The RNA-DNA hybrid maintains the register of transcription by preventing backtracking of RNA polymerase

A structural model of transcription elongation

The path of the nucleic acids through a transcription elongation complex was tracked by mapping cross-links between bacterial RNA polymerase (RNAP) and transcript RNA or template DNA onto the x-ray crystal structure. In the resulting model, the downstream duplex DNA is nestled in a trough formed by the beta' subunit and enclosed on top by the beta subunit. In the RNAP channel, the RNA/DNA hybrid extends from the enzyme active site, along a region of the beta subunit harboring rifampicin resistance mutations, to the beta' subunit "rudder." The single-stranded RNA is then extruded through another channel formed by the beta-subunit flap domain. The model provides insight into the functional properties of the transcription complex.

Pausing by bacterial RNA polymerase is mediated by mechanistically distinct classes of signals

Transcript elongation by RNA polymerase is discontinuous and interrupted by pauses that play key regulatory roles. We show here that two different classes of pause signals punctuate elongation. Class I pauses, discovered in enteric bacteria, depend on interaction of a nascent RNA structure with RNA polymerase to displace the 3' OH away from the catalytic center. Class II pauses, which may predominate in eukaryotes, cause RNA polymerase to slide backwards along DNA and RNA and to occlude the active site with nascent RNA. These pauses differ in their responses to antisense oligonucleotides, pyrophosphate, GreA, and general elongation factors NusA and NusG. In contrast, substitutions in RNA polymerase that increase or decrease the rate of RNA synthesis affect both pause classes similarly. We propose that both pause classes, as well as arrest and termination, arise from a common intermediate that itself binds NTP substrate weakly.

Interference footprinting analysis of telomerase elongation complexes

Telomerase is a reverse transcriptase that adds single-stranded telomeric repeats to the ends of linear eukaryotic chromosomes. It consists of an RNA molecule including a template sequence, a protein subunit containing reverse transcriptase motifs, and auxiliary proteins. We have carried out an interference footprinting analysis of the Tetrahymena telomerase elongation complexes. In this study, single-stranded oligonucleotide primers containing telomeric sequences were modified with base-specific chemical reagents and extended with the telomerase by a single (32)P-labeled dGMP or dTMP. Base modifications that interfered with the primer extension reactions were mapped by footprinting. Major functional interactions were detected between the telomerase and the six or seven 3'-terminal residues of the primers. These interactions occurred not only with the RNA template region, but also with another region in the enzyme ribonucleoprotein complex designated the telomerase DNA interacting surface (TDIS). This was indicated by footprints generated with dimethyl sulfate (that did not affect Watson-Crick hydrogen bonding) and by footprinting assays performed with mutant primers. In primers aligned at a distance of 2 nucleotides along the RNA template region, the footprints of the six or seven 3'-terminal residues were shifted by 2 nucleotides. This shift indicated that during the elongation reaction, TDIS moved in concert with the 3' ends of the primers relative to the template region. Weak interactions occurred between the telomerase and residues located upstream of the seventh nucleotide. These interactions were stronger in primers that were impaired in the ability to align with the template.

DNA melting and promoter clearance by eukaryotic RNA polymerase I

Ribosomal RNA transcription initiation requires the melting of DNA to form an open complex, formation of the first few phosphodiester bonds, commencement of RNA polymerase I movement along the DNA, clearance of the promoter, and the formation of a steady-state ternary elongation complex. We examined DNA melting and promoter clearance by using potassium permanganate, diethylpyrocarbonate and methidiumpropylEDTA.Fe(II) footprinting. In combination, these methods demonstrated: (1) TIF-IB and RNA polymerase I are the only proteins required for formation of an initial approximately 9 base-pair open promoter region. This finding contradicts earlier results using diethylpyrocarbonate alone, which suggested an RNA synthesis requirement for stable melting. (2) DNA melting is temperature-dependent, with a tm between 15 and 20 degrees C. (3) Temperature-dependency of melting, as well as stalling the polymerase at sites close to the transcription start site revealed that the melted DNA region initially opens upstream of the transcription initiation site, and enlarges in a downstream direction coordinate with initiation, eventually attaining a steady-state transcription bubble of approximately 19 base-pairs. (4) The RNA-DNA hybrid protects the template DNA from single-strand footprinting reagents. The hybrid is 9 bp in length, consistent with the longer hybrid estimated by some for the Escherichia coli polymerase and with the hybrids estimated for eukaryotic polymerases II and III.

Regulation of rho-dependent transcription termination by NusG is specific to the Escherichia coli elongation complex

To terminate transcription in E. coli, Rho protein binds an RNA loading site on the nascent transcript, translocates 5'--> 3' along the RNA in an ATP-driven process, and, upon reaching the transcription elongation complex, brings about RNA release. Thus, the Rho-dependent termination process can be viewed, in part, as a kinetic competition between the rate of transcript elongation by RNA polymerase (RNAP) and the rate of Rho translocation along the nascent transcript. In the context of this model, NusG, which is an essential E. coli protein, regulates Rho-dependent termination in an apparently paradoxical way, increasing the rate of transcription elongation of E. coli RNAP in the absence of Rho while also shifting the sites of Rho-dependent termination upstream on the template. Here we investigate the regulation of Rho-dependent termination by NusG. Analytical ultracentrifugation was used to establish the existence of a stable complex of NusG and Rho and to demonstrate a stoichiometry of one NusG monomer per Rho hexamer. Surface plasmon resonance was used to examine the kinetics of the formation and dissociation of the NusG-Rho complex, yielding an association rate constant (k(on)) of 2.8 (+/-0.8) x 10(5) M(-)(1) s(-)(1), a dissociation rate constant (k(off)) of 3.9 (+/-0.7) x 10(-)(3) s(-)(1), and a calculated equilibrium (dissociation) constant (K(d)) of 1.5 (+/-0.3) x 10(-)(8) M. The apparent stability of the NusG-Rho complex is insensitive to changes in salt (potassium acetate) concentration between 0.05 and 0.15 M. The translocation and transcription termination activities of Rho at saturating NusG concentrations were, however, both sensitive to salt concentration over this range, suggesting that these activities do not directly reflect the stability of the NusG-Rho complex. Rho-dependent termination could be demonstrated for transcription complexes in which E. coli RNAP had been substituted by either bacteriophage SP6 or T7 RNAP. NusG, however, was not active in transcription termination assays with either of these phage RNAPs. Thus, we conclude that NusG modulates Rho-dependent termination by interacting specifically with the RNAP of the E. coli elongation complex to render the complex more susceptible to the termination activity of Rho.

The functional role of basic patch, a structural element of Escherichia coli transcript cleavage factors GreA and GreB

The transcript cleavage factors GreA and GreB of Escherichia coli are involved in the regulation of transcription elongation. The surface charge distribution analysis of their three-dimensional structures revealed that the N-terminal domains of GreA and GreB contain a small and large basic "patch," respectively. To elucidate the functional role of basic patch, mutant Gre proteins were engineered in which the size and charge distribution of basic patch were modified and characterized biochemically. We found that Gre mutants lacking basic patch or carrying basic patch of decreased size bind to RNA polymerase and induce transcript cleavage reaction in minimally backtracked ternary elongation complex (TEC) with the same efficiency as the wild type factors. However, they exhibit substantially lower readthrough and cleavage activities toward extensively backtracked and arrested TECs and display decreased efficiency of photocross-linking to the RNA 3'-terminus. Unlike wild type factors, basic patch-less Gre mutants are unable to complement the thermosensitive phenotype of GreA(-):GreB(-) E. coli strain. The large basic patch is required but not sufficient for the induction of GreB-type cleavage reaction and for the cleavage of arrested TECs. Our results demonstrate that the basic patch residues are not directly involved in the induction of transcript cleavage reaction and suggest that the primary role of basic patch is to anchor the nascent RNA in TEC. These interactions are essential for the readthrough and antiarrest activities of Gre factors and, apparently, for their in vivo functions.

Polymerase arrest at the lambdaP(R) promoter during transcription initiation

During transcription initiation by Escherichia coli RNA polymerase, a fraction of the homogeneous enzyme population has been kinetically shown to form two types of nonproductive complexes at some promoters: moribund complexes, which produce only abortive transcripts, and fully inactive ternary complexes (Kubori, T., and Shimamoto, N. (1996) J. Mol. Biol. 256, 449-457). Here we report biochemical isolation of the complexes arrested at the lambdaP(R) promoter and an analysis of their structure by DNA and protein footprintings. We found that the isolated promoter-arrested complexes retain a stoichiometric amount of sigma(70) subunit. Exonuclease III footprints of the arrested complexes are backtracked compared with that of the binary complex, and KMnO(4) footprinting reveals a decrease in the melting of DNA in the promoter region. Protein footprints of the retained sigma(70) have shown a more exposed conformation in region 3, compared with binary complexes. This feature is similar to that of the complexes arrested in inactive state during transcription elongation, indicating the existence of a common inactivating mechanism during transcription initiation and elongation. The possible involvement of the promoter arrest in transcriptional regulation is discussed.

Single-molecule study of transcriptional pausing and arrest by E. coli RNA polymerase

Using an optical-trap/flow-control video microscopy technique, we followed transcription by single molecules of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase in real time over long template distances. These studies reveal that RNA polymerase molecules possess different intrinsic transcription rates and different propensities to pause and stop. The data also show that reversible pausing is a kinetic intermediate between normal elongation and the arrested state. The conformational metastability of RNA polymerase revealed by this single-molecule study of transcription has direct implications for the mechanisms of gene regulation in both bacteria and eukaryotes.

Mapping the bacterial cell architecture into the chromosome

A genome is not a simple collection of genes. We propose here that it can be viewed as being organized as a 'celluloculus' similar to the homunculus of preformists, but pertaining to the category of programmes (or algorithms) rather than to that of architectures or structures: a significant correlation exists between the distribution of genes along the chromosome and the physical architecture of the cell. We review here data supporting this observation, stressing physical constraints operating on the cell's architecture and dynamics, and their consequences in terms of gene and genome structure. If such a correlation exists, it derives from some selection pressure: simple and general physical principles acting at the level of the cell structure are discussed. As a first case in point we see the piling up of planar modules as a stable, entropy-driven, architectural principle that could be at the root of the coupling between the architecture of the cell and the location of genes at specific places in the chromosome. We propose that the specific organization of certain genes whose products have a general tendency to form easily planar modules is a general motor for architectural organization in the bacterial cell. A second mechanism, operating at the transcription level, is described that could account for the efficient building up of complex structures. As an organizing principle we suggest that exploration by biological polymers of the vast space of possible conformation states is constrained by anchoring points. In particular, we suggest that transcription does not always allow the 5'-end of the transcript to go free and explore the many conformations available, but that, in many cases, it remains linked to the transcribing RNA polymerase complex in such a way that loops of RNA, rather than threads with a free end, explore the surrounding medium. In bacteria, extension of the loops throughout the cytoplasm would therefore be mediated by the de novo synthesis of ribosomes in growing cells. Termination of transcription and mRNA turnover would accordingly be expected to be controlled by sequence features at both the 3'- and 5'-ends of the molecule. These concepts are discussed taking into account in vitro analysis of genome sequences and experimental data about cell compartmentalization, mRNA folding and turnover, as well as known structural features of protein and membrane complexes.

Nonlinearity in genetic decoding: homologous DNA replicase genes use alternatives of transcriptional slippage or translational frameshifting

The tau and gamma subunits of DNA polymerase III are both encoded by a single gene in Escherichia coli and Thermus thermophilus. gamma is two-thirds the size of tau and shares virtually all its amino acid sequence with tau. E. coli and T. thermophilus have evolved very different mechanisms for setting the approximate 1:1 ratio between tau and gamma. Both mechanisms put ribosomes into alternate reading frames so that stop codons in the new frame serve to make the smaller gamma protein. In E. coli, approximately 50% of initiating ribosomes translate the dnaX mRNA conventionally to give tau, but the other 50% shift into the -1 reading frame at a specific site (A AAA AAG) in the mRNA to produce gamma. In T. thermophilus ribosomal frameshifting is not required: the dnaX mRNA is a heterogeneous population of molecules with different numbers of A residues arising from transcriptional slippage on a run of nine T residues in the DNA template. Translation of the subpopulation containing nine As (or +/- multiples of three As) yields tau. The rest of the population of mRNAs (containing nine +/- nonmultiples of three As) puts ribosomes into the alternate reading frames to produce the gamma protein(s). It is surprising that two rather similar dnaX sequences in E. coli and T. thermophilus lead to very different mechanisms of expression.

Binding of transcription termination protein nun to nascent RNA and template DNA

The amino-terminal arginine-rich motif of coliphage HK022 Nun binds phage lambda nascent transcript, whereas the carboxyl-terminal domain interacts with RNA polymerase (RNAP) and blocks transcription elongation. RNA binding is inhibited by zinc (Zn2+) and stimulated by Escherichia coli NusA. To study these interactions, the Nun carboxyl terminus was extended by a cysteine residue conjugated to a photochemical cross-linker. The carboxyl terminus contacted NusA and made Zn2+-dependent intramolecular contacts. When Nun was added to a paused transcription elongation complex, it cross-linked to the DNA template. Nun may arrest transcription by anchoring RNAP to DNA.

RNA sequence and secondary structural determinants in a minimal viral promoter that directs replicase recognition and initiation of genomic plus-strand RNA synthesis

Viral RNA replication provides a useful system to study the structure and function of RNAs and the mechanism of RNA synthesis from RNA templates. Previously we demonstrated that a 27 nt RNA from brome mosaic virus (BMV) can direct correct initiation of genomic plus-strand RNA synthesis by the BMV replicase. In this study, using biochemical, nuclear magnetic resonance, and thermodynamic analyses, we determined that the secondary structure of this 27 nt RNA can be significantly altered and retain the ability to direct RNA synthesis. In contrast, we find that position-specific changes in the RNA sequence will affect replicase recognition, modulate the polymerization process, and contribute to the differential accumulation of viral RNAs. These functional results are in agreement with the phylogenetic analysis of BMV and related viral sequences and suggest that a similar mechanism of RNA synthesis takes place for members of the alphavirus superfamily.

Nonequilibrium mechanism of transcription termination from observations of single RNA polymerase molecules

Cessation of transcription at specific terminator DNA sequences is used by viruses, bacteria, and eukaryotes to regulate the expression of downstream genes, but the mechanisms of transcription termination are poorly characterized. To elucidate the kinetic mechanism of termination at the intrinsic terminators of enteric bacteria, we observed, by using single-molecule light microscopy techniques, the behavior of surface-immobilized Escherichia coli RNA polymerase (RNAP) molecules in vitro. An RNAP molecule remains at a canonical intrinsic terminator for approximately 64 s before releasing DNA, implying the formation of an elongation-incompetent (paused) intermediate by transcription complexes that terminate but not by those that read through the terminator. Analysis of pause lifetimes establishes a complete minimal mechanism of termination in which paused intermediate formation is both necessary and sufficient to induce release of RNAP at the terminator. The data suggest that intrinsic terminators function by a nonequilibrium process in which terminator effectiveness is determined by the relative rates of nucleotide addition and paused state entry by the transcription complex.

Yeast RNA polymerase II at 5 A resolution

Appropriate treatment of X-ray diffraction from an unoriented 18-heavy atom cluster derivative of a yeast RNA polymerase II crystal gave significant phase information to 5 A resolution. The validity of the phases was shown by close similarity of a 6 A electron density map to a 16 A molecular envelope of the polymerase from electron crystallography. Comparison of the 6 A X-ray map with results of electron crystallography of a paused transcription elongation complex suggests functional roles for two mobile protein domains: the tip of a flexible arm forms a downstream DNA clamp; and a hinged domain may serve as an RNA clamp, enclosing the transcript from about 8-18 residues upstream of the 3'-end in a tunnel.

Crystal structure of Thermus aquaticus core RNA polymerase at 3.3 A resolution

The X-ray crystal structure of Thermus aquaticus core RNA polymerase reveals a "crab claw"-shaped molecule with a 27 A wide internal channel. Located on the back wall of the channel is a Mg2+ ion required for catalytic activity, which is chelated by an absolutely conserved motif from all bacterial and eukaryotic cellular RNA polymerases. The structure places key functional sites, defined by mutational and cross-linking analysis, on the inner walls of the channel in close proximity to the active center Mg2+. Further out from the catalytic center, structural features are found that may be involved in maintaining the melted transcription bubble, clamping onto the RNA product and/or DNA template to assure processivity, and delivering nucleotide substrates to the active center.

Escherichia coli RNA polymerase translocation is accompanied by periodic bending of the DNA

RNA polymerase was halted in consecutive registers of RNA synthesis ranging from registers 11 to 68. Non-denaturing gel electrophoresis shows that the mobility of the complexes varies (up to 15%), indicating that halted complexes differ in their conformation. The electrophoretic mobility changes with an approximate 10-register periodicity. The change of the mobility can be attributed to relative changes of RNA polymerase-induced bending angle. We suggest that the periodicity of the bending angle reflects periodic changes of the conformation of the halted complexes that might have relevance for the translocation mechanism.

Structural characterization of RNA polymerase II complexes arrested by a cyclobutane pyrimidine dimer in the transcribed strand of template DNA

We have characterized the properties of immunopurified transcription complexes arrested at a specifically located cyclobutane pyrimidine dimer (CPD) using enzymatic probes and an in vitro transcription system with purified RNA polymerase II (RNAP II) and initiation factors. To help understand how RNAP II distinguishes between a natural impediment and a lesion in the DNA to initiate a repair event, we have compared the conformation of RNAP II complexes arrested at a CPD with complexes arrested at a naturally occurring elongation impediment. The footprint of RNAP II arrested at a CPD, using exonuclease III and T4 DNA polymerase's 3'-->5' exonuclease, covers approximately 35 base pairs and is asymmetrically located around the dimer. A similar footprint is observed when RNAP II is arrested at the human histone H3.3 arrest site. Addition of elongation factor SII to RNAP II arrested at a CPD produced shortened transcripts of discrete lengths up to 25 nucleotides shorter than those seen without SII. After addition of photolyase and exposure to visible light, some of the transcripts could be reelongated beyond the dimer, suggesting that SII-mediated transcript cleavage accompanied significant RNAP II backup, thereby providing access of the repair enzyme to the arresting CPD.

Mapping interactions of Escherichia coli GreB with RNA polymerase and ternary elongation complexes

Escherichia coli GreA and GreB modulate transcription elongation by interacting with the ternary elongation complex (containing RNA polymerase, DNA template, and RNA transcript) to induce hydrolytic cleavage of the transcript and release of the 3'-terminal fragment. Hydroxyl radical protein footprinting and alanine-scanning mutagenesis were used to investigate the interactions of GreB with RNA polymerase alone and in a ternary elongation complex. A major determinant for binding GreB to both RNA polymerase and the ternary elongation complex was identified. In addition, the hydroxyl radical footprinting indicated major conformational changes of GreB, in terms of reorientations of the N- and C-terminal domains with respect to each other, particularly upon interactions with the ternary elongation complex.

Nucleotide sequences surrounding the nonanucleotide promoter motif influence the activity of yeast mitochondrial promoter

The highly conserved nonanucleotide (5'-TATAAGTAA[+2]) promoter sequence dictates initiation of gene-specific transcription by the mitochondrial (mt) RNA polymerase in yeast mitochondria. However, transcriptional efficiency of the nonanucleotide promoter in different mt genes varies severalfold. To explore the regulatory role of the promoter-proximal template sequence in mt transcription, different deletion, nucleotide (nt) substitution, and tandem promoter constructs were analyzed under in vitro transcription reaction conditions. It has been found that the conserved nonanucleotide promoter plus more than 9 nt of nonconserved sequence 3' to the promoter were absolutely essential for mt gene-specific transcription. In addition, approximately 300 nt of nonspecific DNA sequence 5' to the promoter was also important for efficient transcription. Interestingly, introduction of consecutive T residues in the early transcribed sequence of the template strongly inhibited mt transcription at low nt concentrations (i.e., 5 microM UTP). In contrast, neither other nt clusters nor a bacterial terminator-like sequences at that location inhibited mt transcription. Under the nonproductive reaction conditions, the full-length transcript from the mt polyT template was drastically reduced with the formation of several short abortive oligoribonucleotides. These results suggest that the transcriptional efficacy of the yeast mt promoter is influenced by sequence 3' to the promoter.

Characterization of structural features important for T7 RNAP elongation complex stability reveals competing complex conformations and a role for the non-template strand in RNA displacement

We have characterized the roles of the phage T7 RNA polymerase (RNAP) thumb subdomain and the RNA binding activity of the N-terminal domain in elongation complex (EC) stability by evaluating how disrupting these structures affects the dissociation rates of halted ECs. Our results reveal distinct roles for these elements in EC stabilization. On supercoiled or partially single-stranded templates the enzyme with a deletion of the thumb subdomain is exceptionally unstable. However, on linear duplex templates the polymerase which has been proteolytically cleaved within the N-terminal domain is the most unstable. The differences in the effects of these RNAP modifications on the stability of ECs on the different templates appear to be due to differences in EC structure: on the linear duplex templates the RNA is properly displaced from the DNA, but on the supercoiled or partially single-stranded templates an extended RNA:DNA hybrid makes a larger contribution to the conformational state of the EC. The halted EC can therefore exist either in a conformation in which the RNA is displaced from the DNA and forms an interaction with the RNAP, or in a conformation in which a more extended RNA:DNA hybrid is present and the RNA:RNAP interaction is less extensive. The partitioning between these competing conformations appears to be a function of the energetics of template reannealing and the relative strengths of the RNA:RNAP interaction and the RNA:DNA hybrid.

The versatility of paramyxovirus RNA polymerase stuttering

Paramyxoviruses cotranscriptionally edit their P gene mRNAs by expanding the number of Gs of a conserved AnGn run. Different viruses insert different distributions of guanylates, e.g., Sendai virus inserts a single G, whereas parainfluenza virus type 3 inserts one to six Gs. The sequences conserved at the editing site, as well as the experimental evidence, suggest that the insertions occur by a stuttering process, i.e., by pseudotemplated transcription. The number of times the polymerase "stutters" at the editing site before continuing strictly templated elongation is directed by a cis-acting sequence found upstream of the insertions. We have examined the stuttering process during natural virus infections by constructing recombinant Sendai viruses with mutations in their cis-acting sequences. We found that the template stutter site is precisely determined (C1052) and that a relatively short region (approximately 6 nucleotides) just upstream of the AnGn run can modulate the overall frequency of mRNA editing as well as the distribution of the nucleotide insertions. The positions more proximal to the 5' AnGn run are the most important in this respect. We also provide evidence that the stability of the mRNA/template hybrid plays a determining role in the overall frequency and range of mRNA editing. When the template U run is extended all the way to the stutter site, adenylates rather than guanylates are added at the editing site and their distribution begins to resemble the polyadenylation associated with mRNA 3' end formation by the viral polymerase. Our data suggest how paramyxovirus mRNA editing and polyadenylation are related mechanistically and how editing sites may have evolved from poly(A)-termination sites or vice versa.

Characterization of the effects of Escherichia coli replication terminator protein (Tus) on transcription reveals dynamic nature of the tus block to transcription complex progression

We have characterized the blocks to progression of T7 and T3 RNA polymerase transcription complexes created when a Tus protein is bound to the template. The encounter with Tus impedes the progress of the transcription complexes of either enzyme. The duration of the block depends on which polymerase is used and the orientation of Tus on the DNA. Both genuine termination (dissociation of the transcription complex) and halting followed by continued progression after the block is abrogated are observed. The fraction of complexes that terminates depends on which polymerase is used and on the orientation of the Tus molecule. The efficiency of the block to transcription increases as the Tus concentration is increased, even if the concentration of Tus is already many times in excess of what is required to saturate its binding sites on the template in the absence of transcription. The block to transcription is rapidly abrogated if an excess of a DNA containing a binding site for Tus is added to a transcription reaction in which Tus and template have been preincubated. Finally, we find that transcription will rapidly displace Tus from a template under conditions that generate persistent blocks to transcription. These observations reveal that during the encounter with the transcription complex Tus rapidly dissociates from the template but that at sufficiently high concentrations Tus usually rebinds before the transcription complex can move forward. The advantage of a mechanism which can create a persistent block to transcription or replication complex progression, which can nevertheless be rapidly abrogated in response to down regulation of the blocking protein, is suggested.

Determinants of the stability of transcription elongation complexes: interactions of the nascent RNA with the DNA template and the RNA polymerase

We use a synthetic "primed bubble-duplex" model elongation complex developed previously to examine certain structural and thermodynamic features of the transcription elongation complex of Escherichia coli. The nucleic acid framework of this model complex consists of a linear base-paired DNA molecule with a central "bubble" of non-complementary nucleotide residues, together with a single-stranded RNA molecule that is complementary (at its 3'-end) to three to 12 nucleotide residues of one of the DNA strands within the bubble. RNA polymerase is added to this framework in trans, and on addition of rNTPs the resulting complex can elongate the 3'-end of the RNA primer in a template-dependent manner with functional properties that are indistinguishable from those of a "natural" promoter-initiated transcription elongation complex operating under the same conditions. In this study we use this model system to show that the formation of a stable elongation complex at any particular template position can be treated as an equilibrium process, and that semi-quantitative dissociation constants can be estimated for the complex by using a gel band-shift assay to monitor the binding of the RNA oligomer to the complex. We then show that the formation of a stable complex depends on the presence of a complementary RNA-DNA hybrid that is at least 9 bp in length, and in addition that several nucleotide residues of non-complementary RNA located upstream of the RNA-DNA hybrid bind strongly to the putative single-stranded RNA binding site of the polymerase and significantly enhance the stability of the resulting elongation complex. Finally, we demonstrate that the measured stabilities of the model constructs in which the length of the RNA-DNA hybrid is varied correlate well with the transcriptional processivity of the functioning complex that results when rNTPs are added. These findings are discussed in the context of related studies of both model systems and natural elongation complexes. The general concepts that emerge are used to define some central structural and functional features of the transcription complex.

DNA bending and wrapping around RNA polymerase: a "revolutionary" model describing transcriptional mechanisms

A model is proposed in which bending and wrapping of DNA around RNA polymerase causes untwisting of the DNA helix at the RNA polymerase catalytic center to stimulate strand separation prior to initiation. During elongation, DNA bending through the RNA polymerase active site is proposed to lower the energetic barrier to the advance of the transcription bubble. Recent experiments with mammalian RNA polymerase II along with accumulating evidence from studies of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase indicate the importance of DNA bending and wrapping in transcriptional mechanisms. The DNA-wrapping model describes specific roles for general RNA polymerase II transcription factors (TATA-binding protein [TBP], TFIIB, TFIIF, TFIIE, and TFIIH), provides a plausible explanation for preinitiation complex isomerization, suggests mechanisms underlying the synergy between transcriptional activators, and suggests an unforseen role for TBP-associating factors in transcription.

Hypermutation in derepressed operons of Escherichia coli K12

This article presents evidence that starvation for leucine in an Escherichia coli auxotroph triggers metabolic activities that specifically target the leu operon for derepression, increased rates of transcription, and mutation. Derepression of the leu operon was a prerequisite for its activation by the signal nucleotide, guanosine tetraphosphate, which accumulates in response to nutritional stress (the stringent response). A quantitative correlation was established between leuB mRNA abundance and leuB- reversion rates. To further demonstrate that derepression increased mutation rates, the chromosomal leu operon was placed under the control of the inducible tac promoter. When the leu operon was induced by isopropyl-D-thiogalactoside, both leuB mRNA abundance and leuB- reversion rates increased. These investigations suggest that guanosine tetraphosphate may contribute as much as attenuation in regulating leu operon expression and that higher rates of mutation are specifically associated with the derepressed leu operon.

Initially transcribed sequences strongly affect the extent of abortive initiation by RNA polymerase II

We investigated transcript initiation and early elongation by RNA polymerase II using templates mismatched between -9 and +3 (bubble templates). Highly purified RNA polymerase II alone was able to initiate transcription specifically on these templates in the presence of dinucleotide primers. The length distribution of abortively initiated RNAs was similar for purified RNA polymerase II on bubble templates and polymerase II on double-stranded templates in HeLa nuclear extracts. Increasing the U content in the initial portion of the transcript caused similar increases in abortive initiation for transcription of bubble templates by pure polymerase and double-stranded templates in extracts. Thus, the level of abortive initiation by RNA polymerase II is at least partly determined by interactions of the polymerase with the transcript and/or the template, independent of the general transcription factors. Substitution of 5-bromo-UTP for UTP reduced abortive initiation on bubble templates, consistent with the idea that transcription complex stability during early elongation depends on the strength of the initial RNA-DNA hybrid. Interestingly, transcription of bubble templates in HeLa extracts gave very high levels of abortive initiation, suggesting that inability to reanneal the initially melted template segment inhibits transcript elongation in the presence of the initiation factors.

Transcription elongation: structural basis and mechanisms

A ternary complex composed of RNA polymerase (RNAP), DNA template, and RNA transcript is the central intermediate in the transcription cycle responsible for the elongation of the RNA chain. Although the basic biochemistry of RNAP functioning is well understood, little is known about the underlying structural determinants. The absence of high- resolution structural data has hampered our understanding of RNAP mechanism. However, recent work suggests a structure-function model of the ternary elongation complex, if not at a defined structural level, then at least as a conceptual view, such that key components of RNAP are defined operationally on the basis of compelling biochemical, protein chemical, and genetic data. The model has important implications for mechanisms of transcription elongation and also for initiation and termination.

Mechanism of intrinsic transcription termination and antitermination

Gene expression is modulated by regulatory elements that influence transcription elongation by RNA polymerase: terminators that disrupt the elongation complex and release RNA, and regulators that overcome termination signals. RNA release from Escherichia coli RNA polymerase can be induced by a complementary oligonucleotide that replaces the upstream half of the RNA hairpin stem of intrinsic terminator transcripts, implying that RNA hairpins act by extracting RNA from the transcription complex. A transcription antiterminator inhibits this activity of oligonucleotides and therefore protects the elongation complex from destabilizing attacks on the emerging transcript. These effects illuminate the structure of the complex and the mechanism of transcription termination.

The mechanism of intrinsic transcription termination

In bacteria, an intrinsic transcription termination signal appears in RNA as a hairpin followed by approximately eight uridines (U stretch) at the 3' terminus. This signal leads to rapid dissociation of the ternary elongation complex (TEC) into RNA, DNA, and an RNA polymerase. We demonstrate that the hairpin inactivates and then destabilizes TEC by weakening interactions in the RNA-DNA hybrid-binding site and the RNA-binding site that hold TEC together. Formation of the hairpin is restricted to the moment when TEC reaches the point of termination and depends upon melting of four to five hybrid base pairs that follow the hairpin's stem. The U stretch-induced pausing at the point of termination is crucial, providing additional time for hairpin formation. These results explain the mechanism of termination and aid in understanding of how cellular factors modulate this process.

Regulation of intrinsic terminator by translation in Escherichia coli: transcription termination at a distance downstream

BACKGROUND

Rho-independent terminators in Escherichia coli are DNA sequences of 30-50 bp consisting of a GC-rich dyad symmetry sequence followed by a run of T residues in the nontemplate strand. The transcription termination at the Rho-independent terminator occurs within the T-tract in vitro. It has been believed that the transcription termination at the Rho-independent terminator occurs within the T-tract in vivo, as established in vitro, and therefore the 3' ends of mRNAs are mostly generated as a direct result of transcription termination. However, how the transcription termination occurs and how the 3' ends of mRNAs are formed in living cells remains to be studied.

RESULTS

We developed a double terminator system in which a second Rho-independent terminator was placed downstream of the crp terminator. This system made it possible to detect transcripts that pass through the crp terminator by Northern blotting. We found that most of the crp transcripts extend beyond the crp terminator. The transcriptional read-through at the crp terminator was reduced when the translation of crp mRNA was interrupted. The level of the read-through transcript decreased with distance between the two terminators, suggesting that transcription termination occurs at multiple positions beyond the crp terminator.

CONCLUSION

We conclude that most RNA polymerase reads through the crp terminator in the natural situation and terminates transcription over a wide region downstream of the crp terminator, resulting in heterogeneous primary transcripts that are subsequently processed back to the terminator hairpin. We propose that ribosome translation to the crp stop codon causes read-through of the terminator. The regulatory effect of translation on Rho-independent termination may be a general phenomenon at other operons.

Structural analysis of ternary complexes of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase: ribonuclease footprinting of the nascent RNA in complexes

Ternary complexes of RNA polymerase containing the DNA template and nascent RNA are the intermediates in transcript elongation in all cells. We have footprinted the RNA transcript with single-strand-specific ribonucleases in ternary complexes of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase. When complexes are treated with elevated levels of ribonucleases A and T1, the nascent transcript can be cleaved to within 3-4 nucleotides of the 3'-terminus. Ternary complexes containing ribonuclease-cleaved transcripts as short as 3 nucleotides remain stable and active, ensuring that the cleavage occurred within an active ternary complex. However, cleavage by ribonuclease I is restricted, and gives a limited digest product of about 16 nt. At lower concentrations of ribonuclease T1, two regions of partial protection are seen. The first region extends through the first 15-16 nucleotides from the 3'-OH terminus; the second region extends from position 30 out to position 45. We interpret these regions of partial protection as defining two RNA product binding sites on the RNA polymerase that bind the product to the enzyme during elongation. Our results rule out the existence of a stable RNA-DNA hybrid in these ternary complexes of greater than 3 base pairs in length.

Functional topography of nascent RNA in elongation intermediates of RNA polymerase

To determine the dynamics of transcript extrusion from Escherichia coli RNA polymerase (RNAP), we used degradation of the RNA by RNases T1 and A in a series of consecutive elongation complexes (ECs). In intact ECs, even extremely high doses of the RNases were unable to cut the RNA closer than 14-16 nt from the 3' end. Our results prove that all of the cuts detected within the 14-nt zone are derived from the EC that is denatured during inactivation of the RNases. The protected zone monotonously translocates along the RNA after addition of new nucleotides to the transcript. The upstream region of the RNA heading toward the 5' end is cleaved and dissociated from the EC, with no effect on the stability and activity of the EC. Most of the current data suggest that an 8- to 10-nt RNA.DNA hybrid is formed in the EC. Here, we show that an 8- to 10-nt RNA obtained by truncating the RNase-generated products further with either GreB or pyrophosphate is sufficient for the high stability and activity of the EC. This result suggests that the transcript-RNAP interaction that is required for holding the EC together can be limited to the RNA region involved in the 8- to 10-nt RNA.DNA hybrid.

Force and velocity measured for single molecules of RNA polymerase

RNA polymerase (RNAP) moves along DNA while carrying out transcription, acting as a molecular motor. Transcriptional velocities for single molecules of Escherichia coli RNAP were measured as progressively larger forces were applied by a feedback-controlled optical trap. The shapes of RNAP force-velocity curves are distinct from those of the motor enzymes myosin or kinesin, and indicate that biochemical steps limiting transcription rates at low loads do not generate movement. Modeling the data suggests that high loads may halt RNAP by promoting a structural change which moves all or part of the enzyme backwards through a comparatively large distance, corresponding to 5 to 10 base pairs. This contrasts with previous models that assumed force acts directly upon a single-base translocation step.

A new model for coronavirus transcription

Coronaviruses contain an unusually long (27-32,000 ribonucleotide) positive sense RNA genome that is polyadenylated at the 3' end and capped at the 5' end. In addition to the genome, infected cells contain subgenomic mRNAs that form a 3' co-terminal nested set with the genome. In addition to their common 3' ends, the genome and the subgenomic mRNAs contain an identical 5' leader sequence. The transcription mechanism that coronaviruses use to produce subgenomic mRNA is not known and has been the subject of speculation since sequencing of the subgenomic mRNAs showed they must arise by discontinuous transcription. The current model called leader-primed transcription has subgenomic mRNAs transcribed directly from genome-length negative strands. It was based on the failure to find in coronavirus infected cells subgenome-length negative strands or replication intermediates containing subgenome-length negative strands. Clearly, these structures exist in infected cells and are transcriptionally active. We proposed a new model for coronavirus transcription which we called 3' discontinuous extension of negative strands. This model predicts that subgenome-length negative strands would be derived directly by transcription using the genome RNA as a template. The subgenome-length templates would contain the common 5' leader sequence and serve as templates for the production of subgenomic mRNAs. Our findings include showing that: 1. Replication intermediates (RIs) containing subgenome-length RNA exist in infected cells and are separable from RIs with genome-length templates. The RFs with subgenome-length templates are not derived by RNase treatment of RIs with genome-length templates. 2. The subgenome-length negative strands are formed early in infection when RIs are accumulating and the rate of viral RNA synthesis is increasing exponentially. 3. Subgenome-length negative strands contain at their 3' ends a complementary copy of the 72 nucleotide leader RNA that is found in the genome only at their 5' end. 4. RIs with subgenomic templates serve immediately as templates for transcription of subgenomic mRNAs. Because subgenomic mRNAs are not replicated, i.e., copied into negative strands that in turn are used as templates for subgenomic mRNA synthesis, we propose that the subgenome-length negative strands must arise directly by transcription of the genome and acquire their common 3' anti-leader sequence after polymerase jumping from the intergenic regions to the leader sequence at the 5' end of the genome. This would make negative strand synthesis discontinuous and subgenomic mRNA synthesis continuous, which is the opposite of what was proposed in the leader primed model.

A surface of Escherichia coli sigma 70 required for promoter function and antitermination by phage lambda Q protein

The sigma initiation factor sigma70 of Escherichia coli acts not only in promoter recognition and DNA strand opening, but also to mediate the transformation of RNA polymerase (RNAP) to an antiterminating form by the phage lambda gene Q protein. Q is able to bind and modify RNAP when alpha70, still present in the initially elongating enzyme, recognizes a repeat of the -10 promoter element and induces a transcription pause. We have isolated mutations in the rpoD gene for sigma70 that impair Q function because they reduce the ability of sigma70 to recognize the downstream pause site. These mutations identify a locus of sigma70 that is important for the formation and stability of open promoter complex, likely because it mediates protein interactions with RNAP core.

Transcriptional properties of RNA polymerase II within triplet repeat-containing DNA from the human myotonic dystrophy and fragile X loci

Expansion of a (CTG)n segment within the 3'-untranslated region of the myotonic dystrophy protein kinase gene alters mRNA production. The inherent ability of RNA polymerase II to transcribe (CTG)17-255 tracts corresponding to DNA from normal, unstable, and affected individuals, and the normal (CGG)54 fragile X repeat tract, was analyzed using a synchronized in vitro transcription system. Core RNA polymerase II transcribed all repeat units irrespective of repeat length or orientation. However, approximately 50% of polymerases transiently halted transcription (with a half-life of approximately 10 +/- 1 s) within the first and second CTG repeat unit and a more transient barrier to elongation was observed roughly centered within repeats 6-9. Transcription within the remainder of the CTG tracts and within the CCG, CGG, and CAG tracts appeared uniform with average transcription rates of 170, 250, 300, and 410 nucleotides/min, respectively. These differences correlated with changes in the sequence-specific transient pausing pattern within the CNG repeat tracts; individual incorporation rates were slower after incorporation of pyrimidine residues. Unexpectedly, approximately 4% of the run-off transcripts were, depending on the repeat sequence, either 15 or 18 nucleotides longer than expected. However, these products were not produced by transcriptional slippage within the repeat tract.

Template end-to-end transposition by RNA polymerase II

On 5'-template strand protruding templates, promoter-initiated run-off transcription by RNA polymerase II generates discrete, 15-16-nucleotide (nt) longer than expected products whose production is abrogated by elongation factor SII (Parsons, M. A., Sinden, R. R., and Izban, M. G. (1998) J. Biol. Chem. 273, 26998-27008). We demonstrate that template terminal complexes produce these RNAs and that transcript extension is a general and salt-sensitive (250 mM) feature of run-off transcription. On 5'-overhung templates the extended run-off transcripts appear to be retained within an RNA-DNA-enzyme ternary complex, and SII facilitates resumption of transcript elongation via a dinucleotide truncation intermediate. Moreover, on one of the 5-overhung templates, the initially extended complexes spontaneously resumed transcript extension and were uniquely resistant to salt (250 mM) challenge. However, SII did not facilitate this long distance extension on all template ends. Run-off transcripts on a blunt-ended template were initially extended by 2-11 nt (roughly in 2-nt increments); SII addition either before or after extension resulted in the accumulation of a 4-5-nt extension product. Based on these findings, we propose that the initial and continuously extended RNAs reflect intermediates and successful completion of template end-to-end transposition (template switching) by RNA polymerase II, respectively. Both the template end sequence and structure influenced the success of such an event.

Sequential hydrolysis of ATP molecules bound in interacting catalytic sites of Escherichia coli transcription termination protein Rho

Escherichia coli transcription termination protein Rho, an RNA-dependent ATPase, disrupts transcription complexes, releasing RNA and allowing RNA polymerase to recycle. Homohexameric Rho binds three molecules of MgATP in a single class of catalytically competent sites. In rapid mix chemical quench experiments, when Rho saturated with ATP was mixed with RNA and the reaction was quenched after various times, hydrolysis of the three bound ATP molecules was not simultaneous. A hydrolysis burst of one molecule of ATP per hexamer occurred at >300 s-1, followed by steady-state hydrolysis at 30 s-1 per hexamer. The burst also shows that a step following ATP hydrolysis is rate-limiting for overall catalysis and requires communication among the three catalytic sites during net ATP hydrolysis. The rate of hydrolysis of radiolabeled ATP when one labeled and two unlabeled ATP molecules are bound indicates a sequential pattern of hydrolysis. Positive cooperativity of catalysis occurs among the catalytic sites of Rho; when only one ATP molecule is bound per hexamer, ATP hydrolysis upon addition of RNA is 30-fold slower than when ATP is saturating. These behaviors are comparable to those of F1-type ATPases, with which Rho shares a number of structural features.

Interaction of a nascent RNA structure with RNA polymerase is required for hairpin-dependent transcriptional pausing but not for transcript release

Nascent RNA structures may regulate RNA chain elongation either directly through interaction with RNA polymerase or indirectly by disrupting nascent RNA contacts with polymerase or DNA. To distinguish these mechanisms we tested whether the effects of the his leader pause RNA hairpin could be mimicked by pairing of antisense DNA or RNA oligonucleotides to the nascent transcript. The his pause hairpin inhibits nucleotide addition when it forms 11 nucleotides from the transcript 3' end. It also can terminate transcription when base changes extend its stem to Collapse

Key Words

• rna polymerase
• rna hairpins
• pausing
• termination

Collapse

MESH Headings

• DNA-Directed RNA Polymerases/metabolism
• Escherichia coli
• Models, Genetic
• Molecular Mimicry
• Nucleic Acid Conformation
• Oligonucleotides, Antisense/metabolism
• RNA/metabolism
• RNA, Bacterial/metabolism
• Structure-Activity Relationship
• Transcription, Genetic

Collapse

Grants

• R01 GM038660 NIGMS NIH HHS
• R37 GM038660 NIGMS NIH HHS
• GM38660 NIGMS NIH HHS

Collapse

Affiliation(s)

I Artsimovitch Department of Bacteriology, University of Wisconsin, Madison, Wisconsin 53706, USA
R Landick

Collapse

Mutations in and monoclonal antibody binding to evolutionary hypervariable region of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase beta' subunit inhibit transcript cleavage and transcript elongation

A 190 amino acid-long region centered around position 1050 of the 1407-amino acid-long beta' subunit of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase (RNAP) is absent from homologues in eukaryotes, archaea and many bacteria. In chloroplasts, the corresponding region can be more than 900 amino acids long. The role of this hypervariable region was studied by deletion mutagenesis of the cloned E. coli rpoC, encoding beta'. Long deletions mimicking beta' from Gram-positive bacteria failed to assemble into RNAP. Mutants with short, 40-60-amino acid-long deletions spanning beta' residues 941-1130 assembled into active RNAP in vitro. These mutant enzymes were defective in the transcript cleavage reaction and had dramatically reduced transcription elongation rates at subsaturating substrate concentrations due to prolonged pausing at sites of transcriptional arrest. Binding of a monoclonal antibody, Pyn1, to the hypervariable region inhibited transcription elongation and intrinsic transcript cleavage and, to a lesser degree, GreB-induced transcript cleavage, but did not interfere with GreB binding to RNAP. We propose that mutations in and antibody binding to the hypervariable, functionally dispensable region of beta' inhibit transcript cleavage and elongation by distorting the flanking conserved segment G in the active center.

NTP concentration effects on initial transcription by T7 RNAP indicate that translocation occurs through passive sliding and reveal that divergent promoters have distinct NTP concentration requirements for productive initiation

The hypothesis that active site translocation during initial transcription occurs by a passive sliding mechanism which allows the pre- and post-translocated states to equilibrate on the time scale of bond formation was tested by evaluating the effects of NTP concentration on individual transcript extension steps in the presence of translocation roadblocks created by proteins bound immediately downstream of a T7 promoter, as well as by evaluating the effects of NTP concentration on competing transcript extension pathways (iterative synthesis and "normal" extension). Results are consistent with a passive sliding mechanism for translocation which is driven by NTP binding, and are inconsistent with mechanisms in which the pre- and post-translocated states fail to equilibrate with each other on the time scale of bond formation or in which translocation is driven by NTP hydrolysis. We also find, in agreement with many previous studies, that divergence from consensus in the ITS (initially transcribed sequence) of the T7 promoter decreases productive initiation. However, this appears to be largely due to increases in the NTP concentration requirements for efficient transcription on the divergent ITSs.

Structural changes in the RNA polymerase II transcription complex during transition from initiation to elongation

We obtained exonuclease III (exoIII) footprints for a series of RNA polymerase II transcription complexes stalled between positions +20 to +51. Downstream advance of the exoIII footprint is normally tightly coordinated with RNA synthesis. However, arrested RNA polymerases slide back along the template, as indicated by exoIII footprints in which the last transcribed base is abnormally close to the downstream edge of the footprint. None of the polymerase II complexes stalled between +20 and +51 were arrested. Nevertheless, the exoIII footprints of complexes with 20-, 23-, or 25-nucleotide RNAs resembled those of arrested complexes, with the last transcribed base very close to the footprint's front edge. The exoIII footprint of the +27 complex was displaced downstream by 17 bp compared to the footprint of the +25 complex. Many complexes between +27 and +42 also showed evidence of sliding back along the template. We compared the effects of template sequence and transcript length by constructing a new template in which the initial transcribed sequence was duplicated beginning at +98. The exoIII footprints of transcription complexes stalled between +122 to +130 on this DNA did not resemble those of arrested complexes, in contrast to the footprints of analogous complexes stalled over the same DNA sequences early in transcription. Our results indicate that the RNA polymerase II transcription complex passes through a major, sequence-independent structural transition about 25 bases downstream of the starting point of transcription. The fully mature form of the elongation complex may not appear until more than 40 bonds have been made.

Yeast transcript elongation factor (TFIIS), structure and function. II: RNA polymerase binding, transcript cleavage, and read-through

The transcriptionally active fragment of the yeast RNA polymerase II transcription elongation factor, TFIIS, comprises a three-helix bundle and a zinc ribbon motif joined by a linker region. We have probed the function of this fragment of TFIIS using structure-guided mutagenesis. The helix bundle domain binds RNA polymerase II with the same affinity as does the full-length TFIIS, and this interaction is mediated by a basic patch on the outer face of the third helix. TFIIS mutants that were unable to bind RNA polymerase II were inactive for transcription activity, confirming the central role of polymerase binding in the TFIIS mechanism of action. The linker and zinc ribbon regions play roles in promoting cleavage of the nascent transcript and read-through past the block to elongation. Mutation of three aromatic residues in the zinc ribbon domain (Phe269, Phe296, and Phe308) impaired both transcript cleavage and read-through. Mutations introduced in the linker region between residues 240 and 245 and between 250 and 255 also severely impaired both transcript cleavage and read-through activities. Our analysis suggests that the linker region of TFIIS probably adopts a critical structure in the context of the elongation complex.