Early postpartum discharges. Impact on distress and outpatient problems

Length of stay after childbirth in India: a comparative study of public and private health institutions

Background

This paper discusses length of stay (LOS) following childbirth as an indicator of quality of postnatal care in health institutions. This research aims to describe LOS according to both vaginal and cesarean deliveries in public and private health care institutions in India, and to identify any association of LOS with postnatal care and post-delivery complications.

Methods

We use recently released nationally-representative data from the National Family Health Survey-4 (2015–16) and apply the Cox proportional hazard model to determine the factors associated with LOS at the health facility after childbirth during a five-year period preceding the survey.

Results

Overall, the average LOS after childbirth is 3.4 days; 2.1 days for vaginal deliveries and 8.6 days for cesarean section (CS) deliveries. Strikingly, half of the women are discharged within 48 h. Women who give birth in private hospitals have a more prolonged stay than those who give birth in public health facilities. For vaginal birth in public hospitals, one-fourth of the women are discharged with insufficient LOS as against only 19.2% women in private hospitals. LOS is significantly related to the cost of delivery only in the case of private facilities. Uneducated women belonging to lower wealth quintile households and those living in rural areas stay for a shorter duration for vaginal deliveries but for a longer duration in case of cesarean deliveries. Women who get four or more antenatal check-ups (ANC) done have a longer stay, while those who receive benefits under the Janani Suraksha Yojna (JSY) have a shorter stay. Another key finding is that women who are discharged on the same day report lower levels of postnatal care and a higher proportion of post-delivery complications.

Conclusion

The study concludes that early discharge has a negative association with maternal health outcomes, which has important program implications. Therefore, it is essential to maintain an adequate LOS at a facility after childbirth. We recommend that government programs should strengthen the JSY scheme not only to improve delivery care, but also to provide effective postnatal care by promoting sufficient LOS at facilities.

Proportion of neonatal readmission attributed to length of stay for childbirth: a population-based cohort study

OBJECTIVE

Most literature on length of stay (LOS) for childbirth focuses on 'early' discharge as opposed to 'optimal' time of discharge and has conflicting results due to heterogeneous definitions of 'early' discharge and differing eligibility criteria for these programmes. We aimed to determine the LOS associated with the lowest neonatal readmission rate following childbirth by examining the incidence pattern of neonatal readmission for different LOS using the Kitagawa decomposition.

DESIGN

Retrospective cohort study using administrative hospitalisation data.

SETTING

Canada (excluding Quebec) from 2003 to 2010.

PATIENTS

Term, singleton live births without congenital anomalies.

INTERVENTIONS

LOS for childbirth.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE

Neonatal readmissions within 30 days of birth.

RESULTS

1 875 322 live births were included. Neonatal LOS peaked at day 1 (47.3%) after vaginal birth and day 3 (49.3%) following caesarean section; 4.2% of infants were readmitted following vaginal birth and 2.2% after caesarean section. In 2008-2010, most readmissions occurred among infants discharged in the first 2 days (83.8%) following a vaginal birth and among infants discharged in the first 3 days (81.7%) following a caesarean birth. Readmissions increased from 4.1% in 2003-2005 to 4.6% in 2008-2010 among vaginal births and from 2.0% to 2.4% among caesarean births and occurred mostly due to changes in the day-specific readmission rates and not due to reductions in LOS.

CONCLUSIONS

Patterns of readmission suggest that readmission rates are lowest following a 1-2-day stay following a vaginal birth and a 2-4-day stay following a caesarean birth given the outpatient support in the community.

Postpartum care: evaluation and experience among care providers and care receivers

INTRODUCTION

There have been substantial alterations in the structure of postpartum care over the last several decades. Our aim was to investigate the perceived quality of, and satisfaction with, postpartum care among caregivers and care receivers in the maternity ward of a community hospital in Norway with about 2600 births per year.

METHODS

We conducted a cohort study of women giving birth and the caregiving staff in the maternity ward during a 7-month period. A questionnaire, with a Cronbach α coefficient above 0.8, was filled in anonymously, both by the staff in the ward and by the women. The questionnaire explored the respondents' evaluations of the information offered by the staff; the teaching of skills in child care and establishment of breastfeeding; assistance with practical tasks like making beds, serving meals, and keeping order in the room; visiting rules; level of noise in the ward; whether the pediatric service was adequate; length of the stay; and to what extent caregivers were able to respond to the individual needs of the mothers. Finally, the questionnaire explored the degree of kindliness communicated by the staff. Five extra questions in the women's questionnaire explored their personal experiences in the ward.

RESULTS

The care receivers' evaluations of the maternity ward did not differ significantly from that of the caregivers in questions related to overall care and service. However, the mothers rated the importance of assistance with child care during the night significantly higher than did the staff. Responses to questions addressing noise in the ward demonstrated a higher tolerance among the mothers compared with the staff. In addition, mothers tended (but not a statistically significant result) to rate the quality of the teaching of child-care skills lower, compared with the staff's ratings.

DISCUSSION

By exploring both the caregivers' and care receivers' evaluations and expectations of the actual services in the maternity ward, areas for enhancement of the quality of the ward and its services can be detected and carried out. The present study revealed 2 areas needing further focus: assistance with child care during the night and teaching of child-care skills during the stay. We believe that investigations that collect data from both caregivers and care receivers, by using adapted and validated questionnaires to gather information on quality and satisfaction with the maternity ward, are mandatory for improvement and continuous adaptation of health services.

Early postpartum discharge and breastfeeding: an observational study from France

BACKGROUND

Early postpartum discharge is a recent practice in France, but the influence of a shortened hospital stay on subsequent breastfeeding is unknown. The objective of the present study was to compare the breastfeeding mode after early discharge (ED) and conventional discharge (CD) from a hospital maternity unit.

METHODS

An observational study was conducted in a French university hospital among 135 breastfeeding mothers, who delivered between 1 January and 31 July 2006. Forty-five ED mothers were matched with 90 CD mothers on 13 criteria. A structured questionnaire was used to collect data regarding feeding practices at 10 weeks postpartum, the period corresponding to paid maternity leave.

RESULTS

Exclusive breast-, mixed, and bottle feedings were reported by, respectively, 35 (77.8%), three (6.7%) and seven (15.5%) ED mothers and 64 (71.1%), 12 (13.3%) and 14 (15.6%) CD mothers (no significant differences). Satisfaction with support for breastfeeding and reasons for switching to mixed or bottle feeding were comparable in the two groups. Multivariate analysis indicated that only the planned duration of breastfeeding and the mother's dissatisfaction with help significantly influenced breastfeeding prevalence.

CONCLUSIONS

Early postpartum hospital discharge organized by skilled professionals is compatible with a satisfactory rate of exclusive breastfeeding up to the return to work. Formalized programs of instruction for perinatal professionals would help to reduce early abandonment.

Utilization of health care services of pregnant women complicated by preeclampsia in Ontario

OBJECTIVE

To assess the utilization of health care services by pregnant women affected by preeclampsia (PE).

DESIGN

Population-based study.

SETTING

Perinatal partnership hospitals in Ontario.

POPULATION

Obstetric deliveries in 2005 Canadian province of Ontario (about 95% of births).

METHODS

For each PE case, four subjects without PE matched by age, parity, plurality, and hospital at childbirth were chosen as the controls. We compared the utilization of intra-partum care services and infant outcomes between the two groups. We also estimated the extra costs to the health care system in Ontario for caesarean delivery and caring of extremely low birth weight infants attributable to PE during the neonatal period and in the first 2 years of life.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Cesarean delivery, hospital stay, extremely low birth weight infants, cost.

RESULTS

Of the 120,611 obstetric deliveries included in this analysis, 1240 (1.3%) were diagnosed with PE. Patients with PE and matched controls were similar in maternal age, parity, and other demographic characteristics. Compared with study subjects without PE, those with PE had increased uses of spinal anesthesia, maternal transfer, Cesarean delivery, labour induction, neonatal transfer, newborn resuscitation, longer hospital stay for childbirth, and higher rates of preterm births and low birth weight. The extra costs to the health care system for cesarean delivery and caring of extremely low-birth-weight infants attributable to PE during the neonatal period and in the first 2 years of life in Ontario were $0.5 millions, 3.1 millions, and $5.1 million per year, respectively, if we use the reported PE rate in this database.

CONCLUSION

PE is associated with substantially increased costs to the health care system.

Health problems related to early discharge of Turkish women

OBJECTIVE

to determine women's problems when discharged early from hospital after normal vaginal birth among a simple convenience sample of mothers in one part of Turkey.

DESIGN

a descriptive interview study.

SETTING

primary health-care unit in Erzurum, Turkey.

PARTICIPANTS

112 mothers who came to the primary health-care unit for vaccination of their 2-month old babies between May and June 2000. Data were collected by structured face-to-face interviews. A symptom checklist was used to determine health problems.

FINDINGS

length of hospital stay after delivery was a mean of 7.1+/-7.0 hrs, and 66.1% (n=74) of mothers did not receive appropriate education about potential postpartum health problems. The findings indicated that the morbidity rate of mothers in the postpartum period was high. Among the most prevalent problems experienced by mothers were fatigue (86.6%; n=97), insomnia (80.4%; n=90), breast problems [engorged breast, tenderness and pain] 71.4%; n=80) and constipation 61.7%; n=69). Vaginal infection was reported by 16 mothers (14.3%; n=16). The prevalence of the use of medical services resulting from postnatal health problems in the postpartum period was 42.0% (n=47). About half of the mothers (51.8%; n=58) were not visited by midwives during the first postpartum week after discharge from hospital because both the maternity hospital and mother had not reported any health problems to the midwife. RECOMMENDATIONS FOR PRACTICE: mothers can experience many problems in the postpartum period. It is not possible to predict which mother will experience risks, such as an infection or mastitis. Therefore, women discharged from hospital in the first 24 hrs after birth should be educated about the problems that may arise during the postpartum period. They should also be given professional care and help in their own home by midwives working in the primary-care unit. Mothers should be told to notify their midwives about delivery and discharge in order to receive early follow-up in their homes. We suggest promoting maternal health education that encourages women to seek appropriate and timely care.

Length of stay after vaginal birth: sociodemographic and readiness-for-discharge factors

BACKGROUND

The impact of reductions in postpartum length of stay have been widely reported, but factors influencing length of hospital stay after vaginal birth have received less attention. The study purpose was to compare the sociodemographic characteristics and readiness for discharge of new mothers and their newborns at 3 discharge time intervals, and to determine which variables were associated with postpartum length of stay.

METHODS

The study sample comprised 1,192 mothers who were discharged within 2 postpartum days after uncomplicated vaginal birth at a tertiary perinatal center in the midwestern United States. The sample was divided into 3 postpartum length-of-stay groups: group 1 (18-30 hr), group 2 (31-42 hr), and group 3 (43-54 hr). Sociodemographic and readiness-for-discharge data were collected by self-report and from a computerized hospital information system. Measures of readiness for discharge included perceived readiness (single item and Readiness for Discharge After Birth Scale), documented maternal and neonatal clinical problems, and feeding method.

RESULTS

Compared with other groups, the longest length-of-stay group was older; of higher socioeconomic status and education; and with more primiparous, breastfeeding, white, married mothers who were living with the baby's father, had adequate home help, and had a private payor source. This group also reported greater readiness for discharge, but their newborns had more documented clinical problems during the postbirth hospitalization. In logistic regression modeling, earlier discharge was associated with young age, multiparity, public payor source, low socioeconomic status, lack of readiness for discharge, bottle-feeding, and absence of a neonatal clinical problem.

CONCLUSIONS

Sociodemographic characteristics and readiness for discharge (clinical and perceived) were associated with length of postpartum hospital stay. Length of stay is an outcome of a complex interface between patient, provider, and payor influences on discharge timing that requires additional study. Including perceived readiness for discharge in clinical discharge criteria will add an important dimension to assessment of readiness for discharge after birth.

The role of early newborn discharge legislation in influencing policy development: understanding the Kansas experience

Early newborn discharge legislation began a movement in health policy towards incremental changes in how medical consumers receive services. While well intentioned, these initiatives may undermine national efforts to address problems through more comprehensive reform, while stifling smaller efforts to address the problems locally. This paper discusses early newborn discharge legislation in Kansas: its origins, apparent impact, and implications. Findings from a hospital survey and two-year follow-up suggest a minimal effect of the legislation on health services in the state. Though acute hospital care appeared to replace home-based programs in many hospitals we spoke with, the more longstanding impact of the legislation seems to have been its precedent in how health policy is now made.

Does postpartum length of stay affect breastfeeding duration? A population-based study

BACKGROUND

Short postpartum hospital stays may leave inadequate time for women to receive assistance with breastfeeding. Women leaving the hospital early may also have household responsibilities that could interfere with breastfeeding. This study examined the relationship between postpartum length of stay and breastfeeding cessation.

METHODS

This study used data from 10,519 respondents to the California Maternal and Infant Health Assessment (MIHA) surveys from 1999 to 2001. MIHA is an annual statewide stratified random sample, population-based study of childbearing women in California. Survival analysis was used to examine the relationship between length of stay and length of time breastfeeding. Women were asked about the number of nights their infant stayed in the hospital at birth, whether they breastfed, and if so, the age of the child when they stopped. Hospital stay was defined in three categories: standard (2 nights for a vaginal delivery, 4 nights for a cesarean section), or shorter or longer than the standard stay.

RESULTS

Approximately 88 percent of women initiated breastfeeding. Unadjusted predictors of breastfeeding cessation included short or long postpartum stay; young maternal age; Hispanic, African American, or Asian/Pacific Islander race/ethnicity; being unmarried; low income or education level; primiparity; being born in the 50 United States or the District of Columbia; smoking during pregnancy; and low infant birthweight. After adjustment for potential confounders, women with a short stay remained slightly more likely to terminate breastfeeding than women with a standard stay (relative risk, 1.11, 95% confidence interval 1.01, 1.23).

CONCLUSION

Women who leave the hospital earlier than the standard recommended stay are at somewhat increased risk of terminating breastfeeding early.

Post-maternity outcomes following health care reform in Alberta: 1992-1996

OBJECTIVE

The effect of Alberta's health reform on length of stay for maternity cases and on subsequent mothers' rehospitalization was examined in the present study.

METHODS

The data set included all Alberta acute care hospital separation records from 1991/92 to 1996/97 inclusive. A logistic regression was applied to the data in order to examine the effects of prepartum condition, type of delivery, length of stay, maternal age, and year on the likelihood of readmission.

RESULTS

Health reform proved to be associated with a dramatic decrease in length of stay for maternity cases; from 3.8 to 2.4 days on average. This was accompanied by very little variation in the 90-day readmission rate for mothers over the same time period (notably, a slight decrease). Higher readmission rates were associated with the existence of difficulties during the pregnancy and other prenatal conditions, maternal age, and with the type of delivery. There were no dramatic changes in the rates for prepartum diagnoses, nor for the type of delivery.

DISCUSSION

The data suggest that the reduction in the length of maternity stay has had no discernible negative health effects on new mothers, perhaps because of the home visiting programs that were put in place. Furthermore, there may still be room to improve outcomes by focussing on those with prepartum conditions and cases involving complicated births.

Effects on breastfeeding of changes in maternity length-of-stay policy in a large health maintenance organization

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effects on breastfeeding rates of a private-sector early discharge program and a subsequent government mandate guaranteeing 48 hours of hospital coverage.

METHODS

Interrupted time-series analyses were conducted on retrospective data from the automated medical records of a large health maintenance organization in eastern Massachusetts. A population of 20 366 mother-infant pairs with normal vaginal deliveries between October 1990 and March 1998 was identified. This study period spanned the 2 interventions of interest: 1) the introduction of a new health maintenance organization protocol of 1 postpartum overnight hospitalization followed by a nurse home visit for normal vaginal deliveries, then 2) Massachusetts state minimum coverage legislation. Breastfeeding initiation and breastfeeding continuation among initiators (exclusive or with supplements) into the third month of life were determined through a text search of the first 90 days of infants' automated medical records.

RESULTS

Both policies had dramatic impacts on length of stay (LOS); postpartum LOS <2 nights rose from 29% of pairs to 65% when the early discharge program was implemented, then fell to 15% after the state mandate. Breastfeeding initiation, however, rose gradually from 71% in the fourth quarter of 1990 to 82% in the first quarter of 1998, with no changes after the interventions. Continuation of breastfeeding among those who initiated remained constant at 73%. Younger maternal age, primiparity, low socioeconomic status, and nonwhite race all were found to be risk factors for lower rates of breastfeeding (either initiation or continuation), but there was no evidence of a decline in breastfeeding associated with shorter LOS among these vulnerable groups.

CONCLUSIONS

Early postpartum discharge with outpatient breastfeeding support and a home visitor program has no adverse effects on initiation or continuation of breastfeeding.

Newborn early discharge revisited: are California newborns receiving recommended postnatal services?

CONTEXT

Responding to safety concerns, federal and state legislation mandated coverage of minimum postnatal stays and state legislation in California mandated coverage of follow-up after early discharge. Little is known about the postnatal services newborns are receiving.

OBJECTIVE

To describe rates of early discharge and of timely follow-up for early-discharged newborns.

DESIGN AND SETTING

Retrospective, population-based cohort study using a 1999 postpartum survey in California.

PARTICIPANTS

A total of 2828 infants of mothers with medically low-risk singleton births.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Rates of early discharge (<or=1-night stay after vaginal delivery and <or=3-night stay after cesarean section) and untimely follow-up (no home or office visit within 2 days of early discharge).

RESULTS

Overall, 49.4% of newborns were discharged early. Of these, 67.5% had untimely follow-up. The odds of early discharge were greater with lower incomes: the adjusted odds ratios (AORs) (with 95% confidence intervals) were 2.06 (1.50-2.83) for incomes <or=100% of poverty, 2.20 (1.65-2.93) for incomes from 101%-200% of poverty, and 2.24 (1.63-3.08) for incomes from 201%-300% of poverty. Untimely follow-up was more likely for infants of women with incomes <or=100% of poverty (AOR = 1.89 [1.13-3.17]) and 201%-300% of poverty (AOR = 1.78 [1.09-2.91]), Medicaid coverage (AOR = 1.73 [1.20-2.47]), Latina ethnicity (AOR = 1.47 [1.02-2.14]), and non-English language (AOR = 1.72 [1.16-2.55]).

CONCLUSIONS

Despite an apparent decline in short stays after legislation, many newborns--particularly from lower-income families--continue to be discharged early. Most newborns discharged early--particularly those with Medicaid and those from low-income, Latina, and non-English-speaking homes--do not receive recommended follow-up. The most socioeconomically vulnerable newborns are receiving fewer postnatal services.

Home versus hospital breastfeeding support for newborns: a randomized controlled trial

BACKGROUND

The advantages of breastfeeding have been well established for both mothers and their infants. Existing research reports equivocal effects of early discharge and postpartum home care on breastfeeding success. The purpose of this study was to compare the effects of breastfeeding support offered in hospital and home settings on breastfeeding outcomes and maternal satisfaction for mothers of term and near-term newborns who experienced standard or early discharge.

METHODS

In a randomized controlled trial with prognostic stratification for gestational age, 101 term and 37 near-term (35-37 weeks' gestational age) mother-newborn pairs were randomized to either a standard care group (standard care and standard length of hospitalization) or an experimental group (standard hospital care with early discharge and home support from nurses who were certified lactation consultants). Data collection occurred before randomization, at discharge from hospital, and from 5 to 12 days postpartum. Primary outcomes included breastfeeding rates and maternal satisfaction.

RESULTS

More mothers of term newborns in the experimental group were breastfeeding exclusively at follow-up (p = 0.02) compared with the control group. No significant breastfeeding differences occurred among mothers with near-term newborns in the experimental and standard care groups.

CONCLUSIONS

In-home lactation support appears to facilitate positive breastfeeding outcomes for mothers of term newborns. This may also be a beneficial model of postpartum care for mothers of near-term newborns; however, further research is required. The findings suggest implications for health caregivers and policy makers with respect to postpartum lactation and health care services.

What mothers want: a postnatal survey

Mothers in the public health care system undergo mandatory early discharge after childbirth. The challenges associated with the decreasing length of hospital stay have rarely been investigated from a service consumer perspective. The aim of this study was to identify mothers' needs in the immediate postpartum period. An inpatient survey of 500 postnatal mothers undertaking the Early Discharge Program. Survey questions aimed to elicit the needs of mothers in the immediate postnatal period; perceived barriers to optimal care; and suggestions as to how these barriers could be addressed. Forms were distributed to all women on admission to a postnatal ward over a two month period and completed prior to discharge. Of 500 eligible mothers, 151 (30.2%) responded to the anonymous open ended survey. A thematic analysis of comments revealed that women wanted specific information about mothering, the creation of a restful environment, adequate pain relief, practical assistance, education, and set visiting times. For new mothers, early discharge made the need for rest and information a high priority. Constraints within the public health care system and midwifery practice need to be examined to better serve mothers' needs. Midwifery practice within the context of early postpartum discharge should seek to better serve new mothers by giving high priority for rest and information requirements.

Breastfeeding initiation and duration: a 1990-2000 literature review

OBJECTIVE

To review the literature on breastfeeding initiation and duration and to delineate effective strategies for promoting positive breastfeeding behaviors.

DATA SOURCES

Computerized searches on MEDLINE, CINAHL, and the Cochrane Library.

STUDY SELECTION

Articles from indexed journals relevant to the objective and published after 1990 (except for classic findings) were reviewed. Although a myriad of pertinent articles was located, referenced citations were limited to three per point. When article selection was required for a specific point, preferences were given to (a) randomized controlled trials; (b) meta-analyses; (c) studies with the largest, most representative samples; and (d) investigations conducted in North America.

DATA EXTRACTION

Data were extracted and organized under the following headings: benefits of breastfeeding, breastfeeding initiation and duration, personal characteristics, attitudinal and intrapersonal characteristics, hospital policies and intrapartum experience, sources of support, breastfeeding interventions, and review implications.

DATA SYNTHESIS

Although the health benefits of breastfeeding are well documented and initiation rates have increased over the past 20 years, most mothers wean before the recommended 6-months postpartum because of perceived difficulties with breastfeeding rather than due to maternal choice. Women least likely to breastfeed are those who are young, have a low income, belong to an ethnic minority, are unsupported, are employed full-time, decided to breastfeed during or late in pregnancy, have negative attitudes toward breastfeeding, and have low confidence in their ability to breastfeed. Support from the mother's partner or a nonprofessional greatly increases the likelihood of positive breastfeeding behaviors. Health care professionals can be a negative source of support if their lack of knowledge results in inaccurate or inconsistent advice. Furthermore, a number of hospital routines are potentially detrimental to breastfeeding. Although professional interventions that enhance the usual care mothers receive increase breastfeeding duration to 2 months, these supportive strategies have limited long-term effects. Peer support interventions also promote positive breastfeeding behaviors and should be considered.

CONCLUSIONS

A promising intervention is the complementation of professional services with peer support from a mother experienced in breastfeeding. This lay support appears to be an effective intervention with socially disadvantaged women.