Dependence and independence of [PSI(+)] and [PIN(+)]: a two-prion system in yeast?

Heterologous prion interactions are altered by mutations in the prion protein Rnq1p

Prions in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae show a surprising degree of interdependence. Specifically, the rate of appearance of the [PSI+] prion, which is thought to be an important mechanism to respond to changing environmental conditions, is greatly increased by another prion, [RNQ+]. While the domains of the Rnq1 protein important for formation of the [RNQ+] prion have been defined, the specific residues required remain unknown. Furthermore, residues in Rnq1p that mediate the interaction between [PSI+] and [RNQ+] are unknown. To identify residues important for prion protein interactions, we created a mutant library of Rnq1p clones in the context of a chimera that serves as proxy for [RNQ+] aggregates. Several of the mutant Rnq1p proteins showed structural differences in the aggregates they formed, as revealed by semi-denaturing detergent agarose gel electrophoresis. Additionally, several of the mutants showed a striking defect in the ability to promote [PSI+] induction. These data indicate that the mutants formed strain variants of [RNQ+]. By dissecting the mutations in the isolated clones, we found five single mutations that caused [PSI+] induction defects, S223P, F184S, Q239R, N297S, and Q298R. These are the first specific mutations characterized in Rnq1p that alter [PSI+] induction. Additionally, we have identified a region important for the propagation of certain strain variants of [RNQ+]. Deletion of this region (amino acids 284-317) affected propagation of the high variant but not medium or low [RNQ+] strain variants. Furthermore, when the low [RNQ+] strain variant was propagated by Delta284-317, [PSI+] induction was greatly increased. These data suggest that this region is important in defining the structure of the [RNQ+] strain variants. These data are consistent with a model of [PSI+] induction caused by physical interactions between Rnq1p and Sup35p.

Ssa1 overexpression and [PIN(+)] variants cure [PSI(+)] by dilution of aggregates

Several cellular chaperones have been shown to affect the propagation of the yeast prions [PSI(+)], [PIN(+)] and [URE3]. Ssa1 and Ssa2 are Hsp70 family chaperones that generally cause pro-[PSI(+)] effects, since dominant-negative mutants of Ssa1 or Ssa2 cure [PSI(+)], and overexpression of Ssa1 enhances de novo [PSI(+)] appearance and prevents curing by excess Hsp104. In contrast, Ssa1 was shown to have anti-[URE3] effects, since overexpression of Ssa1 cures [URE3]. Here we show that excess Ssa1 or Ssa2 can also cure [PSI(+)]. This curing is enhanced in the presence of [PIN(+)]. During curing, Sup35-GFP fluorescent aggregates get bigger and fewer in number, which leads to their being diluted out during cell division, a phenotype that was also observed during the curing of [PSI(+)] by certain variants of [PIN(+)]. The sizes of the detergent-resistant [PSI(+)] prion oligomers increase during [PSI(+)] curing by excess Ssa1. Excess Ssa1 likewise leads to an increase in oligomer sizes of low, medium and very high [PIN(+)] variants. While these phenotypes are also caused by inhibition of Hsp104 or Sis1, the overexpression of Ssa1 did not cause any change in Hsp104 or Sis1 levels.

A systematic survey identifies prions and illuminates sequence features of prionogenic proteins

Prions are proteins that convert between structurally and functionally distinct states, one or more of which is transmissible. In yeast, this ability allows them to act as non-Mendelian elements of phenotypic inheritance. To further our understanding of prion biology, we conducted a bioinformatic proteome-wide survey for prionogenic proteins in S. cerevisiae, followed by experimental investigations of 100 prion candidates. We found an unexpected amino acid bias in aggregation-prone candidates and discovered that 19 of these could also form prions. At least one of these prion proteins, Mot3, produces a bona fide prion in its natural context that increases population-level phenotypic heterogeneity. The self-perpetuating states of these proteins present a vast source of heritable phenotypic variation that increases the adaptability of yeast populations to diverse environments.

The cellular concentration of the yeast Ure2p prion protein affects its propagation as a prion

The [URE3] yeast prion is a self-propagating inactive form of the Ure2p protein. We show here that Ure2p from the species Saccharomyces paradoxus (Ure2p(Sp)) can be efficiently converted into a prion form and propagate [URE3] when expressed in Saccharomyces cerevisiae at physiological level. We found however that Ure2p(Sp) overexpression prevents efficient prion propagation. We have compared the aggregation rate and propagon numbers of Ure2p(Sp) and of S. cerevisiae Ure2p (Ure2p(Sc)) in [URE3] cells both at different expression levels. Overexpression of both Ure2p orthologues accelerates formation of large aggregates but Ure2p(Sp) aggregates faster than Ure2p(Sc). Although the yeast cells that contain these large Ure2p aggregates do not transmit [URE3] to daughter cells, the corresponding crude extract retains the ability to induce [URE3] in wild-type [ure3-0] cells. At low expression level, propagon numbers are higher with Ure2p(Sc) than with Ure2p(Sp). Overexpression of Ure2p decreases the number of [URE3] propagons with Ure2p(Sc). Together, our results demonstrate that the concentration of a prion protein is a key factor for prion propagation. We propose a model to explain how prion protein overexpression can produce a detrimental effect on prion propagation and why Ure2p(Sp) might be more sensitive to such effects than Ure2p(Sc).

Prion switching in response to environmental stress

Evolution depends on the manner in which genetic variation is translated into new phenotypes. There has been much debate about whether organisms might have specific mechanisms for "evolvability," which would generate heritable phenotypic variation with adaptive value and could act to enhance the rate of evolution. Capacitor systems, which allow the accumulation of cryptic genetic variation and release it under stressful conditions, might provide such a mechanism. In yeast, the prion [PSI(+)] exposes a large array of previously hidden genetic variation, and the phenotypes it thereby produces are advantageous roughly 25% of the time. The notion that [PSI(+)] is a mechanism for evolvability would be strengthened if the frequency of its appearance increased with stress. That is, a system that mediates even the haphazard appearance of new phenotypes, which have a reasonable chance of adaptive value would be beneficial if it were deployed at times when the organism is not well adapted to its environment. In an unbiased, high-throughput, genome-wide screen for factors that modify the frequency of [PSI(+)] induction, signal transducers and stress response genes were particularly prominent. Furthermore, prion induction increased by as much as 60-fold when cells were exposed to various stressful conditions, such as oxidative stress (H2O2) or high salt concentrations. The severity of stress and the frequency of [PSI(+)] induction were highly correlated. These findings support the hypothesis that [PSI(+)] is a mechanism to increase survival in fluctuating environments and might function as a capacitor to promote evolvability.

A prion of yeast metacaspase homolog (Mca1p) detected by a genetic screen

Saccharomyces cerevisiae can be infected with four amyloid-based prions: [URE3], [PSI(+)], [PIN(+)], and [SWI(+)], due to self-propagating aggregation of Ure2p, Sup35p, Rnq1p and Swi1p, respectively. We searched for new prions of yeast by fusing random segments of yeast DNA to SUP35MC, encoding the Sup35 protein lacking its own prion domain, selecting clones in which Sup35MC function was impaired. Three different clones contained parts of the Q/N-rich amino-terminal domain of Mca1p/Yca1p with the Sup35 part of the fusion protein partially inactive. This inactivity was dominant, segregated 4:0 in meiosis, and was efficiently transferred by cytoplasmic mixing. The inactivity was cured by overexpression of Hsp104, but the prion could arise again in the cured strain (reversible curing). Overproduction of the Mca1 N-terminal domain induced the de novo appearance of the prion form of the fusion. The prion state, which we name [MCA], was transmitted to the chromosomally encoded Mca1p based on genetic, cytological and biochemical tests.

Insights into intragenic and extragenic effectors of prion propagation using chimeric prion proteins

The study of fungal prion proteins affords remarkable opportunities to elucidate both intragenic and extragenic effectors of prion propagation. The yeast prion protein Sup35 and the self-perpetuating [PSI+] prion state is one of the best characterized fungal prions. While there is little sequence homology among known prion proteins, one region of striking similarity exists between Sup35p and the mammalian prion protein PrP. This region is comprised of roughly five octapeptide repeats of similar composition. The expansion of the repeat region in PrP is associated with inherited prion diseases. In order to learn more about the effects of PrP repeat expansions on the structural properties of a protein that undergoes a similar transition to a self-perpetuating aggregate, we generated chimeric Sup35-PrP proteins. Using both in vivo and in vitro systems we described the effect of repeat length on protein misfolding, aggregation, amyloid formation and amyloid stability. We found that repeat expansions in the chimeric prion proteins increase the propensity to initiate prion propagation and enhance the formation of amyloid fibers without significantly altering fiber stability.

Chaperone-dependent amyloid assembly protects cells from prion toxicity

Protein conformational diseases are associated with the aberrant accumulation of amyloid protein aggregates, but whether amyloid formation is cytotoxic or protective is unclear. To address this issue, we investigated a normally benign amyloid formed by the yeast prion [RNQ(+)]. Surprisingly, modest overexpression of Rnq1 protein was deadly, but only when preexisting Rnq1 was in the [RNQ(+)] prion conformation. Molecular chaperones protect against protein aggregation diseases and are generally believed to do so by solubilizing their substrates. The Hsp40 chaperone, Sis1, suppressed Rnq1 proteotoxicity, but instead of blocking Rnq1 protein aggregation, it stimulated conversion of soluble Rnq1 to [RNQ(+)] amyloid. Furthermore, interference with Sis1-mediated [RNQ(+)] amyloid formation exacerbated Rnq1 toxicity. These and other data establish that even subtle changes in the folding homeostasis of an amyloidogenic protein can create a severe proteotoxic gain-of-function phenotype and that chaperone-mediated amyloid assembly can be cytoprotective. The possible relevance of these findings to other phenomena, including prion-driven neurodegenerative diseases and heterokaryon incompatibility in fungi, is discussed.

Prions

Prions were originally defined as infectious agents of protein nature, which caused neurodegenerative diseases in animals and humans. The prion concept implies that the infectious agent is a protein in special conformation that can be transmitted to the normal molecules of the same protein through protein-protein interactions. Until the 1990s, the prion phenomenon was associated with the single protein named PrP. Discovery of prions in lower eukaryotes, the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae and fungus Podospora anserina, suggests that prions have wider significance. Prions of lower eukaryotes are not related to diseases; their propagation caused by aggregation of prion-like proteins underlies the inheritance of phenotypic traits and most likely has adaptive significance. This review covers prions of mammals and lower eukaryotes, mechanisms of their appearance de novo and maintenance, structure of prion particles, and prospects for the treatment of prion diseases. Recent data concerning the search for new prion-like proteins is included. The paper focuses on the [PSI+] prion of S. cerevisiae, since at present it is the most investigated one. The biological significance of prions is discussed.

A regulatory role of the Rnq1 nonprion domain for prion propagation and polyglutamine aggregates

Prions are infectious, self-propagating protein conformations. Rnq1 is required for the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae prion [PIN(+)], which is necessary for the de novo induction of a second prion, [PSI(+)]. Here we isolated a [PSI(+)]-eliminating mutant, Rnq1Delta100, that deletes the nonprion domain of Rnq1. Rnq1Delta100 inhibits not only [PSI(+)] prion propagation but also [URE3] prion and huntingtin's polyglutamine aggregate propagation in a [PIN(+)] background but not in a [pin(-)] background. Rnq1Delta100, however, does not eliminate [PIN(+)]. These findings are interpreted as showing a possible involvement of the Rnq1 prion in the maintenance of heterologous prions and polyQ aggregates. Rnq1 and Rnq1Delta100 form a sodium dodecyl sulfate-stable and Sis1 (an Hsp40 chaperone protein)-containing coaggregate in [PIN(+)] cells. Importantly, Rnq1Delta100 is highly QN-rich and prone to self-aggregate or coaggregate with Rnq1 when coexpressed in [pin(-)] cells. However, the [pin(-)] Rnq1-Rnq1Delta100 coaggregate does not represent a prion-like aggregate. These findings suggest that [PIN(+)] Rnq1-Rnq1Delta100 aggregates interact with other transmissible and nontransmissible amyloids to destabilize them and that the nonprion domain of Rnq1 plays a crucial role in self-regulation of the highly reactive QN-rich prion domain of Rnq1.

Amyloid of Rnq1p, the basis of the [PIN+] prion, has a parallel in-register beta-sheet structure

The [PIN(+)] prion, a self-propagating amyloid form of Rnq1p, increases the frequency with which the [PSI(+)] or [URE3] prions arise de novo. Like the prion domains of Sup35p and Ure2p, Rnq1p is rich in N and Q residues, but rnq1Delta strains have no known phenotype except for inability to propagate the [PIN(+)] prion. We used solid-state NMR methods to examine amyloid formed in vitro from recombinant Rnq1 prion domain (residues 153-405) labeled with Tyr-1-(13)C (14 residues), Leu-1-(13)C (7 residues), or Ala-3-(13)C (13 residues). The carbonyl chemical shifts indicate that most Tyr and Leu residues are in beta-sheet conformation. Experiments designed to measure the distance from each labeled residue to the next nearest labeled carbonyl showed that almost all Tyr and Leu carbonyl carbon atoms were approximately 0.5 nm from the next nearest Tyr and Leu residues, respectively. This result indicates that the Rnq1 prion domain forms amyloid consisting of parallel beta-strands that are either in register or are at most one amino acid out of register. Similar experiments with Ala-3-(13)C indicate that the beta-strands are indeed in-register. The parallel in-register structure, now demonstrated for each of the yeast prions, explains the faithful templating of prion strains, and suggests as well a mechanism for the rare hetero-priming that is [PIN(+)]'s defining characteristic.

Effects of mutations in yeast prion [PSI+] on amyloid toxicity manifested in Escherichia coli strain BL21

We previously showed that over production of a fusion protein in which the prion domain of Saccharomyces cerevisiae [PSI(+)] is connected to glutathione S-transferase (GST-Sup35NM) causes a marked decrease in the colony forming ability of Escherichia coli strain BL21 after reaching stationary phase. Evidence indicated that the observed toxicity was attributable to intracellular formation of fibrous aggregates of GST-Sup35NM. In this report, we describe the isolation of plasmids that encode mutant forms of GST-Sup35NM which do not confer the toxicity to E. coli strain BL21. Each of the four spontaneous mutant-forms of GST-Sup35NM obtained revealed amino acid substitutions. One substitution was located in the N domain, and the others in the M domain. Congo red binding assay indicated that none of these mutant proteins underwent conformational alteration in vitro. From these results, we conclude that the M domain, in collaboration with the N domain, plays an essential role in aggregation of Sup35NM. In addition, our data demonstrate the usefulness of the E. coli expression system in studying aggregate-forming proteins.

Prion protein/protein interactions: fusion with yeast Sup35p-NM modulates cytosolic PrP aggregation in mammalian cells

In mammalian prion diseases, an abnormally folded, aggregated form of the prion protein (PrP(Sc)) appears to catalyze a conformational switch of its cellular isoform (PrP(C)) to an aggregated state. A similar prion-like phenomenon has been reported for the Saccharomyces cerevisiae translation termination factor Sup35p that can adopt a self-propagating conformation. We have compared aggregation propensities of chimeric proteins derived from the Sup35p prion domain NM and PrP in vitro and in the cytosol of mammalian cells. Sup35p-NM and PrP displayed strikingly different aggregation behaviors when expressed in mammalian cells, with NM remaining soluble and cytosolic PrP spontaneously aggregating due to the globular domain of PrP. When fused to PrP(90-230), Sup35p-M exhibited an inhibitory effect for nucleation but increased aggregate growth, potentially by facilitating recruitment of newly synthesized chimeric proteins into the growing aggregates. This effect, however, could, to some extent, be counteracted by the prion-forming region Sup35p-N, thereby increasing aggregate frequency. Interestingly, a lowered nucleation rate was also observed in the presence of the amino-terminal region of PrP, suggesting that Sup35p-M and PrP(23-90) share some biological function in prion protein assembly. Our results provide new insights into prion protein aggregation behaviors, demonstrating the impact of dynamic interactions between prion domains and suggesting that aggregation of yeast and mammalian prion proteins is strongly influenced by yet unidentified cellular conditions or factors.

Cross-seeding and cross-competition in mouse apolipoprotein A-II amyloid fibrils and protein A amyloid fibrils

Murine senile [apolipoprotein A-II amyloid (AApoAII)] and reactive [protein A amyloid (AA)] amyloidosis are reported to be transmissible diseases via a seeding mechanism similar to that observed in the prion-associated disorders, although de novo amyloidogenesis and the progression of AApoAII or AA amyloidosis remain unclear. We examined the effect of co-injection of AApoAII and AA fibrils and multiple inflammatory stimuli in R1.P1-Apoa2(c) mice with the amyloidogenic Apoa2(c) allele. Both AApoAII and AA amyloidosis could be induced in this system, but the two types of amyloid fibrils preferentially promote the formation of the same type of fibrils while inhibiting the formation of the other. Furthermore, we demonstrate that AA or AApoAII amyloidosis could be cross-seeded by predeposited AApoAII or AA fibrils and that the predeposited amyloid fibrils were degraded when the fibril formation was reduced or stopped. In addition, a large proportion of the two amyloid fibrils colocalized during the formation of new fibrils in the spleen and liver. Thus, we propose that AApoAII and AA can both cross-seed and cross-compete with regard to amyloid formation, depending on the stage of amyloidogenesis. These results will aid in the clarification of the mechanisms of pathogenesis and progression of amyloid disorders.

Saupe S, Liebman SW. A non-Q/N-rich prion domain of a foreign prion, [Het-s], can propagate as a prion in yeast

Prions are self-propagating, infectious aggregates of misfolded proteins. The mammalian prion, PrP(Sc), causes fatal neurodegenerative disorders. Fungi also have prions. While yeast prions depend upon glutamine/asparagine (Q/N)-rich regions, the Podospora anserina HET-s and PrP prion proteins lack such sequences. Nonetheless, we show that the HET-s prion domain fused to GFP propagates as a prion in yeast. Analogously to native yeast prions, transient overexpression of the HET-s fusion induces ring-like aggregates that propagate in daughter cells as cytoplasmically inherited, detergent-resistant dot aggregates. Efficient dot propagation, but not ring formation, is dependent upon the Hsp104 chaperone. The yeast prion [PIN(+)] enhances HET-s ring formation, suggesting that prions with and without Q/N-rich regions interact. Finally, HET-s aggregates propagated in yeast are infectious when introduced into Podospora. Taken together, these results demonstrate prion propagation in a truly foreign host. Since yeast can host non-Q/N-rich prions, such native yeast prions may exist.

Prion-prion interactions

The term prion has been used to describe self-replicating protein conformations that can convert other protein molecules of the same primary structure into its prion conformation. Several different proteins have now been found to exist as prions in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Surprisingly, these heterologous prion proteins have a strong influence on each others' appearance and propagation, which may result from structural similarity between the prions. Both positive and negative effects of a prion on the de novo appearance of a heterologous prion have been observed in genetic studies. Other examples of reported interactions include mutual or unilateral inhibition and destabilization when two prions are present together in a single cell. In vitro work showing that one purified prion stimulates the conversion of a purified heterologous protein into a prion form, suggests that facilitation of de novo prion formation by heterologous prions in vivo is a result of a direct interaction between the prion proteins (a cross-seeding mechanism) and does not require other cellular components. However, other cellular structures, e.g., the cytoskeleton, may provide a scaffold for these interactions in vivo and chaperones can further facilitate or inhibit this process. Some negative prion-prion interactions may also occur via a direct interaction between the prion proteins. Another explanation is a competition between the prions for cellular factors involved in prion propagation or differential effects of chaperones stimulated by one prion on the heterologous prions.

Prion stability

The rate of spontaneous change from psi(-) to the psi(+) condition, determined in yeast by states of the Sup35p protein, is briefly discussed together with the conditions necessary for such change to occur. Conditions that promote and which affect the rate of induction of psi(+) in Sup35p and of other prion-forming proteins to their respective prion forms are also discussed. These include the influence of the amount of non-prion protein, the presence of other prions, the activity of chaperones, and brief descriptions of the role of native sequences in the proteins and how alteration of sequences in prion-forming proteins influences the rate of induction of [prion(+)] and amyloid forms. The second part of this article discusses the conditions which affect the reversion of psi(+) to psi-, including factors which affect the copy-number of prion "seeds" or propagons and their partition. The principal factor discussed is the activity of the chaperone Hsp104, but the existence of other factors, such protein sequence and of other, less well-studied agents is touched upon and comparisons are made, as appropriate, with studies with other yeast prions. We conclude with a discussion of models of maintenance, in particular that of Tanaka et al. published in Nature (2006), which provides much insight into the phenotypic and genetic parameters of the numerous "variants" of prions increasingly being described in the literature.

Prion protein repeat expansion results in increased aggregation and reveals phenotypic variability

Mammalian prion diseases are fatal neurodegenerative disorders dependent on the prion protein PrP. Expansion of the oligopeptide repeats (ORE) found in PrP is associated with inherited prion diseases. Patients with ORE frequently harbor PrP aggregates, but other factors may contribute to pathology, as they often present with unexplained phenotypic variability. We created chimeric yeast-mammalian prion proteins to examine the influence of the PrP ORE on prion properties in yeast. Remarkably, all chimeric proteins maintained prion characteristics. The largest repeat expansion chimera displayed a higher propensity to maintain a self-propagating aggregated state. Strikingly, the repeat expansion conferred increased conformational flexibility, as observed by enhanced phenotypic variation. Furthermore, the repeat expansion chimera displayed an increased rate of prion conversion, but only in the presence of another aggregate, the [RNQ+] prion. We suggest that the PrP ORE increases the conformational flexibility of the prion protein, thereby enhancing the formation of multiple distinct aggregate structures and allowing more frequent prion conversion. Both of these characteristics may contribute to the phenotypic variability associated with PrP repeat expansion diseases.

Effects of Ubiquitin System Alterations on the Formation and Loss of a Yeast Prion

The yeast prion [PSI+] is a self-propagating amyloidogenic isoform of the translation termination factor Sup35. Overproduction of the chaperone protein Hsp104 results in loss of [PSI+]. Here we demonstrate that this effect is decreased by deletion of either the gene coding for one of the major yeast ubiquitin-conjugating enzymes, Ubc4, or the gene coding for the ubiquitin-recycling enzyme, Ubp6. The effect of ubc4Delta on [PSI+] loss was increased by depletion of the Hsp70 chaperone Ssb but was not influenced by depletion of Ubp6. This indicates that Ubc4 affects [PSI+] loss via a pathway that is the same as the one affected by Ubp6 but not by Ssb. In the presence of Rnq1 protein, ubc4Delta also facilitates spontaneous de novo formation of [PSI+]. This stimulation is independent of [PIN+], the prion isoform of Rnq1. Numerous attempts failed to detect ubiquitinated Sup35 in the yeast extracts. While ubc4Delta and other alterations of ubiquitin system used in this work cause slight induction of some Hsps, these changes are insufficient to explain their effect on [PSI+]. However, ubc4Delta increases the proportion of the Hsp70 chaperone Ssa bound to Sup35, suggesting that misfolded Sup35 is either more abundant or more accessible to the chaperones in the absence of Ubc4. The proportion of [PSI+] cells containing large aggregated Sup35 structures is also increased by ubc4Delta. We propose that UPS alterations induce an adaptive response, resulting in accumulation of the large "aggresome"-like aggregates that promote de novo prion generation and prion recovery from the chaperone treatment.

Biochemical and genetic methods for characterization of [PIN+] prions in yeast

The glutamine- and asparagine-rich Rnq1p protein in Saccharomyces cerevisiae can exist in the cell as a soluble monomer or in one of several aggregated, infectious, prion forms called [PIN(+)]. Interest in [PIN(+)] is heightened by its ability to promote the conversion of other proteins into a prion or an aggregated amyloid state. However, little is known about the function of Rnq1p, which makes it difficult to assay the phenotypes associated with its normal vs. prion forms. In this chapter, we describe methods used to detect [PIN(+)] and distinguish between different variations of the prion. Genetic methods are based on the ability of the [PIN(+)] prion to facilitate the appearance of another yeast prion, [PSI(+)], which has an easily detectable phenotype. Biochemical methods exploit the fact that the [PIN(+)] prion exists in the yeast cytosol in the form of large aggregates, composed of SDS-stable subparticles. Sucrose gradient centrifugation, agarose SDS electrophoresis and GFP fusions are used to distinguish between aggregates and subparticles from different [PIN(+)] variants.

Analysis of amyloid aggregates using agarose gel electrophoresis

Amyloid aggregates are associated with a number of mammalian neurodegenerative diseases. Infectious aggregates of the mammalian prion protein PrP(sc) are hallmarks of transmissible spongiform encephalopathies in humans and cattle (Griffith, 1967; Legname et al., 2004; Prusiner, 1982; Silveira et al., 2004). Likewise, SDS-stable aggregates and low-n oligomers of the Abeta peptide (Selkoe et al., 1982; Walsh et al., 2002) cause toxic effects associated with Alzheimer's disease (Selkoe, 2004). The discovery of prions in lower eukaryotes, for example, yeast prions [PSI(+)], [PIN(+)], and [URE3] suggested that prion phenomena may represent a fundamental process that is widespread among living organisms (Chernoff, 2004; Uptain and Lindquist, 2002; Wickner, 1994; Wickner et al., 2004). These protein structures are more stable than other cellular protein complexes, which generally dissolve in SDS at room temperature. In contrast, the prion polymers withstand these conditions, while losing their association with their non-prion partners. These bulky protein particles cannot be analyzed in polyacrylamide gels, because their pores are too small to allow the passage and acceptable resolution of the large complexes. This problem was first circumvented by Kryndushkin et al. (2003), who used Western blots of protein complexes separated on agarose gels to analyze the sizes of SDS-resistant protein complexes associated with the yeast prion [PSI(+)]. Further studies have used this approach to characterize [PSI(+)] (Allen et al., 2005; Bagriantsev and Liebman, 2004; Salnikova et al., 2005), and another yeast prion [PIN(+)] (Bagriantsev and Liebman, 2004). In this chapter, we use this method to assay amyloid aggregates of recombinant proteins Sup35NM and Abeta42 and present protocols for Western blot analysis of high molecular weight (>5 MDa) amyloid aggregates resolved in agarose gels. The technique is suitable for the analysis of any large proteins or SDS-stable high molecular weight complexes.

Genetic interactions between [PSI+] and nonstop mRNA decay affect phenotypic variation

Yeast strains can reversibly interconvert between [PSI+] and [psi-] states. The [PSI+] state is caused by a prion form of the translation termination factor eRF3. The [PSI+] state causes read-through at stop codons and can lead to phenotypic variation, although the molecular mechanisms causing those phenotypic changes remain unknown. We identify an interaction between [PSI+]-induced phenotypic variation and defects in nonstop mRNA decay. Nonstop mRNA decay is triggered when a ribosome reaches the 3' end of the transcript. In contrast, we observed little interaction between [PSI+]-induced phenotypic variation and defects in nonsense-mediated decay, which lead to suppression of premature stop codons. These results suggest that at least some of the phenotypic effects of [PSI+] may be due to read-through of "normal" stop codons, thereby producing extended proteins. Moreover, these observations suggest that nonstop mRNA decay may limit [PSI+]-induced phenotypic variation. Such a process would allow periodic sampling of the 3' UTR, which can diverge rapidly, for novel and beneficial protein extensions.

Prions as adaptive conduits of memory and inheritance

Changes in protein conformation drive most biological processes, but none have seized the imagination of scientists and the public alike as have the self-replicating conformations of prions. Prions transmit lethal neurodegenerative diseases by means of the food chain. However, self-replicating protein conformations can also constitute molecular memories that transmit genetic information. Here, we showcase definitive evidence for the prion hypothesis and discuss examples in which prion-encoded heritable information has been harnessed during evolution to confer selective advantages. We then describe situations in which prion-enciphered events might have essential roles in long-term memory formation, transcriptional memory and genome-wide expression patterns.

Prion genetics: new rules for a new kind of gene

Just as nucleic acids can carry out enzymatic reactions, proteins can be genes. These heritable infectious proteins (prions) follow unique genetic rules that enable their identification: reversible curing, inducible "spontaneous generation," and phenotype surprises. Most prions are based on self-propagating amyloids, depend heavily on chaperones, show strain phenomena and, like other infectious elements, show species barriers to transmission. A recently identified prion is based on obligatory self-activation of an enzyme in trans. Although prions can be detrimental, they may also be beneficial to their hosts.

Prion domain interaction responsible for species discrimination in yeast [PSI+] transmission

BACKGROUND

The yeast [PSI+] factor is transmitted by a prion mechanism involving self-propagating Sup35 aggregates. As with mammalian prions, a species barrier prevents prion transmission between yeast species. The N-terminal of Sup35 of Saccharomyces cerevisiae, necessary for [PSI+], contains two species-signature elements-a Gln/Asn-rich region (residues 1-41; designated NQ) that is followed by oligopeptide repeats (designated NR).

RESULTS

In this study, we show that S. cerevisiae[PSI+] is transmissible through plasmid shuffling and cytoplasmic transfer to heterotypic Sup35s whose NQ is replaced with the S. cerevisiae NQ. In addition to homology, the N-terminal location is essential for NQ mediated susceptibility to [PSI+] transmission amongst heterotypic Sup35s. In vitro, a swap of NQ of S. cerevisiae Sup35 led to cross seeding of amyloid formation.

CONCLUSIONS

These findings suggest that NQ discriminates self from non-self, and is sufficient to initiate [PSI+] transmission irrespective of whether NR is heterotypic. NR as well as NQ alone coalesces into existing [PSI+] aggregates, showing their independent potentials to interact with the identical sequence in the [PSI+] conformer. The role of NQ and NR in [PSI+] prion formation is discussed.

Effects of Q/N-rich, polyQ, and non-polyQ amyloids on the de novo formation of the [PSI+] prion in yeast and aggregation of Sup35 in vitro

Prions are infectious protein conformations that are generally ordered protein aggregates. In the absence of prions, newly synthesized molecules of these same proteins usually maintain a conventional soluble conformation. However, prions occasionally arise even without a homologous prion template. The conformational switch that results in the de novo appearance of yeast prions with glutamine/aspargine (Q/N)-rich prion domains (e.g., [PSI+]), is promoted by heterologous prions with a similar domain (e.g., [RNQ+], also known as [PIN+]), or by overexpression of proteins with prion-like Q-, N-, or Q/N-rich domains. This finding led to the hypothesis that aggregates of heterologous proteins provide an imperfect template on which the new prion is seeded. Indeed, we show that newly forming Sup35 and preexisting Rnq1 aggregates always colocalize when [PSI+] appearance is facilitated by the [RNQ+] prion, and that Rnq1 fibers enhance the in vitro formation of fibers by the prion domain of Sup35 (NM). The proteins do not however form mixed, interdigitated aggregates. We also demonstrate that aggregating variants of the polyQ-containing domain of huntingtin promote the de novo conversion of Sup35 into [PSI+]; whereas nonaggregating variants of huntingtin and aggregates of non-polyQ amyloidogenic proteins, transthyretin, alpha-synuclein, and synphilin do not. Furthermore, transthyretin and alpha-synuclein amyloids do not facilitate NM aggregation in vitro, even though in [PSI+] cells NM and transthyretin aggregates also occasionally colocalize. Our data, especially the in vitro reproduction of the highly specific heterologous seeding effect, provide strong support for the hypothesis of cross-seeding in the spontaneous initiation of prion states.

Saccharomyces cerevisiae Hsp104 enhances the chaperone capacity of human cells and inhibits heat stress-induced proapoptotic signaling

Hsp104, the most potent thermotolerance factor in Saccharomyces cerevisiae, is an unusual molecular chaperone that is associated with the dispersal of aggregated, non-native proteins in vivo and in vitro. The close cooperation between Hsp100 oligomeric disaggregases and specific Hsp70 chaperone/cochaperone systems to refold and reactivate heat-damaged proteins has been dubbed a "bichaperone network". Interestingly, animal genomes do not encode a Hsp104 ortholog. To investigate the biochemical and biological consequences of introducing into human cells a stress tolerance factor that has protein refolding capabilities distinct from those already present, Hsp104 was expressed as a transgene in a human leukemic T-cell line (PEER). Hsp104 inhibited heat-shock-induced loss of viability in PEER cells, and this action correlated with reduced procaspase-3 cleavage but not with reduced c-Jun N-terminal kinase phosphorylation. Hsp104 cooperated with endogenous human Hsp70 and Hsc70 molecular chaperones and their J-domain-containing cochaperones Hdj1 and Hdj2 to produce a functional hybrid bichaperone network capable of refolding aggregated luciferase. We also established that Hsp104 shuttles across the nuclear envelope and enhances the chaperoning capacity of both the cytoplasm and nucleoplasm of intact cells. Our results establish the fundamental properties of protein disaggregase function in human cells with implications for the use of Hsp104 or related proteins as therapeutic agents in diseases associated with protein aggregation.

The role of pre-existing aggregates in Hsp104-dependent polyglutamine aggregate formation and epigenetic change of yeast prions

Amyloid-like protein aggregates have been implicated in various diseases and in the protein-based inheritance of yeast prions. The molecular chaperone Hsp104 has been shown to be necessary for the aggregate formation of polyglutamine in yeast, and for the maintenance of several yeast prion phenotypes through the formation of self-propagating aggregates. In this paper, we show that the polyglutamine aggregates that are formed independently of Hsp104, are required for Hsp104 to efficiently produce more aggregates. Similarly, in the yeast prion [PSI+] system, Hsp104-dependent epigenetic changes to the [PSI+] prion phenotype require the presence of prion aggregates in the normal [psi-] state. We also show that the co-localization of different prion aggregates suggests that cross-seeding by different yeast prions increases the probability of Hsp104-dependent epigenetic change. These findings highlight the role of pre-existing aggregates in chaperone-dependent establishment of the epigenetic trait in yeast prions, and possibly in the pathology of several neurodegenerative diseases.

The Sup35 domains required for maintenance of weak, strong or undifferentiated yeast [PSI+] prions

The Sup35 protein can exist in a non-infectious form or in various infectious forms called [PSI+] prion variants (or prion strains). Each of the different [PSI+] prion variants converts non-infectious Sup35 molecules into that prion variant's infectious form. One definition of a 'prion domain' is the minimal fragment of a prion protein that is necessary and sufficient to maintain the prion form. We now demonstrate that the Sup35 N region (residues 1-123), which is frequently referred to as the 'prion domain', is insufficient to maintain the weak or strong [PSI+] variants per se, but appears to maintain them in an 'undifferentiated' [PSI+] state that can differentiate into weak or strong [PSI+] variants when transferred to the full-length Sup35 protein. In contrast, Sup35 residues 1-137 are necessary and sufficient to faithfully maintain weak or strong [PSI+] variants. This implicates Sup35 residues 124-137 in the variant-specific maintenance of the weak or strong [PSI+] forms. Structure predictions indicate that the residues in the 124-137 region form an alpha-helix and that the 1-123 region may have beta structure. In view of these findings, we discuss a plausible molecular basis for the [PSI+] prion variants as well as the inherent difficulties in defining a 'prion domain'.

Emerging Principles of Conformation-Based Prion Inheritance

The prion hypothesis proposes that proteins can act as infectious agents. Originally formulated to explain transmissible spongiform encephalopathies (TSEs), the prion hypothesis has been extended with the finding that several non-Mendelian traits in fungi are due to heritable changes in protein conformation, which may in some cases be beneficial. Although much remains to be learned about the specific role of cellular cofactors, mechanistic parallels between the mammalian and yeast prion phenomena point to universal features of conformation-based infection and inheritance involving propagation of ordered beta-sheet-rich protein aggregates commonly referred to as amyloid. Here we focus on two such features and discuss recent efforts to explain them in terms of the physical properties of amyloid-like aggregates. The first is prion strains, wherein chemically identical infectious particles cause distinct phenotypes. The second is barriers that often prohibit prion transmission between different species. There is increasing evidence suggesting that both of these can be manifestations of the same phenomenon: the ability of a protein to misfold into multiple self-propagating conformations. Even single mutations can change the spectrum of favored misfolded conformations. In turn, changes in amyloid conformation can shift the specificity of propagation and alter strain phenotypes. This model helps explain many common and otherwise puzzling features of prion inheritance as well as aspects of noninfectious diseases involving toxic misfolded proteins.

The impact of manipulations with cytoplasmically inherited factors on nuclear transmission and degradation in yeast heterokaryons

Heterokaryotic zygotes in yeast provide a unique possibility to study the survival and transmission of two genetically diverse nuclei in one cell. Using partial pedigree analysis, we show that various treatments used to change cytoplasmic hereditary determinants can essentially affect nuclear transmission in yeast heterokaryons. This includes choice of nucleus to enter the first bud and incidence of various classes of mother/daughter pairs demonstrating nuclear degradation patterns in heterokaryotic zygotes. These treatments include guanidine hydrochloride, a prion-curing agent, ethidium bromide, an agent causing elimination of mitochondrial DNA, and cytoplasm replacement by cytoduction, which leads to mtDNA replacement and transfer of some other cytoplasmically inherited determinants. The genetic and cytological evidence obtained favors prion involvement in nuclear transmission and suggests apoptotic features in nuclear degradation in yeast heterokaryotic zygotes.

Destabilizing Interactions Among [PSI +] and [PIN +] Yeast Prion Variants

The yeast Sup35 and Rnq1 proteins can exist in either the noninfectious soluble forms, [psi–]or[pin–], respectively, or the multiple infectious amyloid-like forms called [PSI+]or[PIN+] prion variants (or prion strains). It was previously shown that [PSI+] and [PIN+] prions enhance one another's de novo appearance. Here we show that specific prion variants of [PSI+] and [PIN+] disrupt each other's stable inheritance. Acquiring [PSI+] often impedes the inheritance of particular [PIN+] variants. Conversely, the presence of some [PIN+] variants impairs the inheritance of weak [PSI+] but not strong [PSI+] variants. These same [PIN+] variants generate a single-dot fluorescence pattern when a fusion of Rnq1 and green fluorescent protein is expressed. Another [PIN+] variant, which forms a distinctly different multiple-dot fluorescence pattern, does not impair [PSI+] inheritance. Thus, destabilization of prions by heterologous prions depends upon the variants involved. These findings may have implications for understanding interactions among other amyloid-forming proteins, including those associated with certain human diseases.

Conservation of the prion properties of Ure2p through evolution

The yeast inheritable [URE3] element corresponds to a prion form of the nitrogen catabolism regulator Ure2p. We have isolated several orthologous URE2 genes in different yeast species: Saccharomyces paradoxus, S. uvarum, Kluyveromyces lactis, Candida albicans, and Schizosaccharomyces pombe. We show here by in silico analysis that the GST-like functional domain and the prion domain of the Ure2 proteins have diverged separately, the functional domain being more conserved through the evolution. The more extreme situation is found in the two S. pombe genes, in which the prion domain is absent. The functional analysis demonstrates that all the homologous genes except for the two S. pombe genes are able to complement the URE2 gene deletion in a S. cerevisiae strain. We show that in the two most closely related yeast species to S. cerevisiae, i.e., S. paradoxus and S. uvarum, the prion domains of the proteins have retained the capability to induce [URE3] in a S. cerevisiae strain. However, only the S. uvarum full-length Ure2p is able to behave as a prion. We also show that the prion inactivation mechanisms can be cross-transmitted between the S. cerevisiae and S. uvarum prions.

Guanidine reduces stop codon read-through caused by missense mutations in SUP35 or SUP45

Sup35 and Sup45 are essential protein components of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae translation termination factor. Yeast cells harbouring the [PSI(+)] prion form of Sup35 have impaired stop codon recognition (nonsense suppression). It has long been known that the [PSI(+)] prion is not stably transmitted to daughter cells when yeast are grown in the presence of mM concentrations of guanidine hydrochloride (GuHCl). In this paper, Mendelian suppressor mutations whose phenotypes are likewise hidden during growth in the presence of millimolar GuHCl are described. Such GuHCl-remedial Mendelian suppressors were selected under conditions where [PSI(+)] appearance was limiting, and were caused by missense mutations in SUP35 or SUP45. Clearly, anti-suppression caused by growth in the presence of GuHCl is not sufficient to distinguish missense mutations in SUP35 or SUP45, from [PSI(+)]. However, the Mendelian and prion suppressors can be distinguished by subsequent growth in the absence of GuHCl, where only the nonsense suppression caused by the [PSI(+)] prion remains cured. Recent reports indicate that GuHCl blocks the inheritance of [PSI(+)] by directly inhibiting the activity of the protein remodelling factor Hsp104, which is required for the transmission of [PSI(+)] from mother to daughter cells. However, the nonsense suppressor activity caused by the GuHCl-remedial sup35 or sup45 suppressors does not require Hsp104. Thus, GuHCl must anti-suppress the sup35 and sup45 mutations via an in vivo target distinct from Hsp104.

Prions as protein-based genetic elements

Fungal prions are fascinating protein-based genetic elements. They alter cellular phenotypes through self-perpetuating changes in protein conformation and are cytoplasmically partitioned from mother cell to daughter. The four prions of Saccharomyces cerevisiae and Podospora anserina affect diverse biological processes: translational termination, nitrogen regulation, inducibility of other prions, and heterokaryon incompatibility. They share many attributes, including unusual genetic behaviors, that establish criteria to identify new prions. Indeed, other fungal traits that baffled microbiologists meet some of these criteria and might be caused by prions. Recent research has provided notable insight about how prions are induced and propagated and their many biological roles. The ability to become a prion appears to be evolutionarily conserved in two cases. [PSI(+)] provides a mechanism for genetic variation and phenotypic diversity in response to changing environments. All available evidence suggests that prions epigenetically modulate a wide variety of fundamental biological processes, and many await discovery.

Interactions among prions and prion "strains" in yeast

Prions are "infectious" proteins. When Sup35, a yeast translation termination factor, is aggregated in its [PSI(+)] prion form its function is compromised. When Rnq1 is aggregated in its [PIN(+)] prion form, it promotes the de novo appearance of [PSI(+)]. Heritable variants (strains) of [PSI(+)] with distinct phenotypes have been isolated and are analogous to mammalian prion strains with different pathologies. Here, we describe heritable variants of the [PIN(+)] prion that are distinguished by the efficiency with which they enhance the de novo appearance of [PSI(+)]. Unlike [PSI(+)] variants, where the strength of translation termination corresponds to the level of soluble Sup35, the phenotypes of these [PIN(+)] variants do not correspond to levels of soluble Rnq1. However, diploids and meiotic progeny from crosses between either different [PSI(+)], or different [PIN(+)] variants, always have the phenotype of the parental variant with the least soluble Sup35 or Rnq1, respectively. Apparently faster growing prion variants cure cells of slower growing or less stable variants of the same prion. We also find that YDJ1 overexpression eliminates some but not other [PIN(+)] variants and that prions are destabilized by meiosis. Finally, we show that, like its affect on [PSI(+)] appearance, [PIN(+)] enhances the de novo appearance of [URE3]. Surprisingly, [PSI(+)] inhibited [URE3] appearance. These results reinforce earlier reports that heterologous prions interact, but suggest that such interactions can not only positively, but also negatively, influence the de novo generation of prions.

Amino acid residue 184 of yeast Hsp104 chaperone is critical for prion-curing by guanidine, prion propagation, and thermotolerance

Inactivation of Hsp104 by guanidine is contended to be the mechanism by which guanidine cures yeast prions. We now find an Hsp104 mutation (D184N) that confers resistance to guanidine-curing of the yeast [PSI(+)] prion. In an independent screen we isolated an HSP104 allele altered in the same residue (D184Y) that dramatically impairs [PSI(+)] propagation in a temperature-dependent manner. Directed mutagenesis of HSP104 produced additional alleles that conferred varying degrees of resistance to guanidine-curing or impaired [PSI(+)] propagation. The mutations similarly affected propagation of the [URE3] prion. Basal and induced abundance of all mutant proteins was normal. Thermotolerance of cells expressing mutant proteins was variably resistant to guanidine, and the degree of thermotolerance did not correlate with [PSI(+)] stability. We thus show that guanidine cures yeast prions by inactivating Hsp104 and identify a highly conserved Hsp104 residue that is critical for yeast prion propagation. Our data suggest that Hsp104 activity can be reduced substantially without affecting [PSI(+)] stability, and that Hsp104 interacts differently with prion aggregates than with aggregates of thermally denatured protein.

The utility of prions

Infectious, self-propagating protein aggregates (prions) as well as structurally related amyloid fibrils have traditionally been associated with neurodegenerative diseases in mammals. However, recent work in fungi indicates that prions are not simply aberrations of protein folding, but are in fact widespread, conserved, and in certain cases, apparently beneficial. Analysis of prion behavior in yeast has led to insights into the mechanisms of prion appearance and propagation as well as the effect of prions on cellular physiology and perhaps evolution. The prion-forming proteins of Saccharomyces cerevisiae are members of a larger class of Gln/Asn-rich proteins that is abundantly represented in the genomes of higher eukaryotes, raising the prospect of genetically programmed prion-like behavior in other organisms.

Novel non-Mendelian determinant involved in the control of translation accuracy in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Two cytoplasmically inherited determinants related by their manifestation to the control of translation accuracy were previously described in yeast. Cells carrying one of them, [PSI(+)], display a nonsense suppressor phenotype and contain a prion form of the Sup35 protein. Another element, [PIN(+)], determines the probability of de novo generation of [PSI(+)] and results from a prion form of several proteins, which can be functionally unrelated to Sup35p. Here we describe a novel nonchromosomal determinant related to the SUP35 gene. This determinant, designated [ISP(+)], was identified as an antisuppressor of certain sup35 mutations. We observed its loss upon growth on guanidine hydrochloride and subsequent spontaneous reappearance with high frequency. The reversible curability of [ISP(+)] resembles the behavior of yeast prions. However, in contrast to known prions, [ISP(+)] does not depend on the chaperone protein Hsp104. Though manifestation of both [ISP(+)] and [PSI(+)] is related to the SUP35 gene, the maintenance of [ISP(+)] does not depend on the prionogenic N-terminal domain of Sup35p and Sup35p is not aggregated in [ISP(+)] cells, thus ruling out the possibility that [ISP(+)] is a specific form of [PSI(+)]. We hypothesize that [ISP(+)] is a novel prion involved in the control of translation accuracy in yeast.

Yeast prion protein derivative defective in aggregate shearing and production of new 'seeds'

According to the nucleated polymerization model, in vivo prion proliferation occurs via dissociation (shearing) of the huge prion polymers into smaller oligomeric 'seeds', initiating new rounds of prion replication. Here, we identify the deletion derivative of yeast prion protein Sup35 (Sup35-Delta22/69) that is specifically defective in aggregate shearing and 'seed' production. This derivative, [PSI+], previously thought to be unable to turn into a prion state, in fact retains the ability to form a prion ([PSI+](Delta22/69)) that can be maintained in selective conditions and transmitted by cytoplasmic infection (cytoduction), but which is mitotically unstable in non-selective conditions. MorePSI+](Delta22/69) retains its mitotic stability defect. The [PSI+](Delta22/69) cells contain more Sup35 protein in the insoluble fraction and form larger Sup35 aggregates compared with the conventional [PSI+] cells. Moderate excess of Hsp104 disaggregase increases transmission of the [PSI+](Delta22/69) prion, while excess Hsp70-Ssa chaperone antagonizes it, opposite to their effects on conventional [PSI+]. Our results shed light on the mechanisms determining the differences between transmissible prions and non-transmissible protein aggregates.

Yeast prion protein derivative defective in aggregate shearing and production of new 'seeds'

According to the nucleated polymerization model, in vivo prion proliferation occurs via dissociation (shearing) of the huge prion polymers into smaller oligomeric 'seeds', initiating new rounds of prion replication. Here, we identify the deletion derivative of yeast prion protein Sup35 (Sup35-Delta22/69) that is specifically defective in aggregate shearing and 'seed' production. This derivative, [PSI+], previously thought to be unable to turn into a prion state, in fact retains the ability to form a prion ([PSI+](Delta22/69)) that can be maintained in selective conditions and transmitted by cytoplasmic infection (cytoduction), but which is mitotically unstable in non-selective conditions. MorePSI+](Delta22/69) retains its mitotic stability defect. The [PSI+](Delta22/69) cells contain more Sup35 protein in the insoluble fraction and form larger Sup35 aggregates compared with the conventional [PSI+] cells. Moderate excess of Hsp104 disaggregase increases transmission of the [PSI+](Delta22/69) prion, while excess Hsp70-Ssa chaperone antagonizes it, opposite to their effects on conventional [PSI+]. Our results shed light on the mechanisms determining the differences between transmissible prions and non-transmissible protein aggregates.