Lactic acidosis in metformin-treated patients. Prognostic value of arterial lactate levels and plasma metformin concentrations

Metformin and lactic acidosis: cause or coincidence? A review of case reports

OBJECTIVE

Metformin has been associated with the serious side-effect lactic acidosis. However, it remains unclear whether the use of metformin was a cause or a coincidence in lactic acidosis.

DESIGN

A literature search of the Index Medicus (1959-66) and of the databases Embase, Medline, Medline Express (1966-99) was performed using the keywords metformin, biguanides and lactic acidosis. All articles of cases with metformin-induced lactic acidosis (MILA) were cross-referenced.

SUBJECTS

Cases were included for analysis if they met the following criteria: serum pH < or =7.35, lactate concentration > or =5 mmol L(-1).

INTERVENTION

A forum of six experts in intensive care medicine independently categorized the cases in MILA unlikely (score 0), possible MILA (score 1) or probable MILA (score 2).

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Statistical analysis included the paired interobserver agreement (kappa) and multivariate regression analysis.

RESULTS

Of 80 reported cases, 33 were excluded because of insufficient quality. The forum scores of the remaining 47 cases were distributed normally with a mean score of 7 (range 2-10). The kappa-value was 0.041 (SD = 0.24, range -0.514, 0.427). Neither lactate concentration nor mortality correlated with serum metformin concentrations.

CONCLUSIONS

Given the low interobserver agreement and the lack of any relationship between metformin levels and outcome parameters, the concept that there is a simple, causal relationship between metformin use and lactic acidosis in diabetic patients has to be reconsidered.

Metformin: new understandings, new uses

Metformin, a biguanide, has been available in the US for the treatment of type 2 diabetes mellitus for nearly 8 years. Over this period of time, it has become the most widely prescribed antihyperglycaemic agent. Its mechanism of action involves the suppression of endogenous glucose production, primarily by the liver. Whether the drug actually has an insulin sensitising effect in peripheral tissues, such as muscle and fat, remains somewhat controversial. Nonetheless, because insulin levels decline with metformin use, it has been termed an 'insulin sensitiser'. Metformin has also been shown to have several beneficial effects on cardiovascular risk factors and it is the only oral antihyperglycaemic agent thus far associated with decreased macrovascular outcomes in patients with diabetes. Cardiovascular disease, impaired glucose tolerance and the polycystic ovary syndrome are now recognised as complications of the insulin resistance syndrome, and there is growing interest in the management of this extraordinarily common metabolic disorder. While diet and exercise remain the cornerstone of therapy for insulin resistance, pharmacological intervention is becoming an increasingly viable option. We review the role of metformin in the treatment of patients with type 2 diabetes and describe the additional benefits it provides over and above its effect on glucose levels alone. We also discuss its potential role for a variety of insulin resistant and prediabetic states, including impaired glucose tolerance, obesity, polycystic ovary syndrome and the metabolic abnormalities associated with HIV disease.

Tolerability Profile of Metformin/Glibenclamide Combination Tablets (Glucovance??)

It is important to manage blood glucose intensively in patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus in order to reduce the risk of long-term complications. Oral combination therapy that addresses insulin resistance and beta-cell dysfunction is a proven means of improving glycaemic control when monotherapy becomes insufficiently effective. Metformin/glibenclamide (glyburide) combination tablets were developed to provide a means of applying this strategy while minimising polypharmacy. This review examines the tolerability profile of this treatment from four double-blind, randomised clinical trials in a total of 2342 type 2 diabetic patients with hyperglycaemia despite treatment with diet and exercise, a sulphonylurea or metformin. Treatment with combination tablets was associated with markedly superior blood glucose control, at lower doses of metformin and glibenclamide, compared with monotherapies. The incidence of symptoms of hypoglycaemia varied between dosages and trials, though the incidence of severe or biochemically confirmed hypoglycaemia or withdrawals from clinical trials for this reason was consistently low and comparable with glibenclamide alone. No patient required third-party assistance for hypoglycaemia. Significantly fewer diet-failed patients receiving low-dose combination tablets reported gastrointestinal adverse effects compared with metformin alone, with a comparable incidence between metformin and combination tablets in post-monotherapy studies. The incidence of other adverse events, including serious adverse events, was similar for combination tablets and monotherapies. The lower doses of metformin and glibenclamide with the combination tablet approach, and the design of the combination tablets themselves, may underlie the beneficial tolerability profile of this treatment.

Kinetics of plasma and erythrocyte metformin after acute administration in healthy subjects

OBJECTIVES

Although the existence of a deep compartment for metformin has long been hypothesized, there is still little direct information concerning metformin distribution in individual tissues in man. The only available study involves chronic metformin therapy. In that study, the measurement of metformin in erythrocytes provided a reliable indicator of metformin distribution and of potential accumulation. To determine the kinetics of metformin in plasma and in erythrocytes after acute oral administration, we performed the present study in healthy subjects after a single oral dose of metformin and compared the pharmacokinetics parameters in erythrocytes to those in plasma.

METHODS

Six nondiabetic participants took the study dose of 850 mg metformin at 8: 00 AM after a non-standardized breakfast (i.e., as recommended in clinical practice). Blood samples were collected for metformin measurement in plasma and in erythrocytes at 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 6, 9, 24, 33, 48, 57, and 72 h.

RESULTS

Maximum metformin concentration was attained at 3.0 +/- 0.3 h in plasma and 4.7 +/- 0.5 h in erythrocytes. This difference was not significant. Metformin concentrations peaked at a maximum almost 6 times higher in plasma than in erythrocytes (1.7 +/- 0.1 and 0.3 +/- 0.0 mg/l, respectively). However, because the elimination half-life of metformin was much longer in erythrocytes (23.4 +/- 1.9 h vs. 2.7 +/- 1.2 h), there was no difference in area under the curve between plasma and erythrocytes. The distribution volume (plasma) was calculated to be 146 +/- 11 l. Plasma and erythrocytes concentration-time curves showed that metformin was not detectable in plasma 24 hours after the oral administration, while it remained detectable in erythrocytes up to 48 hours. Metformin concentrations crossed approximately 13 hours after having reached their maximum values in plasma, approximately 16 h after metformin intake.

CONCLUSION

Having demonstrated the rapid elimination of metformin from plasma and its slow disappearance from erythrocytes, the presents results should contribute to adjustment of metformin dosage to renal function, assessment of drug compliance, and retrospective analysis (when blood samples are drawn with delay) of the link between metformin and development of lactic acidosis. Most importantly, the present findings should help to ascertain the optimal dosage of metformin, particularly in elderly patients.

Mild acute renal failure potentiates metformin accumulation in the diabetic rat kidney without further impairment of renal function

OBJECTIVES

To analyze, in acute renal failure (ARF) in diabetic rats, how moderate functional ARF would modify metformin (MET) pharmacokinetics and if plasma and renal tissue MET accumulation could aggravate renal insufficiency and/or elicit plasma lactate accumulation.

METHODS

Streptozotocin-induced diabetic rats were allocated to four groups: control, MET, ARF, ARF-MET (6-7 rats per group). MET (100 mg/kg/day) was given per os for two weeks before ARF was induced by drinking restriction and enalapril treatment. The effects of MET and/or ARF were examined in vivo on renal function in conscious rats (metabolic cages) and ex vivo on renal vascular reactivity (isolated kidney).

RESULTS

MET treatment (plasma level: 5.3 +/- 1.4 microg/ml, mean+/-SEM), resulted in biguanide accumulation in cortex and medulla (53 +/- 17 and 80 +/- 40 microg/g respectively). MET was devoid of any effect on creatinine clearance, mean blood pressure or renal vascular resistance, but moderately increased plasma lactate (3.8 +/- 0.5 vs 3.2 +/- 0.2 mM, P<0.05) and decreased angiotensin II-induced renal vasoconstriction. ARF, although mild, decreased renal MET clearance (0.29 +/- 0.05 vs 1.01 +/- 0.31 ml/min/100 g, P<0.05) and increased plasma and renal tissue MET levels (x 2-4). MET however did not worsen the fall in glomerular filtration rate, nor modify renal vascular reactivity. ARF did not change the MET-elicited moderate increase in plasma lactate.

CONCLUSION

Despite the increase in MET plasma and renal tissue levels subsequent to moderate ARF, no harmful metabolic effect on plasma lactate and no further impairment of renal function was observed in MET-treated diabetic rats subjected to ARF.

Measurement of metformin concentration in erythrocytes: clinical implications

AIMS

Although pharmacokinetics studies have long suggested a deep compartment for the antidiabetic drug metformin, there is still little information concerning metformin accumulation by individual tissues in man. In the present study, the erythrocyte was chosen to represent this putative deep compartment and metformin concentration in erythrocytes (EM) was compared with that in plasma (PM) to delineate clinical implications.

METHODS

A reference group of 58 patients with well-tolerated metformin treatment was studied to provide standard mean metformin concentrations in the fasting state. Secondly, to provide transverse data reflecting clinical practice, the authors reviewed an investigation group of 93 metformin-treated patients with available PM and EM, which had been requested either to adjust metformin dosage to renal function, or to screen for potential metformin accumulation following renal failure, metformin overdose or lactic acidosis. Thirdly, the case of an individual with major metformin accumulation was studied to provide information about metformin elimination.

RESULTS

From the bulk of data, we performed three types of analyses: (1) PM and EM were compared. In the investigation group, this comparison was extended to subgroups separated according to low-to-normal, moderately increased or highly increased metformin concentration. (2) Correlative analyses of PM, EM and serum creatinine were performed. (3) A kinetic study of the spontaneous decline of PM and EM was conducted. PM and EM were, respectively, 0.5 +/- 0.4 mg/l and 0.8 +/- 0.4 mg/l in the reference group, and 11.7 +/- 17.8 mg/l (mean +/- SD, range 0.0-71.9 mg/l) and 7.5 +/- 9.4 mg/l (0.0-34 mg/l) in the investigation group, mean serum creatinine of which was 290 +/- 258 micro mol/l. In the low-to-normal PM subgroup (n = 28), PM and EM were, respectively, 0.39 +/- 0.38 mg/l and 0.84 +/- 0.68 mg/l (p < 0.001). In the moderately increased PM subgroup (from therapeutic concentrations +2 SD to 5 mg/l, n = 24), PM and EM were 2.82 +/- 1.13 mg/l and 2.72 +/- 2.03 mg/l (NS). In the sharply increased PM subgroup (> 5 mg/l, n = 41), PM and EM were 27.6 +/- 23.2 mg/l and 17.0 +/- 11.4 mg/l (p = < 0.001). PM and EM were tightly correlated (r = 0.72 in the reference group and r = 0.90 in the investigation group, p < 0.001 for both). Metformin concentrations were also correlated with those of serum creatinine, but more so in the investigation group; in subgroups, a positive correlation was found only at high metformin concentrations and in erythrocytes. The kinetic study performed in the patient with major metformin accumulation showed that PM and EM dropped within less than 3 days from a maximum concentration of 80.0 mg/l and 20.4 mg/l, respectively, to 0.67 mg/l and 6.52 mg/l.

CONCLUSIONS

In conclusion, metformin appears to accumulate in erythrocytes and, consequently, may be part of a deep compartment for the drug. This evidence of slow decline in erythrocyte metformin concentration may contribute to retrospective diagnosis of metformin accumulation and to refinements in adjusting metformin dosage to renal function.

Metformin-associated lactic acidosis after elective cervical spine fusion: a case report

STUDY DESIGN

A case of metformin-associated lactic acidosis after elective spinal surgery is reported.

OBJECTIVE

To inform spinal surgeons of this potentially fatal side effect and make them aware that metformin should be stopped 48 hours before surgery.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Metformin is a commonly used oral hypoglycemic agent used in the treatment of non-insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus. A rare side effect of metformin is lactic acidosis, which has a 50% mortality rate. Risk factors for metformin-associated lactic acidosis include renal, hepatic, and cardiac failure. Two cases have been reported in postsurgical patients. No cases of this disorder have been reported after orthopedic procedures.

METHODS

A patient who developed metformin-associated lactic acidosis after cervical spinal fusion is presented.

RESULTS

Recognition of the cause and aggressive medical management led to resolution of the lactic acidosis. Subsequent surgery was uneventful when metformin was discontinued more than 48 hours before surgery.

CONCLUSION

Spinal surgeons should be aware of this preventable, potentially fatal side effect and stop metformin 48 hours before surgery.

Metformin in patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus: reconsideration of traditional contraindications

BACKGROUND: The strict limiting criteria for the use of metformin in diabetes mellitus stem largely from reports, in the 1970s, of mortality and lactic acidosis associated with phenformin. Data about metformin are less clear and are based mainly on case reports. The aim of this study was to evaluate the safety of continued use of metformin in patients with contraindications to this agent. PATIENTS: Some 393 patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus (serum creatinine 130-220 &mgr;mol/l) were studied. Among them were 266 patients with coronary heart disease (CHD), 94 with congestive heart failure (CHF), and 91 with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), all of whom had been treated with metformin. The patients were randomized to either continue or to stop metformin and were then followed for 4 years. RESULTS: Analysis was by intention-to-treat. The patients who stopped taking metformin showed a rise in body mass index and in hemoglobin A1c significantly greater than those who continued the drug. There were no cases of lactic acidosis. Lactic acid values did not differ in the two groups and correlated only with serum creatinine and body mass index. Microvascular diabetic complications, cardiovascular events, and cardiovascular and total mortality were identical in the two groups. CONCLUSIONS: Diabetic patients who are treated with metformin and who tolerate the drug well may continue taking it, even when mild renal impairment develops, possibly up to serum creatinine levels of 220 &mgr;mol/l. There is also no apparent reason why patients with CHD, CHF, and COPD should discontinue metformin.

Acidosis induced by lactate, pyruvate, or HCl increases blood viscosity

PURPOSE

Serum lactate correlates with the severity of disease and the mortality in shock. It is not clear if lactate is only a marker or a mediator of disease. We tested the hypothesis that acidosis induced by lactate and pyruvate affects blood flow properties.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Human blood was incubated with additional lactate (0-50 mmol/L) or pyruvate (0-25 mmol/L) for 1 hour at 37 degrees C. Blood viscosity was measured at high (94.5 s(-1)) and low (0.1 s(-1)) shear rate. Hematocrit was measured with an electronic particle counter as well as centrifugation.

RESULTS

A total of 50 mmol/L additional lactate produced acidosis (pH 6.4) and increased whole-blood viscosity at high shear rate (94.5 s(-1): 6.53 +/- 0.51 mPa.s vs 4.94 +/- 0.18 mPa.s for control, n = 5, P <.001) and low shear rate (0.1 s(-1): 93.9 +/- 18.6 mPa.s vs 53.5 +/- 7.7 mPa.s, n = 5, P <.001). Simultaneously, an increased centrifuged hematocrit was observed (about 7% with 50 mmol/L lactate, P <.001), indicating eryth-rocyte swelling. These changes were reversible on removal of lactate. The addition of 25 mmol/L pyruvate also induced acidosis and increased blood viscosity and centrifuged hematocrit. When HCl was used to induce a comparable pH level decrease, a similar increase in blood viscosity and hematocrit were observed.

CONCLUSIONS

Pronounced acidosis induced by either lactate, pyruvate, or HCl impairs blood flow properties, which may contribute to the understanding of the pathophysiology of critical illness.

Oral agents for the treatment of type 2 diabetes mellitus: pharmacology, toxicity, and treatment

Currently available oral agents for the treatment of type 2 diabetes mellitus include a variety of compounds from 5 different pharmacologic classes with differing mechanisms of action, adverse effect profiles, and toxicities. The oral antidiabetic drugs can be classified as either hypoglycemic agents (sulfonylureas and benzoic acid derivatives) or antihyperglycemic agents (biguanides, alpha-glucosidase inhibitors, and thiazolidinediones). In this review, a brief discussion of the pharmacology of these agents is followed by an examination of the adverse effects, drug-drug interactions, and toxicities. Finally, treatment of sulfonylurea-induced hypoglycemia is described, including general supportive care and the management of pediatric sulfonylurea ingestions. The adjunctive roles of glucagon, diazoxide, and octreotide for refractory hypoglycemia are also discussed.

Lactic acidosis in metformin therapy: searching for a link with metformin in reports of 'metformin-associated lactic acidosis'

OBJECTIVE

The link between metformin and lactic acidosis in metformin therapy may be causal, associated or coincidental. Our objective was to investigate this link by studying and analysing published reports of so-called 'metformin-associated lactic acidosis'.

RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODS

systematically searched in the BIOSIS, DERWENT, EMBASE, MEDLINE, and PASCAL databases of the English language and non-English language literature for all reports of so-called 'metformin-associated lactic acidosis' published from May 1995 through January 2000. We did not include reports related to metformin overdose or contrast media-induced renal failure. Metformin accumulation and concurrent pathologies were critically reviewed as precipitating factors for metformin-associated lactic acidosis. Metformin accumulation was assessed in terms of the recorded measurement of metformin concentration in plasma or, if not available, by the presence of primary renal failure, i.e. renal failure that was not secondary to a shock syndrome.

RESULTS

We found 21 reports describing a total of 26 patients. Criteria of lactic acidosis (lactate > 5 mmol/l, pH <or= 7.35) were not met in four patients. In the remaining 22 patients, plasma metformin concentration was determined in only four, of whom one had a normal value. In the 18 patients with lactic acidosis where plasma metformin concentration data was not available, the presence of primary renal failure was absent or unlikely in six patients, uncertain in two, and likely or proven in 14. With regard to these 14 patients, the precipitating factor was metformin in 12 patients (in the context of renal failure either chronic or acute) and intercurrent pathologies in two others. Overall, lactic acidosis was either absent (n = 4), precipitated by concurrent pathology (n = 8), precipitated by metformin without apparent associated pathology (n = 12) or of uncertain origin (n = 2). Death occurred 10 times but only once in the 12 patients with metformin-induced lactic acidosis and this was not related to metformin.

CONCLUSIONS

While the term 'metformin-associated lactic acidosis' is commonly used to depict all situations of lactic acidosis in metformin therapy, true metformin-associated lactic acidosis, i.e. one which refers to metformin and concurrent pathologies as co-precipitating factors, was never observed in the studied reports. As there was no mortality due to metformin alone, it is important that physicians are familiar with the range of other risk factors that contribute to lactic acidosis in patients treated with metformin.

Multicenter case series of pediatric metformin ingestion

OBJECTIVE

There are no large studies, case series, or case reports of metformin ingestion in children. This study summarizes the clinical course and outcomes of metformin ingestion in children reported to the American Association of Poison Control Centers-certified regional poison centers.

METHODS

This was a case series of all metformin ingestions in patients <18 years of age reported to eight regional poison centers. Data collection included age, gender, dose ingested, co-ingestants, symptoms, vital signs, laboratory values, length of hospital stay, and medical outcome. Entrance into the study required at least 24 hours of follow-up.

RESULTS

Fifty-five cases were collected. Ages ranged from 15 months to 17 years, with a mean (+/- SD) of 42+/-4.4 years. The dose ingested, by history, ranged from 250 mg to 16.5 g, with a mean and median of 1710+/-3391 and 500 mg, respectively. Forty-one children (76%) ingested a maximum of two tablets (< or =1700 mg). In the children younger than six years, dosage ranged from 9 to 196 mg/kg, with a mean and median of 60+/-41.1 and 40 mg/kg, respectively. Thirty-seven children were evaluated in a healthcare facility. Clinical effects were limited to nausea (2), diarrhea (2), and dizziness (1). None of the 38 children who had serial glucose measurements experienced hypoglycemia. Arterial blood gas and electrolyte measurements were performed in three and 19 children, respectively. No evidence of acidosis was demonstrated. Two children had lactate concentrations measured and were determined to be in the normal range. Twenty-nine patients received activated charcoal. Five patients received parenteral glucose and one adolescent with a history of diabetes received insulin for hyperglycemia.

CONCLUSIONS

Unintentional ingestion of < or =1700 mg of metformin in the healthy pediatric population does not appear to pose a significant health risk of hypoglycemia or detrimental outcome. In the 21 children who were tested for either blood glucose, electrolyte, or lactate concentrations, no evidence of lactic acidosis was seen.

Lactic acidosis in metformin therapy

The biguanide drugs metformin and phenformin have been linked in the past to lactic acidosis, a metabolic condition associated with high rates of mortality. Although concern over the hyperlactataemic effect of phenformin led to the withdrawal of this drug from clinical practice in the 1970s, the situation with metformin has been less clear. Retrospective data indicate that, in metformin-treated patients with lactic acidosis, neither the degree of hyperlactataemia nor accumulation of metformin is of prognostic significance. Furthermore, the lowest rates of mortality were seen in patients with high plasma concentrations of metformin, which has led to the hypothesis that the drug may confer some benefit, linked to an increase in vasomotility, in such cases. Overall, it appears that mortality in patients receiving metformin who develop lactic acidosis is linked to underlying disease rather than to metformin accumulation, and that metformin can no longer be considered a toxic drug in this respect. These findings are likely to be of considerable relevance to the management of patients with type 2 (non-insulin-dependent) diabetes mellitus, especially where such patients are elderly.