Effect of a modified Nd:YAG laser technique on neuroma formation: An experimental study in rat sciatic nerve

Surgical Approaches for Prevention of Neuroma at Time of Peripheral Nerve Injury

Painful neuroma is a frequent sequela of peripheral nerve injury which can result in pain and decreased quality of life for the patient, often necessitating surgical intervention. End neuromas are benign neural tumors that commonly form after nerve transection, when axons from the proximal nerve stump regenerate in a disorganized manner in an attempt to recreate nerve continuity. Inflammation and collagen remodeling leads to a bulbous end neuroma which can become symptomatic and result in decreased quality of life. This review covers surgical prophylaxis of end neuroma formation at time of injury, rather than treatment of existing neuroma and prevention of recurrence. The current accepted methods to prevent end neuroma formation at time of injury include different mechanisms to inhibit the regenerative response or provide a conduit for organized regrowth, with mixed results. Approaches include proximal nerve stump capping, nerve implantation into bone, muscle and vein, various pharmacologic methods to inhibit axonal growth, and mechanisms to guide axonal growth after injury. This article reviews historical treatments that aimed to prevent end neuroma formation as well as current and experimental treatments, and seeks to provide a concise, comprehensive resource for current and future therapies aimed at preventing neuroma formation.

Reduction of post-traumatic neuroma and epineural scar formation in rat sciatic nerve by application of microcrystallic chitosan

Injury of peripheral nerve is associated with the development of post-traumatic neuroma at the end of the proximal stump, often being the origin of neuropathic pain. This type of pain is therapy-resistant and therefore extremely nagging for patients. We examined the influence of the microcrystallic chitosan gel applied to the proximal stump of totally transected sciatic nerve on the neuroma formation and neuropathic pain development in rats. In 14 rats, right sciatic nerve was transected and the distal stump was removed to avoid spontaneous rejoining. In the chitosan (experimental) group (n = 7), the proximal stump was covered with a thin layer of the microcrystallic chitosan gel. In control animals (n = 7), the cut nerve was left unsecured. Autotomy, an animal model of neuropathic pain, was monitored daily for 20 weeks following surgery. Then, the animals were perfused transcardially and the proximal stumps of sciatic nerves were dissected and subjected to histologic evaluation. The presence, size, and characteristics of neuromas as well as extraneural fibrosis were examined. In chitosan group, the incidence and the size of the neuroma were markedly reduced, as compared with the control group; however, there was no difference in autotomy behavior between groups. In addition, extraneural fibrosis was significantly reduced in chitosan group when compared to the control group. The results demonstrate beneficial influence of microcrystallic chitosan applied to the site of nerve transection on the development of post-traumatic neuroma and reduction of extraneural fibrosis, however without reduction of neuropathic pain.

Role of Nd:YAG laser for prevention of neuroma formation: an in vivo experimental study

Nerve transection is commonly followed by the development of neuroma at the proximal stump. It can be very painful especially at exposed sites. It may arise spontaneously or after mechanical irritation. Neuroma and its high recurrence rate might be resisting problems to treat. Various treatment modalities for neuroma and its recurrence have been proposed, but none has provided satisfactory results. The present study was conducted to evaluate the neodymium:yttrium aluminum garnet (Nd:YAG) laser (1,064 nm) nerve transection technique for prevention of neuroma formation. There were 48 facial nerves out of 24 Rex rabbits divided into two equal groups. The 24 left-sided facial nerves at group A were subjected to Nd:YAG laser for nerve transection, while the 24 right-sided facial nerves at group B were subjected to scalpel nerve transection. The results were grossly and histopathologically evaluated. Grossly, laser-transected nerves showed an infrequent incidence of neuroma formation. Histopathologically, laser-transected nerves showed photothermal degenerative changes of the axons and myelin sheaths with intact perineurium and endoneurium. No Schwann cell hyperactivity could also be elicited among laser-transected nerves. Nd:YAG laser was found to be an effective tool that could be applied, whenever it is possible, for division of major nerves to prevent the formation of the subsequent stump neuroma. Moreover, this technique should be considered during treatment of well-established neuroma to prevent the challenging reported high incidence of recurrence.

Neuroma formation in a rat median nerve model: influence of distal stump and muscular coating

BACKGROUND

The purpose of this study was to investigate neuroma formation in a rat median nerve model.

METHODS

In three groups, the median nerve was exposed and a gap was created. In the first group, a short gap of 1 cm (n = 12) was created; in the second, a long gap of 2 cm (n = 12) was created in the nerve. Another group was used to analyze the development of neuroma formation when the proximal stump was buried in adjacent muscle with an additional gap of 2 cm (n = 12). The use of different lengths should allow one to gain information about dilution effects of distal stump factors that may contribute to neuroma formation. Nine months later, specimens were gathered and histologically analyzed. The cross-sectional areas of neuromas were measured and the neural/connective tissue ratios were estimated.

RESULTS

The cross-sectional areas demonstrated that neuroma formation was significantly higher in the short-gap group than in the long-gap group, and smallest in the muscle-covered group. The percentage of neural tissue was highest in the muscle-covered and long-gap groups and lowest in the short-gap group.

CONCLUSIONS

These results demonstrate an association between neuroma formation and distal stump distance. This observation may be explained by the factors originating from the distal stump that were blocked when the proximal nerve stump was completely buried in the muscle. For clinical application, the authors recommend not only burying the proximal stump in a muscle but also surgically augmenting the gap between the proximal and distal stumps.

Prevention and management of painful neuroma

Painful neuroma is a common sequela of peripheral nerve injury which is usually resistant to pharmacologic treatment and requires surgical intervention. The widely accepted methods of neuroma management prevent regrowth of nerve fibers, thus precluding any functional repair. The present study reviews the currently used methods and experimental approaches to prevent and cure neuromas developing after peripheral nerve injury. The main recommendations are as follows. Special care should be taken to minimize scar formation when operating on peripheral nerves. The laser or scissors transection methods should be used to cut the nerve rather than electrocoagulation or cryoneurolysis. Direct nerve reconstruction, or, if a gap occurs, nerve grafting, should be performed immediately after nerve injury. Surgical resection of recurrent neuroma followed by implantation of the nerve into the muscle or capping the nerve stump with epineural graft seems to be the most effective method of prevention.

Prevention of painful neuromas by oblique transection of peripheral nerves

Object

Neuroma formation often occurs at the proximal stump of the transected nerve, complicating the healing process after gap injuries or nerve biopsies. Most such neuromas cause therapy-resistant neuropathic pain. The purpose of this study was to determine whether oblique transection of the proximal stump of the sciatic nerve can prevent neuroma formation.

Methods

The sciatic nerves of 10 rats were transected unilaterally at an angle of 30°, and the peripheral segments of the nerves were removed. In 10 control animals the sciatic nerves were transected at a perpendicular angle. Twenty weeks after surgery the nerves were reexposed and collected. The presence of neuromas was determined by two board-certified pathologists on the basis of histopathological evaluations.

Conclusions

The oblique transection of peripheral nerves, contrary to perpendicularly transected nerves, is rarely followed by classic neuroma development. Moreover, neuropathic pain is significantly reduced compared with that following the traditional method of nerve transection.

Influence of nerve stump transplantation into a vein on neuroma formation

The objective of this animal study was to investigate the influence of nerve stump transposition into a vein on neuroma formation. In 24 rats the femoral nerve was severed and the proximal nerve stump was transposed into the lumen of the femoral vein on one side. On the other side, the nerve was severed and left in place. The distal nerve stump was shortened to knee level on both sides. In group 1, the bloodstream was released; in group 2, the segment of the femoral vein containing the nerve stump was excluded from circulation. Histological assessment was performed 8 months later. There were significant differences between the treatment and control sides with respect to neuroma size, endoneural architecture, neural-tissue-to-connective-tissue ratio, and myelination of axons. These data suggest that nerve transposition into a vein could inhibit the formation of classic neuroma.