The T-cell repertoire is heavily influenced by tolerance to polymorphic self-antigens

Clonal deletion versus clonal anergy: the role of the thymus in inducing self tolerance

During development in the thymus, T cells are rendered tolerant to self antigens. It is now apparent that thymocytes bearing self-reactive T cell receptors can be tolerized by processes that result in physical elimination (clonal deletion) or functional inactivation (clonal anergy). As these mechanisms have important clinical implications for transplantation and autoimmunity, current investigations are focused on understanding the cellular and molecular interactions that generate these forms of tolerance.

Autoimmune diseases: the failure of self tolerance

The ability to discriminate between self and nonself antigens is vital to the functioning of the immune system as a specific defense against invading microorganisms. Failure of the immune system to "tolerate" self tissues can result in pathological autoimmune states leading to debilitating illness and sometimes death. The induction of autoimmunity involves genetic and environmental factors that have focused the attention of researchers on the trimolecular complex formed by major histocompatibility complex molecules, antigen, and T cell receptors. Detailed molecular characterization of these components points to potential strategies for disease intervention.

Tolerance in transgenic mice expressing major histocompatibility molecules extrathymically on pancreatic cells

Transgenic mice with defined expression of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) proteins provide novel systems for understanding the fundamental question of T cell tolerance to nonlymphoid self components. The MHC class II I-E and I-A and class I H-2K molecules expressed specifically on pancreatic islet or acinar cells serve as model self antigens. In these systems, transgenic proteins are not detected in the thymus or other lymphoid tissues. Yet mice are tolerant to the pancreatic MHC products in vivo; this tolerance is not induced by clonal deletion. These studies have been aided by monoclonal antibodies specific for I-E-reactive T cells and indicate that clonal anergy may be an important mechanism of tolerance to peripheral proteins.

The role of the T cell receptor in positive and negative selection of developing T cells

Although many combinations of alpha beta T cell receptors are available to the T cells in any given organism, far fewer are actually used by mature T cells. The combinations used are limited by two selective processes, positive selection of T cells bearing receptors that will be useful to the host, and clonal elimination or inactivation of T cells bearing receptors that will be damaging to the host. The ways in which these two apparently contradictory processes occur, and the hypotheses that have been suggested to reconcile them, are discussed.

A role for clonal inactivation in T cell tolerance to Mls-1a

Clonal deletion plays a major part in the maintenance of natural self-tolerance in both normal and transgenic mice. Self antigens that are expressed in the thymus result in the physical elimination of autoreactive thymocytes at a particular stage in their development. For example, the majority V beta 6- and V beta 8.1-bearing T cells that recognize the minor lymphocyte-stimulating antigen, Mls-1a (ref. 10) , are clonally deleted in the thymuses of normal mice and transgenic mice expressing Mls-1a (refs 2, 3, 9). In contrast, a very different mechanism of tolerance involving the functional inactivation, but not elimination, of autoreactive cells, termed clonal inactivation or clonal anergy, has been implicated in some experimentally manipulated systems of tolerance. To test further the mechanisms involved in self-tolerance, we have generated transgenic mice expressing a V beta 8.1 beta chain on greater than 95% of peripheral T cells and have tested tolerance to Mls-1a in these mice. Surprisingly, a significant fraction of the CD4+ peripheral cells that survived deletion were non-responsive in vitro to any stimulus tested. Naturally occurring tolerance to a self antigen expressed in the thymus can thus be mediated by clonal anergy, as well as by clonal deletion.

Analysis of T cell receptor V beta gene usage in primary mixed lymphocyte reactions: evidence for directive usage by different antigen-presenting cells and Mls-like determinants on T cell blasts

The usage of four different T cell receptor (TcR) V beta gene families within normal, non-primed T cell populations in response to various types of antigen-presenting cells (APC) in primary mixed lymphocyte reaction has been studied. We demonstrate that distinct patterns of V beta gene usage are obtained within a given T cell population in response to different types of APC with the same allo-H-2. When responder T cells are stimulated with one type of allogeneic APC, from various H-2-disparate mice, the same V beta gene preference is observed. Furthermore, when H-2- and Mls-mismatched APC gene used as stimulators, the Mls-associated V beta 6 and V beta 8.1 gene families are highly elevated in response to both B and T cell blasts from certain Mls-positive strains. The results demonstrate that different types of allogeneic APC have the capacity to generate biases in TcR V beta gene usage and imply that functional Mls-like determinants are presented by T cell blasts. The findings are discussed with respect to TcR-major histocompatibility complex interactions in allostimulation.

Autoreactive T cells in normal mice: unrestricted recognition of self peptides on dendritic cell I-A molecules by CD4-CD8- T cell receptor alpha/beta+ T cell clones expressing V beta 8.1 gene segments

CD4-CD8- double-negative (DN) and CD4+CD8- T cell clones were derived from splenic precursors resistant to killing by anti-Thy-1, -CD5, -CD4 and -CD8 monoclonal antibodies and complement. Both DN and CD4+ clones express functional T cell receptor (TcR) alpha/beta and exhibit strong autoreactivity in vitro. DN cells can be induced to proliferate by dendritic cells (DC) of all haplotypes tested, although this activation is inhibited by antibodies specific for I-A determinants expressed on the stimulatory DC. In contrast, CD4+ clones only respond to syngeneic or I-Ad-compatible DC. Both DN and CD4+ autoreactive clones do not proliferate when cultured with class II+ H-2d normal or tumor macrophages and B cell lines or with class II-transfected L cells, suggesting that these cells recognize self peptides only present on the surface of DC. Despite their phenotype resembling that of immature thymocytes and their inability to interact directly with B lymphocytes, DN cloned T cells, like CD4+ T cells, exhibit nonspecific helper functions and can induce polyclonal B cell proliferation and differentiation. DN TcR alpha/beta+ peripheral T cells represent, like TcR gamma/delta+ lymphocytes, a new T cell subset physiological role whose remains to be defined.

Sequential analysis of distributions of donor-derived thymocytes bearing T-cell antigen receptor (TCR) and donor-derived Ia+ cells in thymuses of fully allogeneic bone marrow chimera in mice

Lethally irradiated SJL/J mice were reconstituted with B10 bone marrow cells, and the process of thymic reconstitution by donor-derived cells positive for I-A or V beta 8 molecules was investigated. The donor-derived Ia+ cells appeared in the medulla on day 7 after reconstitution. The Ia+ cells became confluent up to day 14, and the cellularity in the medulla on day 17 was almost the same as that in the normal thymus. Dull V beta 8+ thymocytes were first recognized in the cortex on day 10 and were identifiable in the medulla by day 14. The V beta 8+ cells seemed to be mainly CD4+8+ double-positive. Furthermore, most of the V beta 8+ cells in the medulla of chimeras given cyclosporin A for 3 weeks after reconstitution appeared to be CD4+8+ thymocytes which bear a low concentration of TCR exist in the thymic medulla at a relatively early stage when donor-derived Ia+ cells have already settled there. The coincidental appearance and coexistence of Ia+ cells and TCR+ thymocytes in the medulla suggest that these histological characteristics may be related to the selection of thymocytes in this area.

The staphylococcal enterotoxins and their relatives

Staphylococcal enterotoxins and a group of related proteins made by Streptococci cause food poisoning and shock in man and animals. These proteins share an ability to bind to human and mouse major histocompatibility complex proteins. The complex ligand so formed has specificity for a particular part of T cell receptors, V beta, and by engaging V beta can stimulate many T cells. It is likely that some or all of the pathological effects of these toxins are caused by their ability to activate quickly so many T cells. It is also possible that encounters with such toxins have caused mice, at least, to evolve mechanisms for varying their T cell V beta repertoires, such that they are less susceptible to attack by the toxins.

Correlation between the V beta 4+ CD8+ T-cell population and the H-2d haplotype

The V beta 4+ T-cell population was examined with a newly established antibody, KT4, specific for V beta 4. Between 4.8% and 19.4% of CD3+ peripheral T cells from various inbred strains of mice or F1 hybrids expressed V beta 4. The CD4 T-cell population had higher numbers of V beta 4+ T cells (5.5%-20.6%) than the CD8 T-cell population (2.5%-10.7%). Deletion of certain V beta-expressing T cells due to the presence of the Mlsa antigen and/or the absence of certain Tcrb-V genes increased relative numbers of V beta 4+ T cells. The data suggest that V beta 4+ CD8+ T cells might be positively selected by H-2d molecules.

Cell components required for deletion of an autoreactive T cell repertoire

T cells become tolerant to self antigens during their development in the thymus. Clonal deletion of thymocytes bearing T cell receptor (TcR) which recognize self antigens is a major mechanism for generating tolerance. In the present study we have used allogeneic bone marrow (BM) chimeras, prepared with various combinations of mouse strains and focusing especially on expressions of I-E molecules and Mls-1a antigens on the cell surface, to investigate both immunohistochemically and by flow cytometry the cell components that contribute to the clonal deletion of T cells positive for V beta 6 TcR. The V beta 6 TcR expression is strongly associated with T cell recognition of both I-E and Mls-1a antigens. We found that I-E+ cells derived from donor BM (and thus not of recipient lineage) represented a primary requirement for deletion of Mls-1a-reactive thymocytes which bear V beta 6 TcR. Immunohistochemical analysis revealed that the donor-derived I-E+ cells were distributed mainly to the thymic medulla and that the V beta 6+ cells were eliminated from the thymic medulla between 2 and 3 weeks following BM transplantation. In contrast, Mls-1a+ cells of either donor or recipient origin might be responsible for the deletion, even though cortical epithelial cells appeared not to express Mls-1a antigens.

Cellular and molecular characteristics of transformed T cells from an antigen-specific T-cell line

An antigen-specific T-cell line which transforms into T-lymphoma cells in vitro but apparently not in vivo is described. Membrane markers, tumorigenicity and T-cell receptor (TcR) V alpha and V beta-gene usage of the in vitro transformed T-cell line were analysed to investigate whether the transformation event was poly-, oligo-, or monoclonal. The results indicate that the T lymphoma has no chromosome abnormalities, contains no tumour-inducing virus, can induce clone-specific immunity, and is oligoclonal with respect to TcR V alpha and V beta expression. The nature of the transformation event and clinical application of vaccination against T lymphomas is discussed. In addition, the expressed TcR V alpha and V beta repertoire of Con A T blasts was apparently not affected by the Igh-l or the MHC haplotype, as investigated in Igh-l and MHC congeneic C57Bl mice.

Origin and selection of peripheral CD4-CD8- T cells bearing alpha/beta T cell antigen receptors in autoimmune gld mice

We have analyzed the origin and development of unusual CD4-CD8- alpha/beta T cell receptor-positive peripheral T cells produced in large numbers by mice homozygous for the gld mutation (C3H-gld/gld). These mice may be an important model for investigating processes controlling T cell development. Bone marrow transfers demonstrated that the gld defect was intrinsic to bone marrow-derived cells. Clonal deletion of potentially autoreactive cells was observed in peripheral gld CD4-CD8-, CD4+CD8-, and CD4-CD8+ T cells, as well as mature thymocytes. This suggests that gld CD4-CD8- T cells have passed through the thymus in ontogeny and that gld autoimmunity does not result from a general defect in elimination of self-reactive thymocytes. These observations, combined with demethylation of the CD8 gene in the CD4-CD8- population, support prior expression of CD4 and/or CD8 in gld CD4-CD8- T cell ontogeny, perhaps at a CD4+CD8+ stage. Steroid sensitivity of gld thymocytes and CD4-CD8- T cells was normal. Therefore, we found no gross abnormalities in two major mechanisms of inducible cell death in the gld thymus, the clonal deletion process associated with tolerance and the steroid-inducible endogenous endonuclease thought to be involved in apoptosis of unselected thymocytes. The data suggest that if gld CD4-CD8- T cells arise via escape from normal elimination in the thymus, they must do so by a novel defect in thymic selection (perhaps related to aberrant positive signals) and/or are expanded by an extrathymic process which allows clonal deletion to occur.

Novel origin of lpr and gld cells and possible implications in autoimmunity

The lpr and gld mutations are prime examples of single-gene defects associated with expansion of a unique double-negative (CD4-8-), T-cell receptor alpha:beta + cell population and heightened polyclonal and autoimmune responses. The exact origin of these autoimmunity-inducing/enhancing T cells remains controversial. Here, we review the characteristics of the lpr and gld mutations, and speculate on the possible relationship of these cells to normal thymic differentiation pathways. We argue that mounting evidence now supports the existence of a CD4/CD8-loss pathway of late thymic differentiation, responsible for the origin of both normal and lpr/gld double-negative alpha:beta + cells. We further speculate that downregulation of CD4 and CD8 accessory molecules on thymocytes with moderately autoreactive T-cell receptors is involved in selecting cells, including lpr/gld precursors for this pathway. Escape of a large number of such autoreactive cells from thymic elimination might be an important contributory factor to the pathogenesis of autoimmunity.

Response of mature unprimed CD8+ T cells to Mlsa determinants

Contrary to existing dogma, evidence is presented that proliferative responses of mature unprimed T cells to Mlsa antigens involve CD8+ cells as well as CD4+ cells. The response of CD8+ cells to Mlsa antigens proved to be heavily dependent on help from CD4+ cells, and responses were stronger in three I-E+ strain combinations than in an I-E- combination. In I-E+ combinations, CD8+ blast cells accounted for 20-25% of the blasts generated from unseparated T cells responding to Mlsa-bearing stimulator cells in vitro; similar findings applied to blast cells generated in vivo. The observation that the majority (greater than or equal to 50%) of Mlsa-stimulated CD8+ cells (and CD4+ cells) were V beta 6+ indicated that CD8+ cells respond to Mlsa antigens, per se, rather than to nonspecific stimuli. Whether CD4+ and CD8+ cells use the same or different H-2-restricting elements to respond to Mlsa antigens has yet to be resolved.

Stimulation of all T cells bearing V beta 1, V beta 3, V beta 11 and V beta 12 by staphylococcal enterotoxin A

To determine the molecular mechanisms of T cell stimulation by staphylococcal enterotoxin A (SEA), we examined the expression of T cell receptor (TcR) V beta on the T cells from four strains of mice stimulated in vitro with SEA, using flow cytometric analysis for the number of T cells bearing V beta 3, V beta 6, V beta 8, V beta 11 and RNA blotting analysis for the amount of transcripts of V beta 1, V beta 5 and V beta 12. The number of T cell blasts bearing V beta 1, V beta 3, V beta 1 or V beta 12 were increased in the T cell blasts proliferating in vitro in response to SEA in C57BL/6 mice. In AKR/J mice, which contain few V beta 11- or V beta 12-bearing T cells due to a tolerance to the self-MHC class II IE-antigens, T cells bearing V beta 1 or V beta 3 responded to SEA. SEA enriched only V beta 1-bearing T cells in BALB/c mice carrying Mls-2a which lack Mls-1a-reactive V beta 3-bearing T cells as well as V beta 11- and V beta 12-bearing T cells. In spite of the presence of V beta 1-bearing T cells, C3H/He T cells exhibited a very low responsiveness to SEA. T cell repertoires skewed by clonal deletion of self-reactive T cells may in part account for the different sensitivity to SEA among the different strains. A tolerance to SEA can be established in C57BL/6 mice which have been primed i.v. with SEA and treated i.p. with 200 mg/kg of cyclophosphamide 2 days later. All mature T cells bearing V beta 3 or V beta 11 were virtually abolished in the periphery of tolerant mice. These results suggest that most T cells reactive to SEA bear V beta 1, V beta 3, V beta 11 or V beta 12 and that clonal deletion of mature T cells reactive to SEA may account for the cellular mechanisms for cyclophosphamide-induced tolerance to SEA.

Preferential usage of V alpha 4 and V beta 10 T cell receptor genes by lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus glycoprotein-specific H-2Db-restricted cytotoxic T cells

Correlations between the T cell receptor (TcR) V gene usage and the specificity of T cells have been primarily described for major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II-restricted helper T cell responses. In the present study the TcR genes expressed by MHC class I-restricted murine cytotoxic T cells (CTL) specific for a major epitope of the lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus (LCMV), LCMV-GP2(275-289), were investigated. The TcR primary structure of an LCMV-GP2(275-289) specific H-2Db-restricted CTL clone has been determined. It uses a member of the V alpha 4 family joined to J alpha AN14.4 for the alpha chain and V beta 10 rearranged to D beta 2.1 and J beta 2.4 for its beta chain. Four other independent LCMV-GP2(275-289) specific H-2Db-restricted CTL clones also expressed V alpha 4 and V beta 10 gene elements. Furthermore, V alpha 4 and V beta 10 were preferentially expressed by polyclonal CTL of C57BL/6 origin specific for LCMV. These results suggest that both TcR V alpha and V beta regions are important for the recognition of the LCMV-GP2(275-289) epitope on H-2Db molecules.

Requirement for cotolerogenic gene products in the clonal deletion of I-E reactive T cells

T cells that express the T cell receptor V beta 5.2 domain react with the class II major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecule I-E, and V beta 5.2+ T cells are deleted in mouse strains that express I-E glycoproteins. By examination of genetically defined recombinant inbred (RI) mouse strains, it was found that the deletion was dependent on the expression of I-E and one of a limited number of non-MHC gene products (cotolerogens). The gene encoding one of these cotolerogens maps to chromosome 12 and is linked to the endogenous provirus Mtv-9. These observations suggest that the I-E-mediated and minor lymphocyte-stimulating antigen (Mls)-mediated deletions of alpha beta T cells from the repertoire are similar; both require the expression of a class II MHC glycoprotein and a second non-MHC gene product.

Programmed death of autoreactive thymocytes

T lymphocytes bearing high-affinity T-cell receptors (TCR) for self-antigens are clonally deleted during thymus development. Several recent studies have identified variable domains of the beta-chain of the TCR that are specifically deleted in vivo in mouse strains that express major histocompatibility complex class II molecules in addition to poorly defined self-antigens, including those encoded by the Mls-1a and Mls-2a loci. Deletion of autoreactive cells in these systems occurs in the thymus, and antibody blocking experiments in vivo have implicated the phenotypically immature CD4+CD8+ 'cortical' subset as the target population for clonal deletion. Similarly, studies with transgenic mice bearing autoreactive TCR have provided independent evidence that clonal deletion occurs at the CD4+CD8+ stage of development. But none of these studies directly identified dying autoreactive cells, and the circumstances leading to deletion remain unclear. Here we report that neonatal thymus contains a significant population of phenotypically mature CD4+CD8- cells bearing autoreactive TCR. When placed in short-term culture, a large proportion (60%) of these autoreactive cells die selectively. Furthermore, their death can be prevented by inhibitors of macromolecule (RNA and protein) synthesis, as is the case for glucocorticoid-induced death of thymocytes. These data indicate that physiological clonal deletion of autoreactive cells involves 'programmed' cell death, and that it can occur in cells with a mature (CD4+CD8-) surface phenotype.

Production of baboon (Papio hamadryas) monoclonal antibodies by herpesvirus papio immortalized baboon lymph node cells

Baboon monoclonal antibodies specific for monomorphic determinants of baboon apolipoprotein B were produced from in vivo primed lymph node cells immortalized by herpesvirus papio (HVP). Two cell lines from the immortalized cells were readily stabilized and grew rapidly. Since Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) cannot be used to immortalize baboon or macaque cells, HVP expands the potential sources of monoclonal antibodies to include baboons, and is the immortalizing agent of choice for macaques as well.

The toxicity of staphylococcal enterotoxin B in mice is mediated by T cells

Staphylococcal enterotoxin B (SEB) has been shown in the past to be a potent T cell stimulant in mouse or man. The toxin acts as a superantigen that is, it binds to class II MHC proteins and, as such a complex, stimulates T cells bearing particular V beta s as part of their receptors. The toxin also has several pathological effects, causing, in mice, rapid weight loss, thymus atrophy, immunosuppression, and, at high doses, death. The data in this paper show that at least one of these effects, weight loss, is T cell mediated. Staphylococcal enterotoxin-mediated weight loss is MHC dependent, and is almost absent in animals expressing MHC class II molecules, which, complexed with SEB, are poor T cell stimulants. Also, mice that lack T cell function, genetically or because of cyclosporin A treatment, lose no or less weight than controls in response to SEB. Finally, animals bred such that they express few T cells bearing V beta s with which SEB can interact lose much less weight in response to the toxin than littermate controls that have higher numbers of reactive T cells. It is therefore suggested that the pathological effects of the staphylococcal, T cell-stimulating toxins in mouse and man may be partially or wholly the consequence of massive T cell stimulation.

Intrathymic clonal deletion of V beta 6+ T cells in cyclophosphamide-induced tolerance to H-2-compatible, Mls-disparate antigens

When C3H (H-2k, Mls-1b) mice were primed intravenously with 10(8) viable spleen cells from AKR (H-2k, Mls-1a) and treated intraperitoneally with 200 mg/kg of cyclophosphamide (CP) 2 d later, not only a long-lasting skin allograft tolerance but also a tolerance in mixed lymphocyte reaction to Mls-1a-encoded antigens was established. The cellular mechanisms of CP-induced tolerance were examined by assessing the V beta 6-bearing T cells that are strongly correlated with reactivity to Mls-1a-encoded antigens bound to MHC class II molecules. At the relatively early stage (2 or 5 wk) after the CP treatment, CD4+-V beta 6+ T cells of C3H origin were preferentially eliminated in the lymph nodes of the tolerant mice, whereas CD8+-V beta 6+ T cells remained. On the other hand, neither CD4+CD8- nor CD4-CD8+ thymocytes bearing a high density of V beta 6 was detected in the chimeric thymus. Namely, in the thymus of the tolerant C3H mice, neither mixed chimerism nor the clonal deletion of the V beta 6-bearing T cells was observed on day 14, whereas both of them were observed on day 35. The clonal deletion and mixed chimerism in the thymus were lasting for greater than 10 wk after the CP treatment. Expression of V beta 6 on the peripheral T cells in the tolerant C3H mice gradually reduced in the process of time. These results strongly suggested that the clonal deletion in the thymus was one of the essential mechanisms in the CP-induced tolerance system.

Variations in the T-cell repertoire against HLA antigens in humans

Allospecific anti-HLA class I antigen cytotoxic T-lymphocyte precursor frequencies (CTLpf) have been estimated in peripheral blood of healthy blood donors with responder stimulator combinations mismatched for one HLA-A,B antigen. The CTLpf ranged from 1 in 400 to 1 in 10,000, with most frequent values of 1 in 600 to 4000. The following observations were made: (1) CTLpf against the same HLA antigen vary among different responders; (2) CTLpf of one responder against various HLA antigens may be different; (3) "narrow" responders produce cytotoxic T lymphocytes that recognize only the private (stimulator) alloantigen, while "broad" responders produce mainly broadly cross-reactive cytotoxic T lymphocytes with public specificity. Split-well analysis shows that very few cytotoxic T lymphocytes of "broad" responders recognize the private alloantigen only. These individual variations are not dependent on the HLA phenotype, because they also occurred in unrelated HLA-identical responders stimulated against the same mismatched stimulator cells.

Minor lymphocyte stimulating (Mls) gene products in mice influence their genetic resistance or susceptibility to induction of autoimmune encephalomyelitis

The role of the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) gene products in the genetics of experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE) is well established. Here we demonstrate how non-MHC gene products, stimulatory to T cells specific to myelin basic protein (MBP), can affect the MHC control in determining genetic susceptibility or resistance to induction of EAE. I-As-restricted MBP-specific T cells derived from SJL/J mice are shown to cross-react with Mls-2a gene products. The Mls-2a gene product expressed by (SJL/J X BALB/c)F1 mice tolerize T cells recognizing I-As/MBP and favor the development of I-Es/d-restricted MBP-specific T cells mediating EAE in the (SJL/J x BALB/c)F1 mice. These I-Es/d/MBP-specific T cells, cross-reactive with Mls-1a, and the I-As/MBP-specific T cells, cross-reactive with Mls-2a gene products, are both eliminated by self tolerance mechanisms in the H-2-matched (SJL/J X DBA/2)F1 mice, expressing Mls-1a2a gene products, and thereby confer genetic resistance to EAE on the (SJL/J X DBA/2)F1 mice bearing EAE-permissive MHC alleles. These results reflect a developmental selection of a T cell repertoire to the self antigen MBP, imposed by self tolerance to self Mls gene products, which affect the genetic susceptibility to EAE. These studies also demonstrate that self tolerance to Mls gene products can strengthen the tolerance to organ-specific self antigens such as MBP, which may not be expressed or which are absent in the thymus at the time of thymic selection.

Surprisingly uneven distribution of the T cell receptor V beta repertoire in wild mice

We have examined TCR V beta expression in a collection of wild mice. Many of the mice were homozygous for a large deletion at the V beta locus, and many animals also suppressed expression of several V betas using self superantigens. Expression of V beta 8.2 was unexpectedly suppressed by a self superantigen in some wild mice, which was due to the presence in these animals of a variant V beta 8.2 gene. The amino acid changes in this gene product suggest contact sites between V beta and the superantigen. Although all V betas are expressed within each wild mouse population, individual mice have a limited and variable V beta repertoire. The independent origin of multiple V beta deletions and the presence of polymorphic self superantigens suggest that this variation may be maintained by balancing selection.

Limited receptor repertoire in a mycobacteria-reactive subset of gamma delta T lymphocytes

The physiological role of lymphocytes bearing the gamma delta T-cell receptor (TCR) is still unclear. A function for a subset of these cells, however, is inferred from the finding that certain gamma delta chain-bearing lymphocytes are stimulated in a receptor-dependent fashion by mycobacterial antigens. We found that hybridomas derived from such cells in newborn murine thymus not only responded to mycobacterial purified protein derivative (PPD), but also exhibited an apparent autoreactivity. In neither response was haplotype-specific major histocompatibility (MHC) restriction demonstrable. To investigate the nature of antigen recognition by these gamma delta+ cells, we sequenced the gamma- and delta-chains from 28 PPD-reactive hybridomas, and found that a specific gamma-chain, together with one of a limited set of delta-chains, was needed to generate the PPD specificity. The reactive gamma delta pairs exhibited considerable junctional diversity, which may act to produce differences in the fine specificities of the responding cells.

Positive and negative selection of T cell receptor V beta domains controlled by distinct cell populations in the thymus

The role of thymic MHC class II-bearing cells in the selection of the TCR repertoire has been investigated in allogeneic radiation bone marrow chimeras. Positive selection of mature CD4+ T lymphocytes expressing the V beta 6+ TCR domain was found to depend upon radioresistant (presumably epithelial) I-E+ thymic cells. On the other hand, negative selection of CD4+ V beta 6+ cells (which was additionally dependent upon expression of the Mls-1a gene product) was controlled by a radiosensitive I-E+ thymic component (most likely dendritic cells). These data argue in favor of a compartmentalization of positive and negative selection events during T cell development.

Identification and characterization of new murine T cell receptor beta chain variable region (V beta) genes

By screening previously isolated genomic clones spanning the mouse TCR V beta locus with V beta-specific oligonucleotides, we have isolated one new functional V beta gene and six V beta pseudogenes. Because this method of identifying new genes does not depend on expression levels, we conclude that most, if not all, V beta genes in the mouse have been identified. The newly identified pseudogenes increase the frequency of mouse TCR V beta pseudogenes to 28%, a frequency similar to that estimated for mouse Ig VH pseudogenes (24). Three of the newly discovered pseudogenes are clustered in a region around another pseudogene (V beta 17b). The extensive DNA diversity, as reflected in both the nucleotide sequence and the RFLP, indicates that this genomic region is a possible hotspot of recombination. The new functional gene, V beta 19a, is expressed at very low levels, which explains why it has not been isolated earlier. V beta 19 shows expression patterns that correlate with the previously described Va beta and Vb beta haplotypes.

Tolerance-related V beta clonal deletions in normal CD4-8-, TCR-alpha/beta + and abnormal lpr and gld cell populations

We have analyzed tolerance-related clonal deletion of Mls-and I-E-reactive thymocytes at the RNA level using a multi-V beta probe RNAse protection assay, and used this phenomenon to identify the maturation stage of the abnormally expanded CD4-8-, TCR-alpha/beta + subset in lpr and gld homozygous mice, and of the phenotypically similar minor thymocyte subset found in normal mice. Essentially complete V beta clonal deletions were detected in lpr and gld cells of all appropriate background strains. Substantial, but not complete, V beta clonal deletions were also detected in the CD4-8- TCR-alpha/beta + subset of normal mice. Since expression of CD4/CD8 is required for V beta clonal deletions to occur, we conclude that lpr and gld cells, and at least a portion of CD4-8- TCR-alpha/beta + thymocytes in normal mice, are derived by secondary loss of CD4/CD8 accessory molecules from more mature CD4+8+ precursors. One possible interpretation of these findings is that such CD4/CD8 loss may affect a class of self-reactive thymocytes that have escaped direct clonal deletion. Exportation and expansion of such cells in the periphery may be an important contributory factor in the induction of systemic autoimmunity.

Reactivity of V beta 17a+ CD8+ T cell hybrids. Analysis using a new CD8+ T cell fusion partner

Tolerance to IE molecules leads to deletion of V beta 17a-bearing T cells. Both, the CD4+ as well as the CD8+ T cell subsets are affected. A large percentage of CD4+ V beta 17a+ T cell hybrids recognize IE molecules. We now have investigated the reactivity for IE antigens of CD8+ V beta 17a+ T cell hybrids. Using a transfection approach, we have introduced the murine CD8 molecule into different V beta 17a+ T cell hybrids. Furthermore, the CD8 cDNA was transfected into the BW5147 alpha-beta- fusion partner. This allowed us to generate a large number of V beta 17a+ T cell hybrids by fusion with the appropriate T cells. Only 6% of T cell hybrids were stimulated to produce IL-2 upon incubation with IE+ cells. However, in those, the CD8 molecule seemed not to contribute to the IE reactivity of the hybrid, since mAbs against the CD8 molecule failed to inhibit their reactivity. This low percentage of V beta 17a+ CD8+ IE-reactive T cell hybrids contrasts with the strong reduction of CD8+ V beta 17a+ T cells in IE+ mice, strongly suggesting that elimination of such cells in the thymus occurs when they are coexpressing CD4 and CD8. This view was confirmed by the occasional expression of CD4 in some hybrids in which case IE reactivity was detected. Furthermore, we demonstrated the functional integrity of the introduced CD8 molecule by: (a) reconstitution of the IL-2 response in a class I-restricted TNP-specific T cell hybrid; and (b) by generation of alloreactive class I-restricted T cell hybrids using the new CD8+ fusion cell line. This CD8+ fusion partner, BWLyt2-4, should prove useful to study antigen processing and antigen presentation requirements of class I-restricted T cells.

Failure of T cell receptor V beta negative selection in an athymic environment

The mature T cell receptor (TCR) repertoire is the result of selection events during T cell development. Previous assessment of TCR beta-chain selection with serologic and molecular probes demonstrated both positive and negative selection. Although this work suggested a critical role for the thymus, no direct assessment has been made of the requirement for a thymus in TCR V beta selection. A comparison of TCR V beta expression in four different congenic pairs of normal and nu/nu (athymic) mice indicated that the normal V beta deletions associated with tolerance to self minor lymphocyte stimulating (Mlsc) antigens or to self major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-encoded E alpha E beta products did not occur in most athymic mice. Thus, the thymus has a critical role in mediating self tolerance by negative selection.

Thymic requirement for clonal deletion during T cell development

During T cell differentiation, self tolerance is established in part by the deletion of self-reactive T cells within the thymus (negative selection). The presence of T cell receptor (TCR)-alpha beta + T cells in older athymic (nu/nu) mice indicates that some T cells can also mature without thymic influence. Therefore, to determine whether the thymus is required for negative selection, TCR V beta expression was compared in athymic nu/nu mice and their congenic normal littermates. T cells expressing V beta 3 proteins are specific for minor lymphocyte stimulatory (Mlsc) determinants and are deleted intrathymically due to self tolerance in Mlsc+ mouse strains. Here it is shown that V beta 3+ T cells are deleted in Mlsc+ BALB/c nu/+ mice, but not in their BALB/c nu/nu littermates. Thus, the thymus is required for clonal deletion during T cell development.

A nondeletional mechanism of thymic self tolerance

T cells become tolerant of self antigens during their development in the thymus. Clonal deletion of thymocytes bearing self-reactive T cell receptors is a major mechanism for generating tolerance and occurs readily for antigens expressed by bone marrow-derived cells. Tolerance to antigens expressed on the radioresistant thymic stromal elements is demonstrated here to occur via a nondeletional mechanism. For minor lymphocyte stimulatory (Mls-1a) and major histocompatibility complex (MHC) antigens, this alternate form of tolerance induction results in clonal anergy.

Induction of self-tolerance in mature peripheral B lymphocytes

In transgenic mice, mature peripheral B lymphocytes in lymphoid follicles, like immature B cells, are rendered tolerant by encounter with self-antigen, provided receptor occupancy by self-antigen exceeds a critical threshold. The tolerant state of the B cell is closely correlated with down-regulation of membrane IgM but not IgD antigen-receptors. Identical changes in antigen-receptor expression occur in a subset of follicular B cells in nontransgenic mice, suggesting that clonally silenced self-reactive cells are common in the peripheral B-cell repertoire.

Interaction of Staphylococcus aureus toxin "superantigens" with human T cells

A modification of the polymerase chain reaction has been used to establish the fact that a collection of Staphylococcus aureus toxins are "superantigens," each of which interacts with the T-cell alpha beta receptor of human T cells by means of a specific set of V beta elements.

Selective development of CD4+ T cells in transgenic mice expressing a class II MHC-restricted antigen receptor

T lymphocytes are predisposed to recognition of foreign protein fragments bound to cell-surface molecules encoded by the major histocompatibility complex (MHC). There is now compelling evidence that this specificity is a consequence of a selection process operating on developing T lymphocytes in the thymus. As a result of this positive selection, thymocytes that express antigen receptors with a threshold affinity for self MHC-encoded glycoproteins preferentially emigrate from the thymus and seed peripheral lymphoid organs. The specificity for both foreign antigen and MHC molecules is imparted by the alpha and beta chains of the T-cell antigen receptor (TCR). Two other T-cell surface proteins, CD4 and CD8, which bind non-polymorphic regions of class II and class I MHC molecules respectively, are also involved in these recognition events and play an integral role in thymic selection. In order to elucidate the developmental pathways of class II MHC-restricted T cells in relation to these essential accessory molecules, we have produced TCR-transgenic mice expressing a receptor specific for a fragment of pigeon cytochrome c and the Ek (class II MHC) molecule. The transgenic TCR is expressed on virtually all T cells in mice expressing Ek. The thymuses of these mice contain an abnormally high percentage of mature CD4+CD8- cells. In addition, the peripheral T-cell population is almost exclusively CD4+, demonstrating that the MHC specificity of the TCR determines the phenotype of T cells during selection in the thymus.

Positive selection of CD4+ T cells mediated by MHC class II-bearing stromal cell in the thymic cortex

T lymphocytes differentiate in the thymus, where functionally immature, CD4+CD8+ (double positive) thymocytes develop into functionally mature CD4+ helper cells and CD8+ cytotoxic (single positive) T cells. The thymus is the site where self-reactive T cells are negatively selected (clonally deleted) and where T cells with the capacity to recognize foreign antigens in association with self-proteins encoded by the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) are positively selected. The net result of these developmental pathways is a T-cell repertoire that is both self-tolerant and self-restricted. One unresolved issue is the identity of the thymic stromal cells that mediate the negative and positive selection of the T-cell repertoire. Previous work has pointed to a bone-marrow-derived macrophage or dendritic cell as the inducer of tolerance, whereas a radiation-resistant, deoxyguanosine-resistant thymic cell seems to mediate the positive selection of self-MHC restricted T cells. Thymic stromal cells in the cortex interact with the T-cell antigen receptor on thymocytes. Using several strains of transgenic mice that express the class II MHC molecule I-E in specific regions of the thymus, we show directly that the positive selection of T cells is mediated by an I-E-bearing cell in the thymic cortex.

Intrathymic signalling in immature CD4+CD8+ thymocytes results in tyrosine phosphorylation of the T-cell receptor zeta chain

Thymic selection of the developing T-cell repertoire occurs in immature CD4+CD8+ double-positive thymocytes and is thought to be mediated by signals transduced by T-cell antigen receptor (TCR) molecules and possibly by CD4 and CD8 accessory molecules as well. It is not known, however, which signal-transduction mechanisms function in immature CD4+CD8+ thymocytes on engagement of TCR, CD4 or CD8 molecules. In mature T cells, CD4 and CD8 molecules are each associated with the src-like protein tyrosine kinase p56 lck and signals transduced by TCR and CD4 activate tyrosine kinases that phosphorylate TCR-zeta chains and other intracellular substrates. Consequently, we examined whether tyrosine kinases could be similarly activated in immature CD4+CD8+ thymocytes. Unexpectedly, we found that TCR-zeta chains from CD4+CD8+ thymocytes were already phosphorylated in vivo, and that dephosphorylation of this TCR subunit occurred on removal of CD4+CD8+ cells from their intrathymic environment. Rephosphorylation of TCR-zeta in cultured CD4+CD8+ thymocytes occurred rapidly in vitro, either in response to cross-linking of TCR, CD4 or CD8 by specific monoclonal antibodies, or on cell-cell contact. These observations indicate that tyrosine kinases are activated in vivo in immature CD4+CD8+ thymocytes undergoing thymic differentiation and selection. They also indicate that TCR, CD4 and CD8 molecules can function in CD4+CD8+ thymocytes as signalling molecules to activate tyrosine kinases and that phosphorylated TCR-zeta serves as a marker of these signalling events.

Analysis of Mlsc genetics. A novel instance of genetic redundancy

The identity of the self determinants involved in the selection of the T cell repertoire has been a matter of considerable interest. In addition to the apparent critical role of MHC gene products, accumulated experimental results indicate the importance of non-MHC gene products in T cell repertoire selection. In particular, murine Mlsa and Mlsc determinants have been shown to be highly stimulatory to allogeneic T cells and to be involved in the negative selection (elimination) of self-reactive T cells expressing selected TCR V beta segments. In this work, a unique phenomenon of genetic redundancy is described in the control of Mlsc expression: Mlsc appears to be controlled by at least two unlinked loci, and the product of either one of these loci is sufficient to evoke Mlsc-specific T cell response and to act as a ligand in the deletion of self Mlsc-reactive V beta 3+ T cells. Based on these findings, we propose a possible explanation for the fact that Mls-like genes or gene products have not been identified in other species such as man.

Selective decreases in T cell receptor V beta expression. Decreased expression of specific V beta families is associated with expression of multiple MHC and non-MHC gene products

Previous reports of TCR V beta usage, studying either expression of a single V beta in a wide panel of strains (6, 7, 10, 12, 13), or expression of multiple V beta s in a very limited strain distribution (14, 15), have identified instances of clonal deletion of potentially autoreactive T cells specific for either self E alpha E beta or minor lymphocyte stimulatory (Mls) antigens. The present study has investigated the range of self antigens that can influence V beta usage by evaluating expression of 16 V beta families in 30 strains of mice. It was found that significant decreases in expression occur in at least 8 of the 16 V beta families and that dominant influences on the T cell V beta repertoire are exerted by expression of Mlsa, Mlsc, and MHC gene products. Decreased expressions of V beta 5, -11, -12, and -16 were influenced by MHC gene products. The patterns of decreased expression seen in intra-MHC recombinant strains and strains of different non-MHC background were distinct for V beta 11, -12, and -16, suggesting that different ligands are involved in the deletion of T cells expressing each of these V beta genes. Mice expressing Mlsa show decreased expression of V beta 9 as well as V beta 6. Mlsc mice lacked V beta 3 expression in those strains where the expressed MHC type was compatible with a strongly stimulatory Mlsc phenotype. V beta 7 was strongly influenced by both MHC and non-MHC products that are not yet identified. These results demonstrate that strain-specific decreases of mRNA expression occur in a major portion of the TCR repertoire. Self antigens including Mlsa, Mlsc, and E alpha E beta, as well as additional MHC and non-MHC products, appear to induce these decreases in expression in the process of eliminating self-reactive T cells from the mature T cell pool.

In vivo expression and function of hybrid Ia dimers (E alpha A beta) in recombinant and transgenic mice

We have found cell surface expression of an E alpha molecule in recombinant and transgenic mouse strains lacking an E beta molecule. Flow cytometry has shown low level expression of E alpha in B10.RQB3 (I-AqEk alpha) and B10.RFB2 (I-AfEk alpha) mice. We have also found that B10.Q (H-2q) mice can express the Ek alpha transgene. Since these strains do not have functional E beta chains, we propose that the E alpha A beta hybrid dimers are formed in low numbers and can be picked up by FACS analysis. So far we have not been able to identify these hybrid molecules by cytotoxicity or immunoprecipitation. The E alpha/A beta molecule can function in vivo during thymic selection in the clonal deletion of two V beta TCR subsets, V beta 11 and V beta 6, which have been shown to interact with the intact I-E molecule.

T-cell receptor V beta 5 usage defines reactivity to a human T-cell receptor monoclonal antibody

The monoclonal antibody 3D6 reacts with the T-cell receptor (Tcr) on the T-leukemic line HPBALL and with 2-13% of human peripheral blood T lymphocytes. In this study V alpha and V beta expression in a panel of T-cell populations and clones expressing the 3D6 epitope was determined by Southern and northern hybridization analysis. The results demonstrate that these 3D6-positive T cells, regardless of CD4/CD8 phenotype or function, express a gene of the V beta 5 family, also expressed by HPBALL. No correlation was found between 3D6 reactivity and expression of the HPBALL V alpha gene. The results demonstrate that 3D6 recognizes an epitope solely on the Tcr beta chain and that the use of this beta chain, together with an appropriate V alpha, can impart a diverse pattern of reactivity to a T cell.

Inhibition of MHC class II-restricted T cell response by Lyt-2 alloantigen

T cell hybridomas were established by fusing a CD8+ V beta 8.1+ CTL clone and a CD4+ V beta 8.1+ helper T lymphocyte (HTL) clone to the thymoma cell line BW5147. In contrast to the HTL x BW hybridomas, which retain the same antigen specificity as the original T cell clone, the CTL x BW hybridomas lost the class I MHC-restricted antigen response but acquired a new specificity to Mlsa antigen. Mlsa reactivity of CTL x BW hybridomas was shown to be mediated by the CTL TCR as assayed by inhibition using an anticlonotypic antibody to the CTL clone. Since hybridomas established with BW5147 lose CD8 expression, we have introduced the CD8 molecule into CTL x BW5147 hybridomas by gene transfection. The CD8+ V beta 8.1+ hybridoma was no longer capable of reacting to Mlsa antigen but exhibited the same antigen specificity as the parental CTL clone. Furthermore, the presence of the transfected CD8 molecule in the HTL x BW hybridomas was found to be inhibitory to class II MHC-restricted antigen reactivity. These results demonstrate that, besides its role in increasing the overall avidity of T cell-class I MHC/antigen interaction, the CD8 molecule inhibits T cell-class II MHC gene product/antigen interaction. This negative effect of the CD8 molecule on a class II MHC-restricted response may account for the failure of CD8+ T cells using either V beta 8.1 or V beta 6, which impart reactivity to the Mlsa antigen on CD4+ T cells, to respond to the Mlsa antigen.