Self-reported giving-way episode during a stepping-down task: case report of a subject with an ACL-deficient knee

STUDY DESIGN

Case report.

OBJECTIVE

To describe the knee kinematics and moments of a giving-way trial of a subject with an anterior-cruciate-ligament- (ACL) deficient knee relative to his non-giving-way trials and to healthy subjects during a step-down task.

BACKGROUND

Episodes of giving way are believed to damage joint structures, therefore treatments aim to prevent giving-way episodes, yet few studies document giving-way events.

METHODS

The giving-way trial experienced by a 32-year-old male subject with ACL deficiency during a step-down task was compared to his non-giving-way trials (n = 5) and data from healthy subjects (n = 20). Position data collected at 60 Hz were combined with anthropometric data and ground reaction force data collected at 300 Hz to estimate knee displacement and 3-dimensional angles and net joint moments.

RESULTS

The knee joint displacement was higher during the giving-way trial: from 4% to 32% of stance, reaching 9.0 mm at 18% of stance as compared to 1.6 +/- 0.7 mm for the non-giving-way trials. After 4% of stance, the knee flexion angle of the giving-way trial was 6.6 degrees higher than the non-giving-way trials and was associated with a higher knee extension moment. The knee frontal plane moment was near neutral during early stance of the giving-way trial in contrast to the non-giving way and healthy subjects which demonstrated a knee abduction moment.

CONCLUSIONS

The response of this subject to the giving-way event suggests that higher knee flexion angles may enhance knee stability and, in reaction to the giving-way event, that knee extension moment may increase.

The effects of proprioceptive or strength training on the neuromuscular function of the ACL reconstructed knee: a randomized clinical trial

OBJECTIVES

The purpose of this study was to determine the effects of a proprioceptive training program (PT) vs. a strength training (ST) program on neuromuscular function after anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction. The second purpose was to establish the determinants of functional ability for the operated limb.

METHODS

Ten participants with unilateral ACL reconstructions were randomly assigned to one of the following 12-week training protocols: (1) isotonic ST, and (2) PT. The outcome measures were: (1) peak torque time of the hamstring muscles (PeakTT), (2) average concentric and eccentric torques of the quadriceps and hamstring muscles, (3) one-legged single hop for distance (SLHD), (4) one-legged time hop (TH), and (5) subjective scores.

RESULTS

: There was a significant group by time interaction effect for PeakTT (P = 0.017). The PT group demonstrated greater percent change in isokinetic torques than the ST group at the end of the 12 weeks (P < or = 0.05). Participants in both groups demonstrated similar significant gains in functional ability and subjective scores (P < or = 0.014). Quadriceps strength is a determinant of functional ability for the operated limb (R2 = 0.72).

CONCLUSIONS

: Both training protocols influenced PeakTT. The beneficial effects of ST on PeakTT appear to be load-dependent, while sufficient practice may be crucial in maintaining PeakTT improvements induced by PT. Proprioceptive training alone can induce isokinetic strength gains. Restoring and increasing quadriceps strength is essential to maximize functional ability of the operated knee joint.

Recent advances in the rehabilitation of isolated and combined anterior cruciate ligament injuries

The rehabilitation process begins immediately following ACL injury, with emphasis on reducing swelling and inflammation; improving motion; regaining quadriceps control; allowing immediate weight-bearing; and restoring full passive knee extension and, gradually, flexion. The goal of preoperative rehabilitation is to prepare the patient mentally and physically for surgery. Once the ACL surgery is performed, it is important to alter the rehab program based on the type of graft used and any concomitant procedures performed. This will aid in preventing several postoperative complications, such as loss of motion, patellofemoral pain, graft failure, and muscular weakness. The goal of this article has been to provide an overview of the application and the scientific basis for formulating a rehabilitation protocol following ACL surgery. For an athlete to return to competition, it is imperative that he or she regain muscular strength and neuromuscular control in their injured leg while maintaining static stability. In the past, rehabilitation programs attempted to prepare the athlete for return to sports by using resistance exercise alone. Current rehabilitation programs focus not only on strengthening exercises, but also on proprioceptive and neuromuscular control drills in order to provide a neurologic stimulus so that the athlete can regain the dynamic stability needed in athletic competition. We believe that it is important to use this approach not only possible causes that might predispose the individual to future injury.

Development of dynamic knee stability after acute ACL injury

Recently, a training program that includes perturbation of support surfaces has been shown to allow most active individuals with ACL injury who pass a screening examination to successfully return to high level activities. The purpose of this study was to identify the effect of this rehabilitation program on involved side muscle activation during walking in subjects with acute ACL rupture and to determine if the activation changes were coincident with improved function. Nine subjects with an acute, unilateral ACL injury or rupture of an ACL graft, who met the screening examination criteria, received ten sessions of rehabilitation that included perturbation training. Motion analysis of five self-paced walking trials were performed before and after training. Electromyographic (EMG) data were collected during stance. After training during walking, the vastus lateralis (VL) integral of activity increased, and relationships between muscles were significantly altered. During walking, VL activation variables were dependent on lateral hamstrings (LH) and/or the soleus (SOL) activation, while no relationships were found before training. Function improved after training, and all subjects returned to their pre-injury activities without experiencing instability. The relationships formed between muscles post-training suggests that perturbation training enhances dynamic knee stability by inducing a well-coordinated strategy among muscles that affect tibial translation.

Consequences of a ligament injury on neuromuscular function and relevance to rehabilitation - using the anterior cruciate ligament-injured knee as model

The purpose of this article is to survey current knowledge concerning the consequences of a ligament injury on neuromuscular function and its relevance to rehabilitation, in relation to clinical practice. Although it deals with the ACL-injured knee, these views may also apply to other joints. The effects of a ligament injury on neuromuscular function are first considered - i.e., proprioception, postural control, muscle strength, functional performance, movement and activation pattern, central mechanisms, motor control and learning. The treatment and effects of rehabilitation on neuromuscular function are then discussed. The survey is concluded by discussing the clinical significance.

Design and implementation of a neuromuscular training program following anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

Neuromuscular training programs are increasingly integrated into clinical practice for lower extremity rehabilitation. A few rehabilitation programs have been evaluated for patients with anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) deficiency and for injury prevention, but there is limited scientific evidence of the effect of neuromuscular training following ACL reconstruction. Therefore, a neuromuscular training program was developed for patients after ACL reconstruction. The objective of the neuromuscular training was to improve the ability to generate a fast and optimal muscle firing pattern, to increase dynamic joint stability, and to relearn movement patterns and skills necessary during activities of daily living and sports activities. The main areas considered when designing the postoperative rehabilitation program after ACL reconstruction were: ACL graft healing and ACL strain values during exercises, proprioception and neuromuscular control, and clinical studies on the effect of neuromuscular training programs. The rehabilitation program consists of balance exercises, dynamic joint stability exercises, jump training/plyometric exercises, agility drills, and sport-specific exercise. The patients exercise 3 times a week for 6 months. The scientific and clinical evidence for the rehabilitation program are described and the main exercises in the program are outlined.

Influence of supervised and nonsupervised training on postural control after an acute anterior cruciate ligament rupture: a three-year longitudinal prospective study

STUDY DESIGN

Prospective randomized longitudinal clinical trial with matched controls.

OBJECTIVES

To investigate the long-term effect of training on postural control and extremity function after an acute anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injury.

BACKGROUND

ACL injuries may cause severe problems with recurrent giving way of the knee and reduced functional capacity. The effect of an acute ACL injury and the effect of various training programs on postural control, as well as the relation between postural control and extremity function after such an injury, have not been studied longitudinally.

METHODS

Sixty-three consecutive patients, 35 men and 28 women (median age 24 years, quartiles 19-33 years), with an acute nonoperated ACL injury, randomized to neuromuscular supervised or self-monitored training, were examined with stabilometry (amplitude and average speed of center of pressure movements) and a one-leg hop test for distance after 6 weeks (stabilometry only), and after 3, 12, and 36 months, and were compared to a control group.

RESULTS

Regardless of treatment, center of pressure amplitude was persistently higher in both the injured and uninjured legs during the 3-year follow-up, but average speed was less affected or unaffected compared to the control group. The one-leg hop had normalized in the neuromuscular group at the 12-month follow-up, but was shorter in both legs throughout the 3-year period in the self-monitored group. The median value (quartiles) for injured/uninjured legs at 3 months was 150 cm (120-174 cm)/177 cm (140-199 cm), at 12 months was 174 cm (140-200 cm)/180 cm (150-202 cm), and at 36 months was 172 cm (146-200 cm)/178 cm (150-200 cm) in the self-monitored group, compared to the control group (median 186 cm, quartiles 177-216 cm).

CONCLUSIONS

The higher center of pressure amplitude in both legs over the 3-year period indicate persistently impaired postural control in single-limb stance. However, functional performance, as measured with the one-leg hop test, was restored by neuromuscular training, but not by self-monitored training.

Rationale for training programs to reduce anterior cruciate ligament injuries in Australian football

This commentary presents the rationale for training programs to reduce the incidence of knee injuries. Our studies have revealed that the external knee loading patterns during sidestep cutting are what put the anterior cruciate ligament at greatest risk for injury. Compared to running, sidestep cutting involves similar levels of knee flexion loading but increased loading in varus-valgus and internal rotation of the knee, and these external loads need to be stabilized or supported by the internal structures of the knee. People use a generalized hamstrings and quadriceps co-contraction to stabilize these external loads, thereby reducing ligament loading. It is proposed that perturbation of the joint receptors reinforces the use of selective hamstrings and quadriceps co-contraction patterns superimposed on a generalized co-contraction pattern. This is not by immediate ligamento-muscular protective reflex, which is too slow to provide any adequate support, but by enhanced proprioceptive information that may be used in learning. In contrast, the immediate effect of muscle stretch reflexes would be to reduce co-contraction, a possibly negative outcome for joint stabilization. The effects of different types of training on the control of joint stability are examined. It is proposed that resistance training may not be appropriate because it enhances muscle stretch reflexes, which may reduce co-contraction, and produces no reductions in voluntary activation times and time to peak torque. However, stability and balance training is thought to suppress muscle stretch reflexes and, in turn, enhance co-contraction. Also, stability and balance training that stimulates the knee joint ligament and capsular receptors may reinforce co-contraction patterns to facilitate greater improvements in joint stabilization. Stability and balance training and plyometric training produce reductions in voluntary activation times and times to peak torque, which may decrease muscle response times so players are more able to perform rapid and unexpected sports maneuvers. Training programs that emphasize these neuromuscular mechanisms may enhance protection of the anterior cruciate ligament and reduce the incidence of injury.

A history of low back injury is a risk factor for recurrent back injuries in varsity athletes

In this prospective study, we investigated whether a history of previous low back injury and dissatisfaction with a coach and teammates could predict future low back injury in varsity athletes during a 1-year follow-up period. Of 679 Yale varsity athletes surveyed in 1999, 18.3% (124) reported that they had sustained a low back injury within the past 5 years, and 6.8% (46) sustained a low back injury in the follow-up season. There were no differences in incidence rates between men and women or between athletes involved in contact or noncontact sports. A history of low back injury was the significant predictor for sustaining low back injury in the following year, and athletes who reported previous low back injury were at three times greater risk. Athletes who still had pain at the time of the survey were six times more likely to sustain a low back injury than were athletes without a history of low back injury. These results suggest that some risk factors associated with a history of low back injury predispose athletes to sustain recurrent injury. They may be congenital or a result of insufficient recovery time after the first low back injury episode.

Review of knee proprioception and the relation to extremity function after an anterior cruciate ligament rupture

Several tests of human conscious knee proprioception have been described, but there is no consensus or reference standard established. Difficulties remain in the separation of information originating from muscles, tendons, and joints, and the tests cannot discriminate between loss of afferent signals or altered activity in the remaining receptors. There is convincing evidence from several descriptive studies that the afferent information is altered after a knee ligament injury and severely disturbed in some patients with anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injuries. However, an inherent inferior proprioceptive ability may also exist in some individuals, which makes them vulnerable to injuries. The deficits in proprioception have mostly been studied and related to the consciously registered sense, whereas the extent of possible disturbances of the unconscious or reflectory mechanisms is largely unknown. The latter may, at least from a theoretical point of view, be predominantly contributing to the overall afferent regulation, and a possibility for major defects thus exists, since there is no knowledge of the quantified relation between the conscious and unconscious part. The clinical importance of the altered afferent information has not been evaluated properly, and the role of proprioception that contributes to function has yet to be investigated. A higher physiological sensitivity to detecting a passive joint motion closer to full extension has been found both experimentally and clinically, which may protect the joint due to the close proximity to the limit of joint motion. Proprioception has been found to have a relation to subjective knee function, and patients with symptomatic ACL deficiency seem to have larger deficits than asymptomatic individuals. Little is known about whether training can restore defects in sensory information or by which mechanisms possible compensatory pathways are established. In rehabilitation, each patient must, however, create muscle strength, alertness, and stiffness in harmony with the disturbed mechanics of the knee, which are present both after nonoperative treatment of the ACL and after a reconstruction of the ACL.

Neuromuscular rehabilitation of a female Olympic ice hockey player following anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

STUDY DESIGN

Case study.

OBJECTIVE

To demonstrate the unique aspects of rehabilitating a female athlete participating in ice hockey following anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction.

BACKGROUND

The patient was a 28-year-old female who sustained a traumatic injury to her left knee while playing ice hockey. After 6 weeks of rehabilitation (15 visits), the athlete elected to undergo ACL reconstruction following buckling episodes that she experienced during both skating and walking.

METHODS AND MEASURES

Following ACL reconstruction using a patellar tendon autograft, the patient was treated for 6 months in 44 visits. Initial treatments consisted of effusion management, neuromuscular control of lower extremity muscles, and regaining passive range of motion, especially extension. Although instability testing revealed a negative pivot shift and a 2-millimeter side-to-side difference on KT-1000 examination, the patient reported a sensation of buckling when she attempted skating at 4 months (27 visits) following ACL reconstruction. Off-ice strength and functional testing of the lower extremity did not demonstrate deficits. At that time, a specific neuromuscular program for returning a patient to ice hockey was implemented.

RESULTS

Following 17 physical therapy visits, which combined sport-specific and sex-specific neuromuscular rehabilitation, the patient was able to return to competitive ice hockey. Six months following ACL reconstruction, the patient reported no feeling of instability during skating. The patient reported a Lysholm score of 100 and Tegner activity score of 9. An on-ice functional test revealed the athlete's score was 80% of her pre-injury score.

CONCLUSIONS

Failure of static knee stabilizers can be a cause of instability. Following ACL reconstruction, a neuromuscular rehabilitation program may prevent residual knee instability once the static stabilizers have been restored. A sport-specific neuromuscular rehabilitation program for the athlete participating in ice hockey should be considered.

Dynamic knee stability: current theory and implications for clinicians and scientists

We will discuss the mechanisms by which dynamic knee stability may be achieved and relate this to issues that interest clinicians and scientists concerned with dynamic knee stability. Emphasis is placed on the neurophysiologic evidence and theory related to neuromuscular control. Specific topics discussed include the ensemble firing of peripheral mechanoreceptors, the potential for muscle stiffness modulation via force and length feedback, postural control synergies, motor programs, and the neural control of gait. Factors related to answering the difficult question of whether or not knee ligament injuries can be prevented during athletic activities are discussed. Prevention programs that train athletes to perform their sport skills in a safe fashion are put forth as the most promising prospect for injury prevention. Methods of assessing neuromuscular function are reviewed critically and the need for future research in this area is emphasized. We conclude with a brief review of the literature regarding neuromuscular training programs.

Giving way event during a combined stepping and crossover cutting task in an individual with anterior cruciate ligament deficiency

STUDY DESIGN

Case study.

OBJECTIVE

To compare knee kinematics and moments of nongiving way trials to a giving way trial during a combined stepping and crossover cutting activity.

BACKGROUND

The knee kinematics and moments associated with giving way episodes suggest motor control strategies that lead to instability and recovery of stability during movement.

METHODS AND MEASURES

A 27-year-old woman with anterior cruciate ligament deficiency reported giving way while performing a combined stepping and crossover cutting activity. A motion analysis system recorded motion of the pelvis, femur, tibia, and foot using 3 infrared emitting diodes placed on each segment at 60 Hz. Force plate recordings at 300 Hz were combined with limb inertial properties and position data to estimate net knee joint moments. The stance time, foot progression angle, and cutting angle were also included to evaluate performance between trials.

RESULTS

Knee internal rotation during the giving way trial increased 3.2 degrees at 54% of stance relative to the nongiving way trials. Knee flexion during the giving way trial increased to 33.1 degrees at 66% of stance, and the knee moment switched from a nominal flexor moment to a knee extensor moment at 64% of stance. The knee abductor moment and external rotation moment during the giving way trial deviated in early stance.

CONCLUSIONS

The observed response to the giving way event suggests that increasing knee flexion may enhance knee stability for this subject. The transverse and frontal plane moments appear important in contributing to the giving way event. Further research that assists clinicians in understanding how interventions can impact control of movements in these planes is necessary.

Rehabilitation of the multiple-ligament-injured knee

Rehabilitation for a patient with a multiple-ligament knee injury should be designed to reduce pain and swelling, restore range of motion, strength, and endurance, and to enhance proprioception, and dynamic stability of the knee, with the goals of restoring function and minimizing disability. The biomechanics of the knee must be considered when designing a rehabilitation program. General guidelines for rehabilitation of the multiple-ligament-injured knee include considerations for promoting tissue healing, decreasing pain and swelling, restoring full motion, increasing muscular strength and endurance, improving proprioception, enhancing dynamic stability of the knee, and reducing functional limitations and disability. A patient's progression through this sequence must be individualized and depends on the pattern of ligament injury or surgical procedure that was performed, and the principles of tissue healing. Specific guidelines for rehabilitation following ACL reconstruction combined with MCL repair, PCL reconstruction, combined ACL-PCL reconstruction, and reconstruction of the LCL and posterolateral corner have been provided.