Inflammatory bowel diseases: health care and costs in Sweden in 1994

The impact of inflammatory bowel disease on labor force participation: results of a population sampled case-control study

INTRODUCTION

Inflammatory bowel diseases are chronic conditions that might cause a severe impact on social life. The aim of the study was to assess employment, chronic work disability, and sick leave in patients with inflammatory bowel disease.

METHODS

A postal questionnaire was sent to 984 patients with inflammatory bowel disease and 1504 controls. Age- and gender-adjusted employment and chronic work disability ratios and rates were calculated using indirect standardization. In subjects in paid employment, proportions of those having an episode of sick leave and lost workdays were analyzed. Logistic regression was used to assess the contribution of age, gender, education, and course of disease.

RESULTS

The results of 680 (69%) patients and 715 (48%) controls could be analyzed. For the entire group of patients, employment was 6.5% lower, compared with controls (95% CI: 4.0-9.0). Chronic work disability was 17.1% higher than expected (95% CI: 15.1-19.1). In those in paid employment, 62% of patients compared with 53% of controls had experienced one or more episodes of sick leave during the past year (p = 0.002). This resulted in 19.2 versus 11.8 days of sick leave per subject per year for patients and controls respectively (p = 0.002). Relative to controls, the risk of chronic work disability was more increased in younger (p = 0.02) and higher educated (p = 0.02) patients. Course of disease contributed to chronic work disability and sick leave.

CONCLUSION

IBD has a significant impact on labor force participation that is higher in CD compared with UC and highest in younger and more highly educated patients.

Infliximab decreases resource use among patients with Crohn's disease

GOALS

Surgery accounts for one half, and hospitalizations for one third, of overall costs for patients with Crohn's disease (CD). Infliximab induces remission and heals fistulas in CD but is more costly than traditional therapies. Its impact upon resource use in CD is unknown.

STUDY

The medical records were reviewed for all CD patients managed at our institution for at least 1 full year both before and after initial infliximab infusion. The incidences of hospitalizations, hospitalized days, surgeries, endoscopies, radiologic examinations, outpatient and emergency room (ER) visits were studied (weighted according to time period).

RESULTS

There were 79 patients (59% female, mean age 38.6 years). A decrease was seen in the annual incidence of all surgeries (38%, p < 0.01), gastrointestinal (GI) surgeries (18%, p < 0.05), endoscopies (43%, p < 0.01), ER visits (66%, p < 0.05), all outpatient visits (16%, p < 0.05), outpatient GI visits (20%, p < 0.01), all radiologic examinations (12%, p < 0.01), and non-plain films (13%, p < 0.01). Fistula patients (n = 37) had decreases in hospitalizations (59%, p < 0.05); GI surgeries (59%, p < 0.01); all surgeries (66%, p < 0.01); all, GI, and surgical outpatient visits (27%, 26%, and 70%, respectively, p < 0.05 for all); ER visits (64%, p < 0.05); all radiologic examinations (40%, p < 0.05); and non-plain films (61%, p < 0.05). Patients with luminal disease(n = 42) had decreases in endoscopies (52%, p < 0.05), and ER visits (69%, p < 0.05). Patients of both genders and all ages experienced decreases in resource use.

CONCLUSION

Patients with CD decreased their use of some services, with a decreased number of hospitalizations and a decrease in the use of surgical services seen primarily in the patients infused for fistulas. This decrease in use of healthcare resources raises the potential of overall cost savings in CD patients receiving this drug.

Cost of illness of Crohn's disease

Crohn's disease is a chronic inflammatory bowel disease of unknown aetiology which affects around 35,000 people in the UK (population 56.8 million). The potential for onset in early adult life, disease chronicity and a need for hospitalisation and surgery mean that the disease can be associated with substantial healthcare costs. Cost-of-illness studies focusing on direct medical costs have identified that over half the average costs associated with the disease relate to hospital costs. Estimates of the contribution of drug costs to the total direct economic burden have varied between 4.6 and 25%. Figures for average annual direct costs per patient in the US have been put at between US dollars 6561 (1990 values) and US dollars 12,417 (1994 values), whereas European studies have given much lower cost estimates (US dollars 655, 1994 values). However, all studies have highlighted that much of the total cost of illness relates to extensive interventions required by a small proportion of severely affected individuals. Indirect costs associated with reduced productivity in Crohn's disease can be high, with long periods of absenteeism and early disability. However, most patients (90%) remain in the workforce and life expectancy is relatively normal. A variety of drugs are employed for the treatment of Crohn's disease, both in an attempt to induce clinical remission in active disease and to maintain remission once this has been achieved. Comparative data on cost effectiveness is lacking, though crude estimates based on randomised trials suggest that the frequently prescribed aminosalicylates, which have only modest efficacy, are a relatively costly drug option. The costs associated with adverse drug effects, particularly for corticosteroids, have not been formally quantified. Despite high costs, new drug therapies for more severe disease, such as anti-tumour necrosis factor (TNF-alpha) antibodies, may prove a cost-effective option if the need for hospitalisation is reduced. In a modelling exercise, a US group estimated that if a theoretical new drug was introduced which was capable of reducing non-drug costs (including hospitalisation) by a fifth despite doubling the overall drugs bill, there would still be a reduction in the overall costs of Crohn's disease by 13%. Although surgical therapy is costly, there may be prolonged post-surgical remission following resection of localised disease and early surgery may represent a cost-effective option for selected patients. Without formal cost-effectiveness analyses, or (better still) clinical trials incorporating cost data, decisions about the relative efficiency of treatment alternatives for Crohn's disease remain subjective and more research is clearly required in this area.

Quality of health care in inflammatory bowel disease: development of a reliable questionnaire (QUOTE-IBD) and first results

OBJECTIVES

As inflammatory bowel disease is a chronic disorder, usually with an early onset in life, quality of care plays an important role for patients. The aim of this study was to develop a questionnaire to measure quality of care through the eyes of patients with inflammatory bowel disease.

METHODS

Ten generic questions were already available because the questionnaire is based on an existing instrument. Patients with inflammatory bowel disease in seven countries were involved in the development of additional disease-specific items. Validation and first field testing of the total questionnaire (QUOTE-IBD) was performed in The Netherlands.

RESULTS

A total of 380 patients cooperated in the development of 13 disease-specific items, with high internal reliability (Cronbach's alpha = 0.83). Another 162 patients were involved in validating and testing of the QUOTE-IBD, which consists of 23 items in total. Pearson's correlation coefficient between QUOTE-IBD and visual analog scale scores of health care items was 0.55. Intraclass correlation coefficient of two assessments was 0.64. First testing showed that patients gave relatively poor marks to some part of health care services, such as providing information about extraintestinal complaints and the psychological as well as physical approach to complaints.

CONCLUSIONS

A short, valid, reliable questionnaire was developed to measure the opinions of patients with inflammatory bowel disease on quality of health care. The QUOTE-IBD can be used for identification of areas for improvement, with the aim of optimizing health care in inflammatory bowel disease.

A 10-year survey of inflammatory bowel diseases-drug therapy, costs and adverse reactions

BACKGROUND

Drug therapy for Crohn's disease and ulcerative colitis is based on anti-inflammatory and immunodulating drugs, nutritional support and surgical resection. Recently, new drugs have been introduced.

AIM

To report drug prescriptions, costs and adverse reactions among inflammatory bowel disease patients in Sweden between 1988 and 1997.

METHODS

Drug use was calculated from the national Diagnosis and therapy survey and drug costs from prescriptions and drug sales. Adverse drug reactions were obtained from the Medical Products Agency's National Pharmacovigilance system.

RESULTS

The annual drug exposure for Crohn's disease was 0.55 million daily doses per million population, mainly supplementation and aminosalicylic acids. Mesalazine and olsalazine had 61% within this group. For ulcerative colitis patients, drug exposure was 0.61 million daily doses per million per year and aminosalicylic acids fell from 70% to 65%. For inflammatory bowel disease patients, corticosteroids and nutritional supplementation were common. The annual average cost for inflammatory bowel disease drugs was 7.0 million US dollars. Annually, 32 adverse drug reactions were reported, mainly haematological reactions such as agranulocytosis and pancytopenia (60%), followed by skin reactions. Only two deaths were reported. Aminosalicylic acids were the most commonly reported compounds.

CONCLUSIONS

Drug use for inflammatory bowel disease in the pre-biologic agent era rested on aminosalicylic acid drugs and corticosteroids with stable levels, proportions and costs. The level of adverse drug reactions was low but haematological reactions support the monitoring of inflammatory bowel disease patients.

Influence of quality of care on quality of life in inflammatory bowel disease (IBD): literature review and studies planned

Inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) is a chronic disorder with an early onset in life. Therefore, it is reasonable to assume that IBD patients are in considerable need of health care. The quality of life of IBD patients is reported to be impaired. Whether optimizing the quality of health care for these patients may positively influence their quality of life is a question that has been raised often during recent years. This review of the literature on health care research discusses different concepts regarding the quality of care assessment in chronic disease, stresses the need to see things from the patient's perspective, and provides recommendations to optimize health care research. The two most important conclusions that can be drawn are that: (1) the relationship between quality of health care and quality of life in IBD is one that is certainly worth studying; and (2) when developing a means to assess patient data on quality of care, it is essential to involve patients from the very start.

Therapy for Crohn disease

Medical therapy for Crohn disease has advanced incrementally: Small, non-definitive controlled trials of mesalamine continue to be reported, but the results are not sufficient to change the conclusion of a large meta-analysis that shows only marginal benefit of mesalamine in Crohn disease. Low-dose, controlled ileal-release budesonide is not effective for preventing postoperative recurrence of Crohn disease. A loading dose of intravenous azathioprine does not accelerate the time to response in patients with steroid-treated Crohn disease; however, standard azathioprine may work more quickly than previously reported. Mycophenolate mofetil may be therapeutically equivalent to azathioprine for active Crohn disease. There is a trend toward benefit of oral methotrexate (15 mg/wk) for active Crohn disease, and there is no significant difference in the blood concentrations of methotrexate in patients with inflammatory bowel disease who receive methotrexate (15 or 25 mg weekly) administered subcutaneously. Results in a pilot study suggest that tacrolimus may close perianal fistulas in patients with Crohn disease. The anti-tumor necrosis factor antibody infliximab is effective in closing perianal and enterocutaneous fistulas and in maintaining remission in patients with Crohn disease. Infliximab also leads to endoscopic and histologic remission. There is a trend toward benefit of subcutaneous recombinant interleukin-11 for active Crohn disease. Two pilot studies have shown that thalidomide may be of benefit in patients with refractory Crohn disease.

Direct hospital costs for patients with inflammatory bowel disease in a Canadian tertiary care university hospital

OBJECTIVE

We set out to determine the direct costs of hospitalizations of patients with Crohn's disease and ulcerative colitis admitted to a university-affiliated tertiary care hospital and to contrast the costs of medical versus surgical inpatient care, Crohn's disease versus ulcerative colitis, and to identify dominant components of inpatient costs.

METHODS

We used a patient-specific case costing system at Saint Boniface General Hospital, Winnipeg, Manitoba, for fiscal years 1994 and 1995. We extracted all inpatients whose hospital discharge abstracts included ICD-9-CM codes 555 (Crohn's disease) and 556 (ulcerative colitis) among the top eight discharge diagnoses, and performed a chart review on all cases to ensure that the hospitalization was for inflammatory bowel disease and the diagnoses were accurate. We analyzed cases based on their disease diagnosis, primary mode of therapy associated with the hospitalization (medical vs surgical), and their major diagnosis-related group (DRG). This study evaluated direct patient care costs only and costs are expressed in Canadian dollars.

RESULTS

Of 362 hospital admissions, 325 were eligible and of these admissions 275 belonged to the digestive system DRGs. Seventy-one (37%) were admitted more than once during the 2 yr of the study, accounting for 202 (62%) of the total number of admissions. The mean cost per admission of all cases of Crohn's disease was $3,149 (95% confidence interval [CI], $2,665-$3,634) and for ulcerative colitis was $3,726 (95% CI $3,008-$4,445). Surgical therapy cases accounted for 49.8% of all admissions, 57.8% of all hospital days, and 60.5% of all costs. Patients treated surgically had more costly hospitalizations than those treated medically, particularly when analyzing only nontotal parenteral nutrition (TPN) cases. Surgical treatment admissions were significantly more costly for ulcerative colitis digestive DRG admissions than Crohn's disease. The nondigestive DRG admissions were more costly than the digestive DRGs in all categories although this was only statistically different among medically treated Crohn's disease. Patients treated medically were similarly costly whether they had Crohn's disease or ulcerative colitis. There was no significant difference in cost per admission among cases admitted multiple times, compared with those admitted only once. TPN cases accounted for 9.5% of cases but 27.1% of costs. TPN-associated hospitalizations were more costly than non-TPN-use hospitalizations but these costs were primarily driven by duration of stay rather than TPN use itself. For all cases, the top five cost categories in descending order were nursing unit bed-days, drugs and pharmacy, diagnostic lab tests, operating room, and diagnostic imaging and endoscopy.

CONCLUSIONS

Using our system we could determine direct costs for inpatients with inflammatory bowel disease and the factors that determined increased costs. Medical therapy admissions were similarly costly between Crohn's disease and ulcerative colitis; however, surgical therapy admissions were costlier among ulcerative colitis patients. Admissions for nondigestive DRGs were more costly than those for digestive DRGs. TPN use identified a sicker group of patients who remained in the hospital longer than nonusers and, not surprisingly, these were the costliest patients.

The cost of hospitalization in Crohn's disease

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to evaluate the demographics, resource use, and costs associated with hospitalization of Crohn's disease patients.

METHODS

All patients hospitalized at our institution from 7/1/96 to 6/30/97 with a primary diagnosis of "Crohn's Disease" were analyzed using a computerized database. Data are presented "per hospitalization."

RESULTS

A total of 175 hospitalizations (147 patients) were identified. Mean patient age was 36.5 yr; 61% were female; 82% Caucasian. Payer mix was most commonly contracted (57%), commercial (21%), or Medicare (13%). 57% of hospitalizations had a primary surgical procedure; the remainder were medical. Average length of stay was 8.7 days (surgical, 9.6 days; medical, 7.5 days). The average cost of hospitalization, excluding physician fees, was $12,528 (surgical, $14,409; medical, $10,020), whereas average charges were $35,378 (surgical, $46,354; medical, $20,744), including physician fees, which averaged $7,249 (surgical, $11,217; medical, $1,959). Mean reimbursements were $21,968 (surgical, $28,946; medical, $12,666) with average weighted reimbursement rates of 60.17% of hospital charges, 69.57% of physician fees. The distribution of costs across subcategories was: Surgery (39.6%), Pharmacy (18.6%), Laboratory (3.8%), Radiology (2.1%), Pathology (0.8%), Endoscopy (0.3%), and Other Hospital Costs (34.9%). Of the hospitalizations, 87% included treatment with steroids, 23% with immunomodulators, and 14% with aminosalicylates; 27% included the administration of total parenteral nutrition, which accounted for 63% of the total pharmacy costs.

CONCLUSIONS

Surgery accounts for the majority of hospitalizations, nearly 40% of their total costs, and 75% of overall charges and reimbursements. Therapy that decreases the number of surgical hospitalizations should substantially reduce inpatient Crohn's disease costs, as well as overall costs.

Current pharmacotherapy for inflammatory bowel disease

Ulcerative colitis (UC) and Crohn's disease (CD), collectively termed inflammatory bowel disease (IBD), are chronic spontaneously relapsing enteropathies of unknown aetiology. Pharmacotherapy for IBD has essentially been unchanged for over twenty years, with therapy based around 5-aminosalicylic acid (5-ASA) preparations, corticosteroids, antibiotics and immunosuppression. Much of the controversy surrounding optimal use of these drugs in IBD arises as a consequence of methodological deficiencies in many of the early trials combined with the difficulty in consistent patient selection due to the heterogeneous nature of both UC and CD. More recently, well-designed clinical trials have attempted to provide an 'evidence based' approach to managing IBD which, in time, will allow optimisation of current therapies and accurate evaluation of novel agents. Over the past two decades, improved research methodology has considerably increased our molecular understanding of the aetiopathogenesis of IBD which has ultimately lead to the development of specific mediator directed or 'designer' drug therapy for IBD. This review evaluates the literature on current IBD therapy, summarises the important recent studies which have made an impact on clinical practice, and examines the risks and benefits of the novel agents which are currently under investigation in clinical trials of IBD therapy.

Review article: economic issues in Crohn's disease--assessing the effects of new treatments on health-related quality of life

The advent of highly effective yet costly new treatments for Crohn's disease will force clinicians, patients, and society to make important choices regarding the allocation of resources. Pharmacoeconomic analyses can be useful in deciding whether new technologies are of good value in comparison to established treatment regimens. In Crohn's disease conventional cost-effectiveness analyses are of limited use because surgery, death, and disease-related complications occur relatively infrequently. Alternatively, cost-utility models relate the incremental cost of new treatments to improvements in health-related quality of life. These analyses require the collection of valid cost and utility inputs that have only recently become available. Ultimately, cost-utility models should allow decision makers to make sensible choices for patients and society. This article describes the techniques of pharmacoeconomic analysis and reviews existing data on the measurement of costs and quality-of-life outcomes in Crohn's disease.

Clinical course and costs of care for Crohn's disease: Markov model analysis of a population-based cohort

BACKGROUND & AIMS

Crohn's disease results in substantial morbidity and high use of health services. The aim of this study was to describe the lifetime clinical course and costs of Crohn's disease in a 24-year population-based inception cohort of patients with Crohn's disease in Olmsted County, Minnesota.

METHODS

Disease states were defined by medical and surgical treatment. A Markov model analysis calculated time in each disease state and present value of excess lifetime costs in comparison with an age- and sex-matched cohort.

RESULTS

For a representative patient, projected lifetime costs were $39,906 per patient using median charges and $125,404 using mean charges. There were 29.1 years (63% of total) without medications. There were 12.7 years (27%) on aminosalicylate therapy, generating $11,467 (29%) in charges, and 3.2 years (7%) on corticosteroid or immunosuppressive therapy, generating $5147 (13%) in charges. Surgery generated $17,526 (44%) in charges.

CONCLUSIONS

Most of the clinical course is spent in remission, either medical or surgical. Aminosalicylate therapy accounts for 29% of the costs of care. Surgery has the highest charges but the longest remissions. Treatment strategies that induce remission in mild disease and maintain remission with lower-cost maintenance therapy will have the largest effect on patient outcomes and costs.