Immunogenicity of 2 serogroup B outer-membrane protein meningococcal vaccines: a randomized controlled trial in Chile

Vaccines against meningococcal disease: current and future technologies

Development of the meningococcal serogroup C conjugate vaccine and its national implementation in the UK has been a major breakthrough in the prevention of meningococcal disease. New technologies are increasing the likelihood that research towards a vaccine against group B meningococcus will be successful. This review covers the recent development of vaccines against meningococcal disease and examines future vaccine candidates. The development of meningococcal polysaccharide vaccines was based on the virulence of the bacterial capsule components. The immunogenicity of these vaccines has been improved by covalent linkage to proteins in the new meningococcal C conjugate vaccines. However, the most promising developments for serogroup B disease have stemmed from other virulence determinants such as outer membrane proteins (OMPs) and lipopolysaccharides (LPS). New genome sequencing technology promises a way forward to developing a broadly cross-protective vaccine for this important pathogen.

Importance of complement source in measuring meningococcal bactericidal titers

Complement-mediated bactericidal antibodies in serum confer protection against meningococcal disease. The minimum protective titer is estimated to be between 1:4 and 1:8 when measured by the Goldschneider assay performed with human complement, the assay used in the 1960s to establish the correlation between bactericidal antibodies and protection. A more recently described bactericidal assay standardized by an international consortium uses rabbit complement, which is known to augment bactericidal titers. To define a protective titer measured by the standardized assay, we compared bactericidal titers against serogroup C strains measured by this assay to titers measured by the assay described by Goldschneider et al. A titer of > or =1:128 measured by the standardized assay was needed to predict with > or =80% certainty a positive titer of > or =1:4 as measured by the Goldschneider assay. However, the majority of samples with titers of 1:4 measured by the Goldschneider assay had titers of <1:128 when measured by the standardized assay. Therefore, by the results of the standardized assay such persons would be falsely categorized as being susceptible to disease. In conclusion, high bactericidal titers measured with the standardized assay performed with rabbit complement are predictive of protection, but no threshold titer is both sensitive and specific for predicting a positive titer measured by the Goldschneider assay using human complement. Up to 10% of the U.S. adult population lacks intrinsic bactericidal activity against serogroup C strains in serum and can serve as complement donors. Therefore, use of the Goldschneider assay or an equivalent assay performed with human complement is preferred over assays that use rabbit complement.

Meningococcal disease among children who live in a large metropolitan area, 1981-1996

Neisseria meningitidis is an important cause of serious bacterial infections in children. We undertook a study to identify meningococcal infections of the blood, cerebrospinal fluid, or both of children in a defined geographic area to describe the burden of disease and the spectrum of illness. We reviewed the medical records of all children aged <18 years who had meningococcal infections at the 4 pediatric referral hospitals in Boston, Massachusetts, from 1981 through 1996. We identified 231 patients with meningococcal disease; of these 231 patients, 194 (84%) had overt disease and 37 (16%) had unsuspected disease. Clinical manifestations included meningitis in 150 patients, hypotension in 26, and purpura in 17. Sixteen patients (7%) died. Although meningococcal disease is devastating to a small number of children, we found that the burden of pediatric disease that it caused at the 4 pediatric referral centers in this geographic region was limited; that patients with overt meningococcal disease are most likely to have meningitis; and that individual practitioners are unlikely to encounter a patient with unsuspected meningococcal disease.

Conjugates and reverse vaccinology to eliminate bacterial meningitis

Bacterial meningitis is caused mainly by Haemophilus influenzae, Streptococcus pneumoniae and Neisseria meningitidis. Haemophilus influenzae type b vaccines have been extremely successful in eradicating the disease from those countries where the vaccine has been introduced. The recent licensure of the conjugated pneumococcal vaccine suggests that this pathogen also will be soon controlled. Consequently, if we succeed in developing effective vaccines against meningococcus, this will enable us to eliminate bacterial meningitis. The global elimination of bacterial meningitis is a goal which, if appropriate resources are applied, can be reached within the first fifteen years of the 21st century.

Meningococcal vaccines

Global control and prevention of meningococcal disease depends on the further development of vaccines that overcome the limitations of the current polysaccharide vaccines. Protein-polysaccharide conjugate vaccines likely will address the marginal protective antibody responses and short duration of immunity in young children derived from the A, C, Y, and W-135 capsular polysaccharides, but they will be expensive to produce and purchase, and may not offer a practical solution to the countries with greatest need. In addition, OMP vaccines have been tested extensively in humans and hold some promise in the development of a serogroup B vaccine, but are limited by the antigenic variability of these subcapsular antigens and the resulting strain-specific protection. Elimination of meningococcal disease likely will require a novel approach to vaccine development, ideally incorporating a safe and effective antigen or antigens common to all meningoccocal serogroups. As a solely human pathogen, however, N. meningitidis has developed many tools with which to evade the human immune system, and likely will pose a formidable challenge for years to come.

Murine monoclonal antibodies to PorA of Neisseria meningitidis show reduced protective activity in vivo against B:15:P1.7,16 subtype variants in an infant rat infection model

The major outer membrane protein PorA of Neisseria meningitidis is the target for bactericidal serosubtyping antibodies and is currently considered as a potential vaccine candidate against group B meningococcal disease. Although the minor antigenic variability of the PorA has been increasingly recognized and described, its implication for vaccine design remains unclear. In this study, the protective activity of murine monoclonal PorA specific antibodies against four isogenic meningococcal P1.7,16 target strains, the prototype P1.7,16a and three loop 4 point mutation variants (designated P1.7,16b to d) constructed from reference strain H44/76 (B:15:P1.7,16a), was evaluated in the infant rat infection model. All monoclonal antibodies had been obtained by immunization of mice with outer membrane protein preparations from meningococcal serosubtype P1.7,16 reference strain H44/76. A challenge dose of 10(5)cfu/pup was given i.p. 1-2 h after the i.p. injection of 1:100 diluted antibodies, and the development of bacteremia was assessed by culturing blood samples taken 6 h after challenge. MN14C11.6, a reference monoclonal antibody for serosubtype P1.7 epitope located in predicted loop 1 (VR1) identical in all the variants, was equally protective against all loop 4 variants. The three P1.16 specific monoclonal antibodies tested (MN5C11G, MN12H2 and 62D12-8) all completely protected animals against the prototype P1.7,16a, variably against the P1.7,16b and P1.7,16c, but not against the P1.7,16d variant. Our findings therefore suggest that certain subtype variants may escape protection in vivo conferred by PorA specific antibodies.

Vaccines and infectious disease

The exponential growth in vaccine research over the last decade, in which many infectious diseases now appear to be amenable to prevention through immunization, is built upon three factors: first, a richer understanding of the immune response (in particular, cellular immunity), second, a greater finesse in understanding the molecular biology of pathogenicity, and third, an expanding use of genetic engineering techniques either to create micro-organisms of greatly attenuated virulence that may be used as vaccines, or to sequence, and express, potential vaccine antigens. With respect to vaccines composed of purified antigens, parallel work is underway to develop immuno-modulating agents (adjuvants) that will selectively and safely induce the necessary immune response. Finally, within this plethora of vaccine candidates, vaccinologists are devoting much effort to alternatives to immunization via injection, such as administration of a vaccine through the mucosal route (e.g., oral, intranasal, intravaginal, etc.), through the transcutaneous route, and even by expression of vaccine antigens in edible fruits and vegetables.

Development of natural immunity to Neisseria meningitidis

Although meningococcal disease is rare in industrialized nations, Neisseria meningitidis holds a prominent position amongst pediatric infections because of the dramatic clinical presentation of the disease, high mortality, epidemic potential and the recent disappearance of many other important infectious diseases in developed countries through improvements in public health and vaccination. The precise nature of natural immunity to meningococci remains unknown, although a complex interaction between the organism and nasopharyngeal mucosal barrier, innate immune mechanisms and acquired immunity is involved. Study of the mechanisms of natural immunity may provide the key to development of vaccines that can reduce the burden of disease in early childhood.

Vaccine trials

This article reviews some of the issues involved in evaluating vaccines in humans. Vaccine trials are required for licensure and are essential for demonstrating a vaccine's safety and protective efficacy. The formal framework of phase I, II, and III trials is described, with particular emphasis on the choice of hypotheses, trial design, and biases that arise in the context of vaccine trials. However, some aspects of a vaccine's performance cannot be evaluated in clinical trials owing to their relatively small size. Thus, vaccine evaluation must continue after licensure, for example, to evaluate the vaccine with respect to rare reactions, duration of protection, and ecological effects. The article reviews some of the methods commonly used for post-licensure studies of vaccine efficacy and safety.

Genetic and immunologic characterization of a novel serotype 4, 15 strain of Neisseria meningitidis

The porin proteins of Neisseria meningitidis are important components of outer membrane protein (OMP) vaccines. The class 3 porin gene, porB, of a novel serogroup B, serotype 4, 15 isolate from Chile (Ch501) was found to be VR1-4, VR2-15, VR3-15 and VR4-15 by porB variable region (VR) typing. Rabbit immunization studies using outer membrane vesicles revealed immunodominance of individual PorB (class 3) VR epitopes. The predominant anti-Ch501 PorB response was directed to the VR1 epitope. Anti-PorB VR1 mediated killing was suggested by the bactericidal activity of Ch501 anti-sera against a type 4 strain not expressing PorA or class 5 OMPs. Studies that examine the molecular epidemiology of individual porB VRs, and the immune responses to PorB epitopes, may contribute to the development of broadly protective group B meningococcal vaccines.

Distribution of Neisseria meningitidis serogroup B serosubtypes and serotypes circulating in the United States. The Active Bacterial Core Surveillance Team

Because the Neisseria meningitidis serogroup B (NMSB) capsule is poorly immunogenic in humans, immunization strategies have focused on noncapsular antigens. Both PorA and to a lesser extent PorB are noncapsular protein antigens capable of inducing protective bactericidal antibodies, and vaccines based on the outer membrane protein (OMP) components of serogroup B meningococci have been shown to be effective in clinical trials. Multiple PorA antigens seem to be needed to prevent endemic meningococcal disease around the world, and a hexavalent PorA-based meningococcal vaccine has recently been developed in The Netherlands. To evaluate the distribution of NMSB PorA and PorB antigens in the United States, serosubtyping and serotyping were done on 444 NMSB strains isolated in the active surveillance areas of the United States (total population, 32 million) during the period 1992 to 1998. A total of 244 strains were isolated from sporadic cases of meningococcal disease, and 200 strains were isolated from an epidemic in Oregon. A panel of 16 mouse monoclonal antibodies reactive with PorA and 15 monoclonal antibodies reactive with PorB were used. Among the NMSB isolates obtained from sporadic cases, the most prevalent serosubtypes were P1.7,16 (14.3%), P1.19,15 (9.8%), P1.7,1 (8.6%), P1.5,2 (7.8%), P1. 22a, 14 (7.8%), and P1.14 (5.3%) and the most prevalent serotypes were 4,7 (27.5%), 15 (16%), 14 (8.6%), 10 (6.1%), 1 (4.9%), and 2a (3.7%). A multivalent PorA-based OMP vaccine aimed at the six most prevalent serosubtypes could have targeted about half of the sporadic cases of NMSB disease that occurred between 1992 and 1998 in the surveillance areas. Twenty serosubtypes would have had to be included in a multivalent vaccine to achieve 80% coverage of strains causing sporadic disease. The relatively large number of isolates that did not react with murine monoclonal antibodies indicates that DNA sequence-based variable region typing of NMSB will be necessary to provide precise information on the distribution and diversity of PorA antigens and correlation with nonserosubtypeable isolates. The high degree of variability observed in the PorA and PorB proteins of NMSB in the United States suggests that vaccine strategies not based on OMPs should be further investigated.

Bactericidal antibody response to Neisseria meningitidis serogroup B in patients with bacterial meningitis: effect of immunization with an outer membrane protein vaccine

We evaluated the bactericidal antibody response to Neisseria meningitidis serogroup B in convalescent patients (n=65) from bacterial meningitis. Patients infected with B meningococci were stratified according to their vaccination status (Cuban BC vaccine) into group 1 (immunized) (n=12) and group 2 (non-immunized) (n=15). The results suggested that antibody titers > or =2 (log(2)) indicate a specific immune response to N. meningitidis. In group 1, 64% of patients had a significant antibody titer (> or =2) in their acute sera against a B:4:P1.15 strain, compared to only 21% of group 2 patients. All patients from group 1 without bactericidal antibodies in their acute sera had a significant increase (at least 2-fold increase in log(2) titers) in antibody titers in their convalescent sera, in contrast, to only 27% of patients from group 2 (P=0.06). Using mutant strains lacking OMP1 or OMP5, it was shown that OMP1 was an important antigen recognized by immunized patients but not by non-immunized patients.

Effect of sequence variation in meningococcal PorA outer membrane protein on the effectiveness of a hexavalent PorA outer membrane vesicle vaccine

Though meningococcal serogroup C conjugate vaccines have been introduced into the UK infant immunisation schedule, there is currently no vaccine solution for serogroup B disease. PorA outer membrane protein (OMP) is a potential serogroup B vaccine candidate. A hexavalent PorA outer membrane vesicle (OMV) vaccine has been evaluated in phase I and II trials with promising results. This vaccine contains six different PorA OMPs each representing a different serosubtype. However, considerable sequence variation occurs in the variable regions (VRs) encoding these serosubtypes. By using recombinant P1.5,10 PorA variants we have demonstrated that the killing of this particular serosubtype combination was due mainly to the induction of antibody to the VR2 (P1.10) epitope region, and that after three or four doses of vaccine there was a significant reduction in the killing of variants P1.10a (three doses, p<0.0001; four doses, p = 0.003) and P1.10f (three doses, p<0.0001; four doses, p = 0.002), as compared to responses to the P1.10 strain, when the P1.10 serosubtype was used as the immunogen. Since large numbers of serosubtype variants are known to exist, this finding may have implications for the use of PorA as a meningococcal serogroup B vaccine.

Update on Haemophilus influenzae serotype b and meningococcal vaccines

Use of conjugate Haemophilus influenzae type b (Hib) vaccines has resulted in the near elimination of Hib invasive disease among infants in the United States in only 10 years, which places this intervention among the most notable public health achievements of the past decade. This has radically altered our perception of the major causes of bacterial meningitis and invasive bacterial disease among children, increasing the prominence of meningococcal disease as an important cause of childhood and adult meningitis and leading researchers to apply the same conjugate technology to the development of improved vaccines for Neisseria meningitidis. Use of conjugated meningococcal vaccines against serogroups A, C, Y, and W-135 are expected to offer the possibility of better control of sporadic disease and outbreaks throughout developed and developing countries within the next 5 years.

Meningococcal disease in Dallas County, Texas: results of a six-year population-based study

OBJECTIVE

Neisseria meningitidis is an important cause of serious bacterial infection in children and adults in the US. From 1992 to 1997 invasive disease caused by N. meningitidis was studied among 1.9 million residents of Dallas County, TX METHODS: The demographic characteristics and diagnoses of 151 patients were identified through active, population-based surveillance and review of medical records. Serogroups were determined for strains infecting 129 (85%) patients.

RESULTS

The average annualized incidence rate was 1.3 cases per 100,000 person years and was highest for children <1 year (13 cases/100,000 person years). Older patients (50+ years old) were more likely to present with pneumonia and less likely to present with meningitis than younger patients. Neither the fatality rate nor the duration of hospitalization for surviving patients was associated with age. Among patients with a known serogroup, serogroup C disease was found in 35% of cases <1 year old, 64% of those 1 to 49 years old and 44% of those 50+ years old. Serogroup B strains were isolated from 26% of patients <1 year, 17% of patients 1 to 49 years old and none of the patients 50+ years old. Serogroup Y disease increased from 22% to 35% of cases between 1992 and 1997 (P = 0.03). This serogroup was identified in 26% of patients <1 year old, 17% of patients 1 to 49 years old and in 50% of patients 50+ years old. Serogroup C and Y accounted for 61% of cases in children <1 year old and for 79% of cases in all age groups.

CONCLUSION

The results underscore the importance of conjugate vaccines for serogroups C and Y.

Identification of vaccine candidates against serogroup B meningococcus by whole-genome sequencing

Neisseria meningitidis is a major cause of bacterial septicemia and meningitis. Sequence variation of surface-exposed proteins and cross-reactivity of the serogroup B capsular polysaccharide with human tissues have hampered efforts to develop a successful vaccine. To overcome these obstacles, the entire genome sequence of a virulent serogroup B strain (MC58) was used to identify vaccine candidates. A total of 350 candidate antigens were expressed in Escherichia coli, purified, and used to immunize mice. The sera allowed the identification of proteins that are surface exposed, that are conserved in sequence across a range of strains, and that induce a bactericidal antibody response, a property known to correlate with vaccine efficacy in humans.

Immunogenicity and safety of a hexavalent meningococcal outer-membrane-vesicle vaccine in children of 2-3 and 7-8 years of age

To study the reactogenicity and immunogenicity of a hexavalent meningococcal outer-membrane-vesicle vaccine (OMV), two different dosages of this vaccine (7.5 and 15 microg of individual PorA proteins) consisting of vesicles expressing class 1 outer-membrane proteins (OMPs) of subtypes P1.7,16; P1.5,2; P1.19,15 and P1.5(c), 10; P1.12,13; P1.7(h),4 were administered to a group of 7-8 year (n=165) and a group of 2-3 year old children (n=172). Control groups of children with similar ages were vaccinated against hepatitis B. All participants received three injections. Pre- and postimmunisation sera were tested for bactericidal antibodies against six isogenic meningococcal vaccine strains expressing different PorA proteins. Antibody titres against OMP of the two different vesicles (PL16215 and PL10124) were measured by ELISA. The meningococcal hexavalent OMV vaccine was well tolerated. No statistically significant differences were seen between the high and low dose of hexavalent meningococcal OMV vaccine. The percentage of children showing a fourfold increase of bactericidal antibody titres against the specific serosubtype varied in toddlers from 28 to 98% and in older children from 16 to 100%. Both ELISA antibody titres and bactericidal activity showed the highest level in the youngest age-group.

Immunogenicity studies with a genetically engineered hexavalent PorA and a wild-type meningococcal group B outer membrane vesicle vaccine in infant cynomolgus monkeys

The immunogenicity of two meningococcal outer membrane vesicle (OMV) vaccines, namely the Norwegian wild-type OMV vaccine and the Dutch hexavalent PorA OMV vaccine, were examined in infant cynomolgus monkeys. For the first time, a wild-type- and a recombinant OMV vaccine were compared. Furthermore, the induction of memory and the persistence of circulating antibodies were measured. The Norwegian vaccine contained all four classes of major outer membrane proteins (OMP) and wild-type L3/L8 lipopolysaccharide (LPS). The Dutch vaccine consisted for 90% of class 1 OMPs, had low expression of class 4 and 5 OMP, and GalE LPS. Three infant monkeys were immunised with a human dose at the age of 1.5, 2.5 and 4.5 months. Two monkeys of each group received a fourth dose at the age of 11 months. In ELISA, both OMV vaccines were immunogenic and induced booster responses, particularly after the fourth immunisation. The Norwegian vaccine mostly induced sero-subtype P1.7,16 specific serum bactericidal antibodies (SBA), although some other SBA were induced as well. The antibody responses against P1.7,16, induced by the Norwegian vaccine, were generally higher than for the Dutch vaccine. However, the Dutch vaccine induced PorA specific SBA against all six sero-subtypes included in the vaccine showing differences in the magnitude of SBA responses to the various PorAs.

Molecular mimetics of polysaccharide epitopes as vaccine candidates for prevention of Neisseria meningitidis serogroup B disease

Neisseria meningitidis is a major cause of meningitis and sepsis. Despite nearly 25 years of work, there is no promising vaccine candidate for prevention of disease caused by meningococcal B strains. This review summarizes newer approaches for eliciting protective meningococcal B immune responses, including the use of molecular mimetics of group B polysaccharide and conserved membrane proteins as immunogens. The capsular polysaccharide of this organism is conserved and serum antibody to this capsule confers protection against disease. However, the immunogenicity of meningococcal B polysaccharide-based vaccines is poor. Further, a portion of the antibody elicited has autoantibody activity. Recently, our laboratory produced a panel of murine monoclonal antibodies (Mabs) that react specifically with capsular polysaccharide epitopes on meningococcal B that are distinct from host polysialic acid. These Mabs elicit complement-mediated bactericidal activity and confer passive protection in animal models. The anti-capsular Mabs were used to identify molecular mimetics from phage display peptide libraries. The resulting peptides were antigenic mimetics as defined by binding to the Mabs used to select them but, to date, are poor immunogenic mimetics in failing to elicit anti-capsular antibodies.

Differences in surface expression of NspA among Neisseria meningitidis group B strains

NspA is a highly conserved membrane protein that is reported to elicit protective antibody responses against Neisseria meningitidis serogroups A, B and C in mice (D. Martin, N. Cadieux, J. Hanel, and B. R. Brodeur, J. Exp. Med. 185:1173-1183, 1997). To investigate the vaccine potential of NspA, we produced mouse anti-recombinant NspA (rNspA) antisera, which were used to evaluate the accessibility of NspA epitopes on the surface of different serogroup B strains by an immunofluorescence flow cytometric assay and by susceptibility to antibody-dependent, complement-mediated bacteriolysis. Among 17 genetically diverse strains tested, 11 (65%) were positive for NspA cell surface epitopes and 6 (35%) were negative. All six negative strains also were resistant to bactericidal activity induced by the anti-rNspA antiserum. In contrast, of the 11 NspA surface-positive strains, 8 (73%; P < 0.05) were killed by the antiserum and complement. In infant rats challenged with one of these eight strains, the anti-rNspA antiserum conferred protection against bacteremia, whereas the antiserum failed to protect rats challenged by one of the six NspA cell surface-negative strains. Neither NspA expression nor protein sequence accounted for differences in NspA surface accessibility, since all six negative strains expressed NspA in outer membrane preparations and since their predicted NspA amino acid sequences were 99 to 100% identical to those of three representative positive strains. However, the six NspA cell surface-negative strains produced, on average, larger amounts of group B polysaccharide than did the 11 positive strains (reciprocal geometric mean titers, 676 and 224, respectively; P < 0.05), which suggests that the capsule may limit the accessibility of NspA surface epitopes. Given these strain differences in NspA surface accessibility, an rNspA-based meningococcal B vaccine may have to be supplemented by additional antigens.

Prophylaxis of bacterial meningitis

A comprehensive review of all major agents causing bacterial meningitis--meningococcus of the groups A, B, C, W135, and Y, pneumococcus, and Haemophilus influenzae type B (Hib)--is done in terms of preventing them by chemoprophylaxis or vaccination. Some evidence suggests that the group B meningococcal disease may also be very likely preventable by a vaccine that is already available. Excellent Hib conjugates use a technique that is expected to revolutionize immunoprophylaxis against most meningococcal and pneumococcal diseases in the near future. Unfortunately, the high cost of conjugate vaccines restricts their use in many poor countries.