Novel vectors for gene delivery formed by self-assembly of DNA with poly(L-lysine) grafted with hydrophilic polymers

Strength of conjugate binding to plasmid DNA affects degradation rate and expression level in vivo

In vitro assays have demonstrated the capability of poly-L-lysine to protect plasmid DNA from serum nucleases and cellular lysates. Our purpose was to evaluate the stability and potency of poly-L-lysine-DNA polyplexes after intravenous injection into mice. Polyplexes consisted of 32P-radiolabeled plasmid DNA complexed with poly-L-lysine at specified charge ratios. Variations in conjugate hydrophobicity and levels of modification with polyethylene glycol were investigated. Our results show that, in contrast to in vitro studies, the systemically administered polyplexes exhibited marked DNA degradation in the vascular compartment within 5 min. Substitution of poly-L-lysine epsilon-amino sites with polyethylene glycol or hydrocarbon chains resulted in faster degradation even when complexed at higher charge (+/-) ratios. Use of excess cationic charge in the polyplexes (+/- 2.5) diminished degradation rates only slightly. An analysis was made of the strength of the poly-L-lysine:DNA interaction by competition with poly-aspartic acid. Polyplexes with the strongest binding between conjugate and DNA in the competition assay were also the most stable in blood. However, tighter binding was not enough to fully protect the polyplex in vivo and polyplex DNA was substantially degraded within 10 min. Increased polyplex stability did not correlate with improved in vivo transfection efficiency.

A versatile system for receptor-mediated gene delivery permits increased entry of DNA into target cells, enhanced delivery to the nucleus and elevated rates of transgene expression

We have developed a method for stabilisation of polyelectrolyte gene delivery vectors by crosslinking their surfaces with biodegradable multivalent copolymers based on N-(2-hydroxypropyl)methacrylamide (HPMA). The resulting nanoparticulate vectors resist attack by serum proteins and can be modified for cell-specific delivery by incorporation of targeting ligands onto the polymer coating. Here we show that vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF), transferrin and basic fibroblast growth factor (bFGF) can each be linked to polyHPMA-coated poly(L-lysine)/DNA complexes. All ligand-targeted complexes demonstrated increased uptake into receptor-positive cells (measured using plasmids containing 32P-dCTP), that could be antagonised with excess free ligand. Targeted complexes also showed increased transfection, resistant to inhibition by serum, suggesting the possibility of effective application in vivo. Analysis using fluorescence microscopy confirmed enhanced uptake of ligand-targeted complexes (using Texas Red-labelled plasmid DNA), although VEGF- and transferrin-targeted complexes were restricted to cytoplasmic or perinuclear distributions. In contrast, bFGF-targeted complexes showed efficient delivery into the nucleus, with accumulation of more than 100000 plasmids per cell within distinct intranuclear compartments. This method permits versatile targeting of genes to selected cells and may also permit manipulation of intracellular trafficking. It should find several important applications in gene delivery systems both in vitro and in vivo.

Transfection efficiency increases by incorporating hydrophobic monomer units into polymeric gene carriers

The water soluble terpolymer, poly(N-isopropylacrylamide (IPAAm)-co-2-(dimethylamino)ethyl methacrylate (DMAEMA)-co-butylmethacrylate (BMA)) was synthesized, and its efficiency in in vitro gene transfection was evaluated. Copolymers with different compositions were synthesized by radical polymerization. For a series of copolymers containing 60 mol% of DMAEMA, the plasmid bands were retained within the gel loading slot, independent of polymer/plasmid weight ratios or BMA monomer content. In contrast, for a series of copolymers containing 20 mol% DMAEMA, plasmid bands of complexes were retarded with increasing weight ratios. For the copolymer with 10 mol% BMA content, the plasmid was completely retained within the gel loading slot. The transfection efficiency of polymer/plasmid complexes was evaluated in COS-1 cells using a pCMV-lacZ plasmid, encoding for beta-galactosidase as a reporter gene. Transfection efficiency of a series of copolymers containing 20 mol% of DMAEMA varied with BMA content. The transfection efficiency of the copolymers with 0, 2, and 5 mol% of BMA was low. The transfection efficiency of the copolymers with 10 mol% of BMA was about 2-fold higher than that of the PDMAEMA control homopolymer. The transfected cells were observed at a very wide range of polymer/plasmid weight ratios. The transfection efficiency of all copolymers containing 60 mol% of DMAEMA was lower than that of the PDMAEMA homopolymer.

Protective copolymers for nonviral gene vectors: synthesis, vector characterization and application in gene delivery

Uncontrolled interactions of gene vectors and drug carriers in and with an in vivo environment pose serious limitations to their applicability. In order to reduce such interactions we have designed, synthesized and applied novel copolymers of poly(ethylene glycol) and reactive linkers which are derivatized with anionic peptides after copolymerization. The anionic copolymer derivatives are used to coat positively charged nonviral gene vectors by electrostatic interactions. The copolymer coat confers to polyelectrolyte colloids of DNA and polycations steric stabilization in their minimal size and prevents salt- and serum albumin-induced aggregation. Furthermore, complement activation and the interaction with serum proteins are drastically reduced or abolished in contrast to unprotected DNA complexes. The designed vectors are compatible with the intracellular steps of gene delivery and can even enhance transfection efficiency as demonstrated with various adherent and nonadherent cell lines in culture. The synthetic concept is amenable to the principles of combinatorial chemistry and the copolymeric products may be applicable beyond gene delivery in targeted drug delivery. Gene Therapy (2000) 7, 1183-1192.

Synthesis and characterisation of polyamine-poly(ethylene glycol) constructs for DNA binding and gene delivery

Improved non-viral vector systems are needed for efficient delivery of DNA to target cell nuclei in gene therapy. A series of linear polyamine poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG) constructs has been synthesised by reaction of appropriately Boc-protected thermine derivatives with omega-methoxyPEG oxiranylmethyl ethers. Constructs carrying 1-3 MeOPEG units and 0, 2 or 4 N-methyl groups have been prepared by this method. H2N(CH2)3NBoc(CH2)3NBoc(CH2)3NHBoc was prepared efficiently by mono-trifluoroacetylation of thermine, attachment of Boc and removal of the trifluoroacetyl group in one pot. A similar process gave H2N(CH2)3NBoc(CH2)3NBoc(CH2)3NH2. BocMeN(CH2)3NHMe was alkylated by 1,3-dibromopropane to give BocMeN(CH2)3NMe(CH2)3NMe(CH2)3NMeBoc. A cyanoethylation/reduction sequence extended H2N(CH2)3NBoc(CH2)3NBoc(CH2)3NH2 to give H2N(CH2)3NBoc(CH2)3NBoc(CH2)3NBoc(CH2)3NBoc(CH2) 3NH2, which was converted to its mono- and di-MeOPEG550 derivatives. Deprotection gave the linear polyamine MeOPEG constructs. A branched triamine-poly(ethylene glycol) construct was prepared by acylation of (BocHN(CH2)3)2N(CH2)3NH2 with omega-methoxyPEG 550 chloroformate, followed by deprotection. A cyanoethylation/reduction/protection sequence from (H2N(CH2)3)2 N(CH2)3NHBoc gave a protected pentamine. Alkylation with Br(CH2)5CONH(CH2)2NHBoc, deprotection, acylation with MeOPEG chloroformate and deprotection gave a pentamine MeOPEG construct in which the MeOPEG is attached through a linker to the central amine. The linear hexamine construct carrying MeOPEG550 at only one terminus was the most effective DNA-interactive member of the two series in an ethidium displacement assay and was effective in delivering a reporter gene to RIF-1 tumours.

Effects of physicochemical characteristics of poly(2-(dimethylamino)ethyl methacrylate)-based polyplexes on cellular association and internalization

The cationic polymer poly(2-(dimethylamino)ethyl methacrylate) (p(DMAEMA)) is able to efficiently bind and condense DNA and to mediate transfection of a variety of cell types. In this study, fluorescence activated cell sorting (FACS), confocal laser fluorescence microscopy (CSLM) and electron microscopy (EM) techniques were used to investigate in vitro the cellular interaction of p(DMAEMA)-based polyplexes with human ovarian carcinoma cells (OVCAR-3). Cellular association and subsequent internalization only occurred when the polyplexes exhibited a positive zeta potential. Small-sized polyplexes have an advantage over large-sized complexes regarding cellular entry. The effect of the presence of tertiary amine groups versus the presence of quatenary amine groups was evaluated by comparing p(DMAEMA) with its quaternary ammonium analogue poly(2-(trimethylamino)ethyl methacrylate) (p(TMAEMA)). The combined cellular interaction and transfection results suggest that the latter polymer does not have an intrinsic endosomal escape property, in contrast to the 'proton sponge' effect proposed for p(DMAEMA). PEGylation of p(DMAEMA) effectively shielded the surface charge and yielded a notably lower degree of cellular interaction. Data on the effects of the presence of endocytosis inhibitors and an endosome-disruptive peptide in the culture medium on the cellular interaction and transfection activity of p(DMAEMA)-based polyplexes support endocytosis as being the principal pathway for intracellular delivery of plasmid. Both the CLSM and EM studies did not reveal the presence of polyplexes or plasmid outside the endocytic vesicles or within the nucleus, suggesting that intracellular trafficking from the endosomes to the nucleus is a very inefficient process.

Physicochemical and biological characterisation of an antisense oligonucleotide targeted against the bcl-2 mRNA complexed with cationic-hydrophilic copolymers

The aim of this study was to evaluate the use of cationic-hydrophilic copolymers for self-assembly with antisense oligonucleotides targeted to the bcl-2 mRNA in order to improve their biocompatibility and modulation of their pharmacokinetics for greater therapeutic usefulness. Examination of the ability of poly(trimethylammonioethyl methacrylate chloride)-poly[N-(2-hydroxypropyl)methacrylamide] (pHPMA-b-pTMAEM) block copolymers to condense the oligonucleotide by fluorescence and electrophoresis techniques showed that complexes were formed more efficiently than with copolymers containing poly(ethylene glycol) blocks grafted onto the backbone of poly(L-lysine) (pLL-g-pEG). In addition, the copolymer pTMAEM-b-pHPMA produced oligonucleotide complexes with the most favourable physicochemical properties appropriate for in vivo applications. The complexes were small (approximately 36 nm in diameter), with low surface charge as measured by zeta potential, relatively stable to physiological salt conditions and could be formed at a DNA concentration of 500 microg/ml. Complex formation with the copolymer pTMAEM-b-pHPMA or pLL-g-pEG reduced the urinary clearance of the oligonucleotide after intravenous injection into mice. However after 30 min, the oligonucleotide complexes were cleared from the bloodstream. These results indicate that for the systemic delivery of oligonucleotides the polymer-derived complexes are not stable enough for prolonged circulation. Instead, these complexes may be more suitable for localised in vivo applications.

A potent new class of reductively activated peptide gene delivery agents

A new class of peptide gene delivery agents were developed by inserting multiple cysteine residues into short (dp 20) synthetic peptides. Substitution of one to four cysteine residues for lysine residues in Cys-Trp-Lys(18) resulted in low molecular weight DNA condensing peptides that spontaneously oxidize after binding to plasmid DNA to form interpeptide disulfide bonds. The stability of cross-linked peptide DNA condensates increased in proportion to the number of cysteines incorporated into the peptide. Disulfide bond formation led to a decrease in particle size relative to control peptide DNA condensates and prevented dissociation of peptide DNA condensates in concentrated sodium chloride. Cross-linked peptide DNA condensates were 5-60-fold more potent at mediating gene expression in HepG2 and COS 7 cells relative to uncross-linked peptide DNA condensates. The enhanced gene expression was dependent on the number of cysteine residues incorporated, with a peptide containing two cysteines mediating maximal gene expression. Cross-linking peptides caused elevated gene expression without increasing DNA uptake by cells, suggesting a mechanism involving intracellular release of DNA triggered by disulfide bond reduction. The results establish cross-linking peptides as a novel class of potent gene delivery agents that enhance gene expression through a new mechanism of action.

DNA delivery systems based on complexes of DNA with synthetic polycations and their copolymers

Block and graft copolymers of N-(2-hydroxypropyl)methacrylamide (HPMA) with 2-(trimethylammonio)ethyl methacrylate were synthesised and used for preparation of polyelectrolyte complexes with calf thymus DNA intended for targeted delivery of genes in vivo. In this study the effects of the speed of component mixing, total concentration of polymers, ionic strength of solvents, copolymer structure and content of HPMA in the copolymers on parameters of the polyelectrolyte complexes was investigated. Static and dynamic light scattering methods were used as a main tool for characterising these complexes. The presence of HPMA units in the polycation had no significant effect on its ability to form complexes with DNA, but did affect molecular parameters and aggregation (precipitation) of the complexes. The size of the complexes increases whereas their molecular weight decreases with increasing content of HPMA units. The density of the complexes decreases with increasing HPMA content independently of the copolymer structure. In order to prepare stable DNA complexes containing single DNA molecule, the following rules should be observed: (1) copolymers should have a content of HPMA units higher than 40%; (2) the DNA concentrations in solutions should be kept below 4 x 10(-5) g/ml and (3) both components should be mixed together in deionized water. The stability of the complexes against precipitation in 0.15 M NaCl and the resistance of the complexed DNA to the action of nucleases was also studied. Whereas DNA complexes of all copolymers showed very good nuclease stability, the presence of a sufficiently high content of HPMA is necessary for their good stability in 0.15 M NaCl. The investigation of the stability and the interaction of DNA complexes in aqueous solutions of serum albumin and dilute human blood serum revealed adsorption of biomacromolecules on DNA complexes accompanied by significant changes in the zeta-potential which finally resulted in formation of a "protein layer" and in undesirable precipitation of DNA complexes. In in vitro transfection experiments, the transfection efficiency of DNA complexes with copolymers was always higher than that of the cationic homopolymer slightly increasing with increasing content of HPMA in the copolymers but being about 10-100-times lower than the complexes DNA-poly(L-lysine. In the cytoplasmic injections, it was observed that DNA complexes produced greater gene expression than a direct microinjection of free DNA. The block copolymer complexes were also found to be more efficient than the corresponding simple polycation complexes. In the nuclear microinjection, precisely the opposite behaviour was observed.

Decreased binding to proteins and cells of polymeric gene delivery vectors surface modified with a multivalent hydrophilic polymer and retargeting through attachment of transferrin

Binding of serum proteins to polyelectrolyte gene delivery complexes is thought to be an important factor limiting bloodstream circulation and restricting access to target tissues. Protein binding can also inhibit transfection activity in vitro. In this study a multivalent reactive hydrophilic polymer has been used to inhibit protein binding. This polymer is based on poly-[N-(2-hydroxypropyl)methacrylamide] (pHPMA) bearing pendent oligopeptide (Gly-Phe-Leu-Gly) side chains terminated in reactive 4-nitrophenoxy groups (8.6 mol%). The polymer reacts with the primary amino groups of poly(L-lysine) (pLL) and produces a hydrophilic coating on the surface of pLL.DNA complexes (as measured by fluorescamine). The resulting pHPMA-coated complexes show a decreased surface charge (from +14 mV for pLL.DNA complexes to -25 mV for pHPMA-modified complexes) as measured by zeta potential analysis. The pHPMA-coated complexes also show a slightly increased average diameter (approximately 90 nm compared with 60 nm for pLL. DNA complexes) as viewed by atomic force and transmission electron microscopy and around 100 nm as viewed by photon correlation spectroscopy. They are completely resistant to protein interaction, as determined by turbidometry and SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis analysis of complexes isolated from plasma, and show significantly decreased nonspecific uptake into cells in vitro. Spare reactive ester groups can be used to conjugate targeting ligands (e.g. transferrin) on to the surface of the complex to provide a means of tissue-specific targeting and transfection. The properties of these complexes therefore make them promising candidates for targeted gene delivery, both in vitro and potentially in vivo.

Cationic polymer based gene delivery systems

Gene transfer to humans requires carriers for the plasmid DNA which can efficiently and safely carry the gene into the nucleus of the desired cells. A series of chemically different cationic polymers are currently being investigated for these purposes. Although many cationic polymers indeed condense DNA spontaneously, which is a requirement for gene transfer in most types of cells, the physicochemical and biopharmaceutical behavior of the current generation of polyplexes severely limits an efficient gene transfer in vitro and especially in vivo. This paper summarizes recent physicochemical and biological information on polyplexes and aims to provide new insights with respect to this type of gene delivery system. Firstly, the chemical structure of frequently studied cationic polymers is represented. Secondly, the parameters influencing condensation of DNA by cationic polymers are described. Thirdly, the surface properties, solubility, aggregration behavior, degradation and dissociation of polyplexes are considered. The review ends by describing the in vitro and in vivo gene transfection behavior of polyplexes.

Non-viral peptide-based approaches to gene delivery

To achieve effective non-viral gene therapy, the control of in vitro and in vivo stability, cellular access, intracellular trafficking and nuclear retention of plasmids must be achieved. Inefficient endosomal release, stability against cytosolic nucleases, cytoplasmic transport and nuclear entry of plasmids are amongst some of the key limiting factors in the use of plasmids for effective gene therapy. Synthetic peptide-based gene delivery systems can be designed for DNA compaction, serum stability, cell-specific targeting, endosomolysis, cytoplasmic stability and nuclear transport. The stability of compacted DNA under physiological conditions can be enhanced by the use of hydrophilic polymers, such as polyethylene glycol. The aims of this review are to (i) explore theoretical and experimental aspects of DNA compaction, (ii) describe approaches for stabilizing compacted DNA, (iii) assess techniques used for characterization of compacted DNA, and (iv) review possible use of peptides for efficient gene transfer.

Characterisation of the binding interaction between poly(L-lysine) and DNA using the fluorescamine assay in the preparation of non-viral gene delivery vectors

A major factor limiting the development of non-viral gene delivery systems is the poor characterisation of polyelectrolyte complexes formed between cationic polymers and DNA. The present study uses the fluorescamine reagent to improve characterisation of poly(L-lysine) (pLL)/DNA complexes post-modified with a multivalent hydrophilic polymer by determining the availability of free amino groups. The results show that the fluorescamine reagent can be used to monitor the self-assembly reaction between pLL and DNA and the degree of surface modification of the resultant complexes with a hydrophilic polymer. This experimental approach should enable the preparation of fully defined complexes whose properties can be better related to their biological activity.

Comparative gene transfer efficiency of low molecular weight polylysine DNA-condensing peptides

In a previous report (M.S. Wadhwa et al. (1997) Bioconjugate Chem. 8, 81-88), we synthesized a panel of polylysine-containing peptides and determined that a minimal repeating lysine chain of 18 residues followed by a tryptophan and an alkylated cysteine residue (AlkCWK18) resulted in the formation of optimal size (78 nm diameter) plasmid DNA condensates that mediated efficient in vitro gene transfer. Shorter polylysine chains produced larger DNA condensates and mediated much lower gene expression while longer lysine chains were equivalent to AlkCWK18. Surprisingly, AlkCWK18 (molecular weight 2672) was a much better gene transfer agent than commercially available low molecular weight polylysine (molecular weight 1000-4000), despite its similar molecular weight. Possible explanations were that the cysteine or tryptophan residue in AlkCWK18 contributed to the DNA binding and the formation of small condensates or that the homogeneity of AlkCWK18 relative to low molecular weight polylysine facilitated optimal condensation. To test these hypotheses, the present study prepared AlkCYK18 and K20 and used these to form DNA condensates and conduct in vitro gene transfer. The results established that DNA condensates prepared with either AlkCYK18 or K20 possessed identical particle size and mediated in vitro gene transfer efficiencies that were indistinguishable from AlkCWK18 DNA condensates, eliminating the possibility of contributions from cysteine or tryptophan. However, a detailed chromatographic and electrospray mass spectrometry analysis of low molecular weight polylysine revealed it to possess a much lower than anticipated average chain length of dp 6. Thus, the short chain length of low molecular weight polylysine explains its inability to form small DNA condensates and mediate efficient gene transfer relative to AlkCWK18 DNA condensates. These experiments further emphasize the need to develop homogenous low molecular weight carrier molecules for nonviral gene delivery.

Formulation of highly soluble poly(ethylene glycol)-peptide DNA condensates

Two poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG)-peptides were synthesized and tested for their ability to bind to plasmid DNA and form soluble DNA condensates with reduced spontaneous gene expression. PEG-vinyl sulfone or PEG-orthopyridyl disulfide were reacted with the sulfhydryl of Cys-Trp-Lys(18) (CWK(18)) resulting in the formation of nonreducible (PEG-VS-CWK(18)) and reducible (PEG-SS-CWK(18)) PEG-peptides. Both PEG-peptides were prepared on a micromole scale, purified by RP-HPLC in >80% yield, and characterized by (1)H NMR and MALDI-TOF. PEG-peptides bound to plasmid DNA with an apparent affinity that was equivalent to alkylated (Alk)CWK(18), resulting in DNA condensates with a mean diameter of 80-90 nm and zeta (zeta) potential of +10 mV. The particle size of PEG-peptide DNA condensates was constant throughout the DNA concentration range of 0. 05-2 mg/mL, indicating these to be approximately 20-fold more soluble than AlkCWK(18) DNA condensates. The spontaneous gene transfer to HepG2 cells mediated by PEG-VS-CWK(18) DNA condensates was over two orders of magnitude lower than PEG-SS-CWK(18) DNA condensates and three orders of magnitude lower than AlkCWK(18) DNA condensates. PEG-VS-CWK(18) efficiently blocked in vitro gene transfer by reducing cell uptake. The results indicate that a high loading density of PEG on DNA is necessary to achieve highly soluble DNA condensates that reduce spontaneous in vitro gene transfer by blocking nonspecific uptake by HepG2 cells. These two properties are important for developing targeted gene delivery systems to be used in vivo.

Thermosensitive polymers as carriers for DNA delivery

Copolymers of 2-(dimethylamino) ethyl methacrylate (DMAEMA) and N-isopropylacryl amide (NIPAAm) of various monomer ratios and molecular weights were evaluated as carrier systems for DNA delivery. All copolymers, even with a low DMAEMA content of 15 mol%, were able to bind to DNA at 25 degrees C. Light-scattering measurements indicate that complexation is accompanied by precipitation of the (co)polymer in the complex caused by a drop of the lower critical solution temperature of the (co)polymer. The (co)polymer/plasmid ratio at which complexes with a size of around 200 nm were formed increased with increasing NIPAAm content of the copolymer and was independent of molecular weight of the (co)polymer. However, complexes containing (co)polymers of low molecular weight or high NIPAAm content prepared at 25 degrees C aggregated rapidly when the temperature was raised to 37 degrees C, whereas complexes containing (co)polymers of high molecular weight or lower NIPAAm content were relatively stable at 37 degrees C. The zeta potential of the complexes was also independent of molecular weight of the (co)polymer and increased with increasing (co)polymer/plasmid ratio until a plateau value was reached. The (co)polymer/plasmid ratio at which this plateau was reached increased with increasing NIPAAm content. The plateau values decreased from around 26 mV to around 13 mV when the NIPAAm content of the copolymer was increased from 0 to 85 mol%. The cytotoxicity of the complexes strongly decreased with increasing NIPAAm content and was independent of molecular weight of the (co)polymer. The transfection efficiency of complexes with poor stability was in general much lower than that of complexes with good stability. The transfection efficiency as a function of the (co)polymer/plasmid ratio showed a bell-shaped curve. The (co)polymer/plasmid ratio at which the transfection efficiency was maximal increased with increasing NIPAAm content, while the maximum transfection efficiency strongly decreased with increasing NIPAAm content of the copolymer. The results of this study show that the formation of stable (co)polymer/plasmid complexes with a size of around 200 nm is a prerequisite for efficient transfection. Furthermore, the transfection efficiency and cytotoxicity strongly decreased with decreasing zeta potential. Therefore, besides the size, the zeta potential can also be used as a characteristic to predict the behavior of this type of (co)polymer/plasmid complexes in transfection. Copolymers of DMAEMA and NIPAAm provided with a homing device may be interesting carrier systems for gene targeting because these copolymers can condense DNA to small particles, and the resulting complexes show a low cytotoxicity and aspecific transfection.

DNA complexes with block and graft copolymers of N-(2-hydroxypropyl)methacrylamide and 2-(trimethylammonio)ethyl methacrylate

Block and graft copolymers of N-(2-hydroxypropyl)methacrylamide (HPMA) with 2-(trimethylammonio)ethyl methacrylate (TMAEM) were synthesized for the preparation of polyelectrolyte complexes with calf thymus DNA intended for targeted delivery of genes in vivo. In this study, the effects of the poly(HPMA) content of copolymers on the parameters of the interpolyelectrolyte complexes is investigated. Static and dynamic light scattering methods were used as a main tool for characterization. The ability of the copolymers to condense DNA was studied by the ethidium bromide displacement method. The stability of the complexes against precipitation in 0.15 M NaCl and the resistance of the complexed DNA to the action of nucleases was also studied. It was found that the presence of poly(HPMA) in the copolymers has not significantly affected the ability of poly(TMAEM) parts of the copolymers to form complexes with DNA, but has an effect on molecular parameters and aggregation (precipitation) of the complexes. The size of the complexes increases with increasing poly(HPMA) content while their apparent molecular weight decreases. The complex stability against precipitation in 0.15 M NaCl strongly depends on the amount of poly(HPMA) in the copolymer structure. The presence of a sufficiently high content of poly(HPMA) is a prerequisite for achieving good stability. The structure of the complexes changes with increasing poly(HPMA) content from soft balls to the polymer coil. The density of the complexes decreases with increasing poly(HPMA) content independently of the copolymer structure. The DNA complexes of all copolymers showed very good nuclease stability.

Transfection and physical properties of various saccharide, poly(ethylene glycol), and antibody-derivatized polyethylenimines (PEI)

BACKGROUND

The ideal non-viral vector should be cell-type directed and form complexes with DNA that are physically stable, small and electrically neutral.

METHODS

We have synthesized several PEI derivatives that coat the PEI/DNA complexes with water-soluble residues able to stabilize the particles, to mask their surface charge and eventually to direct them to a particular tissue. The morphologies and sizes of the complexes were observed by TEM and DLS techniques, and their apparent surface charge was quantitated by zeta potential measurements; in vitro transfection efficacies were determined in serum-containing cell culture medium.

RESULTS

When compared to DNA complexes formed with the unmodified PEI, extensive grafting with maltose (15-25% of the amine functions) led to beneficial electrostatic shielding of the particle surface, but was unable to prevent aggregation in physiological salt concentration. More extended hydrophilic residues were therefore explored as a mean of physical repulsion between the particles. Low grafting (2.7%) with a linear dextran non-asaccharide led to small and stable toroids having no apparent surface charge, yet still reaching effective transfection levels. Electron microscopy of complexes with a higher extent of grafting showed worm-like structures unsuited for cell entry. Conjugation of PEI with as little as 0.5% of a terminally galactose-derivatized polyethyleneglycol (PEG)-3400 also gave neutral complexes of another worm-like structure that failed to transfect receptor-expressing hepatocytes.

CONCLUSION

These results show that conjugation of large and flexible hydrophilic residues to PEI, while protecting the complexes from parasitic interactions also interfere with DNA condensation. PEG conjugation after PEI/DNA complex formation may avoid this problem, provided intracomplex reorganization is slow. Finally an anti-GD2 antibody (mAb) grafted with PEI was synthesized. The corresponding protein-coated DNA complexes were compact and small (50-60 nm), yet did not enhance transfection of GD2 ganglioside-expressing cells.

Stabilization of poly-L-lysine/DNA polyplexes for in vivo gene delivery to the liver

We are developing a self-assembling non-viral in vivo gene delivery vehicle based on poly-l-lysine and plasmid DNA. We have characterized poly-l-lysines of different chain lengths for DNA condensation and strength of DNA binding. Poly-l-lysine chains >20 residues bound DNA efficiently in physiological saline, while shorter chains did not. Attachment of asialoorosomucoid to PLL increased the PLL chain length required for efficient DNA binding in saline and for efficient DNA condensation. By electron microscopy, poly-l-lysine/DNA polyplexes appeared as toroids 25-50 nm in diameter or rods 40-80 nm long; conjugation of asialoorosomucoid to the polylysine component increased the size of resulting polyplexes to 50-90 nm. In water, poly-l-lysine and asialoorosomucoid-PLL polyplexes have effective diameters of 46 and 87.6 nm, respectively. Polyplexes containing only poly-l-lysine and DNA aggregated in physiological saline at all charge ratios and aggregated at neutral charge ratios in water. Attachment of asialoorosomucoid lessened, but did not eliminate, the aggregation of PLL polyplexes, and did not result in efficient delivery of polyplexes to hepatocytes. Conjugation of polyethylene glycol to poly-l-lysine sterically stabilized resulting polyplexes at neutral charge ratios by shielding the surfaces. For efficient in vivo gene delivery, polyplexes will need to be sterically stabilized to prevent aggregation and interaction with serum components.