Corneal Ectasia After Laser In Situ Keratomileusis in Patients Without Apparent Preoperative Risk Factors

Management of chronic habits of abnormal eye rubbing

A review of the provocations and the consequences of chronic habits of abnormal rubbing indicates a range of possible adverse responses. Gentle rubbing may double intraocular pressure. However, the combination of tight eye closure and forceful rubbing may raise intraocular pressure to more than 10 times normal levels. The possibility that, in susceptible individuals, chronic habits of abnormal rubbing may lead to the development or progression of keratoconus has been extended to the possibility of rubbing related adverse responses in other diseases and conditions. The adverse consequences of rubbing appear to be active processes, in contrast to the apparent passive nature of any recovery from those responses. Avoidance of the possibility of permanent adverse changes is clearly preferable. However, advice to avoid rubbing may not be successfully followed. Education and counseling appear to be the foundations for helping patients to control chronic habits of abnormal rubbing. An instrument has been developed as the basis for patient education and counseling for this purpose. It is intended as a take-home document which might have relevance to other family members. The widening of the application of this form of patient education to all members of a family, and a wider range of conditions, may produce beneficial synergy with advantage to patients who may have the most to gain from controlling chronic habits of abnormal rubbing.

Corneal hysteresis using the Reichert ocular response analyser: findings pre- and post-LASIK and LASEK

PURPOSE

To evaluate and compare corneal hysteresis in patients prior to and following laser in situ keratomileusis (LASIK) and laser-assisted subepithelial keratectomy (LASEK) using the Reichert ocular response analyser (ORA).

METHODS

Corneal hysteresis was recorded prior to and 3 months after corneal laser refractive surgery for myopia. Preoperative corneal hysteresis was correlated with age and preoperative central corneal thickness (CCT). Postoperative corneal hysteresis was correlated with postoperative CCT in both the LASIK and LASEK treatment groups. The correlations between postoperative change in hysteresis and stromal ablation depth, percentage of tissue ablated, optical zone and patient age were also examined.

RESULTS

A total of 84 eyes of 84 patients were involved in the study. LASIK was performed in 63 eyes and LASEK in 21. Mean preoperative corneal hysteresis of all eyes was 10.8 +/- 1.5 mmHg. Mean age, preoperative CCT, corneal hysteresis and ablation profile were similar in both groups. A statistically significant decrease in hysteresis occurred following LASIK (p < 0.01) and LASEK (p < 0.01) with similar decrements observed in both treatment groups. A moderate correlation was found between postoperative hysteresis and postoperative CCT in LASIK (r = 0.7) and LASEK (r = 0.7) treated eyes. A weak correlation was found between postoperative decrease in hysteresis and the parameters examined.

CONCLUSION

Corneal hysteresis decreased following LASIK and LASEK. Similar reductions occurred following both procedures, indicating that LASIK involving a thin 120-mum flap did not induce additional biomechanical change. Postoperative reduction in hysteresis did not correlate with the amount or percentage of corneal tissue removed, nor with optical zone or patient age.

Risk Assessment for Ectasia after Corneal Refractive Surgery

PURPOSE

To analyze the epidemiologic features of ectasia after excimer laser corneal refractive surgery, to identify risk factors for its development, and to devise a screening strategy to minimize its occurrence.

DESIGN

Retrospective comparative and case-control study.

PARTICIPANTS

All cases of ectasia after excimer laser corneal refractive surgery published in the English language with adequate information available through December 2005, unpublished cases seeking treatment at the authors' institution from 1998 through 2005, and a contemporaneous control group who underwent uneventful LASIK and experienced a normal postoperative course.

METHODS

Evaluation of preoperative characteristics, including patient age, gender, spherical equivalent refraction, pachymetry, and topographic patterns; perioperative characteristics, including type of surgery performed, flap thickness, ablation depth, and residual stromal bed (RSB) thickness; and postoperative characteristics including time to onset of ectasia.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Development of postoperative corneal ectasia.

RESULTS

There were 171 ectasia cases, including 158 published cases and 13 unpublished cases evaluated at the authors' institution. Ectasia occurred after LASIK in 164 cases (95.9%) and after photorefractive keratectomy (PRK) in 7 cases (4.1%). Compared with controls, more ectasia cases had abnormal preoperative topographies (35.7% vs. 0%; P<1.0x10(-15)), were significantly younger (34.4 vs. 40.0 years; P<1.0x10(-7)), were more myopic (-8.53 vs. -5.09 diopters; P<1.0x10(-7)), had thinner corneas before surgery (521.0 vs. 546.5 microm; P<1.0x10(-7)), and had less RSB thickness (256.3 vs. 317.3 microm; P<1.0x10(-10)). Based on subgroup logistic regression analysis, abnormal topography was the most significant factor that discriminated cases from controls, followed by RSB thickness, age, and preoperative corneal thickness, in that order. A risk factor stratification scale was created, taking all recognized risk factors into account in a weighted fashion. This model had a specificity of 91% and a sensitivity of 96% in this series.

CONCLUSIONS

A quantitative method can be used to identify eyes at risk for developing ectasia after LASIK that, if validated, represents a significant improvement over current screening strategies.

Airbag induced corneal ectasia

PURPOSE

To report a case of airbag induced corneal ectasia.

METHODS

Case report.

RESULTS

A patient 3 years post-LASIK developed bilateral corneal ectasia worse in the right eye following airbag deployment in a road traffic accident. At last follow up, best corrected vision was 20/40 with -4.00/-4.00 x 25 in the right eye and 20/25 with -1.25/-0.50 x 135 in the left eye.

CONCLUSIONS

This is a rare presentation of trauma induced ectasia in a patient post-LASIK. It is possible that reduction in biomechanical integrity of the cornea from prior refractive surgery contributed to this presentation.

Analysis of ectasia after laser in situ keratomileusis: Risk factors

PURPOSE

To examine a database of laser in situ keratomileusis (LASIK) procedures for preoperative and operative factors assumed to increase the risk for developing post-LASIK ectasia.

SETTING

Private clinical practice.

METHODS

A computer database was queried for eyes that had LASIK for myopic refractive errors with the following characteristics: preoperative corneal thickness 500 microm or less, mean keratometry greater than 47.0 diopters (D), patient age 25 years or younger, attempted correction greater than -8.0 D, refractive astigmatism not with-the-rule and greater than 2.0 D, and residual stromal bed thickness (RST) 250 microm or less. Flap thickness and RST were measured using ultrasound pachymetry. All recorded information was exported to MS Excel and analyzed for eyes that had ectasia.

RESULTS

Of the 9700 eyes in the database, none with the above characteristics developed ectasia over mean follow-up periods exceeding 2 years. Seven eyes had multiple risk factors without ectasia. Three eyes with abnormal preoperative topography developed ectasia.

CONCLUSIONS

Individual preoperative and operative factors did not in and of themselves increase the risk for ectasia. Unmeasured and unknown factors that affect the individual cornea's biomechanical stability, in combination with some suspected risk factors as well as the current inability to identify corneas at risk for developing ectatic disorders, probably account for most eyes that develop ectasia today.

Delayed Ectasia Following LASIK With No Risk Factors: Is a 300-µm Stromal Bed Enough?

PURPOSE

To report a case of ectasia occurring > 4 years following LASIK with no risk factors and a residual stromal bed > 300 microm.

METHODS

A 33-year-old woman presented 4 years after LASIK with mild blurring in the left eye. Uncorrected visual acuity (UCVA) had been 20/20 in both eyes previously.

RESULTS

Uncorrected visual acuity was 20/20 and 20/40 in the right and left eyes, respectively. Best spectacle-corrected visual acuity (BSCVA) was 20/20 with -0.75 +2.25 x 70 degrees refraction in the left eye, which matched topography. Preoperative corneal thickness was 595 microm, and topography showed no risk factors preoperatively or immediately postoperatively. Calculated residual stromal bed was 342 microm and measured 400 microm with ultrasound microscopy. One year postoperatively, UCVA decreased to 20/400, and BSCVA decreased to 20/60 with refraction of -4.50 +5.00 x 90 degrees. The patient was intolerant of contact lens wear and is considering collagen cross-linking, Intacs, or corneal transplantation.

CONCLUSIONS

Ectasia can occur more than 4 years after LASIK. Its etiology is unknown and management is challenging.

Hyperopic Keratoconus

PURPOSE

To report three patients (four eyes) with hyperopic keratoconus.

METHODS

Patients were evaluated with corneal curvature topography, ultrasonic pachymetry, and rotating Scheimpflug camera.

RESULTS

One patient, without other risk factors, developed unilateral ectasia after LASIK following primary hyperopic ablation in an eye suspicious for keratoconus. Two additional hyperopic patients (three eyes) had curvature and elevation findings compatible with keratoconus.

CONCLUSIONS

Although rare, keratoconus could present in hyperopia. If keratoconus is suspected, we suggest avoidance of LASIK and its potential for development of corneal ectasia.

Vertical D

PURPOSE

To describe a novel topographic curvature pattern, vertical D, which was present in some keratoconus suspects. This pattern was detected retrospectively in 2 patients who developed post-LASIK ectasia and prospectively in 4 patients who had other corneal abnormalities suggestive of keratoconus.

DESIGN

Retrospective interventional case series and prospective cross-sectional study.

PARTICIPANTS

After vertical D topographic curvature patterns were noted in 2 patients (3 eyes) who developed post-LASIK ectasia, 1168 consecutive potential refractive surgical candidates (2336 eyes) evaluated at a refractive center were screened to detect this vertical D pattern.

METHODS

Placido disc-based curvature topography, ultrasound pachymetry, and elevation-based Scheimpflug topography were performed on these patients.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Corneal curvature topographic patterns, central keratometry, inferior-superior and nasal-temporal ratios, skewed radial axis value, Humphrey Atlas PathFinder corneal analysis, corneal thickness, and corneal anterior and posterior elevation.

RESULTS

Four additional patients (7 eyes) with vertical D patterns were found (prevalence, 0.34%). In addition to this vertical D pattern, these patients had central corneal thickness < 500 microm and/or posterior corneal protrusion > 20 microm or positive results on keratoconus detection analyses. The 10 eyes with the vertical D pattern had more horizontal (nasal-temporal ratio) than vertical (inferior-superior ratio) curvature asymmetry: 0.98+/-0.04 diopters versus 0.44+/-0.2 diopters (paired t test, P<0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

We propose that vertical D is a novel corneal curvature pattern reflecting horizontal asymmetry that was present in keratoconus suspect patients even if standard keratoconus analyses' results were negative.

Outcomes of Wavefront-Optimized Surface Ablation

PURPOSE

To compare early visual outcomes after wavefront-optimized advanced surface ablation (ASA) with those after wavefront-optimized LASIK.

DESIGN

Retrospective comparative series.

PARTICIPANTS

One hundred thirty-six eyes undergoing ASA and 136 preoperative refraction-matched eyes undergoing LASIK from June 2004 through October 2005.

METHODS

Database review of preoperative characteristics, including patient age, gender, refraction, and central corneal pachymetry; perioperative information, including type of surgery, flap thickness (for LASIK cases), ablation depth, and residual stromal bed thickness; and postoperative information, including uncorrected visual acuity (UCVA) at 1 day, 1 week, 2 weeks, and 3 months, refraction at 3 months, and complications. All ASA patients had topical mitomycin C applied intraoperatively.

MAIN OUTCOMES MEASURES

Postoperative UCVA, best spectacle-corrected visual acuity (BSCVA), spherical equivalent (SE) refraction, speed of visual recovery, and postoperative complications.

RESULTS

Surface ablation patients were younger (35.4 years vs. 39.8 years, P = 0.0002) and had thinner corneas (514 microm vs. 549 microm, P<0.0001) preoperatively. Average UCVA was significantly better after LASIK at 1 day (20/26.8 vs. 20/50.4, P<0.0001) and 2 weeks (20/24.4 vs. 20/33.3, P = 0.0002) postoperatively. However, by 3 months postoperatively, UCVA was better after ASA (20/20.8 vs. 20/22.7, P = 0.05), and 81.5% of patients achieved 20/20 or better UCVA after ASA, compared with 70.5% after LASIK (P = 0.05). More ASA eyes had postoperative UCVA that achieved or surpassed preoperative BSCVA than LASIK eyes (66% vs. 41.6%, P<0.0001). There were 53 patients who underwent bilateral simultaneous ASA. By 1 week, 87.5% had 20/40 or better UCVA in at least one eye and 62.5% had 20/40 or better UCVA in both eyes. By 2 weeks, 86.8% had 20/40 or better UCVA in one eye and 82.6% had 20/40 or better UCVA in both eyes.

CONCLUSION

Initial visual recovery is more rapid after LASIK; however, by 3 months postoperatively UCVA and SE refractions were better after ASA. Advanced surface ablation is an effective alternative to LASIK, and based on early visual recovery, bilateral simultaneous surface ablation is a reasonable alternative to sequential surgery for the majority of patients.

Long-term results of laser in situ keratomileusis for high myopia: Risk for ectasia

PURPOSE

To ascertain the long-term stability of laser in situ keratomileusis (LASIK) in highly myopic eyes.

SETTING

Clinical practice office-based surgery.

METHOD

Charts of eyes with high myopia who had LASIK surgery by the same surgeon between 1994 and 2000 were reviewed in 2003, and patients were given an appointment for follow-up examinations. In these highly myopic eyes, surgery was originally performed to create undercorrections with or without decreasing the ablation diameters to maximally conserve the residual stromal bed thickness.

RESULTS

Of the 107 eyes with myopia between -10.00 diopters (D) and -35.00 D reviewed and operated on in a 3-year period between 1994 and 1998, 35 eyes of 31 patients had a single enhancement procedure. One case of ectasia as a result of excessive tissue removal occurred in a patient with a preoperative refraction of -28.00 D. Of the 107 eyes reviewed, 78 (73%) were examined after 5 years, 68 (63%) after 7 years, and 15 (14%) between 9 years and 11 years.

CONCLUSIONS

Operating on eyes with highly myopic refractive errors and removing substantial tissue thickness did not produce ectasia in this series. Although high myopia has been considered a risk factor for post-LASIK ectasia, adherence to proper screening and intraoperative pachymetry appears to decrease the risk.

Corneal Ectasia After Hyperopic LASIK

PURPOSE

To report two cases of corneal ectasia, which developed after hyperopic LASIK.

METHODS

Preoperative pellucid marginal corneal degeneration was observed in patient 1. Patient 2 had no preoperative risk factors.

RESULTS

Patient 1, a 47-year-old man, developed corneal ectasia in his right eye 6 months after unilateral hyperopic LASIK. Preoperative manifest refraction was +2.00 +1.50 x 178 in the right eye and +1.00 sphere in the left eye. Corneal thickness was 585 microm and 575 microm (right and left eye, respectively). Preoperative topography of the right eye demonstrated inferior steepening in the far periphery, suggestive of early pellucid marginal corneal degeneration. Patient 2, a 35-year-old man, developed corneal ectasia in his right eye > 3 years after bilateral LASIK. Preoperative manifest refraction was +2.50 sphere and +3.25 sphere (right and left eye, respectively), and corneal thickness was 556 microm in both eyes. Preoperative topography was normal in both eyes with no evidence of asymmetry, steepening, or irregularity.

CONCLUSIONS

Corneal ectasia can occur after hyperopic LASIK in patients with or without recognized preoperative risk factors. Although uncommon, patients with pellucid marginal corneal degeneration can have hyperopic refractions and are at high risk for developing corneal ectasia after LASIK.

Probability Model of the Inaccuracy of Residual Stromal Thickness Prediction to Reduce the Risk of Ectasia After LASIK Part II: Quantifying Population Risk

PURPOSE

To derive a statistical model to estimate the rate of excessive keratectomy depth below a selected cut-off residual stromal thickness (RST) given a minimum target RST and specific Clinical Protocol; apply the model to estimate the RST below which ectasia appears likely to occur and back-calculate the safe minimum target RST that should be used given a specific Clinical Protocol.

METHODS

Myopia and corneal thickness distribution were modeled for a population of 5212 eyes that underwent LASIK. The probability distribution of predicted target RST error (Part I) was used to calculate the rate of excessive keratectomy depth for this series. All treatments were performed using the same Clinical Protocol; one surgeon, Moria LSK-One microkeratome, NIDEK EC-5000 excimer laser, Orbscan pachymetry, and a minimum target RST of 250 microm--the Vancouver Clinical Protocol. The model estimated the RST below which ectasia appears likely to occur and back-calculated the safe minimum target RST. These values were recalculated for a series of microkeratomes using published flap thickness statistics as well as for the Clinical Protocol of one of the authors-the London Clinical Protocol.

RESULTS

In the series of 5212 eyes, 6 (0.12%) cases of ectasia occurred. The model predicted an RST of 191 microm for ectasia to occur and that a minimum target RST of 329 microm would have reduced the -rate of ectasia to 1: 1,000,000 for the Vancouver Clinical Protocol. The model predicted that the choice of microkeratome varied the rate of ectasia between 0.01 and 11,623 eyes per million and the safe minimum target RST between 220 and 361 microm. The model predicted the rate of ectasia would have been 0.000003: 1,000,000 had the London Clinical Protocol been used for the Vancouver case series.

CONCLUSIONS

There appears to be no universally safe minimum target RST to assess suitability for LASIK largely due to the disparity in accuracy and reproducibility of microkeratome flap thickness. This model may be used as a tool to evaluate the risk of ectasia due to excessive keratectomy depth and help determine the minimum target RST given a particular Clinical Protocol.

Corneal ectasia after photorefractive keratectomy

Two patients developed corneal ectasia after photorefractive keratectomy (PRK). Case 1 had evidence of early keratoconus preoperatively, with manifest refractions of -4.00 +2.50 x 160 (20/20) in the right eye and -7.00 +3.00 x 180 (20/30) in the left eye; thin corneas (472 microm and 441 microm, respectively); and inferior paracentral steepening in the right eye and central steepening in the left eye on topography. Case 2 had manifest refractions of -8.50 +3.75 x 123 (20/20(-2)) in the right eye and -9.25 +4.00 x 077 (20/20(-1)) in the left eye; corneal thickness of 509 microm and 508 microm, respectively; and symmetric bow-tie patterns in both eyes on topography. Case 2 had a family history suspicious for keratoconus, with a sibling who had bilateral corneal transplantation at a young age. Both patients developed bilateral corneal ectasia after PRK.

Post-laser in-situ keratomileusis ectasia: current understanding and future directions

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

The aim of this article is to review the causes, risk factors, management, and future research directions for corneal ectasia after laser in situ keratomileusis.

RECENT FINDINGS

Complex corneal biomechanical processes influence the integrity of the normal and postoperative cornea, and developing an understanding of these processes facilitates recognition of risk factors for ectasia after laser in-situ keratomileusis. Currently identified risk factors include keratoconus, high myopia, low residual stromal bed thickness from excessive ablation or thick flap creation, and defined topographic abnormalities such as forme fruste keratoconus and pellucid marginal corneal degeneration. Ectasia can also rarely occur in patients without currently identifiable risk factors, and future identification of at-risk patients may be facilitated by corneal interferometry and corneal hysteresis measurements. Utilization of intraoperative pachymetry measurements at the time of surgery and confocal microscopy prior to enhancement to measure residual stromal bed thickness should avoid unanticipated low residual stromal bed thickness. Management options for ectasia after laser in situ keratomileusis include intraocular pressure reduction, rigid gas permeable contact lenses, and intracorneal ring segments, in addition to corneal transplantation. In the future, collagen cross-linking may reduce corneal steepening and improve refractive error.

SUMMARY

When ectasia develops, early recognition and proper management are essential to prevent progression, to promote visual rehabilitation, and to reduce the need for corneal transplantation for these patients.