Cytoplasmic transfer of chloramphenicol resistance in human tissue culture cells

Cybrid formation with recipient cell lines containing dominant phenotypes

A clone of Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells, BT3, resistant to Tevenel, the sulfamoyl analog of chloramphenicol has been isolated. Resistance was found to be at the mitochondrial level and was shown to be cytoplasmically inherited. This marker was then used to develop a method by which a cell line possessing a dominant nuclear mutation (resistance to 5,6-dichloro-1-beta-D-ribofuranosylbenzimidazole, DRB) could be used as the recipient in cybrid formation. The unique feature in this procedure was the removal of nucleated cells from the cytoplasts by passage through unipore filters. The dominant character of the DRB- and Tevenel-resistant phenotypes permitted the selection of cybrids immediately after fusion. This initially increased the frequency of cybrid clones 16-fold as compared to a recipient cell line possessing a recessive marker. The possibility of extending the method to recipient cells lacking a selectable drug-resistance marker is discussed.

The human genome through the eyes of Mercator and Vesalius

Images

Cytoplasmic inheritance of oligomycin resistance in Chinese hamster ovary cells

Oligomycin-resistant clones were isolated from Chinese hamster ovary cells by treatment of cells with ethidium bromide, followed by mutagenesis with ethylmethane sulfonate and selection in oligomycin. One clone (Olir 8.1) was chosen for further study. Olir 8.1 cells grow with doubling time similar to that of wild-type cells, whether grown in the presence or absence of drug (doubling time of 13-14 h). In plating efficiency experiments, Olir 8.1 cells are approximately 100-fold more resistant to oligomycin than are wild-type cells. There is approximately a 32-fold increase in the resistance to inhibition by oligomycin of the mitochondrial ATPase from Olir 8.1 cells. The electron transport chain is functional in Olir 8.1 cells. Oligomycin resistance is stable in the absence of selective pressure. There is little or no cross-resistance of Olir 8.1 cells to venturicidin and dicyclohexylcarbodiimide, other inhibitors of the mitochondrial ATPase, or to chloramphenicol, an inhibitor of mitochondrial protein synthesis. Oligomycin resistance is dominant in hybrids between Olir 8.1 cells and wild-type cells. Fusions of enucleated Olir 8.1 cells with sensitive cells and characterization of the resulting "cybrid" clones indicates that oligomycin resistance in Olir 8.1 cells is cytoplasmically inherited.

Characterization of mitochondrial DNA in chloramphenicol-resistant interspecific hybrids and a cybrid

We have examined the restriction endonuclease cleavage patterns exhibited by the mitochondrial DNAs (mtDNA) of four chloramphenicol-resistant (CAPR) human x mouse hybrids and one CAPR cybrid derived from CAPR HeLa cells and CAPS mouse RAG cells. Restriction fragments of mtDNAs were separated by electrophoresis and transferred by the Southern technique to diazobenzyloxymethyl paper. The covalently bound DNA fragments were hybridized initially with 32P-labeled complementary RNA (cRNA) prepared from human mtDNA and, after removal of the human probe, hybridized with mouse [32P]cRNA prepared from mouse mtDNA. Three hybrids which preferentially segregated human chromosomes and the cybrid exhibited mtDNA fragments indistinguishable from mouse cells. One hybrid, ROH8A, which exhibited "reverse" chromosome segregation, contained only human mtDNA. The pattern of chromosome and mtDNA segregation observed in these hybrids and the cybrid support the hypothesis that a complete set of human chromosomes must be retained if a human-mouse hybrid is to retain human mitochondrial DNA.

Cytoplasmic genetics of mammalian cells: conditional sensitivity to mitochondrial inhibitors and isolation of new mutant phenotypes

We report here that glucose, as a carbon source, and pyruvate are required for the phenotypic expression of cytoplasmically transmitted chloramphenicol-resistance (CAP-R) mutations, recovery of CAP-R mutants, and continuous growth in the presence of oligomycin or antimycin. We assume that glucose supplies additional energy when mitochondrial respiration is diminished and that pyruvate provides intermediates when the Krebs cycle is inhibited. Thus, the requirement for pyruvate is fully satisfied by an exogenous source of purines, and partially by alpha-ketoglutarate or a pyrimidine source. Based upon these findings, we have obtained two types of mutations affecting mitochondrial function--oligomycin resistance and pyruvate-independent expression of chloramphenicol resistance. Both are cytoplasmically transmitted and provide new markers for a genetic analysis of mitochondrial biogenesis.

Oligomycin-resistant mitochondrial ATPase from mouse fibroblasts

Fourteen oligomycin-resistant LM(TK-) clones were isolated following the mutagenesis of minicells. In the absence of oligomycin, the mutants grew with population doubling times similar to that of the wild type (1 day). In 3 or 5 microgram oligomycin/ml the doubling times of the mutants were 1.2-2.5 days. Both stable and unstable classes were represented among the oligomycin-resistant mutants. Mitochondrial ATPase activities of the mutants were 1.3-1130 times more resistant to oligomycin than the wild type. The mitochondrial ATPase of OLI 14 was found to be bound firmly to the mitochondrial membrane, showed no alteration in the pH optimum compared to wild-type, and exhibited increased resistance to DCCD and venturicidin. These results are consistent with the conclusion that oligomycin resistance in these mutants results from altered mitochondrial ATPase.

Erythromycin resistance in mouse L cells

The sensitivity of mouse cell lines in culture to the macrolide antibiotic, erythromycin stearate, was investigated. Both resistant and sensitive lines were found. Experiments indicated that in sensitive cells erythromycin stearate inhibits mitochondrial protein synthesis. Mutants resistant to erythromycin stearate were selected from the line LM(TK-), and these are also less sensitive to other macrolide antibiotics such as carbomycin and spiramycin. Attempts to transfer the erythromycin resistance of either the mutants or naturally resistant lines by fusion of cytoplasts with sensitive cells were unsuccessful, and it is concluded that resistance to erythromycin stearate is controlled by nuclear genetic factors.

Cytoplasmic inheritance of erythromycin resistance in human cells

An erythromycin-resistant mutant, ERY2301, was isolated from ethidium bromide-treated HeLa cells in the presence of erythromycin at 300 micrograms/ml. ERY2301 cells were enucleated and the anucleate cytoplasts were fused with D98/AH-2, a hypoxanthine phosphoribosyltransferase-deficient variant of HeLa cells. The resultant cybrids were isolated in a double selective medium containing erythromycin and 6-thioguanine. Cybrid formation occurred at a frequency of 10(-3) to 10(-4). In vitro protein synthesis by intact and Triton X-100 treated mitochondria isolated from ERY2301 was resistant to the macrolide antibiotics erythromycin and carbomycin, but was sensitive to chloramphenicol. These results suggest that the site of erythromycin resistance in ERY2301 may be at the level of mitochondrial protein synthesis and indicate that this trait is cytoplasmically inherited and, therefore, presumably encoded in the mitochondrial genome.

Reversible tenfod reduction in mitochondria DNA content of human cells treated with ethidium bromide

Cells of the human line VA2-B in suspension culture have been treated with very low concentrations of ethidium bromide for the purpose of reducing the amount of mitochondrial DNA (mit-DNA) per cell. Cells maintained in the presence of 5 ng/ml ethidium bromide grew at a normal rate for three days; thereafter, their doubling time gradually increased to a stable value of about 60 h. In these cells, the rate of 3H thymidine incorporation into mit-DNA decreased very rapidly to approximately 60% of the normal, and remained thereafter at this level, while the amount of mit-DNA per cell stabilized around a level of 70--80% of the control. In cells long-term treated with 5 ng/ml ethidium bromide, the rate of mitochondrial protein synthesis was about 35% of the normal, and the cytochrome c oxidase activity about 50% of the control. Cells treated with 20 ng/ml of the drug underwent 3--4 cell doublings at control rates, then gradually stopped growing, and eventually died. In these cells, the rate of incorporation of 3H thymidine into mit-DNA was reduced to 50% of the control value after 10 min treatment with ethidium bromide, and became barely detectable after three cell doublings. At this time, the cells had on the average less than 10% of the control amount of mit-DNA, the rate of mitochondrial protein synthesis was reduced to 3% of the normal, and the specific activities of cytochrome c oxidase and rutamycin-sensitive ATPase were less than 20% of the control values. In spite of these marked changes, the cells exhibited only a 20--30% loss in cell viability, as estimated by cloning efficiency, after three days of exposure to the drug. Cells treated with ethidium bromide at 20 ng/ml for three days, and then transferred to drug-free medium, recovered a near-to-normal growth rate and cloning efficiency and a near-to-normal rate of synthesis and amount of mit-DNA in about five days.

Conservation of genes coding for proteins synthesized in human mitochondria

Proteins synthesized in mitochondria of 27 different human cell lines, identified by labeling with [35S]methionine in the presence of cycloheximide, have been enumerated and their electrophoretic mobilities determined by sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide slab gel electrophoresis and fluorography. Twelve bands were observed in all cell lines. In 24 cell lines, the electrophoretic mobilities of the proteins were the same regardless of race, sex, tissue of origin, cell type, viral transformation, or premature biological aging syndromes. The patterns obtained for the remaining cell lines, HeLa, KB, and Hep-2 were identical. These cell lines showed one protein component that was absent in the 24 others, and lacked a component present in these cell lines. Since it has been previously asserted that KB and Hep-2 are HeLa cells, the data indicate that one basic pattern exists in human cells with a variant of unknown origin occurring in HeLa cells.

Cytoplasmic transfer of resistance to antimycin A in Chinese hamster cells

A mutant subline of V79 Chinese hamster cells resistant to antimycin A (ANT) was obtained by treatment with ethyl methanesulfonate followed by serial selection in ANT-containing medium. Clonal derivatives of the resistant line are less susceptible than parent cells to growth inhibition by ANT in mass populations and show a higher plating efficiency in graded levels of inhibitor. Resistance to ANT is stable in drug-free medium and follows a pattern of incomplete dominance in hybrids between resistant and sensitive cells. No cross-resistance to chloramphenicol or other unrelated compounds was observed. Cytoplasmic transmission of ANT resistance can be readily demonstrated by fusing enucleated cytoplasts from resistant donors to sensitive recipient cells. The resulting cytohybrids ("cybrids") grow selectively in ANT but are identical karyotypically with the recipient cell type. As a putative mitochondrial marker, ANT resistance may be usefully combined with chloramphenicol resistance for studies on segregation and recombination in the mitochondrial genome of mammalian cells.

Mitochondrial inheritance and disease

Spontaneously occurring variants of the D.N.A. content of mitochondria may be responsible for human disease. Among the prime candidates for such a mitochondrial aetiology are certain drug-induced blood dyscrasias, particularly that due to chloramphenicol. Because mitochondria are generally inherited from the female parent, such disorders should be clustered among matroclinally related individuals. The clinical manifestations of such diseases are a function of the manner in which mitochondria are allocated to somatic cells and tissues during development.

Amphibian cells in culture. II. Isolation of drug-resistant variants and an asparagine-independent variant

With L-15 as the base medium, drug-resistant variants were isolated from two amphibian tissue culture strains: the Xenopus laevis A8 diploid cell line and the ICR 2A cell line of Rana pipiens. Four different classes of variants were obtained: (1) A8 cells resistant to chloramphenicol, an inhibitor of mitochondrial protein synthesis; (2) A8 cells resistant to ouabain, an inhibitor of the Na+/K+-activated ATPase of the plasma membrane;(3) ICR 2A cells resistant to low (20 microgram/ml) and high (300 microgram/ml) levels of bromodeoxyuridine (BUdR), a thymidine analog which interferes with the pyrimidine salvage pathway; and (4) ICR 2A cells resistant to 2,6-diaminopurine (DAP), an adenine analog which interferes with the purine salvage pathway. Unlike the other variants, isolation of BUdR resistant cells is a 2-step process. Resistance to low levels of BUdR is phenotypically expressed by a reduction in thymidine transport activities while resistance to high levels of this compound is evidenced by greatly reduced levels of thymidine kinase activity. DAP-resistant cells, which are characterized by reduced levels of adenine phosphoribosyl transferase (APRT) activity, do not die in AAT (adenine, aminopterin, thymidine) selection medium. This suggests that these cells utilize adenine efficiently. With MEM as the base medium, an asparagine independent clone was isolated from the ICR 2A cell line. When compared with the wild type, this variant exhibited a slightly reduced growth rate in the presence or absence of asparagine.

Phenotypic expression of malignancy in hybrid and cybrid mouse cells

This study has been directed toward the effect of cytoplasmic transfer on the expression of marker properties in hybrid cell systems. Conventional hybrids between two nucleated cells were constructed between tumorigenic and nontumorigenic cells. Cytoplasmic hybrids, or cybrids, were constructed between enucleated chloramphenicol resistant (CAP R) donor cells (cytoplasts) and nucleated recipient cells. Clear-cut evidence for the cytoplasmic transmission of CAP resistance was obtained. Although cytoplasmic transfer had no effect on tumorigenicity or growth in soft agar, preliminary evidence was found that saturation density of the recipient cells could be altered by cytoplasmic addition in cybrids.

Cytoplasmic transfer of a determinant for chloramphenicol resistance between mammalian cell lines

A genetic analysis of the resistance phenotype of a recently described chloramphenicol-resistant variant derived from the human cell line, HeLa (MC63), has been undertaken. Whole cells or enucleated fragments, produced by treatment with cytochalasin B, were fused with chloram­phenicol-sensitive mouse, or human cells. Enucleated cells (cytoplasts) act as very efficient donors of the resistance phenotype in fusions with other human cell lines derived from HeLa. We conclude that chloram­phenicol resistance is determined cytoplasmically. Transfer of resistance to unrelated human cell lines occurred at much lower frequency and we were unable to demonstrate transfer to mouse cells. An examination of mitochondrial protein synthesis in the fusion products of cytoplasts and whole cells suggested that mixed populations of mitochondria from both parental cells were maintained under the conditions of selection.

Cytoplasmic inheritance of rutamycin resistance in mouse fibroblasts

Mouse fibroblasts resistant to the drug rutamycin were isolated by selectively introducing BrdUrd into the mitochondrial genome of a line of mouse fibroblasts (clone 1 D) lacking a cytoplasmic thymidine kinase enzyme. The ATPase (ATP phosphohydrolase; EC 3.6.1.3) activity of mitochondria isolated from these cells was resistant to rutamycin. The rutamycin-resistant mutants were enucleated with cytochalasin B and fused with mouse A 9 cells resistant to 8-azaguanine and sensitive to rutamycin. Cytoplasmic hybrids, or cybrids, were selected as cells resistant to rutamycin and 8-azaguanine, and appeared at a high frequency. Other fusions between rutamycin-resistant nucleated cells and A 9 produced colonies at a much lower frequency. Finally, fusions between enucleated clone 1 D cells and A 9 cells produced no rutamycin-resistant colonies. These results indicate that rutamycin resistance is a cytoplasmically inherited characteristic in this cell line.

Carbomycin resistance in mouse L cells

A mutant has been isolated from the mouse cell line LM(TK-) which is stably resistant to the macrolide antibiotic, carbomycin. Mitochondrial protein synthesis in this mutant was carbomycin resistant and chloramphenicol sensitive. Fusions between carbomycin-resistant and -sensitive cells produced hybrids, most of which were sensitive to 10 microgram/ml carbomycin. At 7.5 microgram carbomycin/ml, the average population resistance is low initially but increases with time. Carbomycin-resistant cells were enucleated and fused with carbomycin-sensitive cells under a variety of selective regimes designed to allow growth of carbomycin-resistant cytoplasmic hybrids (cybrids). No transfer of carbomycin resistance via the cytoplasm was detected. Karyoplasts from carbomycin-resistant cells showed a low transfer of resistance to 7.5 microgram carbomycin/ml in karyoplast-cell fusions. Carbomycin resistance in this mutant is therefore most likely encoded in a nuclear gene.

Free calcium in full grown Xenopus laevis oocyte following treatment with ionophore A 23187 or progesterone

Free intracellular Ca2+ was monitored in isolated Xenopus laevis oocyte during induced maturation using the Ca2+ -sensitive luminescent protein, aequorin. Internal free Ca2+ was not precisely measured but data suggest it was quite low (in the micromolar range). No change in internal free Ca2+ was detected during maturation induced either by progesterone or by p-chloromercuribenzoate. By contrast, the ionophore A 23187 gave an increase in the free Ca2+ level when there was a raised external Ca2+ (10 mM), conditions which also induce oocyte maturation. About 3 h after progesterone or p-chloromercuribenzoate stimulation, the oocyte membrane potential decreased by about 50 mV while the membrane resistance increased transitorily.

Selection of reconstituted cells from karyoplasts fused to chloramphenicol-resistant cytoplasts

Murine Balb/3T3 and murine A-MT-BU-A1 mammary tumor cells were separated in the presence of cytochalasin B into enucleated cytoplasmic components (cytoplasts) and nucleated subcellular components (karyoplasts). Karyoplasts were derived from 3T3 cells, while cytoplasts were derived from A-MT-BU-A1 cells that were both chloramphenicol-resistant (CAP(r)) and sensitive to hypoxanthine/aminopterin/thymidine (HAT(s)). CAP(r) has been shown to be cytoplasmically transmitted (possibly a mitochondrial gene mutation), while sensitivity to medium containing HAT has been shown to be transmitted by the nucleus (i.e., nuclear gene mutation). Such CAP(r) cytoplasts derived from A-MT-BU-A1 cells were then fused, using polyethylene glycol, to HAT-resistant 3T3 karyoplasts. The mononucleated reconstituted cells produced by such procedures were cloned in medium containing both HAT and CAP. Some of the reconstituted cells survived, because they were resistant to both drugs, while the nuclear and cytoplasmic whole cell contaminants were killed by one or the other of the two drugs. The results of these experiments indicate that reconstituted cells that are derived from two different cell lines are viable, as indicated by their ability for long-term proliferation in culture. Most of the clones derived resembled morphologically the 3T3 nuclear donor parent cells, but some of the clones did not resemble either parental cell line. It is anticipated that such selection techniques will permit more complete analysis of interrelationships between nucleus and cytoplasm.

Cybrid formation in mouse L cells: the influence of cytoplast-to-cell ratio

The frequency of cybrid colony formation was measured in fusions between enucleated chloramphenicol (CAP)-resistant mouse cells and CAP-sensitive mouse cells in varying ratios. By labeling the CAP-resistant cytoplasts with polystyrene beads and then performing the same fusions with CAP-sensitive cells, the frequency of cybrid fusions could be measured. Comparison of the frequency of viable cybrids (cybrid colonies) with the frequency of cybrid fusions showed that, with increasing fusion ratios of cytoplasts to cells, the proportion of cells fused to cytoplasts increased. Further, the viability of cybrid fusions increased from about 1 in 500 to nearly 1 in 60 over the range of cytoplast-to-cell ratios studied.

Prospects for evaluating genetic damage in mammalian cells in culture

Starting from some general considerations on cultured mammalian cells as a biological material for the detection of genetic changes, information is given on cell lines and genetic markers that have been the subject of extensive research. The experimental variables of mutation assays are then considered, with special reference to those involved in the system resistant to 8-azaguanine. Work now in progressin the field of environmental mutagenesis is mentioned at the end of the article.

Mitotic segregation of cytoplasmic determinants for chloramphenicol resistance in mammalian cells II: Fusions with human cell lines

Cytoplasmically inherited chloramphenicol (CAP) resistance in human cells has been used to study the interaction between sensitive and resistant mitochondria. Cybrids between two HeLa cells were stable for resistance, grew rapidly and cloned well in CAP, and were O2 tolerant. HeLa-HeLa hybrids were also stable up to 70 doublings in the absence of CAP. Cybrids between HeLa and WI-L2 cells were unstable for resistance for up to 40 doublings, grew slowly and cloned poorly in CAP, and were O2 sensitive (S phase). The growth rate then increased and the cells became stable for resistance, cloned well, and were not O2 sensitive (F phase). Doubling time for S but not F phase cells was proportional to CAP concentration, indicating that both kinds of mitochondria were present and functioning. The instability of CAP resistance in many interstrain but not in intrastrain mouse and human cybrids and hybrids is interpreted in relation to lower eukaryotes.

Mitotic segregation of cytoplasmic determinants for chloramphenicol resistance in mammalian cells. I: Fusion with mouse cell lines

The segregation of cytoplasmically inherited chloramphenicol (CAP) resistance in mouse cells was investigated in fusions between CAP-resistant cells or cytoplasts (enucleated cells) and CAP-sensitive cells of varying tissue origin. All hybrids formed in cell-cell fusions were initially CAP-resistant, indicating that CAP resistance is dominant. Hybrids from fusions of cells of the same tissue origin (homologous) were stably CAP-resistant, whereas the hybrid population from fusions of different origins (heterologous) showed a rapid diminution of average CAP resistance. Individual hybrid clones from these heterologous fusions also showed an overall loss of CAP resistance, and a wide variation in CAP resistance which is consistent with a large number of genetic determinants (possibly mitochondrial DNA molecules) contributing to the CAP phenotype. Similar results were obtained from cytoplast-cell fusions, so the observed CAP segregation is not the result of nuclear-nuclear interactions. This segregation of CAP resistance constitutes a second criterion of cytoplasmic inheritance in mammalian cells.