant gene delivery to the CNS of murine models of LSD has been accomplished, but we await the successful treatment of the nervous system in a larger mammalian model of LSD. As yet there is no perfect vector that can solve all of these problems. It is likely that vector technology will evolve into hybrid vectors also using synthetic components that will increase safety and efficacy of recombinant vectors. The treatment of the CNS remains complicated, but progress is being made in this area. Clinical trials already planned will give us increasing information as to the ideal gene therapy for the CNS.

New prospects for the treatment of lysosomal storage diseases

Although individually rare, lysosomal storage disorders constitute a significant burden on society. To date, enzyme replacement therapy (ERT) has been the most successful therapeutic approach for lysosomal storage disorders. ERT reverses systemic manifestations of Gaucher disease but does not effectively treat the neurological complications. Recently, ERT produced a reduction of severe neuropathic pain, stabilisation of renal disease, and improved vascular function and structure in short-term, placebo-controlled trials in patients with Fabry's disease. Long-term studies are necessary to evaluate the full potential of ERT in this disease. In patients with Pompe disease, a fatal cardiac and skeletal muscle disorder, ERT improved cardiac function and structure, and increased overall muscle strength. It has already increased survival in a small number of affected infants. ERT also decreased liver and spleen size, joint mobility and quality of life in patients with mucopolysaccharidosis type I, but when the therapeutic protein is administered intravenously, it is unlikely to modify the neurological outcome in this or in other similar disorders. Bone marrow transplantation continues to be effective in Gaucher disease, in some forms of mucopolysaccharidosis and in mild forms of Krabbé disease, but it has high morbidity and mortality that limits its use in lysosomal storage disorders. Drugs that slow the rate of formation of accumulating glycolipids are being developed and one of them, OGT-918 (N-butyldeoxynojirimycin), is showing promise in patients with Gaucher disease. Gene therapy for lysosomal storage disorders holds promise as a replacement for the other therapies described here but requires much more development before clinical efficacy trials.

Variant Gaucher disease characterized by dysmorphic features, absence of cardiovascular involvement, laryngospasm, and compound heterozygosity for a novel mutation (D409H/C16S)

A 20-month-old girl with developmental delay, dysmorphic features, horizontal supranuclear gaze palsy, retrocollis, and episodes of laryngospasm was diagnosed with variant neuronopathic Gaucher disease. The diagnosis was made enzymatically. Mutation analysis showed compound heterozygosity for D409H and a previously unreported mutation C16S. The presence of dysmorphic features, laryngospasm, absent cardiac findings, and the severe clinical phenotype distinguishes our case from other cases of variant neuronopathic Gaucher disease. We therefore propose to extend the spectrum of variant Gaucher disease.

Decreased bone density in splenectomized Gaucher patients receiving enzyme replacement therapy

Little is known about the effect of enzyme replacement therapy (ERT) on the bone abnormalities in Gaucher disease. Splenectomized Gaucher patients tend to suffer the most severe skeletal complications. We hypothesized that vitamin D supplementation would act synergistically with glucocerebrosidase infusions to increase bone density in splenectomized Gaucher patients. In a 24-month study, 29 splenectomized Gaucher patients were randomized to three groups: Group 1, calcitriol (1,25-dihydroxyvitamin D3; 0.25-3.0 microg/day) alone for the first 6 months with the addition of ceredase/cerezyme at 60 IU/kg every 2 weeks during months 7-12; Group 2, calcitriol together with ceredase/cerezyme at 60 IU/kg every 2 weeks during months 1-6; and Group 3, enzyme only at 60 IU/kg body wt every 2 weeks. In all three groups, enzyme dose was halved after the first 6 months of therapy. The primary outcome measure was bone mineral density of the lumbar spine measured by single-energy quantitative CT. Bone density by single-energy CT (P = 0.001) and by dual-energy CT (P = 0.06) declined overall, but there was no significant difference between the groups. Calcitriol had no significant effect on bone density. Fat fraction in lumbar spine increased (P = 0.000) and skeletal MRI scores improved. Bone-specific alkaline phosphatase (P = 0.002) and serum osteocalcin increased (P = 0.008), while blood cyclic AMP and urinary deoxypyridinoline did not change appreciably. Hemoglobin, platelet counts, and liver volume significantly improved. We conclude that ERT alone, or in combination with calcitriol, cannot repair the bone composition in splenectomized adult Gaucher patients. Alternatively, measuring trabecular bone density may be an inadequate marker of clinical efficacy for treating skeletal involvement in Gaucher disease.

Neonatal biochemical screening for disease

BACKGROUND

The practice of screening the neonatal population for certain diseases by biochemical testing of a dried blood spot is an established public health initiative in many countries. The diseases for which screening is done vary from region to region, based on ethnic, financial and political considerations. Criteria have been established to identify diseases suitable for neonatal screening.

DISEASES SCREENED

In Western countries, screening for phenylketonuria (PKU) and congenital hypothyroidism (CH) has been introduced throughout. Subsequently, cost-benefit analysis has confirmed the existence of a financial benefit. Other diseases screened for in some regions include galactosemia, aminoacidemias and organic acidemias, cystic fibrosis, congenital adrenal hyperplasia, biotinidase deficiency, hemoglobinopathies, glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase deficiency, and Duchenne muscular dystrophy, although in no case has a clear financial benefit been established.

CONCLUSIONS

Since the introduction of neonatal screening over 40 years ago, new methods have resulted in an increase in the number of diseases amenable to screening, better automation and greater specificity. Methods currently used include growth of an inhibited bacterial auxotroph (the original phenylalanine (phe) method of Dr. Robert Guthrie), spectrophotometry, fluorometry, immunoassay, and tandem mass spectrometry with electrospray ionization.