Efficacy, Improved Quality of Life, and Cost-effectiveness of Partial Breast Irradiation: A Triple-Threat Approach

Accelerated Partial Breast Irradiation: An Opportunity for Therapeutic De-escalation

Partial breast irradiation (PBI) has been demonstrated to have comparable outcomes to whole breast irradiation based on multiple randomized trials with long-term follow-up. However, despite the strength of the data available, PBI remains underutilized despite being an appropriate option for many women diagnosed with early-stage breast cancer. This is significant, as PBI offers the potential to reduce toxicities and shorten treatment duration without impacting outcomes; in addition, for low-risk patients, PBI alone is being investigated as an alternative to endocrine therapy alone. Modern PBI can be delivered with multiple techniques, and advances in treatment planning have allowed for improved therapeutic ratios compared with earlier techniques; one such approach is utilizing stereotactic body radiation therapy approaches allowing for smaller target margins and therefore lower breast doses. Moving forward, studies are ongoing evaluating the use of radiation alone including PBI as compared with endocrine therapy alone, with prospective studies evaluating stereotactic body radiation therapy.

Is kV Intraoperative Radiation Therapy an Acceptable Method for Partial Breast Irradiation?

Multiple large prospectively randomized trials of postoperative partial breast irradiation (PBI) have established it as a viable alternative to whole-breast irradiation for risk-adapted breast conserving management of early stage disease. An area of controversy remains regarding the relative efficacy, safety, and utility of intraoperative radiation therapy as a PBI technique. This is particularly true regarding the use of a 50 kV x-ray device, whereby the inherent dosimetry of the applicator results in a low dose of radiation to an exceedingly small volume of tissue. A critical analysis of the current clinical data would strongly support the view that intraoperative radiation therapy with a 50 kV x-ray device is associated with inferior outcomes compared with the variety of currently available modalities used for postoperative PBI.

Advances in Breast Cancer Radiotherapy: Implications for Current and Future Practice

Radiation therapy (RT) is an essential component in the management of breast cancer. Following breast-conserving surgery (BCS), adjuvant RT is the standard of care for most patients. Traditionally, RT was delivered with standard whole breast irradiation (WBI) over 5-7 weeks following BCS. However, WBI regimens have evolved; hypofractionated WBI now represents the standard approach, reducing the duration of treatment to 3-4 weeks. Over the past year, five-fraction WBI regimens have also emerged as standard of care for some patients based on data from the FAST and FAST-Forward trials. An alternative to WBI that is also available for patients with early-stage breast cancer following BCS is partial breast irradiation, which can reduce the duration of treatment and the volume of breast tissue irradiated. Outcomes from multiple randomized trials with over a 10-year follow-up have demonstrated the safety and efficacy of partial breast irradiation approaches. Single-fraction intraoperative RT has also been evaluated in two prospective trials although the outcomes available, as well as current guidelines, do not support its utilization outside of prospective studies. For patients requiring RT to the regional lymph nodes, data have demonstrated the safety of hypofractionated approaches for those undergoing BCS or mastectomy without reconstruction. Future directions for early-stage breast cancer radiotherapy include the study of even shorter regimens and studies evaluating the omission of RT versus omission of endocrine therapy for favorable-risk patients. Furthermore, studies are also underway evaluating shorter courses of radiation in patients undergoing breast reconstruction and the use of tumor genomics to identify appropriate patients for omission of radiation with limited nodal involvement.