Tendon healing in a bone tunnel differs at the tunnel entrance versus the tunnel exit: an effect of graft-tunnel motion?

Immobilization modulates macrophage accumulation in tendon-bone healing

Tendon-to-bone healing occurs by formation of a fibrous, scar tissue interface rather than regeneration of a normal insertion. Because inflammatory cells such as macrophages lead to formation of fibrous scar tissue, we hypothesized immobilization would allow resolution of acute inflammation and result in improved tendon-bone healing. We reconstructed the ACL of 60 Sprague-Dawley rats using a tendon autograft. An external fixation device was used to immobilize the surgically treated knee in 30 rats. We evaluated tendon-bone interface width, collagen fiber continuity, and new osteoid formation histologically. Immunohistochemistry was used to localize ED1+ and ED2+ macrophages at the tendon-bone interface at 2 and 4 weeks. Biomechanical testing was performed at 4 weeks. Interface width was smaller and collagen fiber continuity was greater in the immobilized group. Immobilized animals exhibited fewer ED1+ macrophages at the healing interface at 2 and 4 weeks. In contrast, there were more ED2+ macrophages at the interface in the immobilized group at 2 weeks. Failure load and stiffness were similar between groups at 4 weeks. The data suggest early immobilization diminishes macrophage accumulation and may allow improved tendon-bone integration.

Repair process after fibrocartilaginous enthesis drilling: histological study in a rabbit model

BACKGROUND

Disorders of the enthesis are often a consequence of sports injuries. However, there is uncertainty regarding the process of mechanical stress-related injuries at the enthesis and the subsequent repair process of the injured tissues. To elucidate the repair process of the fibrocartilaginous enthesis, we studied the repair of injured fibrocartilaginous enthesis and the morphological characteristics of the repaired tissue.

METHODS

We drilled 0.5-mm holes in the right tibial insertion of the patellar tendon of Japanese white rabbits, with their own left sides serving as controls. Specimens harvested at 1, 2, 4, 6, 8, and 12 weeks were examined histologically. Morphologically, the ratios of calcified fibrocartilage-bone interface lengths to enthesial lengths were compared between the control and surgical groups.

RESULTS

Repair initiation was observed in the deep bone layer at 1 week, with remarkable progress at 2 weeks. Repair at the enthesis and neoosteogenesis in deep bone layers were detected at 4 weeks, and the drill hole disappeared at 6 weeks. The tendon was partially invaded by fibrocartilage-covered chondroid bone at 8 weeks, and regenerated fibrocartilaginous enthesis and increased calcified fibrocartilage-bone interface irregularity was identified at 12 weeks. The ratios of calcified fibrocartilage-bone interface lengths to enthesial lengths were significantly greater in the surgical group than in the control group.

CONCLUSIONS

Repair progressed from bone to fibrocartilage and ended at fibrous tissue. Cancellous bone disruption triggered repair in all layers. Removal of the subchondral plate enabled infiltration of nutrients via blood vessels, with the underlying bone acting as a scaffold for the regenerating fibrocartilage.

Histologic and biomechanical analysis of anterior cruciate ligament graft to bone healing in skeletally immature sheep

PURPOSE

It was our aim to establish an animal model and to investigate the tendon graft-to-bone and physis healing process in skeletally immature sheep after reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL).

METHODS

Thirty-two immature sheep aged 4 months underwent a fully transphyseal ACL reconstruction by use of a soft-tissue graft. The animals were subsequently killed after 3, 6, 12, and 24 weeks and analyzed histologically and biomechanically.

RESULTS

There was a transient hypertrophy of the physis tissue at the passing site of the graft. Anchoring Sharpey-like fibers evolved as early as 3 weeks after surgery. A strong expression of collagen III messenger ribonucleic acid within the first 6 weeks preceded this anchoring process. The maximum load to failure of the tendon graft in the reconstructed knees initially decreased to 37.8 +/- 17.8 N after 3 weeks and was restored to 522.9 +/- 113 N after 24 weeks. Tendon graft stiffness was restored to 86% when compared with the control knees.

CONCLUSIONS

The early anchoring by Sharpey fibers was found at 3 weeks with continued maturation to 24 weeks. This development of anchoring fibers corresponded to that of biomechanical strength, starting with 5% of the normal knee at 3 weeks and then 15.2% at 6 weeks, 41.2% at 12 weeks, and 69% at 24 weeks. Tendon graft-to-bone and physis healing in skeletally immature sheep is further characterized by a transient hypertrophy of the physis cartilage. The physis recovers well from the trauma of drilling and placement of a soft-tissue graft. The early development of Sharpey-like fibers results in a solid integration of the graft into bone in a timely manner.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

ACL reconstruction in skeletally immature individuals is still controversial. This study describes in detail the histologic and biomechanical stages of tendon graft healing to the bone and physis. These data enrich the existing knowledge of previous studies in adult sheep and may provide a basis for further research in the controversial field of ACL reconstruction during growth.

Graft healing in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

Graft healing within the bone tunnel after anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction is still a complex, poorly understood biological process that is influenced by multiple surgical and postoperative variables. However, remarkable advances in knowledge of this process have been made based primarly on animal models. According to the findings of this review, some surgical and postoperative variables are known to directly affect time-course and quality of graft-tunnel healing. The type of graft, graft motion, and fixation methods have shown to directly affect time-course and quality of graft-tunnel healing. Therefore, the application of early and aggressive rehabilitation protocols should be cautious when using soft-tissue graft, allografts, and direct or aperture type of fixation for ACL reconstruction. With regard to graft placement, several cadaveric models showed biomechanical advantages of a more anatomical graft location; however, there are no studies that explore the relationship between graft placement and healing process. The precise effect of graft tensioning, graft/tunnel diameter disparity, and graft length within the bone tunnel in the graft healing process remains unclear and requires more research. To enhance graft-tunnel healing, tissue-engineering approaches, including the use of growth factors, mesenchymal stem cells, and periosteum graft augmentation, have been tested on animal models. These have shown promising results in terms of enhancement of bone-graft healing rate.

Double-bundle reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament using the transtibial technique

We present an arthroscopic surgical procedure for double-bundle transtibial anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with 2 tibial and femoral tunnels using autologous semitendinosus and gracilis tendons. The first aim is to attempt to create the femoral tunnels correctly through the tibial tunnels. To achieve this, a new tibial guide was used that permitted the simultaneous preparation of the anteromedial and posterolateral tibial tunnels. The intra-articular landmark is the tibial spine region, whereas the extra-articular landmarks are the anterior profile of the medial collateral ligament and the anterior tibial apophysis. We also describe transverse femoral fixation with biopins (1 for each femoral tunnel) after the preparation of the 2 tibial and femoral tunnels.

Tibial aperture bone disruption after retrograde versus antegrade tibial tunnel drilling: a cadaveric study

The purpose of this study is to compare the local microfracture effects of antegrade versus retrograde drilling of the tibial tunnel in ACL reconstruction. Arthroscopic ACL excision was performed on eight matched cadaveric knees. Arthroscopic guided tibial tunnel reaming was performed in either an antegrade (four) or retrograde (four) direction. A 3 x 3 cm section of proximal tibial surrounding the tibial aperture was removed with open dissection, and each section underwent micro-computed tomography analysis. Three musculoskeletal radiologists graded the specimens for bone aperture disruption and discrete fracture lines. Tibial aperture irregularity was seen in all four of the antegrade specimens (mean, Grade 1.5), and in none of the retrograde specimens. Discrete fracture lines were present in all four antegrade specimens (mean 10.13 mm depth; 8.95 mm length). No fracture lines were seen in the retrograde group. Retrograde drilling of the tibial tunnel in ACL reconstruction results in less microfracture trauma to the surrounding aperture bone. The use of retrograde drilling in ACL reconstruction may decrease synovialization of the graft-tissue interface when compared to antegrade drilling.

Augmentation of tendon-to-bone healing with a magnesium-based bone adhesive

BACKGROUND

Healing of an anterior cruciate ligament graft in a bone tunnel occurs by formation of fibrous scar tissue, which is weaker than the normal fibrocartilaginous insertion.

HYPOTHESIS

We hypothesized that a magnesium-based bone adhesive would improve tendon-to-bone healing in a rabbit anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction model.

STUDY DESIGN

Controlled laboratory study.

METHODS

Thirty-five New Zealand White rabbits underwent bilateral anterior cruciate ligament reconstructions with semitendinosus autografts. A total of 12.5 g of bone adhesive was placed in the intraosseous tunnel around the graft in one limb, while the tunnels in the contralateral limb received no implant. Sixteen animals each were sacrificed at 3 weeks and at 6 weeks (12 biomechanical testing/4 histology). Outcomes included semiquantitative histologic analyses for new cartilage formation and fibrous tissue formation in the tendon-bone interface, microcomputed tomography to quantify new bone formation along the bone tunnel, and biomechanical testing of load-to-failure and stiffness. Three animals were sacrificed at time 0 to confirm adequate tunnel fill with the bone adhesive on microcomputed tomography.

RESULTS

All specimens had adequate tunnel fill with the bone adhesive at time 0. Application of the bone adhesive resulted in more cartilage formation and less fibrous tissue formation at the tendon-bone interface at 6 weeks compared with controls (P < .05). There was significantly more bone formation in the tibia of the treated limbs at 6 weeks (P = .01). The load-to-failure was significantly higher in the treated group at 6 weeks (71.8 +/- 31.8 N vs 43.4 +/- 14.8 N; P = .04). There were no differences in stiffness at either time point, and there were no differences at 3 weeks in any outcome variable.

CONCLUSION

The magnesium-based bone adhesive improves tendon-to-bone healing based on histologic and biomechanical testing at 6 weeks in a rabbit model of anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Further studies are needed to investigate the clinical potential of this bone adhesive to enhance healing and decrease recovery time in soft-tissue ligament reconstruction.

Strategies to improve anterior cruciate ligament healing and graft placement

Recent improvements in anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction have been notable for strategies to improve ACL healing and to improve graft placements. The controversial choice of 1-bundle or 2-bundle grafts requires an advanced knowledge of native ACL insertional anatomy and an appreciation for the kinematic effects of graft placements. Understanding the limitations of surgical techniques to place tunnels is important. Once grafts are placed, new biologic strategies to promote intra-articular and intraosseous healing are evolving. Although these biologic engineering strategies are currently experimental, they are projected for clinical application in the near future.

Comparison of initial fixation properties of sutured and nonsutured soft tissue anterior cruciate ligament grafts with femoral cross-pin fixation

PURPOSE

To determine whether or not suturing a soft tissue graft in a whipstitch fashion is an essential procedure in order to ensure sufficient initial fixation strength of the cross-pin fixation technique in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction.

METHODS

Porcine digital extensor tendons were used as 4-stranded soft tissue grafts. Specimens were fixated within 52 porcine femoral bone tunnels using a cross-pin fixation technique (RigidFix; Ethicon, Norderstedt, Germany). In group I (n = 28), the looped-over part of the grafts was sutured using a whipstitch technique; in group II (n = 28) the grafts were not sutured. Initial fixation properties were determined using either a single cycle load to failure protocol or a dynamic loading protocol, submitting the graft to 1,000 cycles of flexion-extension loading between 0 degrees and 90 degrees , followed by ultimate loading to failure. The graft-pin interaction and the graft-tunnel interface was histomorphologically visualized in unloaded and dynamically loaded grafts.

RESULTS

After dynamic loading, the residual displacement in sutured grafts was lower when compared to nonsutured grafts. The ultimate failure loads were significantly lower in nonsutured grafts when compared to sutured grafts after dynamic loading. The histomorphologic analysis demonstrated intratunnel displacement of nonsutured grafts after dynamic loading, while sutured grafts remained in situ. In cases where the cross-pins had not threaded the tendon loops, sutured grafts provided higher fixation strength and less graft displacement.

CONCLUSIONS

The results of the present study suggest that suturing the looped-over portion of a quadruple tendon graft provides superior biomechanical graft fixation properties when compared to nonsutured grafts when using the femoral cross-pin fixation technique.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Suturing the hamstring tendon graft in a whipstitch fashion is recommended for the femoral cross-pin fixation of an anterior cruciate ligament graft.

Tendon healing

An understanding of the processes of tendon healing and tendon-to-bone healing is important for the intraoperative and postoperative management of patients with tendon ruptures or of patients requiring tendon transfers in foot and ankle surgery. Knowledge of the normal process allows clinicians to develop strategies when normal healing fails. This article reviews the important work behind the identification of the normal phases and control of tendon healing. It outlines the failed response in tendinopathy and describes tendon-to-bone healing in view of its importance in foot and ankle surgery.

Biology of autograft and allograft healing in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

The graft-bone attachment site is the weak link in anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction surgery because healing is slow and often incomplete. Each of the many graft options for ACL reconstruction surgery has different healing characteristics and potential. Autografts that allow bone-to-bone healing offer the best healing potential. An understanding of the biology of graft healing should give the surgeon context in graft selection and rehabilitation for ACL reconstruction.

Biomechanical comparison between CentraLoc and Intrafix fixation of quadrupled semitendinosus-gracilis allografts in cadaveric tibiae with low bone mineral density

Supplementary or back-up tibial tunnel fixation of a quadruple semitendinosus-gracilis (STG) graft is often performed when the knee surgeon questions the integrity of intra-tunnel fixation. Back-up fixation devices such as staples however may contribute to increased knee pain and dysfunction. Both primary extra-tunnel and intra-tunnel fixation devices may provide sufficient quadruple STG graft fixation in a tibial tunnel to preclude the need for back-up fixation. This biomechanical study compared the fixation of quadruple STG allografts in standard drilled tunnels prepared in low apparent bone mineral density (BMD) cadaveric tibiae using either an Intrafix device with primary intra-tunnel fixation in a region of predominantly cancellous trabecular bone, or a CentraLoc device with primary extra-tunnel fixation in a region of predominantly cortical bone. The study hypothesis was that the CentraLoc device would display superior fixation in these low apparent BMD cadaveric tibiae. Matched pair tibiae and quadruple STG allografts were divided into two groups of seven specimens each. Extraction drilled tunnels matched allograft diameter. Constructs were pretensioned on a servo hydraulic device between 10 and 50 N for 10 cycles and isometric pretensioned at 50 N for 1 min prior to undergoing 500 loading cycles (50-250 N) and load to failure testing (20 mm/min). The CentraLoc group displayed superior load at failure (448.4+/-171 N vs. 338.4+/-119 N, P=0.04) and survived more loading cycles (410+/-154 cycles vs. 196+/-230 cycles, P=0.04) than the Intrafix group. Most CentraLoc group specimens (6/7, 85.7%) failed by device pullout with intact quadruple STG allograft strands while all Intrafix group specimens (7/7, 100%) failed by slippage of one or more strands (P=0.005).

Anatomic double bundle ACL reconstruction: a literature review

With the abundance of anatomic double bundle ACL reconstruction techniques that currently exist and limited patient outcome data, one has to ask whether or not they should be used and if so, which one, and what is the learning curve for the average knee surgeon to become competent with the technique that they select? The purpose of this literature review is to summarize existing anatomic double bundle ACL reconstruction surgical and rehabilitation techniques and the clinical and biomechanical study evidence that currently exists. In choosing to perform anatomic double bundle ACL reconstruction we suggest that the knee surgeon should look for evidence of: (1) control of the pivot shift phenomenon, (2) improved transverse plane rotatory knee control during the performance of sports type movements, (3) a decreased likelihood of revision procedures either for ACL reconstruction or for treatment of associated primary or recurrent meniscal injuries, (4) improved patient self-reports of perceived function, satisfaction, and quality of life, and (5) radiographic evidence of a lower incidence and/or magnitude of osteoarthritic changes compared to conventional single bundle ACL reconstruction.