Is the incidence of infantile esotropia declining?: a population-based study from Olmsted County, Minnesota, 1965 to 1994

The incidence, clinical features, and management of essential infantile esotropia in the United Kingdom. A British Ophthalmology Surveillance Unit (BOSU) study

BACKGROUND/OBJECTIVES

A national study was undertaken through the British ophthalmology surveillance unit (BOSU) to determine the incidence, presenting features and management of essential infantile esotropia (EIE) in the UK.

METHODS

Data from a prospective national observational study of newly diagnosed EIE presenting to clinicians in the United Kingdom over a 12-month period were collected. Cases with a confirmed diagnosis by a clinician of a constant, non-accommodative esotropia ≥20 prism dioptres (PD), presenting at ≤12 months, with no neurological or ocular abnormalities were identified through BOSU. Follow-up data were collected at 12 months.

RESULTS

A total of 57 cases were reported giving an incidence of EIE of 1 in 12,828 live births. The mean age of diagnosis and intervention were 7.05 ± 2.6 months (range 2-12) and 14.7 ± 4.9 months (range 6.5-28.1), respectively. Management was surgical in 59.6%, botulinum toxin alone in 22.8%, and 17.5% were observed. The preoperative angle of esotropia was smaller in the observation group (P = 0.04). The postoperative angle of esotropia was not statistically significant between botulinum toxin or surgery (P = 0.3), although the age of intervention was earlier in the botulinum group (P = 0.007). Early intervention (before 12 months of age) did not influence the post-intervention motor outcomes between 0 and 10 prism dioptres of esotropia (P = 0.78).

CONCLUSIONS

The incidence of EIE in the UK is considerably lower than reported in other population-based studies. The preferred method of treatment was surgical with earlier intervention in those treated with botulinum toxin. An early age of intervention (<12 months) did not influence motor outcomes.

Gender differences in horizontal strabismus: Systematic review and meta-analysis shows no difference in prevalence, but gender bias towards females in the clinic

Background

Strabismus is a misalignment of the visual axis that affects 2-3% of the population and can lead to loss of binocular vision. It is currently controversial whether there is a gender difference in the most common form of visual misalignment: horizontal strabismus. Some studies claimed that more females than males have an outward deviation (exotropia), while others concluded that there is no significant gender difference. No previous work has systematically explored gender differences in horizontal strabismus or has compared the results of population-based studies with those of clinic-based studies.

Methods

We conducted a systematic review and meta-analysis of studies reporting the prevalence of horizontal strabismus. We included 73 population-based studies and compared their disclosed gender population with that in 141 comparable clinical-based studies. We analysed the data according to gender, strabismus type (esotropia, exotropia), and geographic region/ethnicity.

Results

Summary statistics showed a nearly identical prevalence of horizontal strabismus (2.558% for males, 2.582% for females), esotropia (1.386% males vs. 1.377% females), and of exotropia (1.035% males vs. 1.043% females). Meta-analysis results showed that these differences between males and females were not statistically significant (odds ratio (OR) = 1.01; 95% confidence interval (CI) = 0.97-1.10), but that females were significantly more frequent (by 7.50%) in clinic-based studies than males, with 5.00% more females for esotropia, and 12.20% more females for exotropia when adjusted for the population's sex ratio. The extent of the female gender bias differed between geographic regions/societies, with Asians having the lowest bias towards females and Latin American countries having the strongest bias.

Conclusions

Males and females have the same prevalence of horizontal strabismus, including exotropia. Females with strabismus seek health care or are brought to clinics significantly more often than males. This is an example of gender bias in health care in favour of females rather than males, apparently because parents - erroneously fearing only cosmetic consequences - are more concerned about strabismus in their daughters than their sons. Societal attitudes towards females, as well as economic factors (insurance status), appear to be relevant factors that determine the magnitude of the gender bias in horizontal strabismus.

Association between Gestational Age, Birth Weight, Parental Age at Childbirth, Mode of Delivery, and Infantile Esotropia

SIGNIFICANCE

This study investigated the potential perinatal risk factors associated with infantile esotropia in a Chinese population, including advanced parental age at childbirth and mode of delivery. The findings may be significant in developing better intervention strategies for infantile esotropia.

PURPOSE

This study aimed to investigate the associations between gestational age, birth weight, parental age at childbirth, mode of delivery, family history of strabismus, and infantile esotropia in the Chinese population.

METHODS

Ninety-nine patients with infantile esotropia and 117 control subjects were enrolled between March 2018 and March 2021. Detailed questionnaires were administered to parents to collect relevant information. Univariate and multivariate logistic regression models were used to identify possible risk factors of infantile esotropia. Odds ratios (ORs) and 95% confidence intervals (95% CIs) were calculated.

RESULTS

Infantile esotropia was associated with low birth weight (<2500 g; OR, 4.235; 95% CI, 1.460 to 12.287; P = .008) and emergency cesarean delivery (OR, 2.230; 95% CI, 1.127 to 4.413; P = .02).

CONCLUSIONS

The findings suggest that low birth weight and emergency cesarean deliveries are risk factors for infantile esotropia, highlighting a need for collaborative care between obstetricians, pediatricians, and vision care providers.

Prevalence of the Infantile Strabismus Complex in Premature Children With and Without Periventricular Leukomalacia

PURPOSE

To determine whether rates of strabismus and associated visuomotor deficits differed among children with different severities of periventricular leukomalacia (PVL).

DESIGN

Retrospective, case-control study.

METHODS

Brain magnetic resonance images (MRI) obtained from 98 children aged ≥2 years were analyzed using a standardized scoring system: 67 of 98 had PVL (mean GA 31 weeks) and 31 of 98 did not have PVL (mean GA 29 weeks). Severity of PVL was scored as degree of damage to the posterior optic radiations and the splenium of the corpus callosum on MRI. Ophthalmologic examination data were collated to assess the prevalence of visuomotor deficits and the relationship to PVL severity (grades 1-3, mild to severe).

RESULTS

Infantile strabismus was documented in 61% of children with mild, 74% with moderate, and 88% with severe PVL (esotropia: exotropia ratio 3.5:1). Associated ocular motor deficits also increased systematically with PVL severity: latent ("fusion maldevelopment") nystagmus (20%, 47%, and 40%, respectively), dissociated vertical deviation (13%, 28%, and 30%), and nasotemporal pursuit/optokinetic nystagmus asymmetry (23%, 38%, and 54%). Additionally, the prevalence of retrograde optic neuropathy increased with PVL severity (5%, 26%, and 38%). The prevalence of each of these signs was substantially lower in children who had no PVL.

CONCLUSIONS

Children who suffer PVL are likely to develop the deficits of the infantile strabismus complex. The deficits tend to increase systematically as a function of PVL severity. These findings provide evidence that infantile strabismus is linked to perinatal damage to cerebral vergence and gaze pathways.

Long-Term Effects of Botulinum Toxin in Large-Angle Infantile Esotropia

Purpose

The purpose of this study is the motor outcome analysis of early Botulinum toxin (BT) treatment in patients affected by large-angle infantile esotropia (IE).

Patients and Methods

Retrospective analysis of 130 medical charts of IE patients who underwent BT injections between 2004 and 2019 was performed. All patients underwent BT injections within 13 months of age.

Results

Thirty patients, matching the inclusion criteria, were included in the study. Twenty-eight patients showing residual ET ≥25 PD (34.3±6.6 PD ranged from 25 to 50) underwent surgery.

Conclusion

Our result after 1 Botulinum toxin injection showed a very low success rate (6.7%) at last follow-up (28.3±7.2 months). Our data would suggest one Botulinum toxin injection in children affected by large-angle infantile esotropia allows a significant reduction of deviation but does not avoid the need for surgical treatment.

Effects of Surgical Timing on Surgical Success and Long-term Motor and Sensory Outcomes of Infantile Esotropia

PURPOSE

To investigate the effect of surgical timing on long-term motor and sensory outcomes in patients with infantile esotropia.

METHODS

The medical records of patients who underwent strabismus surgery for infantile esotropia were reviewed retrospectively. The patients were divided into three groups according to age at the time of surgery: early group (6 to 11 months), late group (12 to 17 months), and very late group (18 to 27 months). The main outcome measures were final alignment, surgical success rate (the angle of deviation at final follow-up of ≤ 10 prism diopters [PD] of esotropia, no exotropia and no need for reoperation), stereoacuity, visual acuity, and the number of reoperations required during the follow-up.

RESULTS

A total of 79 patients (44 female, 35 male) met the inclusion criteria. The surgical success rate was 25.9%, 23.1%, and 53.8% in the three groups, respectively (P = .035). After a mean follow-up of 96 months, the average number of operations per child was 1.7 ± 0.9, 1.6 ± 0.6, and 1.4 ± 0.6 in the three groups, respectively (P = .020). The measurable stereopsis rate was higher in the early group (37% vs 3.8% and 3.8%, respectively) (P = .001). The amblyopia rate was similar between groups.

CONCLUSIONS

The results show that performing surgery later in life in patients with infantile esotropia increases the motor success rate of surgery. In addition, orthophoria is achieved with fewer surgical operations. However, earlier surgery may improve stereopsis. [J Pediatr Ophthalmol Strabismus. 2020;57(5):319-325.].

Strabismus Surgery for Esotropia, Down Syndrome and Developmental Delay; Is an Altered Surgical Dose Required? A Literature Review

Background and Purpose:

There is a high rate of strabismus, in particular esotropia, in children with Down syndrome or developmental delay, which frequently requires surgical correction. A paper in 1994 advocated that the surgical dose be adjusted due to an altered response in these children. The aim of this literature review is to evaluate the available evidence to establish whether an altered surgical approach is required in either population.

Methods:

A literature review was conducted using PubMed and Web of Knowledge. Only English language papers were eligible for inclusion. The papers were collated in chronological order for analysis, and their references searched for further relevant papers. Forward citation searches were also undertaken.

Results:

A 2 × 2 comparison is made between publications on Down syndrome (in isolation) and developmental delay populations (including Down syndrome) with adjusted versus non-adjusted surgery. Published surgical success rates on esotropia from unaltered surgical doses range from 62.0%–85.7% (four papers) in the Down syndrome cohort, with none of the adjusted surgeries having a successful outcome. Surgical success rates from adjusted surgical doses in developmental delay cohort range from 37.5%–86.0% (seven papers), with one unadjusted surgical success rate of 76.0%. The results across the studies are summarised in a table and discussed.

Conclusions:

An exaggerated surgical effect in individuals with developmental delay has been reported, and this population may benefit from a reduced surgical dose. Published research does not support giving a reduced surgical dose in individuals with Down syndrome, but more research needs to be done to make a definitive conclusion.

Recent trend of increasing myopia can be traced to infancy

In recent years, a trend has been noted for increasing numbers of myopia cases found globally, which could potentially be indicative of a bigger problem. However, the cause of this trend remains unknown and in addition, we have yet to be able to establish a reliable method for preventing the onset of myopia. Furthermore, previous myopia studies have not paid adequate attention to hyperopia. That is to say, it has been suggested that the development of refraction in infancy and the onset of myopia are distinct from emmetropization. However, myopia studies also need to focus on the development of refraction in infancy, which involves hyperopia. Based on this viewpoint, our new hypothesis is that the trend towards myopia is associated with changes during the infancy period. The supporting evidence for these changes can be found in four areas, epidemiology of hyperopia, relationship with body height, incidence of esotropia, and birth month research. If this hypothesis is true, we need to investigate why there has been a decrease in hyperopia patients rather than why there has been an increase in myopia patients.

The atrophy of white and gray matter volume in patients with comitant strabismus: Evidence from a voxel-based morphometry study

To compare the difference in white matter volume (WMV) and gray matter volume (GMV) between the comitant strabismus (CS) patients and health controls by voxel-based morphometry (VBM) and the relationship with behavioral performance. A total of 20 patients with comitant strabismus (10 males and 10 females), and 20 healthy subjects (10 males and 10 females) with matched age, sex status underwent magnetic resonance examination. The authors analyzed the original 3D T1 brain images using the VBM module. The comitant strabismus groups were compared with the control groups for the GMW and WMV of the entire brain. Correlation analysis was performed to investigate the relationship between the GMV and WMV altered areas and the behavioral performance in comitant strabismus. CS patients were distinguishable from the healthy controls (HCs) by receiver operating characteristic curves. Results of the VBM analysis demonstrated that the CS groups had decreased GMV in the brain regions of the left middle temporal pole, left cerebellum posterior lobe, right posterior cingulate cortex, left cuneus and right premotor cortex. Meanwhile, the WMV was significantly decreased in the brain regions of the left middle temporal gyrus, right middle temporal gyrus, left middle temporal gyrus, right precuneus and right premotor cortex in the comitant strabismus patients compared with HCs. Furthermore, the duration of CS was negatively correlated with the GMV values of the left middle temporal pole (r=-0.486, P=0.030). CS caused GMV and WMV atrophy in many brain regions, which may indicate the neural mechanisms of the ocular motility disorders in CS patients.

Infantile esotropia: risk factors associated with reoperation

The aim of this study was to identify clinical and demographic factors associated with misalignment after first surgery performed on children affected by infantile esotropia to evaluate the reoperation rate. A retrospective study was carried out, analyzing data from 525 children who underwent bilateral medial recti recession, bilateral lateral recti resection, and inferior oblique recession and anteroposition by the same surgeon (AM). Postoperative evaluation included assessment of motor alignment at approximately 3 months, 6 months, 1 year, and 5 years. Statistical analysis was performed with a logistical regression model in which the dependent variable was the presence/absence of reoperation. We found that late surgery (after 3 years of age) and a family history of strabismus are associated with a higher risk of reoperation, while some clinical factors, including some classically associated with worst motor outcome as preoperative angle, dissociated vertical deviation, and amblyopia, did not influence the incidence of reoperation in infantile esotropia. Male patients and patients with hyperopia in preoperative examinations have a significantly decreased reoperation rate.

Adaptation of slow myofibers: the effect of sustained BDNF treatment of extraocular muscles in infant nonhuman primates

PURPOSE

We evaluated promising new treatment options for strabismus. Neurotrophic factors have emerged as a potential treatment for oculomotor disorders because of diverse roles in signaling to muscles and motor neurons. Unilateral treatment with sustained release brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) to a single lateral rectus muscle in infant monkeys was performed to test the hypothesis that strabismus would develop in correlation with extraocular muscle (EOM) changes during the critical period for development of binocularity.

METHODS

The lateral rectus muscles of one eye in two infant macaques were treated with sustained delivery of BDNF for 3 months. Eye alignment was assessed using standard photographic methods. Muscle specimens were analyzed to examine the effects of BDNF on the density, morphology, and size of neuromuscular junctions, as well as myofiber size. Counts were compared to age-matched controls.

RESULTS

No change in eye alignment occurred with BDNF treatment. Compared to control muscle, neuromuscular junctions on myofibers expressing slow myosins had a larger area. Myofibers expressing slow myosin had larger diameters, and the percentage of myofibers expressing slow myosins increased in the proximal end of the muscle. Expression of BDNF was examined in control EOM, and observed to have strongest immunoreactivity outside the endplate zone.

CONCLUSIONS

We hypothesize that the oculomotor system adapted to sustained BDNF treatment to preserve normal alignment. Our results suggest that BDNF treatment preferentially altered myofibers expressing slow myosins. This implicates BDNF signaling as influencing the slow twitch properties of EOM.

Effects of the sustained release of IGF-1 on extraocular muscle of the infant non-human primate: adaptations at the effector organ level

PURPOSE

The authors have demonstrated that prolonged exposure of adult rabbit extraocular muscle (EOM) to insulin-like growth factor-1 (IGF-1) results in significantly increased cross-sectional area and muscle force generation lasting over 3 months. Here the authors assess the effects on EOM of sustained IGF-1 treatment on normal binocular infant Macaca mulatta.

METHODS

Sustained-release IGF-1 pellets were implanted bilaterally in each medial rectus (MR) muscle of two normal infant non-human primates. Eye position was examined using corneal light reflex testing. After 3 months, morphometric analyses of myofiber cross-sectional area and innervation density in treated MR muscles were compared with an age-matched control and with antagonist lateral rectus (LR) muscles.

RESULTS

After 3 months, the slow-release pellets remained at the implantation site in all four MR muscles treated. The treated MR showed pronounced increases in cross-sectional area and nerve density, mirrored in the untreated antagonist LR.

CONCLUSIONS

Three months of bilateral sustained IGF-1 release in infant non-human primate MR resulted in increased muscle size and innervation density, mirrored in the untreated antagonist LR. It appears that bilateral MR treatment resulted in slow adaptation of both treated MR and contralateral LR muscles over time such that functional homeostasis and near-normal alignment were maintained. Further work is needed to determine what signaling mechanisms maintain proportional innervation when EOMs are forced to adapt to an externally applied perturbation.

Trends in surgical correction of strabismus: a 20-year experience, 1990-2009

BACKGROUND

Recent reports and anecdotal observations suggest that strabismus surgery, particularly for infantile esotropia, may be in decline, although a recent population-based study found the incidence to be stable.

METHODS

We analyzed the surgical database of 4,494 primary pediatric strabismus procedures from 1990 through 2009 at Children's Medical Center of Dallas. Linear regression models were used to identify the relationship between the year and the proportion of each surgical category (infantile esotropia, all esotropia, exotropia, and other) using the least-squares approach.

RESULTS

Surgery for infantile esotropia (mean age, 10 months) was performed on 374 patients (mean, 19; range, 11-27/year). Trend analysis demonstrated no significant change in the annual rate of surgery for infantile esotropia (R(2) = 0.004) during the 20-year study period. Additionally, when compared to the annual number of births in Dallas County, no significant change in the incidence of surgically corrected infantile esotropia was noted during the study period (P = 0.25); however, surgery for both infantile esotropia (P = 0.001) and for any esotropia (P = 0.002) declined, while surgery for exotropia increased (P = 0.002) as a proportion of all primary strabismus surgeries.

CONCLUSIONS

The incidence of surgically corrected infantile esotropia has remained stable over a 20-year period. As a proportion of all primary strabismus procedures, surgery for all types of esotropia has decreased and for exotropia has increased.

Best age for surgery for infantile esotropia

Infantile esotropia (IE) is defined as an esotropia before the age of 6 months, with a large angle, latent nystagmus, dissociated vertical deviation, limitation of abduction, and reduced binocular vision, without neurological disorder. Prematurity, low birth weight, and low Apgar scores are significant risk factors for IE. US standard age of first surgery is 12-18 months, in Europe 2-3 years. The only study to date with prospectively assigned early- and late-surgery groups and evaluation according to intention-to-treat, was the European Early vs. Late Infantile Strabismus Surgery Study (ELISSS). In that study 13.5% of children operated around 20 months vs. 3.9% (P = 0.001) of those operated around 49 months had gross stereopsis (Titmus Housefly) at age 6. The reoperation rate was 28.7% in children operated early vs. 24.6% in those operated late. Unexpectedly, 8% in the early group vs. 20% in the late group had not been operated at age 6, although all had been eligible for surgery at baseline at 11 SD 3.7 months. In most of these children the angle of strabismus decreased spontaneously. In a meta-regression analysis of the ELISSS and 12 other studies we found that reoperation rates were 60-80% for children first operated around age 1 and 25% for children operated around age 4. Based on these findings, the endpoints to consider when contemplating best age for surgery in an individual child with IE should be: (1) degree of binocular vision restored or retained, (2) postoperative angle and long-term stability of the angle and (3) number of operations needed or chance of spontaneous regression. IE is characterized by lack of binocular connections in the visual cortex that cannot develop, e.g. because the eyes squint, or do not develop, e.g. after perinatal hypoxia. As the cause of IE, whether motor or sensory, is a determinant of surgical outcome, a subdivision of IE according to cause is needed. As similarities exist between IE and cerebral palsy we propose to adapt the working definition formulated by the Surveillance of Cerebral Palsy in Europe and define IE as "a group of permanent, but not unchanging, disorders with strabismus and disability of fusional vergence and binocular vision, due to a nonprogressive interference, lesion, or maldevelopment of the immature brain, the orbit, the eyes, or its muscles, that can be differentiated according to location, extent, and timing of the period of development."

Predictive value of age, angle, and refraction on rate of reoperation and rate of spontaneous resolution in infantile esotropia

In the Early vs. Late Infantile Strabismus Surgery Study (ELISSS), 13.5% of children operated at 20 months vs. 3.9% of those operated at age 4 had gross binocular vision (Titmus Housefly). Reoperation rates were 28.7% in the former vs. 24.6% in the latter group and, although all were eligible for surgery at baseline at 11 SD 3.7 months, 8% in the early group vs. 20% in the late group were never operated, mostly because their angle decreased spontaneously. We assessed the predictive value of age, angle, and refraction in these matters.

METHODS

The ELISSS reoperation rates were first compared with those found in nine series of consecutive cases in nine university clinics operated during one particular year, between 6 and 23 years previously. Logistic regression was used to estimate the effect of postoperative angle and clinic on the chance of reoperation. Secondly, a meta-regression analysis was done of these and other reported reoperation rates. The mean age at operation and the mean duration of follow-up were regressed on the logistically transformed reported reoperation rates. Finally, to estimate the chance of spontaneous decrease of the angle without surgery, a random-effects model was fitted on the 6-monthly orthoptic measurements of angle and refraction in the ELISSS that antedated surgery, loss to follow-up, or final examination. In the random-effects model (see online-only supplement link or visit, www.simonsz.net), for ELISSS patients the random effect was defined as the deviation of the average angle, the fixed effect. A vector was defined based on age and spherical equivalent of the patient. The variance around the prediction consisted of uncertainty in the estimations, random effects, and residuals.

RESULTS

In the retrospective study, 204 patients who had been first operated between 6 and 23 years previously were eligible. A reoperation had been performed in 32 (19.3%) of the remaining 166 children who were 4.33 SD 1.35 years old at first surgery. The reoperation rate was 7.3% for those with a postoperative angle of -4° to +4° (N = 82), 25% for postoperative divergence > 5°, and 29% for postoperative convergence 10° to 14°. Strabismologists overestimated the reoperation rates at double. In the meta-regression analysis, 12 studies were included. Reoperation rates were between 60% and 80% for children first operated around age 1 and approximately 25% for children operated around age 4 (best fit: -0.221 Ln [age in months] + 1.1069; R(2) = 0.5725). Finally, in the predictions of random-effects model, a small angle at age 1 and hyperopia of approximately +4 increased the chance of spontaneous decrease of the angle into a microstrabismus.

DISCUSSION

The benefit of early surgery for gross binocular vision is balanced by a higher reoperation rate and an occasional child being operated that would have had a spontaneous decrease into a microstrabismus without surgery. The fact that, in the ELISSS, hyperopia was associated with a decrease of the angle underscores the benefit of early refractive correction.

Longitudinal changes in refractive error of children with infantile esotropia

Aim

The aim of this study was to quantify changes in refractive status over time in children with infantile esotropia and to analyse a number of clinical factors associated with infantile esotropia to determine how they may affect emmetropisation.

Methods

Longitudinal cycloplegic refraction data were collected for 5-12 years from 143 consecutive children enrolled in a prospective study of infantile esotropia by 6 months of age. Changes in refractive error with age were summarized with descriptive statistics and the influence of amblyopia, undercorrection of hypermetropia, accommodation, and binocular factors on emmetropisation were evaluated by ANOVA and t-tests.

Results

Most had low to moderate hypermetropia on the initial visit (55% had <+3.00 D). While the initial refractive error is similar to normative data, the rapid decrease in hypermetropia that characterizes normal development during the first 9 months of life is absent in children with infantile esotropia. After 9 months of age, children with infantile esotropia follow a developmental course that is similar to the normative course; there is little change in hypermetropia during years 1-7, followed by a decline of approximately -0.5 D/yr beginning at age 8 years. None of the clinical factors examined had a statistically significant effect on the course of refractive changes with age.

Conclusions

Children with infantile esotropia exhibit a different pattern of refractive development than that seen in normative cohorts. The long term changes in refraction observed in children with infantile esotropia suggest that there is a need for long-term clinical follow-up of these children.