Single-donor platelets reduce the risk of septic platelet transfusion reactions

Bacterial Contamination of Blood Components: Risks, Strategies, and Regulation

Bacterial contamination of transfusion products, especially platelets, is a longstanding problem that has been partially controlled through modern phlebotomy practices, refrigeration of red cells, freezing of plasma and improved materials for transfusion product collection and storage. Bacterial contamination of platelet products has been acknowledged as the most frequent infectious risk from transfusion occurring in approximately 1 of 2,000–3,000 whole-blood derived, random donor platelets, and apheresis-derived, single donor platelets. In the US, bacterial contamination is considered the second most common cause of death overall from transfusion (after clerical errors) with mortality rates ranging from 1:20,000 to 1:85,000 donor exposures. Estimates of severe morbidity and mortality range from 100 to 150 transfused individuals each year.

Concern over the magnitude and clinical relevance of this issue culminated in an open letter calling for the “blood collection community to immediately initiate a program for detecting the presence of bacteria in units of platelets.” Thereafter, the American Association of Blood Banks (AABB) proposed new standards to help mitigate transfusion of units that were contaminated with bacteria. Adopted with a final implementation date of March 1, 2004, the AABB Standard reads “The blood bank or transfusion service shall have methods to limit and detect bacterial contamination in all platelet components.”

This Joint ASH and AABB Educational Session reviews the risks, testing strategies, and regulatory approaches regarding bacterial contamination of blood components to aid in preparing practitioners of hematology and transfusion medicine in understanding the background and clinical relevance of this clinically important issue and in considering the approaches currently available for its mitigation, as well as their implementation.

In this chapter, Drs. Hillyer and Josephson review the background and significance of bacterial contamination, as well as address the definitions, conceptions and limitations of the terms risk, safe and safety. They then describe current transfusion risks including non-infectious serious hazards of transfusion, and current and emerging viral risks. In the body of the text, Dr. Blajchman reviews the prevalence of bacterial contamination in cellular blood components in detail with current references to a variety of important studies. He then describes the signs and symptoms of transfusion-associated sepsis and the sources of the bacterial contamination for cellular blood products including donor bacteremia, and contamination during whole blood collection and of the collection pack. This is followed by strategies to decrease the transfusion-associated morbidity/mortality risk of contaminated cellular blood products including improving donor skin disinfection, removal of first aliquot of donor blood, pre-transfusion detection of bacteria, reducing recipient exposure, and pathogen reduction/inactivation. In the final sections, Drs. Vostal, Epstein and Goodman describe the regulations and regulatory approaches critical to the appropriate implementation of a bacterial contamination screening and limitation program including their and/or the FDA’s input on prevention of bacterial contamination, bacterial proliferation, and detection of bacteria in transfusion products. This is followed by a discussion of sampling strategy for detection of bacteria in a transfusion product, as well as the current approval process for bacterial detection devices, trials recommended under “actual clinical use” conditions, pathogen reduction technologies, and bacterial detection and the extension of platelet storage.

Transfusion medicine for the pediatrician

In the next decade, many of the methodologies and research reviewed in this article will become clinical practice, making the transfusion of blood products safer and more universally available than they are today. NAT will be standard and will surely be performed on each unit of product, PCR testing for pathogens will evolve, and the pathophysiology and immunology of transfusion-related events such as TRALI and immunomodulation will be elucidated. New methods of preservation and early detection of contamination will extend the life of blood products. Red blood cell antigens may be attenuated, making safe products available to more patients. Clinical vigilance at the bedside and in the blood bank will remain key areas for transfusion safety. As I have told many a resident and patient, blood is not saline; there are and will remain risks inherent in this commonly used medical therapy.

Making risk statements stick

Estimates of risk associated with blood transfusion are reported from a variety of sources using different numerical constructs. These data must be judged for validity and generalizability to facilitate decisions for interventions and to estimate potential benefits of interventions. Risk estimates reported in consistent terms, such as occurrences per million units transfused, will assist in comparisons of risks and the expected effect observed at the practitioner level. Use of the estimated number needed to treat puts the effect of an intervention in perspective for the individual practitioner and for national health authorities. We re-evaluated data reported from several recent studies of transfusion risk to highlight this approach. In the USA, the number needed to treat estimated to prevent one HIV transmission is 4.3 million (mini-pool NAT); to prevent one death from bacterial sepsis is 21 thousand (conversion to single donor platelets), and 16 thousand (bacterial screening of platelet concentrates). As interventions are continuing to drive infectious disease transmission rates lower and lower, expressing residual risk as the number needed to treat demonstrates that further improvements in safety are unlikely to be recognized at the local level even though the overall impact at the national level is significant.

Pharmaco-economics of blood transfusion safety: review of the available evidence

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Pharmaco-economics provides a standardized methodology for valid comparisons of interventions in different fields of health care. The role of pharmaco-economics in the safety of blood and blood products has, however, been very limited to date. This review discusses the pharmaco-economic evaluations of strategies to enhance blood product safety that have been published in the scientific literature.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We reviewed pharmaco-economic methodology with special reference to cost-effectiveness analysis. We searched the literature for cost-effectiveness in blood product safety.

RESULT

Net costs per quality adjusted life-year (QALY) gained varied from cost-saving for human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)- and hepatitis C virus (HCV) antibody screening and leucoreduction to several million US dollars per QALY gained for solvent-detergent treatment of plasma, nucleic acid amplification testing and HIV p24 antigen testing.

CONCLUSIONS

To date the safety of blood transfusion has been largely determined by available technology, irrespective of pharmaco-economics. Net costs up to several million US dollars per QALY gained were found for interventions implemented.

Pathogen inactivation of blood components: current status and introduction of an approach using riboflavin as a photosensitizer

Riboflavin is a naturally occurring compound and an essential human nutrient. Studies in the 1960s and 70s showed that it could be effective, when exposed to visible or UV light, in inactivating viruses and bacteria. This suggested to us that it could act as a photosensitizer useful in the inactivation of pathogens found in blood products, because of its nucleic acid specificity and its limited tendency toward indiscriminate oxidation. The riboflavin molecule is a planar, conjugated ring structure with a sugar side chain that confers water solubility. The planar portion is capable of intercalating between the bases of DNA or RNA. Light activated riboflavin oxidizes guanine in nucleic acids, preventing replication of the pathogen's genome. Gambro BCT is developing processes using riboflavin and light to inactivate pathogens in plasma, platelet, and red cell products. We call these Pathogen Eradication Technology (PET) processes. Riboflavin is non-toxic; it must be present in the body for good health. The photo-byproducts formed in the PET processes are lumichrome and protein adducts. The photodegradation of riboflavin in the body is clearly shown by the decrease in its concentration in neonates who are treated with intense visible light to break down circulating bilirubin, which their immature livers cannot yet handle. A definitive lookback study showed no difference in cancer rates between the 55,000 children receiving this therapy in Denmark from 1977 through 1989 and nonirradiated controls. Gambro BCT is developing specific riboflavin-based PET processes for platelet concentrates, fresh frozen plasma, and packed red blood cells. In each, the process is being optimized to achieve high levels of inactivation of specific pathogens, while maintaining acceptable levels of product quality and activity. Extra- and intracellular HIV, BVDV (a model for HCV), and pseudorabies virus (a herpes virus) have been used to guide process development and validation. We have demonstrated 4 to 7 log10 reductions in the titers of these viruses, when they are spiked into blood products and irradiated in the presence of riboflavin. Porcine parvovirus, a tight-capsid, nonenveloped virus is more resistant, a finding in all experimental inactivation approaches. A range of bacteria implicated in platelet and red cell transfusion injuries and deaths, including S. aureus, E. coli, K. pneumoniae, and Y. enterocolitica, are being used to validate antibacterial efficacy. The PET platelet process involves the addition of riboflavin to platelets in plasma, illumination of the product, storage of the product and transfusion without further manipulation. The lack of toxicity of the treatment byproducts permits this ease of use. Quality of the platelets throughout storage has been assessed by pH, PO2, lactate, hypotonic shock response, morphology, glucose, and GMP-140 expression. In vitro function is well maintained. The levels seen are within the range of those reported in commonly transfused products. Radiolabeled transfusion studies of treated platelets have been carried out in primates to determine a preliminary measure of their in-vivo circulation. The in vivo recoveries and survivals of treated and control platelets did not differ. This work suggests that an endogenous photosensitizer, riboflavin, which has an extremely good safety profile, can inactivate high levels of a broad range of viruses and bacteria in platelet concentrates, fresh frozen plasma, and in red blood cells, preserving the activity and functionality of the components. Planned animal and clinical studies are expected to solidify this suggestion into a well-characterized process which can be safely and readily applied to reduce the risks of transfusion transmitted disease.

Seven-day storage of single-donor platelets: recovery and survival in an autologous transfusion study

BACKGROUND

Bacterial screening may effectively reduce the morbidity and mortality risk associated with extended storage of platelets. Platelet viability then becomes the primary determinant of acceptable storage time. This study evaluates the effectiveness of platelets stored in plasma for 7 days.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

WBC-reduced, single-donor platelets (n = 24) were collected and stored by standard methods at two sites. Standard in vitro platelet biochemical and functional parameters were monitored over the storage period. On Days 5 and 7 of storage, platelets were alternately labeled with 51Cr and (111)In and returned to the subject, and recovery and survival were determined.

RESULTS

Component pH(22 degrees C) was maintained in the range 6.2 to 7.61 through 7 days and did not detrimentally affect either in vitro or in vivo outcomes. In vitro platelet characteristics were adequately maintained over 7 days. Day 5 platelets had better recovery (63.0 +/- 4.36 vs. 53.9 +/- 4.36%, p < 0.0001) and survival (161 +/- 8.1 vs. 133 +/- 8.1 hr, p = 0.006) than Day 7 platelets adjusting for radioisotope, center, and donor effects.

CONCLUSION

Although declines in recovery and survival were noted, these are less than used previously to gain licensure of 7-day storage and are unlikely to be clinically significant. Extension of storage to 7 days could be implemented with bacterial screening methods to select out contaminated components without a significant effect on the platelet efficacy compared to 5-day components.

Experience with universal bacterial culturing to detect contamination of apheresis platelet units in a hospital transfusion service

BACKGROUND

Bacterial contamination of platelet units poses one of the greatest risks of morbidity and mortality to platelet transfusion recipients. A routine culture of all units (WBC-reduced apheresis platelet units) was instituted on Day 2 over a 2-year period to reduce this risk.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

A sterile connecting device was used to attach a small transfer pack on the morning of Day 2 after collection, and 10 mL of the unit were transferred to the small bag. After disconnection from the unit, about half of this volume was transferred to an aerobic culture bottle of an automated bacterial detection system. Units were maintained in available inventory until and unless a report was received of growth in the sample. When available, the unit or a retained aliquot was recultured if the initial sample was positive. Units were held up to 2 days beyond their 5-day outdate and used for transfusion if no other suitable units were available to meet the clinical need or were evaluated with in vitro testing on Day 8.

RESULTS

Of 2678 units cultured, 16 (0.6%) were positive on initial culture. Thirteen could be recultured, and all of these samples were negative. Shortly after the 2-year period of the study, two units (split from the same collection) were documented as growing coagulase-negative Staphylococci 12 hours after sampling. Units transfused on Day 6 or 7 (n = 40) yielded expected clinical responses, and CCI available on 21 cipients 10 to 60 minutes after transfusion demonstrated acceptable results (mean, 14,400 +/- 8800; median, 12,191; 90% > 7500). More than 96 percent of units tested on Day 8 had pH greater than 6.2 and continued to demonstrate swirling.

CONCLUSIONS

Routine culturing of apheresis platelet units is feasible, can be accomplished with a low rate of false positivity, and can detect contaminated units. The cost of such a protocol could be mitigated with extension of the storage period, and clinical experience with units held for 6 or 7 days was satisfactory.

Bacterial contamination of blood products: factors, options, and insights

Transfusion of bacterially contaminated blood products remains an overlooked problem. However, the risk of receiving a bacterially contaminated unit is greater than the combined risk of HIV-1/2, HCV, HBV, and HTLV I/II [American Association of Blood Banks Bulletin, no. 294, 1996]. Topics covered in this article include: the current incidence, clinical presentation and outcome, effective methods of detection, and ways to reduce bacterial contamination of blood products. There is no one existing strategy that can completely eliminate the risk of bacterial contamination. It is inevitable that partial solutions or combinations of methods will be implemented in the near future.

Coagulation management in trauma patients

Hemorrhage after traumatic injury results in coagulopathy which only worsens the situation. This coagulopathy is caused by depletion and dilution of clotting factors and platelets, increased fibrinolytic activity, hypothermia, metabolic changes and anemia. The effect of synthetic colloids in compensating the blood loss further aggravates the situation. Bedside coagulation monitoring permits relevant impairment of the coagulation system to be detected very early and the efficacy of the hemostatic therapy to be controlled directly. Administration of fresh frozen plasma, platelet concentrations, clotting factors and probably antifibrinolytic agents is essential in restoring the impaired coagulation system in trauma patients.

Emerging infectious agents: do they pose a risk to the safety of transfused blood and blood products?

The blood supply is safer than it has been at any other time in recent history, and, in the context of other health care-related adverse events, the risks associated with blood transfusion are extremely small. The current high level of safety is the result of successive refinements and improvements in how blood is collected, tested, processed, and transfused; nonetheless, blood and plasma products remain vulnerable to newly identified or reemerging infections. In recent years, numerous infectious agents-including several newly discovered hepatitis viruses, the agents of transmissible spongiform encephalopathies, and tickborne pathogens-have been identified as potential threats to the safety of blood and plasma. Continued vigilance is critical to protect the blood supply from known pathogens and to monitor for the emergence of new infectious agents. Recent terrorist activities in the United States add new considerations to maintaining the safety and supply of blood. Education of clinicians and patients regarding the benefits and risks associated with the judicious use of blood and blood products can assist in informed decision making.

Targeted approaches for the treatment of thrombocytopenia

Molecular targeting of novel therapies has the promise of inducing very specific biologic effects. In clinical hematology and oncology, molecular targeting of specific cell surface receptors with erythropoietin, G-CSF, or GM-CSF has been used to stimulate erythropoiesis and granulopoiesis, respectively. Although anemia and neutropenia can be corrected with targeted therapy, safe and effective treatment of thrombocytopenia remains an unmet medical need. While platelet transfusions still represent the standard of care for severe thrombocytopenia, there are several negative aspects associated with their use, including issues of availability, transient effectiveness, costs, adverse effects, negative perception by patients, and infection considerations. Despite extensive investigations of cytokines which act primarily on primitive levels of hematopoiesis, pharmacologic interventions to date have failed to elevate platelet counts in a reliable, highly effective, and well-tolerated fashion. Recombinant human interleukin-11 has been approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration for the treatment of chemotherapy-induced thrombocytopenia but has only modest efficacy and significant side effects. The identification of c-Mpl as the thrombopoietin receptor has opened new avenues for the therapeutic manipulation of thrombopoiesis. The development of specific c-Mpl ligands, including recombinant human thrombopoietin (rHuTPO), has allowed investigators to target this receptor for the treatment of chemotherapy-induced thrombocytopenia and other medical disorders characterized by extremely low platelet counts. As a potent stimulator of platelet production, rHuTPO has the potential to reduce the need for platelet transfusions and their attendant complications.

Rational use of blood products

Blood product transfusions can be life saving and must be considered in the supportive care of children of any age with underlying oncological or haematological problems, as well as after major surgery or after serious trauma. Paediatric transfusions are particularly challenging because life-long effects of transfusion complications are more durable and serious in children than in adults, in whom the median age at transfusion is >70 years (Tynell E, Norda R, Shanwell A, Björkman A. Long-term survival in transfusion recipients in Sweden, 1993. Transfusion 2001, 41, 251-255). While the general indications for transfusions in paediatric patients are similar to adults, the threshold, volumes and infusion rates for transfusions vary with age. In this Update, we discuss current blood products, then suggest transfusion "triggers" in major surgery and haematological and oncologic practice. Finally, future developments and new possibilities are considered.

Transfusion-transmitted bacterial infection in the United States, 1998 through 2000

BACKGROUND

Bacterial contamination of blood components can result in transfusion-transmitted infection, but the risk is not established.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

Suspected cases of transfusion-transmitted bacteremia were reported to the CDC by participating blood collection facilities and transfusion services affiliated with the American Red Cross, AABB, or Department of Defense blood programs from 1998 through 2000. A case was defined as any transfusion reaction meeting clinical criteria in which the same organism species was cultured from a blood component and from recipient blood, with the organism pair confirmed as identical by molecular typing.

RESULTS

There were 34 cases and 9 deaths. The rate of transfusion-transmitted bacteremia (in events/million units) was 9.98 for single-donor platelets, 10.64 for pooled platelets, and 0.21 for RBC units; for fatal reactions, the rates were 1.94, 2.22, and 0.13, respectively. Patients at greatest risk for death received components containing gram-negative organisms (OR, 7.5; 95% CI, 1.3-64.2; p = 0.009).

CONCLUSION

Bacterial contamination of blood is an important cause of transfusion-transmitted infection; infection risk from platelet transfusion is higher compared with that from RBCs, and, overall, the risk of infection from bacterial contamination now may exceed that from viral agents. Recipients of components containing gram-negative organisms are at highest risk for transfusion-related death. The results of this study may help direct efforts to improve transfusion-related patient safety.

Bacterial contamination of platelet concentrates: incidence, significance, and prevention

Severe transfusion reactions associated with bacteria and/or their products, during or following a blood transfusion, were one of the earliest recognized complications of allogeneic blood transfusions. Bacterial contamination of blood products has thus been a problem for many decades and at present is likely the most common microbiological cause of transfusion-associated morbidity and mortality. Transfusion-associated sepsis due to contaminated platelet concentrates appears to be much more common than that due to contaminated red blood cells. The overall incidence of contaminated cellular blood products is approximately 1 in 3,000. However, transfusion to a recipient of a contaminated platelet unit may not necessarily be associated with clinically apparent morbidity, because the majority of contaminated platelet units contain relatively few organisms. In a minority of instances, contaminated units contain large numbers of potentially virulent bacteria, as well as endotoxins, and their transfusion is often associated with significant recipient morbidity and mortality. The incidence of severe septic episodes has not been clearly established, but is probably of the order of 1 per 50,000 platelet units transfused. With heightened awareness in recent years of the possibility that platelet transfusion-associated septic episodes can occur, a variety of measures have been proposed, and in some cases implemented, to try to prevent and control this transfusion risk.