Ensuring high-quality alternatives while ending pediatric inpatient care as we know it

Children with chronic conditions in pediatric intensive care units located in predominantly French-speaking regions: Prevalence and implications on rehabilitation care need and utilization

OBJECTIVE

To estimate the prevalence of chronic conditions and/or disability in intensive care units admitting children (Pediatric Intensive Care Unit [PICU]) or both neonates and children (Neonatal and Pediatric Intensive Care Unit [NPICU]) and to describe available rehabilitation resources.

DESIGN

A cross-sectional study on two separate days, using a web questionnaire.

SETTING

NPICU/PICUs affiliated to the Groupe Francophone de Réanimation et Urgences Pédiatriques and the Réseau Mère-Enfant de la Francophonie.

PATIENTS

Children >1 month of gestationally corrected age.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

Disability was defined as a Pediatric Overall Performance Category >or=3 before admission and chronic conditions as hospitalization since birth or the presence before admission of any condition requiring ongoing pediatric subspecialty care that was expected to last >or=12 months. Intensivists indicated what rehabilitation services they would have ideally prescribed ("perceived needs") and those provided. Of 45 affiliated units, 8 PICUs and 15 NPICUs participated. Staff included or had access to a psychologist (11 and 5, respectively), a social worker (10 and 3), a physiotherapist (11 and 12), a "psychomotrician" (2 and 8), a child educator (1 and 6), and a speech-language pathologist (0 and 6). Among 289 recorded intensive care unit-days, 236 were analyzed (excluding those for children admitted after surgery): 57 concerned children hospitalized since birth and 179 children admitted from home. Among these 179 recorded intensive care unit-days, 107 concerned children with chronic conditions (including 50 concerning disabled children) and 72 previously healthy children. Thus, prevalence of chronic conditions, including children hospitalized since birth, was 67%. Rehabilitation services included respiratory physical therapy (552 visits), musculoskeletal physical therapy (71), neurologic physical therapy (37), rehabilitation for swallowing (11), and for speech-language disorders (1), representing 79% of perceived needs.

CONCLUSIONS

Prevalence of chronic conditions in NPICU/PICU was 67%. More attention must be paid to the rehabilitation care needs of patients during their NPICU/PICU stay and after discharge.

A prospective cohort study comparing hospital admission for gastro-enteritis with home management

OBJECTIVES

To compare physical and psychological outcomes in children presenting at Accident and Emergency Departments (A&E), diagnosed with gastro-enteritis and admitted to hospital with those of a similar age, sex and severity of illness discharged home. The physical and psychological well-being of children in these two groups, in the month after the episode, were compared as was further use of health care services.

DESIGN

A prospective cohort study.

METHODS

A comparison of 116 children aged 1-6 years with gastro-enteritis, presenting at A&E over a 6 months period. Admitted children were compared with children discharged, of a similar age, sex and illness severity (triage score) with follow-up at 1 week and 1 month. Clinical history, psychosocial factors, investigations and outcomes were recorded at presentation and physical, psychological and family outcomes at 1 week and 1 month.

RESULTS

Of 116 children, 112 (97%) completed the study (56 in each group). No differences were detected in psychosocial factors, socio-economic status, family factors, time of arrival at A&E or waiting times. Parental perception of illness was greater in the admitted group (P < 0.005), but was recorded after the decision on admission was made. At 1 week follow-up admitted children had increased separation anxiety compared with children who were discharged (P < 0.05), but this difference disappeared at 1 month. Clinical outcomes were the same for both groups, although admitted children had more investigations (91% vs. 39%). Parents were equally satisfied with their child's treatment, but one-third of children in both groups sought further consultation with a health professional in the following week.

CONCLUSIONS

There is no statistically significant difference in socio-demographic data, time of arrival at A&E, waiting times, clinical and psychosocial outcomes in children with acute gastro-enteritis admitted to hospital compared with a group of children of similar age, gender and severity of illness managed at home. However, parents seek reassurance and follow-up of acutely ill children, even if the child is admitted to hospital, which has service and resource implications.

Excess risk of severe acute illness in children with chronic health conditions

We estimated the relative risk (RR) of an unscheduled pediatric intensive care unit (ICU) admission as a marker for severe acute illness in children with chronic health conditions, compared with previously healthy children. Potentially preventable events that lead to acute illness were identified to develop preventive strategies.

METHODS

Children with chronic conditions were defined as those who have a chronic physical, developmental, behavioral, or emotional condition and who also require health and related services of a type or amount beyond that required by children generally. RR was estimated from admissions and regional population data. Potentially preventable events that lead to ICU admission of chronically ill children were identified retrospectively from hospital records.

RESULTS

Children with chronic health conditions had an RR of 3.3 for an unscheduled ICU admission related to their chronic condition, compared with previously healthy individuals (95% confidence interval [CI] = 2.5-4.2). The risk of severe acute illness in the small subgroup that received technology-assisted care was much greater (RR = 373; 95% CI = 330-422) than for the large group of chronically ill patients who did not require technology-assisted care (RR = 2.3; 95% CI = 1.7-3.0), each expressed relative to previously healthy children. Acute illness related to chronic health conditions accounted for 45% of 251 unscheduled ICU admissions during the 1-year study. Thirty-two percent of admissions that were related to chronic conditions were judged to have been potentially preventable. Preventable events were more common for those who did not require technology-assisted care, occurring in 38% of admissions, compared with those who received technology-assisted care, for whom 19% of admissions involved a preventable event. Fifty-six percent of potentially preventable events involved the physical or social environment and decisions made by the family, whereas 64% could be attributed to health care system factors.

CONCLUSIONS

Children with chronic health conditions account for a substantial share of severe acute illness in a region. Because their underlying conditions have already been identified, problems may be anticipated. The small number of children who receive technology-assisted care each have such a high risk of severe and unavoidable acute illness that individualized emergency care plans are justified. For the remainder of children with chronic conditions, investigation of health system strategies to improve families' ability to anticipate, minimize, or prevent related acute illness is warranted.

Socioeconomic variation in asthma hospitalization: excess utilization or greater need?

OBJECTIVE

To assess the hypothesis that higher incidence of severe acute asthma exacerbation, not lower severity threshold for admission, explains the difference between the asthma hospitalization rates of inner-city and suburban children.

METHODS

All 2028 asthma hospitalizations between 1991 and 1995 for children (aged >1 month and <19 years) dwelling in Rochester, New York, were analyzed. ZIP codes defined residences as inner-city, other urban, or suburban. Based principally on the worst oxygen saturation (SaO2) during the first 24 hours of hospitalization, severity was examined by hospital record review (n = 443) of random samples of inner-city, other urban, and suburban asthma admissions.

RESULTS

Large inner-city/suburban differences were noted in many sociodemographic attributes, and there was also a distinct, stepwise gradient in risk factors in moving from the suburbs to other urban areas and to the inner city. Racial and economic segregation was particularly striking. Black individuals accounted for 62% of inner-city births versus <3% in the suburbs. Medicaid covered 65% of inner-city births, whereas Medicaid covered only 6% of suburban births. The overall asthma hospitalization rate was 2.04 admissions/1000 child-years. Children <24 months old, those most commonly hospitalized for asthma, were fourfold more likely to be hospitalized (OR: 3.97, 95% CI: 3. 44-4.57) than children between the ages of 13 and 18 years. The hospitalization rate of asthma in boys was almost twice the rate of asthma in girls. The greatest gender difference was observed among children who were <24 months old. For these children, the rate for boys was 6.10/1000 child-years compared with 2.65/1000 child-years for girls (OR: 2.31, 95% CI: 1.95-3.03). This gender difference diminished gradually in older age groups to the extent that there was no difference among girls and boys between the ages of 13 and 18 years (males, 1.12/1000 child-years vs females, 1.09/1000 child-years). Based on worst SaO2 values, mild (worst SaO2 >/=95%), moderate (90%-94%), and severe (<90%) admissions constituted 10.3%, 41.9%, and 47.7% of all hospitalizations, respectively. Although rates within the community followed a distinct geographic pattern of suburban (1.05/1000 child-years) < other urban (2.99/1000 child-years) < inner-city (5.21/1000 child-years), the proportions of admissions with low severity did not vary among areas. Likewise, the proportions of admissions that were severe (SaO2 <90%) were not significantly different (44.8, 45.7, and 52.1% for suburban, other urban, and inner-city areas, respectively). The distributions of asthma severity, measured by the duration of frequent nebulized bronchodilator treatments and the length of hospital stay, were also similar among children from different socioeconomic areas.

CONCLUSION

The marked socioeconomic and racial disparity in Rochester's asthma hospitalization rates is largely attributable to higher incidence of severe acute asthma exacerbations among inner-city children; it signals greater need, not excess utilization. Both adverse environmental conditions and lower quality primary care might explain the higher incidence. Interventions directed at the environment offer the possibility of primary prevention, whereas primary care directed at asthma is focused on secondary prevention, principally on improved medication use. Higher hospitalization rates cannot be assumed to identify opportunities for cost reduction. The extent to which our observations about asthma hold true under other conditions and in other communities warrants systematic attention. Knowledge of when higher rates signal excess utilization and when, instead, they signify greater needs should guide equitable national health policy.

Parental and professional perception of need for emergency admission to hospital: prospective questionnaire based study

AIM

To compare views of parents, consultants, and general practitioners on severity of acute illness and need for admission, and to explore views on alternative services.

METHOD

Prospective questionnaire based study of 887 consecutive emergency paediatric admissions over two separate three week periods in summer and winter of five Yorkshire hospitals, combined with a further questionnaire on a subsample.

OUTCOME MEASURES

Parental scores of need for admission and parent and consultant illness severity scores out of 10. Consultant judgment of need for admission. Alternatives to admission considered by consultants and, for a subsample, by parents and family GP.

RESULTS

Ninety nine per cent of parents thought admission was needed. Parents scored need for admission more highly than severity of illness with no association observed between severity and presenting problem or diagnosis. High parental need score was associated with a fit, past illness, and length of stay. Consultant illness severity scores were skewed to the lower range. Consultants considered admission necessary in 71%, especially for children aged over 1 year, presentation with breathing difficulty or fit, and after a longer stay. More admissions in the evening were considered unnecessary as were admissions after longer preadmission illness, gastroenteritis, or upper respiratory tract infection. Of a subsample of parents, 81% preferred admission during the acute stage of illness even if home nursing had been available. Similar responses were obtained from GPs. Alternative services could have avoided admission for 19% of children, saving 15.6% of bed days used.

CONCLUSIONS

Medical professionals and parents differ in their views about admission for acute illnesses. More information is needed on children not admitted. Alternative services should take account of patterns of illness and should be acceptable to parents and professionals; cost savings may be marginal.

Planning for the future: the experience of implementing a children's day assessment unit in a district general hospital

A paediatric day assessment unit was opened in May 1995. An audit of the first year's activity showed that, despite an increase in emergency admissions of 8.4%, the number of children admitted as an emergency overnight was reduced by 3% in paediatrics and 7.2% in surgery. In the first year, 1731 children were assessed as an emergency of whom 658 did not require admission to the inpatient ward. Midnight occupancy fell 17.7% in paediatrics and 25.4% in surgery. The nurse staffing costs fell over Pounds 32,000 in the first year. No adverse events occurred during the first year of operation; this type of facility could lead to a more efficient use of resources in any children's unit.