Stereotactic radiosurgery for the definitive, noninvasive treatment of brain metastases

Radiosurgery for brain metastases: a score index for predicting prognosis

PURPOSE

To analyze a prognostic score index for patients with brain metastases submitted to stereotactic radiosurgery (the Score Index for Radiosurgery in Brain Metastases [SIR]).

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Actuarial survival of 65 brain metastases patients treated with radiosurgery between July 1993 and December 1997 was retrospectively analyzed. Prognostic factors included age, Karnofsky performance status (KPS), extracranial disease status, number of brain lesions, largest brain lesion volume, lesions site, and receiving or not whole brain irradiation. The SIR was obtained through summation of the previously noted first five prognostic factors. Kaplan-Meier actuarial survival curves for all prognostic factors, SIR, and recursive partitioning analysis (RPA) (RTOG prognostic score) were calculated. Survival curves of subsets were compared by log-rank test. Application of the Cox model was utilized to identify any correlation between prognostic factors, prognostic scores, and survival.

RESULTS

Median overall survival from radiosurgery was 6.8 months. Utilizing univariate analysis, extracranial disease status, KPS, number of brain lesions, largest brain lesion volume, RPA, and SIR were significantly correlated with prognosis. Median survival for the RPA classes 1, 2, and 3 was 20.19 months, 7.75 months, and 3. 38 months respectively (p = 0.0131). Median survival for patients, grouped under SIR from 1 to 3, 4 to 7, and 8 to 10, was 2.91 months, 7.00 months, and 31.38 months respectively (p = 0.0001). Using the Cox model, extracranial disease status and KPS demonstrated significant correlation with prognosis (p = 0.0001 and 0.0004 respectively). Multivariate analysis also demonstrated significance for SIR and RPA when tested individually (p = 0.0001 and 0.0040 respectively). Applying the Cox Model to both SIR and RPA, only SIR reached independent significance (p = 0.0004).

CONCLUSIONS

Systemic disease status, KPS, SIR, and RPA are reliable prognostic factors for patients with brain metastases submitted to radiosurgery. Applying SIR and RPA classifications to our patients' data, SIR demonstrated better accuracy in predicting prognosis. SIR should be further tested with larger patient accrual and for all patients with brain metastases subjected or not to stereotactic radiosurgery.

Stereotactic radiation therapy for malignant choroidal tumors: preliminary, short-term results

PURPOSE

To evaluate the role of stereotactic radiation therapy (SRT) in the treatment of malignant choroidal tumors.

DESIGN

Prospective, noncomparative case series.

PARTICIPANTS

Ten patients with unifocal choroidal metastasis (three lung carcinoma, three breast carcinoma, three colon carcinoma, one cutaneous melanoma) and five patients with primary choroidal melanoma underwent single-dose or fractionated SRT.

METHODS

Before treatment, computed tomography (CT) scans of the orbit were obtained with the patient wearing an individualized immobilization mask. An integrated macro-CCD-camera system viewed the eye for detection of movements. Three-dimensional computer-based treatment planning was carried out. Dose distribution was calculated and displayed in isodose lines on the CT data set. For SRT, a dedicated stereotactic linear accelerator (6 MV) was used. Total doses for choroidal metastases were 12 to 20 Gy in a single dose or 30 Gy over 10 days (3 Gy each session), and total doses for choroidal melanoma were 50 Gy over 5 or 10 days (10 or 5 Gy each session).

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Best corrected visual acuity (ETDRS-chart), biomicroscopy, ultrasound examination, fluorescein angiography, and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) were performed before treatment and at regular intervals after completion of SRT.

RESULTS

During a follow-up period from 1 to 34 months (median, 6.5 months), local tumor control was achieved in all eyes. A decrease in tumor size on ultrasonography or MRI was noted in eight patients. No persistent side effects were observed during follow-up.

CONCLUSIONS

Stereotactic radiation therapy allows steep dose gradients outside the target volume by minimizing the field of exposure. Thus only low radiation doses affect surrounding radiosensitive ocular structures. Our initial findings suggest that this technique may be effective in controlling tumor growth. Further studies are needed to compare treatment efficacy and safety with conventional treatment methods.

Linear accelerator radiosurgery in the management of brain tumours

Radiosurgery is an increasingly popular method for treating a variety of intracranial tumours. A great deal of treatment data has been accumulated suggesting that radiosurgery may be the treatment of choice for small acoustic schwannomas. Moreover, radiosurgery promises excellent tumour control and minimal risk in the treatment of small meningiomas in risky surgical locations such as the cavernous sinus. Radiosurgery offers superior local control rates for many metastatic neoplasms and has promise as an adjuvant 'boost' technique in certain malignant gliomas. This article presents a brief description of the linear accelerator, LINAC, radiosurgical technique, followed by a review of the more common applications of stereotactic radiosurgery in the treatment of intracranial neoplastic disease.

Prognostic factors in brain metastases: should patients be selected for aggressive treatment according to recursive partitioning analysis (RPA) classes?

PURPOSE

To determine whether or not Radiation Therapy Oncology Group (RTOG) recursive partitioning analysis (RPA) derived prognostic classes for patients with brain metastases are generally applicable and can be recommended as rational strategy for patient selection for future clinical trials. Inclusion of time to non-CNS death as additional endpoint besides death from any cause might result in further valuable information, as survival limitation due to uncontrolled extracranial disease can be explored.

METHODS

We performed a retrospective analysis of prognostic factors for survival and time to non-CNS death in 528 patients treated at a single institution with radiotherapy or surgery plus radiotherapy for brain metastases. For this purpose, patients were divided into groups with Karnofsky performance status (KPS) <70% and KPS > or =70%, as proposed by the RTOG.

RESULTS

Median overall survival was 2.9 months (2.0 months for patients with KPS <70% and 3.6 months for patients with KPS > or =70%, p < 0.001). We did not find other variables splitting patients with KPS <70% in different prognostic groups. However, advanced age, multiple brain metastases, presence of extracranial metastases, and uncontrolled primary tumor each predicted shorter survival in patients with KPS > or =70%. When grouped into the original RTOG RPA classes, our data set split into three subgroups with different prognosis and median survival times of 10.5, 3.5, and 2 months, respectively (p < 0.05). Only 3% of patients fell into the most favorable group. Median time to non-CNS death was 4.1 months (12.9 months in RPA class I, 4.9 months in RPA class II, and 3.8 months in RPA class III, respectively, p > 0.05 for RPA class II versus III). However, it was 8.5 months in RPA class II patients with controlled primary tumor, which was found to be the only prognostic factor for time to non-CNS death in patients with KPS > or =70%. In patients with KPS <70%, no statistically significant prognostic factors were identified for this endpoint.

CONCLUSIONS

Despite some differences, this analysis essentially confirmed the value of RPA-derived prognostic classes, as published by the RTOG, when survival was chosen as endpoint. RPA class I patients seem to be most likely to profit from aggressive treatment strategies and should be included in appropriate clinical trials. However, their number appears to be very limited. Considering time to non-CNS death, our results suggest that certain patients in RPA class II also might benefit from increased local control of brain metastases.

Treatment outcome for patients with primary nonsmall-cell lung cancer and synchronous brain metastasis

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the outcome of treatment for patients with newly diagnosed nonsmall-cell lung cancer (NSCLC) with an isolated, single, synchronous brain metastasis. A retrospective review was performed evaluating any patient diagnosed between 1982 and 1996 at the Cleveland Clinic Foundation with NSCLC metastatic only to the brain. Patients with multiple brain metastases or with systemic metastases to any other organ were excluded. Survival was measured from the date of the first treatment for malignancy. All hospital records were thoroughly reviewed in a retrospective manner. Thirty-three patients were identified who met the study criteria. Twelve patients had primary disease limited to the lung and hilar nodes, and 21 had more advanced primary disease with involvement of the mediastinum. Treatment of the chest was considered aggressive in 13 patients and palliative in 15. The primary tumor was observed in 5 patients. The management of the brain metastasis was as follows: 21 patients underwent surgical resection and postoperative whole brain radiotherapy (WBRT), 5 underwent stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) and WBRT, 3 had resection alone, 2 had SRS alone, and 2 underwent WBRT alone. The median overall and disease-free survival for all patients was 6.9 months and 3.3 months, respectively. Overall survival was markedly improved with the addition of WBRT (P = 0.002) and with the aggressive management of the primary tumor (P = 0.005). A total of 9 patients experienced CNS failure, including both patients receiving WBRT alone. CNS failures were divided as follows: 3 local, 5 distant, and 1 local and distant. Two of the 4 patients with a local failure were salvaged, and ultimate local control of the original brain metastasis was achieved in 93.6% of cases. Survival remains poor for patients with Stage IV NSCLC even when metastatic disease is limited to a single site within the brain; however, aggressive therapy of both the lung primary and the brain metastasis may provide a survival advantage. Excellent local control of single brain metastases was achieved with a combination of WBRT with either surgical resection or SRS.

Dose optimization and indication of Linac radiosurgery for brain metastases

PURPOSE

The authors have examined treatment effects of linear accelerator based radiosurgery for brain metastases. Optimal doses and indications were determined in an attempt to improve the quality of life for terminal cancer patients.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Ninety-two patients with 162 lesions were treated with Linac radiosurgery for brain metastases between April 1993 and September 1998. To determine prognostic factors, risk factors for recurrence, and appearance of new lesions, univariate and multivariate analyses were performed. To compare the local control between the high-dose (minimum dose > or =25 Gy: prescribed to the 50-80% isodose line) and low-dose (minimum dose <25 Gy) irradiated groups, matched-pairs analysis was performed.

RESULTS

Median survival time was 11 months. In univariate analysis, extracranial tumor activity (p<0.001) and Karnofsky Performance Status (KPS) (p = 0.036) were two significant predictors of survival. In multivariate analysis, the status of an extracranial tumor was the single significant predictor of survival (p = 0.005). Minimum dose was the single most significant predictor of local recurrence in univariate, multivariate, and matched-pairs analyses (p<0.05). As to the appearance of new lesions, activity of extracranial tumors was a significant predictor (p<0.05). Side effects due to radiosurgery were experienced in 4 of 92 cases (4.3%).

CONCLUSIONS

We concluded that brain metastases patients should be irradiated with > or =25 Gy, when extracranial lesions are stable and longer survival is expected. Combined surgery and conventional radiation may have little advantage over radiosurgery alone when metastatic brain tumors are small and extracranial tumors are well controlled. When extracranial tumors are progressive, the rate of appearance of new lesions in other nonirradiated locations becomes higher. In such cases, careful follow-up is required and a combination with whole brain irradiation should be considered.

Stereotactic radiosurgery for brainstem metastases

OBJECT

Brainstem metastases portend a dismal prognosis. Surgical resection is not part of routine management and radiation therapy has offered little clinical benefit. Radiosurgery provides a safe and effective treatment for many patients with brain metastasis, but its role in the brainstem has not been evaluated. In this study the authors examine the role of radiosurgery in the treatment of brainstem metastases.

METHODS

The authors reviewed the outcomes after stereotactic radiosurgery in 26 patients with 27 brainstem metastases. Tumor locations included the pons (21 tumors) and midbrain (six tumors): 14 patients had additional tumors in other locations. Twenty patients presented with brainstem signs. The median dose to the tumor margin was 16 Gy (range 12-20 Gy). Twenty-four patients received fractionated whole-brain radiation therapy (WBRT) and 12 underwent additional chemotherapy or immunotherapy. The median follow-up time in these patients was 9.5 months (range 1-43 months). After radiosurgery, the local control rate in brainstem tumors was 95%. In one patient in whom the tumor initially decreased in size, tumor enlargement was seen 7 months later. The median survival time was 11 months after diagnosis and 9 months after radiosurgery. Thirteen patients improved, 10 were stable, and three deteriorated. Eventually, 22 patients died, 18 of progression of their extracranial disease, three of new tumor growth (including one hemorrhage into a new brain metastasis), and one of extracranial disease plus new brain tumor growth.

CONCLUSIONS

Although they have slightly lower than the expected survival rates of patients with nonbrainstem tumors, patients with brainstem metastases may achieve effective palliation after stereotactic radiosurgery and WBRT.

Metastatic breast cancer

The unfortunate reality of metastatic breast cancer is that all treatment is palliative in nature. This is a disease that currently has no cure and for which therapy is directed towards accentuating survival and relieving symptoms. Current technology allows the prediction and detection of metastases earlier and with greater accuracy. These achievements need to be consolidated by the discovery of innovative therapies that can alter the inevitable outcome of this disease.

Prophylactic cranial irradiation in locally advanced non-small-cell lung cancer after multimodality treatment: long-term follow-up and investigations of late neuropsychologic effects

PURPOSE

Relapse pattern and late toxicities in long-term survivors were analyzed after the introduction of prophylactic cranial irradiation (PCI) into a phase II trial on trimodality treatment of locally advanced (LAD) non-small-cell lung cancer (NSCLC).

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Seventy-five patients with stage IIIA(N2)/IIIB NSCLC were treated with induction chemotherapy, preoperative radiochemotherapy, and surgery. PCI was routinely offered during the second period of study accrual. Patients were given a total radiation dose of 30 Gy (2 Gy per daily fraction) over a 3-week period starting 1 day after the last chemotherapy cycle.

RESULTS

Introduction of PCI reduced the rate of brain metastases as first site of relapse from 30% to 8% at 4 years (P =.005) and that of overall brain relapse from 54% to 13% (P <.0001). The effect of PCI was also observed in the good-prognosis subgroup of 47 patients who had a partial response or complete response to induction chemotherapy, with a reduction of brain relapse as first failure from 23% to 0% at 4 years (P =.01). Neuropsychologic testing revealed impairments in attention and visual memory in long-term survivors who received PCI as well as in those who did not receive PCI. T2-weighted magnetic resonance imaging revealed white matter abnormalities of higher grades in patients who received PCI than in those who did not.

CONCLUSION

PCI at a moderate dose reduced brain metastases in LAD-NSCLC to a clinically significant extent, comparable to that in limited-disease small-cell lung cancer. Late toxicity to normal brain was acceptable. This study supports the use of PCI within intense protocols for LAD-NSCLC, particularly in patients with favorable prognostic factors.

A patient with brain metastasis from ovarian cancer who showed complete remission after multidisciplinary treatment

We describe a case with brain metastasis from ovarian cancer who showed complete remission after multidisciplinary treatment. The case was diagnosed as epithelial ovarian cancer, FIGO stage IIIc. She underwent cisplatin-based chemotherapy after optimal cytoreductive surgery and achieved clinical complete remission. Thirty-two months after surgery for ovarian cancer, a solitary metastasis occurred in the left frontal lobe of the brain. No recurrent lesions were observed outside the brain. The metastatic tumor was resected. Five days after operation, adjuvant chemotherapy comprising carboplatin and cisplatin was initiated (a total of three courses at 4-week intervals), and whole brain irradiation at 55 Gy was added. After these treatment methods, complete remission of the brain metastasis has been observed for 57 months with good quality of life.

Stereotactic radiosurgery plus whole brain radiotherapy versus radiotherapy alone for patients with multiple brain metastases

PURPOSE

Multiple brain metastases are a common health problem, frequently diagnosed in patients with cancer. The prognosis, even after treatment with whole brain radiation therapy (WBRT), is poor with average expected survivals less than 6 months. Retrospective series of stereotactic radiosurgery have shown local control and survival benefits in case series of patients with solitary brain metastases. We hypothesized that radiosurgery plus WBRT would provide improved local brain tumor control over WBRT alone in patients with two to four brain metastases.

METHODS

Patients with two to four brain metastases (all < or =25 mm diameter and known primary tumor type) were randomized to initial brain tumor management with WBRT alone (30 Gy in 12 fractions) or WBRT plus radiosurgery. Extent of extracranial cancer, tumor diameters on MRI scan, and functional status were recorded before and after initial care.

RESULTS

The study was stopped at an interim evaluation at 60% accrual. Twenty-seven patients were randomized (14 to WBRT alone and 13 to WBRT plus radiosurgery). The groups were well matched to age, sex, tumor type, number of tumors, and extent of extracranial disease. The rate of local failure at 1 year was 100% after WBRT alone but only 8% in patients who had boost radiosurgery. The median time to local failure was 6 months after WBRT alone (95% confidence interval [CI], 3.5-8.5) in comparison to 36 months (95% CI, 15.6-57) after WBRT plus radiosurgery (p = 0.0005). The median time to any brain failure was improved in the radiosurgery group (p = 0.002). Tumor control did not depend on histology (p = 0.85), number of initial brain metastases (p = 0.25), or extent of extracranial disease (p = 0.26). Patients who received WBRT alone lived a median of 7.5 months, while those who received WBRT plus radiosurgery lived 11 months (p = 0.22). Survival did not depend on histology or number of tumors, but was related to extent of extracranial disease (p = 0.02). There was no neurologic or systemic morbidity related to stereotactic radiosurgery.

CONCLUSIONS

Combined WBRT and radiosurgery for patients with two to four brain metastases significantly improves control of brain disease. WBRT alone does not provide lasting and effective care for most patients.

Surgery and radiotherapy compared with gamma knife radiosurgery in the treatment of solitary cerebral metastases of small diameter

OBJECT

The aim of this retrospective study was to compare treatment results of surgery plus whole-brain radiation therapy (WBRT) with gamma knife radiosurgery alone as the primary treatment for solitary cerebral metastases suitable for radiosurgical treatment.

METHODS

Patients who had a single circumscribed tumor that was 3.5 cm or smaller in diameter were included. Treatment results were compared between microsurgery plus WBRT (52 patients, median tumor dose 50 Gy) and radiosurgery alone (56 patients, median prescribed tumor dose 22 Gy). In case of local/distant tumor recurrence in the radiosurgery group, additional radiosurgical treatment was administered in patients with stable systemic disease. Survival time was analyzed using the Kaplan-Meier method, and prognostic factors were obtained from the Cox model. The patient groups did not differ in terms of age, gender, pretreatment Karnofsky Performance Scale (KPS) score, duration of symptoms, tumor location, histological findings, status of the primary tumor, time to metastasis, and cause of death. Patients who suffered from larger lesions underwent surgery (p < 0.01). The 1-year survival rate (median survival) was 53% (68 weeks) in the surgical group and 43% (35 weeks) in the radiosurgical group (p = 0.19). The 1-year local tumor control rates after surgery and radiosurgery were 75% and 83%, respectively (p = 0.49), and the 1-year neurological death rates in these groups were 37% and 39% (p = 0.8). Shorter overall survival time in the radiosurgery group was related to higher systemic death rates. A pretreatment KPS score of less than 70 was a predictor of unfavorable survival. Perioperative morbidity and mortality rates were 7.7% and 1.6% in the resection group, and 8.9% and 1.2% in the radiosurgery group, respectively. Four patients presented with transient radiogenic complications after radiosurgery.

CONCLUSIONS

Radiosurgery alone can result in local tumor control rates as good as those for surgery plus WBRT in selected patients. Radiosurgery should not be routinely combined with radiotherapy.

MR imaging response of brain metastases after gamma knife stereotactic radiosurgery

PURPOSE

To characterize the magnetic resonance (MR) imaging response of brain metastases after gamma knife stereotactic radiosurgery and determine whether imaging features and tumor response rates correlate with local tumor control and survival.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Serial MR examinations were performed in 48 patients (25 men, 23 women; mean age, 58 years) with 78 lesions. Pretreatment and follow-up enhancing lesion volumes and imaging features were assessed. Rates of response to stereotactic radiosurgery were calculated. Prognostic imaging features affecting local control and survival were analyzed.

RESULTS

Local tumor control was achieved in 66 (90%) of 73 metastases at 20 weeks after stereotactic radiosurgery; 61% maintained local control at 2 years. A homogeneous baseline enhancement pattern and initial good response rate (> 50% lesion volume reduction) predicted local control. Five metastases demonstrated a transient volume increase after treatment. The median survival time after stereotactic radiosurgery was 53 weeks and correlated with systemic disease burden and primary tumor type.

CONCLUSION

Baseline homogeneous tumor enhancement and initial good response correlate with local control. Initial lesion growth does not preclude local control and may represent radiation-related change. Recognition of these serial MR imaging findings may guide image interpretation and influence treatment in patients with stereotactic radiosurgery-treated metastases.

Brain metastases in musculoskeletal sarcomas

BACKGROUND

In musculoskeletal sarcomas, brain metastases are rare, but severely affect quality of life.

METHODS

All patients with musculoskeletal sarcomas who were treated at our institutions from 1975 to 1997 were reviewed for examples of brain metastasis.

RESULTS

Of 480 sarcoma patients, 179 had distant metastases, including 20 patients with brain metastases (4.2%). Alveolar soft part sarcoma (3/4), extraskeletal Ewing's sarcoma (2/8), rhabdomyosarcoma (2/13) and bone Ewing's sarcoma (2/18) tended to metastasize to the brain. All 20 patients had distant or local relapses and 16 of the 20 patients had pulmonary metastases. Three patients underwent surgical treatment and two of them survived over 1 year. Mean survival after diagnosis of brain metastasis was 5.1 months.

CONCLUSIONS

Patients with alveolar soft part sarcoma, Ewing's sarcoma, rhabdomyosarcoma and pulmonary metastases have a high risk of brain metastasis.

Resection of brain metastases from colorectal carcinoma in 73 patients

BACKGROUND

At the time of diagnosis of colorectal carcinoma, 2-3% of patients are likely to be harboring brain metastases, and another 10% of patients will develop brain lesions during the course of their disease. The purpose of this study was to examine the clinical course of a group of patients with metastatic brain disease who underwent surgical resection in a single institution. The authors believe this information will be useful for establishing prognostic factors and for clinical decision making.

METHODS

Between 1974 and 1993, 709 consecutive patients underwent surgical resection of brain metastases at Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center. Seventy-three patients had histologically confirmed colorectal carcinoma. The medical records of these patients were reviewed retrospectively, and the data were analyzed by univariate and multivariate analysis.

RESULTS

The median age of the 43 women and 30 men was 61.5 years. The median interval from the time of diagnosis of the primary tumor and the development of brain metastases was 27.6 months. The primary colorectal tumor was resected in all patients, and the median survival from the day of surgery was 38 months. The median survival from the time of craniotomy was 8.3 months. The 1-year and 2-year survival rates were 31.5% and 6.8%, respectively. Postoperative mortality was 4%. Gender, presence of multiple metastases, presence of lung lesions, and adjuvant brain radiation after craniotomy appeared to have no impact on survival as determined by multivariate Cox analysis. Only the presence of cerebellar brain metastases was associated with decreased survival.

CONCLUSIONS

The results of this series, which the authors believe is the largest series of resected brain metastases from colorectal carcinoma published to date, indicate that surgical resection may increase the survival of these patients. Analysis of prognostic factors shows that infratentorial tumor location is associated with a poorer survival compared with supratentorial tumor location (5.1 months vs. 9.1 months; P < 0.002). In patients with recurrent brain disease, repeated resection is a worthwhile consideration because it may prolong survival compared with patients who do not undergo re-resection.

Prognostic factor analysis for multiple brain metastases after gamma knife radiosurgery: results in 97 patients

Stereotactic radiosurgery (SR) is being used with increasing frequency in the treatment of brain metastases. This study provides data from a clinical experience with radiosurgery in the treatment of cases with multiple metastases and identifies parameters that may be useful in the proper selection and therapy of these patients. From January 1993 to April 1997, 97 patients (43 women and 54 men; median age 58 years) suffering from multiple brain metastases (median 3; range 2-4) in MRI scans, received SR with the Gamma Knife. The median dose at the tumor margin was 20 Gy (range 17-30 Gy). Median tumor volume was 3900 cmm (range 100-10,000). Different forms of hemiparesis, focal and generalized seizures, cognitive deficit, headache, dizziness and ataxia had been the predominant neurological symptoms. Major histologies included lung carcinoma (44%), breast cancer (21%), renal cell carcinoma (10%), colorectal cancer (8%), and melanoma (7%). The median survival time was 6 months after SR. The actual one-year survival rate was 26%. In univariate and multivariate analysis, a higher Karnofsky performance rating and absence of extracranial metastases had a significantly positive effect on survival. Local tumor control was achieved in 94% of the patients. Complications included the onset of peritumoral edema (n = 5) and necrosis (n = 1). SR induces a significant tumor remission accompanied by neurological improvement and, therefore, provides the opportunity for prolonged high quality survival. We conclude that radiosurgical treatment of multiple brain metastases leads to an equivalent rate of survival when compared to the historic experience of patients treated with whole brain radiotherapy. Patients presenting initially with a higher Karnofsky performance rating and without extracranial metastases had a median survival time of nine months. Each such case should therefore be evaluated based on these factors to determine an optimal treatment regimen.

Detection of brain metastasis in potentially operable non-small cell lung cancer: a comparison of CT and MRI

STUDY OBJECTIVE

To compare the usefulness of MRI and CT in the detection of brain metastases during preoperative evaluation and postoperative follow-up.

DESIGN

A prospective and sequential comparison.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Of 332 patients with potentially operable non-small cell lung cancer who were free of neurologic signs and symptoms, brain CT was performed preoperatively on 155 patients (CT group) and brain MRI on 177 patients (MRI group). Patient characteristics in both groups were comparable. In 279 patients with complete resection of the primary lung tumor, intensive follow-up with CT and MRI was performed in the respective groups. The preoperative detection of brain metastases, postoperative intracranial recurrence rates, and characteristics of detected brain tumors were compared between the two groups. The survival of patients with brain metastases was also compared.

RESULTS

From the first evaluation to 12 months after surgery for primary lung cancer, brain metastases were observed in 11 patients (7.1%) from the CT group and 12 patients (6.8%) from the MRI group. MRI detected brain metastases preoperatively in 6 of the 12 patients (3.4% of the total MRI group), whereas CT detected brain metastases preoperatively in 1 of the 11 patients (0.6% of the total CT group). MRI showed a tendency toward a higher preoperative detection rate of brain metastases than CT (p = 0.069). Furthermore, the mean (+/- SD) maximal diameter of the brain metastases was significantly smaller in the MRI group (12.8+/-9.1 mm) than in the CT group (20.3+/-7.0 mm) (p = 0.041). However, the median survival time and 2-year survival rate after treatment of detected brain metastases, respectively, were 10 months and 27% in the CT group and 17 months and 28% in the MRI group. There was no significant difference between the groups in survival time.

CONCLUSIONS

Preoperative evaluation and intensive follow-up with MRI could facilitate early detection of brain metastases in patients with potentially operable lung cancer. However, further studies on detection and treatment of the metastatic tumors are considered necessary.

The changing role of surgery in the diagnosis and treatment of cancer

Many changes have occurred in the surgical treatment of the cancer patient. For many tumors, surgery has been modified or eliminated. These changes are due to the realization that, for some cancers, more extensive surgical procedures are not more beneficial, to improvements in radiation therapy and chemotherapy, to the availability of better noninvasive or less invasive diagnostic and therapeutic techniques, and to improved surgical equipment (such as videoscopic surgery).

Fractionated stereotactic radiotherapy of small intracranial malignancies

PURPOSE

To retrospectively evaluate the effectiveness of fractionated stereotactic radiotherapy (FSRT) in patients with small intracranial malignancies.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

From July 1991 to March 1997, 80 patients with a total of 121 brain or skull-base tumors were treated with FSRT alone, and were followed for periods ranging from 3 to 62 months (median 9.8). The majority of patients received 42 Gy in 7 fractions over 2.3 weeks, but in July 1993, protocols using smaller fraction doses were introduced for patients whose radiation-field diameters were larger than 3 cm or whose tumors were close to critical normal tissues.

RESULTS

For 64 patients with metastatic brain tumors the overall median survival was 8.3 months and 1-year actuarial survival rate was 33%. Significant prognostic factors were: the presence of extracranial tumors, pre-treatment performance status, and the lung as a primary site. Patients without extracranial tumors prior to FSRT had a median survival of 21.2 months. For seven patients with high-grade glioma, 1-year actuarial local control rate was 75%, with a median survival of 10.3 months. For patients with skull-base tumors the local control was achieved in 6 of 6 patients (100%), with a median survival of 30.7 months. No one suffered from acute complications, but three patients, two of whom had undergone FSRT as the third course of radiotherapy, developed late radiation injuries.

CONCLUSION

Overall high local control and low morbidity rates suggest that FSRT is an effective and safe modality, even for those with a history of prior irradiation. However, patients with risk factors should be treated with smaller fraction doses.

Local delivery of chemotherapy prolongs survival in experimental brain metastases from breast carcinoma

OBJECTIVE

Despite improved systemic control of metastatic breast cancer, the incidence of brain metastases from breast carcinoma continues to rise, in part because most systemically administered agents have poor central nervous system penetration. Therefore, as a method of optimizing drug delivery into the central nervous system, we studied the safety and efficacy of chemotherapy delivered locally via biodegradable polymers in a mouse model of breast carcinoma metastases to the brain.

METHODS

The chemotherapeutic agents carmustine (BCNU), carboplatin, and camptothecin were incorporated into controlled release polymers and tested individually against intracranial challenges of EMT-6 breast tumor in BALB/c female mice. For each drug, four groups were tested: Group 1, empty polymer (no drug); Group 2, external beam radiotherapy (XRT) alone; Group 3, local chemotherapy from biodegradable polymer alone; and Group 4, local chemotherapy and XRT together. Polymers were implanted 5 days after intracranial tumor inoculation; XRT was administered on Days 7 through 9 (300 cGy/d).

RESULTS

BCNU polymer alone (n = 10; median survival time, >200 d; P < 0.0001) and BCNU and XRT together (n = 10; median survival time, 41 d; P = 0.02) significantly improved survival in mice with intracranial EMT-6 breast cancer in comparison with control animals (n = 20; median survival time, 17 d). Carboplatin and camptothecin, either with or without XRT, and XRT alone did not have any significant effect on survival.

CONCLUSION

Local delivery of BCNU with biodegradable polymers can significantly prolong survival in a murine model of intracranial metastatic breast cancer. Surgical resection and placement of BCNU polymers into the resection cavity may decrease the incidence of local recurrence of breast cancer metastases with minimal morbidity.

Preliminary experience with frameless stereotactic radiotherapy

PURPOSE

To report initial clinical experience with a novel high-precision stereotactic radiotherapy system.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Sixty patients ranging in age from 2 to 82 years received a total of 1426 treatments with the University of Florida frameless stereotactic radiotherapy system. Of the total, 39 (65%) were treated with stereotactic radiotherapy (SRT) alone, and 21 (35%) received SRT as a component of radiotherapy. Pathologic diagnoses included meningiomas (15 patients), low-grade astrocytomas (11 patients), germinomas (9 patients), and craniopharyngiomas (5 patients). The technique was used as means of dose escalation in 11 patients (18%) with aggressive tumors. Treatment reproducibility was measured by comparing bite plate positioning registered by infrared light-emitting diodes (IRLEDs) with the stereotactic radiosurgery reference system, and with measurements from each treatment arc for the 1426 daily treatments (5808 positions). We chose 0.3 mm vector translation error and 0.3 degrees rotation about each axis as the maximum tolerated misalignment before treating each arc.

RESULTS

With a mean follow-up of 11 months, 3 patients had recurrence of malignant disease. Acute side effects were minimal. Of 11 patients with low grade astrocytomas, 4 (36%) had cerebral edema and increased enhancement on MR scans in the first year, and 2 required steroids. All had resolution and marked tumor involution on follow-up imaging. Bite plate reproducibility was as follows. Translational errors: anterior-posterior, 0.01 +/- 0.10; lateral, 0.02 +/- 0.07; axial, 0.01 +/- 0.10. Rotational errors (degrees): anterior-posterior, 0.00 +/- 0.03; lateral, 0.00 +/- 0.06; axial, 0.01 +/- 0.04. No patient treatment was delivered beyond the maximum tolerated misalignment. Daily treatment was delivered in approximately 15 min per patient.

CONCLUSION

Our initial experience with stereotactic radiotherapy using the infrared camera guidance system was good. Patient selection and treatment strategies are evolving rapidly. Treatment accuracy was the best reported, and the treatment approach was practical.

Patient selection criteria for the treatment of brain metastases with stereotactic radiosurgery

In this study we evaluate prognostic factors that predict local-regional control and survival following stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) in patients with brain metastasis and establish guidelines for patient selection. Our evaluation is based on 73 patients with brain metastasis treated with SRS at the University of Minnesota between March 1991 and November 1995. The ability of stereotactic radiosurgery to improve local control in patients with brain metastases is confirmed in our study in which only 6 of 62 patients failed locally after SRS, with an actuarial local progression-free survival of 80% at 2 years. Variables that predicted worse prognosis were larger tumor size (p = 0.05) for local progression-free survival and multiplicity of metastasis (p = 0.03) and infratentorial location of metastases (p = 0.006) for regional progression-free survival. Absence of extracranial disease, KPS > or = 70, and single intracranial metastasis were significant predictors of longer survival. Patients who fulfill all three criteria will survive longer after SRS (MS = 17.7 months) and will most likely benefit from the increase local control in the brain achieved by SRS. Survival in patients who do not meet any of these criteria is very poor (MS = 1.5 months), and these patients are less likely to benefit from this treatment. Careful selection of patients for SRS is warranted.

Stereotactic radiosurgery for cerebral metastatic melanoma: factors affecting local disease control and survival

PURPOSE

The development of a brain metastasis represents an ominous event for patients with malignant melanoma. We evaluated results after stereotactic radiosurgery (SR) for patients with metastastic melanoma to identify patient outcomes and factors for survival.

METHODS

The authors reviewed the management results of 60 consecutive patients with melanoma metastases, with a total of 118 melanoma brain metastases, undergoing SR during a 9-year interval. Of these, 51 also had whole-brain radiation therapy (WBRT). A total of 118 tumors of mean volume of 2.95 ml (range, 0.1-25.5 ml) were treated by SR with a mean margin dose of 16.4 Gy (range, 10 to 20 Gy). Univariate and multivariate analyses were used to determine significant prognostic factors affecting survival in 60 patients.

RESULTS

Median survival was 7 months after SR in all 60 patients and 10 months from brain tumor diagnosis (mean follow-up period, 9.3 months). Lack of active systemic disease and a solitary metastasis were associated with improved survival in multivariate analysis (median, 15 months). The imaging-defined local control rate of evaluable tumors (n = 72) was 90% (disappearance = 11%, shrinkage = 44%, and stable = 35%). Local recurrence developed in 7 patients and remote brain disease developed in 14 patients. WBRT combined with radiosurgery did not improve survival nor local tumor control. New brain metastases developed less often when WBRT was added to SR (23% vs. 44%), but this difference was not significant. Only 4 patients (7%) died from progression of a radiosurgery-managed tumor. No patient developed a delayed radiation-related complication, but 3 patients developed delayed intratumoral hemorrhage at the radiosurgery site, 2 of whom had new symptoms.

CONCLUSIONS

Stereotactic radiosurgery for melanoma brain metastasis is effective and is associated with few complications. The use of radiosurgery alone is an appropriate management strategy for many patients with solitary tumors.

Radiographic findings and morbidity in patients treated with stereotactic radiosurgery

PURPOSE

To determine the prognostic significance of pretreatment edema, lesion size and location on morbidity following stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS).

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Forty-seven evaluable patients with 63 lesions were treated on a 6-MV linear accelerator radiosurgery system at Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center. All patients received a 10-mg intravenous bolus of dexamethasone sodium phosphate (Decadron) prior to SRS. Thirteen patients were treated for asymptomatic lesions while 34 were treated because of neurologic symptoms. The median dose delivered was 1800 cGy and the median prescription isodose curve was 85%. Pretreatment edema was measured on a transaxial T2-weighted MR image acquired within 1 month of the SRS.

RESULTS

Ten patients experienced morbidity as a result of their treatment. The complication rate was measured by neurologic events following SRS and was not significantly influenced by the extent of peritumoral edema. Lesion size was also unrelated to the development of post-treatment symptoms as assessed by the ease of tapering steroids. The only parameter found to influence post-SRS complications was lesion location. Four of six (66%) patients treated to lesions in the motor cortex suffered post-SRS seizure activity, whereas only 6 of 37 (16%) patients treated to lesions elsewhere in the brain parenchyma experienced seizure activity.

CONCLUSION

The presence of pretreatment edema and lesion size are not predictors of post-SRS complication rates or the ability to taper Decadron. Lesion location is predictive of post-SRS seizure activity.

Prognostic factors derived from recursive partition analysis (RPA) of Radiation Therapy Oncology Group (RTOG) brain metastases trials applied to surgically resected and irradiated brain metastatic cases

PURPOSE

(a) To identify the prognostic factors that determine survival after surgical resection and irradiation of tumors metastatic to brain. (b) To determine if the prognostic factors used in the recursive partition analysis (RPA) of brain metastases cases from Radiation Therapy Oncology Group (RTOG) studies into three distinct survival classes is applicable to surgically resected and irradiated patients.

METHOD

The medical records of 125 patients who had surgical resection and radiotherapy for brain metastases from 1985 to 1997 were reviewed. The patients' disease and treatment related factors were analyzed to identify factors that independently determine survival after diagnosis of brain metastasis. The patients were also grouped into three classes using the RPA-derived prognostic parameters which are: age, performance status, state of the primary disease, and presence or absence of extracranial metastases. Class 1: patients < or = 65 years of age, Karnofsky performance status (KPS) of > or =70, with controlled primary disease and no extracranial metastases; Class 3: patients with KPS < 70. Patients who do not qualify for Class 1 or 3 are grouped as Class 2. The survival of these patients was determined from the time of diagnosis of brain metastases to the time of death.

RESULTS

The median survival of the entire group was 9.5 months. The three classes of patients as grouped had median survivals of 14.8, 9.9, and 6.0 months respectively (p=0.0002). Age of < 65 years, KPS of > or = 70, controlled primary disease, absence of extracranial metastases, complete surgical resection of the brain lesion(s) were found to be independent prognostic factors for survival; the total dose of radiation was not.

CONCLUSION

Based on the results of this study, the patients and disease characteristics have significant impact on the survival of patients with brain metastases treated with a combination of surgical resection and radiotherapy. These parameters could be used in selecting patients who would benefit most from such treatment.

Central nervous system metastases

OBJECTIVES

To review current management of individuals with metastases to the central nervous system and brachial nerve plexus, and to provide a scientific basis for nursing management of the effects of the disease and treatment.

DATA SOURCES

Published articles, book chapters, clinical trial data, and experience from nursing literature.

CONCLUSIONS

Central nervous system metastases are events that may create oncologic emergencies with neurologic impairment and pain. Treatment of patients with central nervous system metastases is generally palliative regardless of the type of the primary cancer. Early diagnosis and treatment improve the chances for optimal recovery of neurologic function and pain management.

IMPLICATIONS FOR NURSING PRACTICE

Central nervous system metastases may develop in patients with systemic disease. Disease and treatment effects present challenges to patients, family, and care providers. Nurses have a responsibility in educating the patient/family and in providing supportive care.

Stereotactic radiosurgery for brain metastasis from renal cell carcinoma

BACKGROUND

The authors evaluated results after stereotactic radiosurgery (SR) for brain metastases from renal cell carcinoma (RCC) and identified factors associated with improved survival and tumor control.

METHODS

The authors reviewed the management results from a total of 52 RCC brain metastases in 35 consecutive patients who underwent stereotactic radiosurgery (SR) during a 9-year interval. Twenty-eight patients also underwent whole brain radiation therapy (WBRT). The mean tumor volume was 2.4 mL (range, 0.1-14.1 mL). The mean dose delivered to the tumor margin was 17 gray (Gy) (range, 13-20 Gy). Univariate and multivariate testing was performed to determine significant prognostic factors.

RESULTS

The median survival was 11 months after SR and 14 months after brain tumor diagnosis. Only 2 patients (8%) died of progression of the irradiated tumor. Age < 55 years, lack of active systemic disease, and use of chemotherapy and/or immunotherapy after SR were significant favorable prognostic factors in multivariate testing. Post-SR imaging was evaluated in 26 patients (39 tumors). The local control rate from the 39 treated tumors imaged was 90% (tumor disappearance, 21%; tumor regression, 44%; and stable disease, 26%). Local recurrence developed in 3 patients (4 lesions) and remote brain disease in 12 patients. No patient developed a new focal neurologic deficit due to SR. Patients were classified into two groups: SR with and SR without WBRT. The addition of WBRT to SR did not improve survival. Distant failure occurred similarly in both groups (46% vs. 50%). WBRT combined with SR may contribute to local control, but did not prevent the development of new remote tumors.

CONCLUSIONS

SR for brain metastasis from RCC results in brain disease control in the majority of patients and was associated with few complications. Early detection of brain metastases and treatment with SR provides extended quality survival.

Prognosis of patients treated for intracranial metastases with whole-brain irradiation

Seventy-five patients with brain metastases from solid tumours were treated with whole-brain irradiation at our institution between 1990 and 1993. The primary cancers included 35 cases of lung cancer, 19 cases of breast cancer, nine cases of renal-cell cancer, six cases of melanoma and six cases of other primary sites. In each case the total dose to the whole brain was at least 25 gray (Gy). The primary site, age, performance status, number of brain metastases and the presence of extracranial disease were studied as prognostic factors for survival. The median survival for the whole population was 4 months (range 1-62 months). The patients with the brain as the only metastatic site had significantly better survival (P = 0.019) than those with both intracranial and extracranial metastatic sites. Poor performance status at the time of diagnosis of brain metastases was also related to short survival (P = 0.001). None of the other studied variables had prognostic significance. Four of the 75 patients with primary tumour sites in the breast (two patients) and the kidney (two patients) survived for more than 2 years. In general, patients with breast cancer had better survival than patients with other primary cancers. Our study confirms the generally poor prognosis of cancer with brain metastases, although individual patients may survive several years after whole-brain irradiation. Approximately two-thirds of the patients experienced a relief in symptoms allowing a reduction in the dose of corticosteroid medication, which clearly supports the use of whole-brain radiotherapy as a palliative treatment.

[Importance of radiotherapy in stereotactic conditions (radiosurgery) in brain metastasis: experience and results of the Hôpital Pitié-Salpêtrière Group]

PURPOSE

Retrospective analysis of the influence of clinical and technical factors on local control and survival after radiosurgery for brain metastasis.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

From January 1994 to December 1996, 42 patients presenting with 71 metastases underwent radiosurgery for brain metastasis. The median age was 56 years and the median Karnofsky index 80. Primary sites included: lung (20 patients), kidney (seven), breast (five), colon (two), melanoma (three), osteosarcoma (one) and it was unknown for three patients. Seventeen patients had extracranial metastasis. Twenty-four patients were treated at recurrence which occurred after whole brain irradiation (12 patients), surgical excision (four) or after both treatments (eight). Thirty-six sessions of radiosurgery have been realized for one metastasis and 13 for two, three or four lesions. The median metastasis diameter was 21 mm and the median volume 1.7 cm3. The median peripheral dose to the lesion was 14 Gy, and the median dose at the isocenter 20 Gy.

RESULTS

Sixty-five metastases were evaluable for response analysis. The overall local control rate was 82% and the 1-year actuarial rate was 72%. In univariate analysis, theoretical radioresistance (P = 0.001), diameter less than 3 cm (P = 0.039) and initial treatment with radiosurgery (P = 0.041) were significantly associated with increased local control. Only the first two factors remained significant in multivariate analysis. No prognostic factor of overall survival was identified. The median survival was 12 months. Six patients had a symptomatic oedema (RTOG grade 2), only one of which requiring a surgical excision.

CONCLUSION

In conclusion, 14 Gy delivered at the periphery of metastasis seems to be a sufficient dose to control most brain metastases, with a minimal toxicity. Better results were obtained for lesions initially treated with radiosurgery, theoretically radioresistant and with a diameter less than 3 cm.

Neurologic emergencies in cancer patients

Neurologic emergencies are common among cancer patients and their incidence is increasing as patients live longer as a result of improved antineoplastic therapy. This article reviews acute neurologic complications in cancer patients. Among those complications reviewed are brain metastases, epidural spinal cord compression, leptomeningeal metastases, cerebrovascular disorders, complications of antineoplastic therapy, and paraneoplastic syndromes.

Focal, high dose, and fractionated modified stereotactic radiation therapy for lung carcinoma patients: a preliminary experience

BACKGROUND

Stereotactic radiation therapy is highly effective in the treatment of small brain metastases, regardless of the histology. This suggests that small extracranial malignancies may be curable with similar radiation therapy. The authors developed a novel treatment unit for administering such therapy.

METHODS

The unit consisted of a linear accelerator (linac), an X-ray simulator (X-S), computed tomography (CT), and a table. The gantry axes of the three machines were coaxial and could be matched by rotating the table. Patients were instructed to perform shallow respiration with oxygen. The motion of the tumor was monitored with the X-S. When the motion was slight enough, the table was rotated to the CT. To include all geometric movement on the CT images, each scan was made while the patient was performing shallow respiration. After the CT positioning, the table was rotated to the linac, and non-coplanar treatment was given. Beginning in October 1994, 45 patients with 23 primary or 43 metastatic lung carcinomas were treated. Radiation doses at the 80% isodose line were 30-75 gray in 5-15 fractions over 1-3 weeks with or without conventional radiation therapy.

RESULTS

The treatment was performed with no or minimal adverse acute symptoms. The daily treatment time was short. During a median follow-up of 11 months, local progression occurred in 2 of 66 lesions. Interstitial changes in the lung were limited.

CONCLUSIONS

With this unit and procedure, focal radiation therapy similar to stereotactic radiation therapy is possible for extracranial sites. The preliminary experience appeared safe and promising, and further exploration of this approach is warranted.

Stereotactic radiosurgery for brain metastases: comparison of lung carcinoma vs. non-lung tumors

In the medical literature, stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) for brain metastases results in rates of local control of 65 to 85 %. To define patient selection criteria, we measured the survival in a population with a high proportion of non-small cell lung carcinoma (NCS lung) metastases that occurred soon after primary diagnosis. Between 9/89 and 10/93 30 adults (21 M, 9 F) had SRS for metastatic NSC lung carcinoma (14 patients) vs. non-lung carcinomas (16 patients having breast (3), renal (3), melanoma (3), GI (2, thyroid (1) or carcinoma of unknown origin (4)). The metastases were solitary for 22 patients and multiple for 8 patients. Average ages (y) (+/-SD) were 58.6+/-10.4 for NSC lung patients and 53.4+/-12.5 (p = 0.32) for non-lung patients. The average interval (months) from diagnosis of the primary to metastasis was 23.8+/-41.4 for all patients. This interval was shorter for NSC lung patients: 3.1+/-6.0 vs. 48.0+/-51.7 (p < 0.001) for non-lung patients. Twenty seven patients had conventional radiotherapy (XRT) before (24 patients) or after (3 patients) SRS. Doses (cGy) were 3303+/-841 for 13 NSC lung patients and 4256+/-992 for 14 non-lung patients (p = 0.034). The median time from primary diagnosis to SRS was shorter for the NSC lung patients (11 mo) compared to the non-lung patients (35 mo). SRS was given for recurrence of metastases after XRT for 11/14 NSC lung patients and 13/16 non-lung patients. The doses (cGy) of SRS were 1579+/-484 vs. 1682+/-476 (p=0.45) for the NSC lung and non-lung groups, respectively. After SRS a decrease in metastasis diameter was observed in 10 of 14 NSC lung patients vs. 12 of 16 non-lung patients (p=0.85 Chi-square). Twenty-seven of the 30 patients have died. For all patients, the median survival after diagnosis of the primary and after radiosurgery was 31.3 and 8.4 months, respectively. The median survival (95% CI) from primary diagnosis was 24.3 months (13.2-27.3) for NSC lung patients and 46.5 months (39.2-65.5) for non-lung patients (p=0.005 logrank test). The median survival (95% CI) after SRS was 7.9 months (3.0-14.3) for the NSC lung patients and 8.4 (2.9-11.9) months for the non-lung patients (p=0.98 logrank test). Within the two groups, no difference in survival was observed for patients who had SRS sooner (< 1 yr for NSC lung; < 3 yr for non-lung) after primary diagnosis: 9.3 vs. 6.5 mo for NSC lung (p=0.21) and 10.5 vs. 7.2 mo for non-lung (p=0.87). In this series, the shortened intervals from primary diagnosis to SRS for NSC lung metastases was associated with post-SRS survivorship that was equivalent to the more favorable non-lung group.

[Radiosurgery of brain metastasis]

Radiosurgery has recently provided an alternative to conventional therapy for the treatment of brain metastases. This non-invasive technique delivers a single large fraction of ionizing radiation to a well-defined small intracranial target as brain metastases. After a computerized tomography (CT) with stereotactic frame in place for tumor localization, a dosimetric study was performed. The sharp dose gradient of radiation reduces the dose to the surrounding normal structures at a minimal level (> 10%). The prescribed dose at the periphery of the lesion varies from 8 to 27 Gy with a combined whole brain irradiation and from 20 to 35 Gy without any irradiation. Radiosurgery has been reported to be highly efficacious with a local control rate of 86% (not increased size without local recurrence). Brain metastases from melanoma and renal carcinoma are usually resistant to conventional irradiation and are highly sensitive with this technique. The morbidity is very low with a symptomatic edema rate of 5-10% at 2 years, resolved with corticosteroids. A radiation necrosis has been reported in less than 5% of cases. The patients with a good performance status, without any extracranial metastasis and with a solitary brain metastases have presented the best survival rate. New brain metastases have occurred in 20 to 30% of the cases during the follow-up. Eleven to 25% of patients died from their intracranial disease and the others from the extracranial evolution of the cancer. The median survival was still poor, ranging from 8 to 12 months. Radiosurgery is a good choice for surgically inaccessible and recurrent tumors. It represents an alternative to the neurosurgery with or without whole brain irradiation, taking into account different prognostic factors and morbidity rate. The local control and the survival rates without neurologic symptom should be considered the major endpoints of different ongoing randomized studies for evaluating the role of the radiosurgery.

Clinical management of brain metastasis

Brain metastasis is a common complication occurring in about 15-20% of all cancer patients. For the initial management, distinguishing between three types of presentation is essential: de novo brain metastasis, simultaneous presentation of both brain metastasis and the primary tumour (usually lung carcinoma), and the presentation of a patient known to have systemic cancer developing a brain metastasis. For de novo brain metastasis, surgery is required, and detecting the primary tumour is of limited value. For simultaneous presentation, both a craniotomy and a thoracotomy may be indicated and may lead to cure in a number of cases. For a sequential presentation, the outcome is determined by a number of independent prognostic factors: age, performance status, and the extent of metastatic disease. In relatively young patients with a single brain metastasis, good performance status and no progression of systemic disease, treatment by either surgery or radiosurgery in combination with whole brain radiation therapy is indicated. Otherwise, as in multiple brain metastases, radiation therapy only is the main treatment. For symptomatic therapy of brain oedema or increased intracranial pressure, dexamethasone is administered. The standard doses of dexamethasone may vary between 4 and 16 mg/day, depending on the severity of symptoms.

Serial MR imaging of intracranial metastases after radiosurgery

PURPOSE

To evaluate the spatiotemporal evolution of radiosurgical induced changes both in metastases and in normal brain tissue adjacent to the lesions by serial magnetic resonance (MR) imaging.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Thirty-five intracranial metastases of different primaries were treated in 25 patients by single high-dose radiosurgery. MR images acquired before radiosurgery were available in all patients. Sixty-three follow-up MR studies were performed in these patients including T2- and contrast-enhanced T1-weighted MR images. The average follow-up time was 9 +/- 5 months (mean +/- standard deviation [SD]). Based on contrast-enhanced T1-weighted MR images, tumor response was radiologically classified in the following four groups: stable disease was assumed if the average tumor diameter after treatment did not show a tumor shrinkage of more than 50% and an increase of more than 25%, partial remission as a shrinkage of tumor size of more than 50%, a disappearance of contrast-enhancing tumor as a complete remission, and an increase of tumor diameter of more than 25% as tumor progress. Moreover, we analysed signal changes on T2-weighted images in brain parenchyma adjacent to the enhancing metastases.

RESULTS

The overall mean survival time was 10.5 +/- 7 months, with a 1-year actuarial survival rate of 40%. Stable disease, partial or complete remission of the metastatic tumor was observed in 22 patients (88%). Central or homogeneous loss of contrast enhancement appeared to be a good prognostic sign for stable disease or partial remission. This association was statistically significant (p < 0.05). Three patients (12%) suffered from tumor progression. In eight patients (32%) with stable disease or partial remission, signal changes on T2-weighted images were observed in tissue adjacent to the contrast enhancing lesions. A progression of the high signal on T2-weighted images was seen in seven of the eight patients between 3 and 6 months after therapy, followed by a signal regression 6-18 months after irradiation.

CONCLUSION

MR imaging is a sensitive imaging tool to evaluate tumor response as well as the presence or absence of adjacent parenchymal changes following radiosurgery. Loss of homogeneous or central contrast enhancement on Gd-enhanced MR images appeared to be a good prognostic sign for tumor response. Tumor shrinkage seems not to be dependent on time. In addition, most cases of radiation induced changes in normal brain parenchyma observed on T2-weighted images seem to be self limited.

Radiosurgery for the treatment of brain metastases

Surgical resection and whole brain radiotherapy (WBRT) have been the mainstays of the treatment of cerebral metastases. This approach results in a median survival of about 10 months. Several recent publications and our own experience suggest that a similar median survival can be achieved with stereotactic radiosurgery using either the Leksell Gamma Knife or the linear accelerator radiosurgical techniques. In addition, radiosurgery can effectively treat metastatic tumors in surgically inaccessible sites, e.g., the brainstem. Radiosurgery can also effectively treat multiple intracranial metastases in widely separated areas of the brain. In fact, we have shown that patients with multiple metastases have similar lengths and qualities of survival as do patients with single metastases treated with stereotactic radiosurgery. The most important predictor of success in radiosurgical treatment of cerebral metastases is the neurological status of the patient, usually expressed as the Karnofsky Performance Status (KPS). The histological type of primary cancer is not an outcome predictor. Even so-called "radioresistant" tumors (e.g., melanoma, renal cell) respond favorable to radiosurgery. A great benefit of radiosurgery is the virtual lack of perioperative complications and the minimal interference with quality of life compared either to surgery or to fractionated whole brain radiotherapy. Long-term complications of radiosurgery are infrequent and primarily relate to failure of local tumor control (10%) and radiation-induced edema or necrosis. The later usually can be controlled with corticosteroids, but occasionally, craniotomy may be required to treat life-threatening mass effects. We believe that radiosurgery is the treatment of choice for most cerebral metastases. Only large lesions (> 3.5-4 cm diameter) and those which require immediate decompression to treat life-threatening mass effects require surgical treatment. Radiosurgery also may be used to treat residual disease after surgical resection. We have shown that WBRT does not increase the efficacy of radiosurgery in the treatment of cerebral metastases, and, therefore, we prefer to avoid both the short- and long-term morbidity of that treatment, if possible.

Whole brain radiotherapy in the treatment of metastatic brain tumors

Previous prospective and retrospective trials have failed to demonstrate the best treatment approach for patients with brain metastases. As a result, fractionated whole brain radiotherapy (WBRT) has been the mainstay of treatment for several decades. However, with improved surgical techniques and the advent of radiosurgical procedures to treat single and multiple metastases, the continued value of WBRT is in question. This is particularly true in the treatment of a favorable patient subset where the risks of long-term morbidity need to be addressed. This article reviews the trials of the Radiation Therapy Oncology Group (RTOG) and other select radiotherapy brain metastases trials, and compares their morbidities and outcomes to surgical and radiosurgical techniques. It is unfortunate that the inherent selection bias in most retrospective studies makes comparisons difficult. Therefore, to better understand the roles of WBRT, surgery, and radiosurgery in the treatment of brain metastases, additional randomized studies need to be conducted on homogeneous patient groups.