Measurement of the proportion of free to total prostate-specific antigen improves diagnostic performance of prostate-specific antigen in the diagnostic gray zone of total prostate-specific antigen

The additional value of free prostate specific antigen to the battery of age-dependent prostate-specific antigen, prostate-specific antigen density and velocity

This study describes the value of using the fraction of free prostate-specific antigen as a further marker in the early detection of prostate cancer. This newly introduced marker is compared to the usual battery of age-dependent total prostate-specific antigen, prostate-specific antigen density (microg/l x g tissue) and prostate-specific antigen velocity (microg/l x year). Determination of total prostate-specific antigen and free prostate-specific antigen was performed on fresh serum samples obtained from 3470 symptomatic patients aged 45-80 attending the Urology Clinics, or their General Practitioners. Among them, 310 patients had total prostate-specific antigen above the age-dependent cut-off, and/or free/total prostate-specific antigen under 11%, with different prostate-specific antigen densities and velocities. Only 147 patients complied to undergo biopsy: in 72 of those patients, benign prostatic disease was histologically confirmed, while in 75 patients primary prostate cancer was histologically confirmed. Total and free prostate-specific antigen levels were determined using the third generation DPCs prostate-specific antigen assay performed on the Immulite automated immunoassay instrument. Total prostate-specific antigen age reference values were adopted from Oesterling et al. (J Am Med Ass 1993; 270:860-4); the prostate-specific antigen density was considered suspicious of prostate cancer if it was greater than 0.15 microg/l prostate-specific antigen per gram tissue (Seaman et al. Urol Clin N Am 1993; 20:653); prostate-specific antigen velocity greater than 0.75 microg/l x year (Carter et al., J Am Med Ass 1992; 267:215) was considered suspicious for prostate cancer. Of the 147 patients, 75 had prostate cancer and 72 had benign prostatic hypertrophy. The difference between prostate cancer and benign prostatic hypertrophy was significantly reflected only by free/total prostate-specific antigen and prostate-specific antigen velocity. These parameters also provided the best sensitivity and specificity. Only these parameters proved to be significant when using a backwards logistic regression model (prostate-specific antigen velocity, p = 0.007 odds ratio 2.782; free/total prostate-specific antigen %, p = 0.016 odds ratio 2.678). Combinations of various parameters became significant when including free/total prostate-specific antigen, increasing prostate cancer detection to 88%. We conclude that free/total prostate-specific antigen is the most significant among prostate-specific antigen quantities (total age-dependent prostate-specific antigen, prostate-specific antigen density and prostate-specific antigen velocity). Adding this parameter to other prostate-specific antigen parameters improves the discrimination between prostate cancer and benign prostatic hypertrophy for the population at risk.

Biological variation of prostate specific antigen levels in serum: an evaluation of day-to-day physiological fluctuations in a well-defined cohort of 24 patients

PURPOSE

We evaluated the daily biological variation of serum prostate specific antigen (PSA) concentrations to determine the critical difference required between 2 consecutive PSA measurements that would indicate a significant elevation.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A total of 24 men, grouped according to clinical diagnosis and PSA, underwent phlebotomy for 10 consecutive weekdays. Duplicate serum samples were measured using 3 separate lots of Tandem-E and IMx PSA assays. The biological variation was calculated and the 2 PSA assay systems were compared. The critical difference was examined to determine the percent elevation necessary to indicate (with 95% confidence) that PSA had increased beyond what would be expected from biological and analytical variation.

RESULTS

The biological variation, defined in terms of percent coefficient of variation, had a log-normal distribution with a geometric mean of 7.3% coefficient of variation and a 95th percentile value of 19.2% coefficient of variation using the Tandem-E PSA assay. Assuming an analytical variation of 5% coefficient of variation, the median critical difference was 20.5% and the 95th percentile critical difference was 45.8%. There was no significant difference between the 2 PSA assay systems in biological variation. However, PSA concentrations measured by the IMx assay were consistently lower compared to values measured by the Tandem-E assay.

CONCLUSIONS

Characterizing the biological variation of serum PSA assists in evaluating the significance of changes in serial PSA measurements. The degree of biological variation differs among patients, such that an increase between 2 consecutive PSA levels that is less than 20 to 46% may be due to biological and analytical variation. These data influence interpretation of repeated measurements of serum PSA with time.

Issues in the assessment of prostate-specific antigen immunoassays. An update

Prostate-specific antigen (PSA) immunoassays continue to provide unique and valuable information in the early diagnosis and clinical management of prostate cancer. During the past few years there has been considerable progress in the standardization of routine PSA assays and an emergence of PSA assays with novel applications. The authors discuss these developments and provide some insight when assessing the nuances of assay performance and clinical value.

Prostate-specific antigen as a screening test for prostate cancer. The United States experience

Serum PSA-based early detection for prostate cancer has been studied fairly extensively for the past several years. It appears that we can state fairly categorically what the relative performances of total serum PSA, DRE, and TRUS are in detecting early-stage prostate cancer; that initial screening is effective in detecting histologically significant and pathologically organ-confined prostate cancer; that annual, serial, repetitive screening, at least over a 4- to 5-year horizon, does not overdetect prostate cancer, and that the results of early detection will improve as our ability to use certain PSA transformations such as PSA density, PSA slope, age-specific PSA adjustment, and knowledge of free versus total serum PSA is better characterized. These advances in our ability to diagnose early-stage prostate cancer likely will be coupled with an increased ability to predict the behavior, curability, and significance of individual tumors. It is hoped that information soon will be available to allow physicians to categorize an individual tumor as insignificant, significant and surgically curable, or significant and incurable by standard approaches. This ability, coupled with the demonstrated ability to detect prostate cancer, will make an even more compelling argument for widespread PSA-based screening. At present, annual DRE and total serum PSA measurements are recommended for men older than 50 and among younger men at high risk for prostate cancer. All suspicious DRE findings should be evaluated with prostatic biopsy. Among younger men, PSA levels over 2.5 ng/mL should be considered worrisome and further evaluated. For men older than 65, serum PSA levels above 4 ng/mL should be considered abnormal and warrant biopsy. Men with persistent serum PSA elevation and a negative biopsy should undergo repeat biopsy at least once, and perhaps more often if PSA slope exceeds 0.75 per year, if density is greater than 0.10, or if f-PSA is less than 20%.

Molecular forms of serum prostate-specific antigen. The clinical value of percent free prostate-specific antigen

The concept of measuring the proportions of various forms of PSA in serum, particularly the proportion of free to total PSA, represents a new and exciting method of detecting early curable prostate cancers and avoiding unnecessary prostate biopsies in men who have BPH only. Compared with other methods of improving diagnostic specificity, it does not require transrectal ultrasound for determination of prostate volume, as does the use of PSA density, and it does not require multiple blood sampling over a sufficiently long period, as does PSA velocity. Recent findings suggest determination of the proportion of free to total PSA, rather than that of complexed to total PSA, to be the optimal discriminator between patients with prostate cancer and those with BPH in the PSA reflex range of 2.5 or 3 ng/mL to 10 ng/mL, and to improve the clinical accuracy of the PSA test substantially. If the total PSA value is normal, percent free PSA improves the sensitivity (increases cancer detection) of the PSA test; if the total PSA value is slightly elevated, percent free PSA enhances the specificity (eliminates unnecessary negative prostate biopsies) of the PSA test. Both of these outcomes are clinically desirable in attempting to diagnose early, curable prostate cancers in a cost-effective manner among men who also have varying degrees of BPH. Figure 5 contains a diagnostic algorithm for the detection of clinically significant prostate cancers at a curable stage, employing the concept of percent free PSA. As more is learned about percent free PSA, however, it may be necessary to make modifications in how this concept is used clinically.

Age-specific reference ranges for serum prostate-specific antigen

Since PSA was discovered nearly 20 years ago, significant progress has been made in improving the clinical utility of this glycoprotein as a tumor marker. Factors contributing to the initial limitations in sensitivity and specificity of PSA as a diagnostic tool for early cancer now are understood better. As a result, PSA now is being used [table: see text] widely for the diagnosis of early, curable prostate cancer. PSA, however, because of the inability to differentiate benign processes from malignancy, fails to perform at the ideal tumor-marker level. Nevertheless, in 1997, it remains the best tumor marker in all cancer biology. The research that has been conducted by several independent investigators, showing the correlation between PSA, prostate volume, and patient age, was a vital step in the process of improving the clinical and diagnostic utility of PSA. From this, Oesterling, Dalkin, DeAntoni and others have recommended similar age-specific reference ranges for serum PSA. Subsequent investigations have supported the initial theories that the use of age-specific reference ranges would improve the sensitivity of PSA in younger men, leading to the diagnosis of additional early, organ-confined prostate cancer. The issue of improved specificity in older men has been somewhat less straightforward in that decreasing negative biopsies also result in undetected prostate cancers. The real question involves determining what percent of these undetected prostate cancers are clinically significant to the older patient. Of additional significance is the determination of differing age-specific reference ranges in whites, Asians, and African-Americans (Table 1). In 1997, it is important to know not only the age of the patient but also the race of the patient to interpret the serum PSA concentration. The clinical meaning of a given serum PSA value differs from one race to the next. The recent discovery of the different molecular forms of PSA and their potential ability to improve the diagnostic specificity of PSA is another significant step. Accordingly, the information about the relationship of age to the specific molecular forms and their ratios is a necessity. As urologists continue the quest for the ideal tumor marker for prostate cancer, utilizing age-specific reference ranges will continue to improve the clinical utility of the PSA test.

Novel bispecific immunoprobe for rapid and sensitive detection of prostate-specific antigen

Prostate-specific antigen (PSA) is one of the most useful tumor markers for the screening and follow-up of prostate cancer. Bispecific monoclonal antibodies (bsMAbs) are unique immunoprobes that incorporate two different binding sites in the same antibody molecule. This antibody designing can bring important advantages in the development of new immunoassays. We have developed a new hybrid hybridoma that secretes bsMAb anti-PSA × anti-horseradish peroxidase. This bsMAb has shown rapid kinetics and an excellent detection limit in a sandwich single-step assay with a total incubation time of 15 min and a 5-min substrate development. This assay in a manual format has a detection limit of 0.028 μg/L. Comparison with the Hybritech Tandem-E® PSA assay yielded a regression equation with slope = 0.433 [95% confidence interval (CI) = 0.415–0.451], intercept = 0.88 (CI = 0.45–1.31), and Sy|x = 1.83 μg/L (r = 0.98). This new immunoprobe can be used to develop a new generation of assays for clinical laboratories and can be adapted to screening devices for physicians’ offices and even home diagnostics.

Percent free prostate-specific antigen: entering a new era in the detection of prostate cancer

The introduction of prostate-specific antigen (PSA) testing into clinical medicine in 1986 revolutionized the management of patients with prostate cancer. The major limitation of this tumor marker stems from its inability to provide a clear distinction between benign prostate disease and prostate cancer, especially in patients with upper limit of normal or slightly increased PSA values. Recent research has established that PSA exists in the serum in several molecular forms. Patients with benign prostatic hyperplasia have more of the free form, whereas those with prostate cancer have more of a complexed form (PSA covalently bound to alpha 1-antichymotrypsin). Several investigations have now confirmed that determining percent free PSA (proportion of free PSA to total PSA) enhances the ability of PSA testing to distinguish between prostate cancer and benign prostatic hyperplasia. In addition, percent free PSA seems to have the greatest clinical significance in patients whose total PSA values range from 2.5 or 3.0 ng/mL (lower limit) to 10.0 ng/mL (upper limit). When the total PSA value is in the normal range (2.5 or 3.0 to 4.0 ng/mL), percent free PSA makes PSA a more sensitive test (increases cancer detection). When the total PSA level is minimally increased (4.1 to 10.0 ng/mL), percent free PSA makes PSA a more specific test (eliminates performance of unnecessary prostate biopsies). Although further work remains, it seems that percent free PSA can substantially improve the clinical utility of the PSA test for detecting early, curable prostate cancer.

Percentage of free prostate-specific antigen in sera predicts aggressiveness of prostate cancer a decade before diagnosis

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate serial measurements of free and total prostate-specific antigen (PSA) as a predictor of prostate cancer aggressiveness.

METHODS

Twenty men diagnosed with adenocarcinoma of the prostate in the pre-PSA era had serum PSA measurements made on multiple stored frozen sera samples available for up to 18 years prior to diagnosis. Subjects were categorized as having aggressive cancer (n = 12) based on the presence of clinical Stage T3, or nodal or bone metastases (N+, M+), or pathologic positive-margin disease, or a Gleason score of 7 or greater; nonaggressive cancer (n = 8) was identified by the absence of these criteria.

RESULTS

There was no statistically significant difference in free PSA levels among men with aggressive and nonaggressive prostate cancers from 0 to 15 years before diagnosis. Total PSA levels were significantly different between the groups by 5 years before diagnosis (P = 0.04). At a time when total PSA levels were not different between groups (10 years before diagnosis), there was a statistically significant difference in the percentage of free PSA between aggressive and nonaggressive cancers (P = 0.008). Among 14 men who had sera available for analysis at 10 years before diagnosis, all 8 men with aggressive cancers had a percent free PSA of 0.14 or less; this compares with only 2 of 6 men (33%) with nonaggressive cancer.

CONCLUSIONS

These data suggest that the percentage of free PSA in sera is predictive of tumor behavior at a time when total PSA levels provide no information on tumor aggressiveness. Evaluation of the percentage of free serum PSA may be helpful in making the decision between expectant management and treatment for those men who are diagnosed with early prostate cancers by PSA testing.

Molecular forms of prostate-specific antigen in the serum of women with benign and malignant breast diseases

Using a highly sensitive immunofluorometric procedure, we measured the total prostate-specific antigen (PSA) concentration in 632 sera obtained from female blood donors and women with idiopathic hirsutism, breast cancer or benign breast diseases. A total of 50 sera with total PSA > 15 ng l(-1) were fractionated by high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) in order to resolve the two immunoreactive molecular forms, i.e. free PSA (approximately 30 kDa) and PSA bound to alpha1-antichymotrypsin (PSA-ACT, 100 kDa). We found that breast cancer patients have presurgical serum total PSA levels similar to those of blood donors. Total serum PSA concentration decreases with age in women with idiopathic hirsutism, in cancer patients and in patients with benign breast diseases. The major molecular form of PSA in the serum of all normal and hirsute women (n = 15) is PSA bound to the proteinase inhibitor alpha1-antichymotrypsin. The major molecular form in 44% of presurgical cancer patient sera is free PSA. A total of 58% of benign breast disease patients also have in their serum mainly free PSA. We conclude that about half the patients with breast cancer or benign breast diseases have free PSA as the major molecular form in their serum, whereas patients without breast pathologies (normal blood donors, idiopathic hirsutism) have PSA bound to alpha1-antichymotrypsin as the major molecular form. The ratio of PSA/PSA-ACT may have value as a simple biochemical test for diagnosis of breast pathologies including breast cancer.

Determination of the "reflex range" and appropriate cutpoints for percent free prostate-specific antigen in 413 men referred for prostatic evaluation using the AxSYM system

OBJECTIVES

Prostate-specific antigen (PSA) exists in the serum in two clinically important molecular forms: free PSA and PSA complexed to alpha 1-antichymotrypsin. Total PSA approximates the sum of the free and complexed forms. Preliminary investigations have illustrated the potential benefits of using percent free PSA to enhance the clinical utility of PSA in distinguishing benign prostate disease from prostate cancer. The current study defines the optimal range of total PSA for measuring percent free PSA (reflex range) and generates appropriate cutpoints for percent free PSA within this range.

METHODS

A total of 413 patients, 225 (54%) with benign prostate disease (mean age, 67 years) and 188 (46%) with prostate cancer (mean age, 66 years), who had PSA values between 2.0 and 20.0 ng/mL participated in the investigation. All patients underwent a sextant biopsy to establish the diagnosis. The serum specimens were assayed with the AxSYM PSA assay (total PSA) and AxSYM Free PSA assay (Abbott Laboratories; Abbott Park, IL). Percent free PSA was calculated for all patients. Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves were generated for various ranges of total PSA to determine the reflex range that maximized the increase in sensitivity and specificity of percent free PSA over total PSA. Within the optimal range, the ROC curves were utilized to generate cutpoints for percent free PSA to be used in clinical practice.

RESULTS

The appropriate reflex range for the utility of percent free PSA was 3.0 to 10.0 ng/mL. The appropriate cutpoint for percent free PSA when the total PSA value was 3.0 to 4.0 ng/mL to achieve 90% sensitivity for the detection of prostate cancer was 0.19. This approach resulted in a biopsy rate of 73% and a cancer detection rate of 44% in men with a total PSA value between 3.0 and 4.0 ng/mL. The appropriate cutpoint for percent free PSA when the total PSA value was 4.1 to 10.0 ng/mL to ensure 95% sensitivity for detection of prostate cancer was 0.24. Within the range of 4.1 to 10.0 ng/mL, this approach resulted in 13% fewer negative biopsies and failure to detect 5% of the cancers.

CONCLUSIONS

Percent free PSA should be utilized in patients with a total serum PSA value between 3.0 and 10.0 ng/mL. In patients with a total PSA value between 3.0 and 4.0 ng/mL, percent free PSA enhanced the detection of prostate cancer (improving sensitivity). In patients with a total PSA concentration ranging from 4.1 to 10.0 ng/mL, negative biopsies were eliminated (improving specificity).

Multicenter comparison of the diagnostic performance of free prostate-specific antigen

OBJECTIVES

This study examined the multicenter clinical performance of noncomplexed (free) prostate-specific antigen (PSA) in men presenting with total PSA values between 2.5 to 20 ng/mL.

METHODS

Prebiopsy serum samples were obtained from 1,081 consecutively accrued, histologically diagnosed men between the ages of 40 and 75 years with total PSA values falling between 2.5 and 20 ng/mL. Total PSA was determined by either the Tosoh AIA-1200 or Hybritech method. Free PSA values were determined using the Dianon PSA II immunoradiometric method. Free PSA was expressed as a percentage of total PSA. Immunochemistry was performed at each accrual site.

RESULTS

Among men diagnosed with prostate cancer (CaP), only 4% (21/520) had proportions of free to total PSA values > 25%. Conversely, among men with benign prostatic disease, only 2% (13/561) had proportions of free to total PSA values < 7%. These results confirm those of previous research. Differences among sites were found in age and prostate volume.

CONCLUSIONS

These data confirm that free PSA values < 7% are highly suspicious for CaP whereas free PSA values > 25% suggest absence of malignancy. The data also suggest that age and/or prostate volume influences the serum level of free PSA but does not affect the diagnostic cutoff points of 7% and 25%. Future analysis is needed to confirm that younger men with small prostates are at higher risk for CaP.

Comparison of analysis of the different prostate-specific antigen forms in serum for detection of clinically localized prostate cancer

OBJECTIVES

To compare different forms and ratios of serum prostate-specific antigen (PSA) to determine which form or ratio provides optimal diagnostic specificity and sensitivity in distinguishing between benign prostatic hyperplasia (BPH) and clinically localized prostate cancer.

METHODS

Serum samples were obtained from 47 patients with BPH and 39 with clinically localized prostate cancer. Patients with BPH underwent either transurethral resection of the prostate or transurethral microwave thermotherapy. Patients with prostate cancer, all of whom had no metastases on radionucleotide bone scans and no pelvic lymph node involvement, underwent either radical external beam radiation therapy or radical retropubic prostatectomy. All patients had pretreatment serum PSA levels between 1 and 20 ng/mL. The different forms of serum PSA (free PSA [PSA-F], PSA complexed to alpha 1-antichymotrypsin [PSA-ACT], and total PSA [PSA-T]) were measured using different monoclonal antibodies against PSA and ACT and immunofluorometric assay techniques. Furthermore, three ratios (PSA-F/PSA-T, PSA-ACT/PSA-T, and PSA-F/PSA-ACT) were calculated.

RESULTS

By receiver operating characteristic curve analysis, the performance of the different forms and ratios were compared. The PSA-F/PSA-T ratio had the greatest area under the curve (AUC, 0.776), significantly larger than that for PSA-T (0.612; P = 0.024). For PSA-ACT/PSA-T, the AUC was 0.695 (P = 0.283 versus PSA-T) and 0.773 for PSA-F/PSA-ACT (P = 0.051 versus PSA-T). At a cutoff level < 0.17, PSA-F/PSA-T had a sensitivity of 79%, a specificity of 66%, and a positive predictive value of 66% compared with 74%, 38%, and 50%, respectively, for PSA-T at a cutoff level > 4.0 ng/mL.

CONCLUSIONS

The PSA-F/PSA-T ratio gives the best diagnostic performance compared with that for other forms and ratios of PSA and will reduce the number of prostatic biopsies in patients with BPH.

Prospective use of free prostate-specific antigen to avoid repeat prostate biopsies in men with elevated total prostate-specific antigen

OBJECTIVES

We prospectively evaluated whether free PSA improves the specificity of PSA and can be useful as a clinical guide to avoid repeat prostate biopsies in patients with persistent PSA elevations, normal digital rectal examinations, and previous negative prostate biopsies.

METHODS

Sixty-seven men with persistent PSA elevations (median 9.5, range 4.1-24.8 ng/mL), normal digital rectal examinations and two or more prior sextant biopsies (mean 2.8) had serum collected for measurement of total and free PSA. All patients were rebiopsied to determine the receiver operating characteristics of total PSA versus percent free PSA for prostate cancer detection.

RESULTS

The study biopsy identified 11 prostate cancer cases. The median percent free PSA was significantly higher at 18.0% among men without prostate cancer compared to 6.7% in men with prostate cancer (P < 0.00005). When sensitivity was plotted against 1-specificity, the area under the receiver operating characteristic curve for percent free PSA was 0.93, compared to 0.69 for free PSA density, 0.66 for PSA density, and 0.51 for PSA. In patients with elevated total PSA levels, normal digital rectal examinations and two prior negative sets of sextant prostate biopsies, a cutoff of 10% free PSA would maintain sensitivity at 91% with a corresponding specificity of 86%.

CONCLUSIONS

Selective measurement of percent free PSA can significantly improve the specificity of prostate cancer screening with PSA. A low percent free PSA (< 10%) appears to be a powerful predictor of prostate cancer even after two negative prostate biopsies.

Does free to total ratio of prostate-specific antigen alter decision-making on prostatic biopsy?

OBJECTIVES

For patients with prostate specific antigen (PSA) values of 4-10 ng/mL, some urologists perform prostatic biopsies depending upon the findings of digital rectal examination (DRE) and transrectal ultrasonography (TRUS), and others perform biopsies on most of these men regardless of the findings of DRE and TRUS. The purpose of this study was to examine whether the information given by the measurement of the ratio of free to total (F/T) PSA can alter decision-making on prostatic biopsy.

METHODS

One hundred and two (102) men with PSA values between 4 and 10 ng/mL, were included in this study. All men were examined with DRE and TRUS; a F/T PSA ratio was also measured, and six prostatic biopsies were taken from each patient.

RESULTS

In 102 men who were biopsied, 22 (21.5%) prostatic carcinomas were identified. Among these 22 cancer patients, 13 had abnormal findings in DRE and/or TRUS and would have been biopsied and diagnosed anyway. If we use only the F/T PSA ratio (cut-off value 0.20) to decide whom to biopsy, we would have diagnosed 16/22 cancers; the difference between these two procedures was not statistically significant (P = 0.17). If we decide to biopsy those patients who have abnormal findings in DRE and/or TRUS and those who have a F/T PSA ratio < 0.20, we would diagnose 20/22 cancers (P = 0.05) and at the same time, reduce the unnecessary biopsies from 80 to 41 (48%). With a PSA value between 4 and 10 ng/mL and no findings in DRE and TRUS and at the same time with a F/T PSA ratio > or = 0.20, we would have to perform biopsies in 20.5 men to find one cancer. On the other hand, in patients with suspicious findings in DRE and/or TRUS and a F/T PSA ratio < 0.20, in every two men that we biopsy we would find one cancer.

CONCLUSION

We believe that among patients with PSA values between 4 and 10 ng/mL after performing DRE and TRUS, the additional information of F/T PSA ratio can help since it increases the number of cancers detected and reduces the number of unnecessary biopsies.

Comparison of three assays for total serum prostate-specific antigen and percentage of free prostate-specific antigen in predicting prostate histology

OBJECTIVES

To determine the statistical performance of three different assays for prostate specific antigen (PSA) and the percentage of free PSA with respect to the differentiation of histologic benign prostatic hyperplasia (BPH) and prostate cancer in men who underwent surgical removal of prostate tissue.

METHODS

Serum of 86 men scheduled for prostate surgery (transurethral resection of the prostate [TURP], simple open prostatectomy, radical prostatectomy, cystoprostatectomy) was frozen and subjected to measurement in batches using three different assays for total PSA (Hybritech Tandem-E, Abbott IMx, Tosoh AIA-600) and free PSA by the Hybritech method after a single freeze-thaw cycle. The histologic diagnosis of the removed tissue (35 BPH and 51 cancer) was used as a "gold standard" for classification of disease status. Sensitivity, specificity, positive and negative predictive values, and diagnostic efficiency were calculated for the three total PSA assays and the free/total PSA ratios for the entire cohort and subsets. Receiver-operating characteristic (ROC) curve analysis was used to compare the performance of the assays and ratios.

RESULTS

Mean and median total PSA values differed slightly between the three assays for all patients, and for those with BPH and cancer, but this difference was not significant. Because of a considerable overlap, the differences between the mean PSA values for men with BPH and prostate cancer were not significant. At a cutpoint of 4.0 ng/mL, sensitivity with respect to the differentiation between BPH and prostate cancer was 68.6% for all three total PSA assays; the respective AUCs (0.613-0.625) were not significantly different. While the performance of the free/total PSA ratios was superior, the differences were only significant when subsets of patients were considered with a total PSA between 4 and 10 ng/mL or 4 and 15 ng/mL (AUCs 0.789-0.816). Likewise, sensitivity, specificity, and diagnostic efficiency was better in these subsets of patients.

CONCLUSIONS

In this study in which a "gold standard" based on histologic analysis of the entire (or large part of) the prostate gland was used to classify disease status, the three assays for total serum PSA (Hybritech Tandem-E, Abbott IMx, and Tosoh AIA-600) performed very similarly with identical sensitivities (at a cutpoint of 4.0 ng/mL) and comparable AUCs with respect to the differentiation of men with histologic BPH and prostate cancer. The ratios of free/total PSA calculated as free PSA by the Hybritech manual immunoradiometric assay (IRMA) method over all three total PSA assays, performed marginally better in the entire patient population. However, in the subsets of patients with a PSA of 4-10 ng/mL and 4-15 ng/mL, all three ratios performed significantly better than the three total PSA assays. The proper choice of a cutpoint for the ratio (15%, 17%, 19%, or 21%) depends on the desirability of maximizing either sensitivity or specificity while optimizing diagnostic efficiency.

The role of free/total prostate-specific antigen ratio in the prediction of final pathologic stage for men with clinically localized prostate cancer

OBJECTIVES

The combined use of total prostate-specific antigen (PSA), clinical stage, and Gleason score accurately predicts final pathologic stage for men with clinically localized prostate cancer. Recently, the free/ total PSA ratio has been proposed as an adjunct for early detection of prostate cancer. We examined the association between free/total PSA and pathologic stage.

METHODS

In a prospective study, 301 consecutive men with clinically localized prostate cancer (average age 58.8 years, range 45-72) underwent a staging pelvic lymphadenectomy and radical prostatectomy. Total PSA and free PSA were measured from preoperative sera. Pathologic stage was determined as organ-confined (OC, n = 169), capsular penetration (CP+, n = 108), seminal vesicle involvement (SV+, n = 13) and lymph node involvement (LN+, n = 11).

RESULTS

Overall, 292/301 (97%) of the free/total PSA values were < 25%, and thus suspicious for prostate cancer. Combination of total PSA, Gleason score, and clinical stage predicted well OC (P = 0.00001) and LN+ (P = 0.023); whereas, replacing total PSA with free/total PSA ratio did not improve the prediction of OC (P = 0.0007) nor LN+ (P = 0.03).

CONCLUSIONS

The free/total PSA ratio cutoff point of 25% had high sensitivity for prostate cancer among a group of men with clinically localized disease. The free/total PSA ratio did not significantly improve the prediction of pathologic stage provided by total PSA when used alone or in combination with Gleason score and clinical stage. These preliminary data demonstrate that free/total PSA levels provide no additional information for pathologic stage prediction when combined with Gleason score and clinical stage in men with clinically localized prostate cancer.

Free to total prostate-specific antigen (PSA) ratio improves the discrimination between prostate cancer and benign prostatic hyperplasia (BPH) in the diagnostic gray zone of 1.8 to 10 ng/mL total PSA

OBJECTIVES

Improved discrimination between prostate cancer (PC) and benign prostatic hyperplasia (BPH) is clearly needed. Our aim in this study was to evaluate whether the free to total prostate-specific antigen (PSA) ratio would be useful in the gray zone of 1.8-10 ng/mL total PSA range.

METHODS

In a consecutive series of 435 clinic patients referred for prostate evaluation, 308 had a total PSA < 10 ng/mL (92 had PC and 216 BPH). Free and total PSA were measured, and the free to total PSA ratio calculated.

RESULTS

Total PSA values were significantly different between the two groups. For the 200 patients with a total PSA < 6 ng/mL, no significant difference in total PSA values were seen (P = 0.411), whereas free to total PSA ratios remained statistically different (P < 0.001). Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve analysis comparing the performances of total PSA over the ratio of free to total PSA showed a clear advantage for the ratio at all sensitivity levels.

CONCLUSIONS

These data demonstrate that in a significant number (n = 308) of prostatic patients in the diagnostic gray zone of 1.8-10 ng/mL total PSA, the routine use of free to total PSA might be advantageous in discriminating between cancer and benign hyperplasia. This advantage remained for total PSA < 4 ng/mL. Further study is warranted to confirm these findings in an unselected population.

In vitro stability of free prostate-specific antigen (PSA) and prostate-specific antigen (PSA) complexed to alpha 1-antichymotrypsin in blood samples

OBJECTIVES

To study the in vitro stability of free and complexed forms of prostate specific antigen (PSA) in blood samples in order to establish guidelines for specimen handling, in particular for the clinical utility of the analysis of percentage free PSA.

METHODS

Blood samples were collected and processed to generate serum, heparin plasma, and EDTA plasma. Three different two-site immunoassays were used to measure the concentrations of total PSA (PSA-T), free form of PSA (PSA-F), and PSA-alpha 1-antichymotrypsin complex (PSA-ACT) in order to determine the effect of repeated freezing and thawing, delayed separation of serum from blood cells, and stability during storage at 4 degrees C and 30 degrees C.

RESULTS

Five cycles of freezing and thawing introduced no statistically significant changes in the measured concentrations of PSA-T, PSA-F, or PSA-ACT. The effect of storing blood samples at room temperature for 1-6 h before separation of serum revealed a statistically significant decrease only for PSA-F after 5.5 h of storage (mean decrease 3.5%). PSA-T and PSA-ACT showed good stability in both serum and plasma samples, whereas PSA-F, after 1 week of storage at 4 degrees C, decreased on average by 28.8%, 7.8%, and 5.6%, respectively, in serum, heparin plasma, and EDTA plasma. The decreases of PSA-F at 4 degrees C were statistically significant (P < 0.05) relative to the controls (samples stored at -20 degrees C) after storage for 23 h in serum, 86 h in heparin plasma, and 71 h in EDTA plasma. When the same samples were stored at 30 degrees C for 24 h, only the mean decrease of PSA-F (4.8%) in serum was statistically significant.

CONCLUSIONS

PSA-F in blood samples is less stable than PSA-ACT. It is not advisable to store samples on the clot, especially if time and temperature cannot be controlled. Serum samples should be stored frozen if not analyzed during the same day. After thawing, samples can be stored up to 23 h at 4 degrees C prior to analysis. The use of plasma samples improves the stability of free PSA.

Analysis of percent free prostate-specific antigen (PSA) for prostate cancer detection: influence of total PSA, prostate volume, and age

OBJECTIVES

To determine whether the use of the free-to-total PSA ratio (percent free PSA) could increase the specificity of PSA testing for prostate cancer detection in men with serum PSA concentrations between 4.0 and 10.0 ng/mL, and to assess the influence of total PSA, prostate volume, and age on percent free PSA.

METHODS

Sera were obtained from 217 men with histologically confirmed diagnoses (139 prostate cancer, 78 benign). Free and total PSA concentrations were determined using Hybritech Tandem assays.

RESULTS

Use of percent free PSA increased PSA specificity: 29% of negative biopsies would be spared while retaining 95% sensitivity. Percent free PSA increased with increasing age and prostate volume. Percent free PSA decreased as total PSA increased. A significant relation exists between percent free PSA and the probability of a positive biopsy; in this cohort, a patient with a low percent free PSA (< or = 10%) had a higher probability of cancer (63 +/- 9%) than a patient with a high percent free PSA (> or = 26%) (probability 2 +/- 3%).

CONCLUSIONS

Percent free PSA may be used as an aid in distinguishing prostate cancer from benign disease in men with a total PSA between 4.0 and 10.0 ng/mL. Large prospective multicenter trials are required to develop consistent recommendations and determine the appropriate cutpoints and risk probabilities, controlling for total PSA, prostate volume, age, and biopsy history.

Constitutive expression of high levels of prostate-specific antigen in the absence of prostate carcinoma

OBJECTIVES

To identify distinguishing serologic features in patients with stable marked elevation in prostate-specific antigen (PSA) and multiple negative biopsies.

METHODS

The study population consisted of 7 patients with a stable PSA level of greater than 20 ng/mL (average 27.0), followed for at least 34 months (average 56), and with two or more negative prostatic biopsies including transition zone biopsies. The PSA density (PSAD), rate of change in PSA, reverse transcriptase/polymerase chain reaction (RT/PCR), and free/total PSA were obtained.

RESULTS

Rate of change in PSA level was stable (0.18 +/- 1.2 ng/mL/yr), suggesting that there was no occult cancer; PSAD was high (0.34 +/- 0.5 ng/mL/cc), indicating that prostate size was not the sole cause of the elevation. The RT/PCR was negative in 6 of 7 patients, further decreasing the likelihood of an occult malignancy. Free versus total PSA was not consistent, averaging 16.8%, but with a range of 6% to 34%.

CONCLUSIONS

Novel PSA tests were not found to be useful in this cohort of patients with multiple negative biopsies and PSA elevations greater than 20 ng/mL. Additional studies with larger sample size are required to confirm this finding.

The use of prostate-specific antigen and free/total prostate-specific antigen in the diagnosis of localized prostate cancer

Although there is controversy regarding the benefit of early detection of prostate cancer, it has been demonstrated that early detection can be best achieved through the use of a combination of digital rectal examination and prostate-specific antigen (PSA). This article outlines the clinical use of PSA for early detection of prostate cancer and focuses primarily on the value of molecular forms of PSA (free PSA, complexed PSA, and total PSA) in the diagnosis of localized prostate cancer.

Role of transrectal ultrasound and prostate biopsy

Transrectal ultrasound (TRUS) has revolutionized our ability to image the human prostate. In the present review, we have attempted to present salient observations with respect to this modality. We emphasize its use in combination with biopsy in men who are considered at risk for harboring carcinoma. The relevant English literature is reviewed. In addition, our experience with 2,231 consecutive ultrasound-guided biopsies performed at the University of Washington and the Seattle VA Medical Center is analyzed. TRUS appears to have its primary use in directing the biopsy needle into suspicious areas and in performing the so-called systematic sector approach to biopsy. The role of transrectal ultrasound in staging established malignancy or in monitoring men following therapy remains to be defined. In our experience, carcinoma was detected in 27.2% of the subjects. Carcinoma was found in 30.7% of patients with a hypoechoic sector. Of note, 18.4% of men had their only carcinoma found in isoechoic areas. Failure to biopsy isoechoic sectors would have resulted in missing almost 20% of men with carcinoma. The role of TRUS in men with initially negative biopsy is also discussed. In summary, ultrasound guided biopsy is a useful addition to our armamentarium, particularly with respect to performing biopsy. Future advances in this modality include image enhancement utilizing computer technology as well as the potential additive role of color flow ultrasound.

Evaluation and comparison of two new prostate carcinoma markers. Free-prostate specific antigen and prostate specific membrane antigen

BACKGROUND

Two new prostate cancer markers, free-prostate specific antigen (f-PSA) and prostate specific membrane antigen (PSMA) were recently introduced. This report summarizes a prospective two-year multicenter test of their diagnostic or prognostic capabilities. Total PSA was also measured.

METHODS

There were four clinical groups studied: (1) 226 individuals from a screening project undergoing ultrasound and biopsy evaluation had markers obtained: (2) 68 patients suspected of having prostate cancer and undergoing 2 or more biopsies had the markers obtained on multiple occasions: (3) 100 patients undergoing radical prostatectomy had markers obtained pre- and post-operatively: and (4) 31 patients with metastatic prostate cancer each had multiple samples for marker assay obtained over a 2-year period. In all, 465 patients had one or more samples obtained and studied.

RESULTS

Free-PSA affords little additional diagnostic advantage compared with total PSA in the screening population. The receiver operating characteristic curves for diagnostic accuracy were ranked: (1) PSA density; (2) total PSA; (3) f-PSA; and (4) PSMA, PSMA showed the best correlation with stage of the primary tumor in the screened group. In the multiple negative biopsy group, f-PSA varied from 12 to 21%. PSMA values were evaluated in all histologic categories. PSA density was > or = 0.15 in all categories. In the prostatectomy cases PSA values postoperatively were quite low in Stage II; f-PSA was of no value. Later, f-PSA was increased in association with elevated total PSA values. Mean PSMA values were above normal in all postoperative time periods except in Stage III patients at 6 months to 1 year postoperatively. PSA densities were all > or = 0.15. In patients with metastatic carcinoma, elevated PSMA values correlated best with a poor prognosis (clinical progression), as has been described.

CONCLUSIONS

These data suggest that f-PSA values do not provide additional diagnostic benefit compared with total PSA in screening populations, in the presence of suspected cancer, postprostatectomy, or in metastatic disease. PSMA is of prognostic significance, especially in the presence of metastatic disease, and correlates well with the stage of disease in cancers detected in a screened population.

Age- and race-specific reference ranges for prostate-specific antigen from a large community-based study

OBJECTIVES

To analyze the relationship of age and race to prostate-specific antigen (PSA) levels among participants in a community-based study.

METHODS

A total of 77,700 records of men aged 40 to 79 years were analyzed from a longitudinal study of PSA conducted during Prostate Cancer Awareness Week 1993 and 1994. Records from 1994 were not included for men who were tested in 1993. All cases of prostate cancer were excluded. Records with outlier PSA values greater than 20 ng/mL were eliminated from the analysis (n = 190; 24%).

RESULTS

Mean PSA values (ng/mL) of 10-year age groups differed significantly (P < 0.0001) between each group (ages 40-49, 0.83; 50-59, 1.23; 60-69, 1.83; 70-79, 2.31). In each successively older age group, PSA variance increased significantly (P = 0.0001). Standard deviations (SD) by age group were: 40-49, 0.79; 50-59, 1.33; 60-69, 1.94; and 70-79, 2.35. Significant differences in mean PSA by race were found. Pairwise differences in mean PSA were found between whites and blacks, whites and Latinos, blacks and Asians, and Asians and Latinos (P < 0.0001). No statistically significant differences in PSA variance between racial groups were found. Age-within-race analysis resulted in consistent statistical significance when comparing variance among age cohorts in each race.

CONCLUSIONS

Age-specific PSA reference ranges are a result of the increasing mean PSA and increasing PSA variance in successively older cohorts of men. Mean PSA values differ significantly by race, but differences in PSA variance do not. The clinical significance of race-specific PSA reference ranges has yet to be determined.

Free, complexed, and total serum prostate-specific antigen concentrations and their proportions in predicting stage, grade, and deoxyribonucleic acid ploidy in patients with adenocarcinoma of the prostate

OBJECTIVES

Nearly half of men with clinically localized prostate cancer are understaged. We evaluated whether knowledge of preoperative free prostate-specific antigen (f-PSA), complexed (c-PSA), and total (t-PSA) concentrations or the ratios thereof (f-PSA/t-PSA, c-PSA/t-PSA, and f-PSA/c-PSA) could improve upon the staging of prostate cancer when compared with standard PSA testing (t-PSA). In addition, we examined their associations with tumor grade and deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) ploidy.

METHODS

Two hundred ninety patients with prostate cancer, 178 (61%) of whom were treated with radical prostatectomy, formed the study group.

RESULTS

Although there were significant differences in the f-PSA concentrations with respect to clinical stage, considerable overlap in PSA levels among the clinical substages was observed. Statistically significant differences but weak correlations were observed between the individual f-PSA, c-PSA, and t-PSA concentrations with regard to pathologic stage (organ-confined versus extraprostatic) and grade. No significant relationship, however, was observed with the three ratios. Higher PSA values were not always associated with a pathologic stage of pT3 or greater, and lower levels did not ensure that a tumor was organ-confined. Only a slight association was observed between c-PSA and t-PSA levels and DNA ploidy. No significant relationship was observed between the f-PSA levels as well as the three ratios with regard to DNA ploidy. A statistically significant improvement in predicting pathologic stage was observed when combining knowledge of preoperative t-PSA concentration with the c-PSA/t-PSA ratio. However, the area under the receiver operator characteristic curves was only slightly increased; as such this combination was of limited clinical utility.

CONCLUSIONS

Statistically significant but weak correlations were observed between the molecular forms of PSA and stage, grade, and DNA ploidy. The significant overlap in f-PSA and c-PSA values among all stages, grades, and ploidy values precluded any useful predictive information for the individual patient. As such, preoperative knowledge of f-PSA and c-PSA values and the three ratios provided no additional diagnostic information over standard PSA (t-PSA) values alone.

Using proportions of free to total prostate-specific antigen, age, and total prostate-specific antigen to predict the probability of prostate cancer

OBJECTIVES

This study was undertaken to define the probability of prostate cancer as a function of the proportion of free to total prostate-specific antigen (FTPSA), total PSA, and age for those patients with total PSA levels between 2.5 and 20.0 ng/mL.

METHODS

Prebiopsy serums were obtained from 428 untreated patients (165 malignant, 263 benign) who had undergone sextant six-core biopsy. Each patient had no prior history of prostate cancer and a prebiopsy total PSA value between 2.5 and 20.0 ng/mL. Total PSA levels were determined using the PA immunoassay performed on the TOSOH AIA-1200 automated immunoassay instrument. Free PSA levels were determined using a monoclonal-polyclonal antibody sandwich radioimmunoassay.

RESULTS

In men with total PSA values between 2.5 and 20.0 ng/mL, the FTPSA significantly differentiated between patients with benign and malignant histologic states. Log linear modeling indicated distinct differences in the risk for cancer as a function of FTPSA, total PSA, and age. The highest probability for cancer was observed in men greater than 70 years of age who had a FTPSA less than 7% and total PSA more than 10.0 ng/mL. Conversely, the lowest probability for cancer was observed in patients less than 60 years of age who had a FTPSA more than 25% and a total PSA less than 4 ng/mL.

CONCLUSIONS

The probability that prostate cancer will be found on biopsy has a marked gradient that is associated with age, total PSA, and FTPSA. The extreme ends of FTPSA of less than 7% and more than 25% are diagnostic for prostate cancer and benign prostatic disease, respectively.

The proportion of free to total prostate specific antigen: a method of detecting prostate carcinoma

BACKGROUND

Prostate specific antigen (PSA) is the most useful marker for prostate carcinoma (CaP). However, the sensitivity and specificity for PSA are not sufficient for the diagnosis of organ-confined prostate carcinoma. Recent studies have revealed that anti-PSA antibody identifies both PSA complexed to alpha-1-antichymotrypsin and free PSA, whereas anti-gamma-seminoprotein antibody recognizes free PSA exclusively. To enhance the ability of PSA to detect CaP in patients with total PSA levels of 10 ng/mL or lower, we developed the ratio of gamma-seminoprotein and PSA (free/total PSA index).

METHODS

We measured free/total PSA indices for 285 patients who had serum PSA levels of 10 ng/mL or lower and who were diagnosed pathologically.

RESULTS

Of the 285 patients, 228 had no prostate carcinoma (NC) and 57 had CaP. The mean total PSA level for CaP (5.137 +/- 2.483 ng/mL; mean +/- standard deviation) was significantly greater (P < 0.0001) than that for NC (3.251 +/- 2.129). The mean free/total PSA index for CaP (0.774 +/- 0.468 was significantly lower (P < 0.0001) than that for NC (1.563 +/- 0.938). The sensitivity for the free/total PSA index was similar to that for total PSA (78.9% vs. 75.4%). However, the specificity, positive predictive value, and overall accuracy for the free/total PSA index (75.9%, 45%, and 76.5%, respectively) increased by 15-20% compared with those for total PSA (56.6%, 30.3%, and 60.4%, respectively).

CONCLUSIONS

The free/total PSA index improved the specificity of PSA without impairing the sensitivity in detecting CaP among patients with serum PSA levels of 10 ng/mL or lower.

Clinical utility of measurements of free and total prostate-specific antigen (PSA): a review

BACKGROUND

Prostate-specific antigen (PSA) is a widely-used tumor marker to aid in the early detection of prostate cancer. PSA testing has appreciable false-positive and false-negative results, particularly in the 2.5-10.0 ng/ml range. Measurements of the percentage of nonprotein-bound (free) PSA in serum, which is lower in patients with prostate cancer, has been evaluated as a method for increasing the accuracy of PSA testing.

METHODS

The literature on forms of PSA in serum, as it relates to issues of clinical utility for prostate cancer screening, was reviewed and summarized through May 1996.

RESULTS

Measurements of the percentage of free PSA in serum increase the accuracy of PSA testing for prostate cancer in men whose total PSA levels are 2.5-10.0 ng/ml. Cutoffs for screening are affected by prostate volume and total PSA levels. One study also demonstrated a correlation between percentage of free PSA and pathologic features of cancer aggressiveness.

CONCLUSIONS

Measurement of free PSA in serum has potential clinical utility for increasing the sensitivity and specificity of PSA screening. Insufficient data are available to establish cutoffs to be used in clinical practice. Cutoffs are affected by total PSA level and prostate volume. The prevalence rate of cancer in the screened population (age, race, previous biopsy history, etc.) will also influence screening cutoffs. Percentage of free PSA may also correlate with the potential aggressiveness of early-stage prostate cancer.