Animal model for thoracoscopic laser ablation of emphysematous pulmonary bullae

Video-assisted thoracoscopy

Thoracoscopy is a minimally invasive operative endoscopic procedure designed for visual inspection of the thoracic cavity. The use of small, highly maneuverable, rigid telescopes allows visualization beyond what is possible by standard operative techniques. The use of a small video camera attached to a standard rigid telescope allows the operator and assistants to view a simultaneous, enlarged, and clear image. This article focuses on the basic diagnostic and surgical techniques used in veterinary video-assisted thoracoscopy.

Effects of Nd:YAG laser irradiation on morphometry and lung function in elastase-induced emphysema in rats

BACKGROUND & OBJECTIVE

Although thoracoscopic laser ablation therapy has been hailed as an effective surgical treatment for diffuse emphysema, no one has as yet made an in-depth study of the efficacy of this treatment. This investigation was undertaken to research the effects of laser pneumoplasty on an animal model of emphysema.

STUDY DESIGN/MATERIALS AND METHODS

Eight weeks after elastase treatment, the rats' left lungs were irradiated using contact Nd:YAG laser. Pulmonary function tests were performed 4 weeks after irradiation and the lungs were prepared for histologic examination.

RESULTS

Dense fibrous scars beneath the pleura were observed at 4 weeks after irradiation. Although mean linear intercept values of irradiated lungs were not much lower than those in the non-irradiated elastase-treated group, laser irradiation caused a significant decrease in lung volume. While there was no significant difference in quasistatic compliance, elastic recoil pressure of the lung increased to control levels at total lung capacity volume.

CONCLUSION

We conclude that laser therapy does not cause normalization of compliance, or improvement in the deeper part of the emphysematous lung, but rather a peripheral volume reduction and "encasement effect" on the lungs as a result of fibrotic scars.

Effect of lung volume reduction surgery in a rabbit model of bullous lung disease

Clinical use of staple lung volume reduction surgery (LVRS) has proliferated for treatment of emphysema despite limited data regarding efficacy or optimal techniques. Recent studies in animal models of obstructive lung disease describe the decrease in lung compliance and increase in airway support as mechanisms of an improvement in pulmonary functions analogous to human data. We describe contrasting results in an animal model of bullous lung disease with a mixed but predominantly restrictive pattern of lung disease. Mixed restrictive and bullous lung disease was induced in 17 New Zealand white rabbits with i.v. Sephadex beads and endotracheally instilled carrageenan. Unilateral stapled lung volume reduction surgery was performed at 5 weeks postinduction of emphysema on the right lower lobe by lateral thoracotomy using a pediatric stapler. Static trans-pleural pressures were measured at 60, 40, and 20 cm3 inflation at preinduction (baseline), pre- and postoperatively, and 1 week postoperatively in anesthetized animals. Lungs were then harvested en bloc and examined histopathologically. The effects of volume reduction surgery on static lung compliance, lung conductance, and forced expiratory flows (FEF) were assessed. Five weeks after induction of lung disease, the animals had no significant change in static compliance and forced expiratory volume in 0.5 s (FEV0.5) or lung conductance compared to baseline. Immediately following LVRS, the animals showed a significant decrease in static compliance, FEV0.5, and conductance. One week postoperatively, compliance increased to approximately baseline levels along with a slight increase in FEFs and conductance toward preoperative levels. Histology examination revealed restrictive and bullous lung disease. Thus, we have demonstrated the feasibility of using an animal model for evaluation of volume reduction therapy for restrictive-obstructive lung disease. Physiologically, this model showed decrease conductance and decreased forced expiratory flows following lung volume reduction despite increased recoil. This is in contrast to increased conductance and flows seen in humans with severe emphysema following surgery and suggests that current criteria excluding patients with a significant restrictive component to their lung disease from LVRS surgery may be justified.

Comparison of Ho:YAG versus Nd:YAG thoracoscopic laser treatment of pulmonary bullae in a rabbit model

OBJECTIVE

To determine the relative efficacy and morbidity of Ho:YAG versus Nd:YAG laser treatment of bullous lung disease in an animal model.

SUMMARY BACKGROUND DATA

Laser coagulation procedures for treatment of emphysematous pulmonary bullae and heterogeneous emphysema continue to evolve. The role of lasers in lung volume reduction surgery remains controversial due to issues of relative efficacy and morbidity. The Nd:YAG laser is most commonly used for these procedures. We hypothesized that the shallower penetration of the Ho:YAG laser may be better suited for laser bullae coagulation and emphysema lung volume reduction with increased efficacy and reduced lung injury.

METHODS

Thirty New Zealand White rabbits (15 normal rabbits; 15 with bullous lung disease) were evaluated with Ho:YAG compared to Nd:YAG laser exposures. Bullae were coagulated by either Ho:YAG or Nd:YAG treatment. In all animals (bullous-induced and normals), unaffected lung tissue in the upper lobes and contralateral lungs were treated with 5 spot exposures of Nd:YAG and Ho:YAG, each to assess depth of lung injury. Animals were sacrificed at Days 0, 7, and 21 and their lungs were examined histologically.

RESULTS

Ho:YAG and Nd:YAG exposures caused equivalent lung injury to normal lung tissue. In the acute phase, parenchymal necrosis depth was similar for both Ho:YAG and Nd:YAG (850 +/- 273 microns vs. 900 +/- 270 microns respectively, p = 0.7). By Day 7, lung necrosis depth was 925 +/- 133 microns Ho:YAG vs. 1225 +/- 235 microns Nd:YAG (p = 0.33), and lung fibrosis depth was 300 +/- 134 microns Ho:YAG vs. 558 +/- 127 microns Nd:YAG (p = 0.11). By Day 21, pulmonary parenchymal necrosis was not seen. Pleural fibrosis depth was maximal at Day 21, reaching 250 +/- 102 microns for Ho:YAG vs. 300 +/- 156 microns Nd:YAG (P = 0.88). Pleural necrosis depth was 67 +/- 42 microns Ho:YAG vs 48 +/- 34 microns Nd:YAG (p = 0.42) on Day 7 and resolved by Day 21. During surgical coagulation procedures, the Ho:YAG laser was dramatically more efficient in coagulating bullae. The Ho:YAG laser required less exposure at equivalent power and resulted in immediate desiccation of bullae, in sharp contrast to the Nd:YAG laser.

CONCLUSIONS

Because the Ho:YAG was more effective and did not result in more acute lung injury than the standard Nd:YAG laser in this study, Ho:YAG lasers may have improved potential for laser treatment of bullae or lung volume reduction surgery (LVRS) compared to Nd:YAG lasers.

Doppler grid surface scanning applications for pulmonary subsurface parenchymal perfusion assessment

Subsurface perfusion to lung parenchyma underlying the pleura is difficult to assess in live ventilated animals. The purpose of this study was to assess applicability of a newly developed laser Doppler grid scanning imaging technology that measures perfusion of pleural subsurface lung regions in intact normal and abnormal animal lungs. Eighty-six Doppler grid perfusion measurements were performed in five New Zealand White Rabbits (3-5 kg); four with unilateral bullous lung disease, one normal control. Left upper lobe lung surface was exposed to 10 1-sec spot Nd:YAG exposures (70 W/cm2). One week following laser exposure, all rabbits underwent sequential bilateral open thoracotomy. Unaffected left lower lobes in these animals and all four lobes of a previously untreated rabbit were used as controls. Pleural subsurface perfusion measurements were recorded over a contiguous 900-pixel square surface grid using quantitative noncontact laser Doppler imaging during open thoracotomy procedures. Scans were obtained in a normal volume ventilation mode, at 30 cm of inspiratory hold airway pressure, and postinflation. A perfusion-pressure response curve was obtained in normal lung at 10-, 20-, and 30-cm static airway pressure. Post mortem measurements were used as 0 flow controls. Normal lung tissue was found to have relatively high pleural subsurface perfusion (1362 +/- 328 corrected units on a scale of 0-4095). Areas of atelectasis had decreased perfusion (659 +/- 512 U., 48.4 +/- 12.5% compared to normal lung, p < 0.02), but returned to normal levels after inflation of the lung (1253 +/- 363 U., p = 0.21 compared to normal). Pleural subsurface perfusion decreased uniformly and progressively as lung inflation pressure increased (p < 0.0001). Perfusion increased immediately to supranormal values following release of high inspiratory inflation pressure holds (1603 +/- 626 U., 117 +/- 18% compared to normal lung, p = 0.03). Bullae had markedly decreased perfusion (541 +/- 68 U.) that was not further reduced by increased inflation pressures. Noncontact laser Doppler grid perfusion imaging appears to provide a new tool for measuring pleural subsurface perfusion over a large area of lung surface in clinical experimental settings. Results are rapid, reproducible, and consistent. Sampling errors inherent in current point sampling Doppler flow techniques are reduced by the multiple contiguous measurements. We have used this technique to demonstrate inspiratory pressure-related reduction in pleural subsurface perfusion in normal lung, reversible decreased perfusion in atelectatic regions, and reduced perfusion in bullous and laser-treated lung regions.