Model for the three-dimensional folding of 16 S ribosomal RNA

A functional pseudoknot in 16S ribosomal RNA

Several lines of evidence indicate that the universally conserved 530 loop of 16S ribosomal RNA plays a crucial role in translation, related to the binding of tRNA to the ribosomal A site. Based upon limited phylogenetic sequence variation, Woese and Gutell (1989) have proposed that residues 524-526 in the 530 hairpin loop are base paired with residues 505-507 in an adjoining bulge loop, suggesting that this region of 16S rRNA folds into a pseudoknot structure. Here, we demonstrate that Watson-Crick interactions between these nucleotides are essential for ribosomal function. Moreover, we find that certain mild perturbations of the structure, for example, creation of G-U wobble pairs, generate resistance to streptomycin, an antibiotic known to interfere with the decoding process. Chemical probing of mutant ribosomes from streptomycin-resistant cells shows that the mutant ribosomes have a reduced affinity for streptomycin, even though streptomycin is thought to interact with a site on the 30S subunit that is distinct from the 530 region. Data from earlier in vitro assembly studies suggest that the pseudoknot structure is stabilized by ribosomal protein S12, mutations in which have long been known to confer streptomycin resistance and dependence.

Mutations in the 915 region of Escherichia coli 16S ribosomal RNA reduce the binding of streptomycin to the ribosome

The nine possible single-base substitutions were produced at positions 913 to 915 of the 16S ribosomal RNA of Escherichia coli, a region known to be protected by streptomycin [Moazed, D. and Noller, H.F. (1987) Nature, 327, 389-394]. When the mutations were introduced into the expression vector pKK3535, only two of them (913A----G and 915A----G) permitted recovery of viable transformants. Ribosomes were isolated from the transformed bacteria and were assayed for their response to streptomycin in poly(U)- and MS2 RNA-directed assays. They were resistant to the stimulation of misreading and to the inhibition of protein synthesis by streptomycin, and this correlated with a decreased binding of the drug. These results therefore demonstrate that, in line with the footprinting studies of Moazed and Noller, mutations in the 915 region alter the interaction between the ribosome and streptomycin.

A single base substitution in 16S ribosomal RNA suppresses streptomycin dependence and increases the frequency of translational errors

A C to U substitution at position 1469 of 16S ribosomal RNA (rRNA) from Escherichia coli suppresses streptomycin dependence and causes increased translational error frequencies. Strains containing the rpsL252 or StrM287 streptomycin-dependent alleles are able to grow in the absence of streptomycin when transformed with plasmids containing the U1469 mutation in 16S rRNA. Ribosomes containing wild-type proteins and U1469 mutant 16S rRNA misincorporate leucine in vitro at elevated levels, comparable to that of some typical S4 ram ribosomes. These results provide additional support for the participation of 16S rRNA in maintaining translational accuracy.

The three-dimensional folding of ribosomal RNA; localization of a series of intra-RNA cross-links in 23S RNA induced by treatment of Escherichia coli 50S ribosomal subunits with bis-(2-chloroethyl)-methylamine

Intact 50S ribosomal subunits from E.coli were cross-linked with the symmetrical bifunctional reagent bis-(2-chloroethyl)-methylamine. After deproteinization, selected regions of the 23S RNA were excised by treatment with ribonuclease H in the presence of appropriate complementary decadeoxynucleotides, and screened for the presence of intra-RNA cross-links by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis. Individual isolated cross-linked RNA fragments were analysed by our established procedures. Sixteen intra-RNA cross-links were identified, three of which corresponded to those previously published. The thirteen 'new' cross-links were localized in the 23S RNA at positions 774-78 linked to 792-94, 876-79 linked to 899-900, 979-81 or 983-84 to 2029, 1715 to 1743-46, 1911-21 to 1964, 1933 to 1966, 2032 to 2054-55, 2112 to 2169-71, 2116-17 to 2163-67, 2128-32 to 2156-59, 2392-93 to 2422-23, 2737-38 to 2763-66, and 2791 to 2890. These results are discussed in the context of three-dimensional model-building studies with the 23S RNA, with particular reference to the environment of the 'active centre' of the 50S subunit.

Localization of a segment of 16S RNA on the surface of the small ribosomal subunit by immune electron microscopy of complementary oligodeoxynucleotides

Oligonucleotides that complement Escherichia coli 16S ribosomal RNA residues 685-696 and 694-705 have been synthesized so as to incorporate antibody-recognizable markers: a 3'-terminal residue of N6-delta 2-isopentenyladenosine, a 5'-dinitrophenyl group, or both. Each oligonucleotide is able to bind RNA within the small ribosomal subunit, whether free or in 70S ribosomes. Immune electron microscopy places probes at nucleotides 685, 694 and 705 within a single area, at the tip of the subunit platform, very near the position of the 3'-end of the 16S RNA.

How does the mRNA pass through the ribosome?

A working model of the mRNA path through the ribosome is proposed. According to the model, the template goes around the small ribosomal subunit along the region where its 'head' is separated from other parts of the subunit. The 5'-end of the mRNA fragment covered by the ribosome is located near the 3'-terminus of 16S rRNA, whereas the 3'-terminal residues of the fragment are situated on the outer surface of the subunit, opposite its 'side ledge'. When associated with the 50S subunit, the 30S subunit is oriented in such a manner that the decoding center faces the L7/L12 stalk. Implications of the proposed working model of the mRNA topography for the function of the ribosome are discussed.

On the conformation of the alpha sarcin stem-loop of 28S rRNA

A synthetic RNA that is a substrate for the cytotoxin alpha sarcin has been examined by NMR. The molecule in question includes the entire sequence of the so-called alpha sarcin loop from rat 28S rRNA (U4316-C4332), and it is cleaved at the residue that corresponds to G4325, the site of alpha sarcin cleavage in 28S rRNA. The data show that the terminal stem designed into the molecule's sequence exists, as expected, and that its loop has a definite structure, which is stable to at least 40 degrees C under ionic conditions compatible with its cleavage by alpha sarcin.

RNA-protein interactions in the Escherichia coli ribosome

Over the last two decades essentially three different approaches have been used to study the topography of RNA-protein interactions in the ribosome. These are: (a) the analysis of binding sites for individual ribosomal proteins or groups of proteins on the RNA; (b) the determination of protein footprint sites on the RNA by the application of higher order structure analytical techniques; and (c) the localisation of RNA-protein cross-link sites on the RNA. This article compares and contrasts the types of data that the three different approaches provide, and gives a brief and highly simplified summary of the results that have been obtained for both the 16S and 23S ribosomal RNA from E coli.

A consonant model of the tRNA-ribosome complex during the elongation cycle of translation

Chemical and photochemical affinity techniques have been used extensively to determine the positions of the tRNA binding sites on the Escherichia coli ribosome. Recent advances in our understanding of ribosome structure and function prompted us to critically review the data that have accumulated on tRNA-ribosome cross-links. As a result, we propose a new model of the tRNA-ribosome complex that accounts for nearly all of the pertinent evidence.

Topography of the Escherichia coli ribosomal 30S subunit-initiation factor 2 complex

The specific effect of the binding of initiation factor IF2 on E coli 16S rRNA within the [IF2/30S/GTP] complex has been probed by crosslinking experiment with trans-diamminedichloro platinum (II) and by phosphate alkylation with ethylnitrosourea. Several 16S rRNA fragments crosslinked to IF2 have been identified and are mostly located in the head and the lateral protrusion of the 30S subunit. The study of the effect of IF2 binding to the 30S subunit reveals that the factor does not tightly bind to the 16S rRNA and induces both isolated reductions and enhancements of phosphate reactivity in the 16S rRNA. Several of them are located near the binding site of IF2 and weak effects are observed in distant parts of the subunit. These results are discussed in the light of current knowledge of the topographical localization of IF2 with the 30S subunit and of its relation with function.

RNA-RNA and RNA-protein interactions in 30 S ribosomal subunits. Association of 16 S rRNA fragments in the presence of ribosomal proteins

The E. coli 16 S rRNA with single-site breaks centered at position 777 or 785 was obtained by RNase H site-specific cleavage of rRNA. Spontaneous dissociation of the cleaved 16 S rRNA into fragments occurred under 'native' conditions. The reassociation of the 16 S rRNA fragments was possible only in the presence of ribosomal proteins. The combination of S4 and S16(S17) ribosomal proteins interacting mainly with the 5'-end domain of 16 S rRNA was sufficient for reassociation of the fragments. The 30 S subunits with fragmented RNA at ca. 777 region retained some poly(U)-directed protein synthetic activity.

30S ribosomal subunits with fragmented 16S RNA: a new approach for structure and function study of ribosomes

A new approach for function and structure study of ribosomes based on oligodeoxyribonucleotide-directed cleavage of rRNA with RNase H and subsequent reconstitution of ribosomal subunits from fragmented RNA has been developed. The E coli 16S rRNA was cleaved at 9 regions belonging to different RNA domains. The deletion of 2 large regions was also produced by cleaving 16S rRNA in the presence of 2 or 3 oligonucleotides complementary to different RNA sites. Fragmented and deleted RNA were shown to be efficiently assembled with total ribosomal protein into 30S-like particles. The capacity to form 70S ribosomes and translate both synthetic and natural mRNA of 30S subunits reconstituted from intact and fragmented 16S mRNA was compared. All 30S subunits assembled with fragmented 16S rRNA revealed very different activity: the fragmentation of RNA at the 781-800 and 1392-1408 regions led to the complete inactivation of ribosomes, whereas the RNA fragmentation at the regions 296-305, 913-925, 990-998, 1043-1049, 1207-1215, 1499-1506, 1530-1539 did not significantly influence the ribosome protein synthesis activity, although it was also reduced. These findings are mainly in accordance with the data on the functional activity of some 16S rRNA sites obtained by other methods. The relations between different 16S RNA functional sites are discussed.

Neighbourhood of the central fold of the tRNA molecule bound to the E. coli ribosome--affinity labeling studies with modified tRNAs carrying photoreactive probes attached to the dihydrouridine loop

The neighbourhood of the dihydrouridine loop of tRNA molecule bound to E. coli ribosome has been studied by affinity labeling, using modified tRNAs carrying photoreactive azidonitrophenyl probes attached to the 3-(3-amino-3-carboxypropyl)-uridine located at position 20:1 of Lupin methionine elongator tRNA. The maximum distance between the pyrimidine ring and the azido group estimated for the two probes employed in this study is 10-11 A and 18-19 A, respectively. Cross-linking of the uncharged, modified tRNAs has been studied with poly(A, U, G) as a message, under conditions directing uncharged tRNAs preferentially to the ribosomal P-site. Modified tRNAs bind covalently to both ribosomal subunits with high yields upon irradiation of the respective non-covalent complexes. Proteins S7, L33 and L1 have been consistently found cross-linked to tRNAs modified with both probes, and S5 and L5 to tRNA modified with the longer probe. Surprisingly, an S5-tRNA cross-linking product is reproducibly found in a protein fraction prepared from the purified 50S subunit. Cross-linking to rRNAs is significant only for the longer probe and is stimulated 2-4 fold in the presence of poly(A,U,G). The cross-linking sites are located between nucleotides 1302 and 1398 in 16S rRNA and between nucleotides 2281 and 2358 in 23S rRNA.

A conformational switch involving the 915 region of Escherichia coli 16 S ribosomal RNA

A novel alternative conformation, which involves an interaction between the 5' terminal and 915 regions (E. coli numbering), is proposed after a screening of compiled sequences of small subunit ribosomal RNAs. This conformation contains a pseudoknot helix between residues 12-16 and 911-915, and its formation requires the partial melting of the 5' terminal helix and the disruption of the 17-19/916-918 pseudoknot helix of the classical 16 S rRNA secondary structure. The alternate pseudoknot helix is proximal to the binding site of streptomycin and various mutations in rRNA which confer resistance to streptomycin have been located in each strand of the proposed helix. It is suggested that the presence of streptomycin favours the shift towards the alternate conformation, thereby stabilizing drug binding. Mutations which destabilize the novel pseudoknot helix would restrict the response to streptomycin.

Purification of E. coli 30S ribosomal proteins by high-performance liquid chromatography under non-denaturing conditions

High-performance ion-exchange chromatography was applied to the separation of proteins from the 30S ribosomal subunit under non-denaturing conditions. It was shown that a single chromatographic step only allows the purification of nine proteins. To increase the number of separated proteins, a prefractionation step was added that depends on the physical characteristics of the proteins to be purified. Sixteen out of 21 proteins could be purified by using prefractionation (gel permeation and lithium chloride salt washing). This method is well suited to preparing fresh samples on demand for optical studies owing to the simplicity of the buffers used and the amounts of proteins recovered in the eluted peaks (0.05-0.1 mg/ml).

Sites of contact of mRNA with 16S rRNA and 23S rRNA in the Escherichia coli ribosome

The locations of close encounter between ribosomal RNA (rRNA) and messenger RNA (mRNA) were determined by photochemical cross-linking experiments that employ an artificial mRNA, 51 nucleotides long, containing 14 U residues that were randomly substituted by 1-4 4-thiouridine (s4U) residues. The mRNA was bound to 70S ribosomes or 30S subunits and then was irradiated at 366 nm to activate cross-linking between the s4U residues and rRNA. Cross-linking occurred to both 16S rRNA and 23S RNA. The rRNA was then analyzed by a series of reverse transcriptase experiments to determine the locations of cross-linking. Twelve sites in the 16S rRNA and two sites in the 23S rRNA have been detected. In the 16S rRNA, two of the sites (U1381, C1395) are in the middle part of the secondary structure close to position C1400, and the remaining sites (G413, U421, G424; A532; G693; U723; A845; G1131/C1132; G1300; G1338) are distributed between six regions that are peripheral in the secondary structure. In the 23S rRNA, one site (U1065) is located in the GTPase center close to A1067, the site of thiostrepton-resistance methylation in domain II, and the other site (U887) is located a short distance away also in domain II. The distribution of these rRNA sites in the ribosome specifies an mRNA track that is consistent with other information. In addition, some of the contact points represent new constraints for the three-dimensional folding of the rRNA.

Explicit distance geometry: identification of all the degrees of freedom in a large RNA molecule

An alternative approach to distance geometry ("explicit" distance geometry) is being developed for problems, such as the modeling of RNA folding in the ribosome, where relatively few distances are known. The approach explicitly identifies minimal sets of additional distances that can be added to a distance matrix in order to calculate structures that are consistent with all the known information without distorting the original input data. These additional distances are bounded to the extent possible by the known distances. These explicitly added distances can be treated as degrees of freedom and used to explore the full range of alternative foldings consistent with the original input in an organized way. The present paper establishes that it is practical to explicitly determine such degrees of freedom for even very large RNAs. To demonstrate the feasibility of the approach tRNA was represented as a simple undirected graph containing all relevant information represented in the usual cloverleaf secondary structure and nine base-base tertiary interactions. Using a three atom representation for each residue a total of 206 degrees of freedom are explicitly identified. To accomplish this a graph theoretic approach was used in which a minimal covering cycle basis was determined.

Structural analysis of the peptidyl transferase region in ribosomal RNA of the eukaryote Xenopus laevis

Accessible single-strand bases in Xenopus laevis 28 S ribosomal RNA (rRNA) Domain V, the peptidyl transferase region, were determined by chemical modification with dimethylsulfate, 1-cyclohexyl-3-(2-morpholinoethyl-carbodiimide metho-p-toluene sulfonate and kethoxal, followed by primer extension. The relative accessibilities of three rRNA substrates were compared: deproteinized 28 S rRNA under non-denaturing conditions (free 28 S rRNA), 60 S subunits and 80 S ribosomes. Overall, our experimental results support the theoretical secondary structure model of Domain V derived by comparative sequence analysis and compensatory base-pair changes, and support some theoretical tertiary interactions previously suggested by covariation. The 60 S subunits and 80 S ribosomes generally show increasing resistance to chemical modification. Bases which are sensitive in free 28 S rRNA but protected in 60 S subunits may be sites for ribosomal protein binding or induced structural rearrangements. Another class of nucleotides is distinguished by its sensitivity in 60 S subunits but protection in 80 S ribosomes; these nucleotides may be involved in subunit-subunit interactions or located at the interface of the ribosome. We found a third class of bases, which is protected in free 28 S rRNA but sensitive in 60 S subunits and/or 80 S ribosomes, suggesting that structural changes occur in Domain V as a result of subunit assembly and ribosome formation. One such region is uniquely hypersensitive in eukaryotic ribosomes but is absent in Escherichia coli ribosomes. Sites that we determined to be accessible on empty 80 S ribosomes could serve as recognition sites for translation components.

Structural elements in RNA

This chapter describes the RNA structural characteristics that have emerged so far. Folded RNA molecules are stabilized by a variety of interactions, the most prevalent of which are stacking and hydrogen bonding between bases. Many interactions among backbone atoms also occur in the structure of tRNA, although they are often ignored when considering RNA structure because they are not as well-characterized as interactions among bases. Backbone interactions include hydrogen bonding and the stacking of sugar or phosphate groups with bases or with other sugar and phosphate groups. The interactions found in a three-dimensional RNA structure can be divided into two categories: secondary interactions and tertiary interactions. This division is useful for several reasons. Secondary structures are routinely determined by a combination of techniques discussed in chapter, whereas tertiary interactions are more difficult to determine. Computer algorithms that generate RNA structures can search completely through possible secondary structures, but the inclusion of tertiary interactions makes a complete search of possible structures impractical for RNA molecules even as small as tRNA. The division of RNA structure into building blocks consisting of secondary or tertiary interactions makes it easier to describe RNA structures. In those cases in which RNA studies are incomplete, the studies of DNA are described with the rationalization that RNA structures may be analogous to DNA structures, or that the techniques used to study DNA could be applied to the analogous RNA structures. The chapter focuses on the aspects of RNA structure that affect the three-dimensional shape of RNA and that affect its ability to interact with other molecules.

Localization of a series of RNA-protein cross-link sites in the 23S and 5S ribosomal RNA from Escherichia coli, induced by treatment of 50S subunits with three different bifunctional reagents

50S ribosomal subunits were reacted with bis-(2-chloroethyl)methylamine, 2-iminothiolane or methyl p-azidophenyl acetimidate, and RNA-protein cross-link sites on the RNA were localised using our published procedures. The degree of precision with which these sites could be determined was variable, depending on the particular protein or RNA region concerned. The following positions in the 23S RNA were identified as encompassing the individual cross-link sites (numbered from the 5'-end, with asterisks denoting sites previously reported): L1, 1864-67, 1876-78, 2119-33, 2163-72*, L2, 1819-20*; L3, 2832-34; L4, 320-25*; 613-17*; L5, 2307; L6, 2473-81*; L9, 1484-91; L11, 1060-62; L13, 547-50; L14, 1993-2002; L17, 1260-95; L18, 2307-20; L19, 1741-58; L21, 544-48*; 1198-1248; L23, 63-65, 137-41*; L24, 99-107*; L27, 2272-83, 2320-23*; 2332-37*; L28, 195-242, 368-424; L29, 101-02*; L30, 931-38; L32, 2878-90; L33, 2422-24. Cross-links to 5S RNA were observed with L5 (positions 34-41), and L18 (precise site not localised).

Structural analysis of the 5' domain of the HeLa 18S ribosomal RNA by chemical and enzymatic probing

The secondary structure of HeLa 18S rRNA was investigated by a combination of chemical and enzymatic probing techniques. Using four chemical reagents (DMS*, kethoxal, DEPC and CMCT) which react specifically with unpaired bases and two nucleases (RNase T1 and cobra venom nuclease) which cleave the ribopolynucleotides at unpaired guanines and helical segments, we have analyzed the secondary structure of the 5' domain of 18S rRNA isolated from HeLa 40S ribosomal subunits. The sites at which chemical modifications and nuclease cleavages occurred were identified by primer extension using synthetic deoxyoligonucleotides and reverse transcriptase. These studies led to the deduction of an intra-RNA pairing pattern from the available secondary structure models based on comparative sequence analysis. Apart from the general canonical pairing we have identified noncanonical U-U, G-A, A-G, A-C, C-A and G-G pairing in HeLa 18S rRNA. The differential reactivity of bases to chemical reagents has enabled us to predict the possible configuration of these bases in some of the noncanonical pairing. The absence of chemical reactivities and cobra venom nuclease sensitivity in the terminal loops of helices 6 and 12 indicate a tertiary interaction unique to HeLa 18S rRNA. We have confirmed the existence of the complex tertiary folding recently proposed (Gutell and Woese 1990 Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 87, 663-667) for the universally conserved helix 19 in HeLa 18S rRNA. The complementarity of chemical modifications and enzymatic cleavages provided experimental evidence for the proposal of a model structure for the 655 nucleotides of the 5' domain of HeLa 18S rRNA.

Codon recognition in polypeptide chain termination: site directed crosslinking of termination codon to Escherichia coli release factor 2

An RNA synthesized in vitro was positioned on the Escherichia coli ribosome at the P site with tRNAala, and with a termination codon, UAA, as the next codon in the A site. Such a complex bound stoichiometric amounts of release factor 2 (RF-2); a corresponding RNA with UAC in place of UAA was not a template for the factor. An RNA containing 4-thio-UAA in place of the UAA supported binding of RF-2, and this has allowed site-directed crosslinking from the first position of the termination codon to answer two long standing questions about the termination of protein biosynthesis, the position of the termination codon and its proximity to the release factor during codon recognition. An RF-2.mRNA crosslinked product was detected, indicating the release factor and the termination codon are in close physical contact during the codon recognition event of termination. The 4-thio-U crosslinked also to the ribosome but only to the 30S subunit, and the proteins and the rRNA site concerned were identified. RF-2 decreased significantly the crosslinking to the ribosomal components, but no new crosslink sites were found. If the stop codon was deliberately displaced from the decoding site by one codon's length then a different pattern of crosslinking in particular to the rRNA resulted. These observations are consistent with a model of codon recognition by RF-2 at the decoding site, without a major shift in position of the codon.

Cloning and analysis of the Bacillus subtilis rpsD gene, encoding ribosomal protein S4

The rpsD gene, encoding ribosomal protein S4, was isolated from Bacillus subtilis by hybridization with oligonucleotide probes derived from the S4 amino-terminal protein sequence. Sequence analysis of the cloned DNA indicated that rpsD is likely to be monocistronic, in contrast to Escherichia coli rpsD, which is located in the alpha operon and is the translational regulator for alpha operon ribosomal protein gene expression in E. coli. The cloned gene was shown to map at position 263 degrees on the B. subtilis chromosome, at the position to which mutations conferring alterations in the electrophoretic mobility of protein S4 were localized. A promoter was identified upstream of the rpsD coding sequence; initiation of transcription at this promoter would result in a transcript containing a leader region 180 bases in length. Immediately downstream of the rpsD coding region were two sequences resembling transcriptional terminators. An open reading frame homologous to tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase (tyrS) genes was identified downstream of rpsD but in the opposite orientation. The leader region of rpsD mRNA is predicted to have extensive secondary structure, resembling a region of B. subtilis 16S rRNA where S4 is likely to bind; similar mRNA features have been found to be important in ribosomal gene regulation in E. coli. These results provide the first steps toward analysis of the regulation of rpsD gene expression in B. subtilis.

Bacillus subtilis mutants with alterations in ribosomal protein S4

Two mutants with different alterations in the electrophoretic mobility of ribosomal protein S4 were isolated as spore-plus revertants of a streptomycin-resistant, spore-minus strain of Bacillus subtilis. The mutations causing the S4 alterations, designated rpsD1 and rpsD2, were located between the argGH and aroG genes, at 263 degrees on the B. subtilis chromosome, distant from the major ribosomal protein gene cluster at 12 degrees. The mutant rpsD alleles were isolated by hybridization using a wild-type rpsD probe, and their DNA sequences were determined. The two mutants contained alterations at the same position within the S4-coding sequence, in a region containing a 12-bp tandem duplication; the rpsD1 allele corresponded to an additional copy of this repeated segment, resulting in the insertion of four amino acids, whereas the rpsD2 allele corresponded to deletion of one copy of this segment, resulting in the loss of four amino acids. The effects of these mutations, alone and in combination with streptomycin resistance mutations, on growth, sporulation, and streptomycin resistance were analyzed.

Nuclease S1 mapping of 16S ribosomal RNA in ribosomes

Escherichia coli 16S rRNA and 16S-like rRNAs from other species have several universally conserved sequences which are believed to be single-stranded in ribosomes. The quantitative disposition of these sequences within ribosomes is not known. Here we describe experiments designed to explore the availability of universal 16S rRNA sequences for hybridization with DNA probes in 30S particles and 70S ribosomes. Unlike previous investigations, quantitative data on the accessibility of DNA probes to the conserved portions of 16S rRNA within ribosomes was acquired. Uniquely, the experimental design also permitted investigation of cooperative interactions involving portions of conserved 16S rRNA. The basic strategy employed ribosomes, 30S subunits, and 16S rRNAs, which were quantitatively analyzed for hybridization efficiency with synthetic DNA in combination with nuclease S1. In deproteinated E. coli 16S rRNA and 30S subunits, the regions 520-530, 1396-1404, 1493-1504, and 1533-1542 are all single-stranded and unrestricted for hybridization to short synthetic DNAs. However, the quantitative disposition of the sequences in 70S ribosomes varies with each position. In 30S subunits there appear to be no cooperative interactions between the 16S rRNA universal sequences investigated.

A deletion mutation at the 5' end of Escherichia coli 16S ribosomal RNA

A deletion of five nucleotides was introduced at the 5' end of the Escherichia coli 16S rRNA gene cloned in an appropriate vector under control of a T7 promoter. The 16S rRNA generated by in vitro transcription could be assembled into 30S subunits. The deletion did not affect the efficiency of translation of natural messengers and the correct selection of the reading frame. However, it reduced the binding of the messengers, which suggests that the 5' end of 16S rRNA is located on the pathway followed by the messengers on the 30S subunits. The deletion also restricted the stimulation of misreading by streptomycin in a poly(U)-directed system. This is in accord with the proximity of the 5' end of 16S rRNA to proteins S4, S5 and S12, which are known to be involved in the control of translational accuracy.

The conformation of the initiator tRNA and of the 16S rRNA from Escherichia coli during the formation of the 30S initiation complex

The conformation of the E. coli initiator tRNA and of the 16S rRNA at different steps leading to the 30S.IF2.fMet-ARN(fMet).AUG.GTP complex has been investigated using several structure-specific probes. As compared to elongator tRNA, the initiator tRNA exhibits specific structural features in the anticodon arm, the T and D loops and the acceptor arm. Initiation factor 2 (IF2) interacts with the T-loop and the minor groove of the T stem of the RNA, and induces an increased flexibility in the anticodon arm. In the 30S initiation complex, additional protection is observed in the acceptor stem and in the anticodon arm of the tRNA. Within the 30S subunit, IF2 does not significantly shield defined portions of 16S rRNA, but induces both reduction and enhancement of reactivity scattered in the entire molecule. Most are constrained in a region corresponding to the cleft, the lateral protrusion and the part of the head facing the protrusion. All the reactivity changes induced by the binding of IF2 are still observed in the presence of the initiator tRNA and AUG message. The additional changes induced by the tRNA are mostly centered around the cleft-head-lateral protrusion region, near positions affected by IF2 binding.

Probing tRNA binding sites on the Escherichia coli 30 S ribosomal subunit with photoreactive analogs of the anticodon arm

Two analogs of the anticodon arm of yeast tRNAPhe (residues 28-43), in which G43 was replaced by the photoreactive nucleosides 2-azidoadenosine and 8-azidoadenosine, have been used to create 'zero-length' cross-links to ribosomal components at the peptidyl-tRNA binding site (P site) of 30 S subunits from the Escherichia coli ribosome. To prepare the analogs, 2-azidoadenosine and 8-azidoadenosine bisphosphates were first ligated to the 3' end of the anticodon-containing dodecanucleotide ACmUGmAAYA psi m5CUG from yeast tRNAPhe. The trinucleotide CAG was then joined to the 5' end of the resulting tridecanucleotide in a subsequent ligation. Both analogs bound to poly(U)-programmed 30 S subunits with affinities similar to that of the unmodified anticodon arm from yeast tRNAPhe. Irradiation of noncovalent complexes containing the photolabile analogs, poly(U) and 30 S ribosomal subunits with 300 nm light led to the covalent attachment of the anticodon arms to proteins S13 and S19. Further analysis revealed that S13 accounted for about 80%, and S19 for about 20%, of the cross-linked material. Labeling of these two proteins with 'zero-length' cross-linking probes provides useful information about the location and orientation of P site-bound tRNA on the ribosome and permits a test of recently proposed models of the three-dimensional structure of the 30 S subunit.

The three-dimensional structure and function of Escherichia coli ribosomal RNA, as studied by cross-linking techniques

A large number of intra-RNA and RNA-protein cross-link sites have been localized within the 23S RNA from E. coli 50 S ribosomal subunits. These sites, together with other data, are sufficient to constrain the secondary structure of the 23 S molecule into a compact three-dimensional shape. Some of the features of this structure are discussed, in particular, those relating to the orientation of tRNA on the 50 S subunit as studied by site-directed cross-linking techniques. A corresponding model for the 16S RNA within the 30 S subunit has already been described, and here a site-directed cross-linking approach is being used to determine the path followed through the subunit by messenger RNA.

Influence of the second and third codon on the expression of recombinant hirudin in E. coli

The effect of all possible codons corresponding to the second and third amino acid (isoleucine and threonine) on the expression level of hirudin in E. coli has been analysed. These levels could not be correlated with changes in primary and secondary mRNA structure. A decrease in the rate of synthesis and of product accumulation follows the introduction for ile of the ATA codon which is of very low usage, and for thr of the ACC codon, which results in homology of the mRNA with the 3'-end of 16S rRNA. The results are discussed according to current concepts of protein expression in E. coli.

Selective isolation and detailed analysis of intra-RNA cross-links induced in the large ribosomal subunit of E. coli: a model for the tertiary structure of the tRNA binding domain in 23S RNA

Intramolecular RNA cross-links were induced within the large ribosomal subunit of E. coli by mild ultraviolet irradiation. Regions of the 23S RNA previously implicated in interactions with ribosomal-bound tRNA were then specifically excised by addressed cleavage using ribonuclease H, in conjunction with synthetic complementary decadeoxyribonucleotides. Individual cross-linked fragments within these regions released by such 'directed digests' were isolated by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis and the sites involved in the cross-links determined using classical oligonucleotide analysis techniques. Using this approach, seven 'new' cross-links could be precisely localised, between positions 1782 and 2608-2609, 1940 and 2554, 1941-1942 and 1964-1965, 1955 and 2552-2553, 2145-2146 and 2202, 2518-2519 and 2544-2545, and between positions 2790-2791 and 2892-2895 in the 23S RNA sequence. These data, in conjunction with data from RNA-protein cross-linking studies carried out in our laboratory, were used to define a model for the tertiary organisation of the tRNA binding domain of 23S RNA 'in situ', in which the specific nucleotides associated with tRNA binding in the 'A' and 'P' sites are clustered at the base of the 'central protuberance' of the 50S subunit.

Alternative base pairing between 5'- and 3'-terminal sequences of small subunit RNA may provide the basis of a conformational switch of the small ribosomal subunit

The compiled sequences of small subunit ribosomal RNAs have been screened for base complementary between 5'- and 3'-terminal regions. Highly conserved complementary sequences are found which allow formation of a helix between the two ends of 5 or 6 base pairs. This helix is composed of sequences from the loop region of the first 5'-terminal stem and from sequences immediately distal to the last stem (the Me2A-stem) of the 3' terminus and therefore allows a coaxial stacking with either of these two flanking stems. Formation of the 5'/3'-helical arrangement is, however, only possible at the cost of dissolving the 'pseudo-knot' helix between the 5'-terminal region and the internal region of small subunit RNA. It is postulated that the mutually exclusive conformational states are in dynamic equilibrium and that they correlate with distinct functional states of the small ribosomal subunit. The 'pseudo-knot' containing conformation with the 3'-terminal sequences more exposed is likely to represent the initiating state, whereas the 5'/3' terminal paired 'closed' conformation may represent the elongating state in which interaction with fortuitous ribosomal binding sequences of mRNAs is avoided.

The initiation of translation in E. coli: apparent base pairing between the 16srRNA and downstream sequences of the mRNA

Bacteriophage T7's gene 0.3, coding for an antirestriction protein, possesses one of the strongest translation initiation regions (TIR) in E. coli. It was isolated on DNA fragments of differing length and cloned upstream of the mouse dihydrofolate reductase gene in an expression vector to control the translation of this gene's sequence. The TIR's efficiency was highly dependent on nucleotides +15 to +26 downstream of the gene's AUG. This sequence is complementary to nucleotides 1471-1482 of the 16srRNA. Similar sequences complementary to this rRNA region are present in other efficient TIRs of the E. coli genome and those of its bacteriophages. There seems to be a correlation between this sequence homology and the efficiency of the initiation signals. We propose that this region specifies a stimulatory interaction between the mRNA and 16srRNA besides the Shine-Dalgarno interaction during the translation initiation step.

The anti-Shine-Dalgarno region in Escherichia coli 16S ribosomal RNA is not essential for the correct selection of translational starts

Plasmid pPM114, which contains the Escherichia coli 16S rRNA gene under control of a T7 promoter, was linearized upstream of the 3' end of the gene and used in an in vitro transcription assay to yield a 16S rRNA lacking about 30 nucleotides at its 3' end. This truncated 16S rRNA was assembled into 30S subunits which contain the full complement of 30S proteins, including S21, but were impaired in their capacity to associate to the 50S subunits. This impairment was paralleled by a decrease in their protein synthesis activity under the direction of natural or artificial messengers. However, although the anti-Shine-Dalgarno sequence was missing, the initiation step was not specifically affected, and the mutated ribosomes could initiate translation at the correct start sites. This supports previous suggestions that the translational efficiency and the selection of translational starts are not solely controlled by the Shine-Dalgarno interaction. A novel interpretation of the role of protein S21 is also proposed which is independent of the activation by this protein of the base-pairing potential of the anti-Shine-Dalgarno sequence of 16S rRNA.

Pseudoknots: a new motif in the RNA game

In the last few years a novel RNA folding principle called pseudoknotting has emerged. Originally discovered in noncoding regions of plant viral RNAs, pseudoknots now appear to be a widespread structural motif in a number of functionally different RNAs. These structural elements are part of tRNA-like structures and are involved in folding catalytic sites of ribozymes. They increase the efficiency of ribosomal frameshifting or can serve as specific binding sites for regulatory proteins.

Effects of mutagenesis of a conserved base-paired site near the decoding region of Escherichia coli 16 S ribosomal RNA

Eleven of 15 possible single and double mutations were constructed in a cloned copy of Escherichia coli 16 S rDNA at a base-paired site, 1409-1491. Expression of any of these mutations was detrimental to the growth of E. coli. Mutations that substituted unpaired purine bases were lethal in the system described. Otherwise, the degree of detrimental effect on growth-rate was not directly correlated with specific rRNA primary or secondary structures. Using reverse transcription of rRNA isolated from subunits or 70 S ribosomes, we were able to determine the amount of mutant rRNA used in translation. From these experiments, we found that the lethal mutations appeared to be selectively excluded from the pool of 70 S ribosomes following expression from a repressible plasmid. In contrast, a non-lethal mutation was present in subunits, ribosomes and polysomes in approximately equal amounts. Mutations that disrupted base-pairing were found to confer varying levels of resistance to nine aminoglycosides, including four neomycins, two kanamycins, gentamicin, apramycin and hygromycin. A high frequency of reversion from resistant and slow-growth phenotypes due to a host mutation was observed.

Prediction of the three-dimensional structure of Escherichia coli 30S ribosomal subunit: a molecular mechanics approach

We introduce a computer-assisted procedure for folding large RNA chains into three-dimensional conformations consistent with their secondary structure and other known experimental constraints. The RNA chain is modeled using pseudoatoms at different levels of detail--from a single pseudoatom per helix to a single pseudoatom for each nucleotide. A stepwise procedure is used, starting with a simple representation of the macromolecule that is refined and then extrapolated into higher resolution for further refinement. The procedure is capable of folding different random-walk chains by using energy minimization, allowing generation of a range of conformations consistent with given experimental data. We use this procedure to generate several possible conformations of the 16S RNA in the 30S ribosomal subunit of Escherichia coli by using secondary structure and the neutron-scattering map of the 21 proteins in the small subunit. The RNA chain is modeled using a single pseudoatom per helix. RNA-RNA and RNA-protein crosslinks, reported in current literature, are included in our model. Footprinting data for different ribosomal proteins in the 16S RNA are also used. Several conformations of the 16S RNA are generated and compared to predict gross structural features of the 30S subunit as well as to identify regions of the 16S RNA that cannot be well-defined with current experimental data.

DNA-hybridization electron microscopy tertiary structure of 16 S rRNA

Seven regions of 16 S rRNA have been located on the surface of the 30 S ribosomal subunit by DNA-hybridization electron microscopy. This information has been incorporated into a model for the tertiary structure of 16 S rRNA, accounting for approximately 40% of the total 16 S rRNA. A structure labeled the platform ring is proposed for a region of rRNA within the central domain. This structure rings the edges of the platform and includes regions 655-751 and 769-810. Another region, the recognition complex, consists of nucleotides 500 to 545, and occupies a region on the exterior surface of the subunit near the elongation factor Tu binding site. Ribosomal proteins that have been mapped by immunoelectron microscopy are superimposed onto the model in order to examine possible regions of interaction. Good correlation between the model locations of ribosomal proteins, and regions of rRNA protected by ribosomal proteins provide independent support for this model.

Localization of an oligodeoxynucleotide complementing 16S ribosomal RNA residues 520-531 on the small subunit of Escherichia coli ribosomes: electron microscopy of ribosome-cDNA-antibody complexes

The oligodeoxynucleotide dACCGCGGCTGCT, complementary to Escherichia coli small ribosomal subunit RNA residues 520-531, has been used to probe subunit conformation and to localize the sequence in the subunit. Conditions for binding of the cDNA to 30S subunits were optimized and specificity of the interaction was demonstrated by RNase H cleavage. Three kinds of terminal modification of this cDNA were used to allow its localization by immune electron microscopy. A solid phase support with 5'-dimethoxytrity-N6-delta 2-isopentenyl-adenosine linked to controlled pore glass was synthesized, and used to prepare oligomer with an added 3'-terminal residue of isopentenyl adenosine. cDNA with a 5' primary amine substituent was modified with 1-fluoro-2,4-dinitrobenzene to prepare 5'-dinitrophenyl oligonucleotide, and both modifications together gave doubly-derivatized probes. Immune electron microscopy with antibodies to dinitrophenol, isopentenyl adenosine, or both, was used to place the cDNA on 30S subunits. In each case the probe was placed at a single site at the junction of the head and body of the subunit, near the decoding site and the area in which elongation factor Tu is bound. It is proposed that this segment of ribosomal RNA functions in mRNA binding and orientation.

Dominant lethal mutations in a conserved loop in 16S rRNA

The 530 stem-loop region in 16S rRNA is among the most phylogenetically conserved structural elements in all rRNAs, yet its role in protein synthesis remains mysterious. G-530 is protected from kethoxal attack when tRNA, or its 15-nucleotide anticodon stem-loop fragment, is bound to the ribosomal A site. Based on presently available evidence, however, this region is believed to be too remote from the decoding site for this protection to be the result of direct contact. In this study, we use a conditional rRNA expression system to demonstrate that plasmid-encoded 16S rRNA genes carrying A, C, and T point mutations at position G-530 confer a dominant lethal phenotype when expressed in Escherichia coli. Analysis of the distribution of plasmid-encoded 16S rRNA in ribosomal particles, following induction of the A-530 mutation, shows that mutant rRNA is present both in 30S subunits and in 70S ribosomes. Little mutant rRNA is found in polyribosomes, however, indicating that the mutant ribosomes are severely impaired at the stage of polysome formation and/or stability. Detailed chemical probing of mutant ribosomal particles reveals no evidence of structural perturbation within the 16S rRNA. Taken together, these results argue for the direct participation of G-530 in ribosomal function and, furthermore, suggest that the dominant lethal phenotype caused by these mutations is due primarily to the mutant ribosomes blocking a crucial step in protein synthesis after translational initiation.

Binding of tRNA to the ribosomal A and P sites protects two distinct sets of nucleotides in 16 S rRNA

Transfer RNA protects a characteristic set of bases in 16 S rRNA from chemical probes when it binds to ribosomes. We used several criteria, based on construction of well-characterized in vitro ribosome-tRNA complexes, to assign these proteins to A or P-site binding. All of these approaches lead to similar conclusions. In the A site, tRNA caused protection of G529, G530, A1492 and A1493 (strongly), and A1408 and G1494 (weakly). In the P site, the protected bases are G693, A794, C795, G926 and G1401 (strong), and A532, G966, G1338 and G1339 (weak). In contrast to what is observed for 23 S rRNA, blocking the release of EF-Tu.GDP from the ribosome by kirromycin has no detectable effect on the protection of bases in 16 S rRNA.

Thermodynamics of protein-RNA recognition in a highly conserved region of the large-subunit ribosomal RNA

Ribosomal protein L11 from Escherichia coli specifically binds to a highly conserved region of 23S ribosomal RNA. The thermodynamics of forming a complex between this protein and several different rRNA fragments have been investigated, by use of a nitrocellulose filter binding assay. A 57-nucleotide region of the RNA (C1052-U1108) contains all the protein recognition features, and an RNA fragment containing this region binds L11 10(3)-10(4)-fold more tightly than tRNA. Binding constants are on the order of 10 microM-1 and are only weakly dependent on K+ concentration (delta log K/delta log [K+] = -1.4) or temperature. Binding requires multivalent cations; Mg2+ is taken up into the complex with an affinity of approximately 3 mM-1. Other multivalent cations tested, Ca2+ and Co(NH3)63+, promote binding nearly as well. The pH dependence of binding is a bell-shaped curve with a maximum near neutral pH, but the entire curve is shifted to higher pH for the smaller of two RNA fragments tested. This result suggests that the smaller fragment favors a conformation stabilizing protonated forms of the RNA recognition site and is potentially relevant to a hypothesis that this rRNA region undergoes an ordered series of conformational changes during the ribosome cycle.

Site-directed cross-linking of mRNA analogues to the Escherichia coli ribosome; identification of 30S ribosomal components that can be cross-linked to the mRNA at various points 5' with respect to the decoding site

Three different mRNA analogues (28 to 34 nucleotides long) were prepared by T7 transcription from synthetic DNA templates. Each message contained the sequence ACC-GCG (coding for threonine and alanine, respectively), together with a single thio-U residue located at a variable position on the 5'-side of these coding triplets. A photo-reactive group was introduced by substitution of the thio-U with 4-azidophenacyl bromide. The messages were bound to E. coli 70S ribosomes in the presence of the appropriate tRNA-Thr or tRNA-Ala, and the azidophenyl group was photoactivated. Cross-linking was found to occur exclusively within the 30S subunit, with the 32P-label in the cross-linked mRNA being divided roughly equally between 30S ribosomal proteins and 16S RNA. Immunological analysis of the cross-linked proteins showed that, in the presence of either tRNA species, protein S7 was the primary target, whereas in the absence of tRNA only small amounts of protein S21 were cross-linked. The cross-link site to 16S RNA lay in all cases very close to its extreme 3'-terminus. These data indicate that the outgoing message leaves the cleft of the 30S subunit in a "northerly" direction.

Distances as degrees of freedom

Tertiary contact distance information of varying resolution for large biological molecules abounds in the literature. The results provided herein develop a framework by which information of this type can be used to reduce the allowable configuration space of a macromolecule. The approach combines graph theory and distance geometry. Large molecules are represented as simple, undirected graphs, with atoms, or groups, as vertices, and distances between them as edges. It is shown that determination of the exact structure of a molecule in three dimensions only requires the specification of all the distances in a single tetrahedron, and four distances to every other atom. This is 4N-10 distances which is a subset of the total N(N-1)/2 unique distances in a molecule consisting of N atoms. This requirement for only 4N-10 distances has serious implications for distance geometry implementations in which all N(N-1)/2 distances are specified by bounded random numbers. Such distance matrices represent overspecified systems which when solved lead to non-obvious distribution of any error caused by inherent contradictions in the input data. It is also shown that numerous valid subsets of 4N-10 distances can be constructed. It is thus possible to tailor a subset of distances using all known distances as degrees of freedom, and thereby reduce the configuration space of the molecule. Simple algebraic relationships are derived that relate sets of distances, and complicated rotations are avoided. These relationships are used to construct minimum, complete sets of distances necessary to specify the exact structure of the entire molecule in three dimensions from incomplete distance information, and to identify sets of inconsistent distances. The method is illustrated for the flexible structural types present in large ribosomal RNAs: 1.) A five-membered ring; 2.) a chemically bonded chain with its ends in contact (i.e., a hairpin loop); 3.) the spatial orientation of two separate molecules, and; 4.) an RNA helix that can have variation in individual base pairs, giving rise to global deviation from standardized helical forms.