Tetrasomy 5p mosaicism due to an extra i(5p) in a severely affected girl

Diagnosis and clinical delineation of mosaic tetrasomy 5p

OBJECTIVE

Our objective was to review the phenotypic and genetic characteristics of tetrasomy 5p from the fetal period until adulthood including prenatal diagnostic evaluations.

BACKGROUND

Tetrasomy 5p is a rare chromosomal abnormality. Of the 14 reports, most document mosaic tetrasomy 5p resulting from a supernumerary marker chromosome or isochromosome. There is a wide range of phenotypic manifestations with severity related to more proximal breakpoints and the degree of mosaicism.

DESIGN

We conducted a systematic review using Scopus, PubMed Central® and Ovid MEDLINE® from inception through July 1, 2018 for all articles describing tetrasomy 5p. All articles describing the syndrome of tetrasomy 5p were included.

RESULTS

Of the 15 included cases, 13 exhibited mosaic tetrasomy and two had complete tetrasomy identified by amniocentesis. The most common features include seizures (8/11 live births, 73%), hypotonia (7/11 live births, 64%), developmental delay (7/9 cases that reached childhood, 78%), abnormal external ears (6/11 live births, 55%), short stature (6/11 live births, 55%), ventriculomegaly (5/11 live births, 45.5%) and congenital heart defect (6/15 cases, 40%). The clinical phenotype ranged in severity from mild with no defining characteristics to severe with seizures, developmental delay, and multiple congenital anomalies, resulting in early death. Of these 15 cases, only 6 were diagnosed prenatally by prenatal genetic testing (40%) with prenatal ultrasound identifying abnormalities in 4/6 (67%). Confined placental mosaicism (CPM) was diagnosed in six additional cases due to discordance between CVS and amniocentesis results. Four of the five live births returned for evaluation and each showed normal development.

CONCLUSIONS

Fourteen out of 15 (93%) cases of tetrasomy 5p were associated with an abnormal phenotype. Once a diagnosis is made prenatally, a detailed anatomy ultrasound and fetal echocardiogram must be performed to further characterize any structural abnormalities of the fetus and potentially estimate the clinical severity. Caution should be exercised when prenatal diagnosis of mosaic tetrasomy 5p is found by chorionic villus sampling. CVS alone is insufficient to diagnose tetrasomy 5p and needs to be confirmed with amniocentesis. Our review seeks to inform clinicians on the current literature regarding tetrasomy 5p so that they may better counsel patients when this syndrome is diagnosed.

A boy with developmental delay and mosaic supernumerary inv dup(5)(p15.33p15.1) leading to distal 5p tetrasomy - case report and review of the literature

Background

With only 11 patients reported, 5p tetrasomy belongs to rare postnatal findings. Most cases are due to small supernumerary marker chromosomes (sSMCs) or isochromosomes. The patients share common but unspecific symptoms such as developmental delay, seizures, ventriculomegaly, hypotonia, and fifth finger clinodactyly. Simple interstitial duplications leading to trisomies of parts of 5p are much more frequent and better described. Duplications encompassing 5p13.2 cause a defined syndrome with macrocephaly, distinct facial phenotype, heart defects, talipes equinovarus, feeding difficulties, respiratory distress and anomalies of the central nervous system, developmental delay and hypotonia.

Case presentation

We present a boy with dysmorphic features, developmental delay, intellectual disability and congenital anomalies, and a mosaic sSMC inv dup(5)(p15.33p15.1). He is the fourth and the oldest reported patient with distal 5p tetrasomy. His level of mosaicism was significantly different in lymphocytes (13.2%) and buccal cells (64.7%). The amplification in our patient is smaller than that in the three previously published patients but the only phenotype difference is the absence of seizures in our patient.

Conclusions

Our observations indicate that for the assessment of prognosis, especially with respect to intellectual functioning, the level of mosaicism could be more important than the extent of amplification and the number of extra copies. Evaluation of the phenotypical effect of rare chromosomal aberrations is challenging and each additional case is valuable for refinement of the genotype-phenotype correlation. Moreover, our patient demonstrates that if the phenotype is severe and if the level of sSMC mosaicism is low in lymphocytes, other tissues should be tested.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (10.1186/s13039-018-0377-1) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Detectable clonal mosaicism in the human genome

Human genetic mosaicism is the presence of two or more cellular populations with distinct genotypes in an individual who developed from a single fertilized ovum. While initially observed across a spectrum of rare genetic disorders, detailed assessment of data from genome-wide association studies now reveal that detectable clonal mosaicism involving large structural alterations (>2 Mb) can also be seen in populations of apparently healthy individuals. The first generation of descriptive studies has generated new interest in understanding the molecular basis of the affected genomic regions, percent of the cellular subpopulation involved, and developmental timing of the underlying mutational event, which could reveal new insights into the initiation, clonal expansion, and phenotypic manifestations of mosaic events. Early evidence indicates detectable clonal mosaicism increases in frequency with age and could preferentially occur in males. The observed pattern of recurrent events affecting specific chromosomal regions indicates some regions are more susceptible to these events, which could reflect inter-individual differences in genomic stability. Moreover, it is also plausible that the presence of large structural events could be associated with cancer risk. The characterization of detectable genetic mosaicism reveals that there could be important dynamic changes in the human genome associated with the aging process, which could be associated with risk for common disorders, such as cancer, cardiovascular disease, diabetes, and neurological disorders.

De novo complete trisomy 5p: clinical and neuroradiological findings

Partial or complete duplication of 5p is a rare chromosomal abnormality in which genotype-phenotype correlation studies are hampered by other commonly associated chromosomal abnormalities. We report on a new patient in whom a complete de novo trisomy 5p in all metaphases represented the only chromosomal aberration. The present case further contributes to delineate the typical clinical picture of the trisomy 5p syndrome. Long-term clinical follow-up demonstrated low levels of secretory immunoglobulin A (IgA) on several occasions and likely related to the patient's recurrent respiratory infections (RRIs), a main clinical feature of the trisomy 5p syndrome. An extensive neuroradiological study detected a progressive triventricular hydrocephalus during the fist year of life with subsequent stabilization. Neuronal migration disorders were also present and probably account for the drug-resistant epilepsy presented by the patient.

Isochromosome 5p mosaicism at prenatal diagnosis: observations and outcomes in six cases at chorionic villus sampling and one at amniocentesis

We present six cases of 47,+i(5p)/46 mosaicism diagnosed at chorionic villus sampling (CVS), this being the first prospective series to be reported. The clinical indication in each was advanced maternal age. Further prenatal studies in four (amniocentesis, plus fetal blood sampling in one) did not show the isochromosome. In one case, subsequent amniocentesis showed 1/48 in situ colonies with the isochromosome, but fetal blood was karyotypically normal. These five pregnancies resulted in phenotypically normal livebirths; further normal follow-up reports (from age 4 months through 4 years) are noted in four of these. Analysis of placental tissue in one case confirmed the presence of the i(5p) mosaicism. In the remaining case, in which 100% of CVS cultured cells had the i(5p), the pregnancy was terminated. Fetal skin fibroblasts did not show the i(5p). Thus, in none of these six cases was true fetal mosaicism detected, nor an abnormal phenotype noted. We suggest that a 47,+i(5p)/46 karyotype, detected at CVS, may frequently reflect confined placental mosaicism. In addition, we report a case of the primary diagnosis of 47,+i(5p)/46 mosaicism at amniocentesis. The infant appeared normal at birth, but a brain malformation was subsequently identified.

Prenatal diagnosis of mosaic tetrasomy 5p

We report the prenatal diagnosis of a fetus with tetrasomy 5p mosaicism resulting from a supernumerary isochromosome for the short arm of chromosome 5. The pregnancy was terminated and fetal autopsy revealed minor facial abnormalities (long philtrum, up-slanting palpebral fissures and a broad nasal bridge). Cultures were established from fetal skin, kidney, and pancreas for cytogenetic analysis; the i(5p) was observed only in the skin fibroblasts. To our knowledge, this is the fourth report of mosaic tetrasomy 5p and the first report of prenatal diagnosis of this abnormality.